This document was prepared by Jenna Snow, Kathryn McGee, and Leslie Heumann for the property owner Sapphire Equity, CTA Buildings No. 1 and No. 2 were evaluated in an Environmental Impact Report, certified by the City of Los Angeles in February which found CTA Building No. 1 eligible for listing in the California Register of Historical Resources and as a City of Los Angeles Historic Cultural Monument. Due to alterations, the Environmental Impact Report did not find CTA Building No. 1 eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places. The Environmental Impact Report studied impacts of a development that involves demolition of both buildings. In view of that, when the City of Los Angeles certified CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No.
CA-2960 (page 2) the Environmental Impact Report, mitigation documentation was required to lessen historical resources impacts. Alan White of Aqyer prepared measured drawings detailing the prime architectural features and visible structural elements. The set includes the north, south, and east elevations, in addition to the first floor and fifth oor plans for a total of nine (5) drawings. Stephen Schafer of Schaf Photo produced the photographic documentation, consisting of eighteen views of the context, facades, character defining features and interiors with large format 4x5 inch film and 18 archival color digital views. Schaf Photo also created the photo index, key-maps and digital print cards. Part I. Historical Information A. Physical History 1.
Date of erection: A permit for construction of West 6th Street was issued in 1 and a certificate of occupancy was issued in 2 2. Architect: The firm of Kistner, Wright and Wright consisted of architects Theodore Charles Kistner 3 Henry Lyman Wright 4 and engineer William Theodore Wright 5 As described in detail below, the firm was founded by Kistner in and grew into Kistner, Wright and Wright by The firm initially maintained an office in downtown Los Angeles, moving into the CTA Building No. 1 following its completion.
Kistner retired from the firm in and passed away in San Diego County in Wright and Wright continued to practice at the building until the firm ceased operation in the mid- It is estimated that the firm, from its founding by Kistner in until it ceased operation, designed over schools in Southern California, as well as numerous other public and private buildings. Firm founder and senior partner Kistner, graduated from the School of Architecture at the University of Illinois in and practiced architecture in his home state, prior to moving to San Diego for his health in He established a specialty in school design early in his career; the Oceanside Union High School was one of his earlier commissions. In Kistner was awarded a prize by the state Department of Education for best example 1 W.
6th Street, Application to Construct New Building and for Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit Jan 13, 2 W. 6th Street, Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit and December 17, 3 Theodore C. Kistner, United States Federal Census, Census Place: San Gabriel, Los Angeles, California; Roll: m- Page: 1A; Enumeration District: Ancestry.com. Theodore Charles Kistner, U.S., Find a Grave Index, 1600s-Current, Ancestry.com. 4 Henry Lyman Wright, National Archives at St. Louis; St. Louis, Missouri; WWII Draft Registration Cards for California, Record Group: Records of the Selective Service System, Box: Ancestry.com.
Henry Lyman Wright appears to have died in in Oregon but historical records regarding his death are unclear. ( Henry Lyman Wright, Oregon State Library; Oregon Death Indexes, Reel Title: State of Oregon Death Index; Year Range: Ancestry.com.) 5 William Wright, U.S. Social Security Death Index, Ancestry.com. CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No. CA-2960 (page 3) of a four-room schoolhouse 6 and became the consulting architect of the San Diego School District. He had at least 18 schools to his credit, spread from southern California to Arizona, by in addition to other public buildings, such as the Chula Vista Library and Anaheim City Hall (with M.
Eugene Durfee, 7 His pre-war designs reflected the popular styles of the period, ranging from Mission Revival (Riverview Union High School in the Lakeview School District, to Spanish Colonial Revival (Brea Grammar School, to Moderne (Leuzinger High School in the Centinela Valley School district, and San Juan Capistrano High School, Kistner opened an office in Los Angeles in and he built his own house in San Marino in Oak Knoll). His office boy and subsequently junior draftsman in the Los Angeles office was Henry L. Wright. Wright attended school while working for Kistner, first the University of California Los Angeles and then the University of Southern California Upon matriculation, Wright became chief draftsman and office manager in Los Angeles.
