Heroes Grove and Gold Star Mothers Memorial Boulder, in Golden Gate Park, together embody the distinctive characteristics of a post-World War I heroes grove in America, and represent the work of master gardener1 John McLaren, in collaboration with the community, especially the Gold Star Mothers,2 of San Francisco. Description: There are no signs announcing the entrances to Heroes Grove in Golden Gate Park. Most people pass by the grove on their way to nearby museums and gardens without realizing its significance. Those who venture into the grove find a quiet space under tall trees, punctuated by a boulder and a depression. Topography The depression, which occupies the northwest quadrant of the roughly 8-acre site, resembles a lop-sided bowl. The north rim of the bowl is the highest.
The southwest and southeast quadrants slope down to the south rim of the bowl. The northeast quadrant slopes down to the base of the bowl.3 A May 19, photograph of McLaren overlooking the undeveloped site, from somewhere near its northwest corner, shows him at the edge of a wide, deep area filled with brush and Pinus (Pine) trees. McLaren s designs were naturalistic; it is difficult to say where nature s topography ends and McLaren s grading begins.4 Boundaries When McLaren selected the site in it was surrounded by streets: city Fulton Street to the north, park Main Drive to the south, and connecting streets 1 McLaren eschewed the titles landscape architect and landscape designer in favor of head gardener. [Girvan Aikman, 2 See the History section for the definition of Gold Star Mother.
3 Site acreage estimated by the historian using Google Earth Pro and AutoCAD. 4 Picking a Site for Memorial to Hero Dead, Examiner, 19 May Girvan Aikman, 45. GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO. CA-49-B PAGE 2 Park Presidio Drive and Avenue to the west and east, respectively.5 After Park Presidio Drive was re-routed, the Rose Garden was dedicated in its place in Main Drive was re-named John F.
Kennedy Drive in Tenth Avenue became an underground parking garage driveway in Circulation McLaren drew one circulation route on his May 19, site plan sketch: a wide path curving from the southeast corner, down to the south rim of the depression, around the rim, and then up to the northwest corner.7 Today, that route is an unpaved road for maintenance vehicles, as well as a public path. There are also several narrower unpaved pedestrian paths and desire footpaths from the site perimeter to the maintenance road. Climate and Soil The grove is about 2.4 miles east of the Pacific Ocean.
The environment is challenging to plants, due to ocean winds, sandy soil, summer fog, little rain May through September, and occasional year-round drought.8 Trees The canopy trees in the interior are almost entirely Sequoia sempervirens (Coast Redwood) planted in a naturalistic pattern. The other species are several Pinus radiata (Monterey Pine) along the southeast edge of the depression, one Calocedrus decurrens (Incense Cedar) in the depression, a few (invasive non- native) Eucalyptus globulus (Blue Gum) in the southeast quadrant, and a cluster of (deciduous) Ulmus (Elm) in the northeast corner. The interior is almost devoid of understory trees, except for (invasive non-native) Pittosporum undulatum (Victorian Box) in the northeast quadrant and under the Monterey Pine.
The canopy trees at the perimeter are Hesperocyparis macrocarpa (Monterey Cypress), Monterey Pine, Blue Gum, and Coast Redwood. The understory trees on the south perimeter are a diverse collection of conifers and one deciduous conifer. McLaren enjoyed horticultural diversity and may have specified some of the understory conifers. The deciduous conifer was not introduced to the U.S. until after McLaren s death.9 The base of the depression had some adult Pine trees in May photographs.
From aerial photographs, they appear to have remained until sometime between 5 Indorses Site for Heroes Grove, Examiner, 19 May 6 All Chronicle: Rose Garden Dedicated in the Park, 9 Jan People's Day in the Park: Cars Banned, Drive Renamed, 3 Apr Controversial Garage for Museum Opens, 14 Oct 7 Indorses Site for Heroes Grove, Examiner, 19 May 8 Ehrlich, 17. 9 McClintock, The deciduous conifer is Metasequoia glyptostroboides (Dawn Redwood). GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO. CA-49-B PAGE 3 and Today, there are eight young (5 ' to 15 ' high) Coast Redwood trees in their place. Coast Redwood trees are wind-sensitive. Monterey Cypress trees have been planted as windbreaks since the early days of the park.
