Report prepared by Christina Chiang, M.A., Associate Architectural Historian, and Wendy L. Tinsley Becker, AICP, Principal of Urbana Preservation & Planning, Existing conditions photographs by David G. De Vries of Mesa Technical. Project sponsored by Southern California Edison Company. BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO.
CA- O Page 3 INTRODUCTION As part of an effort to manage historic properties within its service territory, SCE has sponsored the preparation of this report to comprehensively document the Vincent Transmission Line which was formally determined eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places as a contributing element to the Big Creek Hydroelectric System Historic District and as an individual electric power conveyance system that historically served as one of the backbone transmission lines within the SCE service territory. This HAER package is regarded as a treatment for future projects or undertakings that may result in an effect or adverse effect to all or portions of the Vincent Transmission Line.
Photographic documentation includes representative views of original tower type, identified modifications, to the line, spatial relationship to connecting substation complexes, and landscape / setting changes as the line spans from mountain and forest, over rivers and streams, through agricultural fields and open valleys, and into high desert. The written narrative includes a contextual history of SCE, a physical history of the Vincent Transmission Line, including its original construction campaign and subsequent modifications, and a description of the engineering features of the line.
The field records portion of the report includes engineering data sheets documenting the individual tower data for the line as well as topographic maps delineating the line during the historic period and today. BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 4
Date of Construction: December through January Engineer: Southern California Edison, Department of Engineering Design. Builder: Southern California Edison, Newport News Ship Building and Dry Dock Company (tower fabrication), and Pacific Coast Steel Company (tower fabrication). Constructed between December and January under SCE General Order No. the Vincent Transmission Line was the third transmission line installed to convey electricity from the Big Creek Hydroelectric System in unincorporated Fresno County to Southern California s Los Angeles region. Upon completion of construction, the line spanned between Big Creek Powerhouse No.
3 (a pre- existing facility built in and the Gould Substation in La Ca ada Flintridge (constructed in as the southern terminus of the line) via the Magunden Switching Station in Bakersfield (a pre- existing facility built in Construction was formally authorized in early when the Federal Power Commission amended the license for Federal Project No. 120 to include a Transmission Line designated as the Vincent Transmission Line extending from Big Creek Power House No. 3, about 224 miles to and including a switching station 1 designated as Crescenta Switching Station in the vicinity of Los Angeles, Calif. The Vincent Transmission Line was constructed in a separate right- of- way sited generally parallel to, but east of, the Big Creek No. 1 and No.
2 Transmission Lines installed in at a capacity of and 2 upgraded in to a capacity of The line was installed to accommodate the voltage capacity upgrade at Big Creek from to The line s towers were originally numbered consecutively by mile in ascending order from the Gould Substation at south to Big Creek at north. SCE initiated roadwork in advance of the transmission line in August with the construction of a road through the San Gabriel Mountains. The first 15 miles of the line spanning the San Gabriel Mountains did not run parallel to the other Big Creek lines and was the most inaccessible section, needing more than two miles of road constructed for 3 every mile of the line. When the St. Francis Dam failure washed out the Big Creek No. 1 and No.
2 lines on March 12, the Vincent Transmission Line was able to keep electricity flowing to Southern 4 California, because it was on a separate right- of- way. Work camps were established along the construction route and indicate the order of roadwork from south to north. An incline railway was built in October in the Arroyo Seco near Camp Oakwild for transporting camp and road construction materials to advance locations. By this means, the roadwork was pushed 5 forward rapidly at several points. A list of work camps is included as Table 1 on the following page. 1 United States Federal Power Commission, Sixth Annual Report (Washington, Government Printing Office, 2 The Big Creek No. 1 and No.
2 Transmission Lines, historically referred to as the big Creek East and West Transmission Line, are recorded as HAER No. CA-167-N. 3 Carlson and H. Michener, The Vincent Transmission Line: Engineering and Construction Features, Transactions of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers, Volume issue 12 (December Presented at the Pacific Coast Convention of the AIEE (Salt Lake City, Utah), September 4 William A. Myers, Iron Men and Copper Wires: A Centennial History of the Southern California Edison Company (Glendale: Trans-Anglo Books, 5 Southern California Edison Company and Steal, Southern California Edison Company Unit Cost Report Vincent Transmission Line as of March 31, Part of Federal Project No. 120 (Southern California Edison Company Accounting Department, June 3.
BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 5 6 Table 1. Construction Camps established for the Vincent Transmission Line. Location / Date Date Camp # Notes Vicinity Opened Closed Served as headquarters until 1 Crescenta when HQ moved to Camp #6.
2 Aliso 3 Firebreak 4 Telephone Portable Portable 5 Yucca Served as headquarters until 6 Antelope when HQ moved to Camp 7 38OC Saddle 8 Clear Creek 8 Tejunga Open December 9 North Fork 10 Red Mountain 11 Tejon 11 Tejon For road work and brush burning Served as headquarters until 12 Magunden when HQ moved to Camp July Rush July Rush 14 Poso Creek Work Work July Rush July Rush 15 Rag Gulch Work Work Reopoened 15 Rag Gulch 16 Arvin Served as headquarters until 17 Fountain Springs when HQ moved to Camp Served as headquarters until 18 El Mirador when HQ moved to Camp 19 Yokohl 20 Lemon Cove Dec-27 21 Cottonwood Dec-27 22 Squaw Valley Jun-27 23 Watts Valley Jul-27 24 Cressmans Aug-27 Feb-28 6 Southern California Edison Company and Steal, BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO.
