The Municipal Pier Recording Project was undertaken in through the cooperation of the Heritage Documentation Programs Paul Dolinsky, Acting Chief, a division of the National Park Service, and San Francisco Maritime National Historical Park (SAFR), Kevin Hendricks, Superintendent, and the Council of American Maritime Museums (CAMM), Greg Gorga, President. Todd Croteau, served as project leader and produced the large-format photographs. Justine Christianson, wrote the historical report. Fieldwork and drawings were completed by Dana Lockett Cristina Montenegro Torres (CAMM), and Onairis N. Perez (CAMM). AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 2) The Aquatic Park, including Municipal Pier, was documented in with large-format photographs, measured drawings, and a historical report.
See HALS CA-113 for additional documentation. This report includes additional contextual information about the design and construction of the pier and places it within the history of pier construction in San Francisco. AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 3) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History 1. Date of establishment: The pier was completed in and officially opened to the public in January 2. Architects/Engineers: The firm Bakewell & Brown plus John A. Bauer (associate architect) and Frank G. White and Harry E. Squire (consulting engineers) developed the initial plans for the pier. The firm Punnett, Parez & Hutchison designed the concrete parapets, curbs, and seating. John Bakewell, Jr. and Arthur Brown, Jr.
formed Bakewell & Brown, which operated from Both were University of California graduates who had studied under Bernard Maybeck and attended the cole des Beaux Arts. Their work included several buildings for the Panama Pacific International Exposition, Berkeley City Hall, the San Francisco Savings Union, and buildings at Stanford University, in addition to San Francisco s City Hall (now a National Historic Landmark). The firm, along with John A. Bauer, also developed the plans for the Aquatic Park at the request of San Francisco s Board of Park Commissioners.1 Frank G. White attended the University of Iowa-Iowa City, where he studied civil engineering. He ended up in San Francisco, working in the city engineer s office from and then the Port Authority.
From White was the chief engineer on the Board of Harbor Commissioners for San Francisco where he shaped the development of San Francisco Harbor by overseeing the design, development of specifications, and construction of piers, wharves, and other harbor structures.2 The firm of Punnett, Parez & Hutchison was comprised of John M. Punnett, George Neaves Parez, and E. Elmore Hutchison. The San Francisco-based firm specialized in civil engineering and surveying, and its work included mapping various subdivisions in the city and serving as civil engineering consultants on numerous projects. 3. Builders: Healy-Tibbitts Construction Company won the contract to build the pier. Meyer Brothers built the parapets, curbs, and seating. 4.
Original and subsequent owners: The City of San Francisco initially owned and operated Aquatic Park, including the pier. This was an unusual arrangement because the Board of Harbor Commissioners of San Francisco oversaw the rest of the city s piers and wharves. For a short time during World War II, the Federal government assumed authority of the pier but relinquished it back to the city. In the U.S.
Congress established Golden Gate National Recreation Area, which ultimately resulted in the transfer of the park from the Recreation and Park Commission of 1 Plans for New City Hall Decided Upon, San Francisco Call, June 21, Bakewell and Brown, Architects, John Bakewell, and Arthur Brown, entries in Pacific Coast Architecture Database (PCAD), available online at accessed September 18, 2 Frank G. White Dies in California, Winterset Madisonian [Winterset, Iowa], February 15, available online at accessed September AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 4) the City and County of San Francisco to the U.S. Department of the Interior five years later. San Francisco Maritime National Historical Park was established as an independent unit of the National Park System in 5.
Periods of development: a. Original plans and construction: The August plans by Bakewell & Brown, John A. Bauer (associate architect), and Frank G. White and Harry E. Squire (consulting engineers) depict a reinforced-concrete curved pier ending at a node. There was a section of earth and rock fill between the shore and the beginning of the pier. The substructure was comprised of five rows of pilings, designated A, B, C, D, and E from the bay to the cove. There were two types of pilings shown in the initial plans, but both were basically timber pilings enclosed in reinforced-concrete jackets. Type A were the brace pilings, measuring 22" square with chamfered edges. These were found in rows A, D, and E.
The Type B piling was like Type A at the top and bottom but it had a central 6'-long section that was wider than the rest of the piling at 22" x This accommodated the angled insertion of the wave baffle slab, which extended upwards to the pilings in row C. The slabs were kept in place by 4'- 3"-long steel pins with the void between the slab and the piling filled with cement mortar. Each reinforced-concrete baffle slab was nearly a foot long and 18" thick. A 14" x 14" concrete brace extended at an angle down from the pier deck to row C, and a brace piling also extended at an angle from row C to the bottom. The reinforced-concrete deck cantilevered past rows A and E by 5', and the entire deck was 60' wide.
The plans indicated hand railings were to be built comprised of concrete posts standing over 3' tall with 3" galvanized pipe rails between them.3 The pier s railings, curbs, and seating were separately designed, with Punnett, Parez & Hutchison completing the plans in August Instead of concrete posts and pipe railings, there would be tall concrete parapets containing an electrical light conduit (measuring in diameter) on the side facing the cove and electrical light, electrical power (measuring in diameter), and telephone line (measuring conduits on the side facing the bay. The seats were located at regular intervals along the sides of the pier, as were the electroliers.