Monterey Pine and Blue Gum were also planted in the early days. A forestry plan is in place for replacing aging trees of those three species: Monterey Cypress with the same, Monterey Pine with Pinus species less susceptible to a lethal fungal disease, and Blue Gum with less invasive Eucalyptus species.11 Design Development When the San Francisco Examiner (Examiner) newspaper, on May 17, suggested that a heroes grove a memorial grove with one tree per hero be dedicated in Golden Gate Park on Memorial Day to San Francisco s war dead, McLaren quickly selected a site and proposed a concept.
His initial concept, as described in the Examiner on May 19, was for a meadow of native grasses in a clearing, surrounded by native ferns and native rhododendron under a multi- variety grove of native forest trees, with one variety12 per hero. In the meantime, letters of support poured into the Examiner, at least one of which said the living memorial must be evergreen.13 By the afternoon of May 19, McLaren had been appointed chairman of, and authorized to choose citizens for, a special Heroes Grove committee. He chose forty-four citizens, from a wide range of organizations, including Gold Star Mother Leah H. Davis.14 By Memorial Day (May the design had evolved into a mono-species grove of (native, long-lived, evergreen) Coast Redwood.
The Examiner reported that to people attended the dedication. McLaren cradled a young Coast Redwood tree throughout the ceremony, and placed the first spadeful of (well-amended) soil in its planting hole. No further trees could be planted, the master of ceremonies reported, until to was approved for copious amounts of loam, to be mixed into the sandy soil.15 10 Wakelee; U.S.G.S., Aerial Imagery. 11 McLaren, Gardening in California, Ehrlich; McClintock, 76, 89, The fungal disease is pine pitch canker disease. 12 Botanists classify plants by genus, then species, then variety.
(There are classification levels above and below those, but they are not relevant here.) 13 All Examiner Heroes Grove Suggested by The Examiner, 30 May [reprint of 17 May suggestion]; Picking a Site for Memorial to Hero Dead and Indorses Project for Heroes' Grove, 19 May; J. B. Holohan, letter to the editor, in City is United for Heroes Grove, 20 May. 14 Memorial Committee Named, Examiner, 20 May 15 All Examiner, 31 May First Tree is Set in Grove, Glen Filled with Throng of Patriots, Examiner Lauded for Grove Idea. GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO. CA-49-B PAGE 4 In Davis and other mothers pleaded with the Supervisors, and McLaren with the Park Commissioners, for funding to complete Heroes Grove.
McLaren said that the Coast Redwood would outlast stone monuments. The Park Commissioners recommended funding but the Supervisors declined due to insufficient funds.16 News coverage of Heroes Grove then went dormant in the San Francisco Chronicle (Chronicle) newspaper. McLaren s adult son, and only child, died suddenly in and his wife in McLaren fell gravely ill in early but recovered.17 In the Native Sons & Daughters of the Golden West and the Ladies of the Grand Republic each requested small (39 and 50 trees, respectively) memorial groves in Golden Gate Park. Both requests were granted, with the former dedicated on November 6 and the latter on November 27.
The Gold Star Mothers cried out they had been waiting longer and asked the Supervisors for to complete Heroes Grove.18 Beginning in it is difficult to track funding in the government records, because Heroes Grove was used to refer to both the Gold Star Mothers Heroes Grove and the Native Son s Grove of Memory, a heroes grove located on the opposite side of Park Presidio Drive. It appears that was approved for the original Heroes Grove.
When the Gold Star Mothers re-dedicated their grove on the tenth anniversary of Armistice Day, they announced that 615 trees had been planted.19 Davis thanked McLaren during the Gold Star Mothers pilgrimage to Heroes Grove on Armistice Day, On November 20, the Gold Star Mothers announced that the McGilvray-Raymond Granite Company would donate a memorial boulder of California granite,20 and that the Gold Star Mothers would hold fundraisers to pay for the inscription of all the names.21 16 All Board of Supervisors, 7 Feb; Gold Star Mothers Urge Tree Planting, Chronicle, 8 Feb; Native Redwood Memorials Urged, Chronicle, 12 Feb; Heavy Demand Made for Coin in New Budget, Chronicle, 28 Apr. 17 Girvan Aikman, John M Laren Much Better.