CA- O Page 6 The line was constructed in four distinct sections: 24 miles between Mile 99 Tower 1 T1) and Mile 123 Tower 1 T1) completed on July 30, 95 miles between Gould and Magunden Substations completed on November 14, 100 miles between Magunden Substation between T3 completed on December 7, and 7 4.5 miles between T3 and Powerhouse No. 3. The 24- mile section completed in July was rushed through in 24 days to meet a emergency 8 operating condition in the San Joaquin Valley. The 96- mile southern portion of the line between Magunden and Gould Substations was constructed and in operation by the end of The Vincent Transmission Line 9 was extended north to Big Creek Powerhouse No.
3 in and placed into service in January Inclusive of all engineering adjustments to the line after its initial in- service dates, final completion of the 10 Vincent Transmission Line was reported as October 1, Following is an historical summary of the construction effort as communicated by SCE in a March 31, Unit Cost Report. Construction Methods: The field organization consisted of an average of 500 to 600 men with approximately two- thirds in transmission and one- third on road work. The transmission line work was divided into sections of about 20 miles long, each with 150 to 200 men under the supervisions of a Camp Foreman. The field organization at headquarters camp handled most of the timekeeping, payrolls and unit cost reports.
Special branches of the work, such as transportation, materials, messhalls, timekeeping and accounting were in charge of department heads specializing on each branch. Road Construction: The roughest and most impassable part of the route was over the San Gabriel mountains in the first 19 miles section of the line and it was necessary to construct approximately 38 miles of continuous mountain road, 9 ft. wide with prevailing maximum grades of 10% and short pitch grades of 12 to About cubic yards of earth were removed for this road. This difficult road construction was more economical however than would be the right- of- way expense for a route paralleling the old Big Creek lines. In building this road a foot trail was first established and widened to a 5 ft.
tractor trail by manual labor and use of compressors, jackhammers and blasting powder. This was then widened to a 9 ft. road by means of 30 tractors, road plows and 8 ft. leaning wheel type graders. Transportation of Materials: The major materials were shipped to the nearest railroad points, then sorted and hauled 10 to 30 miles on 2 ton pneumatic tired trucks equipped with duplex rear tires and chain drive. 30 tractors were used to help the trucks over steep grades. It was necessary at some points to transfer the loads to stone boats or trailers and carry to location by means of tractors or lines from 5 ton winch trucks. The 2 ton cable reels were delivered in some 7 Southern California Edison Company and Steal, 4. 8 Ibid. 9 R.A. Davis, D.A. Denholm, and A.G.
Denyer, Southern California Edison Company History, (Unpublished Chronology of the SCE 150 & systems), Updated 10 Southern California Edison Company and Steal, 4. BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 7 cases on reel dollies attached to a 60 tractors road materials were hauled on special narrow- tread, double- end steering trailers attached to 30 tractors and operated over the 5 ft. tractor trail. Miscellaneous materials such as insulators, hardware, hot lunches, and cookhouse supplies were delivered by one ton truck.
Tower Erection: The tower stubs or footings were set in places and the lower section of tower or extension assembled in panels and hinged up into place on special case hardened tool steal bolts by means of power from truck or 5 ton winch mounted on truck. The structure was then completed by assembling panels on the ground and hoisting them into place. Conductor Stringing: An outstanding advance in conductor stringing methods has been made in the past few years by the use of an aluminum sheave made like a snatch block specially designed with roller bearings so as to be as nearly frictionless as possible. This sheave was attached directly to the insulator string that supports the conductor.
The outside conductors were strung on the ground and then by use of a nigger head and a 3/8 steel cable on a winch truck the conductor was raised and placed in the sheave when it was then ready to be pulled to tension. In the case of the center conductor it was fed through the sheaves as it was strung through the tower. After the cable was pulled to tension the conductor was lifted out of the sheave and the latter was replaced with the regular suspension clamp. In this way long tension pulls of four to five miles were made as the cable quickly adjusts itself and no excessive loads on the conductor in spans nearest the point of pull are produced. The pull was obtained directly from 60 tractors if feasible or from winches mounted on tractors and trucks.
In flat, uncultivated country the conductor reel was placed on a truck and the outside conductors strung along the ground. The center conductor wheel was put on jacks and mandrel and the cable pulled out and passed through the tower. In rough mountain country the three conductors were attached to a bridle and pulled out at the same time plow steel cable was used for hand lines across canyons and inaccessible places. The few dead- end connections were assembled on the ground after the conductor had been pulled to tension, marked and let back to the ground. The conductor and assembly were then pulled up to the tower and a single bolt connection made to the tower. Splicing is an important part of conductor stringing and only experienced men were used for this work.
Approximately splices were made, and each was numbered and a record kept of the number, location and maker. A soft steel sleeve 11 long was compressed on the steel core with a 100 ton hydraulic press. The joint was then water proofed and a 30 cast aluminum sleeve put in place and compressed over that portion of the sleeve that is in 11 contact with the aluminum conductor. 11 Southern California Edison Company and Steal, BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 8
Formative Years of the SCE The SCE is comprised of electrical infrastructure built by SCE and its predecessor companies obtained through a series of mergers and acquisitions in the company s history from forward. SCE traces its origins back to July 4, On that day, the partnership of Holt and Knupp, which later became the Visalia Electric Light and Gas Company, first used a steam engine fueled by cord wood to power arc lights during th Visalia s evening 4 of July celebrations. Later that same year, the Santa Barbara Electric Light Company was formed and quickly installed outdoor arc lights to illuminate the balmy resort evenings in downtown Santa 12 Barbara.
Both the Visalia and Santa Barbara companies would later be merged into SCE in the early In the first commercial hydroelectric plant in the west was built at the community of Highgrove near the city of Riverside. Built by the Riverside Water Company, the plant took advantage of a 50- foot water drop in an irrigation canal to turn three waterwheels and direct current dynamos. The electricity was transmitted a very short distance to illuminate 30 arc lights in Riverside and Colton. In the Riverside Water Company 13 was incorporated as the San Bernardino Electric Company and was later acquired by SCE in the early That same year the Pasadena Electric Light and Power Company installed steam- driven current generators to power arc lights for street lighting in Pasadena.
