Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage, Stanislaus National Forest, Kennedy Meadow
Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage, Stanislaus National Forest, Kennedy Meadow, Tuolumne County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CA-2279, with a 3,885-word written history.
From the record
“The Relief Cabin was constructed in as part of the Spring Gap- Stanislaus System to replace the original Relief Dam tender's cabin lost to fire in The cabin is clearly representative of PG&E's early hydroelectric development in the Sierra Nevada and California.”
Written record, HAER CA-2279 survey. Machine-read text.
Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CA-2279 · the record runs 3885 words · one of 64 surveyed structures published for this county.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2279.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
Kennedy Meadow Vicinity Emigrant Wilderness, Tuolumne County, California USGS Sonora Pass Quadrangle, UTM Coordinates: Zone 11, E, N Date(s) of Construction: modifications in Builder: Pacific Gas and Electric Company Present Owner(s): Pacific Gas and Electric Company Present Occupant(s): Pacific Gas and Electric Company
Significance
3770 words
The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2279.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
The Relief Cabin was constructed in as part of the Spring Gap- Stanislaus System to replace the original Relief Dam tender's cabin lost to fire in The cabin is clearly representative of PG&E's early hydroelectric development in the Sierra Nevada and California. The cabin has been determined eligible for the National Register of Historic Places under criteria A and C with a period of significance dating to its construction in Report Prepared By: Cindy L. Baker, Historian PAR Environmental Services, Inc. Street Sacramento, CA Date: December Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage (Building HAER No. CA-2279 Page No. 2
Description
The employees' residence, Relief Cabin (Building is part of the Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Camp in Tuolumne County, California. It was built in by Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) to replace an earlier tender's cottage destroyed by fire. Relief Reservoir is part of the Spring Gap-Stanislaus System (FERC Project No. issued by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). The Spring Gap- Stanislaus System is located in Calaveras and Tuolumne counties and consists of two powerhouses, two dams and reservoirs, two diversion dams, associated ditches, tunnels, penstocks, and other hydroelectric features. A comprehensive history and evaluation of the system is available in National Register of Historic Places Evaluation, Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, FERC No.
Calaveras and Tuolumne Counties, California (Baker The Spring Gap-Stanislaus System as a whole is ineligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places Some elements of the system are eligible on an individual basis. Among those elements, Relief Dam was evaluated in as individually eligible at a state level of significance under criteria A and C with a period of significance from to (Cindy Baker, National Register of Historic Places, Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, FERC No. Tuolumne County, California. (Sacramento: PAR Environmental Services, Relief Dam was the largest rock-fill dam of its kind when it was constructed in and remained so until the construction of Fordyce Dam in Nevada County in Relief Cabin has been in continuous use for 80 years.
The cabin's physical setting is unchanged since its construction in consisting of undeveloped steeply sloping mountainsides with mature pine forest and other native forest vegetation. In Relief Cabin was determined eligible at a local level of significance under criteria A and C for its close association with Relief Dam, with a period of significance of its year of construction (Cindy Baker and Mary Maniery, National Register of Historic Places Evaluation for Relief Cottage, Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Tuolumne County, California (Sacramento: PAR Environmental Services, Inc., 11.
On-site examination of the cottage, an analysis of engineering drawings and reports, and archival research indicate that the historical integrity of the original structural design, materials, workmanship, setting, location, feeling and association are intact. II. ARCHITECTURAL AND ENGINEERING INFORMATION Building (Dam Tender's Cabin) and Camp Site The cabin site consists of a Pacific Gas and Electric Company cabin, an outhouse, a bridge, a rock wall, a well house, other features of unknown function and an associated trash scatter with several concentrations. It is situated in a wilderness meadow surrounded by a conifer forest (CA-2279-1). Relief Cabin (Building is a rectangular, wood-frame structure measuring 25 feet by 40 feet.
The one-story cabin sits on a concrete foundation and has an above-ground full-width basement, a first floor and full attic. The structure's footprint is 22 feet by 40 feet, and is divided into three rooms. Two rooms (the kitchen and living rooms) are 12 feet by 22 feet, while the third room (the bedroom) is 16 feet by 22 feet. A bathroom is Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage (Building HAER No. CA-2279 Page No. 3 attached to the bedrooms (Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Construct House for Lake Tender at Relief Reservoir, GMO The cabin is simple in design with a steeply-pitched gable roof clad in galvanized metal sheets with exposed rafter tails and three knee braces at each end; one at the apex and one at each eave joint.
