BlockBefore

Marsh-Sperry Garden, 1440 and 1450 Hawthorne Terrace, Berkeley

Marsh-Sperry Garden, 1440 and 1450 Hawthorne Terrace, Berkeley, Alameda County, CA. Surveyed as HALS CA-172, with a 6,679-word written history.

From the record

“The Marsh-Sperry garden is an excellent example of a substantially intact residential landscape.”

Written record, HALS CA-172 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HALS program as HALS CA-172 · the record runs 6679 words · one of 198 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Significance

5954 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-172. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Marsh-Sperry garden is an excellent example of a substantially intact residential landscape. It is significant for its association with Mabel Symmes, an early California female landscape architect. The Marsh-Sperry landscape retains many of its original features. Designed as two adjoining and related landscapes on one property, the landscape now spans two separate and adjoining properties. Symmes studied at the University of California, Berkeley in but did not finish her degree. Only a handful of her gardens are known, all residential, and her papers seem to have been lost; however, she worked with prominent architects and may have been the only female landscape architect practicing in the San Francisco Bay Area during the and Three of her gardens were used as teaching environments.

Symmes was also influential in the introduction, use, and study of the appropriateness of new plants in California. Symmes, with her sister, Anita Blake, explored many new plant varieties at Blake Estate. Symmes was a member of the California Botanical Society1 from its earliest days and presented information about plants and gardens to various groups, and occasionally wrote for magazines and newspapers. The period of significance is date of the design and construction of the garden, Description: The two properties were originally developed as a single property containing various and related gardens and is now two separate properties with a shared center garden. In this document, the combined landscape is called Marsh-Sperry, as is shown on the original drawings.

The house to the north is at Hawthorne Terrace and is called while the house to the south is called Based on two site visits on December 8, and May 2, on descriptions, and photographs, an overview of landscape characteristics and features follows and is not a complete study of character defining features. There was no physical 1 The California Botanical Society was later named the California Horticultural Society. MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 2 access to Hawthorne Terrace; however, parts of the landscape are visible from the street. Within this limitation, the two properties are described and compared to the original plan for the Marsh-Sperry garden.

An original blueprint for the entire landscape plan is in the ownership of Marion McNiven, an owner of one of the two properties, at Hawthorne Terrace. The plan shows the location of spaces, elements, and plant massing. There are no construction details or a planting plan. A comparison of the original plan and an aerial view show that the landscape of the two properties retains much of the original design. Original Design The long and rectangular piece of land is located in the Berkeley hills, with views to the San Pablo Bay. Sloping towards the west, the original single property covered .80 acres, with a frontage on Hawthorne Terrace about 232 . long with an average width of 146 .

James Cameron Sperry desired a house for his family, and a separate house for his widowed sister, Marion Marsh. The architect, Henry H. Gutterson, oriented the buildings along Hawthorne Terrace, close to the street, placing the Marsh house at the northeast corner and the Sperry house at the southeast end, allowing a generous side yard for the Sperry house. Between the two houses was located a four-bay garage, above which are two adjoining apartments. The garage/apartment structures attach the Sperry and Marsh houses. Mabel Symmes plan for the Marsh-Sperry garden from indicated a garden with straight-forward, geometric, and practical treatments for the shallow entry gardens at each house.

Stucco privacy walls and retaining walls were employed along the edge of the eastern sidewalk, and in conjunction with the pathways in the front yard of accommodating a somewhat significant grade change. At the end of the block, at Vine Street, an old rhyolite stone wall curves around the corner and to the end of the property at The area between the four-bay garage and the sidewalk was clearly intended to contain plants, as shown on the plan. The back and side gardens were more expressive, progressing from the most formal at the north, to the informal at the south. The north garden contained a bilaterally symmetrical parterre. Centered between the individual gardens was a shared garden with an oval form, symmetrical along the east-west axis.

This center garden related to the axes in the north garden and to winding paths in the south garden, as well as to a shared patio covered by a pergola that was located behind the garage. This center garden plan created a strong relationship between the constructed elements that were incorporated into the architecture of the property (the patio and pergola) and the semi-circular beds opposite. Behind the semi-circular beds were views to the San Francisco Bay. The intended focal point at the west end of the oval is not clear in the Symmes plan. A Gutterson- proposed tea house may or may not have been intended for this location and may MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 3 or may not have been constructed. It was not extant when Hugh and Marion McNiven bought the house in (M. McNiven).