The reinforced-concrete benches faced outwards and were 4' tall with wood seats attached by bolts and brass screws to the concrete. The concrete curbs were tall and 9" wide with a scupper on the curb s inside edge. The curb on the bay side of the pier held a 3" water pipe with gate valves. The electroliers were not part of the contract, but the drawings illustrated the square and tall concrete bases on which they would sit.4 3 Bakewell & Brown, John A. Bauer, Frank G. White, and Harry E.
Squire, City and County of San Francisco, Board of Park Commissioners, Plans for the Improvement of the Aquatic Park by the Construction of a Recreation Pier, August Sheets 1, 2, 3, and 4, all in HDC 555 (SAFR Museum Plans Collection, San Francisco Maritime National Historical Park (hereafter cited as 4 Punnett, Parez & Hutchison-Civil Engineers, Plan of Concrete Parapet, Curb and Seat to be Constructed on Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, Board of Park Commissioners, City and County of San Francisco, August 29, in HDC 555 (SAFR Museum Plans Collection, AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 5) b.
Changes and additions: Various repairs have been made to the pier as the result of vessel damage and to protect the structure from scouring in the and Additional information is in the Historical Context section below. B. Historical Context: Design and Construction of Aquatic Park Pier On March 28, Congress approved An Act to authorize the board of park commissioners of the city and county of San Francisco to construct a recreation pier at the foot of Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco, California. This allowed the Secretary of War to grant a permit to the San Francisco Board of Park Commissioners to build, maintain, and operate a pier at the foot of Van Ness Avenue as part of the Aquatic Park. The proposed location, however, was in Fort Mason and already occupied by a U.S.
Army Quartermaster wharf. As a result, the permit to construct the new civilian recreational pier stipulated the relocation of the Army wharf to a suitable nearby location at no cost to the U.S. government. The permit also required that dredging be done evenly and without leaving behind piles of material or creating ridges and that the construction activity not hinder navigation. Finally, the replacement Army wharf had to be completed on or before December 31, The City and County of San Francisco s Board of Supervisors awarded the contract to remove the ca. Army wharf and build the replacement recreational pier to McGowan at a cost of On June 22, the Board of Supervisors passed Resolution No. formally transferring the new wharf to the U.S.
government.5 Meanwhile, planning for the new recreational pier was underway. The Board of Park Commissioners unanimously approved the plans and specifications at a June 26, meeting. A year later, the construction of the first section of the pier (encompassing bents opened for bidding. The Board of Park Commissioners voted to reject those submitted by George Pollock Company, Clinton Construction Company, McGowan, Inc., A.W. Kitchen & Company, and Duncanson-Harrelson. The low bids submitted by Healy-Tibbitts Construction Company and Merritt-Chapman & Scott Corporation underwent further review by a select committee.
On July 7, the committee decided to award the project to Healy-Tibbitts, who had submitted the lowest bid at with the cost of building an additional eleven bents at each, reduced to for each bent constructed after that.6 With the contractor selected, the Board of Park Commissioners then reviewed the recommendations made by Frank G. White, who was serving as a consultant to the project. As noted earlier, new piers and wharves erected in the San Francisco Harbor were generally built under the direction of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners, but this one was not under that agency s purview. Instead, commissioners proposed providing a resident engineer experienced in 5 Journal of Proceedings, Board of Supervisors, City and County of San Francisco 26, no.
2 (San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, September 2, 60- 71. These minutes are available at the San Francisco Public Library or online at 6 Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, June 26, 26; July 6, 51; and July 7, 52. Merritt- Chapman & Scott s bid was for the first section and for each additional bent. AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 6) pier construction to supervise the project for $275/month. The board would also assist in interpreting plans and specifications, approving tests of materials, and preparing and certifying monthly payments to contractors.
White assured the Park Commissioners that he or Harry Squire (also from the Board of State Harbor Commissioners) would personally inspect the contractor s work as needed but at least once a week. This supervision would cost $200/month, not to exceed The Board of Park Commissioners unanimously decided to employ Frank White and Harry Squire plus a resident engineer as proposed. Evidence that a resident engineer was involved in the project is not apparent, but Squire and White did provide project oversight.7 Construction of the pier began with Healy-Tibbitts building the forms and casting the concrete jackets for the pilings in August The Fort Mason pier was removed from September to October, and work officially began on the pier on October 5 at am according to Frank White s daily notes.
By December of the of pier included in the contract had been completed, with the remainder in various stages of completion. The Board of Supervisors noted that as of December, 100 percent of the concrete jacket castings were completed, pile driving was underway, 32 percent of the wave baffle slabs were placed, and the reinforced concrete and steel for the decking were 33 percent and 31 percent complete respectively.8 Work continued through In February, White s daily reports indicated that typical work included setting the jackets and brace pilings, placing baffle slabs, pile driving, and touching up asphalt paint below the decking. He also recorded construction problems.
