The City of Los Angeles (City), in partnership with the State of California Department of Transportation (Caltrans), will widen and seismically retrofit the First Street Viaduct over Glendale Boulevard. The retrofit includes foundation strengthening, column base strengthening, column strengthening, and hinge and FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 2) bent cap modifications. The bridge deck will be widened by 2-6 on each side using cantilevers. Physical features including decorative railings and street light poles will be salvaged and reincorporated into the rehabilitated bridge.
The west end approach will be realigned and reconstructed to eliminate an existing dip where the roadway meets the structure. HAER documentation was prepared for the First Street Viaduct over Glendale Boulevard prior to the seismic retrofit and rehabilitation. The bridge is owned by the City of Los Angeles but the project is funded in part through the Federal Highway Administration s Highway Bridge Program. Written Historical and Descriptive Data prepared by Amanda Duane, Associate Architectural Historian with GPA Consulting. HAER photography was completed by Stephen Schafer. FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 3) PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: 1.
Date of Construction: An initial phase of construction for the First Street Viaduct Over Glendale Boulevard (First Over Glendale Viaduct) began in By the reinforced concrete foundations were completed; however, the City of Los Angeles (City) was unable to secure the remaining funds needed to finish the project, and construction was placed on hold. The foundations were buried and the street was repaved. In after revising the plans and receiving sufficient financing, construction on the viaduct resumed. The bridge was built in phases and completed in in It was opened to traffic in October of that year.1 2. Engineers: The viaduct was designed by the City Bureau of Engineering under the supervision of Deputy City Engineer, Merrill Butler. 3. Builder: Works Progress Administration (WPA). 4.
Original Plans and Construction: The first set of plans for the First Over Glendale Viaduct were completed in The original plans called for a long steel structure with a 202 long steel-tied arch main span. The fully steel design was chosen so that the bridge beams and trusses could be constructed offsite then put into place in order to avoid major traffic disruptions at such a complicated intersection.2 Improvements to 2nd Street were already underway, so the City constructed reinforced concrete foundations as a part of these improvements in Unfortunately, full funding for the remainder of the steel bridge could not be secured and the project was put on hold.
The foundations were buried and 2nd Street was paved over them.3 In the WPA tentatively approved funding for the project and the City began accepting bids for the design; however, the increased demand for 1 JRP Historical Consulting, Historical Resources Evaluation Report: Beverly Boulevard Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation Structure prepared for the City of Los Angeles Department of Public Works Bureau of Engineering and California Department of Transportation, District 7, October 12. 2 Ibid. 3 Ibid. FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No.
CA-2343 (Page 4) steel during wartime preparations made the first design prohibitively expensive and a new design was required.4 The new design was for a continuous concrete girder structure that was 562 long, including abutments. The design had a 202 main span consisting of a 104 suspended concrete tee beam span resting on cantilevered box girders. The new plan was approved. Funding was provided by the federal government and augmented with additional money from the State Highway Department and Pacific Electric Railway.5 5. Alterations and Additions: The viaduct has not undergone any major changes. Minor alterations include replacement cobrahead lanterns affixed to historic posts, a repaved roadway surface, and a non-original mural under the east approach. B.
Historical Context: The Bureau of Engineering, the Municipal Arts Commission, and the City Beautiful Movement The first iteration of the Los Angeles Bureau of Engineering and the Department of Public Works was formed in following the first city election. Newly- elected officials formed the Common Council, which in turn appointed fifteen committees. These fifteen committees were each given a responsibility, such as water and irrigation, garbage disposal and street cleaning, sanitation, and public works. These responsibilities would later become a function of the Board of Public Works,6 which was appointed in by the Common Council.
This new board had about twenty members that handled the various aspects of public works and supervised two new department heads that were appointed by the mayor: the Street Superintendent and the City Surveyor. The responsibilities, duties, title, and elective status of the City Surveyor sometimes called City Engineer varied greatly throughout the and The position was even abolished for a short period, but then quickly reinstated.7 It was not until the Board of Public Works was reorganized by a charter that it began to resemble the current administration. Similarly, the Bureau of Engineering was reorganized in 4 Ibid. 5 Ibid.
