BlockBefore

Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle, and Bridge, Belmont Avenue, Fresno

Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle, and Bridge, Belmont Avenue, Fresno, Fresno County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CA-2325, with a 3,412-word written history.

From the record

“Completed in the Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge was a combined effort between Fresno County, the City of Fresno, the State of California and the Southern Pacific Railroad.”

Written record, HAER CA-2325 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CA-2325 · the record runs 3412 words · one of 32 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

236 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2325. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Completed in the Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge was a combined effort between Fresno County, the City of Fresno, the State of California and the Southern Pacific Railroad. The project was undertaken as an early effort to eliminate dangerous at-grade railroad crossings. The subway, bridge and the associated 300 diameter traffic circle roadway approach is the first configuration of this type in California to address a key railroad grade-separation along former Highway 99, and is among the first examples of a traffic circle in the western United States. In addition, the project was the first to incorporate a traffic circle as a design approach to a subway.

The other historic- period traffic circles, including Long Beach and Bakersfield, were not constructed as part of a subway project. The property has been determined eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places at the local level under Criterion C as one of the earliest examples of this type of traffic feature in the western United States. The structures also have been determined eligible for their association with master engineer Jean L. Vincenz. Historians: Madeline Bowen, MA and Patricia Ambacher, MA Historians AECOM L Street, Suite 400 Sacramento, CA Initial Draft: November Joel Levanetz, MA AICP RPA Senior Architectural Historian Chambers Group, Inc. Chesapeake Drive, Suite 202 San Diego, CA Revised Draft: May BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No.

CA-2325 PAGE 2

Written history

3067 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-2325. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Level II Historic American Engineering Record (HAER) contained within this document was prepared for the California High Speed Rail Authority to record the property in partial fulfillment of mitigation measures outlined for Construction Package 1 of the project. The documentation was originally drafted in by AECOM. Madeline Bowen of AECOM served as principal investigator for the project. Patricia Ambacher of AECOM conducted primary research and assisted with document preparation. The original draft was then updated and revised by Joel Levanetz, a Senior Architectural Historian with Chambers Group, Inc., San Diego, California. As such, the following HAER relies on documentation previously prepared for the undertaking.

All materials are properly cited to clearly indicate the source of the information. Stephen Schafer (Schaf Photo) created new contact prints from the negatives in February BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No. CA-2325 PAGE 3 Part I. Historical Information A. Physical History 1. Date of Construction: The property was originally constructed at the site in as part of a collaborative project between the Southern Pacific Railroad, the City of Fresno and Fresno County. 2. Engineer: Jean L. Vincenz was born in Enfield, Illinois. The Vincenz family moved to Fresno where Jean completed high school and junior college. He earned his civil engineering degree from Stanford University in Later, in he earned a degree in public administration from San Diego State College.

Vincenz worked as the Commissioner of Public Works, City of Fresno Engineer and Utilities Manager from to In Vincenz accepted a post as Assistant Chief of the Repairs and Utilities Division of the Corps of Engineers. Vincenz served as Public Works Director for the San Diego County Public Works Department between and In he became President of the American Public Works Association.1 3. Builder, Contractor, Suppliers: The historical record identified the builder as the City of Fresno. 4. Original Plans: The initial design is largely evident in the current form of the subject property. The subway remains extending in an east-west orientation beneath the associated bridge and a railroad overcrossing. The subway corridor connects with the traffic circle just beyond its western terminus.

According to research and available historic- period aerials, the street configuration surrounding the subject property, as well as the roadways that constitute the subway, traffic circle and bridge appear to retain the same layout as originally intended. See Part II. Structural/Design Information for a detailed description of the features. 5. Alterations and Additions: According to the Department of Parks and Recreation 523 Forms, the Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge have undergone minor alterations.2 Ornamental light fixtures originally attached to railings along the subway and bridge were removed at an unknown date.

The intersection at the eastern end of the subject property has also been modified since The Weber Avenue Overcrossing (notable as one of the first pre-stressed concrete road bridges in California) now spans the eastern approach ramp of the subway. This alteration occurred with the construction of the overcrossing in 1 Melosi, Martin V. NPS Form National Historic Landmark Nomination for Fresno Sanitary Landfill. 2 AECOM. Historic Property Survey Report: Merced to Fresno Section High-Speed Train Project EIR/EIS. BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No. CA-2325 PAGE 4 B. Historical Context During the early as automobiles rose in prevalence, accidents at railroad grade crossings increased.