Likewise, in the Ventura Land and Power Company installed hydroelectric generation to power arc lights in downtown Ventura, thereby catching up with their 14 neighbors in Santa Barbara further up the coast. In businessman Henry Sinclair and Dr. Cyrus G. Baldwin, the first president of Pomona College, co- founded the San Antonio Light and Power Company with the intention to provide electric street lighting to the city of Pomona. The technical challenge they faced was that direct current power could not be practically transmitted long distances. Baldwin hired A.W. Decker, an engineer familiar with the cutting edge of advances being made with alternating current. Decker installed the first single- phase alternating current hydroelectric generator in San Antonio Canyon above Claremont.
In late power was transmitted 14- miles to Pomona and, one month later, 29- miles to San Bernardino. The age of long- distance transmission had begun, thereby opening access to remote hydroelectric resources. Most history texts consider the Niagara Falls to Buffalo, New York transmission line as the first long- distance line in the nation built in but the reality is that the San Antonio Light and Power Company (with A.W. Decker) did it four years earlier in 15 San Antonio Canyon. A bronze plaque marks the spot on Mt. Baldy Road. In Henry Sinclair formed the Redlands Electric Light and Power Company to provide power to the Union Ice Company for the new electric motors in its ice- making facility in Mentone. The closest hydroelectric resource was eight- miles away at Mill Creek.
This long distance would require a high- voltage alternating current. Decker recommended that a new three- phase alternating current generator be installed. The new three- phase system enabled electric motors to start and stop independently of the generator and delivered a smoother power torque to the rotating equipment. The Mill Creek plant was the first commercial power plant in the United States to use three- phase alternating current. Today, the three- phase power generation remains the standard for power 16 generation worldwide. In the Mill Creek plant powered electric pumps installed to irrigate many of the 17 orange groves in Redlands. This was the earliest recorded use of electric pumps for irrigation purposes.
Although the original equipment was upgraded in the Mill Creek plant remains in operation today as the oldest active poly- phase power plant in the United States. 12 Edison International, Lighting Up the Town of Visalia California A Look Back: Our History accessed October 13, 13 Ibid., Hydroelectric Power near Riverside, Calif. 14 Ibid., Steam-powered Street Lights in Pasadena, Calif. 15 Ibid., Electric Streetlights for the City of Pomona 16 Ibid., Introducing Three-phase Alternating Current Generation 17 Ibid., Irrigating Orange Groves with the Help of Electric Pumps BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO.
CA- O Page 9 In the Kaweah Power and Water Company was formed to survey the potential development of hydroelectric facilities on the Kaweah River above Visalia and Tulare County. The Kaweah Hydro Plant began operating in and its operations were folded into the larger Mount Whitney Power Company. In the Mount Whitney Power Company was renamed as the Mount Whitney Power and Electric Company, and in 18 was acquired by SCE. Based in the central valley, the Mt. Whitney Power Company focused primarily on rural customers with Visalia being the largest town on its system.
The company covered most of Tulare County and portions of the neighboring Kings and Kern Counties, and built two additional hydroelectric plants on the Kaweah River; Plant Two in and Plant Three in The company purchased the Tule River hydroelectric plant in from the Globe Light and Power Company, enlarged its existing Visalia Steam Plant in and acquired a smaller plant at Tulare in from the Tulare County Power Company. Henry Huntington, of the Pacific Light and Power Company, purchased controlling interest of the Mount 19 Whitney Power and Electric Company in June West Side Lighting Company and the Edison Electric Company In in Los Angeles, California, a syndicate of businessmen formed the West Side Lighting Company in response to the city s increased need for electricity.
The West Side Lighting Company sought to utilize the Edison three- wire conduit technology invented years earlier by Thomas Edison. They soon discovered, however, that use of the Edison technology was prohibited due to a special contract negotiated between a speculative and inactive company established in under the name Los Angeles Edison Electric Company and Thomas Edison s own General Electric Company. The contract provided the Los Angeles Edison Electric Company with exclusive Southern California rights to the three- wire technology.
In that same year, Henry Sinclair of the Redlands Electric Light and Power Company teamed up with Henry Fisher, a prominent Redlands resident, to form the Southern California Power Company to pursue the construction of a new hydroelectric facility on the Santa Ana River. In West Side Lighting Company President George H. Barker met with General Electric officials in San Francisco to negotiate for use of the Edison technology in the Los Angeles area and to discuss a potential merger between the West Side Lighting Company and General Electric.
The new Edison Electric Company of Los Angeles (EEC) was incorporated on December 1, and with George Barker as the company head, the new company took over all the properties and franchises of the West Side Lighting Company and secured the valuable equipment licenses of the inactive Los Angeles Edison Electric Company. Thirsty for more power supplies for downtown Los Angeles, the EEC purchased the Southern California Power Company in and constructed the Santa Ana River No. 1 to Los Angeles Transmission Line, an 83- mile high- voltage transmission line to bring the power into downtown Los Angeles. At the time, this was by far the longest and highest voltage transmission line built anywhere in the country. Edison engineer Orville Ensign designed the Redlands insulator for use on the line.
This innovative insulator 20 design was rapidly adopted throughout the West. In the following years, EEC merged with and acquired additional electric lighting and power companies and soon expanded into communities outside of Los Angeles as far north as Santa Barbara and as far east as Redlands. The West Side Lighting Company and the EEC, with the Pacific Light and Power Company, are among the most important of SCE s ancestral companies. At the turn- of- the- century, the EEC, alongside its primary competitors, Pacific Light and Power Company, the San Joaquin Power & Light Company, and Pacific Gas & Electric Company, served as the pioneering commercial entities for electrical generation and distribution in California.