6 Patricia Adler-Ingram, Public Works, in The Development of Los Angeles City Government: An Institutional History (Los Angeles: Los Angeles City Historical Society), 7 Adler-Ingram, 8 Matthew W. Roth, Los Angeles Transportation, in The Development of Los Angeles City Government: An Institutional History (Los Angeles: Los Angeles City Historical Society), FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 5) The Municipal Arts Commission was formed in and consisted of five commissioners, appointed by the mayor, to work for the gradual elimination of ugliness from the conspicuous parts of our city.
9 In order to carry out their goals, the Commission hired Charles Mulford Robinson, a landscape architect, to create a city plan for Los Angeles in Robinson would eventually write twenty-five such plans throughout the United States, and was a major proponent of the City Beautiful Movement.10 The City Beautiful Movement was an urban design philosophy spawned in response to the increasing chaos and disorder in industrializing urban centers, especially on the east coast. Civic improvements such as parks, boulevards, gardens and monumental civic centers were seen as symbols of a humane society that might bring some order and tranquility to newly industrialized cities.
These ideas were popularized at fairs such as the World s Columbian Exposition in Chicago.11 Robinson s city plan, titled Los Angeles: The City Beautiful was published in The report included suggestions for a new city hall, transit hub (Union Station), and bridges. He stressed that structures, especially bridges, could be both functional and aesthetically pleasing in their design and advocated the use of concrete arches in place of trestle bridges: The bridges are about as ugly as they can be. As these are replaced, handsome structures should be substituted. The concrete arch now makes practicable a bridge that is beautiful at no more cost than the ugly iron type of the railroad bridge.
12 Homer Hamlin, City Engineer between and wrote an addendum to Robinson s report titled, Bridge Construction in the City of Los Angeles that affirmed the Bureau of Engineering s revision of bridge construction policy to reflect the City Beautiful ideals: The earlier policy was to consider first cost alone and to construct the cheapest and narrowest bridge that would serve the purpose. Then a few steel structures were erected across the river of the truss or the girder type, which are inherently unsightly.
It is now the policy of the Board of Public Works to recommend cheap wooden bridges only in the outlying districts and occasionally for more important crossings where a temporary bridge can serve purposes until funds are available for a more permanent 9 JRP Historical Consulting, City of Los Angeles Monumental Bridges Historic Context and Evaluation Guide, prepared for State of California Department of Transportation, May 8. 10 Ibid., 9. 11 Paul Gleye, The Architecture of Los Angeles (Los Angeles: Rosebud Books, 12 JRP Historical Consulting, City of Los Angeles Monumental Bridges, 9. FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No.
CA-2343 (Page 6) structure The aesthetic side is taken care of by adopting the arch form and by special treatments of the concrete surfaces.13 Following the publication of Los Angeles: The City Beautiful, the city charter was amended in to give the Municipal Art Commission authority to approve the design for public buildings and infrastructure including bridges, approaches, fences, retaining walls, lamps and lamp posts. The charter was amended so that no design could be finalized without the prior approval of the Commission. Two of the first reinforced concrete bridges in Los Angeles were the Main Street Bridge and the Buena Vista Street Bridge (now the Broadway Bridge), completed in and respectively.
Following Robinson s City Beautiful advice, the bridges were executed in Beaux Arts style reinforced concrete. The Buena Vista Street Bridge was hailed by contemporaries as a masterpiece.14 While the Municipal Art Commission had a great deal of influence on public projects through World War II, their responsibilities and focus began to shift for a combination of reasons. New and different state and federal agencies began to head transportation projects, over which the city commission had no authority. References to design aesthetics slowly disappeared from Bureau of Engineering articles and official documents, despite postwar funding being plentiful for public works projects.
Instead, the Municipal Arts Commission turned their attention to promoting art and cultural programs for the City.15 As the ties between the Commission and the Bureau came to an end, so did a distinct golden age of the Los Angeles River Bridges. The Los Angeles Bureau of Engineering was responsible for some of the best work accomplished by California engineers, and the Municipal Arts Commission would go on to be nationally recognized for their collaborative role.16 Bridge Building in Los Angeles In the early twentieth century, the population of Los Angeles was rapidly increasing.
