The chain of twenty-one missions built in California between and represents some of California s earliest European habitation. Mission construction began while California was still controlled by Spain long before Mexico gained control in or the United States took possession in As each mission was dedicated it formed the core of a new community, many of which grew into major California cities including San Diego, San Luis Obispo, San Francisco, Santa Barbara, Santa Cruz, and San Rafael. Mission San Francisco de Asis was established in when Juan Bautista de Anza led a group of people from Tubac, Mexico for the purpose of establishing a permanent settlement in San Francisco.
The first mass, which dedicated the mission site, was celebrated on 29 June The mission was moved from its original site, about feet to the east, to its current site in and developed as the center of the mission community that included the present-day Mission Dolores adobe church, housing, workshops and storerooms, gardens and orchards, and a cemetery. Mission Dolores, the adobe church completed in and its adjacent cemetery, which had its first burial in are significant for their associations with the Spanish era mission landscape and with San Francisco's eighteenth century origins.
Description: Mission Dolores and the mission cemetery are the only remaining portions of the Spanish era mission landscape remaining on a block of land owned by the Roman Catholic Church, under the auspices of the Archdioceses of San Francisco. This block, bounded by Dolores Street (east side), Street (north side), Church Street (west side), and Chula Lane (south side), generally corresponds to the block of land south of Dolores Street that was granted to Mission Dolores in as part of the U.S. Land Commission settlement (less the area that was given to the adjacent streets and their sidewalks that were laid out in the latter part of the nineteenth century and the early part of the twentieth century).
Other features on this block include the Mission Dolores Basilica located just north of Mission Dolores, a row of buildings along the north side of the block that house the Mission Dolores Parish's rectory and offices and the facilities of the Mission Dolores Academy, and a building in the southwest corner of the block occupied by the Children's Council of San Francisco. Asphalt MISSION SAN FRANCISCO DE ASIS HALS NO. CA-83 PAGE 2 paving, used as a parking lot and a playground for the school, covers the remaining open space on the block.
Mission Dolores and the cemetery are located in the southeast corner of the block on a .42-acre parcel (San Francisco Assessor Parcel Number Mission Dolores, which measures x (interior dimensions), is oriented lengthwise east/west on the northern portion of this parcel. A small, modern, restroom building (approximately 11' x 22' ) is located about 22' west of the church's west end. A modern, walled courtyard (approximately 22' x 26' ) encloses the space between these two buildings. The cemetery, located south of the church, occupies the rest of the open space on the .42-acre parcel. The south sides of Mission Dolores, the courtyard, and the restroom building form the north boundary of the cemetery.
The cemetery is enclosed on the other three sides by walls of various heights and chain link fencing, all of which were added at some point in the twentieth century. The concrete wall across the east end fronts onto Dolores Street and is the most decorative; it is constructed of concrete, finished with cement plaster to resemble adobe, and has a row or cap of clay roof tiles; a chain link fence which extends above this wall is attached to poles which are mounted in the ground on the inner side of this wall. A chain link fence which sits on top of a low, concrete, retaining wall spans the south side (Chula Lane).
The west end of the cemetery is enclosed by a wall constructed of hollow, clay tile, finished with cement plaster to resemble adobe, and has a row or cap of clay roof tiles; a chain link fence which extends above the wall is attached to poles which are mounted in the ground on the ouuter side extends of this wall. Public admission to the church and cemetery are through the front door of the Mission Dolores gift shop, a small addition (approximately 16' x 20' ) attached to the east end of the church's south side. From the gift shop, visitors enter the east end of the church and exit via a door on its north side.
This door leads to a narrow outdoor passageway between Mission Dolores and the Mission Dolores Basilica where interpretive displays, with a diorama that depicts the mission's appearance in the and historical photographs, are located. This passageway provides access to the walled courtyard at the west end of the church, which in turn provides access to a museum located in a former classroom at the west end the Mission Dolores building, to the restroom building that forms the west side of the courtyard, to the basilica on its north side, and to the cemetery through a wrought iron gate on its south side.
(Gates at the east and west ends of the cemetery that lead to Dolores Street and the Mission Dolores Academy playground [formerly part of the cemetery], respectively, are not open to the public.) Upon entering the cemetery from this gate, the visitor encounters a three-panel sign that provides a site plan that shows the layout of the paths, locations of headstones, and schematic arrangement of vegetation within the cemetery. The sign also has an alphabetized list of people buried in the cemetery MISSION SAN FRANCISCO DE ASIS HALS NO. CA-83 PAGE 3 and a list of plants, both of which are keyed to this plan. The plan and lists were prepared by the Stephen Marcus Landscape Company during a mid-1990s renovation of the cemetery's landscape.