The siding is vertical battens behind wide (12-inch) boards and appears to be a modern addition. Original siding (as seen inside the basement) was horizontal shiplap siding. A belly band wraps around the building. Fenestration is symmetrical and consists of wood-sash, double-hung single pane windows with extended stiles. One aluminum slider window is present at the basement level on the west side (see attached floor plan for window locations). The east elevation contains four windows, all symmetrically placed (CA-2279-2, There are two centrally placed windows on the north elevation and one on the south elevation above the staircase. There are also three symmetrically placed windows on the west elevation.
In addition to the basement and first floor windows, one original window is present at the attic level on each gable end of the building. The cabin is accessed by a side staircase and landing on the south, main fa9ade (CA- A second staircase leads to a second entry on the west side (CA-2279-3). The basement access is provided by a ground-level exterior entry on the north side (CA-2279-2, -4) and an interior staircase. Four exterior doors at these entries to the cabin are original and are five-panel wood with metal knobs. Windows and doors are covered with shutters (CA-2279-9) for protection against the elements. The basement (CA-2279-16) has concrete floors and an eight-foot-tall exposed strut ceiling with few interior walls that are finished with horizontal clapboard siding.
The space is used as a shop area and has a built-in work bench, wood storage space, water heater closet and a staircase. The basement floor rises in elevation from north to south, with a step leading to each raised section. The attic is unfinished with a sloping ceiling seven feet tall at the ridgeline. The living space on the main floor contains a kitchen, living room, bedroom and bath. The interior walls are clad with beaver board. It features hot and cold water plumbing, although it had no electric service. Two wood-burning stoves, one for cooking and heating water and one for room heating, provide all the heat in the cabin. The kitchen stove has a 30- gallon water tank. Flue pipes for the cabin are galvanized iron with terra cotta lining and terra cotta flue heads.
All lighting is provided by kerosene lanterns and lamps. The kitchen (CA-2279-11, has built-in cabinets and pantry and contains the original wood-burning cook stove. The four-burner cast iron stove (Wood Stove No. Al/Wrought Iron Range Company, St. Louis, Missouri) (CA-2279-10) is stamped "HOME COMFORT." A propane-fueled modern range is also present. The living room (CA-2279- 13, has a built-in window seat on the east wall and a closet. It is heated by an original cast-iron Wedgewood-brand stove. The stove is stamped "JAS Graham Co., & Newark, CA." The bedroom (CA-2279-15) contains a closet on the north wall and also has two vertical ladders in the southwest corner of the room accessed by a door. One ladder leads to the attic and the other to the basement.
The bath is small and contains an original cast-iron claw-foot tub, a modern fiberglass shower, toilet and built-in shelves and linen closet. Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage (Building HAER No. CA-2279 Page No. 4 There is a four-foot-square outhouse (CA-2279-17, located approximately 70 feet west of the cabin on the other side of a small drainage. The outhouse is wood frame and clad with sheet metal pieces on the exterior. It has a sheet metal shed roof with a rectangular vent. The interior is wood with a platform and one seat. The outhouse is elevated and sits on a wood platform. There is a bridge (CA-2279-18) located on a small drainage (tributary of Summit Creek) approximately 40 feet west of the cabin.
It is wood frame and the deck of the bridge consists of three-foot-long boards laid crosswise over the beams. The bridge is fifteen feet long and three feet wide. There is a U-shaped concrete abutment at the east end of the bridge. The concrete abutment is four feet wide at its narrowest part, near the bridge. It has three- foot-long concrete wings that extend out from the bridge at approximately 30-degree angles, creating a funneled approach. The west end is placed in the slope of the drainage and has no visible abutment. A well house (CA-2279-19, is situated approximately 35 feet west of the cabin. It measures eight feet long by six feet wide and is three to four feet high. The well house consists of two parts that are joined, but have different construction.