In Kistner entered into a partnership with Robert Rice Curtis, leaving Curtis in charge of the San Diego office. The firm was active in the rebuilding of schools that followed the Long Beach Earthquake and subsequent passage of the Field Act, hiring structural engineer and brother of H. L. Wright, William T. Wright, to assist. W. T. Wright became a full partner in the firm Kistner, Curtis and Wright in The firm developed another specialty, providing designs for improvements at several military installations, including navy buildings in San Diego and marine bases at El Toro, El Centro, Santa Barbara, Mojave, and Nyland. 8 By the time Kistner, Curtis and Wright was disbanded in to be replaced with Kistner, Wright and Wright, with H. L.
Wright also a full partner, the firm could claim it had completed over 540 projects for 70 school districts between and and averaged 280 employees. 9 Kistner, Wright and Wright continued to be active designers of schools, military facilities, and other public and private buildings throughout the and including the CTA Retired Teachers Home Cerritos College for which it won an A.I.A. award of excellence; the American President Lines Passenger Terminal (joint venture with architect Ed Fickett, published in the August issue of Arts and Architecture and also awarded by the A.I.A. in the Norwalk county building and the library at Cal Poly Pomona Additionally, the firm served as consulting architect to school districts in San Bernardino, Ventura, and Riverside.
10 Several of the firm s school designs were published in various architectural journals. Both Kistner and H. L. Wright were members of the American Institute of Architects, Wright having achieved F.A.I.A. status by Wright also served as national president of the A.I.A. in and represented the A.I.A. on several national panels. Brother 6 Bruce, William George, The American School Board Journal, Vol. XLVII, No. 3, September 23, 7 California Index listings, Los Angeles Public Library, www.lapl.org. 8 White, Laura S. et al. Historic Building Assessment for the Cerritos College Facilities Master Plan, March 9 Ibid. 10 American Institute of Architects, A.I.A. Historical Directory of American Architects, and CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No.
CA-2960 (page 4) William similarly was a fellow of the American Society of Civil Engineers. Kistner retired from the firm in and passed away in San Diego County in Wright and Wright continued to practice at the CTA Building No. 1 until the firm ceased operation in the mid- 3. Original and subsequent owners: CTA Building No. 1 was constructed for and occupied by the Southern Section of the California Teachers Association, which maintained ownership until the Subsequent owners include the following: 11 Churchill Group Sixth Street Association Keith Lord YWCA of LA Kensei Co., Inc. Tek-Tan, Inc. 6th Street Properties Inc.
Miguel and Nila Zanabers John Saliba Sixth Street Capital Investors TC Bixel LLC Sapphire Equity LLC California Teachers Association (CTA)12 The CTA, an education lobbying group, was founded in as the California Educational Society by the fourth state Superintendent of Public Instruction, San Francisco schoolteacher John Swett. Initially the group was small, with less than 100 members, and distracted by the Civil War. But by their role as the voice for universal public education in the state and for the rights of students and teachers had become a force in the state. After several years, the group foundered, and was re-organized at the turn-of-the century as the CTA.
In the group incorporated and made a deliberate effort to bring in regional associations as sections, or chapters, from around the state; formerly, the group had a marked northern California identity. Over their 153-year existence, the CTA has advocated for numerous causes, including professional standards, status, and certification for teachers; reduced class sizes; equal access to public education for all, regardless of location, ethnicity, disability, or first language; establishment of the community college system; collective bargaining and other rights of teachers; and adequate public funding for education. While the CTA was the primary occupant of CTA Building No.
1 until the late other professional enterprises shared the building, including the building s architects, Kistner, Wright and Wright. In recent decades, various medical concerns have been the primary tenant, including the Kidney Center of Los Angeles. Additionally, a large amount of office space has been occupied for the last approximately twenty years by United American Indian 11 As neither a chain of title nor County of Los Angeles Assessor Deeds Books were available, a history of recent ownership was extrapolated from building permits. 12 California Teachers Association, organization website, www.cta.org. CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No.
CA-2960 (page 5) Involvement, Inc., a private, non-profit organization offering a wide array of health and human services to the native American community. 4. Contractor: CTA Building No. 1 was constructed by contracting company Myers Brothers Construction Company. Established around in Los Angeles, by the time founder Ray A. Myers died in the company had become one of the largest contractors in the United States. 13 5. Original plans and construction: In it was announced that the Southern Section of the CTA would build a new headquarters building at West 6th Street, to be designed by Kistner, Wright and Wright and with an estimated cost of 14 Presumably membership in the CTA had surged as a result of the post-war population boom, necessitating expanded and centralized facilities.
