BlockBefore

Friendship Park, Park Road, Imperial Beach

Friendship Park, Park Road, Imperial Beach, San Diego County, CA. Surveyed as HALS CA-165, with a 3,593-word written history.

From the record

“Friendship Park is the only public park along the Mexico-US border envisioned as a binational friendship encounter area.”

Written record, HALS CA-165 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HALS program as HALS CA-165 · the record runs 3593 words · one of 194 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

102 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-165. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Park Road, Imperial Beach, San Diego County, California Located on the westernmost point of the international border between Mexico and the U.S. It is inside Border Field State Park within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Reserve. Directions: From San Diego, south on Interstate 5 about 15 miles to Dairy Mart Road; south on Dairy Mart Road about 1 mile to Monument Road; thence west on Monument Road about 4 miles to Border State Park; through Park Gate, turn left on Park Road about 1.5 miles to its termination at Monument No. (National Register of Historic Places, (Center of Monument No. Google Earth,

Significance

2938 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-165. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Friendship Park is the only public park along the Mexico-US border envisioned as a binational friendship encounter area. It serves as a meeting spot where people who are unable to see each other due to immigration status can interact on a limited basis. The physical form of the park throughout the years has changed, reflecting the state of immigration policies between the two nations. Description: Friendship Park is a quarter-acre section of Border Field State Park, a 2500-acre designated wildlife reserve. The park is located on a significant Kumeyaay cultural site. The park faces a collateral friendship park in the Playas de Tijuana neighborhood in Tijuana, Baja California, Mexico. The border fence divides this binational area in two as seen in figure 1. Part 1: U.S.

Side of Friendship Park This portion includes parking, public restrooms, a lawn area, and a restricted encounter zone. Parking is located on an unnamed road that branches off from Monument Road the main access road to Border Field State Park. There are roughly sixty- eight parking spaces, including four for ADA. Adjacent to the parking lot are public restrooms for men and women, as well as a single drinking fountain. To the west of the parking lot is a central lawn in an oval shape form which measures roughly half an acre. Notched out of this lawn is a semi-circle picnic area measuring 50 in radius. Three large triangular canopies anchored on metal columns provide ample shade for ten picnic tables, two grills, and two prep FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 2 tables.

Two concrete seat walls measuring thirty-five linear feet wrap around parts of the outer edge of the plaza. Opposite to this picnic area is another semi- circle landscape bed planted with native vegetation. Around the perimeter of this central lawn is a 10 wide concrete sidewalk in a semi rectangular shape. The areas between the oval lawn and the sidewalk are filled in with additional plant beds and decomposed granite pathways. Seven picnic benches are located in these decomposed granite areas as well as two more seat walls. One of the seat walls is forty linear feet long and the other twenty. Surrounding the entirety of the lawn area, sidewalks, and other paths is a stacked brick wall along the northern and western edges.

The western portion runs tight along the sidewalk while the northern wall goes further away from the central park. The restricted area is where the original Friendship Park plaza dedicated by Richard Nixon in is located. Access is available through a 10 wide concrete sidewalk which crosses a restricted access road patrolled by Customs and Border Protection agents. The 10 connecting sidewalk is located in the south-western corner of the central lawn area. It is blocked off by two jersey barriers connected by a metal chain. Signage denoting that access is restricted can be seen adjacent to the sidewalk. The restricted access area is enclosed by a metal fence with 15 tall pickets covered in metal screening in the bi-national interaction area. This fence follows grade all the way to sea level.

A pedestrian gate, connected to the park, is located in the center of the sidewalk. Ten feet to the left of this pedestrian gate is a 20 tall sliding vehicular access gate which is roughly sixty feet wide. Passing through the pedestrian gate is the original Friendship Park circular plaza and border Monument No. now located south of the primary wall. Originally constructed as monument No.1 in it was damaged by visitors chipping pieces of marble off and was repaired and renumbered in This structure is a large obelisk approximately 9 tall resting on a marble pedestal. The monument is not accessible from the U.S. as the international border wall curves around it leaving it accessible only from Mexico.

The original design of the park had divisive fencing running through the center of the plaza with the monument visible and accessible from both nations. Within the restricted area, visitors can look at the monument through a tight metal mesh which reinforces the international border wall in order to prevent the transfer of goods across borders. The international border wall also features a pedestrian gate connecting the United States and Mexico to enable access for U.S. Customs and Border Protection staff to maintain the historic monument now located on the south side of the border wall. This gate was also used as part of an annual event called FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO.