More than 600 people were injured and were killed at grade crossings throughout the United States in The severity of the situation resulted in a combined study undertaken by the California Highway Commission (Commission), Bureau of Public Roads and the State Railroad Commission which rated more than 500 existing crossings. Using the findings of their study, these agencies established a program to eliminate the most dangerous crossings. The California Highway Commission identified the preferred alternative to the dangerous at- grade crossings through the construction of subways.4 In the Commission in conjunction with the State Railroad Commission undertook an intensive study of railroad grade crossings existing upon the highway system.

The collected data: 1) identified each location of railroad grade crossings; 2) approximated levels of railroad and automobile traffic at each crossing; 3) noted types of warning designs in place; and 4) recorded accidents at each crossing. These agencies used this data to determine cost estimates for the elimination of at grade crossings by either relocating the railroad or highway, or constructing underpasses or overpasses.5 Subways continued as the preferred alternative throughout California and much of the western United States. Typically, these subways featured utilitarian steel plate girder superstructures that often included some curb, gutter and sidewalk improvements.6 By the federal government had allocated funds for all states to construct safer railroad crossings.

California received million for 39 projects in 18 different counties.7 Belmont Avenue in Fresno was heavily traveled, particularly during the summer months where traffic peaked at vehicles in 16 hours. Nearly half of those travelers used Highway 99 while the remainder entered Roeding Park. This vehicular traffic coupled with the high frequency of Southern Pacific Mainline Train crossings made Belmont Avenue particularly hazardous and frequently caused delays for travelers on this section of Highway In officials proposed a subway at the Belmont Avenue crossing. Fresno s Commissioner of Public Works and Engineer, Jean L. Vincenz, recommended a traffic circle as part of the western approach to the subway.

The traffic circle concept met initial resistance from the Commission because it believed it could not accommodate future traffic needs. Vincenz countered that the concept had previously been proven to work. 3 Woodson, Elimination of Grade Crossings Grave Problems. California Highways. August 4 Ibid., p.9 5 State of California Railroad Commission and Department of Public Works Division of Highways, Pursuant to Assembly Concurrent Resolution No. 23, Chapter 45, Laws of 6 Dunkhorst, Paul. Grade Separation Built by State on Route 4 in City Bakersfield. California Highways and Public Works, August 6 Stover, Longest Steel Plate Girders in State Places at McConnell Subway Crossing. California Highways and Public Works, September 7 McCoy, George T.

39 Grade Crossings on California Highways Being Eliminated with Federal Funds. California Highways and Public Works, October 8 Beuthel, Walter. First Coast Traffic Circle-Subway Improvement Completed at Fresno. California Highways and Public Works, July BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No. CA-2325 PAGE 5 The first example of a traffic circle constructed in the United States was New York City s Columbus Circle in New Jersey soon followed, constructing several additional traffic circles during that period. These early century traffic circles adopted the yield-to-right principle for right-of-way and were concentrated on a weaving movement as a main design consideration. These two factors resulted in common traffic-jams in the circle.

By the when traffic volumes increased, engineers designed larger circles to accommodate higher speeds and longer weaving distances that helped avoid rear-end collisions and traffic congestion.9 Vincenz consulted with traffic experts on the east coast and successfully demonstrated that his design, with its 200 radius, could accommodate more than vehicles per day.

The Commission then authorized for its portion of the project.10 By the end of December the Fresno County Board of Supervisors, and the California State Railroad Commission each provided its approval and committed its share of the project.11 Construction began in February and the traffic circle and subway formally opened on July 22, The Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge do not appear to meet the eligibility requirements under Criterion A/1. State and local officials acknowledged grade changes at railroads, including those in Fresno, as being dangerous as early as the early and noted the necessity to change these crossings for the safety of motorists.

California conducted intensive studies in the late and early and made comprehensive changes to numerous at-grade crossings throughout the state. The construction of the traffic circle also does not represent a successful and long-term movement to incorporate traffic circles as safety measures in the west. By the early there appear to have been only three traffic circles of note in the cities of Long Beach, Bakersfield, and Fresno. However, because traffic circles continued to cause traffic jams during peak traffic hours, the design quickly fell out of favor. By the most traffic circles were replaced with signalized intersections or had signals added to them.

In general, the construction of this first western traffic circle (as part of the subway design) does not appear to have galvanized or represent a significant event related to transportation history nationally or within the State of California. Under Criterion the subway, traffic circle and bridge do not appear significant. These properties are not associated with persons who made a significant contribution to history at the local, state or national levels. While they are associated with engineer Jean J. Vincenz, that association is better understood under Criterion C/3 as the work of a master engineer.

Therefore, these structures do not appear to meet Criterion The Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge do appear to meet Criterion at the local level of significance, for representing the earliest example of this type of traffic feature in the western United States and for its association with engineer Jean L. Vincenz. Completed in the Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge was a 9 Jaquemart. Georges. Synthesis of Highway Practice Modern Roundabout Practice in the United States. Washington, D. C.: 10 State Approves Circle Plan for Belmont Subway. The Fresno Bee, December 7, On file at the California State Library, Sacramento, CA. 11 State Agrees to Give to Belmont Subway. The Fresno Bee, December 12, On file at the California State Library, Sacramento, CA.