The stream side (western) two-thirds of the well house is of concrete block construction. The south wall of the western part of the well house has two hollow tile blocks covered with screen mesh at the center of the wall. The concrete block section is capped with large aggregate cement cap that is approximately three inches thick. The east or upslope third of the well house has a concrete block foundation and a wood frame structure clad with random-pattern shingles. This section has a shed roof covered with shakes. Modifications In PG&E performed maintenance work on the cabin, the first since its construction 44 years earlier.
Exterior work included replacing the two exterior stairways, including the handrails, the front door and wood half-screen door, all window screens, casings, stops and trim. More exterior work included removing cracked and peeling coating on the cladding to prepare the building for painting. Wood shutters were also installed to prevent vandalism and winter storm damage. Interior repairs included covering the bedroom ceiling with plywood to cover damaged areas. Once this work was completed, the entire cabin was painted inside and out (Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Maintenance and Repairs to Relief Reservoir Cabin Building No.
- Tuolumne County GM While most maintenance consisted of in-kind repairs, others, such as wood shutters and the plywood ceiling, represented minor changes to the original cabin design. III. IDSTORICAL INFORMATION Spring Gap-Stanislaus Project The climate and topography of the Stanislaus River provides an excellent location for a hydroelectric system. Hydroelectric systems exist where conditions make it possible to combine production with convenient transmission to a market. The water source must be higher in elevation than the powerhouse and the powerhouse cannot be too far removed from the market place, the ultimate power consumers.
The highest point in the Spring Gap- Stanislaus Project (Project) is the reservoir at Relief Dam at feet above mean sea level Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage (Building HAER No. CA-2279 Page No. 5 (amsl), which collects a considerable storage of precipitation runoff. From this high elevation, the water provides a valuable power before its gravitation energy runs out on the Sacramento Valley floor (Baker, Spring Gap-Stanislaus, 6). From Relief Reservoir, water is released to the Middle Fork Stanislaus River where it flows 45 miles (through two larger reservoirs now owned by Tri-Dam Project) to Sand Bar Diversion Dam, which diverts the water to an 11-mile-long tunnel.
Water from the tunnel exits to a 320-acre-foot forebay and 4,707-foot-long penstock before reaching the Stanislaus Powerhouse in the Stanislaus River canyon below. A second large reservoir, Pinecrest Lake, on the South Fork Stanislaus River is created by Strawberry Dam, which releases stored water to the river. A few miles downstream, it is diverted to the Philadelphia Ditch, which carries it 4.7 miles to Spring Gap Forebay and the penstock to the Spring Gap Powerhouse. Once its head has been expended for hydroelectric generation, the water is released to the Middle Fork Stanislaus River where it joins the water from the Relief Reservoir above the Sand Bar Diversion Dam (Baker, Spring Gap-Stanislaus, 6).
The Spring Gap-Stanislaus Project was formulated and established during the rush in the early twentieth century to develop hydroelectric generation in the United States. Its origins are complex. By the Stanislaus Electric Power Company began construction of the system with the completion of Relief Dam and the original Stanislaus Powerhouse. After their economic failure, the Sierra and San Francisco Power Company continued the work with the construction of Strawberry Dam, only to suffer economic collapse itself. The Company ultimately completed the project with the development of the Spring Gap Powerhouse project.
By the early three companies -- Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Pacific Light and Power, and Great Wes tern Power -- were racing to develop their systems in California and capture the major urban markets (Baker, Spring Gap-Stanislaus, 9). The storage foundations of the Project are Relief Reservoir and Pinecrest Lake. Relief Reservoir provides storage for the Stanislaus Powerhouse, while Pinecrest serves the Spring Gap Powerhouse (completed in The system today is an important power producer of the PG&E's Motherlode Watershed, one of its five watersheds in California between Bakersfield and the Oregon border (Baker, Spring Gap-Stanislaus, 4). Relief Dam and Cabin Relief Dam was constructed between and by the Stanislaus Electric Power Company.
At that time, it was one of the first large rock-filled reinforced concrete dams ever built. Concrete's ability to hold water was largely untested and engineers took great care in Reliefs design. All of the backing for the concrete facing was laid by hand and carefully filled (Baker, Spring Gap-Stanislaus, 9). The dam sits at the outlet of Relief Valley at 7 feet above mean sea level in an area that typically receives 15 feet of snowfall annually. When the dam was completed, the last structure needed was a four-room cabin for the dam tender. The tender, who monitored water levels, releases, and dam safety, also watched over the construction camp, still filled with equipment, that remained at the remote site.