CA-165 PAGE 3 Opening the Door for Hope in which agents opened the gates for three minutes for people on both sides of the wall to meet face to face. Unfortunately, the program was shut down in The circular plaza, paved in concrete, is around 30 in radius. A tree which symbolizes the original one planted at the park s opening in by then first lady Pat Nixon is located east of the plaza. The original tree was lost at an unknown time and replaced in Further east is the binational native plant garden. The US portion, bordering the Mexican garden, was destroyed in January and was partially replanted in the same month. Maintenance is restricted by the U.S. Customs and Border Patrol The separated portions of the garden look to be one unit except for the fence that separates them.

Due to the high degree of surveillance, this significant area is off limits to visitors. Dividing the two nations is an 18 wall made up of rhomboid steel columns filled with concrete. The topmost portion of the wall has solid steel panels approximately 4 in height. On the U.S. side, the wall is reinforced with a metal wire screen, barely allowing visitors to touch fingertips through it. This reinforcement spans about 80 to the east and west from the center point of the original Friendship Park plaza. Part 2: Mexican Side of Friendship Park On the southern side of the border wall is Mexico s Parque de la Amistad (the Mexican portion of Friendship Park).

This area includes an international border monument marker, a lighthouse, a central monument plaza next to a dolphin plaza overlooking the Pacific Ocean, Imperial and Playas de Tijuana beaches. There are restrooms, and a picnic garden area. Across the street from this area is the famous bullring by the beach built in the second largest in Mexico. The Mexican side of the metal border fence that delimits the park is decorated with murals that are replaced periodically. The murals express freedom, unity, sisterhood/brotherhood, and US-Mexico international politics. The rhombus shaped columns allow visitors to view two different murals depending on where they are standing. Looking towards the east one can see a completely different mural than when looking to the west.

This amplifies the amount of available canvas resulting in a large collection of art on the wall. Parque de la Amistad is less fragmented and surveilled than the U.S. s Friendship Park. Monument No. 258 is located along the centerline of the official U.S.-Mexico border. The monument currently sits entirely within Mexico to ensure the continuity of the international border wall. The circular plaza acts as the focal point of Parque de la Amistad. The plaza is paved in concrete with a large sun motif radiating from the monument. The sun motif is differentiated by tinted concrete and flagstone. Ten concrete cubes FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 4 which can be used as seats, line the outer rim of the plaza.

The cubes are painted in shades of vibrant orange, purple, lime, magenta, blue, yellow, and lilac. These same colors can be seen throughout the site s furnishings, giving the site a freshness and liveliness that can be starkly contrasted with the highly regimented aesthetic of the U.S. Friendship Park. Following the path to the west of the monument, visitors can access an overlook platform. It is situated on the roof of the public restrooms and is a large oval roughly 40 by 30 . The platform overlooks another oval plaza surrounding a large statue of dolphins emerging from the ocean. On either side of the statue are five Washingtonia robusta palm trees. Each situated within a square plant bed that is slightly raised above the plaza s elevation.

The planters are made up of concrete embedded with river rock that create grade transition. Additionally, the plant bed has an 8 concrete curb painted to match the rest of the site. A 5 tall TIJUANA sign with concrete letters in front of the restrooms facing south enhances the area and is used for photo memories. Tijuana s motto Aqu empieza la patria is written beneath the large letters. The pavement treatment of the Dolphin Plaza is a series of concentric ovals. The central oval is red tinted concrete followed by a grey stamped concrete and then again, the red tinted concrete. The outer edge of the plaza is a stacked stone-wall with a tubular steel guardrail attached to the top. At the western apex of the oval is a large fiberglass heart sculpture measuring roughly 5 tall by 6 wide.

More fiberglass hearts can be found throughout the park and along the pier of the Playas de Tijuana neighborhood. The hearts were donated by the Mexican charity Fundaci n Telet n in Each sculpture was painted by local artists who were allowed to explore themes at their will. East of the monument plaza is a lawn area with concrete picnic tables painted in the same saturated colors from the other painted elements within the park. Five simple concrete tables with benches are scattered on the lawn along with more fiberglass hearts. Colorful bollards line the outer edge of the lawn protecting visitors from traffic driving along the adjacent road. Metal barrels painted black act as trash cans for the site.