The advantages of the site were its location one-half mile from Pershing Square, easy access to all freeways, and abundant parking. Facilities in the new building would include an auditorium, conference and committee rooms, and specialized spaces for research, development, public relations, counselling, placement, insurance, welfare, and credit union services of the organization. 15 It was envisioned that CTA and its affiliates would utilize the first two floors and that the upper three floors would be leased. Building permits for the five-story, 75-foot-high new building were pulled on January 13, with Kistner, Wright and Wright identified as architects and engineers and Myers Bros. as the contractor.
Ground-breaking ceremonies were held on January 15, with the participation of leaders of education, the California Congress of Parents and Teachers, city officials and others. 16 The design of the new building was described in the newspaper account of the event as contemporary. 17 Dedication ceremonies were held in April for the facility, whose final cost was reported to be 18 A certificate of occupancy, which cited the assembly room with a capacity of 550 and the banquet room with room for 62 occupants, was issued on December 17, 6. Alterations and additions: In a decade after CTA Building No. 1 opened, more space for the CTA was needed. Construction began on an adjacent parking garage in July and on the adjacent office building (CTA Building No.
2) at 6th Street in A tunnel was made connecting CTA Building No. 1 with the new office building, including new doors in the basements of both buildings. 19 The two buildings were also connected at the exterior by a courtyard. Over the years, numerous modifications to CTA Building No. 1 have been made. From under the ownership of the CTA and Teachers Insurance Co, multiple building permits were issued for non-bearing partition walls and suspended ceilings. 20 Subsequent 13 Funeral Monday for Ray Myers, Highland Park News Herald and Journal, March 13, 8. 14 Plans for Teachers Group Building Set, Los Angeles Times, May 23, F1. 15 Plans for Teachers Group Building Set, Los Angeles Times, 23 May F1. 16 Start of New Structure Scheduled, Los Angeles Times, 16 January 17 Ibid.
18 Dedication Set for Structure, Los Angeles Times, 15 April 19 W. 6th St, Application to Alter-Repair-Demolish and for Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit December 20, 20 Various permits were issued for this work. Permit was issued for new metal stud and drywall partitions and new light fixtures ( W. 6th St, Application to Alter-Repair-Demolish and for Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit March 13, CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No. CA-2960 (page 6) owners also made numerous changes to interior spaces for tenant improvements over ensuing decades. An earthquake-damaged post was repaired following the Northridge Earthquake.
21 Additional repairs were made in totaling to replace broken windows, replace damaged doors, replace roof-level flooring, and replace the rear stairway and service equipment, as well as repair exterior siding and termite damage. 22 In worth of work was completed to add new windows at the front of the building with a 3 6 wide architectural projection above. 23 In a tenant improvement was made at suites 101 and 102 with new partition walls and ceiling. 24 The building was reroofed for in 25 The ground floor, including lobby space, has been reconfigured for the current use as a medical clinic. B. Historical Context: L.A.
Modernism, The modern movement in architecture emerged in Europe in the early twentieth century and was brought to Los Angeles by European emigres, most prominently Richard Neutra and Rudolf Schindler. Los Angeles proved to be fertile ground for the movement, which deliberately turned its back on historicism and embraced modern technologies, materials, and lifestyles. In a seminal exhibit at the Museum of Modern Art in New York claimed modern architecture to have become The International Style.
Although more traditional styles in architecture continued to dominate in Los Angeles until mid-century, after World War II, Modernism proliferated, particularly with respect to certain building types, including office buildings and skyscrapers, schools, civic buildings, and a large percentage of commercial buildings. Several distinct styles are contained within the umbrella of post-World War II modernism, including Late Modernism, which proliferated from until about1980. Charles Jenks, in his book on the subject simply titled Late-Modern Architecture, defines Late Modernism as tak[ing] the ideas and forms of the Modern Movement to an extreme, exaggerating the structure and technological image of the building in its attempt to provide amusement, or aesthetic pleasure.
