North Beach Place was a public housing project that occupied two city blocks in the North Beach neighborhood of San Francisco for fifty years. Designed in delayed by World War II, and constructed in it was one of the early housing projects in the city. Originally, occupancy was intended to be restricted to Caucasians, according to a neighborhood patterning policy then in place; but a successful lawsuit by the NAACP overturned this policy. For many years the housing project was occupied by a mix of Asian, African-American, and Caucasian residents. Generally harmonious relations existed among residents, staff, and the surrounding neighborhood until the crack cocaine epidemic of the mid-1980s.
The project has long had ties with a non-profit service organization, the Telegraph Hill Neighborhood Center. Architecturally, the housing project was an early example of modernism in San Francisco. Strongly horizontal in its lines, with balconies curved at the corners, and nearly devoid of ornament, the buildings that make up this project were a blend of the Streamlined Moderne and International styles. NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 2) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History Please refer to the "Narrative" report, HABS No. CA-2727 for the history of the construction of the North Beach Place project. Regarding Building 11 specifically, a substantial alteration was made at an unknown date.
In this alteration, the open pass-through at the northern end of the building was filled in, and the use of some of the original office and storage rooms was changed. The result of these changes was that the pass-through was filled in to become housing project's new Community Room, and a shop room became a new laundry room for the complex. Wooden trellises were laid over concrete walls on the west side of the building to mark the entrances to these rooms. B. Historical Context Please refer to the" Narrative" report, HABS No. CA-2727. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement Please refer to the "Narrative" report, HABS No. CA-2727. B. Description of Exterior 1.
Overall dimensions Building 11 was located on the north side of Francisco Street, between Taylor Street and Columbus Avenue. Its long side stretched almost all the way to Bay Street. It was four stories in height and measured 35 (east- west) by 245 (north-south). 2. Foundations Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A. 3. Walls and structural system North Beach Place employed reinforced concrete exterior bearing walls, a reinforced concrete post-and-girder interior system, and reinforced concrete flat slab floors and roof. In two of the buildings, Building 7 and NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No.
CA-2727-K (Page 3) Building 8, the northern portion of the ground level was left open, allowing people to pass from one courtyard to another. In these buildings, the underpass occupied the northern 60' -0" of the ground floor level. Two rows of square reinforced concrete posts, each about one foot in diameter, supported the upper floors in these underpasses. Building 11 was built in the same manner, but at an unknown date the underpass in this building was filled in with new rooms, with exterior walls of reinforced concrete construction. Exterior wall surfaces were left unfinished, except for paint. 4. Balconies, stairwells, stoops, and garbage chutes In North Beach Place, concrete balconies ran across the upper floors of one of the long sides of each building.
All buildings in each block were connected to each other by these balconies, which wrapped around comers to connect with each other. Where the balconies wrapped around comers, they formed distinct curves, giving the complex its Streamlined Modeme style. In Building 11, balconies ran along the full width of the third and fourth stories of the east side of the building. At their northern ends, they connected with a stairwell at the junction of Building 11 with buildings 4 and 5. Stairwells could be found at the junctions of east-west oriented buildings with north-south oriented buildings; and near the south ends of the north- south oriented buildings. Built entirely of concrete, these stairwells were rectangular in form, with flat walls.
In the upper two stories, the stairwells emptied onto continuous exterior balconies, which provided access to apartment entries. Five stairwells were associated with Building 11. One was located where it joined with buildings 4 and 5. Another was on the east side of the building, about twenty feet north of its south end. Both of these rose to the fourth floor, and served all of the upper stories. The other three stairwells were almost evenly spaced along the east side of the building and rose only to the second story, where they each served two units. Building 11 differed from the other buildings in the complex in that it did not have raised concrete entrance stoops and privacy walls for the ground floor units.
In Building 11, first story entrances opened directly onto a sidewalk along the east side of the building. Balconies provided access to a garbage chute. The chute serving Building 11 could be found midway along the balcony on the east side of the building, and was rectangular in form. This was in contrast to the rounded chutes that served buildings facing Bay Street. NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 4) 5. Openings Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A, for a description of exterior openings in this building. Alterations were made at an unknown time to add a new Community Room and laundry room to the first story.
