The Western Salt Company Salt Works has been in continuous operation since and retains integrity of design, function, and setting. The Western Salt Company is eligible to the National Register of Historic Places because it has WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No. CA-67 (Page 2) played an important role in the solar salt industry in California. The plant produced up to 10% of California s salt by the The property is also significant because the Salt Works embodies the distinctive characteristics of a solar salt processing facility. Distinctive landscape qualities represented by the Western Salt Company Salt Works have changed little from the operation.
The solar salt industry is predicated on natural processes of evaporation to concentrate the salinity of sea water to create salt crystals. Design features include extensive evaporation ponds, smaller condensing ponds, and very small crystallizing ponds. Ponds are created with earthen dike divisions. Seawater enters the first series of large ponds where the water begins to evaporate and the salinity increases. When salinity reaches a brine-stage the water is moved to smaller condensing ponds, and finally to the crystallization pond, where salt crystals form and are harvested. Processing facilities are located outside of the network of ponds. Description: The full range of evaporation, condensation, and crystallization ponds are represented on the site.
The site includes all of the necessary buildings, structures, and land necessary for operating the Salt Works (Table 1). Primary structures associated with the processing plant are located on the east side of the property. The South Bay Salt Works currently lease the ponds and own and operate the processing plant. The processing plant, while determined eligible, is not included in this HALS report. History: See narrative below. The Western Salt Company Salt Works has been in continuous operation since and retains integrity of design, function, and setting. The Western Salt Company is eligible to the National Register of Historic Places because it has played an important role in the solar salt industry in California.
The plant produced up to 10% of California s salt by the The property is also significant because the Salt Works embodies the distinctive characteristics of a solar salt processing facility. Distinctive landscape qualities represented by the Western Salt Company Salt Works have changed little from the operation. The solar salt industry is predicated on natural processes of evaporation to concentrate the salinity of sea water to create salt crystals. Design features include extensive evaporation ponds, smaller condensing ponds, and very small WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No. CA-67 Page 2 crystallizing ponds. Ponds are created with earthen dike divisions.
Seawater enters the first series of large ponds where the water begins to evaporate and the salinity increases. When salinity reaches a brine-stage the water is moved to smaller condensing ponds, and finally to the crystallization pond, where salt crystals form and are harvested. Processing facilities are located outside of the network of ponds. Historian(s): Angie Gustafson, Architectural Historian and Carrie Gregory, Staff Archaeologist; under the supervision of Dr. Karen J. Weitze, Senior Architectural Historian, EDAW. Report Reference: Historic Resource Evaluation Report for Western salt Company Salt Works, San Diego County, Chula Vista, California. Prepared for Tierra Environmental Services and California Department of Transportation.
Prepared by Gustafson and Gregory, EDAW, San Diego, CA, PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History Date of Construction: Landscape Architect, Designer, etc: Western Salt Company. Builder, contractor, Laborers, suppliers: Western Salt Company. Original and La Punta Salt Works Western Salt Company Subsequent owners, South Bay Salt Company (2000-currently). occupants: Periods of development: a. Original plans and construction: initial construction. b. Changes and additions: reconstruction of ponds, addition of evaporation ponds, revision of power supply, maintenance of levees. B.
Historical Context: The California salt industry began in the but it did not become a commercial industry in the state until the (Ver Planck San Diego Bay was blessed with the three principal requirements to manufacture salt by solar evaporation of seawater on a commercial scale: a large tract of coastal land; a reasonably dry climate; and the existence of a market (Ver Planck Salt has long been a commodity in San Diego Bay, as remembered in the autobiography of Kumeyaay elder, Delfina WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No.
CA-67 Page 3 Cuero, who references salt collection by local Native Americans for use as a cure for fish and as a trade good with other tribes (Phillips Shipek The first foreign exploration of San Diego Bay was in when Juan Rodriguez Cabrillo sailed into the harbor. Although not the first Spanish explorer to arrive in California, Cabrillo was a distinguished man and the one credited with its discovery.