26 The style is contrasted with the simple forms of Moderism, as well as historical reference of Post-Modernism. Alexandra Lang, in her essay on why Late Modern architecture is worthy of more critical attention, notes that Late Modernism is a style without theory, practiced by architects who were trying to build their way out of the diminishing returns of Miesian copies. 27 Kazys Varnelis, making a case for Late Modernism in Los Angeles, writes that even though Late Modernism worked to give 21 W. 6th St, Application to Add-Alter-Repair-Demolish and for Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit April 11, 22 W.
6th St, Application for Building Permit and Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit April 30, 23 W. 6th St, Application for Building Permit and Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit July 8, 24 W. 6th St, Application for Building Permit and Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit June 26, 25 W. 6th St, Application for Building Permit and Certificate of Occupancy, City of Los Angeles, Department of Building and Safety, Permit June 14, 26 Charles Jenks, Late-Modern Architecture, (New York: Rizzoli, 8. 27 Alexandra Lange, What is Late Modernism? Curbed, January 5, CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No.
CA-2960 (page 7) physical form to big business and big government the style became prevalent throughout southern California during this era, one in which the Southern California landscape was reshaped more thoroughly than during any previous or subsequent decades. 28 Late Modern architecture was popularly, though by no means exclusively, used in large-scale commercial and civic buildings. The style displayed many different forms, both focused on structure and glass skins as well as sculptural forms, which were described in an exhibit at the Museum of Modern Art in entitled, Transformations in modern architecture. Little scholarly attention has been paid to the style, specifically its southern California varieties, and most has focused on large, corporate office buildings.
However, the style was commonly used for smaller buildings. Unlike many Late Modern corporate high-rise buildings that feature a glass curtain wall of mirror skin, 29 the style is also characterized by a focus on massing and creating interplay between solids and voids. Part II. Architectural Information A. General statement 1. Architectural character: CTA Building No. 1 is designed in the Late Modern style as exemplified by the following features: flat roof, concrete and glass exterior walls, contrast of sold walls and window voids, strong horizontality, fenestration pattern with ribbon windows, canopy with broad fascia over the ground floor, ground-level columns suggestive of pilotis, unadorned surfaces, and elevated, recessed main entry. 2.
Condition of fabric: The condition of the building fabric is good as the building has been maintained for ongoing use for general and medical office tenants. B. Description of Exterior: CTA Building No. 1 was the first building constructed as part of a complex of two office buildings, including West 6th Street, and a parking garage at West 5th Street, built as the headquarters of the Southern Section of the CTA. The two office buildings are on adjacent parcels, located between Bixel Street on the east and Lucas Avenue on the west. Oriented south, the buildings are separated by a shared open courtyard elevated a few steps above street level and extending from 6th Street to an alley to the north. CTA Building No. 1 is a five-story, flat-roofed, concrete office building.
The rectangular footprint of the building is varied by a one-story projection extending from the southwest corner eastwards to the main building entry located at the approximate center of the south (primary) facade. The overall design has a strong horizontal emphasis resulting from the fenestration. At the primary, south fa ade, ribbons of continuous, metal-framed windows are set flush with the exterior walls and outlined by slightly projecting surround. This pattern is repeated on the 28 Kazys Varnelis, Embracing Late Modern, L.A.
Forum, issue 7, 29 As described in the oft-used textbook for college classes on a survey of architectural history, the Late Modern style is depicted as A cool, mirror-glass building of the is as forbidding, antisocial, and hostile as a person wearing mirror sunglasses. Ask it what it is or where to enter; and it tells you that the sky is blue and that you are on the sidewalk. (Marvin Trachtrenberg and Isabelle Hyman, Architecture: From Prehistory to Post-Modern/The Western Tradition (The Netherlands: Harry N. Abrams, CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No. CA-2960 (page 8) second through fifth floors on the south facade.
At the first floor, a flat canopy with a broad, angled fascia is supported by a series of stout, freestanding columns, stretching eastward from the entry to wrap the southeast corner of the building, and shading the full-height windows. Elevated several steps above ground level, the entry vestibule features a curved east wall. Two pairs of metal-framed glass doors are topped by transoms and flanked by full-height windows. The southwest projecting wing has been altered; the fenestration has been modified and a tiled mosaic has replaced an original relief by artist Jay Rivkin. The north elevation of the building is characterized by bands of windows, set flush with the exterior and unframed, on the second through fifth floors.