These rooms had doorways in the west wall of the building, and these doorways were marked by wooden trellises laid over concrete walls. 6. Roof Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A. C. Description of Interiors 1. Floor plans a. Basement Building 11 had no basement. Utility rooms such as a garbage and boiler room, which in other buildings were located in the basement, were originally located in the first story of this building. b. Apartment floor plans and common areas The North Beach Place housing project contained living units of one, two, three, and four bedrooms. At the time of construction, Building 11 contained twenty-seven living units, including a one- bedroom unit, fifteen two-bedroom units, eight three-bedroom units, and three four-bedroom units.
A number of utility, office, shop, and storage rooms were also located in this building. A pass-through was located at the northern end of the building, just as in buildings 7 and 8. At an unknown date, this pass-through was filled in with additional rooms. The units and rooms in Building 11 were distributed as follows: Upon the completion of construction, the ground floor was dedicated to a wide variety of uses. The northern end of the ground floor was open for use as a pass-through, enabling pedestrian passage between courtyards. Three living units - a one-bedroom, a two-bedroom, and a three-bedroom - occupied NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 5) most of the middle area of the first story.
A boiler room, garbage room, and transformer room were sandwiched between two of these living units. The southern end of the first story was used as a manager's office, an office and workroom, a waiting room, a repair shop, and three storage rooms. The second story contained seven three-bedroom units and one four-bedroom unit. The third and fourth stories each contained seven two-bedroom units and a four-bedroom unit. In each of these stories, the four-bedroom unit was located at the extreme south end of the building. A short eastward extension of the building at this end accommodated these fourth bedrooms. At an unknown date, the pass-through at the northern end of the building was filled in, and the use of some of the original office and storage rooms was changed.
One result of these changes was that the housing project's Community Room, consisting of a meeting room, an anteroom, a kitchen, two bathrooms, and three storage closets, occupied the space once occupied by the pass- through. Another result was that the former repair shop became a laundry room for the complex. This laundry room measured approximately twenty-five feet by thirty feet. One of the first story living units was converted into a "One Stop Shop," also at an unknown time. The single one-bedroom unit measured roughly twenty feet by thirty feet. Each two-bedroom unit measured 23 by about thirty feet. Each three-bedroom unit measured 29' -1" by about thirty feet. Each four-bedroom unit measured 32' -8" by 35 minus a notch at the northeast comer of the unit.
Each unit extended the full depth of the building, so that light poured into each unit from two sides. The sole entrance to each unit was from the balcony or front stoop directly into the dining area. In addition to bedrooms, each unit in Building 11 contained a living room, a kitchen with dining area, a bathroom, and a small linen closet. Units on the third and fourth floors also had storage rooms. Linen closets were located adjacent to the bathroom. Each bedroom also had its own closet. Bathrooms contained a bathtub, a sink, and a toilet. Kitchens contained a refrigerator, a range, a combination sink and tray for dishwashing, a counter, and shelves. 2. Flooring NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No.
CA-2727-K (Page 6) For a description of the flooring ofliving units, please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A. Flooring for both the Community Room and the laundry room was twelve- inch square vinyl tiles. 3. Wall and ceiling finish For a description of the wall and ceiling finish of the living units, please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A. The Community Room and laundry room both had walls of the same gypsum-plasterboard as found be found in the living units. The ceiling of the Community Room was acoustic tiles, and that of the laundry room was concrete. 4. Openings and trim Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A. 5. Bedroom closets Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No.
CA-2727-A. 6. Kitchen fixtures Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A. 7. Bathroom fixtures Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A. 8. Community Room fixtures Community Room fixtures appeared to date to the They included fluorescent lights and wooden cabinets with Formica counters. The refrigerator, range, and dishwasher appeared to be of more recent date. NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 7) 9. Laundry room fixtures The structural elements of the building -- four concrete posts supporting concrete beams above -- were left exposed in this room. New washers and dryers surrounded the perimeter of the room. This room was also equipped with a plastic wash-basin.
Lighting was fluorescent. 10. Mechanical equipment and fixtures Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A. D. Site 1. General setting and orientation Building 11 was located on the north side of Francisco Street, between Taylor Street and Columbus A venue, in the more western of the two blocks of North Beach Place. The building was oriented on a north-south axis and stretched north almost to Bay Street. It was connected by balconies to buildings 4 and 5, which fronted on Bay Street and ran east- west. By means of such connections, Building 11 and the other buildings in the block formed a series oflinked U-shapes. 2.