In March, for example, White noted that the grout used on the baffle slab installations, did not prove satisfactory until a form was placed at site of jackets, fitted to top of baffle slab and secured by spreaders between jackets. The next month he recorded that eleven baffle slabs from bents 78 to 67 had been placed over seven hours while the installation of eleven braces only took one hour. On April 16 at a.m., the contractor started pouring the concrete for bents to (fourteen in total) and finished at The deck, however, was not completed until that evening, which White noted was too large an area to pour in one day. Considerable trouble in getting satisfactory finish.
On June 7, the first section of the pier was finished, inspected, and accepted.9 On June 3, the board approved a resolution reading, in part, Whereas the Board of Park Commissioners of the City and County of San Francisco on the of July, did enter into a contract with the Healy- Tibbitts Construction Company for the construction of 600 feet more or less of the Recreation Pier at Aquatic Park, all in accordance with the plans, drawings and specifications as prepared by Bakewell & Brown and John A. Bauer, architects, and Frank G. White and Harry E.
Squire, Engineers, and whereas the provisions of this contract do permit the Park Commissioners to secure from the 7 Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, September 2, 8 Journal of Proceedings, Board of Supervisors, City and County of San Francisco 26, no. 26 (San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, 9 Folder: White, Frank G. Papers, Notebook Contents re: Aquatic Park, est. + Reports, in HDC 260 (SAFR State Board Harbor Commissioner Chief Frank G. White Records, AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 7) contractor the construction of additional bents on the continuation of this Pier, for the sum of per bent .
The resolution went on to authorize the Board of Park Commissioners to request another from the mayor to fund the pier s completion.10 On September 16, the city attorney affirmed the legality of the commissioners retaining Healy-Tibbitts for the construction of the additional bents at the original contracted price without re-advertising the contract. The commissioners then requested the city budget for construction, as well as for engineering, surveying, and inspection services and for hand labor. Frank G. White would continue supervising construction for a fee of $175/month for no more than seven months.11 The San Francisco civil engineering firm Punnett, Parez & Hutchison designed the reinforced- concrete parapet walls, curbs, and benches.
The Board of Park Commissioners advertised the construction contract in August and awarded it in October to Meyer Brothers, who had the lowest bid at (The other bidders included DeLuca & Son, Inc., Monson Brothers, Anderson & Ringrose, Eaton & Smith, Young & Horstmeyer, B.A. Hawkins & Company, The Fay Improvement Company, Amoroso & Sons, Healy-Tibbitts Construction Company, E.J. Treacy, Burr, Charles L. Harney, and Herman Lawson Company.) Once poured, the concrete specified as a mixture of cement, sand/fine aggregate, rock/coarse aggregate at a maximum size of and water was to be tamped into place using vibrators driven by compressed air. The steel reinforcing bars had to be structural grade, rolled from new billet stock, and galvanized after cutting.
The parapet walls were built using wood forms and once cured, the concrete would be rubbed with carborundum stone to remove imperfections. The bench seats would be Oregon pine, painted as close to the color of the concrete bench supports as possible.12 Just when the pier was almost complete, a Southern Pacific-Golden Gate Ferries Company ferry ran into it on January 7, The Board of Park Commissioners resolved to forward a damage report prepared by Punnett, Parez & Hutchison to the ferry company and request that they make the repairs.
The resolution to this situation is not known, but on March 15, Punnett, Parez & Hutchison presented a certificate of work completion from Meyer Brothers on the contracted parapets, curbs, and seats and authorized another for unspecified additional work.13 Due to public interest, San Francisco officials opened the pier in summer To facilitate access, some minor grading and resurfacing was undertaken at the pier s entrance. The Allied Rowing Club lobbied for an opening at the south end of the pier to provide row boat access but 10 Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, June 2, 44. 11 Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, September 22, and December 22, 94.
12 Specifications for Furnishing Materials and Construction, Concrete Parapet Walls, Concrete Curbs, and Concrete Seats on Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park at the Foot of Van Ness Avenue, City and County of San Francisco, in Folder: San Francisco Recreation and Park Department Specifications in HDC (SAFR San Francisco Recreation & Park Department Specifications Collection, See also, Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, August 22, 42, and October 5, 13 Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, January 18, 5, and March 15, 21. AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 8) this was found to be an orifice through which Bay refuse passed to collect in the quiescent waters of Aquatic Park or upon the sand beach on the southerly side. Thus, the opening was filled in with rock around this time.
Finally, the North Beach Promotion Association had requested the construction of a convenience station on the pier, but park commissioners demurred, citing a lack of funds and the absence of a sewage plan. However, San Francisco s Board of Supervisors passed Resolution No. in August to expend from the Emergency Fund to build a convenience station at the end of the pier. The minutes of the January 20, meeting of the board of park commissioners indicate that John Bakewell, Jr. had recommended the board accept the Works Progress Administration s plans for the convenience station (to be finished with a modernistic type of treatment ) and the board agreed.
This station remains unfinished to this day.14 In January the San Francisco Board of Supervisors enthusiastically announced that the pier had been thrown open to the use of the public and this modern, concrete structure is enjoyed daily by thousands of San Francisco fishermen. The Aquatic Park pier proved to be so popular with bass fishermen that San Francisco Park Commissioners decided to have sections treated with Konset, a cement finishing material, and to install water lines. In a newspaper reported on the pier s continued popularity, noting some days there were as many as fishermen. Presumably the heavy use contributed to the decision to prohibit the sale of bait on the pier.15 A U.S.