The pergola and rectangular patio adjoining the two houses were shown as edged in shrubbery, with openings into the garden in the center and the north. The so- called drying yards, occupying the elevated area between the patio and garage, were shown as simple rectangular spaces. Adjoining the central garden was the larger, southern garden. This section was quite informal, with a central lawn edged in masses of plants. The design extended into the wide side garden and incorporated the character and expression of the back garden. In the garden of a round pond was located across from the southern portion of the back of the house, and a birdbath was placed along the upper side path.

The design cleverly related to the architecture of the homes while providing a variety of landscape experiences across the width of the property. (The character of the two individual gardens may also have reflected the interests of the original occupants.) Existing Landscape A discussion of plants is included as part of the descriptions of areas, with additional detail in the section on Plants. The front stucco walls are extant, although height was added to the walls at 1440.The walls along the sidewalk are covered in fig vine (Ficus pumila). Stucco walls, concrete stairs, and concrete paths remain at as do simple metal handrails. Garden lighting was added by Hugh and Marion McNiven (M. McNiven).

Shrubs and flowers occupy the planting beds; some may predate the McNiven s ownership of the house. The front garden at was not accessible but viewed from the street it appears to have a layout that is the same as that on the plan. The area between the garage and the street contains a vine- covered arbor at each end and planting pockets are located between the Hollywood or strip driveways. The greening of this area is consistent with the Symmes plan. The back and side garden divisions remain as they were originally designed, with the important central garden still defined by hedges, architectural elements, the layout, and views to the bay. The formal garden behind the McNiven s house, to the north, was removed and now consists of lawn and various plants.

A wide stone path remains behind this house, and the entry points into the central garden remain. Shrubs and trees define the north and west edges, such as holly hedges and soap bark trees, MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 4 consistent with the original plans. These were mature plants when Marion McNiven arrived in the and appear to date to the original garden. The central garden is predominantly intact and retains its spatial organization, although it has lost some of its detail. To the east, the patio, pergola, and fountain are intact, as well as the wide step into the garden and the shrub borders. The patio is edged with a hedge of myrtle (Myrtus communis) and a low wall.

The patio consists of square and rectangular concrete pavers, mortared into place, that have been in place since at least the and appear to be original (C. F. McNiven). An old wisteria vine covers the pergola. A formal fountain is clearly original. It is centered on the wall at the back of the patio, neatly fitted into the narrow area and opposite the wide step into the garden. The pavers, fountain, pergola, and wisteria were in place and clearly old when Marion moved to and give every appearance of being original. The myrtle shrubs lining the north half of the patio were replaced by Marion, using the same genus and species as had been in place previously.

The central lawn retains its overall shape and is still terminated by a roughly circular gravel form that intersects with the lower north-south gravel path. While the lower planting beds to the north have lost their form, the beds to the south have retained theirs. Each bed is filled with plants. The western terminus of the gravel path is punctuated by two narrow Italian cypress and a simple wooden pergola. In Marion McNiven s recollection, a similar pergola was present when she first arrived at the property and it persisted for some years, finally succumbing to decay. It had been covered in a climbing rose; now a wisteria vine is twining over the structure. The current structure is 11 wide and 6 deep. It is constructed of 4 x 4 posts with 4 x 8 beams, 1 x 1 cross ties.

The sides have a center 4 x 4 post, and 1 x 2 are spaced, vertically along the sides. A wooden bench occupies the space. The western edge of the garden is defined by a 4 tall fence of vertical boards. The fence is above a retaining wall and the properties behind the wall are several feet lower than the Marsh-Sperry garden. There are views to the San Pablo Bay beyond. In this lower garden the stone steps and dry-stack walls appear to be original. These walls are about 20 high. To the north the wall abuts a perpendicular stone wall that edges the northern garden. This wall is approximately 4 high. The western section of this wall, approximately 4 in length, is of concrete, approximately 10 wide. Holly shrubs (Ilex continue to line the north and south edges of the lawn.