Chronicle, 18 Mar 18 All Board of Supervisors, 6 Jun, 19 Sep, 31 Oct, 28 Nov; Board of Park Commissioners, 26 Jun, 14 Jul, 20 Oct; Memory Grove Dedicated to Native Sons Killed in War, Chronicle, 7 Nov; Memorial Grove Dedicated Today, Chronicle, 27 Nov. 19 All Board of Supervisors, 21 May; Bay Region Begins 3-Day Celebration of Tenth Anniversary of Armistice Day, Chronicle, 11 Nov. 20 In the Chronicle reported that the boulder was McGilvray-Raymond silver gray granite. [ Star Mothers Will Dedicate Shaft to Dead, Chronicle, 13 Nov If that is accurate, then it was from San Diego County. [Basin Research.] See the History section for the history of the McGilvray family. 21 All Chronicle, Gold Star Pilgrimage, 10 Nov.
Tree Planted in Grove by Star Mothers, 11 Nov; Boulder for Vets Graves, 20 Nov; Gold Star Mothers to Give Benefit Card Party, 15 Dec. The November 11 article reported 700 trees in Heroes Grove. Counts reported in the Chronicle tended to inflate with time. The GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO. CA-49-B PAGE 5 In March Davis strongly protested to the Supervisors that money intended for the Gold Star Mothers Heroes Grove was going to the Native Sons heroes grove. The Supervisors assured her that the original Heroes Grove would be adequately funded.22 Davis died seven months later.
Monument The Gold Star Mothers dedicated their Memorial Boulder on November 13, The boulder, which is near the main (southeast) entrance, resembles a rounded pyramid or obelisk, depending on point of view. It is about 9' high and about 6' x 8' at the base. The top and all but one of the sides are natural; the north side was cut to a plane at a roughly 64 angle and left unpolished. When the sun hits the boulder, it gives off a soft, golden glow, in contrast to the soft shade of the surrounding Coast Redwood trees. Inscribed on all sides of the boulder are the names of 759 sons and daughters who died in service between April 6, and July 2, The names include men and women, combatant and non-combatant, from many ethnic backgrounds.
Less than half were residents of San Francisco when they enlisted; others died in service at San Francisco military bases, were buried in San Francisco National Cemetery, and/or had relatives in the Greater Bay Area.25 Vandalism of the boulder was decried to the Park Commissioners or Chronicle five times between and Some damaged names appear to be the work of vandals and a subtle patch on the north face may be a repair due to vandalism. The stone is crumbling from the interior of some of the closed letters (B, D, O, P, Q, and R).
Further investigation is needed to determine whether the damage is due to chiseling vandals, or to inherent weakness in the carving exacerbated by environmental conditions, graffiti removal solvents, and/or sprinkler spray.27 historian counted roughly 550 young trees in the aerial photograph [Ryker], so 615 seems a more likely number. 22 Board of Supervisors, 17 Mar Heroes Grove Funds Pledged, Chronicle, 18 Mar 23 Gold Star Mothers Dedicate Monument in Hero s Grove, Chronicle, 14 Nov Memorial Boulder was shortened to Rock by [Board of Park Commissioners, 23 May 24 The historian counted 759 inscribed names. The time range is almost the window of eligibility for the Gold Star Pilgrimage: April 5, to July 1, [Potter.] See the history section for more information on the Gold Star Pilgrimage.
25 The historian separated the names into two groups: those that were on the published (by Haulsee et al. and the State War History Committee) fatality lists for San Francisco, and those that were not. The historian then researched a sampling of the latter group on Ancestry.com to surmise why they were on the boulder. 26 Anna C. Wellbrock, letter to the editor, Chronicle, 6 Jun and 13 Oct Emily Andrews, letter to Board of Park Commissioners, 19 Nov and 27 May Mr. Joseph Grindon, letter to Board of Park Commissioners, 31 May 27 The sprinklers are on portable tripod stands, and are capable of forcefully hitting almost the entire inscription. GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO.