In California, at the inception of electrical transmission technology, power was distributed via wood poles and later iron poles, but was limited th to short spans carrying a low voltage.
The development of hydroelectric power at the end of the 19 century th set precedent for satisfying the demands of commercial electrical needs of the 20 century, and led to the installation of electrical transmission lines spanning great distances from generating facilities at California s river banks, through mountain ranges and deserts, before terminating within the urbanizing communities of 18 Edison International, Developing Hydroelectric Facilities on the Kaweah River 19 Myers, 20 Edison International, Hydroelectric Power & the Santa Ana River BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 10 Southern California. Leading the company in this period of innovation and expansion was John Barnes Miller.
He had joined the West Side Lighting Company as its General Manager in Miller coined the company motto that survives to this day: Good Service, Square Dealing, and Courteous Treatment. Known as the Great Amalgamator he recognized that lower costs could be achieved by expanding the scale of the company through mergers and acquisitions. Miller served as President of the EEC (and later SCE) for 31 years, presiding over the most expansive period in its history. He died in To date John Barnes Miller has 21 been the longest serving chief executive officer of SCE. In EEC began operations at the Kern River #1 Powerhouse, a volt facility on the banks of the Kern River north of Bakersfield, California. Five years earlier, in EEC Chief Hydraulic Engineer, F. C.
Finkle surveyed the remote area of Kern Canyon with a vision of a great hydroelectric power plant supplying the electrical needs of the rapidly growing region of Los Angeles. Two years after the initial survey, EEC Vice President Henry Sinclair chose a suitable location along the Kern River what was reckoned to become the location of Kern River Powerhouse No. 1. Situated approximately 14- miles upstream from the mouth of Kern 22 River, the EEC Kern River Powerhouse No.1 was set for service in early The Powerhouse served as the generating facility for the EEC s Kern River to Los Angeles Transmission Line, a mile span supported by galvanized steel transmission towers that were modeled after windmill frames, and supplied by the Wind Engine and Pump Company of Batavia, Illinois.
The towers are generally regarded as one of the first steel lattice transmission tower types in the United States. The Kern River to Los Angeles Transmission Line conveyed volts over its mile span, and terminated at EEC s pre- existing Steam & Transformer Plant No. 3 in Los Angeles, where the electricity was then distributed into Los Angeles via EEC s wood pole 23 distribution system. The Kern River to Los Angeles Transmission Line was cited in an August 10, Electrical World article as one of the longest transmission lines operating on the North American continent.
With its steel towers and specially designed insulators intended for a voltage capacity of the Kern River to Los Angeles Transmission Line with its associated Powerhouse typified the latest modern practice in 24 hydroelectric power plant design. At the start of operation, the Kern River Hydroelectric Project was 25 identified as the most permanent and costly hydraulic waterway in the country. SCE Reincorporation, Mergers, Acquisitions, Expansion, and Innovation By the EEC provided electricity to over people throughout five counties. To reflect this expanded presence, the company was reincorporated as the Southern California Edison Company (SCE). In the first two decades of the Twentieth Century SCE continued to expand throughout the growing Southern California region.
The company initiated construction of its Long Beach Steam Plant in and implemented a new system of steel tower transmission lines to replace its previous network of wood pole lines. In SCE merged with Henry Huntington s Pacific Light & Power Corporation The merger was viewed as beneficial to both parties. Huntington received about $12 million in Edison stock and SCE gained absolute control over all former holdings and future expansion efforts, including the Borel Powerhouse and associated Borel to Los Angeles Transmission Line, and the Big Creek Hydroelectric System.
After the successful merger between SCE and the company focused its labors at expanding the Big Creek Hydroelectric System, initially in- service in at a level of and upgraded to in By the year of the and SCE merger, 56 Southern California communities were lit by SCE infrastructure. Of those 56 communities serviced, 22 were initially serviced by infrastructure installed in the EEC- period and 34 were serviced by SCE- period infrastructure. By an 21 Edison International, Our motto: Good Service, Square Dealing, and Courteous Treatment 22 Frederick Hall Fowler, Hydroelectric Power Systems of California and Their Extension into Oregon and Nevada, Water-supply paper, issue (Washington, Government Printing Office, 23 Kern River No.
1 Power Plant of Edison Electric Co., Los Angeles, Electrical World, Volume 50, August 10, 24 Ibid., 25 Ibid. BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 11 additional 153 communities were serviced by SCE resulting from the merger with Huntington s and 26 the acquisition of the Mount Whitney Power and Electric Company. Into the late SCE continued to develop its Big Creek Hydroelectric System through the creation of dams and reservoirs, building of powerhouses, rail lines, and tunnels, as well as support camps replete with food and housing for workers, recreation and entertainment offerings, medical facilities, and administrative offices.
Upgrades were completed at the existing East and West Transmission Lines, and additional transmission lines were installed to convey electricity from Big Creek to Los Angeles. By when the initial Big Creek Hydroelectric system was completed, its capacity consistently generated more electrical power than any other systems in place at the time. The Big Creek system boasted many innovative engineering features, including the longest water tunnel in the world, the mile Big Creek East and West 150 / Transmission Lines, the mile Vincent Transmission Line, with all three lines spanning between the Big Creek generating facilities on the upper San Joaquin River and the Gould Substation in Los Angeles, the longest electrical transmission lines in the world at that time.
Developing in a parallel path to these early and SCE projects were the hydroelectric facilities at Bishop Creek. Built by a syndicate of investors under multiple successor corporations, including the Nevada Power, Mining and Milling Company (incorporated in the Nevada- California Power Company (incorporated in the Southern Sierras Power Company (incorporated in and the Nevada- California Electric Corporation (incorporated in the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System included multiple powerhouses, each with an associated residential complex for operators and maintenance crews, and a control station which served as the switching point for the collection and distribution of electricity from the system. In the Nevada- California Power Company was renamed as the California Electric Power Company.