12 Beuthel, Walter. First Coast Traffic Circle-Subway Improvement Completed at Fresno. California Highways and Public Works, July BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No. CA-2325 PAGE 6 combined effort between Fresno County, the City of Fresno, the State of California and the Southern Pacific Railroad and was part of the efforts to eliminate dangerous at-grade railroad crossings. The subway and its associated 200 radius traffic circle roadway approach is the first configuration of this type in California to address a key railroad grade-separation along former Highway 99, and is one of the earliest examples of traffic circles in the West.

The project was the first to incorporate a traffic circle as a design approach to a subway.13 The other historic- period traffic circles, including those built in Long Beach and Bakersfield, were not constructed as part of a subway project. Bakersfield s traffic circle saw construction in and was designed to route traffic from Highway 99 into Bakersfield.14 The Long Beach traffic circle (also known as the Los Alamitos Traffic Circle) was installed after Belmont and was part of a larger highway improvement project at a major intersection along the Pacific Coast Highway.

Additionally, the Long Beach traffic circle was altered in and converted to a modern roundabout using design standards of the late-20th century and no longer retains an appreciable level of integrity.15 As noted above, the structures also appear eligible for their association with master engineer Jean L. Vincenz. Vincenz graduated from Stanford University in with a degree in civil engineering. He worked briefly at a private firm in Fresno and, in was elected Commissioner of Public Works. In this role Vincenz undertook several public works projects in Fresno, including the innovative Fresno Sanitary Landfill (now a National Historic Landmark), improvements to the Fresno Municipal Airport, and various infrastructure projects relating to the city s sewer system and roads.

Vincenz was responsible for the design of the traffic circle. In his role as City Engineer, Vincenz made significant contributions to the public works in Fresno including this particular project which the City considered momentous. Under Criterion the structures do not appear likely to yield information important to history and they do not appear to meet this criterion. 13 Beuthel, Walter. First Coast Traffic Circle-Subway Improvement Completed at Fresno. California Highways and Public Works, July 14 Badger, Bakersfield By-Pass Relocation is Opened with Dedication Ceremonies. California Highways and Public Works, June 15 Jaquemart. Georges. Synthesis of Highway Practice Modern Roundabout Practice in the United States. Washington, D. C.: 15 Roussel, Juliem D.

Eight Contracts Completed on State Street Project in Long Beach Area. California Highways and Public Works, July BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No. CA-2325 PAGE 7 Part II. STRUCTURAL/DESIGN INFORMATION A. General Statement 1. Character: The character of the subject property is notable in its innovative design. The combination of the subway corridor with the associated bridge and traffic circle was a unique approach to address safety concerns at the railroad crossing. Research indicates that this configuration was the first of its kind in California and is among the earliest examples of a traffic circle in the western United States. 2. Condition of fabric: The subject property includes the Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge.

In general, this resource consists of concrete, asphalt and landscaping elements. At the time of this analysis, these components appeared to be in fair condition. However, some portions of the concrete subway and bridge exhibit minor flaking and spalling. This is attributed to natural weathering through exposure to the elements. B. Description 1. Materials: In large part, the materials used in the construction of the subject property consist of concrete and asphalt. The concrete was employed in the construction of such elements as the bridges structure, pedestrian walkway, decorative handrails and retaining walls beneath the Weber Avenue Overcrossing.

In addition to the concrete components, the subject property includes three lanes of an asphalt roadway that extends from east of the overcrossing and stretches around the Belmont Avenue Traffic Circle. The traffic circle features a concrete curb surrounding its perimeter and both non-native grasses and mature trees within its footprint. 2. Dimensions: The Belmont Avenue Traffic Circle measures approximately 300 feet in diameter. The linear span from the eastern terminus to the intersection of North Weber and East Belmont Avenues to the east of the subway is approximately 700 feet. As such, from the eastern entry of the subway to the western exit of the traffic circle is nearly feet. 3.

Layout: The Belmont Avenue Traffic Circle is situated at the western end of the subject property as a whole. The circle is slightly off-center to the north of the axis created by West Belmont Avenue to the east. Two segments of Golden State Boulevard extend from the north of the traffic circle, forming a triangular plot of land between the roadway corridors. Similar, but smaller triangular islands are found as Belmont Avenue continues west and Wesley Avenue continues south, away from the traffic circle. Following Belmont Avenue east, the roadway descends below the surrounding grade before it traverses beneath the Weber Avenue Overcrossing and Bridge No. The street returns to the relative elevation of the surrounding grade near the intersection with Weber Avenue east of the subway.

BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No. CA-2325 PAGE 8 C. Mechanicals/Operation Part of the significance embodied by the Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge is that the design eliminated the public exposure to a potentially dangerous railroad crossing without the use of mechanical processes. Rather than traditional signals or lights, the system employs the traffic circle to mitigate travel speeds while the subway allows passage beneath the bridge and railroad line, eliminating the risk of a contested right-of-way. The simplicity of the design also allows a fluid transition to surrounding streets by eliminating the traditional controlled intersection. D.

Site Information The Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge is situated in an area of Fresno that represents the boundary between several distinctive land uses. To the north and south of the subject property are residential neighborhoods characterized by detached, single-family homes. Northwest of the resource is Roeding Park. This property includes a zoo and various other recreational facilities. Southeast of the traffic circle is a water collection basin under the authority of the Fresno Metropolitan Flood Control District. Parcels located further south and southeast of the property support heavy commercial and industrial uses. BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No. CA-2325 PAGE 9 Part III. Sources of Information A.

Primary Sources Badger, Bakersfield By-Pass Relocation is Opened with Dedication Ceremonies. California Highways and Public Works, June Beuthel, Walter. First Coast Traffic Circle-Subway Improvement Completed at Fresno. California Highways and Public Works, July California Department of Transportation Division of Maintenance Bridge Inspection Records Information System. Bridge Number Bridge Reports and As-Built Plans. On file with the City of Fresno. Construction to Start Soon on Belmont Subway. The Fresno Bee, December 27, On file at the California State Library, Sacramento, CA. County Approves Subway Project. The Fresno Bee, December 15, On file at the California State Library, Sacramento, CA. Dunkhorst, Paul. Grade Separation Built by State on Route 4 in City Bakersfield.

California Highways and Public Works, August McCoy, George T. 39 Grade Crossings on California Highways Being Eliminated with Federal Funds. California Highways and Public Works, October Packard, L. D. Progress Made on Grade Crossing Elimination. California Highways. April Roussel, Juliem D. Eight Contracts Completed on State Street Project in Long Beach Area. California Highways and Public Works, July State of California Railroad Commission and Department of Public Works Division of Highways, Pursuant to Assembly Concurrent Resolution No. 23, Chapter 45, Laws of State Agrees to Give to Belmont Subway. The Fresno Bee, December 12, On file at the California State Library, Sacramento, CA. State Approves Circle Plan for Belmont Subway.

The Fresno Bee, December 7, On file at the California State Library, Sacramento, CA. Stover, Longest Steel Plate Girders in State Places at McConnell Subway Crossing. California Highways and Public Works, September Woodson, Elimination of Grade Crossings Grave Problems. California Highways. August BELMONT AVENUE SUBWAY, TRAFFIC CIRCLE & BRIDGE HAER No. CA-2325 PAGE 10 B. Secondary Sources AECOM. Historic Property Survey Report: Merced to Fresno Section High-Speed Train Project EIR/EIS. Jaquemart. Georges. Synthesis of Highway Practice Modern Roundabout Practice in the United States. Washington, D. C.: Laval, Jerome D. As Pop Saw It Volume III Photographs of the San Joaquin Valley. Fresno: Graphic Technology Company, Melosi, Martin V.

NPS Form National Historic Landmark Nomination for Fresno Sanitary Landfill. C. Likely Sources Not Yet Investigated Other repositories that may contain historical background information relevant to the Belmont Avenue Subway, Traffic Circle and Bridge include the following: Fresno Historical Society, which may contain historic photographs; and the Fresno County Clerk of the Board.

In context

Fresno, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Fresno County, California 484 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Fresno

14 records

The federal surveyors worked through Fresno building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Fulton MallHALS CA-11610,914 words
Roeding ParkHALS CA-597,634 words
Ivan Carter McIndoo HouseHABS CA-28856,822 words
John G. Porter HouseHABS CA-28846,711 words
Matthew McIndoo HouseHABS CA-28766,575 words
Albert G. Wishon HouseHABS CA-28836,210 words
Charles H. Cobb HouseHABS CA-28775,371 words
Newman J. Levinson HouseHABS CA-29055,029 words
Lamb TownhouseHABS CA-28744,457 words
Ira H. Brooks HouseHABS CAL,10-FRES,1-4,276 words
Burnett Nurse's HomeHABS CAL,10-FRES,2-3,672 words
O'Brien HouseHABS CA-28823,326 words
George H. Larsen HouseHABS CA-28753,087 words
Weber Avenue OvercrossingHAER CA-23242,653 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CA-2325. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.