Southeast Sewage Treatment Plant, 750 Phelps Street, San Francisco
Southeast Sewage Treatment Plant, 750 Phelps Street, San Francisco, San Francisco County, CA. Surveyed as HABS CA-2930, with a 3,829-word written history.
From the record
“The Southeast Treatment Plant is associated with the completion of the Sewer System Master Plan that allowed for all sewage generated in the southeast quadrant of San Francisco to be treated at this facility.”
Written record, HABS CA-2930 survey. Machine-read text.
Surveyed by the federal HABS program as HABS CA-2930 · the record runs 3829 words · one of 382 surveyed structures published for this county.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HABS CA-2930.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
750 Phelps San Francisco, San Francisco County, California The Southeast Sewage Treatment Plant is an approximately 15-acre property (Assessor Parcel No. that includes most of the buildings in the south side of the larger Southeast Water Pollution Control Plant, on the block bounded by Phelps Street, Jerrold Avenue, and Quint Street, and also includes a few buildings in the southern part of the north side of the plant, located north of Jerrold Avenue, between Phelps and Quint streets. (center of Administration Building, Google Earth,
Significance
2852 words
The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HABS CA-2930.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
The Southeast Treatment Plant is associated with the completion of the Sewer System Master Plan that allowed for all sewage generated in the southeast quadrant of San Francisco to be treated at this facility. The plant was the largest, most expensive, and final element of the Master Plan. Operation of the plant, along with two other facilities, substantially reduced nearshore water pollution along San Francisco Bay and the Pacific Ocean, and was key to reduction of water pollution in the City and County of San Francisco.
The Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District was documented in and encompasses a portion of the Southeast Treatment Plant.1 The district contains 22 contributing buildings and structures that are significant for their architectural design as examples of Streamline Moderne architecture in San Francisco. Character-defining features of the district include horizontal orientation, rectilinear massing, 1 Brad Brewster, Department of Parks and Recreation 523 Record, Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District (San Francisco: Environmental Science Associates, SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No.
CA-2930 (page 2) glass block windows, terra cotta tile coping at the roofline with a speed line motif, and cast concrete moldings at windows and doors. The plant also includes more utilitarian buildings such as tanks and service and control buildings. The period of significance for the Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District is when construction of the plant was completed. Historians: Rebecca Allen, and Johanna Kahn, M.Ar.H. Environmental Science Associates (ESA) Capitol Ave., Suite 200 Sacramento, CA December PART
Historical Information
In the City and County of San Francisco completed construction of the Southeast Treatment Plant in the Bayview-Hunters Point area within San Francisco. The facility represented a major improvement to the city s sewage and water treatment, and helped to significantly reduce nearshore water pollution. During the there was an increased construction of Modern-style buildings within the city limits that emphasized their utilitarian uses. The Southeast Treatment Plant is historically representative of this period and is a relatively late example of Streamline Moderne architecture within San Francisco. 2 See also the written historical and descriptive data for the Southeast Treatment Plant Building HABS No. CA-2930-A. A. Physical History 1.
Date of erection: Construction of the Southeast Treatment Plant began in and was completed in 2. Architect: The San Francisco Department of Public Works, Bureau of Engineering, oversaw design and construction of the Southeast Treatment Plant. The Streamline Moderne- style design is not attributed to any one architect or engineer employed by or at any of the private architecture, engineering, or construction firms that assisted this city department. 3. Original and subsequent owners, occupants, uses: The San Francisco Department of Public Works owned and operated this facility for wastewater and sewage processing.
The San 2 Information on this resource derived or excerpted from Brewster, Department of Parks and Recreation 523 Record, Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District. SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No. CA-2930 (page 3) Francisco Public Utilities Commission currently owns and maintains the facility, using it for its original purpose. 4. Builder, contractor, suppliers: None have been identified to date. 5. Original plans and construction: A review of the original architectural plans of the Southeast Treatment Plant shows that it was concurrently designed with the Northpoint Treatment Facility at Bay Street (near Midway Street within city limits).
The San Francisco Department of Public Works used the same team of assisting architects and engineers for both facilities. Preliminary plans for the Southeast Treatment Plant from to were labeled as the North Point Sludge Treatment Plant Near Islais Creek. When construction began in it was known as the Southeast Treatment Plant, so as to not confuse the two facilities. Annual reports refer to the facility as the Southeast Sewage Treatment Plant. 3 Later annual reports simplified the name to the Southeast Treatment Plant. 6. Alterations and additions: Modest changes to the buildings include limited window and door infill, and installation of additional vents and pipes along various elevations, although these changes do not diminish the architectural style of the buildings and structures.