Several early long- distance transmission records originated from Bishop Creek. In a high- voltage mile power line was installed between Bishop Creek, Tonopah, Nevada and Goldfield, Nevada on two wood pole lines. In a double circuit transmission line was constructed on double circuit lattice steel towers from Control Substation on Bishop Creek to the San Bernardino Substation (renamed Calectric) in San Bernardino, California for a total span of 239 miles.
The line was called the "Tower Line" because of the new off- the- shelf towers being used from the Milliken Brothers of New York, which had become the norm, as opposed to the wooden or metal poles, pole towers, or windmill poles as found in early lines like the Kern- Los Angeles Transmission Line (built in In the Tower line was built between Bishop Creek and San 27 Bernardino, California for a total span of 239 miles. On April 26, SCE entered into a contract with the United States Interior Department to generate electricity for itself and other investor- owned electric utility companies, and to distribute that power to its southern California service territory.
The source of power, the Hoover Dam, was intended for construction, and SCE s contract, along with similar contracts in place between the United States government, the City of Los Angeles, and the Southern Sierra Power Company helped to guarantee the amortization of the 28 project expenses over a 50- year period. The Boulder Dam to San Bernardino transmission line was energized in to initially convey power to the dam for construction purposes, and then was later reversed to carry electricity to San Bernardino when the dam was completed and in operation. Into the late in the post- WWII period, additional SCE projects were undertaken at Big Creek to make improvements to existing powerhouses including the addition of new generators, and construction of new dams and powerhouses.
This later phase of construction continued through the The modern- period upgrade campaign at Big Creek was instrumental in responding to the increased electricity needs of Southern 26 Myers, 27 Dorothea Theodoratus, Clinton M. Blount, Valerie H. Diamond, Stephen G. Helmich, and Robert A. Hicks / Theodoratus Cultural Research, Inc., Evaluation of the Historic Resources of the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System (July 9. 28 Myers, BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 12 California resultant from post- war suburban expansion. In the California Electric Power Company and its holdings were acquired by SCE, including the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System and its associated transmission lines.
Today SCE maintains an electrical infrastructure comprised of individually constructed substations, transmission lines, and other electrical generation and distribution equipment supporting 14 million customers over an approximate square- mile service territory. The SCE territory covers all or portions of Fresno, Inyo, Kern, Kings, Los Angeles, Madera, Mono, Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, Santa Barbara, Tulare, and Ventura Counties. Additionally, SCE owns facilities in eastern Arizona and Nevada that transmit electricity to Southern California. SCE Steel Towers The earliest identified steel lattice towers employed at an SCE transmission line were installed at the Kern River- Los Angeles Transmission Line.
SCE soon implemented additional all- steel tower lines within their service territory including additional Kern Towers at the Santa Ana to Los Angeles Transmission Line, acquisition of the Big Creek Towers, and improvement on that larger tower type at the Vincent Transmission Line. Other SCE steel lattice tower types include the more common steel lattice obelisk type installed 29 throughout the SCE transmission network. The obelisk tower type replaced an earlier wood pole system, and appears to have been initially installed throughout the SCE service areas subsequent to the completion of the company s Long Beach Steam Plant which provided for increased 30 voltage capacities throughout SCE territory.
From the forward SCE s steel lattice towers increased in size to correspond to increased loads from higher voltage capacity, which by the had achieved These oversized steel lattice transmission towers typically featured a cinched waist massing with a wide base, narrow mid- point, and extended horizontal cross arms. Insulators, constructed of porcelain, were of larger size. Big Creek Hydroelectric System The Big Creek Hydroelectric project is considered a premier example of a single, integrated hydroelectric system, which required innovative engineering methods and advanced technological application to harness the power of water for the purpose of creating electricity.
Between and the initial construction period of the project, the Big Creek Hydroelectric System was one of the highest generating systems in place and drew attention from engineers and laypersons globally. The concept behind the Big Creek system was developed by engineer John Eastwood, who formalized and executed his idea with the support and financial backing of capitalist Henry Huntington; railway, lumber and land entrepreneur William G. Kerckhoff; and electrical engineer and power and electric company founder Allan C. Balch. Henry Huntington, nephew of Southern Pacific Railway owner Collis P.
Huntington, developed an empire of Southern California land holdings, electric railroad transportation companies, and public utility companies, which by made him one of the most powerful men in the state. Kerckhoff, president of Kerckhoff- Cuzner Mill & Lumber, held interests in the San Gabriel Valley Rapid Transit Railway which ran through Los Angeles County in the cities of Los Angeles, Pasadena and Monrovia. The RTR was acquired by the Southern Pacific Railway Company, of which Henry Huntington served on the Board of Directors. Kerckhoff s proceeds from the RTR sale provided him with substantial financial abilities to pursue his interests in developing electrical power systems to supply California, which in turn, would support his primary holdings in the lumber industry.
29 Named obelisk by the author for the tower type s tall narrow pylon form with a pyramidal top, similar to the obelisk form common to ancient Egyptian and Egyptian Revival architecture. 30 Myers, 49. BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 13 Allan Balch received degrees in electrical and mechanical engineering from Cornell University in Ithaca, New York. He founded the Sierra Power Company, the Mentone Power Company, and the San Gabriel Electric Company. Through his academic background, entrepreneurial spirit and ownership of the San Gabriel Electric Company, Balch affiliated himself with Huntington and Kerckhoff.
