The garage was a contributing structure to the Presidio of San Francisco National Historic Landmark. The Historic American Engineering Record recognizes its significance as "Associated with century expansion of Letterman Hospital into the largest military hospital on the Pacific Coast." PARTI. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: The structure was erected in (remodeled in and completed on Oct. 1 of that year at an unknown cost. The structure was originally constructed by the Army as a seven vehicle detached garage for officers' private automobiles. The architect is not known. Presidio of San Francisco, Officers' Vehicles Garage (Structure No. HABS No.
CA-2717 (Page 2) On December 14, renovations were completed at a cost of External photographs indicate that work included the replacement of garage doors and alterations to the roof. The building was later used for storage. The U.S. Army proposed demolishing the structure in due to deterioration and lack of historical or architectural significance.
In a document entitled "Directorate of Facilities Engineering," dated August 8, (attached), the Facilities Engineer reached this determination, pursuant to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of "These undertakings [the proposed demolition] will have no adverse effect on the historic quality of surrounding property." The document also states, "The master plan for the Letterman Army Medical Center provides for consolidating obsolete facilities into a reduced number of modular facilities that will increase operating efficiency. Sites of buildings proposed for removal will be restored to a green area compatible with the surrounding environment." Army documents state that the structure's continued use and/or repair could not be economically justified.
The building, however, was not destroyed and in fact survived beyond the end of Army occupation of the Presidio. Management was transferred from the Department of Defense to the Department of the Interior on October 1, and to the Presidio Trust on October 1, It continued to function as a storage facility under the National Park Service and the Presidio Trust.
As National Historic Landmark documentation prepared in states, "The integrity is somewhat compromised by the non-historic replacement of all of the garage doors." The structure was substantially destroyed by fire on March 28, The National Park Service fire investigation report concluded that, "The most probable cause of this fire was a spark or sparks from the grinding process [attributed to Friends of the Urban Forest] which landed among the large mix of combustibles and smoldered for a long period of time before breaking out into open flame." The garage was subsequently demolished in At the time of the fire, the structure was being utilized for storage by National Park Service Cultural Resources and Friends of the Urban Forest. Only the concrete foundation/floor currently remains. B.
Historical Context: The structure, located in the Letterman Hospital Complex, contributes to the Presidio of San Francisco, a National Historic Landmark. The buildings at the Presidio represent architectural and strategic philosophies employed by the Army over nearly 150 years. The following is based mainly on passages from Presidio of San Francisco, Officers' Vehicles Garage (Structure No. HABS No.
CA-2717 (Page 3) the Historic American Buildings Survey Report, written in by the Department of the Army and the National Park Service: The Presidio was formally established as a Spanish military outpost on September 17, It saw successive use by the militaries of Spain, Mexico, and the United States until As a Spanish garrison, it played a key role in the extension of Spanish settlement into Northern California. Upon Mexico's independence it became their main base in Northern California. It was then transferred to the United States as a result of the Mexican American War. During the Indian Wars of the and the Civil War, the Spanish-American War, and the United States' territorial expansion into the Pacific basin, the Presidio was a cornerstone of U.S.
military operations throughout the West. A precursor to the modem Letterman Hospital Complex, the Presidio Army General Hospital was developed in as the first of its kind in the United States. Its successor, the Letterman Hospital complex, became the largest military hospital on the Pacific Coast, operating as a receiving facility for military personnel wounded in the Pacific during World War II. The Presidio, included in the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, was designated a National Historic Landmark in It is recognized for its important role in the colonial and military history of the West. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement: 1. The garage was a single story, utilitarian wood frame structure with seven bays. 2.
Currently, the only remaining feature of the structure is the concrete foundation/floor. The garage was demolished in following a fire. B. Description of Exterior: 1. Overall Dimensions: x The structure originally had a gross area of sq. ft. After the remodeling, the floor area is sq. ft. (as stated in the Integrated Facilities Systems Real Property Inventory worksheet). The IFS worksheet also states that the usable floor space is sq. and the total area by roof is sq. ft. Presidio of San Francisco, Officers' Vehicles Garage (Structure No. HABS No. CA-2717 (Page 4) 2. Foundation: Reinforced concrete slab foundation; the first floor was 4" above ground. 3. Walls: Wood walls constructed of 1" x 8" redwood tongue and groove siding. 4.
Framing: Balloon frame construction using 2" x 4" wood studs. 5. Openings: a. Doors: Seven garage bays with a height of 7.5 ft. and width of 8 ft. b. Windows: Small windows, one for each garage stall, pierce the wall opposite the garage door openings. 6. Roof: a. The original roof appears to have been a gable roof (see photocopies CA-2717-18-21). The original roof was covered in shingles. b. Quartermaster Report for the structure states that the roof was covered by asphalt mineral surfaced (rolls). The IFS Worksheet (post- renovation) states that the roof is being supported by rafters, roof deck material is wood (less than and roof surface materials are tar and gravel. C. Description of Interior: 1. Main Room as initially built - width length 60' height 8'.