Six original buildings have been demolished, and several buildings and structures situated on the north and south sides of the plant were constructed in and along with other facilities constructed outside the boundaries of the historic district. B. Historical Context Industrial Development of Bayview-Hunters Point Area The Bayview-Hunters Point area in southeast San Francisco is generally bounded by Cesar Chavez Boulevard (formerly Army Street) on the north, San Francisco Bay on the east, U.S. Highway 101 on the west, and Candlestick Hill on the south. This area developed as one of San Francisco s early industrial districts.
Shipbuilding facilities were already established along the shoreline when 1850s-era ordinances pushed slaughterhouses from residential areas to the edge of the city in southeastern San Francisco.4 Industrial development in the late included facilities for the Pacific Rolling Mills Company, Union Oil Works, San Francisco Cordage Factory and Rope Works, California Sugar Refinery, and the City Gas Company.5 Several railroads served the area beginning in the early twentieth century, including the Southern Pacific Railroad which built the Bayshore Cutoff rail line between and 3 Annual Report of the Department of Public Works, City and County of San Francisco. (San Francisco: Department of Public Works, 17. Available online at archive.org and the San Francisco Public Library.
4 Kelley & VerPlanck, Bayview-Hunters Point Area B Survey, Town Center Activity Node (San Francisco: San Francisco Redevelopment Agency, 1; San Francisco, Ordinances and Joint Resolutions of the City of San Francisco (San Francisco: Published by authority, Roger W. Lotchin, San Francisco From Hamlet to City (Lincoln, NB: University of Nebraska Press, 12. 5 Sanborn Map Company, San Francisco, California (New York: Sanborn Map Company, SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No.
CA-2930 (page 4) near the future location of the Southeast Treatment Plant.6 A city zoning ordinance directed industrial areas to be constructed along the shoreline of San Francisco Bay and within the South Basin and Islais Creek Estuary areas (the latter is where the Southeast Treatment Plant would later be constructed).
Land reclamation in the area was completed in although maps and aerial photographs from the show the area near the edge of the Islais Creek estuary to be low and poorly drained.7 After World War II, the Bayview- Hunters Point area was identified as a site for the development of public works and municipal facilities.8 Industrial growth continued into the with the redevelopment of Butchertown area south of Islais Creek and the India Basin Industrial Park completed in India Basin Industrial Park slowly brought more industry and commercial businesses to the area, and is considered an ongoing project.
Into the twenty-first century, Bayview- Hunters Point remains the focus of redevelopment efforts such as a Community Revitalization Concept Plan, and it retains its industrial character in 9 City planning of infrastructure needs, including sewer treatment plans, have been key to the area s continued industrial development. Development of a Sewer Master Plan By the late nineteenth century, San Francisco was the largest city on the West Coast. To support its growing population, the city designed and built a collection system to carry combined wastewater and stormwater flows to the shoreline.
By over 300 miles of combined sewers had been completed, and that year, the city developed its first Sewer System Master Plan that aimed to: develop a standardized, coordinated sewer design to provide effective drainage; construct four pump stations; consolidate to eliminate on-land discharges; and construct 700 miles of combined sewers. 10 Although many improvements were made during the early twentieth century, untreated sewage continued to be discharged into the San Francisco Bay and the Pacific Ocean. 11 New neighborhoods were established near the coastlines, and the public was less willing to accept polluted beaches.
A sewer bond in made funds available for a board of consulting sanitary engineers to prepare remedial studies and recommendations, resulting in the Sewer System Master Plan.12 The plan proposed major improvements to the city s sewer system: sewage generated in the North Point and Marina districts would be treated at a plant at North Point; sewage generated in the Baker s Beach or East Richmond district, West Richmond, and Sunset districts would be treated at the Richmond-Sunset Sewage Treatment Plant; and sewage generated in the southeast quadrant of the city be treated at a treatment plant at Bayview-Hunters Point.13 The main accomplishments of the plan were: the 6 Railroad Buying in Butchertown, San Francisco Chronicle (December 22, 13.