Further east is another portion of the binational garden with five Washingtonia robusta palm trees planted alongside the international border wall. Between each palm is a series of plant beds lined colorfully painted tires half buried in the ground. More picnic tables are located on concrete pads adjacent to the gardens. The design of the binational garden has changed a lot throughout the years. It was first planted in as a small rectangular plot roughly 9 by 3 wide in the U.S. park and a larger 3 by 40 wide in the Mexican park. The garden has been primarily affected in the U.S. side as border control and visibility are a top priority for The Mexican side of the garden has not been impacted in the FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 5 same way due to the lack of access restrictions.

The original friendship tree, planted by Pat Nixon on the Mexican park, was destroyed by the ravages of time and lack of maintenance. A replacement tree exists in approximately the same location as originally planted, within the regulated enforcement area. Part 3: Timeline of Impacts The following is a timeline of the impacts that have occurred to the binational garden on the U.S. side of the wall in modern history. A flagpole, granite base, and plaque to commemorate the historic monument being placed on the National Historic Register were installed in a location now within the double fence on September 27, This matches a commemorative flagpole, granite base and plaque on the Mexico side of the international plaza.

On the United States side the flagpole was removed at an unknown point prior to The plaque was removed from granite base sometime between September and May The granite base and iron fence surrounding the circle were removed in The commemorative flagpole, granite base and plaque remain on the Mexico side of the bi-national plaza. In the U.S. side of the bi-national garden and park adjacent to the international boundary was uprooted in order to make way for the construction of the secondary metal picket fence located roughly 100 to the north of the international border fence. This secondary fence was built to secure the area adjacent to the international border wall and restrict access.

Heavy site work can be observed through aerial images from February After construction finished, access to the binational garden and the international plaza became restricted and heavily monitored. The historic Monument No. 258 was relegated to the southern side of the primary border fence at this time. In the bi-national garden was replanted and expanded by a group of volunteers. The design of the garden changed drastically from a small rectangular plot to a series of three circular beds, which were split along the middle by the international border wall. Each circle had a theme: the first was a mirror garden in which the same plants were planted on both halves of the circle. The second was a toyon (Heteromeles arbutifolia) and yellow flower garden. The third was a cactus rock garden.

The rocks in this final circle had wishes written upon them and used as top dressing. Additionally, a strip of white sage (Salvia apiana) was planted in a zig-zag pattern along the entire length of the garden. Unfortunately, the sage was poached frequently and did not survive. In August a new tree was planted in the spot where Pat Nixon had planted the first tree at Friendship Park in Additional site furnishings were installed including an eco-bench made with cement and old bottles, signage FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 6 describing the garden and giving information on plantings, as well as bollards leading visitors to the binational garden. In the binational garden was once again damaged to make way for improvements to the international border wall.

Prior to the fencing along Friendship Park consisted of an open metal fence, similar to chain link. The improvements converted this into the 18 wall made of rhomboid steel columns filled with cement existing at the time of this report. The site furnishings installed earlier were all removed and have not been replaced since. After the garden remained somewhat stable until January of when CBP demolished it once again in order to tighten control on the transfer of goods across the wall. According to CBP Chief Douglas E. Harrison Traffickers cut the legacy border mesh and were using the binational garden to cover illegal activities. I know they Agents] had to take measures to eliminate the vulnerability.

I contacted Friends of Friendship Park and will meet with them to discuss the next steps (Gomez and Bravo, After meetings with the grass-roots coalition, Friends of Friendship Park, the garden was once again replanted in January with modifications. A 4 wide clear zone between garden plants and the fence had to be created in order for CBP officers to maintain clear visibility of the fence. This configuration is what is present at the time this majority of this report was written, in early CBP currently restricts maintenance of this garden. History: Monument No.1 installed by US-Mexico Boundary Commission. Monument is refurbished and renamed Monument 258 by the International Boundary Commission.

August 18, First lady Pat Nixon visits the site of the monument and dedicates Border Field State Park, within which Friendship Park is located. During her visit parts of the fence were cut, creating a welcoming landscape where people from both countries can meet. February 24, Reports of the barbed wire fence being cut around the monument are published in the San Diego Union-Tribune. Burkholder, local representative of the International Boundary and Water Commission took down the fence a week ago on orders from Commissioner Joseph Friedkin. The order was issued after Friedkin was visited...by a delegation from the Chula Vista Chamber of Commerce. The removal was celebrated by the delegation and met with concern by border patrol and customs agents.