Army tug crashed into the pier in so the San Francisco District of the Corps of Engineers developed plans for repairs the following year. The plans revealed approximately of the parapet on the bay side of the pier from bents 76 to 64 and another 16' near bent 61 had to be removed and replaced. One piling was broken and four others were gone; the fenders at the end of the pier needed to be replaced as well. New beams were required on the outer edge of the pier between bents 75 and 66, and a new deck slab had to be poured in this area. The drawings noted replacement was to be in kind.
On June 23, the Army Corps awarded the contract to Duncanson-Harrelson Company.16 Punnett, Parez & Hutchison undertook a survey of the pier s pilings that involved numerous soundings, elevations, and an inspection by divers of all the piles that looked to be in danger after the soundings were made. The findings were troubling. Teredos (bivalve mollusks capable of burrowing into wood that are also known as shipworms) had damaged or destroyed a 14 Journal of Proceedings, Board of Supervisors, City and County of San Francisco 29, no. 1 (San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, July 23, quote from page 50; January 6, 9; and January 20, 20.
15 Quote from Journal of Proceedings, Board of Supervisors, City and County of San Francisco 30, no. 1 (San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, Minutes, Board of Park Commissioners, May 17, 33, and July 23, 50; Muni Pier is Popular with Anglers, July 30, in Folder: SF Parks: Aquatic Park (pre-1949), San Francisco History Center, San Francisco Public Library (hereafter cited as 16 San Francisco District, Corps of Engineers, War Department, Aquatic Park, Repairs to Recreation Pier, Plans, May 6, Sheet 1 of 3; Structural Details, May 6, Sheet 2 of 3; Electrical, April 30, Sheet 3 of 3, in HDC letter from E.
Elmore Hutchison of Punnett, Parez & Hutchison to Park Commission of the City and County of San Francisco, December 31, in Folder: Parks, Aquatic (pre- AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 9) significant number of pilings. Evidence of teredo damage was found from bents 78 to 48, while on the bay side from bents 83 to 37 and on the cove side from bents 83 to 63, teredos had damaged or eaten away the pilings. At bents 77 to 66, the bottom dropped off on the west side of the pier, perhaps as the result of sand dredging. To prevent scouring, and thus exposing the timber pilings within the concrete jackets, the engineers recommended placing riprap between bents 88 and 35 on the bay side and between bents 81 and 52 on the cove side. E.
Elmore Hutchison was so alarmed by the survey results that he warned the Park Commissioners, unless something is done immediately a sudden storm may cause a collapse of this portion of the pier. 17 Punnett, Parez & Hutchison also developed plans to address the failing pilings. The plan required driving 106 pilings to replace the seventy-seven that had failed. The new precast concrete pilings would be located at bents and in row A.
In rows B and C, new pilings would be installed at bents and in row D from bents and in row E from bents New beams would be placed between rows B and C from bents and The drawing notes specified driving eight test pilings to a bearing value of 50 tons first (while keeping accurate driving records ) from which the lengths of remainder of piles will be determined and ordered. The damaged pilings in row B, for example, were to be left in place and the new ones erected adjacent. Hangar rods would extend from the top of the new beam down through the baffle slab on the existing piling and then to the new one. Hutchison noted that the cost of removal and replacement of collapsed sections of pier would be three times as much as repairing the structure.
Despite those dire warnings and a appropriation, the repairs had still not been completed by December The pier consequently continued to be in great danger of collapse in case of a heavy sea storm. 18 On January 31, the Board of Supervisors appropriated from the Emergency Reserve Fund to supplement the earmarked for repairs when it became clear the work would cost more than the appropriated amount. The resolution noted the repairs were urgently needed due to the dangerous condition of the pier and fears that it would collapse. Ben C. Gerwick, Inc.
won the contract for the work, with Healy-Tibbitts Construction and Duncanson- Harrelson Company also submitting bids.19 17 Letter from Hutchison to Park Commissioners, December 31, Punnett, Parez & Hutchison, Consulting Engineers, Chart to Accompany Report, Recreation Pier, Aquatic Pier, San Francisco, California, September 30, HDC 555 letter from E. Elmore Hutchison to Board of Park Commissioners, September 3, in Folder: San Francisco Recreation and Park Department Specifications HDC Catalog SAFR 18 Quote from letter from Hutchison to Park Commissioners, December 31, Punnett, Parez & Hutchison and J.E.
Hayes, Associated Consulting Engineers, City and County of San Francisco, Board of Park Commissioners, Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, General Plan, November 18, Sheet 1; Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, Typical Plan and Section, November 18, Sheet 2; and Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, Details, November 18, Sheet 3, all in HDC 19 Letter from Hutchison to Park Commissioners, December 31, Resolution No. of the Park Commission of the City and County of San Francisco, adopted by the Park Commission at a meeting held January 12, in Folder: Parks, Aquatic, Journal of Proceedings, Board of Supervisors, City and County of San Francisco 44, no.
