Tri-Dam and Stanislaus National Forest sponsored the Sugar Pine Railway grade documentation for recreational improvements required under the Federal Regulatory Energy Commission license for the Beardsley-Donnells Hydroelectric Project (FERC No. Kevin (Lex) Palmer of HDR Engineering prepared the historical report. David De Vries of Mesa Technical performed the large format photography and archival print production. SUGAR PINE RAILWAY GRADE HAER-CA-2308 (PageJ1 Part I. Historical Information A. Context and Physical History: In New York financier Thomas S. Bullock began efforts to establish the Sierra Railway Company to access timber patents he purchased in the Sierra Nevada Mountain range. Bullock partnered with the French Prince Poniatowski, and San Francisco banker W. H.
Crocker, and oversaw completion of the standard gauge Sierra Railway from the city of Oakdale in the Central Valley to Jamestown in Tuolumne County: When completed in the Sierra Railway penetrated further into the Sierra Nevada than any other railroad in California, excepting the transcontinental Central Pacific. l This line would provided mainline access for the soon-to-be- constructed Sugar Pine Railway. The Standard Lumber Company Tenure: Thomas Bullock's numerous business interests included the Standard Lumber Company incorporated in 2 The company owned three mills and a sash and door factory located adjacent to the Sierra Railway's docking yard in Sonora.
3 Bullock reasoned that the company would be more efficient if a spur was added to the existing railroad line to transport timber from the forests to the market place. The Sugar Pine Railway incorporated on February 24, with plans to establish sixty miles of track east from the Sonora locale to the Big Tree Grove in Calaveras County. By late workers had laid nine miles oftrack.4 Logging of sugar pine and ponderosa pine began immediately in the surrounding forest. By the Sugar Pine Railway tracks had reached the 5 Lyons Reservoir adding five miles to the previous route. At Lyons Creek, to the east of the reservoir and at the east terminus of the Sugar Pine, an incline was built to connect the Sugar Pine Railway with the Empire City Railway.
Construction activity under Bullock's tenure had now completed. He then worked to transfer the railway ownership to the Standard Lumber Company, and arrange for conveyance rights to allow Sugar Pine trains passage over the Sierra Railway tracks with the purpose of reaching two spurs, a mill, and a shop located in Sonora. 6 . This was an important transaction for the Sierra Railway, which had been built primarily to carry passengers and gold mining-related freight. Sierra Nevada hard rock gold mine production had declined and decreased the need to ship ore from mines to crushing mills. Timber became a more valuable commodity to haul and thus emphasis was placed on transporting the raw and finished wood product via the railroads.
I Dorothy Newell Deane, Sierra Railway (Berkeley: Howell-North, Charles M. Coleman, and E. of California. The Centennial Story of Pacific Gas and Electric Company (New York: McGraw-Hill, nd 2 Pamela Connors, The Sugar Pine Railway History of a Sierran Logging Railroad. 2 ed. (Big Oak Flat: Yosemite Highway Herald, N. A., "Timber!" The Quarterly 6 3 The Quarterly, 4 Connors, The Sugar Pine Railway. 7. 5 California State Railroad Commission, "In the Matter of Ascertaining the Value of the Property of the Sugar Pine Railroad" (Sacramento: California State Archives, 6 Manuel J.
Marshall, Sugar Pine Railroad (Sonora: Tuolumne County Historical Society, SUGAR PINE RAILWAY GRADE HAER-CA-2308 (Page;1f The Sugar Pine Railway trains hauled logs out of the woods to mills across the fourteen miles of standard gauge rail from Lyons to Ralph.7 The line was extended to Rushing in slightly east of Lyons Reservoir. 8 The Sonora mill closed that year and milling operations moved to the new town of Standard located two miles west of Ralph Station. 9 The Standard Lumber Company constructed a six-mile railroad line frOlTI the Sugar Pine line at Rushing, to Camp Fraser which remained the east terminous for years.
The Empire Mill and significant stands of timber owned by the Standard Lumber Company burned down in A few years later, the Standard Lumber Company could not obtain insurance for its remaining mills located in the forest. IO This signaled an end for California lumber mills being located in forested settings. Harvested logs were hauled out of forests to centralized lumber mills located in urban settings from this point onward. 11 Pickering Railroad and Lumber Company Tenure: The Sugar Pine Railway and Standard Lumber Company sold in to W. R. and W. H. Pickering, who changed the name of their acquisitions to the Pickering Railroad and Pickering Lumber Company, respectively.
The Pickerings significantly expanded logging activity on over acres of forest lands to supply the Tuolumne County mills. The Sonora mill itself manufactured doors annually during the period of prosperity. 12 Bullock originally established the Sugar Pine Railway to reach the massive sequoia trees at Big Grove in Calaveras County. The Pickerings began efforts in to achieve Bullock's goal and to access the estimated four billion board feet of timber located along the Middle Fork of the Stanislaus River. W.A Pickering hired consulting engineer R.E. Jackson to survey the locale and locate terrain that had suitable rail grade topography and supervise its construction. Jackson worked for the Portland-based Thomas & Meservey firm that specialized in forest engineering.
During the fall of and spring of Jackson and his crew surveyed the area and marked a route from Beardsly Flat north to Soap Creek Pass (refer to Figure 1 below).13 During the summer of Marsh Brothers and Gardenier, Incorporated workers constructed portions of the new grade at Schoettgen Junction (situated two miles above Lyons Reservoir) to divert trains from the old Standard Lumber Company line toward Schoettgen Pass. 14 The line would later be extended to Soap Creek Pass. 7 California State Railroad Commission, 8 California State Railroad Commission, "Physical Valuation of the Sugar Pine Railroad as of June (Sacramento: California State Archives, 9 E.H. Hodge, "Condensed Histories of East Belt Communities of Tuolumne County" The Quarterly 1 3.