These are approximately 5 tall and are pruned into rectangular forms on the north, and sport curving tops on the southern hedge. Both hedges are accented by wide, softly curving planting beds. Plastic benderboard defines the beds on the MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 5 north edge of the central garden, and the trimmed lawn edge outlines the southern side of the lawn. Marion McNiven, who has lived at the house at since indicated that she and the owners at agreed to maintain symmetrically-placed plants throughout these beds, but since the neighbors died, that level of detail has slipped in recent years (M. McNiven). Some of the symmetry of the beds has been lost, but this is not an irrevocable condition.

The holly hedge the serves as a divider between the north and south gardens was well established when Marion moved to and appears to be original. The low stone wall and stone steps at the lower central garden were also in place and appear to be original. The drying yards, between the apartments and the patio and pergola, also retain their basic rectangular forms. Viewed from the street, it is clear that many of the paths and steps throughout the garden at are intact; as are redwood trees, and a tall birdbath is visible in its original location. It is believed that the pond is extant but obscured by soil (M. McNiven); however, this is not known. Various shrubs, trees, ferns, clumps of bamboo, and vines occupy the garden. The rhyolite wall persists, although it is failing in places.

A wooden gate, leading to stone stairs, is present. Comparison of the Symmes plan and a Google Earth image shown that the spatial organization is largely intact. Plants Little is known about the plants intended for the property. Symmes indicated Shrubbery and Flowers on her plan. Plants are noted in various parts of the garden, above, and additional information is included here. According to Marion McNiven, when she arrived at there had been rhododendron, camellia, roses, pittosporum, eugenia, laurel, nandina, iris, and soap bark trees (Quillaja saponaria)2. A small stand of soap bark trees in the back yard of were well-established in and Marion McNiven feels quite certain that these trees are original to the property (M. McNiven).

Symmes wrote about the soap bark tree in her article Adelante and we know that Symmes was familiar with the plant and liked it. (Symmes, Adelante) At there were, and are, redwood trees, particularly at the northwest end of the property, in the informal area of the landscape. It appears that a redwood tree (Sequoia sempervirens) may have already anchored the southeast corner of the property at the time of the Symmes plan, judging from the original plan. A group 2 Quillaja Saponaria is an unusual tree, not commonly seen in the region. Native to Chili, a soap bark tree in Geelong Botanic Garden, in Australia, is listed as being 145 years old (Register). MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO.

CA-172 PAGE 6 of redwood trees grow in that location now, with the trunks forming a circle, strongly suggesting that these trees are the progeny of the original tree. This arrangement of trees is commonly known as a fairy ring and research shows that most of the trees occurring this way are offspring of an older tree that has been removed (Save the Redwoods League). 3 The redwood nearest the corner is causing a section of the rhyolite wall to fail. The trumpet vine (Campsis radicans) growing on the garage pergola, from the property at was already well established in and may be original; the trumpet vine growing from onto the pergola is a sprout of the former vine (M. McNiven).

As noted above, Marion McNiven replaced the myrtle (Myrtus communis) shrubs with identical ones along the northern half of the shared patio. The holly hedges (Ilex bordering the central garden predate Marion McNiven s arrival in (M. McNiven). The myrtle shrubs on the southern half of the central and shared patio predates Marion s arrival and are likely original. Its age is not known. Mature rhododendron, camellia, and roses remain on the site at both properties; some may be original. Stone Rhyolite, stone common to the area, was used for walls, and is most prominent along the Vine Street edge, curving around the corner at Hawthorne.

This wall predates the Gutterson plan, and therefore the Berkeley fire (Gutterson, Henry Stone steps and pathways were installed in the back and side of the southern garden at accommodating the sloping land. It is not clear from the Symmes plan how extensively stone was used in the northern garden, but any on the site now appears to be original. When Marion McNiven arrived in the stone paths and stairs on the north side of the house and wide stone walk and immediately behind the house were in place. In the intervening years, she and Hugh had the dry-laid stone path set on a concrete base, and they removed the formal parterre garden in the center of the lawn (M. McNiven).

3 It is fitting that redwoods are on the property since the Sperrys were intimately involved in the preservation of redwood trees in California, and both Donald and Sylvia McLaughlin, later owners of the Sperry house, both sat on the board of the Save the Redwoods League (Sylvia McLaughlin Mourned and Celebrated by Save the Bay), (Library). MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 7 History: The property was originally part of the Ranchos of Vincent and Domingo Peralta (Plot later part of the Beardslee Tract conveyed to Carlisle in Later it was part of the Bayview Homestead, carved from the Carlisle Tract. James Cameron and Adelia Sperry applied for building permits for the property in one year after a devastating fire eliminated many structures in Berkeley hills.