7 Kelley & VerPlanck, Bayview-Hunters Point Area B Survey, Historic Context Statement, 8 Kelley & VerPlanck, Bayview-Hunters Point Area B Survey, Historic Context Statement, 9 Kelley & VerPlanck, Bayview-Hunters Point Area B Survey, Historic Context Statement, 10 San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, San Francisco Sewer System Master Plan, Summary Report Final Draft (San Francisco: 11 FoundSF, Sewerage, online at (accessed 27 June 12 CSWA Journal (California Sewage Works Association), Problems in the Operation of the Richmond-Sunset Sewage Treatment Plant, Journal 12, No. 1, 13 CSWA Journal, SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No.
CA-2930 (page 5) consolidation of sewer districts; construction of three primary wastewater treatment plants; construction of offshore deep-water effluent outfalls; elimination of dry-weather sewage overflows; and construction of 900 miles of additional combined sewers and 35 miles of intercepting sewers, 56 sewage diversion structures, and 22 pump stations located throughout the city.14 Construction of the Southeast Treatment Plant The Southeast Treatment Plant was constructed on the edge of the Islais Creek estuary. Construction began on 13 March and was completed by mid-1952, with 18 buildings and two groupings of five digester tanks each (10 in total).
The original contract award for the plant was While the plant was expected to be open by mid-1951, construction delays put the final costs closer to 15 The buildings at the Southeast Treatment Plant represent a more rectilinear interpretation of the Stream Moderne architectural style and are very similar in design to the North Point Treatment Facility constructed at Bay and Kearny streets, just off of the Embarcadero, that was built at roughly the same time. The Southeast Treatment Plant s layout remained essentially unchanged from to During this time, the passage of the Federal Water Pollution Control Amendments (33 U.S.C.
also known as the Clean Water Act, prompted the City and County of San Francisco to create the Sewer System Master Plan, as well as a response to abatement orders that would have resulted in a building moratorium if the city was not brought into compliance with the Clean Water Act. The plan led to numerous construction projects implemented over an approximately 25-year period. The plan included decommissioning of the Richmond-Sunset Sewage Treatment Plant, and upgrading and expanding the Southeast Treatment Plant. Twenty-one buildings or groups of identical structures were built between and to expand the plant. This larger facility was renamed as the Southeast Water Pollution Control Plant.
The San Francisco Department of Public Works, Bureau of Engineering, constructed 15 of these buildings to address the Clean Water Act requirements, and these were designed in the Brutalist style and constructed between and 16 Most of this newer construction is located outside the boundaries of the Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Historic District, with a few exceptions. The table below summarizes contributing and non-contributing buildings and structures within the district. 14 San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, San Francisco Sewer System Master Plan, 15 26-Acre Islais Creek Sludge Treatment Plant Begins to Take Form, San Francisco Chronicle (28 May 14. 16 San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, Sewer System Master Plan, Task Technical Memorandum No.
Seismic Condition Assessment, Final Draft (San Francisco: August, SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No. CA-2930 (page 6) Building No. Building Function Year Built, Contributing Architectural Style Element of Historic District North Side of Plant Building 040 Sedimentation Building No. 1 Streamline Moderne Yes Building 041 Sedimentation Building No. 2 Streamline Moderne Yes Building 043 Sedimentation Control Room Brutalist No Building 850 Operator s Building and Streamline Moderne Yes Engineering Offices Building 870 Service Building Streamline Moderne Yes Building 965 Entrance Control Building ca. Utilitarian No South Side of Plant Building 620 Digestion Control Building No. 1 Streamline Moderne Yes Building 630 Anaerobic Digester Tank No.
1 Industrial Modern Yes Building 640 Anaerobic Digester Tank No. 2 Industrial Modern Yes Building 650 Anaerobic Digester Tank No. 3 Industrial Modern Yes Building 660 Anaerobic Digester Tank No. 4 Industrial Modern Yes Building 680 Digestion Control Building No. 2 Streamline Moderne Yes Building 690 Anaerobic Digester Tank No. 6 Industrial Modern Yes Building 700 Anaerobic Digester Tanks No. 7 Industrial Modern Yes Building 710 Anaerobic Digester Tanks No. 8 Industrial Modern Yes Building 720 Anaerobic Digester Tanks No. 9 Industrial Modern Yes Building 730 Anaerobic Digester Tanks No. 10 Industrial Modern Yes Building 740 Gas Booster Station Streamline Moderne Yes Building 741 Gas Storage Facility (former Tank Industrial Modern Yes No.