10 Adolph Hungry Wolf, Rails in the Mother Lode (Burbank: Darwin Publications, II Lawrence Shoup, Shelly Davis-King, and Susan K. Goldberg, Cultural Resources Investigations for the Phoenix Hydroelectric Project License Application (FERC (San Francisco: Pacific Gas and Electric Company, 22. 12 Hungry Wolf: 13 Connors, 14 Connors, SUGAR PINE RAIL WAY GRADE HAER-CA-2308 (Page)'ftf11 Beardsley Flat Logging Camp and Reservoir Beardsley Flat located along the Middle Fork of the Stanislaus River provided ideal topograpy to base logging operations so as to access the vast timber tracts in the locale. Reaching this area proved one of the most difficult construction feats for the Sugar Pine Railway. During the construction season work took place in the Middle Fork canyon downstream from the flat.
It required costly and time-consuming cutting into granite which resulted in the nickname "Million Dollar Road," for the construction costs per mile associated with this segment. Work was completed on a steel bridge that crossed the Middle Fork by Chinaman Creek below the flat in July and the new route was in place at Beardsley Flat with its distinctive loop located on the northeast side of the flat. Marsh Brothers workers built the standard-gauge grade at this location using Giant Powder to blast rocks out of the railroad grade and by clearing out trees. They installed iron drainage culverts to carry snow melt water away from the grade during the spring. Laborers cut the grade through hillocks and extended the line from the Beardsley Camp loop northeast to access tilnber tracts.
Pickering also established the Beardsley Flat camp for its logging crews in (refer to Figure 2 below). As these new improvements began to be used the Black Friday stock market crash occurred. This economic downturn ended the construction boom that lumber companies had supplied. The Pickerings halted logging operations from to Curtailed logging operations by the Pickerings began in using Dry Meadows as a base. Camp Beardsley no longer housed logging crews, having been replaced by section and railroad operations maintenance crews. By Pickering began using trucks to haul logs, a trend that increased over time and ultimately resulted in the demise of the Sugar Pine Railway.
IS The Last Years o.fOperation: As early as the Beardsley Flat area had been studied as a dam site for the Oakdale and South San Joaquin irrigation districts. This did not reach fruition until the late when construction began on three dams along the river that became known as the Tri-Dam Project. Pickering Lumber was forced to relocate its logging camp, Camp Beardsley, in and portions of the railroad grade and the former logging camp disappeared under the waters of the newly formed Beardsley Reservoir. Workers laid rails across the top of the dam to allow the Sugar Pine Railway trains to traverse the now-flooded Beardsley Flat so as to access the Soap Creek Pass segment to the west.
16 The efficiency of trucks with their flexibility to traverse both paved and unpaved roads economically outweighed the benefits of logging trains with their ability to haul larger loads. Workers removed thirty-two miles of the main line rails between Soap Creek Pass and Schoettgen Pass in By December the rail crossing over Beardsley Dam was converted to a road to allow trucks to carry logs to rail cars at Schoettgen Pass. The last Sugar Pine Railway train made a run on the remaining rails between Lyons Pass and Standard in December ending over sixty-five years of operation.
17 15 Connors, 16 Connors, 17 Connors, SUGAR PINE RAILWAY GRADE HAER-CA-2308 (Page After the Pickering railroad logging operation ended the Stanislaus National Forest established a campground in the former Camp Beardsley location. The environment surrounding the segments consists of Sierra Nevada range lower montane zone vegetation consisting of incense cedar and sugar pine trees, and understory formed by native grasses, mountain misery, and manzanita. Beardsley Reservoir is located immediately to the east. Workers removed the rails and ties from the grade after it had been abandoned. This made conversion of the former grade for use as a campground road easy for the Forest Service.
Intact portions of the Sugar Pine Railway at Camp Beardsley have been documented as Segments A, Band F (refer to Figure 3 below). None of the segments have retained their ties or rails. Segment A of the railroad grade trends north of Segment B near where Segment F begins. Segments F and B appear to be part of a former siding located along the main Sugar Pine Railway line. Seglnent A is a dirt surface railroad standard-gauge grade spur. It trends northeast and is long and 12' wide (refer to Figure 3 below). The east end of the grade terminates in the Beardsley Reservoir. No rails or wood ties are present and the grade has two drainage culverts installed in Features 1 and 2 are metal culverts located beneath Segment A that channel water underneath the grade to a natural drainage.
Feature 1 is a 16" -diameter, 15'-long iron culvert buried 3' below the grade surface. Thirty local granite boulders are on the northeast side and ten boulders on the southwest side where the culvert ends surface. Feature 2 is a second historic age culvert also installed to capture natural drainage and carry it away from the grade. The culvert is a 16"-diameter, IT -long iron pipe buried 2' -5" below the grade surface. One local granite boulder is visible on the east side of the grade immediately on top of the pipe. None are visible on the west side. Segment B is a 525'-long and 12'-wide dirt railroad grade with a northeast alignment that extends from Forest Service Road to an earthen berm. A 40' -high cut extends along the entire length of the segment.
A section of heavily deteriorated asphalt paving is located at the northeast end of the segment. Segment F is a -long and 11' -wide dirt surface railroad grade located at the base of a steep slope. It is a portion of the Sugar Pine Railway main line and has a southwest-northeast semi-circle configuration. A portion of the grade cuts through a finger ridge that descends from the steep slope, and forms a manmade berm along the eastern margin of the grade. SUGAR PINE RAILWAY GRADE HAER-CA-2308 (PageX~ SOURCES CONSULTED A. Primary