The cemetery is divided into an irregular grid by the layout of the concrete sidewalks that are generally 2' to 3' wide. These paths have varying widths, scoring patterns, and finishes and were added to the cemetery at different times and without an overall plan. (A review of historical photographs including aerial photographs taken in and show similar but different layouts to the present-day path system.) Within this grid approximately 200 stone headstones and burial monuments are arranged into rows. These markers date from to the last burial in and are of varying styles including tablets, flat markers, obelisks, and box tombs some of which are surrounded by wrought iron fencing.
Although the first burial in the cemetery occurred in the wooden crosses that would have marked the earliest graves deteriorated and disappeared long ago. The approximately unmarked Native Americans graves were in the part of the cemetery that is no longer extant (the area located to the west that is now under pavement or buildings.) A stone monument depicting. "Kateri Tekawitha Our Lady of the Mohawks" (the first Native American who was beatified), located in the southwest portion of the cemetery, is dedicated to the Native Americans who were buried in the cemetery. A wooden headstone was added in to honor two Ohlone neophytes, JOCBOCME and his wife POLYLEMJA who were buried in unmarked graves in and respectively.
This headstone is located in the southeast portion of the cemetery just east of a traditional Ohlone tule reed house, also added in as part of the commemoration of the role of Native Californians in the construction and operation of the mission. Like the paths, the vegetation within the cemetery has been added at different times during the twentieth century. Two key organizational features include the remains of three rows of mature English yews (Taxus baccata) specimens within each row are missing planted in the late or the early and a rose garden in the center of the cemetery that provides a setting for "The Padre", a 6'-6"-tall, cast stone sculpture by Arthur Putnam of Father Junipero Serra.
In addition to the yews, there are mature evergreen at three of its four corners (Pinus radiata in the southeast corner, Cedrus deodora in the southwest corner, and P. muricata in the northwest corner; the gift shop occupies the northeast corner), a row of four Lombardy poplars (Populus nigra 'Italica') along its south edge, a tree-sized Chinese juniper (Juniperus chinensis) and an Italian cypress (Cupressus sempervirens) in the southwest portion, and a redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) located in the central portion to the east of the rose garden.
There are a variety of smaller trees which appear to have been planted where there was available space along the south edge and east and west ends of the cemetery (rather than in reference to a specific plan); a partial list includes Japanese maple (Acer palmatum), Western redbud (Cercis occidentalis), Mission fig (Ficus MISSION SAN FRANCISCO DE ASIS HALS NO. CA-83 PAGE 4 carica), Southern magnolia (Magnolia grandiflora), saucer magnolia (Magnolia x soulangeana), Canary Island palm (Phoenix canariensis), and olives (Olea europa).
There is a similar wide variety of shrubs, perennials, groundcovers, and vines; including species typically found in San Francisco gardens (such as Acanthus mollis, Agapanthus africanus, Aloe arborescens, Bougainvillea Camillia japonica, , Ceratostigma plumbaginoides, Echium fastuosum, Fragaria chiloensis, Hedera helix, Jasminum polyanthum, Lantana Pittosporum crassifolium, Passiflower alatocaerulea, Rosa Strelitzia reginae, and Vinca minor) and a number of native California species, some of which have cultural significance to the Ohlone, which were added during the mid-1990s renovation efforts (for example, Arctostaphylos edmundsii 'Carmel Sur', Carpenteria californica, Ceanothus Eschscholzia californica, Gaultheria shallon, Heuchera micrantha, Iris douglasiana, Oxalis oregano, and Sisyrinchium bellum).
Based on a review of historical photographs from the second half of the nineteen century and first half of the twentieth century, the cemetery has had a changing variety of vegetation (trees, shrubs, vines, perennials, etc.) over the years, and with exception of the large trees much of the vegetation that exists within the cemetery today appears to have been added within the past several decades. The cemetery's plantings have the romantic appearance associated with Mission Revival gardening and are reflective of twentieth century gardening tastes rather than being a documentation of the appearance of the cemetery during the Spanish colonial era.
History: The Spanish established a chain of twenty Franciscan missions, four military presidios, and three civilian settlements or pueblos along the coastal region of California in the late eighteenth century as they expanded their empire northward from Mexico and Baja California into Alta (upper) California. The missions, as part of the Spanish colonization system used throughout the New World, were seen as the instrument to integrate indigenous people into the greater Spanish Empire. They were to be largely self-sufficient, with crops grown at the mission intended to provide food for the mission, the presidio (guarding the mission), and the civic settlement or pueblo (as these were established).