The growth of railroad, industry, and transportation infrastructure kept pace with the population boom until there were at least sixteen water crossings along the Los Angeles River, varying from earthen causeways to the previously mentioned and unsightly wood and iron trestle bridges. The combination of an unpredictable river and a sharp decline in undeveloped land created a perfect storm of flood danger: the less undeveloped land, the less run-off water that could 13 Ibid. 14 Portia Lee, Andrew Johnston, and Elizabeth Watson, Los Angeles River Bridges, HAER No. CA-271, Historic American Engineering Record (HAER), National Park Service, Department of the Interior, 10. 15 Ibid., 16 JRP Historical Consulting, City of Los Angeles Monumental Bridges, 13, 25.
FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 7) be absorbed in a heavy storm.17 In heavy winter rains, the Los Angeles River would swell and flood, often changing course and sweeping increasingly larger debris mud, rocks, trees, animals, even dwellings into its path as it raced down the San Gabriel Mountains. When enough of this debris gathered, it would swamp and destroy the earth and wooden bridges, halting travel and causing millions of dollars in damage and repair costs to properties along the riverbank.
Residents and businesses rallied public support for better and stronger all-weather bridges.18 The public also united against another dangerous side effect of the rapid population increase: massive traffic congestion. A tangled network of freight trains, passenger trains, automobiles, trolleys and even horse-drawn carriages created congestion that was unprecedented at that time in Los Angeles, and perhaps even the United States.
The primary issue was discovered to be between trains and cars: automobile traffic was delayed for nearly 15 percent of the day as trains crossed.19 Both public and private interests agreed upon the need for a system of bridges and grade separations that would help prevent accidents and reduce traffic delays.20 In order to address the problem, the Los Angeles Traffic Commission was formed. Comprised of a number of civic and public organizations, the commission got to work on a series of traffic studies. Meanwhile, the City Council proposed a bond measure to fund bridge construction on the ballot. The formal Major Traffic Street Plan was released in and between and voters approved bond measures of million to construct twelve new bridges.
By this time, the Bureau of Engineering had grown to over employees, compared to just 200 at the turn of the century.21 The Municipal Arts Commission actively participated in design approval for new projects. At its height in the Commission approved a total of plans with a valuation of In the Bureau of Engineering Annual Report, it states that the design intent for the bridges was to excite comment from visitors who enter and leave the city, and raise the status of Los Angeles as an enterprising, properly developed city. 23 With these ideas in mind, the last of the bond measure bridges, the Sixth Street Bridge, was dedicated in 17 Lee, et.al., 7. 18 Ibid. 19 Stephen D.
Mikesell, The Los Angeles River Bridges: A Study in the Bridge as a Civic Monument, Southern California Quarterly 68 (Winter 20 Lee et.al., 13. 21 Roth, 22 JRP Historical Consulting, City of Los Angeles Monumental Bridges, 12. 23 Ibid. 24 Lee, et.al., New Viaduct Dedicated, Los Angeles Times, June 17, A1. FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 8) The bridge building program, however, was far from complete. In the City of Los Angeles Bureau of Engineer s Annual Report it read: In spite of the very large volume of bridge construction work done since there are still many bridges and grade separations required to complete the highway system of the city.
There are now ten bridges and grade separations which have been planned or are being planned for early construction. These are all new structures required to complete major highway improvements or to better existing conditions at busy intersections. It is therefore anticipated that the work of the division in renewing structures or constructing new bridges will continue as rapidly as work can be financed. Among the unfinished bridges was the First Over Glendale Viaduct. Planning for the viaduct began as early as as residential, commercial and light industrial development in the area increased, and the need for a connection between Downtown Los Angeles and the areas northwest of Bunker Hill became more apparent.
Property owners suggested a series of improvements including a tunnel through Bunker Hill at First or Second streets, street widening to accommodate additional automobile and electric railway lines, as well as a viaduct to allow First Street to safely travel over Glendale Boulevard.25 In the City began to move forward with a two-part plan to create a tunnel through Bunker Hill at Second St.
and transform Beverly Boulevard into a major thoroughfare between downtown and Beverly Hills.26 However, the tunnel was delayed for several years as the City navigated the lengthy legal process to approve the projects while World War I put a strain on available resources.27 Excavation for the Second Street Tunnel finally began in and the project was completed in Shortly after, the City completed paving Beverly Boulevard in The newly paved Beverly Boulevard traveled west to Beverly Hills from its starting point at Glendale Boulevard, and would be informally dedicated as a major traffic artery in In the meantime, the intersection of First and Second streets and Glendale Boulevard was becoming more dangerous than ever as a result of continued development in the area, an increase in traffic between downtown and northwest 25 JRP Historical Consulting, Beverly Boulevard Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation Structure 26 Ibid., 11.