IFS (post renovation) states that the ceiling height is 9'. Interior space was divided into bays using chain link fencing at an unknown date. 2. Original floor was rock, but at some point prior to the renovation it was replaced with a concrete floor. 3. Electric lights were installed at a cost of prior to the renovations. D. Site: The structure is oriented lengthwise on a SW to NE axis. The front faces the NW direction. It is located in the NW comer of the extended Letterman complex, immediately next to a tennis court (structure at the intersection of Gen. Kennedy Ave. and Birmingham Rd. Presidio of San Francisco, Officers' Vehicles Garage ' (Structure No. HABS No. CA-2717 (Page 5) PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION 1.
National Register of Historic Places Registration Forms, Prepared by National Register Programs, National Park Service, Western Regional Office. Submitted October 16, 2. Quartermaster Building Records, GGNRA, NPS 3. NAER Inventory Cards. U.S. Department of Interior. Inventoried by Mark Brack and James P. Delgado, 4. Thompson, Erwin N. Defender of the Gate. Historic Resource Study published by GGNRA/NPS, 5. NPS Fire Investigation Report-A7631 (GOGA-PRFD), incident 6. U.S. Department of Army records, GGNRA/NPS Presidio Archives. 7. Integrated Facilities Systems Real Property Inventory Worksheets, Dept of Army records, GGNRA/NPS Presidio Archives. 8. Presidio of San Francisco National Historic Landmark District Historic American Buildings Survey Report.
Authored by National Park Service and Department of the Army, PART IV. PROJECT INFORMATION This report was prepared by Presidio Trust researcher Jonathan Nettler, pursuant to the Programmatic Agreement among the Presidio Trust, the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the National Park Service and the California State Historic Preservation Officer regarding deconstruction, new construction, and the execution of associated leases at the Letterman Complex, Presidio of San Francisco, California. Large format negatives were photographed by Jed Manwaring and Julianne Polanco. Due to the current state of the structure, all architectural information had to be gathered from existing photographic and documentary records, thus limiting the extent of the Architectural section.
Furthermore, due to the diffusion of Army records, such important documents as the original and remodeling floor and construction plans could not be located. Presidio of San Francisco, Officeis' Vehicles Garage (Structure No. IiABs No. CA-2117 (Page 6) _ .0 "O I '~ I . -,, y .' ILJ~ 0 t ~ ,. . -~ I ~ .,' \ .. ,e , q ' L, C'> \-\ " ~ ~. ~~i-, . i \ . e=.,\ ,.~ \._ f . ~) J \ . \ :, { CA-2717 ~ Photocopy of photograph (original photograph in possession of National :~ Park Service, GOGA-2037) Photographer unknown, from Letterman General Hospital Photo Study EXTERIOR OF GARAGE, FACING EAST ',r . ~ : ::occ (/) 0.. c; 0 l ~ ~ ~ z 0 0 (]) n g >- () < I (]) N i::: (]) (") ~ -z 0 (/) f-0 Q ~ ~ ~ R~ 00 Ul (IQ - ' (]) '",,i:J (1> C/J 0: 0 0 (/) 'Tj D. ~0 0 (1> .
(/) z ,__ n 2 "'~ ;J> 0 < t0 8 & r; (\) z (p 0 (/) "U. c:i ~ ,_. "' (JQ 0 '"1 (1> U1 ii' u,uq '' n CA-2717;,Jli/ Photocopy of photograph (original photograph in possession of National Park Service, GOGA-2880) Photographer unknown AERIAL VIEW OF LETTERMAN GENERAL HOSPITAL AREA, FACING EAST .; >tJ 6 en ~ 0 >-ti CIJ 41 (') ~ ~ CIJ 0. z 0 9l h ~ (f) () CIJ >; )>- @ en~ I (') < Cll CA-2717-;)RI" Photocopy of photograph (original photograph in possession of National e: ~ Ei (') Park Service, GOGA-1766) . ~ (1) Photographer unknown, from Photo Section, Air Service, US Army Q' en fl; 0 Taken February 23, (JQ fl; (1) 0>; Lil fl; AERIAL VIEW OF LEITERMAN GENERAL HOSPITAL AREA 9~~ FROM FEET, FACING NORTH ' I ! r -- -. . . I . ~ ~ ~ CZl 0..
0 0 I-+, .{~ Cll (") ~o ~ 0 z 0 Si () (1) 0 C/) >; > g CA~ ' - '4 , t0 n < .. ,, l . . -~ .ii:) CA-2717il'f .Photocopy of photograph (original photograph in possession of National . -- ~;l ~~lo-' -.l (1) (") . Park Service, GOGA-2072) Z c=D '"d 0 Cll Photographer unknown 0 (Jq (1) 0>4 VIEW OF EXTERIOR OF TENNIS COURT IN FOREGROUND, SIDE Lil ._. Lil aq AND ROOF OF GARAGE;: VISIBLE IN RIGHT SIDE OF THE IMAGE ' - ' t"P