Reports of the Spanish expeditions refer to the salt found in the marshes of San Diego (Pourade 30, The first Euro-American settlement along the southeastern portion of San Diego Bay began in July of when the Kimball brothers, Frank, Warren, and Levi, bought the old Spanish land grant of El Rancho de la Nacion, that included six miles of bay waterfront( Pourade Hoping that San Diego would become a terminus for one of the transcontinental railroads, Frank Kimball prepared the area for the expected influx of people and founded National City.
He made a Town Plat, built a wharf and a hotel, granted land for the railroad, and secured land and bonds from the city of San Diego (Phillips Kimball s dream was fulfilled when the California Southern Railroad was built in National City in the late-1880s (Pourade The bayside railroad and the wharf prompted land speculation in the South Bay area and gave rise to many industries. The area quickly became home to a power plant, reduction plant, iron works, planning mill, brick kiln, and creosote plant. The industrial growth also stimulated residential development of the bayside area, creating the communities of Chula Vista, Oneonta, and Otay.
By Kimball financed the National City and Otay Railway Company, which ran a line from National City to the southern end of the bay (Pourade The San Diego Division of Natural Resources provides one of the earliest records of commercial salt production in San Diego Bay, reporting 300 tons produced in (Ver Planck The earliest written reference of a commercial salt plant in San Diego Bay is of La Punta Salt Works, founded by Shaffer & Stone. La Punta Salt Works began operation in February in the southern portion of the bay at the future site of the Western Salt Company Salt Works. Shaffer and Stone continued to expand La Punta Salt Works to meet the increasing demands. Stone sold his interest in to E.E. and J.E. Shaffer, who continued operations under the name of Shaffer Bros.
By they were the only operating salt plant in the county and annual production was large enough to supply all of Southern California (Elliot Hoping to cash-in on rising salt prices, the Klauber-Wagenheim Company purchased and took over operations of the La Punta Salt Works in (Levy The San Diego City Directory references the extensive manufacturing of salt in the bay, and a Los Angeles Star newspaper correspondent reported that two plants were operating in the bay that same year (Truman The Chollas Valley Works, owned by Duncan and Sons, produced salt sometime before The Division of Mines began keeping records in and show that the Chollas Valley Works manufactured salt from to State records also indicate that the California Salt Company produced small amounts of salt at their Carlsbad and La Costa plants in and (Elliot Graham Babcock founded and incorporated the Western Salt Company in at a location approximately a quarter of a mile northeast of the extant La Punta Salt Works plant (Riehle USC&GS map Graham died a few years later leaving the company to his wife, who sold her WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No.
CA-67 Page 4 interest in the company in January to Graham s father, Elisha S. Babcock. Elisha dissolved the corporation, bought land at the southern end of the bay, and built levees to expand the salt works operation. Babcock continued expanding the operations and making property improvements, reincorporating the Western Salt Company in July (Riehle By the Salt Works installed a narrow gauge rail line at the plant, with permanent track placed on the levees and portable track extending into the ponds at harvest time (Historic photographs; Ver Planck The Western Salt Company began shipping salt to the Pacific Northwest in direct competition with salt producers in San Francisco. Elisha Babcock, an Indiana railroad financier, and Hampton L.
Story, a piano manufacturer, both arrived in San Diego in to improve their health. Babcock, at the age of 34, and his wife Isabel decided to permanently settle in San Diego. Babcock and Story shared a fondness for the San Diego peninsula (Coronado) and formed a syndicate to purchase the property. Planning to build a fine hotel (Hotel del Coronado), they bought more than acres of land, which included Coronado and North Island. The newly formed Coronado Beach Company cleared land and sold residential lots for the community.
Around the same time, Babcock and Story financed the Coronado Railroad Company that operated the Coronado Belt Line around the Bay up to Coronado Island (Pourade In January months of rain finally took its toll on the South Bay communities, causing the collapse of the Lower Otay Dam. The high water of January severely damaged the Western Salt Company, flooding the plant and many of the ponds. The damage caused a financial crisis for Mr. Babcock who had refinanced the company shortly before the flood and still owed the bank about In order to recoup their monies, the bank supported the reconstruction of the site, which lasted through (Riehle Employees of the Western Salt Company rebuilt the Salt Works using plans from an unidentified designer.