The Mission San Francisco de Asis along with El Presidio de San Francisco, which housed the Spanish garrison and supported its administrative and training operations, and the Castillo de San Joaquin, which guarded the entry into San Francisco Bay, were established in when Juan Bautista de Anza led 240 people from Tubac, Mexico for the purpose of establishing a permanent settlement. The mission, named for the founder and patron saint of the Franciscan Order, was established in the interior portion of the peninsula, a few miles southeast of the presidio, in a protected basin surrounded by hills (including Diamond Heights and Twin Peaks to the southwest, Bernal Heights to the south, and Potrero Hill to the southeast) that afforded protection from ocean winds and fog.
The site also was adjacent to ample fresh water supplies MISSION SAN FRANCISCO DE ASIS HALS NO. CA-83 PAGE 5 including a creek, named the Arroyo de los Dolores because it was discovered on Viernes de Dolores (Friday of the Sorrows, which is the name given to the Friday before Palm Sunday), and a lake, the Laguna de Nuestra Senora de los Dolores (Lake of Our Lady of Sorrows). (Subsequently, the mission became known locally as Mission Dolores.) The size of the lake varied with seasonal rainfall, but it roughly extended between the present-day Street, South Van Ness Avenue, Street, and Guerrero Street, and was fed by the Arroyo de los Dolores (Dolores Creek), which originated on Twin Peaks and flowed along the alignment for today s Street (Carey & Co. Inc.
The first mission settlement, most likely located at present-day and Mission streets, stood about 400 varas or feet to the east of the present-day Mission Dolores site. This original site included a temporary chapel and living quarters and was surrounded by a stockade for protection. A nearby cemetery, a corral for cattle, and an aqueduct were also constructed. Then in the mission quadrangle was moved to the area of the present day intersection of and Dolores streets. Construction on a permanent chapel was started in and the building was dedicated on 2 April The chapel, constructed of over sundried adobe bricks made by the local Indians, had 4'-thick walls on the south, west, and north sides, a 10'-thick wall on the east end, and measured x 22' .
By the time the chapel was complete, it stood at the heart of a growing mission settlement (Carey & Co. The report of a Works Progress Administration era study of the mission identified forty-seven buildings and structures, including barracks, granaries, a soap factory, grain mills, workhouses for looms and adobe brick production, a smithy, a carpenter shop, storerooms, tanneries, a mission prison, a school, a bathhouse, and a neophyte rancheria, described as consisting of about 100 cabins by (Hendry and Bowman: cited in Carey & Co. Although the exact extent of the mission complex is not known, it appears to have extended from about present-day Guerrero Street to Church Street and from Street to Street (i.e., to the banks of Dolores Creek).
Corrals, orchards, gardens, and a cemetery were also established nearby. The mission's fields and gardens were mainly to the east, the cemetery was next to the chapel, and the orchard stood to its west, separated from the complex by the El Camino Real that linked the mission with the presidio and settlements to the south (Carey & Co. Brother Guire Cleary in his history of the mission noted that in at its most prosperous period, Mission Dolores "owned sheep, cows, and thousands of horses, goats, pigs, and mules. Its ranching and farming operations extended as far south as San Mateo and east to Alameda. Horses were corralled on Potrero Hill, and the milking sheds for the cows were located along Dolores Creek at what is today Mission High School.
Twenty looms were kept in operation to process wool into cloth. The circumference of its holdings was said to have been about 125 miles" (Cleary MISSION SAN FRANCISCO DE ASIS HALS NO. CA-83 PAGE 6 Following this initial successful period of settlement and the conversion of the local Ohlone population, Mission Dolores stagnated and then declined for a number of reasons including neophyte deaths and desertions, competition from Mission San Rafael Arcangel (in present-day Marin County), and the decline in external support that followed the Mexican Revolution of By the late the complex had fallen into ruin, and the Mission Dolores was one of the poorest missions along the entire California coast (Carey & Co.
In the Mexican government secularized the missions and began distributing large portions of their holdings in land grants known as ranchos which shifted power in colonial California from the church to secular governors and powerful ranching families (Paddison With the loss of their vast land holdings and the demise of their agricultural, ranching and manufacturing enterprises, the missions essentially became parish churches "consisting of only the church proper, the residence of the priests and a small amount of land immediately surrounding the churches for use as kitchen gardens and cemeteries" (Cleary During the Mexican period, this process occurred at Mission Dolores as its lands were subdivided into a number of large land grants with additional subdivision occurring following the Gold Rush and after California became a part of the United States in The Board of U.S.
Land Commissioners was created by the Act of to rule on the validity of the Spanish and Mexican land grants and to determine which lands were available for U.S. citizens who were flooding into the state. Archbishop Joseph Alemany, acting on behalf of the Roman Catholic Church, filed twenty-one petitions to the board for confirmation of the California missions on 19 February The petition for Mission Dolores was finalized on 3 March This 8.54-acre grant included land on both sides of the present-day Dolores Street at its intersection with Street.