1 (San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 10) Additional repairs were required in after the Luckenbach Steamship Company vessel struck the pier on February 23. The company offered to fund the repairs and to reimburse the city the paid to Punnett, Parez & Hutchison and J.E. Hayes for preparation of plans and specifications.
The damage was confined to bents 67 and 66 with some cracking and shearing of the beams and pilings, plus 33' of the parapet, 23' of the curb, and some concrete decking.20 Later periodic repairs included placement of protective rock fill along the bay side of the pier from bents 100 to 20 and on the cove side from bents 100 to 50 in In addition, the existing concrete jackets at bents 45 to 40 would be cut off. The following year, an 85'-long broken stone groin was planned for the west side of the pier, extending from the shore. This groin was to be 3' wide at the top with a slope of 1 A survey of the pier found both environmental and vessel damage to the pier, manifested in spalling concrete and exposed steel reinforcement.
Although it is still currently open to the public (as of the pier requires a significant investment to address the severe deterioration and possibly even replacement. A citizen group called Save Aquatic Park Pier is working with the San Francisco Maritime National Park Association and the National Park Service to identify and procure funds to build a replacement pier.22 Overview of Pier Design and Construction in San Francisco The State of California has owned and operated the port of San Francisco since with port revenues and bonds supplying the necessary operating, maintenance, and construction funds.
The Board of State Harbor Commissioners, comprised of three commissioners appointed by the governor, managed the harbor facilities, which extended the length of the San Francisco Bay (aside from a stretch of shoreline at the Presidio and Fort Mason that was Federal land). In the early twentieth century, San Francisco Bay was described as practically an inland lake due to the narrow channel (called Golden Gate ) connecting it to the Pacific Ocean. The bay was also fed by several rivers, resulting in brackish waters. In low rainfall amounts coupled with the increasing diversion of water into the feeders for irrigation purposes and Golden Gate channel improvements resulted in larger amounts of salt water flowing into the bay.
The changing salinity of the harbor water was thought to be one reason for the spread of marine borers from the Golden Gate channel area, where they had previously been observed, deeper into the bay after 20 Journal of Proceedings, Board of Supervisors, City and County of San Francisco 48, no. 1 (San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, Punnett, Parez & Hutchison and J.E. Hayes, Associated Consulting Engineers, City and County of San Francisco, Board of Park Commissioners, Proposed Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, Plans & Details, August 3, Sheet 1, and Proposed Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, Details, August 3, Sheet 2, both in HDC 21 E. Elmore Hutchison and J.E.
Hayes, Associated Engineers, City and County of San Francisco, Board of Park Commissioners, Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, Plans and Details, September 4, Sheet 1 of 1, and E. Elmore Hutchison and J.E. Hayes, Associated Engineers, Construction of a Broken Stone Groin at Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, San Francisco, California, October 1, both in HDC 22 See accessed September 23 Thomas S. Williams, Concrete Wharf Supports in San Francisco Harbor, Professional Memoirs, Corps of Engineers, United States Army and Engineering Department at Large 9, no. 46 (July-August John AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 11) In the Board of State Harbor Commissioners completed plans for a $2-million harbor improvement project designed to increase capacity.
A January article noted there were forty-nine active piers providing a total berthing area of 15 miles and a 245-vessel capacity. Over an eight-year period, starting in twenty-six piers were built, ten piers were rebuilt, and linear feet of bulkhead wharves were erected. Yet, even with all this space every foot of wharfage along the waterfront is now occupied, and steps are being taken to hasten the completion of all work now under way, and to start on the new work, because, unless sufficient facilities are provided soon, the port may be swamped with commerce, the article stated.24 By there were forty-nine piers and terminals, fifteen passenger and automobile ferry slips, six car ferry slips, plus numerous small wharves available. San Francisco ranked second among U.S.
ports in terms of the value of commerce.25 This concerted building effort plus the conditions of the San Francisco Bay meant there was significant experimentation with concrete pier construction in the first part of the twentieth century.
There were three basic types of pier design seen in the United States during this time: the pile-platform pier type (consisting of timber, concrete, or a combination of concrete and metal pilings supporting a wood, steel, or concrete platform), the block-and-bridge pier type (concrete or masonry blocks or timber cribwork supporting a deck), or the solid pier type (earth or another material fill placed between retaining walls).26 As early as however, there was a recognition that conditions along the waterfront of San Francisco are such that piers and wharves require special design and involve much difficult construction.
27 At the turn of the twentieth century, the wharves and piers along the West Coast (including San Francisco) were generally built of wood, thanks to the availability of that resource. It soon became apparent, however, that destructive marine borers specifically teredo, limnoria, and xylotrya were present in West Coast waters generally and San Francisco specifically. Marine borers were insidious; these crustaceans or mollusks burrowed into untreated wood and then methodically ate it, making the structure unsafe. Teredos were particularly destructive because they created a pinhole-sized opening in the piling for entry and then proceeded to burrow into it so that the piling appeared to be structurally sound from the exterior.