27 Ibid.; Ready for Record Tunnel Job, Los Angeles Times, November 7, II1. 28 Huge Bites by Shovel Mark Start on Tunnel, Los Angeles Times, April 12, II1. 29 Beverly s Link to Sea Dedicated, Los Angeles Times, January 6, B7. FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 9) Los Angeles, and a new Pacific Electric Railway tunnel that emerged just south of the already complicated intersection.30 In the City decided to move forward with the construction of a grade crossing at First Street and Glendale Boulevard.
Plans for the viaduct were completed in The viaduct was to be of steel construction that could be manufactured off site and assembled quickly in order to minimize the disruption of traffic.31 The City was able to get a head start on the construction on the viaduct s foundations in as part of ongoing improvements to Second Street; however, full funding to complete the bridge was never secured, and in the midst of the Great Depression, funding was difficult to come by. The City was forced to put the project on hold indefinitely. The completed foundations were buried and Second Street was repaved.32 Works Progress Administration (Works Projects Administration) In response to the national economic crisis during the Great Depression, President Franklin D. Roosevelt enacted the New Deal.
The New Deal was a series of federal programs put in place to promote economic recovery and job creation while helping to effect civic improvement.33 One of the largest of the New Deal programs was the Works Progress Administration (WPA). President Roosevelt created the WPA in May of by signing Executive Order No. The WPA hired people directly, creating millions of jobs between and While most WPA projects involved building or improving public infrastructure, such as bridges, roads, airports, schools, other efforts included music, theater and visual arts projects, as well as research, writing, and even the manufacture of clothing. In certain federal agencies were reorganized.
At this time, the WPA was renamed the Works Projects Administration, and was placed under the purview of the newly formed Federal Works Agency.34 Construction for the First Over Glendale Viaduct was still on hold until the WPA tentatively approved funding for the project in With this approval in place, the City began receiving bids and preparing a contract to finish building the design; however, as the bids came in, the proposed costs were much higher than initial estimates. Steel was in high demand as the United States prepared for World War II, driving up costs and monopolizing the available supply. In order to reduce costs, the Bureau of Engineering had to revise the design of the steel structure.
The resulting redesign for the viaduct combined the use of reinforced 30 JRP Historical Consulting, Beverly Boulevard Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation Structure 11. 31 Ibid., 12. 32 Ibid. 33 What Was the New Deal? The Living New Deal, accessed July 12, 34 Works Progress Administration (WPA), The Living New Deal, accessed July 12, FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No.
CA-2343 (Page 10) concrete box girders and tee beams and incorporated the foundations that were completed in Construction began on the grade separation structure in with an anticipated completion date of however, after the United States entered World War II following the attack on Pearl Harbor, there was an acute labor shortage as able-bodied men enlisted in the war effort. Construction was delayed, and city workers were called upon to augment the dwindling construction crew. Following its completion, the bridge was dedicated in October In the WPA was dissolved as many previously unemployed workers found wartime jobs at the onset of World War II.
During its 8-year span, thousands of civic improvements were made possible by the WPA, including over miles of roadway improvements, new or improved parks, and miles of new water lines.37 With the help of federal funds, a second albeit smaller- scale period of bridge construction occurred in Los Angeles between and Along with the First Over Glendale Viaduct, a number of other Los Angeles bridges were completed under various New Deal agencies, including the Sunset and Glendale Viaduct Federal Public Works), the Figueroa Street Viaduct Bureau of Public Roads), the Riverside Drive Bridge PWA), the Temple Street Bridge PWA), and the Aliso Street Bridge WPA).38 Reinforced Concrete Bridge Construction, Art Deco and Streamline Moderne While concrete alone has been used in construction for centuries, the first use of reinforced concrete in building was in Europe in the late Reinforced concrete is concrete strengthened at its core with steel bars: the bars bond to the concrete and provide tensile strength.
Concrete is strong under compression, while steel is strong under tension. The two materials react similarly to temperature changes, and combining them together creates a versatile building material suited to a wide variety of projects.39 By the the technology had reached the United States. In the early days, it was typically used for large residences or warehouses.40 Engineers in Europe pioneered the use of reinforced concrete in bridges, namely Robert Maillart. Maillart s understanding of the 35 JRP Historical Consulting, Beverly Boulevard Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation Structure 12. 36 Ibid.,12-13.
