Golden Gate Park, Pershing and Doughboy Monuments, Bounded by Fulton Street, Stanyan Street, Fell Street, Baker Street, Oak Street, Frederick Street, Lincoln Way, and the Great Highway., San Francisco
Golden Gate Park, Pershing and Doughboy Monuments , Bounded by Fulton Street, Stanyan Street, Fell Street, Baker Street, Oak Street, Frederick Street, Lincoln Way, and the Great Highway., San Francisco, San Francisco County, CA. Surveyed as HALS CA-49-C, with a 3,636-word written history.
From the record
“The Pershing and Doughboy monuments have historic significance for commemorating and perpetuating the story, events, and sacrifices of World War I.”
Written record, HALS CA-49-C survey. Machine-read text.
Surveyed by the federal HALS program as HALS CA-49-C · the record runs 3636 words · one of 382 surveyed structures published for this county.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HALS CA-49-C.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
The Pershing and Doughboy monuments have historic significance for commemorating and perpetuating the story, events, and sacrifices of World War I. The participants and survivors are now gone, but the monuments carry their stories forward. Both monuments exhibit exceptional artistic craftsmanship by significant sculptors and both have unique settings. The monuments are also significant for their contemplative landscape settings in Golden Gate Park, providing a very different experience from monuments in urban settings. Description: This HALS documentation focuses on two monuments in Golden Gate Park associated with World War I: the Pershing Monument, and the Doughboy Monument with its Grove of Memory. These two monuments commemorate World War I in very different ways.
One honors General John J. Pershing, who led the American Expeditionary Forces. The other honors the everyman of the infantry that achieved victory under his leadership. Both monuments found their place in San Francisco s Golden Gate Park, where, by design, the city s elite and the working classes recreated side by side. Pershing Monument The Pershing Monument consists of a statue and pedestal placed within a landscape setting. The main element is a bronze figurative statue of General John J. Pershing standing on a 5 tall granite pedestal. The statue and base sit within a 21 square plot enclosed by a granite border. The monument is at the northeast end of Golden Gate Park s Music Concourse, aligned with the central axis of the 14-acre Concourse.
The Music Concourse differs from the rest of Golden Gate Park in that it has a formal, axial design with the Spreckels Temple of Music at one end and the Pershing Statue at the other. Also on the central axis are the Rideout Fountain and the Francis Scott Key Monument. Within the 21 square plot are planted shrubs (Westringia and ground covers. Turf surrounds the plot and tall shrubs form a background for the monument and separate it from the adjacent rhododendron dell. GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 2 The Pershing statue, created by sculptor Haig Patigian, portrays the General in a highly detailed uniform with field jacket, riding pants, and boots.
He is wearing his hat, and based on photographs of Pershing, the head appears to be an excellent likeness. At Pershing s feet on the bronze pedestal are depicted a tree stump and a damaged German helmet with several holes in it. The granite base is simply designed with a poppy motif frieze on all sides, an inscription in Roman letters on the front side, and a stepped, flared base. The inscription is cut into the granite and highlighted with gold leaf. It reads: IN TRIBUTE TO GENERAL PERSHING AND THE VICTORIOUS ARMIES OF THE UNITED STATES AND HER CO-BELLIGERENTS DURING THE WORLD WAR PRESENTED BY
Dr. Morris Herzstein
The monument s bronze and stone elements are all in good condition. The Doughboy Monument and the Grove of Memory The Doughboy Monument and the Grove of Memory consist of a bronze statue on a natural boulder in a meadow setting and adjacent to a grove of redwood trees. The monument is flanked by two flagpoles. The grove was planted in to memorialize those killed during World War I. The tall figurative bronze statue depicts a World War I-era doughboy 1 holding a laurel wreath. His sleeves are rolled up, his collar is open, and he wears no helmet. The statue stands on a large natural, irregularly shaped boulder.
A large bronze plaque on the boulder includes the following inscription: THIS GROVE IS DEDICATED TO THE MEMORY OF THE MEMBERS OF THE SAN FRANCISCO PARLORS, NATIVE SONS OF THE GOLDEN WEST, WHO GAVE THEIR LIVES IN THE WORLD S WARS I AND II. 2 The plaque includes thirty-nine names of those killed during World War I and an additional sixteen names of those killed during World War II. The monument stands facing east at the edge of one of the park s sunken meadows. Meadows in the park were typically created in the lowest topographical areas to protect them from the winds. Doughboy Meadow, as it is informally known, is approximately 12 lower than the adjacent main park 1 Doughboy is an informal term for a U.S. infantryman, particularly during World War I.