5) Building 750 Digested Sludge Thickening Tanks Streamline Moderne Yes Building 790 Sludge Filtration Building Streamline Moderne Yes Building Dryer Building and Chimney Streamline Moderne Yes Building 810 Cogeneration Building Industrial Modern No Building Digester Heater Boilers/Waste Gas Industrial Modern No Burners Building 891 Southside Substation Streamline Moderne Yes Building 900 Maintenance Shop Streamline Moderne Yes n/a Security Fence ca.1981, Utilitarian No Modern Architecture in San Francisco During the there was increased construction of Modern-style buildings in San Francisco, initially in the Art Deco and Streamline Moderne styles and later in the International Style, as well as in its regional variation known as the Second Bay Area Tradition.
In it was estimated that more than a third of the city s buildings (more than were constructed between and 17 The post-World War II era in San Francisco saw a boom in the construction of municipal buildings, driven by a growing population and passage of several bond measures that allowed for construction of the city s 17 Mary Brown, San Francisco Modern Architecture and Landscape Design Historic Context Statement (San Francisco: City and County Planning Department, SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No. CA-2930 (page 7) infrastructure and public buildings. During the the city designed and constructed taxpayer-funded projects with a priority on efficiency, expediency, and low cost.
18 Post- war architects embraced new materials and technologies such as the use of glass curtain wall systems and steel framing, that allowed wider spans and larger, open interiors. The Modern design aesthetic emphasized horizontal lines.19 San Francisco became known for its Culture of Modernism. 20 Streamline Moderne, the architectural style in which the original Southeast Treatment Plant buildings were designed, expresses the dynamism of the Machine Age. It evolved from Art Deco and incorporated elements of the International Style; it was the first modern style to gain widespread acceptance within the United States. In San Francisco, Streamline Moderne was first used for residential tract development.
21 This style peaked in residential buildings in the and was applied to commercial, municipal, and industrial buildings into the The San Francisco Modern Architecture and Landscape Design Historic Context Statement identifies the following character-defining features for buildings designed in the Streamline Moderne Style: rounded corners and curved surfaces; curved railings and overhangs; speed lines (bands of horizontal piping, also known as speed whiskers ); curved glass windows or small porthole windows; horizontal ribbon windows; flat roof with coping at the roofline; smooth stucco or concrete wall surface, often painted white; wraparound windows at the corners; metal balconettes/railings, often curved; general absence of historically derived ornamentation; and horizontal orientation and asymmetrical fa ades.
22 PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General statement 1. Architectural character: The buildings and structures of the Southeast Treatment Plant reflect architectural characteristics unique to this facility, as they were designed for the treatment of the city s wastewater and sewage. As an example of Streamline Moderne architecture that is significant at a local level, the Southeast Treatment Plant embodies several distinctive characteristics that are commonly found in industrial buildings of this style: horizontal orientation, rectilinear massing, glass block windows, terra cotta tile coping at the roofline with a speed line motif, and cast concrete moldings at windows and doors.
The tanks built in are utilitarian Industrial Modern-style structures and are historically and functionally associated with the central control buildings (Buildings 620 and that are significant examples of the Streamline Moderne style. 18 Brown, San Francisco Modern Architecture and Landscape Design 62; Page & Turnbull, Historic Resource Evaluation: San Francisco Fire Department Station No. 1, 676 Howard Street, San Francisco, California, 14. 19 Brown, San Francisco Modern Architecture and Landscape Design 91. Betsy Hunter Bradley, The Works: The Industrial Architecture of the United States, (New York: Oxford University Press, and 20 Brown, San Francisco Modern Architecture and Landscape Design 92.
21 Brown, San Francisco Modern Architecture and Landscape Design 22 Brown, San Francisco Modern Architecture and Landscape Design SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No. CA-2930 (page 8) 2. Condition of fabric: The original buildings at the Southeast Treatment Plant have been subject to minor alterations over time, as noted above. The buildings have been in continuous use until and they remain in good and operable condition. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Selected
Sources
790 words
The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Source document
Quoted word for word from HABS CA-2930.
Not written, edited or summarised by this site.