In Huntington, Kerckhoff and Balch consolidated their holdings and formed the Pacific Light and Power Company, which included the holdings and territories of the San Gabriel and San Joaquin Valley Electric Companies. Prior to its acquisition by the Pacific Light and Power Company, the San Joaquin Valley Electric Company employed John Eastwood as vice- president and chief engineer. In this capacity Eastwood was able to propose his plan for designing and building one of the largest hydroelectric power systems in the world. Eastwood spent much of and surveying the Big Creek area, designing the hydroelectric system, and filing patents, claims to water rights, and permit applications with the federal government.
With the backing of Kerckhoff and Balch, Eastwood s proposal was submitted to Henry Huntington to decide whether the Huntington s Railways and the Pacific Light and Power Company s activities necessitated building of such an enormous undertaking. Huntington did not support the Big Creek proposal at that time, opting instead to develop a cheaper and more efficient steam power plant to service the Huntington, et. al. companies. Although the proposal was not immediately approved, efforts to implement the project continued into the with Eastwood continuing his work on securing land use and road development permits and water rights claims, and designing powerhouses which ultimately would serve as primary components of the Big Creek System.
In after reorganizing his business holdings - specifically dissolving his interests in the Southern Pacific Railroad Company - Huntington, with partners Kerckhoff and Balch, created a new company, the Pacific Light and Power Corporation, which replaced their previous Pacific Light and Power Company. Knowing the Southern Pacific Railroad Company would require major amounts of electricity as the company railroad lines were converted to electrical power and with a financing plan in place from a syndicate of New York bankers, the Pacific Light and Power Corporation commenced construction of the Big Creek Hydroelectric System in At the end of the first phase of the Big Creek System was completed.
By that time, Huntington was the primary owner and stockholder of the Pacific Light and Power Corporation, having bought out Kerckhoff and Balch in the spring of In the Huntington was at the end of his enormously successful career, and was looking to merge his company with SCE, a longstanding proposition that had been previously rejected by Edison s president John B. Miller. In Huntington s offer to merge was accepted by SCE. The merger was viewed as beneficial to both parties; for Huntington about $12 million in Edison stock and for Edison absolute control over company holdings, including future expansion efforts at the Big Creek Hydroelectric System.
SCE continued to develop its hydroelectric system at Big Creek into the late through the creation of lakes, dams and reservoirs, building of powerhouses, rail lines, and tunnels, as well as support camps replete with food and housing for workers, recreation and entertainment offerings, medical facilities, and administrative offices. By when the initial system was completed its capacity consistently generated more electrical power than other systems in place at the time and was also boasted as featuring the longest water tunnel in the world among other innovative engineering features. In the late additional projects were undertaken at Big Creek to make improvements to existing powerhouses including the addition of new generators, and construction new dams and powerhouses.
This later phase of construction continued through the Today the Big Creek Hydroelectric System Historic District is formally determined eligible for the National Register of Historic Places with a period of significance of when construction commenced, through when the initial planned phases of the system were completed. BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 14 Transmission Lines at Big Creek, Three transmission lines were installed at / from Big Creek within the identified through period- of- significance. The first two were Big Creek No. 1 / East and Big Creek No. 2 / West. The Big Creek East and West Transmission Lines are formally recorded as HAER No. CA- N.
The Vincent Transmission Line is the third line built from Big Creek within the period of significance. According to engineer David Redinger in The Story of Big Creek From the switchyard near Power House No. 3, three transmission lines carry the energy southward to the San Joaquin Valley and Southern California. Two of these lines are the original era lines, rebuilt in 23 to carry volts. The third line is the so- called "Vincent" line, completed in via a separate right- of- way. Major substations at Springville and Vestal (Richgrove) in Tulare County, and at Vincent, Gould, Eagle Rock and 31 Laguna Bell in Los Angeles County feed Big Creek Energy to Edison customers. The first three transmission lines were installed to connect from the Big Creek Power House No.
3, the operating headquarters for the Big Creek Hydroelectric System. According to Redinger When Big Creek Power House No. 3 first went into operation in the trade press hailed it as "Electrical Giant of the West" for its (then) kilowatts of rated capacity made it the largest hydroelectric plant in the West. Since that time, two additional units have been added to the plant, giving it a rated capacity of kilowatts. Unit No. 1 went into service on October 3, Unit No. 2 on September 30, Unit No. 3 on October 5, Unit No. 4 on April 28, and Unit No. 5 on February 24, Each of these units is powered by a Francis- type vertical reaction turbine operating on a static head of 827 feet. Located at an elevation of feet, Power House No.
3 is the operating headquarters for the Big Creek system, housing the control center for the entire project. From a switchyard located near the power house, volt transmission lines carry the electrical energy produced at Big Creek to customers in Southern California and 32 Central California. 31 David H. Redinger, The Story of Big Creek (Glendale: Trans-Anglo Books, 32 Ibid., BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 15 ENGINEERING /
The steel towers installed at the Vincent Transmission Line were modeled after the original tower types installed at the Big Creek No 1. And No. 2 Transmission Lines, however, SCE installed larger versions to accommodate the greater weight and load resultant from the heavier insulators and heavier transmission wire. The towers installed on the Vincent Transmission Line came to be identified as the Vincent Towers , of which modifications in the design and engineering occurred relating to the functions of Suspension, Dead End, and Transposition. In their article The Vincent Transmission Line: Engineering Construction and Features, SCE engineers Carlson and H. Michener explain how the Vincent Towers were specifically designed to allow for vertical leg extensions.
Extension heights of 7, 14, and 21 ft. were those which seemed to supply the needs of the profile. These extensions legs were arranged to permit combinations of any of them on a tower to a more economically fit profile. This latter arrangement has proved useful, as much of the country traversed was very rocky and difficult to excavate. Special cases required the combination of the 14- ft. and 21- ft. extensions making a 35- ft. in all, and in the case of the Tule River Crossing two special ft. towers were used. It was also necessary to supply certain other specialties such as transposition frames, attachments for towers to solid rock, footing extensions where uplift cover resistance was not available, 33 and single leg extensions without bracing to main structure.