CA-49-B PAGE 6 McLaren believed that statues and nature did not go well together, and would obscure new statues with plantings as soon as possible. The aerial photograph shows the boulder surrounded by Coast Redwood trees. Two trees between the maintenance road and the boulder were removed by the time of aerial photograph.28 Decorative Plantings In December the Gold Star Mothers requested improvements around the boulder. The rectangular outline of a small hedge is visible in the aerial photograph. The ca. photograph of the boulder shows a flowerbed around the base of the boulder, and the boulder viewing area edged with lawn and an immature Buxus (Boxwood) hedge. By the time of the photographs, the hedge remained, but the flowerbed and lawn were gone.29 Today, the hedge no longer exists.
The grove has a thick carpet of soft redwood needles, except for patches of gravel on the maintenance road and in the depression. Rows of flowering perennials flank the main (southeast) entrance, and there are a few flowering shrubs along the maintenance road. History: Park Superintendent John McLaren John McLaren was born in Scotland. He worked as a gardener and studied botany in Scotland before immigrating to the United States in In San Mateo County, California, he designed and directed large plantings (on the order of tens of thousands of trees at a time) until taking on the still-nascent and struggling Golden Gate Park in at age 41. He ruled Golden Gate Park until his death at age 96.
Much has been written about how he tamed the shifting sand dunes and shifty politicians to transform Golden Gate Park into a much- loved urban oasis.30 Gold Star Mothers A Gold Star Mother is a mother whose child has died, or is missing in action, during active military service. The term originated during World War I, when families displayed service banners in their windows with a blue star for each family member in active military service, and a gold star for each family member who died in service. Family members in mourning for someone who died in active service wore a black armband with a gold star.
In the Gold Star Mothers successfully lobbied the federal government to fund a pilgrimage of 28 Girvan Aikman, 99; Ryker; U.S.G.S., Aerial Imagery, The Lincoln Relief Corp requested the tree removal in as well as the addition of a flagpole and flanking cannons. There is no evidence that the latter requests were fulfilled. [Board of Park Commissioners, 12 May 29 Board of Park Commissioners, 22 Dec Ryker; Unknown Photographer; Blair. 30 Girvan Aikman, 5, Credit must be given to first Park Superintendent William Hammond Hall for establishing the park s initial framework and for recommending McLaren for the position in For more information on McLaren and Golden Gate Park, see the Sources section. GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO.
CA-49-B PAGE 7 mothers and widows to the graves of their children and husbands (respectively) in Europe. Between and the U.S. Army carefully orchestrated the Gold Star Pilgrimage of women.31 Leah H. Davis was born in England and immigrated to the United States in ca. While her son, and only child, served in the Army in France, she was an active volunteer for the war effort in San Francisco. When her son died in February from pneumonia at a hospital in France, she organized Gold Star Mothers of San Francisco into a group. That group merged into a national organization of Gold Star Mothers in When Davis died the next year, the Board of Supervisors expressed sorrow at the loss.
Davis and, later, her husband were buried with their son in San Francisco National Cemetery.32 Gold Star Mother Emily Andrews also born in England, succeeded Davis as head of the San Francisco Chapter. Andrews only son died in the Argonne Forest in France in October and was buried in Meuse- Argonne American Cemetery. Andrews joined other Gold Star Mothers on the Gold Star Pilgrimage to France in and led annual Armistice Day ceremonies at Heroes Grove.
The last record in the Chronicle of a ceremony at Heroes Grove, by Gold Star Sisters and Mothers, was Armistice Day, Andrews, who lived to be and other Gold Star relatives may have made unpublished visits to Heroes Grove after Stone Builder John Duff McGilvray, and Sons John Duff McGilvray was born of Scottish parents in Ireland, and considered himself a Scotsman.