Historic landscape To a certain degree the landscaping plan for North Beach Place by Thomas Church remained intact through The courtyard formed by buildings 4, 10, and 11 remained devoted to parking. According to plans shown in John S. Bolles' article "North Beach Place Housing Project" the courtyard formed by buildings 5, 11 and 12 was originally intended to be surfaced with paving and lawns, with the former predominating. This surfacing was still largely in place in The northern half of this courtyard was lower in elevation than was the southern half. This elevation change was effected by a concrete staircase (to the east) and a concrete ramp (to the west).
The plans mentioned above show that this courtyard was originally intended to be used for a "Social Center." It is unknown if this use was ever realized. In a rectangular prefabricated building occupied a part of the courtyard. This building was used as an office for North Beach Head Start. Please refer to the outline report for Building 1, HABS No. CA-2727-A, for more detail on the historic landscape of North Beach Place. NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 8) PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Original Architectural Drawings The original plans of have not been found. Perspective drawings and site plans from that period, however, were published with an article entitled "North Beach Place Housing Project," by John S.
Bolles, in Architect and Engineer in July As-built drawings dated July were supplied by the San Francisco Housing Authority. These drawings were revisions of plans dated August B. Early Views No early photographic views of North Beach Place have been found. C. Interviews The author of this report interviewed Denise McCarthy, Executive Director of the Telegraph Hill Neighborhood Center, in June Ms. McCarthy had been associated with the Center for about twenty years, and has had close contact with residents of North Beach Place during that period. The author interviewed Susan Cerny in March Ms Cerny has probably gathered more information on Henry Gutterson, one of the architects of North Beach Place, than anyone else. D. Bibliography 1.
Title history Sales Ledgers, At the San Francisco Assessor's Office, City Hall. 2. Design and construction "Bids Asked on North Beach Place," San Francisco Chronicle, October 5, p. 10. Bolles, John S. "North Beach Place Housing Project," Architect and Engineer, July "Housing Projects Postponed by High Building Costs." San Francisco Chronicle, January 24, p. 9. NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 9) "In the News." Architect and Engineer, October p. 46. "In the News." Architect and Engineer, November p. 45. "New Buildings for Old." San Francisco Chronicle, March 10, p. 7. "North Beach Housing." San Francisco Chronicle, March 10, p. 30. "North Beach Place to Be Built by San Francisco Chronicle, October 16, p. 10. 3.
Opening and NAACP lawsuit Calene, John. "North Beach Housing Will Ban Negroes." San Francisco Chronicle, August 22, p. 1. "Court Acts on Housing Race Issue." San Francisco Chronicle, September 4, p. 1. "Court Voids Policy on Housing." San Francisco Chronicle, August 27, p. 1. "New Housing Project Opens." San Francisco Chronicle, September 14, p. 3. Negro Housing Ban Is Outlawed." San Francisco Chronicle, October 2, Housing Segregation Loses Again." San Francisco Chronicle, October 23, p. 1. 4. Ethnic and occupational analysis The reverse directories at the ends of the and San Francisco city directories listed the names of nearly all residents of North Beach Place.
As the housing project had not fully opened when the directory was canvassed, only 112 names ofresidents were found in that year. In and 217 and 212 names were found, respectively. All of these names were then looked up in the front section of the directories, which listed occupations (if any) of the residents. 5. Crime and drug issues, Anders, Corrie, and Leslie Guevarra. "Drug trade booming at housing projects." San Francisco Examiner, October 4, p. NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 10) D'Emilio, Frances. "Fed-Up Tenants Fight City Hall." San Francisco Chronicle, February 26, p. 6. Linn, Amy. "Politics the view from the projects." San Francisco Examiner, July 23, p. A-1. _ _ _ .