Even though operations were of a limited scale, the Western Salt Company produced more than five percent of California s salt in (Historic photographs; San Diego Union Ver Planck Salt produced in San Diego Bay was sold for use in water softeners, textile dying, pickling, road de-icing, hide processing, the fishing industry, and other chemical applications (Gene Mullenix, personal communication Under the management of Drown, the Western Salt Company began to recover financially after the flood. A couple years later, Frank Riehle took over management and the company began showing profits. Rather than pay off the bank note on the Salt Works, Babcock used these profits to finance other business ventures. In April the bank called in his loan and put the company s stock up for sale.
Hearing of Babcock s financial dilemma, Henry G. Fenton came to the Babcock family with an offer to purchase the salt plant. Henry Fenton assisted Elisha Babcock during the early years of the Coronado development, and was a friend of Babcock s son Arnie. In Fenton bought the Salt Works, paid off other notes of the Babcock s, and arranged for their financial support until the death of Babcock in Fenton was a successful businessman who already possessed adjacent property, where he planned to create an industry of delivering rock and sand by barge to the City of San Diego, when he seized the opportunity to purchase the salt works (Riehle WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No.
CA-67 Page 5 Fenton retained the Western Salt Company s management staff of Superintendent Neil B. Dittenhaver and Plant Manager Frank Riehle, who continued working under Mr. Fenton for another twenty-nine years. The experience and knowledge of these two men contributed to the increases in production and sales at the Western Salt Company.
By the end of the Western Salt Company produced more than six percent of California s salt, a figure that rose to eight percent in and ten percent in Although Fenton was new to the salt industry, he quickly gained the respect of California competitors by showing increased production totals and even higher sales totals during the Depression (Riehle A United States Bureau of Mines study found that commercial-scale solar evaporation plants were only found at the Great Salt Lake in Utah and on the California coast because there were only a few areas within the United States where using this method is economically feasible (Coon and Harris Other competing solar salt works in California were the Leslie Salt Works in Newark, the Arden Salt Company and Oliver Brothers Salt Works near San Francisco, and the Monterey Bay Salt Works near Moss landing.
The Pacific Coast Salt Producers Association was organized in by Henry Fenton along with Aldwyn Hewitt, a manager from the Arden Salt Company of San Francisco. This organization helped to stabilize the industry through the end of World War II, when salt consumption increased dramatically (Riehle In Fenton secured submerged land that supported evaporation pools by submitting a bid to lease the land from the newly appointed steward, the California State Lands Commission.
The Western Salt Company offered a bid on 110 acres, which was the only bid for submerged lands that the Commission received (San Diego Union, Between and Fenton purchased or leased at least five other California salt plants with various partners (Riehle The zenith of pond development occurred in when the greatest amount of acreage had been acquired by Fenton. Unfortunately, Fenton died suddenly in leaving behind his legacy in the California salt industry and the successful operation of the Western Salt Company. California salt production continued to increase and in the State of California Division of Mines found, with only minor exceptions, that California produced all of the salt consumed in California, Oregon, Washington, northern Idaho, western Nevada, and Arizona.
The various salt plants in San Francisco Bay, the Western Salt Company in San Diego Bay and Newport Bay, and the Monterey Bay Salt Works at Moss Landing supported practically all of the salt production in California. The Western Salt Company in San Diego Bay was second only to the plants in San Francisco in solar salt production from seawater (Ver Planck 42, Salt production levels in South San Diego Bay remained fairly constant from the to the Changes in the industry caused the Western Salt Company to sell approximately 800 acres to the State Lands Commission and the Port of San Diego in The land was then transferred to the U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service for inclusion in the South San Diego Bay Unit of the San Diego National Wildlife Refuge-Complex of more than acres of salt ponds and adjacent shore line for the protection of several species of threatened or endangered birds that live or feed in the salt ponds. The Fenton family also sold the Western Salt Company to a new enterprise comprised of former employees. The new company, called South Bay Salt Company, leases the Salt Works land from the Port of San Diego and the U.S. Fish WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No. CA-67 Page 6 and Wildlife Service (Gene Mullenix, personal communication Under this agreement, the salt works continues to operate although on a reduced scale.