The windows are bisected by a broad, concrete panel that rises the full height of the building. The windows wrap the corners onto the side elevations, terminated by solid panels situated midway to the southeast and southwest corners of the building. Inverted L-shaped supports that taper towards the ground and a row of columns carry a canopy that shades the first floor of the north elevation. A mechanical penthouse is visible above the northwest corner. 1. Overall dimensions: The building is 201 x 84 , with the longer facade parallel to West 6th Street. It is five stories tall. 2. Foundations: The foundation is concrete. 3. Walls: Exterior walls are composed of concrete and glass. 4. Structural system framing: Steel frame. 5. Porches, stoops, balconies, porticoes, bulkheads: None. 6.
Chimneys: None. 7. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: At the south fa ade, two pairs of metal-framed glass doors are topped by transoms and flanked by full-height windows. At the north elevation, the entrance is covered by a canopy supported by inverted L-shaped columns that taper towards the ground. b. Windows and shutters: The south fa ade is defined by ribbons of metal-framed windows at upper floors. At the first floor, full-height windows are shaded by a canopy. The north elevation also includes ribbons of windows that wrap the corners onto the side elevations, terminated by solid panels situated midway to the southeast and southwest corners of the building. 8. Roof: a. Shape, covering: The roof is flat with a parapet. b. Cornice, eaves: None. c. Dormers, cupolas, towers: None.
CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No. CA-2960 (page 9) C. Description of Interior 1. Floor plans: The first-floor interior has a lobby featuring a curved wall and a row of columns; however, non-original partition walls and finishes obscure the original design. Interiors of the upper stories are characterized by double-loaded corridors flanked by offices. Most finishes appear to be non-original. 2. Stairways: The building has two staircases. The main staircase, featuring a half-turn stair, is located on the north side of the corridor, adjacent to two elevators toward the west side of the corridor. The unadorned staircase has concrete steps and a simple pipe rail. The secondary stair is located on the south side of the main corridor toward the east side of the building. 3.
Flooring: Flooring is generally contemporary with a combination of linoleum, artificial wood, and carpeting. 4. Wall and ceiling finish: Walls have smooth painted finishes. Ceilings have a combination of smooth painted finishes and suspended acoustical tile. At the ground floor, floors and 5. Openings: There are no significant interior openings. 6. Decorative features and trim: None. 7. Hardware: No notable hardware. 8. Mechanical equipment: a. Heating, air conditioning, ventilation: The building has a modern HVAC system. b. Lighting: Lighting consists of contemporary, ceiling-mounted florescent fixtures. c. Plumbing: The building has functional plumbing. d. Original furnishings: There are no notable furnishings. D. Site 1.
Historic landscape design: There is no significant historic landscape design. Existing landscaping is limited to a planting strip along the north fa ade with a couple of mature trees and low plantings; a strip of mature planted trees along the north elevation; and a grouping of potted trees along the east elevation (in the courtyard between buildings). 2. Outbuildings: There are no outbuildings. CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No. CA-2960 (page 10) Part III. Sources of Information Primary Sources American Institute of Architects, A.I.A. Historical Directory of American Architects, and Bruce, William George, The American School Board Journal, Vol. XLVII, No.
3, September 23, Biographical records (United States Census, birth records, death records, military records), Ancestry.com. Building permits, various, City of Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety, available online, California Index listings, Los Angeles Public Library, www.lapl.org. California Teachers Association, organization website, www.cta.org. Dedication Set for Structure, Los Angeles Times, April 15, Plans for Teachers Group Building Set, Los Angeles Times, May 23, F1. Start of New Structure Scheduled, Los Angeles Times, January 16, Secondary Sources Heumann, Leslie, Historic Resources Technical Report, Sapphire Project, and West 6th Street, West 5th Street, Los Angeles, July 12, White, Laura S., et al.
Historic Building Assessment for the Cerritos College Facilities Master Plan, March CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No. CA-2960 (page 11) Site Map CTA Building No. 1 circled blue CALIFORNIA TEACHERS ASSOCIATION BUILDING NO. 1 HABS No. CA-2960 (page 12) CTA Building No. 1 outlined in blue N Source: Los Angeles County Assessor,