2 When originally dedicated in the plaque only referenced World War I. In the plaque was updated to include the additional names of members killed during World War II. GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 3 drive. The grassy meadow is defined by areas of the park s naturalistic forest. Behind the monument is the Grove of Memory, thirty-nine memorial redwood trees (Sequoia sempervirons). The trees, planted in now stand between 80 and 120 tall, creating a backdrop for the monument, and a densely shaded space within the grove. The monument, meadow, and grove are all in good condition. History: Introduction World War I was a major event in the history of the United States, forever altering its role in global geo-politics.
Although thousands of miles away, the war had a profound impact on almost every city and town in the country. After the war, there was overwhelming desire to commemorate and memorialize the sacrifice young men and women made for the greater good. Memorials and monuments were proposed in many cities and towns, and San Francisco was among them. After the cessation of World War I hostilities, there were several proposals for commemoration of the war in Golden Gate Park. The Board of Park Commissioners that governed the park was generally favorably disposed to these proposals. A Grove of Heroes was proposed in 3 A monument to General John J.
Pershing, still living at the time, was proposed in A Grove of Memory and a memorial to members of the Foresters of American were approved in Elsewhere in San Francisco, two major architectural projects of the the War Memorial Opera House and Veterans Building, and the Palace of the Legion of Honor were planned to commemorate World War I. San Francisco s Golden Gate Park became a favored location for monuments and statues of all kinds. This was particularly true in the first decades of the twentieth century. Created in by William Hammond Hall, the park was very much in keeping with the park tradition established by New York s Central Park. It was meant to be a retreat to nature for urban dwellers.
Both Hall and his long-time successor John McLaren stood against the idea of putting statues and similar things in the park. Statues and other urban objects would only serve to interrupt the bucolic landscape experience Hall and McLaren intended. In spite Hall s and McLaren s viewpoints, the overwhelming desires of every sort of civic and ethnic group, politician, and philanthropist carried the day. Today there are over three dozen monuments and statues commemorating all sorts of people and events throughout Golden Gate Park. Monument to General John J. Pershing and his Armies 3 See separate HALS documentation. GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 4 General John J.
Pershing is best known for leading the American Expeditionary Force that fought on the Western Front in World War I during and At that time, Pershing had the rank of General of the Armies, the highest possible rank in the United States Army. Pershing was raised on a farm in Laclede, Missouri. After completing high school, began a career as a teacher, but after two years he applied to the United States Military Academy. During his time at West Point, Pershing s leadership abilities became apparent and he was promoted to First Captain, the highest cadet rank. In he began his active duty career with the 6th Cavalry, serving primarily in the West. In Pershing returned to West Point as an instructor, and he later led troops in the Spanish-American War and the Philippine- American War.
Pershing had an unfortunate history in San Francisco. In having returned from the Philippines, he moved his wife and three children into a home on the parade ground in the Presidio of San Francisco. Pershing soon left for Mexico and a house fire took the lives of his wife and two daughters. The site in the Presidio at the head of the Main Parade Ground is now a formal ceremonial ground known as Pershing Square. A Monument for Pershing After World War I, San Francisco philanthropist Dr. Morris Herzstein toured the European battlefields with General Pershing. Upon his return, he decided to commission a monument honoring Pershing and his armies. Herzstein consulted with Alfred Gump who recommended sculptor Haig Patigian for the commission.
A site at the east end of the Golden Gate Park Music Concourse was chosen. The highly detailed bronze statue was completed in and dedicated on Armistice Day, November 11, with Pershing in attendance.4 Herzstein died in and in his estate, he provided a endowment to the Board of Park Commissioners for the proper upkeep and maintenance of the Pershing Statue and the ground upon which said statue stands in Golden Gate Park. 5 The larger-than-life statue figure is approximately tall and stands on a simple rectangular stone base with scrollwork, inscription, and a flared base. The statue itself is remarkably detailed and textured depicting Pershing in his uniform. The statue also has a remarkable likeness of Pershing.
On the bronze base with the statue is a burned out tree stump and a damaged German infantry helmet. The site of the monument is an informal setting with a background of tall shrubs, but this belies the fact that the monument stands on the formal central axis of the Music Concourse and Pershing is staring straight down the axis. Also 4 San Francisco Chronicle. November 12, 5 Minutes of the July 16, meeting of the Board of Park Commissioners. GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 5 on the Music Concourse axis are the Francis Scott Key monument (relocated to that spot in the Rideout Fountain, and the Spreckels Temple of Music. Other statues of General Pershing are located in Washington, Laclede, Missouri; Versailles, France; and Puerto Palomas, Mexico.