He learned stone masonry in Scotland before immigrating to the United States in He moved from New York to Chicago (which he helped to rebuild after the Great Fire of to Denver (where, in addition to his stone business, he was active in local and state politics), before settling in San Francisco in There, he and his sons (all born in America) established the McGilvray Stone Company and later the McGilvray-Raymond 31 The American Legion, Blue Star Banner, legion.org/troops/bluestar; American Gold Star Mothers, Our History, Potter.
Service banners started in September and armbands in late May 32 Wire Turns Her Cheers to Sobs: Mother who Labored to Give Boys Comfort Finds She Has Lost Her Own, Chronicle, 13 May Gold Star Mothers of America Begin Nationalization Work in Chronicle, 10 Oct Death Takes Founder of Star Mothers, Chronicle, 10 Oct Leah Davis, Founder of Gold Star Mothers' Association, Dead. Jewish Daily Bulletin, 12 Oct Board of Supervisors, 14 Oct Leah H. Davis, death certificate, County of San Francisco Vital Records, obtained 29 May Davis maiden name was not on her death certificate. 33 Chaplain Praises L.A.
Boy's Bravery, Los Angeles Examiner, 24 Feb Bay Region Gold Star Mothers to Honor France with Flowers, Chronicle, 27 May Today s Club Notebook, Chronicle, 9 Nov A Very Merry Lady Turns Chronicle, 5 Jan First Gold Star Mothers' Rites, Chronicle, 30 May GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO. CA-49-B PAGE 8 Granite Company. His sons continued the business after his death, with the eldest son, John Duff McGilvray, Jr. as president.34 The McGilvray family built many important Bay Area buildings, including much of the original Stanford University campus, San Francisco s first skyscraper, and San Francisco City Hall.
Several McGilvray-built buildings survived the earthquake and fire, and the McGilvray family helped to rebuild San Francisco after that disaster.35 Living Memorials in Post-World War I (WWI) America According to Mosse, communities embraced nature in their post-WWI memorials as an antidote to and atonement for the horrors of the War.36 The concept of a living memorial certainly resonated with the community of San Francisco. In May the Examiner wrote that the memorial for San Francisco s war dead should live and grow, because liberty and freedom were living and growing due to their sacrifice.37 The Examiner s suggestion may have germinated from a letter written by a member of the American Forestry Association (AFA).
The AFA had been promoting the planting of trees on Arbor Day since When Cleveland, Ohio, in Summer (before Armistice Day) announced its intention to plant memorial street trees, the AFA saw another opportunity to promote tree plantings. In their December issue (their first after Armistice Day), the AFA urged all its members to write letters to newspapers editors suggesting the planting of memorial trees. In their January issue, the AFA reported that all levels of governments had responded positively, viewing the AFA s suggestion as an opportunity for civic beautification.
The AFA started a national registry of memorial trees that January, and, in July, started selling customized bronze memorial tree markers for each.39 The living memorials took many forms, including memorial street,40 all e,41 park,42 single tree,43 grove,44 and forest.45 34 McGilvray-Raymond Co. and McGilvray Stone Co. are Leaders in Building, Chronicle, 12 Jan John D. McGilvray Dies at Stanford, Chronicle, 26 Mar California's Granites Are Unsurpassed: John D. McGilvray, Pioneer Stone Man, Develops Great Industry Here, Chronicle, 7 Jun John D. McGilvray, Shriner, Dies, Chronicle, 17 Jun1955; Basin Research. 35 Basin Research.
36 Paraphrasing Mosse, The Appropriation of Nature, 37 Indorses Project for Heroes Grove, Examiner, 19 May 38 American Forestry Congress, Proceedings, especially John B. Peaselee, Arbor Day or Tree Planting Celebration, Sep Writers Program of the WPA, Arbor Day was founded in by J. Sterling Morton in Nebraska. [ The History of Arbor Day, Arbor Day Foundation, 39 All AFA, American Forestry: Trees for the Dead, Aug Memorial Trees for Sailors and Soldiers, Dec Trees for Memorials, Jan Memorial Trees, Jul 40 E.g., Liberty Row, Cleveland, OH. [Ken Goldberg and Chris Roy, Cleveland Heights Liberty Row, Cleveland Heights Historical Society, GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO.