The crystallizing ponds, salt processing plant, all buildings, except the pump house, and salt pile are still maintained as privately held South Bay Salt Company property (Gustafson and Gregory PART II. PHYSICAL INFORMATION Salt Works A. Landscape Character and Description Summary: Operating a large-scale solar salt business requires thousands of acres for the range of evaporation, condensation, and crystallization ponds necessary for the slow process of changing seawater to salt. Ponds are divided by earthen dikes and arranged in a sequence with seawater entering the first tier of ponds where it is held until the salinity level increases, then the brine is transferred to condensing ponds and finally to the crystallizing ponds where the salt precipitates and is harvested.
There is only one building in the Salt Works, a pump house, located on the levee between two ponds. Small scale elements such as siphons, tide gates, and water control structures control water flow between ponds. Buildings and structures associated with the processing, packaging, and shipping of salt are located outside of the salt pond landscape. B. Character Defining Features: The Western Salt Company salt ponds were initially developed in the as part of the La Punta Salt Works, but a devastating flood in destroyed the ponds. Rebuilding after the flood took into consideration modern tools and equipment and is reflected in the size, shape, and number of ponds created between and Ponds were added over the years, especially on the exterior tier of the unit, further out into the Bay.
The zenith of production and pond size was attained by about Unlike other salt producing regions such as San Francisco Bay, the period of small family-owned salt works was never the pattern in South San Diego Bay, rather it was the site of only a few salt works in the which had combined by and were destroyed in The salt works in South San Diego Bay was operated by a single company between and Since the salt works has been operated by the South Bay Salt Company. The Western Salt Company Salt Works retains a high degree of integrity and clearly reflects the association, setting, function, design, and appearance of a solar salt evaporation operation that has operated continuously for more than 100 years.
Major natural features of the solar salt industry include environmental conditions, available salt water, large parcels of flat tidal lands, and impervious mud. 1. Natural features: a. Topography: Salt marshes and mud flats in South San Diego Bay were considered nearly worthless until salt production began altering the natural landscape. The solar salt industry is dependent on the perfect assemblage of natural environmental features for the production of sea salt. While sea salt may be produced nearly anywhere that salt water is present, the areas where the production can reach an industry-level are few. For instance, only San Francisco Bay, Monterey Bay, and San Diego Bay represent the necessary natural conditions for producing salt from seawater in California.
WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No. CA-67 Page 7 In order for the solar salt industry to flourish several natural features need to occur: a protected bay; large expanses of flat, shallow water shoreline; abundant salt water; months of sunny weather; and periods of rain. The land ideally should be absolutely level and at or close to sea level. Above all, it should be impervious to prevent leakage of brine. Salt marshes most nearly fulfill these conditions (Ver Planck All of the necessary qualities are present in the South San Diego Bay.
Initially the salt industry simply augmented the naturally occurring conditions, but to achieve greater capacity and purer salt the natural tidal marsh and mud flats were improved by building levees to create a network of evaporation ponds. In the twentieth century industrial expansion of the salt industry required larger evaporation ponds and additional pickle ponds to meet the growing demand for salt. The ponds vary in size and shape, in part, by the existing land forms, such as slough or creek channels and the edge of the mud flat. In most instances the ponds have sinuous edges. The crystallizing ponds are usually smaller than the evaporation ponds and are more likely to be rectangular in shape.
Once established the ponds are usually maintained because the cost of building the levees and requirement to create an impervious seal for the bottom of the ponds takes about five years to develop. b. Vegetation: There is no vegetation related to the solar salt industry landscape. c. Water: Water is the primary element of the solar sea salt landscape. Sea water is transported through tide gates into a series of ponds, where it is controlled and allowed to evaporate to create brine. The concentrated brine solution is moved to smaller ponds where it evaporates further. The landscape is defined by the water-filled ponds and changing color of the water as the salinity level increases. The final crystallizing ponds turn white with the precipitating salt crystals.