Sculptor Haig Patigian The Pershing statue was created by sculptor Haig Patigian Patigian was born in the Ottoman Empire in Western Armenia.6 At the age of 15, Patigian s father was involved in political troubles and the family fled to the United States and settled on a farm near Fresno. His parents instilled an interest in art and Haig moved to San Francisco to pursue an art career. He worked in watercolor, oils, and found work as an illustrator. He enrolled at the Mark Hopkins Institute (now the San Francisco Institute of Art) and gravitated to sculpture.7 After the earthquake, Patigian spent two years studying classical sculpture in Paris, after which he returned to San Francisco and established a studio.
He developed relationships with San Francisco architects including Timothy Pflueger, for whom he created the pediment sculpture for the former Metropolitan Life building (now the Ritz-Carlton hotel). Other notable works by Patigian include the Abraham Lincoln sculpture in San Francisco s Civic Center, the Thomas Starr King sculpture that for many years was California s contribution to Statuary Hall in the U.S. Capitol Building in Washington, The Doughboy Monument and the Grove of Memory The San Francisco Parlors of the Native Sons of the Golden West and the Native Daughters of the Golden West sought to commemorate thirty-nine members who gave their lives during World War I. A site was chosen in Golden Gate Park and in for a grove of memory.
9 In the grove thirty-nine redwood trees were planted and a 20-ton red stone boulder was placed to mark the entrance to the grove. The dedication ceremony was held on November 6, At the ceremony, a campaign was announced to raise for a statue and bronze plaque bearing the names of the members that died during the war. In March of the Board of Park Commissioners provided to the Native Sons and Daughters for the monument.11 6 The American Elite and Sociologist Blue Book Progressive Americans Prominent in the Social, Industrial and Financial World.
7 Fine Art Museums of San Francisco website: accessed 8 At the June 23, Board of Park Commissioners meeting, the Grove of Memory Association of the Native Sons and Daughters asked to change the location of their Grove of Memory from Sloat Boulevard and Ocean Avenue to a site in Golden Gate Park. Superintendent John McLaren selected a site for the grove north of the Main Drive in the vicinity of the Boat House, between and Avenues. 9 The grove is also referred to as Redwood Memorial Grove. 10 San Francisco Chronicle. November 7, 11 Minutes of the March 24, meeting of the Board of Park Commissioners. GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 6 Artist M. Earl Cummings was commissioned to create the bronze plaque and statue entitled The Doughboy.
The statue was placed on top of the boulder and dedicated on June 6, On June 3, a new plaque was dedicated with the names of sixteen additional members that were killed during World War II. The origin of the term doughboy is debated by historians and there are several theories, but there is no definitive explanation. The term was applied to infantrymen in both Britain and the United States from the early nineteenth century, but it was the American troops sent to Europe during World War I for whom the term achieved common parlance.13 There are numerous doughboy monuments in towns and cities around the country.
Cummings life-size doughboy is somewhat unusual in that instead of carrying a gun and wearing a helmet as most of the other statues do, this doughboy has no helmet and stands with sleeves rolled up with open collar, holding a laurel wreath, a symbol of victory and honor. The boulder base is also unusual in that it is in its rustic natural form, not sculpted into a formal base. Two 38 flagpoles now flank the monument. Smaller flagpoles were present at least as early as The monument sits at the west edge of one of the park s many meadows, with the memorial redwood trees forming a backdrop. The meadow is informally known as Doughboy Meadow.
Like many of the meadows in the park, Doughboy Meadow is in a low area to afford protection from wind, and it sits approximately 12 feet below the adjacent JFK Drive. Sculptor M. Earl Cummings Melvin Earl Cummings was a San Francisco sculptor with a legacy of many surviving works. Cummings was born in Salt Lake City but his family moved to San Francisco when he was 20 years old. With an interest in art, he enrolled in the Mark Hopkins Art Institute (now the San Francisco Art Institute) and studied sculpture with Douglas Tilden. Tilden took special interest in Cummings and the young sculptor apprenticed in Tilden s studio. Cumming s first independent work was a bust of Tilden presented to the Mark Hopkins Institute.
Arts patron Phoebe Apperson Hearst (mother of William Randolph Hearst) was also interested in Cummings progress and sent him to Paris for three years of study at the cole des Beaux-Arts. In Cummings returned to San Francisco and became involved in civic affairs and he was appointed to the San Francisco Park Commission, an honor he 12 California Art Research, Volume Six, Abstract from WPA Project 13 Hanlon, Michael E. The Origins of Doughboy. Web article of the Doughboy Center. 14 Doughboy monument photograph dated San Francisco Public Library, Photo ID Number: AAA-8111. GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 7 held for 32 years. This association led to many commissions for works in San Francisco s parks.