The archbishop donated the portion of the grant on the east side of the street, which included gardens and various small buildings, to the Order of Notre Dame de Namur who established a school for girls, the Notre Dame Academy, there in The four- acre parcel on the west side of the street remained under the control of the Roman Catholic Church and, based on hand drawn block maps from this period, included the former mission's quadrangle of buildings (the mission's adobe chapel [Mission Dolores], the rectory, stables, and storerooms), a walled garden west of the quadrangle, and the cemetery (Black Perez Cleary Following the discovery of gold in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada mountain range in San Francisco grew from a settlement with fewer than people at the beginning of to a booming city of by the end of that year, and the rural landscape around the former mission quickly began to develop into an urban neighborhood.
The area surrounding Mission Dolores was platted into large city blocks in the and street grading began in the (Carey & Co. The mission's chapel, now known locally as Mission MISSION SAN FRANCISCO DE ASIS HALS NO. CA-83 PAGE 7 Dolores, remained intact, but the mission era buildings, gardens, and portions of the cemetery were removed as new facilities were built to serve the neighborhood's growing population.
In honor of San Francisco's centennial, a large brick Gothic Revival building was constructed to the north of Mission Dolores to serve as the parish church; this building was dedicated on 4 July However, it was so badly damaged in the earthquake that it had to be torn down, and in its place a new reinforced concrete church was begun in and completed in In Pope Pius XII raised the church to the honor of a Minor Basilica, and the church is known today as the Mission Dolores Basilica.
Although the cemetery continued to extend throughout the L-shaped area along the south side and west end of the block, the area along had been filled with a rectory and school by (A portion of the cemetery along Street was removed in when the street was extended from Dolores Street to Church Street.) Over the next several decades the size of the cemetery was incrementally reduced as new buildings were added (in and and portions of the former cemetery were paved over to be used as a playground and a parking lot. Additionally, a portion of the east end of the cemetery was removed in as the result of grading for Dolores Street and its sidewalk. These changes necessitated the consolidation and removal of remains.
Although up to people, including approximately Indians neophytes, were originally interred in the larger cemetery, today there are only about 200 headstones in the remaining portion of the cemetery. Some of these burials were consolidated in a mass grave on site and some were relocated to various cemeteries throughout the Bay area (Cleary A restoration of Mission Dolores was undertaken in by noted San Francisco architect Willis Polk who strove for architectural authenticity and vowed to preserve the time-worn beauties of the building without introducing the garish note of modern imitation (San Francisco Chronicle As described in the historic context for the Revised Mission Dolores Neighborhood Survey, prepared by Carey & Co. Inc. in "[a]fter meticulously photographing the roof . . .
Polk s design called for the roof to be removed, a steel framework to be put in place, then the original rafters and their buckskin thongs to be returned. Original tiles were used whenever possible, with new ones tinted to match the old. Similarly, [the] patchwork of the adobe walls was designed to match the existing building" (Carey & Col This restoration effort was part of "a larger movement to capitalize on regional nostalgia for Spanish colonial days and Californians growing love of the automobile and tourism" (Carey & Co. This combination of historic preservation interest and tourism promotion led the efforts to restore the extant missions and to "recreate" the garden areas around the missions.
To facilitate auto tourism between these newly restored sights, the new "king s road" was planned to roughly follow the original trail of the Franciscans who founded missions along the California coast during the eighteenth century. "Harriet Forbes in Southern California gathered the support of many women s clubs and MISSION SAN FRANCISCO DE ASIS HALS NO. CA-83 PAGE 8 convinced a group of men to invest in recreating and paving El Camino Real from San Diego to Sonoma" (Carey & Co. Road work on the El Camino Real began in and Forbes designed the mission-bell guidepost in to demarcate the new highway.
Dolores Street, running in front of (east) Mission Dolores was designated as part of the El Camino Real, and one of the mission bell guideposts, designed by Forbes, is located in its median almost directly in front of the church's front doors. Mission San Francisco de Asis (Mission Dolores) was documented around by the Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS CAL 38 SANFRA 1 [HABS No. CA-113]), was designated as San Francisco City Landmark No. 1 in and was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in Other historical designations associated the mission include California Historical Landmark No. 327 for the site of the non-extant original mission church and Dolores Lagoon and California Historical Landmark No.
784 for the El Camino Real, the original trail of the Franciscans who founded the missions along the California coast during the eighteenth century. One of the mission bell guideposts, designed by Harriet Forbes in to demarcate the California highway route that roughly follows the El Camino Real's original route, is located in the Dolores Street median, just east of the entrance to Mission Dolores.