Water control structures, gates, siphons, and flumes are used to manipulate the filling and discharge of salt water between ponds. 2. Spatial Organization a. Land patterns: The solar salt industry is distinguished by its spatial organization as defined by levees that divide the concentrating ponds. The solar salt industry is based on a series of various sized ponds divided by levees. The size and placement of ponds relates to levels of salinity and controlling water and brine. The initial concentrating ponds are arranged in a series of about 10 ponds along the exterior of the salt works, separated from the Bay by a berm. Salt water flows in from the bay and is monitored during the spring, summer, and fall.
When the brine reaches a certain salinity level it is called pickle and is moved to the pickling ponds where the salinity continues to intensify. The crystallizing pond is the final step in the evaporation process. The crystallizing pond is managed to a specific gravity by withdrawing bittern and replacing it with fresh pickle until the correct depth of salt deposits is reached (Ver Planck WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No. CA-67 Page 8 Crystallizing ponds are fairly small, rectangular in shape, and have flat bottoms. The ratio of concentrating ponds to crystallizing ponds is usually 15 to 1. Evaporation ponds can be up to 200 acres in size, pickle ponds about 100 acres and crystallizing ponds range in size from 10 acres or less to 50 or 60 acres.
Evaporation takes place only during the spring, summer, and fall. During the winter the concentrating ponds remain full, and at some plants the crystallizing ponds are left full also (Ver Planck Currently, the salt works encompasses six large evaporation ponds, 18 condensing ponds, and four crystallization ponds separated by earthen berms or levees. The Western Salt Company purchased and developed the four large ponds 12, 14, 15) closest to the bay in The outside levees are 40 feet wide at the base, 12 feet wide at the top and 3 feet high. To prevent leakage between the base of the levee and the old surface, the levee is keyed to solid material by coring. In coring a trench is dug through the grass and peat along the center line of the levee and filled with clean mud.
Cross levees, or levees that separate one pond from another, may be slightly lower and usually are not cored (Ver Planck Other features of the large exterior levee are the borrow pit alongside the exterior of the levee where clean mud is gathered for topping the levee and in some areas sheet metal pilings may be used to keep the levees from eroding (Ver Planck For the smaller ponds, wooden planking forms the walls of the ponds. b. Circulation: The system of water circulation is critical to the solar salt industry. Salt works require the flow of water: from intake, through the ponds, to the washer. Ponds are interconnected, moving bay water and brine through the ponds as the salinity is gradually increased.
Water control structures, gates, pumps, and pipes or siphons were all used to move water between the ponds. Controlling water flow was also important so that brine was not contaminated by fresh bay water. Bay water is taken in through automatic gates that open at high tide and close when the tide drops below the pond level. Where possible the gates are placed in north or northwesterly facing levees to take advantage of the prevailing wind. The intake at some points is by means of pumps (Ver Planck Concentrating bay water requires passing the brine slowly through a series of ponds, the flow is regulated by gates, pipes, and pumps, and the salinity level is checked often.
The stages of salt production include: 1) bay water reduced to a salinity level of Be and reduced the volume to nearly half of that taken in, suspended matter settles, carbonates precipitate begins; 2) evaporation continues until at Be, the brine is saturated with respect to salt; 3) by Be the brine is transferred to the pickle pond where it is reduced to about ten percent of the volume of bay water taken in (Ver Planck Crystallizing ponds are provided with an elaborate system of ditches and pumps for rapid filling and emptying Pickle flows from the supply ditch to the concentrating ponds, and from thence bittern ditches carry bittern away. Close control is required to prevent, as far as WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No.
CA-67 Page 9 possible, the precipitation of either gypsum or bittern salts in the crystallizing ponds (Ver Planck Brine ditches may be constructed with wood and have the appearance of a flume, except that it looks essentially level. Another conveyance structure is a brine bridge which carries brine across a canal (Ver Planck Pickle enters the crystallizing pond at Be, and bittern is withdrawn at 29 Be. An effort is made to keep the specific gravity within these limits by continuously drawing off a small amount of bittern. Two to five times during the season, however, it is necessary to empty the ponds and refill them with fresh pickle. As evaporation occurs, tiny seed crystals of salt form on the surface and are supported by surface tension.