The earthquake and fire led to a rebuilding of the city and many opportunities for artists and sculptors. In addition to the Doughboy sculpture, Cummings works in Golden Gate Park include the Robert Burns statue, the Pool of Enchantment and the Sundial at the de Young Museum, the statue of John McLaren, bear and cougar sculptures of the Brown Gate, and the Rideout Fountain sculpture. Other notable works include the Sather Memorial Gate at U.C. Berkeley, and the Commodore Sloat Memorial in Monterey.15 Chronology of the Pershing and Doughboy Monuments July 28 Austria-Hungary declares war on Serbia, the start of what would become World War I. August 3 Germany declares war on France. August 4 United Kingdom declares war on Germany. April 6 United States declares war on Germany.
June 25 First American troops arrive in France. November 11 Germany signs the Armistice of Compiegne, ending World War I. November 11. Pershing monument dedicated. November 16. Board of Park Commissioners accepts a gift from Dr. Morris Herzstein for a statue of General John J. Pershing. June 23. Board of Park Commissioners granted the Grove of Memory Association of the Native Sons and Daughters permission to change the location of the Grove of Memory from Sloat Boulevard and Ocean Avenue to Golden Gate Park. Superintendent McLaren selected a site for this grove north of the Main Drive in the vicinity of the Boat House, between and Avenues. November 6 Dedication ceremony for the Grove of Memory and the 20-ton red stone boulder.
15 California Art Research, Volume Six, Abstract from WPA Project GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 8 July 16. Board of Park Commissioners accepts the Herzstein Bequest of from the estate of Dr. Morris Herzstein for the proper upkeep and maintenance of the Pershing Statue and the ground upon which said statue stands in Golden Gate Park. March 24. City enters contract with the Grove of Memory Association, Native Daughters of the Golden West and Native Sons of the Golden West, for erection of a monument known as The Dough Boy. Monument is in memory of the members of the United States Military Forces who gave up their lives in the World s War. The cost of the monument shall not exceed June 6. Doughboy statue dedicated.
June 3 A new plaque is dedicated at the Doughboy monument adding names of those killed during World War II. November 11 Centennial of the end of World War I.
Sources
165 words
Source document
Quoted word for word from HALS CA-49-C.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
Board of Park Commissioners Meeting Minutes. Various dates, available online through the San Francisco Public Library website. California Art Research, Volume Six, Abstract from WPA Project Fine Art Museums of San Francisco website: accessed Hanlon, Michael E. The Origins of Doughboy. Web article, Doughboy Center, The Story of the American Expeditionary Forces. No date. accessed Herringshaw, Thomas William, editor. The American Elite and Sociologist Blue Book Progressive Americans Prominent in the Social, Industrial and Financial World. American Blue Book Publishers, Nelson, Douglas. National Register of Historic Places Registration Form for Golden Gate Park. Pollock, Christopher. San Francisco s Golden Gate Park A Thousand and Seventeen Acres of Stories.
WestWinds Press, Royston Hanamoto Alley & Abey, Landscape Architects. Golden Gate Park Master GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 9 Plan. San Francisco Recreation and Park Department. October San Francisco Arts Commission. Adopt-A-Monument Report, Golden Gate Park. ca.1994. San Francisco Chronicle. Various dates, available online through the San Francisco Public Library website.
Written history
302 words
Source document
Quoted word for word from HALS CA-49-C.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
Douglas Nelson, ASLA RHAA Landscape Architects 225 Miller Ave., Mill Valley, CA July HALS Challenge Entry: Memorialization, Commemorating the Great War Overview of the Pershing monument and its landscape setting. The monument is set in the landscape, surrounded on three sides by large shrubs and enclosed by a 21 -square granite border. (Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 10 Close-up view of the highly detailed sculpture. (Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 11 Detail view of Pershing s left hand and the textures on the uniform. (Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, Detail view of the damaged German helmet at Pershing s feet.
(Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 12 Detail view of the stone pedestal with stylized poppy frieze. The inscription is cut into the stone and highlighted with gold leaf. (Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 13 Overall view of the Doughboy monument in its meadow setting and the redwood trees of the Grove of Memory behind it. (Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, Doughboy monument flanked by flagpoles. (Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 14 Doughboy monument with bronze statue and plaque on the natural stone boulder.
(Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 15 Close-up view of the Doughboy statue with open collar and rolled-up sleeves holding a laurel wreath. (Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8, GOLDEN GATE PARK, PERSHING AND DOUGHBOY MONUMENTS HALS NO. CA-49-C PAGE 16 Interior view of the Grove of Memory redwood trees. (Douglas Nelson photographer, June 8,
The federal surveyors worked through San Francisco building by building. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HALS CA-49-C. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.