Standard Tower height was designed as 64 from the base to the crossarm. Anchor Tower height was designed as 56 from tower base to the crossarm. Tower extensions were 7, 14, or 21 and could be placed on any or all tower corners. The average number of towers is per mile and range from 336 to in span 34 35 length. The standard tower cross arm was 22 3 from the center. Tower panel lengths were 8 , while the panel was 7 for the extensions. The combinations of different extensions allowed towers to fit the rocky landscape the transmission line traversed. Some cases required a combination of the 14 and 21 extensions 36 and in a special case, two 120 towers were used for the Tule River Crossing.
Transpositions required two 37 towers (one with a right- hand cross arm and the other with a left- hand) and were not set off the centerline. Bird guards were placed to prevent flashovers by hawks and other large birds. A sheet iron pan approximately 4 wide and 10 long protects the lower members of the cross arm, and saw tooth guards that are 3 long and made of galvanized iron were placed about 6 from the end of the cross arm to prevent birds 38 from perching above the outside conductor. The Vincent Towers were primarily fabricated offsite by two companies: Newport News Ship Building and Dry Dock Company of Newport News, Virginia, and Pacific Coast Steel Company of San Francisco and Seattle.
The towers were fabricated and brought on- site where work crews used a two- ton truck to raise the steel lattice panels of the pre- assembled towers from the ground and completed assembly via installation of tower tops and cross arms. A construction crew of 14 men would erect a standard tower in an average of six hours. For the Vincent line, SCE developed a new aluminum stringing sheave with ball bearings to string the 39 conductors. Overhead ground wires were installed after the first few months of operation had proven them necessary. To accommodate the ground wire project, the northern portion of the line was removed from 33 Carlson, and H. Michener, 34 Ibid., 35 Southern California Edison, Vincent Transmission Line: Transpositions for Vincent Line between Crescenta & Big Creek No.
3, drawing 36 Carlson and Michener, 37 Ibid., 38 Ibid., 39 Ibid., BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 16 service two weeks and the installation was completed on August 10, Installation of ground wires at the 40 southern portion of the line was completed on July 12, Construction of the northern portion, between Big Creek and Magunden Substation, was documented in a September 18, Los Angeles Times titled Costly Power Station Built which detailed the project progress and the visibility of the Vincent Towers in the Southern California landscape.
Throughout the year a crew of about 600 men pushing through to an early completion the northern end of the third volt transmission line past the Vincent line between Magunden substation just outside of Bakersfield and the hydroelectric plants in the high Sierras. Great towers with aluminum cables are striding northward toward the generating plants. 41 This work will be completed early in the spring of The line s physical construction details were documented by SCE in a March 31, Unit Cost Report. Description of Line: The Vincent Transmission Line is a Single circuit steel tower line extending miles from Gould Switching Station, a few miles Northwest of Pasadena to Powerhouse No. 3 at Big Creek.
Beginning at Gould the line crosses the San Gabriel mountains, reaching an elevation of extends over the Antelope Valley, passes over the Tehachapi mountains to a height of ft. and then across the Southern end of the San Joaquin Valley. It then follows the foothills along the Eastern edge of that valley until it reaches the mountains at Big Creek where it crosses Pine Ridge at an elevation of ft. The right- of- way is 200 ft. wide and provides for a second (East) tower line expected to be built in the future. The rights- of- way for road and telephone vary in width and for the most part are outside the right- of- way for the transmission line, crossing and recrossing it.
The Vincent line ties in with the two original Big Creek lines at the Magunden Switching Station as well as at Eagle- Bell Line and Power House 3 Loop. Its rated carrying capacity is which is 50% greater than either of the original lines. Spans vary from 236 ft. to there being an average of approximately four towers per mile. Anchor towers are used for all horizontal angles of more than 11 40 and also at several other points where special conditions are encountered. Only sixteen such towers are used in the line and the rest are standard suspension towers with the exception of 65 Eagle- Bell towers used because they were on hand in stock. Standard towers are 64 ft. high to cross arm and anchor towers 57 ft. Tower extensions are 7, 14, or 21 ft.
high any of these heights are used on any or all corners of a tower, making an economical arrangement to fit the rugged nature of the 40 Southern California Edison Company and Steal, 4. 41 Costly Power Station Built Los Angeles Times, September 18, (E2). Authors Note: This article appears to have incorrectly identified the fourth Big Creek transmission line as the third Big Creek transmission line. The third Big Creek transmission line is the Big Creek #3 / Vincent Transmission Line. BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 17 country traversed. Steel grillage footings 8 ft. and 9 ft. deep are used for earth footings. A very few rock anchor footings are used.
The Conductor consists of 54 strands of aluminum with cross- section of which is equal in conductivity to of copper, and has a reinforcing core of 7 strands of steel. All strands are in diameter and the total Conductor diameter is . Aluminum used instead of copper because it is lighter, cheaper and stronger. The maximum tension provided for in snow and sleet districts is and in light loading districts Insulators are 10 cap and pin type with a minimum strength of Suspension assemblies consist of a single string of 13 units or double string of 15 units each. Dead end assemblies consist of a double string of 15 units each. Tie down assemblies consist of a single string of 14 units. Insulator hardware is mostly made of wrought or forged steel. Shield rings are x 3 steel strap.
Two overhead ground wires or skylines of or 1/2 steel cable as well as bird guards and pans were installed over the length of the line. Approximately 185 miles of roads were constructed in several sections and these connect with existing public highways to form a continuous road from Gould to Powerhouse No. 3. A telephone line, supported on pressure- treated southern pine poles, generally following the road, gives communication for operating purposes. This is a four- wire lead except for the eight- wire tap leads to Vestal Substation and Palmdale Patrol Station and the six- wire main lead from Basin to Powerhouse No. 3.