The Sperrys wanted a property where they could raise their three children, and that they could share with James sister, Marion, providing her with a house of her own. James Sperry was a mining engineer, but also an executive with Magnavox, which was then located in Oakland, California. Architect Henry H. Gutterson was a highly regarded and prolific architect. Best known for his Bay Area Tradition buildings (Woodbridge), in later years he also explored the International Style. In his Bay Tradition buildings, he artfully blended historical details into modern and expressive designs. The development featured a large English Tudor home on the southwest end of the lot and a smaller Gothic-style home on the southeast end of the lot Between the two houses was a wide and shallow garage.

A pergola extended from the garage over a short garage access area; above the garage was a two-story apartment building. Noted in newspapers of the day, this project was the most expensive of any in the post-fire construction zone for Residences). The builder was a highly regarded contractor, Axel Cederborg. James C. and Adelia Sperry, and Marion Marsh James C. Sperry was president of the Magnavox Corporation in his later life and was a mining engineer prior to that. He grew up in Murhpys, California. His father, James. L. Sperry, operated Sperry Flour Mills with his brother, Willard. An appreciation for the forests and landscapes of California ran deep in the Sperry family. James C. Sperry s father, James L.

Sperry, was passionate about the Calaveras Big Tree Grove where giant sequoia trees reigned. He owned the land on which the trees grew and after losing and regaining ownership, he sold the land to the U.S. Government in hopes of achieving permanent protection for the trees. There was no funding for maintenance, and under threat of logging, when a later generation had to fight for the grove, James C. Sperry led the effort. In James C. Sperry, with five others, incorporated the Save the Redwoods League, an influential organization on the West Coast. Sperry was also the first manager of the group and went on to negotiate property acquisitions.

Among other success of the group were Humboldt Redwoods National Park, and expansion of Sequoia National Park, and the establishment of Calaveras Big Trees Park in MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 8 Marion Marsh, James sister, had previously been managing the Mammoth Hotel and acting as postmistress in the Sierra Mountains town of Murphys. Following her husband s death, she moved to Berkeley to live in the smaller of the two houses, next to, and sharing the same property as her brother. Shortly after Marion moved into the house, her brother, Willard Sperry, and his wife, Mabel, moved in to live with her. In the Donald and Sylvia McLaughlin bought the Sperry house.

Donald was a professor as well as regent at UC Berkeley and Sylvia was one of the co- founders of the Save the Bay organization that rallied to prevent the filling of San Pablo Bay. The Save the Bay efforts resulted in the establishment of the California Coastal Commission. Donald died in Sylvia died in The house was sold to Michael and Karen Dreyfuss. The Marsh house was purchased by Hugh and Marion McNiven in Hugh passed away in Daughter Carolyn McNiven and her husband reside at the house with Marion. The property was split into two when the Sperrys sold the houses, creating a division through the garage/apartments and through the central and shared garden.

The McLaughlins and McNivens, who had a close friendship, maintained the central garden as a shared space, keeping its original character. Later, Sylvia McLaughlin and the McNivens created an agreement to maintain it as such. This agreement is currently being challenged by the Dreyfuss at Hawthorne. Mabel Symmes Mabel Symmes was born in in San Francisco. She died in February of Her parents developed significant wealth and Symmes, it seems, remained financially comfortable throughout her life (Blake Estate oral history project: oral history transcript / p She received a Bachelor of Arts degree in from the University of California, Berkeley (University of California). In Mabel traveled with her parents to tropical lands, including Hawaii and Tahiti (San Francisco Chronicle).

Symmes returned to the University in to take classes in Landscape Gardening (Blake Estate oral history project: oral history transcript / p The Division of Landscape Gardening and Floriculture was precursor to the Landscape Architecture program and was established in This means Symmes was among the first women in the program, although she MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 9 was not the first landscape architect to take classes in the Agriculture School at Berkeley.4 Symmes was 39 years old when she returned to school. It appears that Symmes did not complete the program, and this may have been due to the death of her father in to the uncertainty and reduction in classes during WWI, or to other matters.