The first tender's cabin was completed in (Lawrence Shoup and Glenn Caruso, Cultural Resources Overview and National Register of Historic Places Significance Evaluation of Relief Dam and Vicinity, Stanislaus National Forest Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage (Building HAER No. CA-2279 Page No. 6 After PG&E took over operation of the dam as part of its Stanislaus Hydroelectric System lease agreement. From then on, all work on Relief Dam and the cabin was conducted by PG&E (Baker, Spring Gap-Stanislaus, 11; Shoup and Caruso Relief Dam, In the fall of a forest fire swept through the area, destroying the cabin, gate valve house, and other wooden structures at Relief Dam.
During the winter, the tender was required to make daily trips by foot to the dam. During the spring and summer when runoff was greater, two trips a day were necessary (Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Construct House for Lake Tender at Relief Reservoir, GMO PG&E constructed a new dam tender's cabin at Relief in the summer of Hauling the materials to the site proved to be no small task and was one of the major expenses of the project. All supplies had to be trucked 60 miles from Sonora to Kennedy Meadow and then hauled up a steep grade to Relief, one and a half miles over rough trail. In addition to wood, building paper, and other basic building materials, furnishings such as a Wedgewood stove and cast iron bathtub also needed to be carried in.
In all, over $1, 119 of the total construction cost of was for shipping, roughly a quarter of the costs (PG&E "Construct House"). The cabin's design was intended to be similar to that of the tender's house at Bear River. The cabin was designated by PG&E as Building In the Company added an 18-inch by 72-inch metal exterior sign on the gable-end of the cabin reading, "Relief Cabin, Pacific Gas & Electric, Elevation (Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Place sign at Relief Reservoir, Metal, 18" by 72" PG&E made an exhaustive inventory of the cabin and its furnishings in At that time, the buildings at Relief Reservoir included the cabin, an outdoor cooler, an outhouse, a spring shelter, and a tool house located at the weir on Relief Creek.
The tool house was an unpainted wood-framed shed measuring five feet, 10 inches by four feet, eight inches and almost seven feet tan. It was wood framed with sheathing and battens. Its roof was covered with pine shakes (Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Inventory and Appraisal, Federal Power Project No. Stanislaus-Spring Gap, as of Jan. 1, Vol. Buildings and Property Improvements, Field Notes and Computations: Relief Reservoir, Sand Bar Dam, Camp (Valuation Department, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, The tool house has been removed. In the equipment at Relief included camp furniture, fire station equipment, and tools. The cabin could accommodate many occupants, if needed. It included eight folding steel pipe-frame cots with angle iron spring frames.
There were 14 army-type mattresses, two cotton mattresses, and four handmade cot pads. There were also four feather pillows and 12 double- sized wool blankets. Other furniture included five homemade benches, a folding camp chair, a wood kitchen chair, two handmade Morris chairs with adjustable backs and canvas seats and backs, and a 10-inch-square handmade stool. There were four handmade tables. One was two feet square for the bedroom and another was two and a half feet by five feet with two drawers. Two others were covered with linoleum. One measured three feet square and sat in the living room, while the other was three feet by six and one half feet and served as a dining table with bench seating.
There were also firewood boxes in the living room and kitchen near the stoves (PG&E "Inventory"). Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage (Building HAER No. CA-2279 Page No. 7 Lighting was provided by 13 kerosene lamps. Seven had glass globes, four of which could be mounted to the walls. The other six were iron "Magnet" table lamps. The Relief "fire station," situated in the kitchen and labeled with a glass-faced fire station site, contained a two and one-half-gallon "Protex" fire extinguisher. For safety purposes, the cabin had two Bullard brand first aid kits and one manufactured by Johnson and Johnson. Finally, because the cabin was used heavily in winter, standard furnishings included skis and snowshoes (PG&E "Inventory").