37 Works Progress Administration (WPA), The Living New Deal, accessed July 12, 38 New Deal Projects by State and City: Los Angeles, The Living New Deal, accessed January 22, 39 Lee, et.al., 26. 40 Stephen D. Mikesell, Historic Highway Bridges of California (Sacramento: California Department of Transportation, 71. FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 11) medium of reinforced concrete and the designs he created with it paved the way for bridges in Los Angeles, and for the bridge engineering field as a whole.41 The first reinforced concrete bridge in the United States, the Alvord Lake Bridge, was constructed in in San Francisco and designed by E.L. Ransome.
As such, California introduced reinforced concrete bridges to the rest of the United States, and continued to be at the forefront of the technology.42 Concrete bridge construction was more economically feasible in California and the West Coast than the rest of the country, due to the high cost of steel. High quality cement, on the other hand, was plentiful, readily available, and allowed for a wider variety of bridge building due to its ability to take on smooth and curving shapes.43 Four major types of concrete bridge construction developed: closed spandrel, open spandrel, concrete girder, and concrete slab. A closed spandrel bridge consists of a solid form of rigid material the arch with vertical side walls, or spandrel walls.
The empty space between the arch and the spandrel is filled, typically with dirt, and the bridge deck tops the dirt. The earliest reinforced concrete bridge, the previously mentioned Alford Lake Bridge, is a closed spandrel bridge. In California, closed spandrel bridges were primarily constructed prior to World War I.44 The second type of bridge, the open spandrel bridge, consists of the arch and spandrel walls being constructed as individual members and joined together at critical junctures. The arch typically consists of arch rings tied together with horizontal struts and connected to the bridge deck by vertical columns.
The earliest open spandrel bridge is the previously mentioned Buena Vista (or Broadway) Street Bridge in Los Angeles, completed in In California, this type of bridge was constructed up until World War II; very few were constructed after the war.45 The third type of bridge, the concrete slab, consists of a monolithic slab of concrete that spans the abutments while serving as both the deck and structural member of the bridge. While this type was typically limited to very short crossings, advances in prestressed concrete have increased the spans possible for a concrete slab bridge.46 41 Lee, et.al., 42 Mikesell, Historic Highway Bridges, 71. 43 Ibid., 71. 44 Ibid., 45 Ibid. 46 Ibid.
FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 12) The fourth type of bridge, the concrete girder bridge, consists of large, horizontal members (or girders) that span from abutment to abutment beneath the bridge deck.
This type is especially suitable for short crossings.47 Concrete tee beam girder bridges were a common alternative to concrete arch designs as the latter became more expensive to build during the and The concrete girder bridge is likely the most common type constructed in California, with the first constructed as early as Though the technology has evolved over time, girder bridges are still built today.49 One variation of the concrete girder bridge is the concrete box girder bridge, which was utilized for the First Over Glendale Viaduct. The technology was developed during the by a French engineer named Eugene Freyssinet. Box girders are created by enclosing the bottom of a tee beam girder to create a hollow, rectilinear form.
Box girders were easier to construct, required less materials and labor, and were able to resist more torsion than their tee beam counterparts. The earliest known examples were constructed in Europe, but the technology was used in the United States and California by the The earliest known example, the Soquel Creek Bridge in Capitola, California, was constructed in Box girder bridge construction would not become commonplace until after World War II. There are only forty-two known examples constructed prior to including the First Over Glendale Viaduct. After the war, concrete box girder bridges became the most common type of bridge constructed in California. Today, there are more than examples.50 Concrete bridge construction also allows for greater variation in style.
Many of the earlier reinforced concrete Los Angeles bridges were executed in the popular and ornate Beaux Arts or Period Revival Styles; however, during the late and early there was an overall aesthetic shift to more modern styles. This new stylistic movement would later come to be known as Art Deco after the Exposition Internationale des Arts Decoratifs et Industriels Modernes of Paris in Art Deco was especially prominent in Los Angeles. The style employed geometric forms, stylized sculptural elements, and modern building materials such as polychrome terra cotta.52 The style is characterized by its zigzag decorative features, smooth stucco surfaces, geometric ornament, and an emphasis on verticality.