The presence of xylotrya was noted in at Mare Island Navy Yard, and just three short years later, this genus was found in greater numbers and in other locations in San Francisco Bay. By limnoria and teredo were observed near the Golden Gate channel. Limnoria lignorum Rathke was particularly destructive, as the species had been observed to create as many as 200 to 240 burrows in just one square inch of wood. Dr. Charles Kofoid, a well-known zoologist and chair of the Zoology Department at the University of California-Berkeley, studied the marine borers in the bay around and reported that Teredo navalis Linnaeus was McCallum, Harbor Board Plans Enlargement of Port Facilities, San Francisco Chronicle, January 14, 15; Timber Piling in Water Infested by Marine Borers, The Engineer no.
(July 15, 57. 24 Charles W. Geiger, Harbor Improvements at San Francisco, International Marine Engineering 24, no. 1 (January 31. 25 Biennial Report of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners, Port of San Francisco, for the Fiscal Years Commencing July 1, and Ending June 30, (Sacramento: California State Printing Office, 7. 26 Carleton Greene, Wharves and Piers: Their Design, Construction, and Equipment 3d ed. (New York: McGraw- Hill Book Company, Inc., 27 An Improvement in Pier Construction, San Francisco, Engineering Record 16, no. 3 (July 16, 65. AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 12) present in brackish waters particularly near Mare Island.
Xylotrya setacea Tryon , the largest of the marine borers, was found along the San Francisco waterfront, including at Fort Mason (near where the Aquatic Pier would eventually be located).28 The research into marine borers and the performance of marine structures in the early twentieth century clearly revealed that untreated wood pilings or even those treated with just creosote had limited lifespans in San Francisco waters. Therefore, various treatments were developed to extend the life of wood pilings that typically involved some kind of heavy paint of a bituminous, asphaltic, or similar nature, combined with burlap, felt, roofing paper, wire mesh, wood battens, or other material.
These treatments included the Keywest Armor process developed in for a Fremont Street wharf in which the wood piling was coated in bituminous paint, wrapped in canvas, recoated in bituminous paint, and then covered with coral sand. A similar treatment, called the Paraffine paint method, utilized patented products from San Francisco s Paraffine Paint Company. The so-called P&B Paint was applied to the piling, then P&B Pile Covering was wrapped around it and attached with galvanized nails. Next the covering was coated with P&B Asphalt and redwood battens were embedded in it.
Finally, another coat of the patented asphalt was applied.29 The Board of State Harbor Commissioners began recommending the use of concrete in pier construction whenever possible, and by the turn of the twentieth century, experimentation with the use of reinforced concrete in marine structures was underway. As noted in a article in Engineering Record, the natural conditions at San Francisco are best met by the construction of the open pier all in concrete, substructure and superstructure.
30 Early concrete structures in the San Francisco Harbor were car-ferry slips for the Belt Railroad a sea wall and wharf at the Ferry Building the Pacific Street Pier and the Folsom Street Pier Harry Squire, the assistant harbor engineer with the Board of State Harbor Commissioners, reported that from to there was tremendous expansion in the concrete industry as reinforced concrete was being introduced and exploited as a panacea for structural problems.
31 There were two general types of concrete supports used in marine construction at this time, the striking difference between the two of them being that the cylinders are put in as wet concrete fresh from the mixer and allowed to set in position inside a wooden frame, whereas the pilings are manufactured on shore, thoroughly seasoned by being allowed to set at least thirty days and frequently as long as sixty days, and then are driven into position by a pile-driver or steam hammer.32 28 Ralph Barker, Cement and Concrete for Protecting Piles in Sea Water, Cement X, no. 12 (April Report on the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Survey, prepared under the supervision of the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Committee of the American Wood-Preserver s Association, rev. ed.
(published by the committee, San Francisco, California, August The Marine Borer: Some New Light, Pacific Marine Review 19, no. 8 (August American Wharf Design, Engineering Record 70, no. 14 (October 3, 29 Report on the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Survey, Timber Piling in Waters, 57. 30 American Wharf Design, 31 Harry E. Squire, Thirty-Five Years of Sea-Water Exposed Concrete on the San Francisco Waterfront, World Ports 15, no. 11 (September 32 Williams, AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 13) Various techniques had also been developed starting in the late nineteenth century to essentially envelope timber pilings in concrete. These cylinder-type pilings required driving a wood piling to refusal and then placing a cylindrical form of wood staves around it.
Concrete was then poured into the form and allowed to set. Problems with this type of piling included vessel propellers or other forces stirring up the bottom and exposing the timber below the concrete, which provided opportunities for borers to attack the piling and cause failure. Standing water in the form could prevent concrete from properly setting as well. As a result, the construction method was further refined. Wood pilings were driven 8' below the dredging line but only extended 5' into the form, which consisted of a cylindrical steel shell or caisson surrounding the piling and driven into the bottom. Any water or mud was pumped out of the bottom of the caisson or shell before a second form of steel-reinforced wood was placed inside it.
Finally, the concrete was poured into the inner form and tamped. Once it had set, the outermost shell or caisson was pulled out. A similar process patented by Howard C. Holmes utilized a form whose bottom flared like a bell to help keep out the mud and water. This process was used to build San Francisco piers 7, 9, 21, 23, 25, and 27 from to The Koetitz piling, patented by Frederick A. Koetitz in was used at pier 17 in This involved placing a precast reinforced-concrete cylinder over a piling and filling the space between the piling and cylinder with sand or grout. Pre-molded concrete pilings, on the other hand, were poured on shore and allowed to cure before being driven into place by pile drivers.