New chain link fence is installed once again dividing both nations. FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 7 Two-thirds of Border Field State Park is designated as a wildlife reserve. This further obfuscated access to Friendship Park for United States citizens. May 11, The Real ID Act is signed into law by President George W. Bush. This act allows waivers for any and all laws, particularly environmental impact laws, in order to ensure the quick construction of roads and barriers. This significantly impacted the landscape along the Mexico-US border by allowing construction to occur without following necessary environmental protection policies. The binational garden is planted.

June 24, Supreme Court refuses to hear a case from The Sierra Club regarding the Real ID Act waivers with regard to the border wall construction. This dismissal allows for the construction of a taller, more secure fence between the countries and an additional fence to the north separating Friendship Park from the rest of the country. Prior to this addition the park had functioned as a meeting space for individuals from both countries to interact. The modifications from onward further reduces the permeability of the international fence and as a result uses on the site becomes more limited and monitored.

Binational garden is destroyed to make way for construction of restricted access roads running parallel along the border wall and an additional metal picket fence restricting access to the border wall. Binational garden is redesigned and replanted. Improvements to the international border wall cause impacts to the U.S. side of the binational garden and the historic monument is relegated to the south side of the wall. January the binational garden is demolished by CBP officers due to the obstruction the plants created along the border wall. Garden is replanted with a 4 clear zone that same month. - The CBP announces plans to construct the double 30-tall fence through the park to the coast.

Sources

180 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-165. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Associated Press. Border Patrol Allows Replanting after 'Unintentional Destruction' of Friendship Park. FOX 5 San Diego, FOX 5 San Diego, 26 Jan. FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 8 Bravo, Christina. CBP Closes 'Door of Hope' on Cross-Border Reunification Event. NBC 7 San Diego, NBC San Diego, 7 Jan. reunification-event/164460/. Cort s, Norma. Corazones En El Malec n De Playas De Tijuana. San Diego Union-Tribune En Espa ol, San Diego Union-Tribune, 26 Mar. Dunbar, Vivian Marlene. Friendship Park Celebrates Anniversary. La Prensa San Diego, La Prensa San Diego, 26 Aug. laprensa- Gomez, Ann and Bravo, Christine. Crews Bulldoze Friendship Park Garden at US-Mexico Border. NBC 7 San Diego, NBC San Diego, 10 Jan. mexico-border/2242427/. Holsiln, Jill M.

Friends of Friendship Park: Conflict and Consensus in the Making of a Place. The Politics of Hope, Landis, Paige E., "A History of Friendship Park" University Honors Thesis Paper National Register of Historic Places, Initial Point of Boundary Between U.S. and Mexico, San Diego, San Diego, CA, Scaglione, Cecil." Patrol Aides Object, U.S. Border Open By Fence Removal." San Diego Union. February 24,

Written history

316 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-165. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Valerie Verduzco for ASLA San Diego Edited by Amy Hoffman, ASLA and Michelle Landis, ASLA August FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 9 Aerial view of Friendship Park with annotations. (Verduzco, December FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 10 Monument No. 258 in March of The international border line is denoted by this barbed wire fence. Note how the fence runs to the middle of the monument as opposed to present day when it goes around it. (National Park Service, March FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 11 Monument No. 258 as seen from the Mexican side of the border (Michelle Landis, October FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 12 Typical look at the international border wall on the Mexican side. A typical painted concrete bench can be seen here as well as throughout the site.

Note how artists use the angled posts on the wall as two different canvases. (Verduzco, December FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 13 Heteromeles arbutifolia growing in front of the international border wall. In the distance, U.S. surveillance tower can be seen peering up above the wall. (Verduzco, December FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 14 Colorful repurposed tires outline the circles of the Binational Garden. Aloe sp. growing alongside the walkway. In the distance a large Heteromeles (Verduzco, December Picnic area on the Mexican side of the park. In the distance a fiberglass heart sculpture can be seen. (Verduzco, December FRIENDSHIP PARK HALS NO. CA-165 PAGE 15 The Playas de Tijuana lighthouse casting a shadow on Monument No.

Note the tall surveillance tower behind the wall in the U.S.. Additionally, the LOVE heart mural on the left corner is a gate in the international border wall. This was utilized as part of the CBP program Opening the Doors of Hope until when the program was discontinued. (Verduzco, December View of the overlook platform and the dolphin plaza. (Verduzco, December

In context

Imperial Beach, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Diego County, California 602 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Imperial Beach

1 record

The federal surveyors worked through Imperial Beach building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Western Salt Company Salt WorksHALS CA-6710,130 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HALS CA-165. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.