As their weight increases, they sink deeper During the season 4 to 6 inches of salt forms, and about 70 percent of the salt in the pickle is extracted Bittern is withdrawn from the crystallizing ponds to bittern ponds where the specific gravity increases and it is sold to chemical companies (Ver Planck Principal features of the circulation system include the intake gates, pump stations, siphons, and pipes. Roads are located on top of the levees to access the water control structures. The Salt Works had its own narrow-gauge railway that also crossed the levees and transported salt during harvesting. Sea water enters the ponds at high tide through gates located at the northwest corner of the property. The mineral content of the sea water is approximately three and a half percent by weight.
Gravity and siphons transport the water through a series of condensation ponds. In these ponds, the seawater evaporates and becomes weak brine. The water travels from the condensation ponds to the crystallization ponds, and salt crystals form on the surface of the seawater when the mineral content reaches twenty-six percent. The crystals sink to the bottom of the ponds, creating a layer of pure salt. Employees removed the brine (or bittern) that remains at the top of the pond and sell it to be used in magnesium chloride recovery. Harvesting takes place during the late summer and fall. Gypsum and the remaining bittern are removed by washing, and the large outdoor piles are used for storage of the salt.
Due to the nature of the salt process, very little has changed in the layout of the ponds or levees since they were first constructed. In Pond 30 was converted from a pickling pond, which currently has a salt floor of both calcium sulfate and sodium chloride, to a crystallizer pond, a pond where sodium chloride can be harvested. The conversion of Pond 30 required modifying the surrounding earthen berm to protect the crystallizing salt from berm failure that would contaminate the commercial-grade salt. Levee boards were installed around the perimeter of Pond 30 using the natural contour of the levees to support the boards. Fill was placed on the outside of the levee boards to stabilize them. The levee boards consist of sawn lumber in. and 1x6 inch.
The vertical boards are supported by tieback boards, and backfilled to an elevation of 2 ft above the pond floor. This perimeter area and the taper of the existing levees was backfilled with dirt. WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No. CA-67 Page 0 c. Views and vistas: The spatial structure of the salt works is difficult to comprehend at ground level, because they are by definition flat and at sea level. There are no vistas points available for viewing the salt pond landscape. But the salt ponds are visually striking from the air with the ponds clearly divided, and the color of the water reflecting the increasing salinity from ponds of pink to magenta to white. d. Water: Only naturally occurring seawater is used in the salt pond landscape (see above discussion).
e. Buildings and structures: Seven buildings, related to the Western Salt Company s operation have been determined eligible and are located on a small lot on the east side of the ponds (see Overview Report). The salt processing equipment, washer, grinder, and storage pile were located close to the railway and road system. The Western Salt Company operation is compact with all of the salt production funneled to the east shoreline where crystallizing, processing, and shipping activities occur. f. Small scale elements: Tide gates, siphons, pipes, pumps, and water control structures are all considered small scale elements within the solar salt pond landscape.
Each of these elements has been altered over the years, for instance, the tide gates shifted to the outer ponds when new ponds were constructed. Controlling pond water is dynamic and changes with each expansion or contraction. g. Archaeological sites: All of the salt ponds created by Western Salt Company occurred during the twentieth century industrialization. No sites such as boat landings, salt processing plants, or residences were ever part of the salt pond development in South San Diego Bay. Native American sites unrelated to salt collection have been identified along the Otay River and bay-front shore line. h. Other: Elements of the landscape that are unusual or unique include the seasonally very large pile of salt adjacent to the processing plant.
After each salt harvest season, a large outdoor storage pile is located to the north of the main processing plant. The outer layer of the pile forms a crust that protects the salt from rain. The piles are largest during the winter months, after harvest, and diminish during the rest of the year. Although the pile is not a permanent feature of the Salt Works, it is an important element of the solar salt landscape. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Drawings, plans: Salt Works plan map. Salt Works plan map. WESTERN SALT COMPANY SALT WORKS (South Bay Salt Company) HALS No. CA-67 Page 1 B. Historic view, photographs: view C. Interviews: Gene Mullenix, D.