The cabin, the only protected dwelling in this remote, high elevation location, became heavily used by PG&E personnel. It is also on the main trail to the Emigrant Basin Wilderness Area leading from Kennedy Meadows Packing Station. According to a PG&E work order, hikers and skiers caught by unexpected weather also sometimes used the cabin for emergency shelter (Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Install Septic Tank and Leaching Field, Relief Reservoir Cabin, GM By it was the headquarters for water regulation and maintenance crews for the reservoir. With the fairly constant use of the cabin's facilities, effluent was leaching into the groundwater from the cabin's septic system.
To relieve the situation, PG&E sent a crew with horses and mules to gather all the drain lines from the cabin together into a common line and install a new septic tank and leach field farther from the cabin and away from the spring. At the same time, a new sink was installed in the bathroom and new sink faucets were installed in the kitchen. This work entailed the first maintenance of the cabin (PG&E "Install Septic"). In PG&E performed additional maintenance work on the cabin, the first since its construction 44 years earlier. Exterior work included replacing the two exterior stairways, including the handrails, the front door and wood half-screen door, all window screens, casings, stops and trim.
More exterior work included removing cracked and peeling coating on the cladding to prepare the building for painting. Wood shutters were installed to prevent vandalism and winter storm damage. Interior repairs included covering the bedroom ceiling with plywood to cover damaged areas. Once this work was completed, the entire cabin was painted inside and out (Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Maintenance and Repairs to Relief Reservoir Cabin Building No. - Tuolumne County GM While most maintenance consisted of in-kind repairs, others, such as wood shutters and the plywood ceiling, represented minor changes to the original cabin design. Other than these repairs, the cabin has remained largely intact from its original construction design.
Relief Cabin has been in continuous use by the Company for over 80 years. According to local PG&E personnel, it is occasionally used for emergency shelter by hikers and skiers caught in harsh winter storms in this remote location. Today it is a well- known landmark on the trail from Kennedy Meadow on the way to the Emigrant Basin Wilderness Area. IV.
PROJECT INFORMATION This documentation has been prepared at the request of PG&E (the Licensee), who is required by Stanislaus National Forest to remove the Relief Cottage on the Spring Gap- Stanislaus Hydroelectric System (FERC The documentation is being completed to fulfill stipulations set forth in a Memorandum of Agreement between the California State Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage (Building HAER No. CA-2279 Page No. 8 Historic Preservation Officer, FERC and PG&E as part of the Section 106 compliance process. The Project Manager, Cindy L. Baker of PAR Environmental Services, Inc. was the Principal Investigator for the written documentation. The document is based on a previous investigation conducted by PAR Environmental Services, Inc.
reported in National Register of Historic Places Evaluation for Relief Cottage, Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System (FERC Tuolumne County, California (Baker and Maniery The photographer for the recordation was David DeVries of Mesa Technical of Berkeley, California. James Mangold of Pacific Gas and Electric Company facilitated the work as PG&E's contact and coordination persons. Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Relief Reservoir Dam Tender's Cottage (Building HAER No. CA-2279 Page No. 9 V.
Sources
Cindy Baker, National Register of Historic Places, Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, FERC No. Tuolumne County, California. (Sacramento: PAR Environmental Services, 37. Cindy Baker and Mary Maniery, National Register of Historic Places Evaluation for Relief Cottage, Spring Gap-Stanislaus Hydroelectric System, Tuolumne County, California (Sacramento: PAR Environmental Services, Inc., Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Construct House for Lake Tender at Relief Reservoir, GMO Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Place sign at Relief Reservoir, Metal, 18" by Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Inventory and Appraisal, Federal Power Project No. Stanislaus-Spring Gap, as of Jan. 1, Vol.
Buildings and Property Improvements, Field Notes and Computations: Relief Reservoir, Sand Bar Dam, Camp (Valuation Department, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Install Septic Tank and Leaching Field, Relief Reservoir Cabin, GM ( Pacific Gas and Electric Company, "Maintenance and Repairs to Relief Reservoir Cabin Building No. - Tuolumne County GM Lawrence Shoup and Glenn Caruso, Cultural Resources Overview and National Register of Historic Places Significance Evaluation of Relief Dam and Vicinity, Stanislaus National Forest
The federal survey recorded these other structures elsewhere in Tuolumne County. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CA-2279. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.