This type of piling was not often used cost being a significant factor but San Francisco was reportedly among the pioneers in its use. 33 Pre-cast concrete pilings reinforced with steel rods were utilized at piers 3, 29, 31, 33, and 35 in San Francisco, dating from to Therefore, the first decades of the twentieth century saw experimentation with piling construction, both in terms of methods and in materials. Pier 54, built in with reinforced- concrete girders and beams, was the first completely reinforced-concrete pier built by the Board of State Harbor Commissioners. Yet the adoption of concrete marine structures by the commissioners was slow due to the high cost of construction and the failures of early concrete experiments.
The board continued specifying the use of creosoted timber pilings in those structures built in soft ground while concrete pilings were used at those sites with hard ground.35 While all this structural experimentation with concrete was taking place, the American Wood- Preservers Association appointed a committee to study the situation with marine borers in San Francisco Bay in At the same time, the Forest Products Laboratory of the U.S. Forest Service in Madison, Wisconsin, was embarking upon a study of marine pilings in the United 33 Williams, 34 Williams, Practice and Experience of State Harbor Commissioners, San Francisco, with Concrete Wharf Supports, Engineering and Contracting LXVII, no.
13 (March 28, Report on San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Survey, The San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Survey, Second Annual Progress Report, prepared under the supervision of the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Committee of the American Wood- Preserver s Association (published by the committee, San Francisco, California, January 15, 42; New Concrete Piers at San Francisco, The Marine Review 40, no. 7 (July 35 Squire, AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 14) States.
The two projects were joined and worked cooperatively as the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Survey.36 The purpose of the ambitious survey was to: Determine the extent of the damage from marine borers in the San Francisco Bay, especially that of excessive severity which has occurred within the last three years in the northern portion of the bay; to determine the present distribution of the several marine borers and as much of their past history in the bay as it was possible to learn; to increase the present knowledge of the dissemination, growth, and habits of the borers; to study the factors influencing the rate of attack and amount of damage from them, including the effect of climate and river discharge upon the salinity conditions in the bay; to throw more light upon the effectiveness, both in physical life and economic advantage, of the various methods of protecting wooden piling, and of the substitutes for it, together with the best methods of construction which have been developed; and to collect data on the relative cost of the different methods of protection and construction.37 Their work helped inform the Board of State Harbor Commissioners design and development of San Francisco s marine structures in fact, Frank G.
White was a member of the survey team. By the time the Municipal Pier at the Aquatic Park was built starting in methods of building concrete marine structures had been well established. What is less well-known, however, is how common the use of the wave baffle panel was in pier construction. A review of the engineering literature did not reveal other contemporary West Coast piers that utilized these baffle panels. The inclusion of this element in the Municipal Pier appears to have been an innovative solution to the site. Since the cove was developed for recreational purposes, calm water was necessary. Thus, the wave baffle panels on the pier s pilings served as a breakwater for the rougher waters of the bay while also allowing fresh water to flow in and out of the cove. PART II.
The open, reinforced-concrete Municipal Pier curves to the north around the west side of the cove at Aquatic Park and has a bulbous terminus. The pier is approximately 1,400'-long and wide. The pier s substructure features pilings with precast wave baffle panels that serve as a breakwater and help reduce the sediment washing into the cove. Thus, the pier helped create a calm lagoon for swimming and served as a barrier to the rougher waters of the bay and to the boat traffic. The pier s substructure is comprised of 116 bents, each made up of five vertical pilings (there are nearly 634 timber pilings enclosed in reinforced-concrete jackets) and two battered pilings. The timber is 16" in diameter but the concrete jacket makes the pilings 22" square.
The baffle panels are inserted into the pilings that have a wider central section. The battered pilings and diagonal 36 The first members of the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Committee consisted of representatives from Federal agencies and private companies operating on the Bay or with an interest in the problem (like creosote companies), engineers, Dr. Charles Kofoid of the University of California-Berkeley, T. G. Townsend of the Forest Products Laboratory, and Frank G. White of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners. 37 Report on the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Survey, 7. AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 15) braces help resist the forces on the pier.
The longitudinal reinforced-concrete deck beams are spaced apart 12' on center and support the 7"-thick reinforced-concrete slab. Near the entrance to the pier on the cove side at bents is an opening in the parapet wall with a metal plate and hinge that once supported a no-longer extant floating dock system. A metal fence was installed prior to at the pier s entrance and along the west side for safety reasons due to the pier s deteriorated condition. The tall concrete parapet walls with indented panels lining the pier feature squared openings along the bottom at regular intervals for drainage. Electrical conduits were part of the parapet walls and supply power to the street lights located on the tops of the walls.
These lights are comprised of concrete posts with a pebble finish and bronze and glass globes. They stand tall. Concrete curbs line the roadway to separate vehicles (which are now prohibited from operating on the pier) from pedestrians; they also contain water pipes with occasional valve fixtures. The sidewalks flanking the roadway are slightly elevated and openings are located at regular intervals under the sidewalks to promote drainage. Concrete benches measuring just over tall face the water. A concrete convenience/concession stand echoing the Streamline Moderne style used elsewhere in the park was intended to be located at the end of the pier but this was never fully realized.