Four patrol stations were constructed: One at Tujunga in the San Gabriel Mountains, one at Palmdale in the Antelope Valley, another at Cummings in the Tehachapi Mountains and the last at Lemon Cove near Visalia. Other patrol stations at Gould, Magunden, Vestal, Citrus Cove, Toll House and Powerhouse No. 3 serve the Vincent Line but were previously 42 established or built under other general work orders. Following is a general engineering chronology of the Vincent Transmission Line naming protocol with a corresponding summary of modifications. - Final completion of the line was reported on October 1, At this time the line was comprised of two segments located between Big Creek Powerhouse No.
3, Magunden Substation, and Gould Substation and identified as follows: Big Creek #3- Magunden Transmission Line, and Magunden- Gould Transmission Line. By SCE no longer identified the Vincent Transmission Line by its original moniker, rather all engineering records and transmission line data sheets were renamed to correspond to the above- listed segment identifiers. These two segments comprised the entire line until - In the SCE Antelope Substation was built within the right- of- way of the Magunden- Gould segment, which resulted in further segmentation and renaming of the line as follows: Big Creek #3- Magunden Transmission Line, 42 Southern California Edison Company and Steal, BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO.
CA- O Page 18 Magunden- Antelope Transmission Line, and Antelope- Gould Transmission Line. These three segments comprised the entire line until In the SCE Vincent Substation was built within the alignment of the Antelope- Gould segment, which resulted in further segmentation and renaming of the line as follows: Big Creek #3- Magunden Transmission Line, Magunden- Antelope Transmission Line, Antelope- Vincent Transmission Line, and Vincent- Gould Transmission Line.
These four segments comprised the entire line until In the SCE Pardee Substation was built west of the line south of the Vincent Substation, which resulted in further segmentation and renaming of the line as follows: Big Creek #3- Magunden Transmission Line, Magunden- Antelope Transmission Line, Antelope- Vincent Transmission Line, Pardee- Vincent Transmission Line, and Vincent- Gould Transmission Line. These five segments comprised the entire line until Between and limited modifications occurred at the line including the removal of 14Vincent Towers that were replaced with newer tower types, and installation of 10 additional new towers in places along the original mile span. Following is a breakdown of the specific modifications.
Installation of a new MAB tower at M0- 1B, Installation of a new MA SPEC tower at T1A, Removal of a Vincent tower and installation of a replacement B tower type at T6 / T2 (same location tower renumbered), Removal of a Vincent tower and installation of a replacement MA SPEC tower at T1A, Removal of a Vincent tower and installation of a replacement MA SPEC tower at T3, Installation of a new MS tower at T3A, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement MS tower at T2, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement MS tower at T3, Installation of a new MA SPEC tower at T4A, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement type P tower at T1, Installation of a new tower at T3A, Installation of a new tower at T2A, Installation of a new tower at Installation of a new tower at Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement MS tower at T3, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement MS tower at T4, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement EB tower at T1, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement EB tower at T2, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement H- Frame tower at T2, Installation of a new tower at T1, Installation of a new tower at T1A, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement Anchor tower at T1, Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement Anchor tower at T2, and BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO.
CA- O Page 19 Removal of a Vincent Tower and installation of a replacement Anchor tower at T1. The remaining identified modifications entail repairs to concrete footings and extension of Vincent Tower bases in locations. Additionally the tower extensions appear to have been completed according to original Vincent specifications that provided for field variations and extensions at 7, 14, and 21 . In approximately 148 towers were removed from the line over an approximate 37- mile span. All towers south of the SCE Antelope Substation were removed, thereby establishing the Antelope Substation as the new southern terminus for the line. In a new transmission line was constructed in the former right- of- way at the removed line locations south of the Antelope Substation complex.
Today 717 original towers are extant over the remaining mile alignment of the historic Vincent Transmission Line. BIG CREEK HYDROELECTRIC SYSTEM, VINCENT TRANSMISSION LINE HAER NO. CA- O Page 20
Primary Sources Carlson, and H. Michener. The Vincent Kv. Transmission Line: Engineering and Construction Features. Transactions of the American Institute of Electrical Engineers December Davis, R.A., D.A. Denholm, and A.G. Denyer. Southern California Edison Company History. Unpublished. Updated Fowler, Frederick Hall. Hydroelectric Power Systems of California and Their Extension into Oregon and Nevada. Water- supply paper, issue Washington, Government Printing Office, Kern River No. 1 Power Plant of Edison Electric Co., Los Angeles. Electrical World 50. August 10, Redinger, David H. The Story of Big Creek. Glendale: Trans- Anglo Press, Southern California Edison. Confidential Substation Database.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Southern California Edison Photographs and Negatives. Huntington Digital Library. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Vincent Transmission Line: Transpositions for Vincent Line between Crescenta & Big Creek No. 3, drawing Southern California Edison Company and Steal. Unit Cost Report Vincent Transmission Line as of March 31, Part of Federal Project No. Southern California Edison Company, June On file at The Huntington Library, SCE Collection. United States Federal Power Commission. Sixth Annual Report. Washington, Government Printing Office, Secondary Sources Edison International. A Look Back: Our History. us/our- history.html#27764. Accessed October 13, Myers, William A.
Iron Men and Copper Wires: A Centennial History of the Southern California Edison Company. Glendale: Trans- Anglo Books, Theodoratus, Dorothea, Clinton M. Blount, Valerie H. Diamond, Stephen G. Helmich, and Robert A. Hicks / Theodoratus Cultural Research, Inc. Evaluation of the Historic Resources of the Bishop Creek Hydroelectric System.