CA-49-B PAGE 9 Heroes Groves in Post-WWI America According to Groenig and Mosse, the concept of a heroes grove originated with a memorial design proposed by landscape architect Willy Lange in Germany in December German communities distilled Lange s design down to its essence: a semi-circle of Quercus (Oak) trees, with one tree per hero, centered on a natural, native boulder.46 Like San Francisco, many American communities chose a mono-species grove of long-lived native trees planted in a naturalistic pattern, with one tree per hero, and a natural, native boulder inscribed with all the names.
Some variations included non-native species,47 bi-species grove,48 mono-species grove within multi-species grove,49 pavilion,50 statue,51 concentric circle pattern,52 grid pattern,53 name plaque on each tree,54 and name marker near each tree.55 Sequoia sempervirens McLaren wrote that if one wants a majestic massing of conifers there is no genus better suited than Sequoia. Sequoia sempervirens is an ancient, long-lived species, native only to the Pacific Coast between Monterey County and southern 41 E.g., Oak All e, Audubon Park, New Orleans, LA. [Julia Street, Julia Street with Poydras the Parrot: The Pursuit to Answer Eternal Questions. New Orleans Magazine, March 42 E.g., Memorial Park, Fort Wayne, IN. [ Memorial Park Home to a Lot of History, News Sentinel, 29 May 43 E.g.
Louis Boex Memorial Tree, Cincinnati, OH. [AFA, American Forestry, Trees for Memorials, Op. cit.] 44 E.g. Heroes Grove, Eden Park, Cincinnati, OH. Eden Park has two groves named Heroes Grove. The first was dedicated in to Revolutionary War Heroes. [Writers Program of the WPA, 45 E.g. American Legion Forest, Herkimer County, NY. [ Huge Forest as Memorial: American Legion Will Plant Acres, The [American] Legion Annual, 46 Groenig, Mosse, Lange s design was a circular ditch and hedge enclosing concentric circles of Quercus (Oak), with one tree per hero, which surrounded one Tilia (Linden) tree and stones inscribed with names, with a path from the exterior to the interior. The Linden represented the emperor.
[Groenig, 47 E.g., Populus nigra Italica (Lombardy Poplar) at Georgetown University, Washington, [ Planting of Memorial Trees, June 16, in A War to End All Wars?, Georgetown University Library, 48 E.g.., Quercus rubra (Red Oak) and Picea (Spruce) at Memorial Grove, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID. [Paul Warnick, World War I Memorial Grove, ArborNotes, May 1.] 49 E.g., Ulmus minor (English Elm) for the deceased and multiple species, for those who served and survived, at Memorial Grove, Wellesley, MA. [Wellesley Public Media, "Remembering Wellesley Residents Killed in WWI," 8 Sep 50 E.g., Grove of Remembrance, Druid Hill Park, Baltimore, MD. [Jacques Kelly, Grove of Remembrance Largely Forgotten, Baltimore Sun, 12 May 51 E.g. Doughboy Statue, Grove of Memory, Golden Gate Park.
52 E.g., Memorial Grove, Fairmount Park, Philadelphia, PA. [Barry Johnson, Fairmount Park World War I Memorial Grove, 53 E.g., Memorial Grove, Green Hill Park, Worcester, MA. [Worcester Tree Initiative, World War I Memorial Park, Green Hill Park, 54 E.g., see Worcester, MA in previous footnote. 55 E.g., Infantry Memorial Grove, Central Park, New York, NY. [Malcolm Schade, Infantry Regiment Memorial, GOLDEN GATE PARK, HEROES GROVE AND GOLD STAR MOTHERS MEMORIAL BOULDER HALS NO. CA-49-B PAGE 10 Oregon. As early as McLaren advocated for the creation of a Redwood National Park, to protect old-growth forests from logging.
McLaren, knowing that Sequoia sempervirens takes years to reach majestic maturity, said that he planted seedlings for future generations, not for himself.56 In choosing Sequoia sempervirens, McLaren connected the deaths, of San Franciscans in a foreign-land, to their homeland over a continuum of time from the ancient past to the far future.