Art Deco detailing often incorporated imagery of new technology and conveyed a sense of movement; this feeling of movement, and a general 47 Ibid. 48 JRP Historical Consulting, City of Los Angeles Monumental Bridges, 20. 49 Mikesell, Historic Highway Bridges, 50 Jessica B. Feldman, Myra L. Frank & Associates, Caltrans Historic Bridges Inventory Update: Concrete Box Girder Bridges, rev. April 51 Art Deco: The Paris Exhibition, The Victoria and Albert Museum, accessed July 16, 52 Gleye FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 13) fascination with modern new technology and transportation was concentrated and amplified into the Streamline Moderne style.
These sleek and aerodynamic designs were applied to everything from automobiles to toaster ovens in the and architecture and bridge design were no exception.
The Streamline Moderne style is characterized by its unornamented surfaces, curved corners, and emphasis on horizontality through sweeping, aerodynamic lines.53 The geometric decoration of the First Over Glendale Viaduct, including octagonal piers, diamond-shaped pier caps, beveled lamppost bases and railing posts, pyramidal-capped newel posts, and geometric pilasters, is reminiscent of the Art Deco and Streamline Moderne styles; however, the viaduct s overall simplicity, smooth surfaces, and visible structure are more indicative of the growing influence of International Style Modernism, which would go on to dominate postwar bridge design in Los Angeles.
As such, the design of the viaduct represents an important aesthetic shift in bridge design in Los Angeles.54 Merrill Butler Merrill Butler was born in in Gouverneur, New York. His family moved to Los Angeles in After attending Los Angeles Polytechnic High School, Butler found work in as a draftsman with the Los Angeles Railway Company. During this time, he continued his education through correspondence courses in math and civil engineering at the University of Wisconsin.55 Butler was first employed by the City of Los Angeles as a draftsman in the City s Bridge Division starting in November he was promoted to Assistant Engineer by and worked directly on bridge plans and designs. After the start of World War I, Butler was granted a Reserve Commission as First Lieutenant Engineering Officer.
Following training, he went to France with the Engineers Regiment of the Division of the American Expeditionary Force, receiving a service ribbon and four battle stars before being discharged as a Captain.56 After the war and a stint in the Arizona State Highway Department, he returned to Los Angeles in and was promoted to Structural Engineer. In this new 53 Gleye 54 JRP Historical Consulting, Beverly Boulevard Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation Structure 55 Biography of Merrill Butler, Engineer of Design, Bureau of Engineering Department of Public Works, City of Los Angeles, Retiring on October 31, Butler, Merrill, California Bibliography File, Municipal Reference Collection, Los Angeles Public Library, accessed January 21, 56 Ibid.
FIRST STREET VIADUCT OVER GLENDALE BOULEVARD (Beverly Boulevard over Glendale Boulevard Grade Separation) (Bridge No. HAER No. CA-2343 (Page 14) position, he oversaw the designs for the Ninth and Macy Street Bridges over the Los Angeles River.57 In the Bridge and Structural Design Division of the Bureau of Engineering was reinstated after having been temporarily dissolved during World War I. At this time, Butler was named head of this division and given the title of Bridge and Viaduct Engineer. He would remain in this position until Among the number of projects he supervised as Bridge and Viaduct Engineer are the First, Fourth, Sixth, Seventh, Spring, and Washington Street Bridges, as well as the Glendale Hyperion Bridge.
He also oversaw the design for the Anaheim Street Viaduct, the Figueroa Street Tunnels, and the Sepulveda Boulevard Tunnel.59 In he took the position of Deputy City Engineer (Design) where he would remain until his retirement in As Deputy City Engineer (Design), he was responsible for overseeing all the design work for all divisions of the Bureau of Engineering including the Bridge and Structural, Sewer, Storm Drain, and Street and Freeway divisions.60 It is doubtful that Butler was singlehandedly responsible for the design of each of the bridges and viaducts mentioned above, nor for the First Over Glendale bridge.
Rather, the designs are a significant and important reflection of the combined efforts of a group of individuals in the Bureau of Engineering; however, Butler is worth distinguishing both for the length of time he spent as an engineer for the City of Los Angeles, and for the fact that he would have had added influence in his supervisory role.61