26-Acre Islais Creek Sludge Treatment Plant Begins to Take Form. San Francisco Chronicle, 28 May 14. Annual Report of the Department of Public Works, City and County of San Francisco. (San Francisco: Department of Public Works, Available online at archive.org and the San Francisco Public Library. Bradley, Betsy Hunter. The Works: The Industrial Architecture of the United States. New York: Oxford University Press, Brewster, Brad. Department of Parks and Recreation 523 Record, Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District. San Francisco: Environmental Science Associates, Brown, Mary. San Francisco Modern Architecture and Landscape Design Historic Context Statement. San Francisco: City and County Planning Department, City of San Francisco.
Ordinances and Joint Resolutions of the City of San Francisco San Francisco: Published by authority, CSWA Journal (California Sewage Works Association). Problems in the Operation of the Richmond-Sunset Sewage Treatment Plant. Journal 12, No. 1, FoundSF. Sewerage. Online, Accessed 27 June JRP Historical Consulting, Historical Resources Evaluation, Sea Cliff Pump Station No. 2 Project, San Francisco, California. Davis: Report prepared for the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission and the San Francisco Planning Department, Kelley & VerPlanck. Bayview-Hunters Point Area B Survey, Town Center Activity Node. San Francisco: Report to San Francisco Redevelopment Agency, Lotchin, Roger W. San Francisco From Hamlet to City.
Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No. CA-2930 (page 9) North Point Plant Major Link in Sewage System, and M and K Firm s Experts Run Job on New Plant, San Francisco: San Francisco Public Library History Center, Newspaper Clipping File, 3 September Polanco, Julianne, Determination of Eligibility for Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District, 750 Phelps Street, San Francisco. Sacramento: Letter from Office of Historic Preservation, 6 October Railroad Buying in Butchertown. San Francisco Chronicle, 22 December 13. Sanborn Map Company. San Francisco, California. New York: Sanborn Map Company, San Francisco Planning Department. Biosolids Digester Facilities Project Final Environmental Impact Report.
San Francisco: City and County of San Francisco, Planning Department Case No. 2015-000644ENV, San Francisco Public Utilities Commission. Sewer System Master Plan, Task Technical Memorandum No. Seismic Condition Assessment, Final Draft. San Francisco, August Aerial photos of the Southeast Treatment Plant, San Francisco Sewer System Master Plan, Summary Report Final Draft. San Francisco, State Water Resources Control Board. Order No. WQG January 22, Online, Accessed 27 June B. Likely Sources Not Yet Investigated: As-built drawings may be available in the archives of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission, but have not yet been located. PART IV:
Project Information
The original buildings and structures at the Southeast Treatment Plant represent a significant and distinguishable entity comprised of 22 buildings and structures that contribute to the Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District. Four non-contributing buildings and structures are also present within the district.23 23 ESA inventoried exteriors of above-ground buildings and structures. Interiors of above-ground structures and all below-ground structures such as tunnels and pipes were not accessible, and were not considered in this documentation and evaluation. SOUTHEAST SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT HABS No.
CA-2930 (page 10) ESA staff surveyed and evaluated buildings and structures of the Southeast Water Pollution Control Plant, evaluating them for eligibility to the National Register of Historic Places (National Register) and California Register of Historical Resources (California Register), identifying the Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District. The State Historic Preservation Officer concurred with this recommendation in a letter dated 6 October 24 This district was determined to be eligible at a local level for the National Register under Criterion A for its historical associations with the implementation of the Sewer System Master Plan and under Criterion C as representative of the use of Streamline Moderne architecture in an industrial setting.
As a result of this formal determination of eligibility, the district is listed in the California Register. The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission plan to demolish Building a contributing element of the Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District, as part of necessary improvements for the Southeast Water Pollution Control Plant. The removal of Building 870 in combination with other proposed improvements would result in a cumulative adverse impact on the district. The Final Environmental Impact Report included a mitigation measure for HABS documentation and recordation of this facility.25 ESA staff prepared the written documentation and conducted the background historical research.
David De Vries (Mesa Technical in Berkeley, California) completed the photography services for Building 870 (HABS No. CA-2930-A). 24 Julianne Polanco, Determination of Eligibility for Southeast Treatment Plant Streamline Moderne Industrial Historic District, 750 Phelps Street, San Francisco. (Sacramento: Letter from Office of Historic Preservation, 6 October 25 San Francisco Planning Department, Biosolids Digester Facilities Project Final Environmental Impact Report (San Francisco: City and County of San Francisco, Planning Department Case No. 2015-000644ENV, to
The federal surveyors worked through San Francisco building by building. These are the other structures
they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.
Written history. Quoted verbatim from HABS CA-2930. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.