The unfinished circular building sits on a low, stepped platform and has two recessed bands near the top for a decorative finish and a section intended to have glass block infill. The rough concrete surface was meant to be parged like the other structures in the park but was not realized. The interior features a circular chamber in the floor that protrudes under the deck of the pier; its intended purpose is not known.
The flat roof has a circular roof structure comprised of a rusted metal framework and a four-tier concrete roof.38 38 Winzler & Kelly, Structural Condition Assessment and Repair Alternatives Study of Municipal Pier at Aquatic Park, Draft Final Report, January 12, fieldwork conducted by Heritage Documentation Programs staff in AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 16) PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION Primary: Drawings, HDC 555 (SAFR Museum Plans Collection, San Francisco Maritime National Historical Park. Bakewell & Brown, John A. Bauer, Frank G. White, and Harry E. Squire. City and County of San Francisco, Board of Park Commissioners. Plans for the Improvement of the Aquatic Park by the Construction of a Recreation Pier. August 4 sheets. E. Elmore Hutchison and J.E.
Hayes, Associated Engineers. Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, Plans and Details. September 4, Construction of a Broken Stone Groin at Recreational Pier, Aquatic Park, San Francisco, California. October 1, Punnett, Parez & Hutchison-Civil Engineers. Plan of Concrete Parapet, Curb and Seat to Be Constructed on Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park. Board of Park Commissioners, City and County of San Francisco. August 29, Chart to Accompany Report, Recreation Pier, Aquatic Pier. September 30, Punnett, Parez & Hutchison and J.E. Hayes, Associated Consulting Engineers, City and County of San Francisco, Board of Park Commissioners. Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, General Plan ; Typical Plan and Section ; Details. November 18, 3 sheets.
Proposed Repairs to Recreation Pier, Aquatic Park, Plans & Details ; Details. August 3, 2 sheets. San Francisco District, Corps of Engineers, War Department. Aquatic Park, Repairs to Recreational Pier, Plans ; Structural Details ; Electrical. May 6, Sheets 1, 2, 3. Folders, San Francisco Maritime National Historical Park. HDC 260 (SAFR State Board Harbor Commission Chief Engineer Frank G. White Records. HDC (SAFR San Francisco Recreation & Park Department Specification Records. Folders: San Francisco History Center, San Francisco Public Library. Folder: Parks: Aquatic Park (pre-1949). AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 17) Folder: Parks: San Francisco Maritime National Historical Park. American Wharf Design. Engineering Record 70, no. 14 (October 3, Barker, Ralph.
Cement and Concrete for Protecting Piles in Sea Water. Cement X, no. 12 (April Biennial Report of the Board of State Harbor Commissioners, Port of San Francisco, for the Fiscal Years Commencing July 1, and Ending June 30, Sacramento, CA: California State Printing Office, Geiger, Charles. Harbor Improvements at San Francisco. International Marine Engineering 24, no. 1 (January Greene, Carleton. Wharves and Piers: Their Design, Construction, and Equipment 3d ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., Journal of Proceedings, Board of Supervisors, City and County of San Francisco 26, no. 2. San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, 29, no. 1. San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, 30, no. 1.
San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, 44, no. 1. San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, 48, no. 1. San Francisco: The Recorder Printing and Publishing Company, The Marine Borer: Some New Light. Pacific Marine Review 19, no. 8 (August McCallum, John. Harbor Board Plans Enlargement of Port Facilities. San Francisco Chronicle, January 14, 15. Minutes, San Francisco Board of Park Commissioners, various dates. Available at the San Francisco Public Library or online at New Concrete Piers at San Francisco. The Marine Review 40 no. 7 (July Practice and Experience of State Harbor Commissioners, San Francisco, with Concrete Wharf Supports. Engineering and Contracting LXVII, no.
13 (March 28, Report on the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Survey, prepared under the supervision of the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Committee of the American Wood-Preserver s Association. rev. ed. Published by the Committee, San Francisco, California, August AQUATIC PARK, MUNICIPAL PIER HALS CA-113-A (Page 18) Second Annual Progress Report, prepared under the supervision of the San Francisco Bay Marine Piling Committee of the American Wood-Preserver s Association. Published by the Committee, San Francisco, California, January 15, Squire, Harry E. Thirty-Five Years of Sea-Water Exposed Concrete on the San Francisco Waterfront. World Ports 15, no. 11 (September Timber Piling in Water Infested by Marine Borers. The Engineer no. (July 15, Williams, Thomas S.
Concrete Wharf Supports in San Francisco Harbor. Professional Memoirs, Corps of Engineers, United States Army and Engineering Department at Large 9, no. 46 (July-August Secondary: Cultural Landscape Report, Aquatic Park, San Francisco Maritime National Historical Park. Oakland, CA: National Park Service, Pacific West Region, Winzler & Kelly. Structural Condition Assessment and Repair Alternatives Study of Municipal Pier at Aquatic Park. Draft Final Report, January 12,