"Shelter Skelter." Weekly, November 1, McCarthy, Denise. Telephone interview by William Kostura, June 3, O'Connor, John D. "Crack gangs at war in San Francisco Examiner, January 4, p. A-18. ___ . cops on trail of gang gunplay." San Francisco Examiner, December 2, p. A-1. 6. Demolition and replacement of North Beach Place Hatfield, Larry D. gets millions to redo housing." San Francisco Examiner, August 25, p. 1. Karakasevic, Laura. "Reconstruction of North Beach Housing Development Under Reconsideration." North Beach Now, April Lelchuk, Ilene. "North Beach project residents ready to fight eviction." San Francisco Chronicle, August 9, _ _ _ . "Strapped tenants hesitant to move." San Francisco Chronicle, November 23, Mullman, Jeremy. "A Moving Experience." Weekly, December 12, 7.
Early history of housing project construction in the United States Robinson and Associates, Inc., and Jeffrey Shrimpton. "Historic Context: Public Housing in the United States, (Draft). Prepared for U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, 8. Early Housing Projects in San Francisco Andreini, Don. "San Francisco Marks 50 Years of Public Housing." Heritage Newsletter, Vol. 17, no. 3 NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 11) "Chinatown Project First of Six Local Developments." San Francisco Chronicle, July 3, p. 2. "San Francisco Builds Low Rent Homes." Architect and Engineer, July 9. Henry Gutterson Cerny, Susan Dinkelspiel. Berkeley Landmarks.
Berkeley, CA: Berkeley Architectural Heritage Association, See listings of buildings by Gutterson. _ _ _. "Henry Gutterson." In Robert Winter, ed., Toward a Simpler Way of Life. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, ___ (writing as Susan Dinkelspiel Stem). "Henry Higby Gutterson: Residential Work in Berkeley." Berkeley, CA: Berkeley Architectural Heritage Association, ___ . Telephone interview by William Kostura, March 15, 10. Ernest Born "Ernest Born, California Monthly, December "In Memory." AJA/SF, October p. 15. "Milestones." CED News (University of California), Fall p. 41. DeMars, Vernon Armand. Interviewed by Suzanne B. Reiss. "Ernest Born." Berkeley Digital Library SunSITE (The Library, University of California, Berkeley). Joncas, Richard, et. al. Stanford University.
New York: Princeton University Press, Woodbridge, Sally. "From the Large-Small House to the Large-Large House." In Woodbridge, ed., Bay Area Houses. Salt Lake City: Gibbs Smith, E. Likely Sources Not Yet Investigated San Francisco city directories for the years could reveal how long residents of North Beach Place lived at that housing project. A random sample of names can be obtained from the reverse index at the rear of the directory. These names could be looked up in the front of directories and the dates of residency NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (Building No. 11) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 12) could thus be established.
It might be useful to compare how long early residents of North Beach Place lived in the housing project, compared to how long residents from later in the building's history lived there. No residents of North Beach Place were interviewed for this report. Interviews with long-time residents would certainly provide useful information. PART IV. PROJECT INFORMATION In William Kostura, of Oakland, and Carey and Co., of San Francisco, produced Historic Architecture Survey Report for the Replacement of North Beach Place Housing Project, San Francisco, CA for Robert Shaw and Associates, BRIDGE Housing Corporation, and the Mayor's Office of Housing. The demolition and replacement of North Beach Place is using federal funds, and is subject to NEPA and CEQA.
The report was produced to satisfy the historic preservation elements of NEPA and CEQA. The report found North Beach Place to be eligible for the National Register under Criterion C, for its design and for its association with two important Bay Area architects, Henry Gutterson and Ernest Born. It was significant at the local level, within the broader historic context of public housing in the United States before and shortly after World War II. This HABS report was written in as mitigation for the demolition of North Beach Place. The author was William Kostura, an architectural historian. In addition to this written report, large-format archival photographs have been taken to document the appearance of this housing project.
NORTH BEACH PLACE, 531 BAY STREET, 650 Francisco Street (BuiJding No. J 1) HABS No. CA-2727-K (Page 13) . f i i I ~r ; 1 . -,, i.i -~ m'. 1a~-~ + ~ i 4 1;;';;;:'H'!i'~.,~ = l''...,oo=!>:"=-- =d~~;.,;..:;.;;~,jb~~~-A:i~ . " ... ' -_ _ ;;-~J~i!;;~~'ea;r-~ "_" - till . . _ :r- ; .., # First through fourth floor plans Building 11, North Beach Place