It appears, from a letter Mabel s sister wrote in that Mabel was suffering from health issues at this time (Blake). In Mabel and her mother, Anna Day Symmes, traveled for several months in Europe, visiting the British Isles, France, Belgium, Holland, Switzerland, Spain and Italy (U.S. Passport Application). By Symmes had prepared a master plan for the Blake estates, at that time two associated properties. One property was owned by Anson S. Blake and Anita D. Blake; Anita was Mabel s only sister (there were four brothers). The adjoining property was owned by Edwin T. and Harriet W. Blake. Edwin was Anson s brother and they had acquired this property from their mother. The Blake Estate project was a significant event in Symmes career.

Symmes became closely associated with the Anson and Anita Blake property, living at the house and working in the garden over the second half of her adult life. For many years following Symmes death, it was the only commonly known example of her work. The Anita and Anson Blake estate, at acres, is now known as the Blake Garden and is owned by UC Berkeley, persisting as a garden for experimentation, education, and aesthetic pleasure. The Blake Garden is a sophisticated solution to a challenging site that contains sharp slopes, rock outcroppings, and streams (Blake Garden Geology and Hydrology). The natural features were preserved and used to enhance the garden experience.

Formal landscape elements were positioned nearest the house and responded to the character, forms and lines of the architecture. The Pink and Yellow garden at the Blake estate was said to be reminiscent of a villa in Italy (College of Environmental Design, UC Berkeley). Forced perspective techniques were employed as part of the backdrop to the classical reflecting pool. Receding from the house, the landscape became less formal. Symmes created several different areas over the then 22-acre acre property and connected the various gardens with a series of paths. Some areas were devoted to California native plants, such as the redwood grove, appropriately located along a natural waterway, and a Ceanothus Woods (California lilac).

Roads and pathways took advantage of the property s topography and views. Mabel Symmes and 4 It may not be possible to ever learn much about women in the Landscape Gardening program. Only students completing a degree are listed in Blue and Gold, the yearbook and accessible record of students at that time The first woman to graduate from UC Berkeley was Rosa L. Scrivner who completed her degree in agriculture in (Berkeley Florence Yoch took classes in (The Huntington Library). MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 10 Anita Blake were both accomplished horticulturalists, and the gardens evolved to include many exotic species. Linda Haymaker worked in the Blake Garden for 13 years, initially as a student, hired by the chief gardener, Walter Vodden.

She wrote an article about the Blake Garden, The Historical Validity of Blake Garden that eloquently describes the garden design and the integration of the natural landscape into the formal gardens (Haymaker, The Historical Validity of Blake Garden). The home (built between and was designed to accommodate both Mabel and mother Anna; Anna died before the house was completed. Symmes maintained her own personal wealth and contributed monthly funds towards the upkeep of the property (Blake Estate oral history project: oral history transcript / In the Symmes spoke at clubs about Italian gardens. She penned articles and made presentations about plants during the and She was involved in the Rose Society, the California Horticultural Society, and the California Garden Club.

She was described as an eager and patient teacher by those who worked with her at the Blake Estate (Blake Estate oral history project: oral history transcript / Mai Arbegast was a landscape architect who taught at UC Berkeley and worked in Blake Garden as a student at UC Berkeley. In the Blake Estate Oral History, once of the most accessible documents with information about Symmes, Arbegast asserted that Symmes did little landscape architectural work, except maybe for friends, and could recall knowing about only one other garden, no longer extant. This information is not accurate. Records of Symmes work have been difficult to find as her papers appear to have been lost, yet recently, additional garden designs have come to light, and more may emerge.

Consistent with other women designers of her time, Symmes did not promote her work. She was described as a modest and quiet person by various people in the Blake Estate Oral History, as well as in condolence notes Anita Blake received after Symmes death in Women landscape architects and designers in earlier eras often practiced without much attention, and this was particularly true for self-effacing women. It may be that most of Symmes' gardens were designed for people with whom she had a social connection. This reflects her social standing and was typical for women designers in that era. Some have dismissed these activities as only being a kind of social activity between society women, but these were powerful women who were working within the constraints of their milieu.

MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 11 It is clear that Mabel Symmes did create and enjoy a career as a landscape architect, and her career included working closely with prominent architects. Other than the locally well-known Blake Garden, landscapes currently identified as being by Symmes were discovered in articles about architects where Symmes was mentioned, or a homeowner has original drawings that they ve made known. The sophistication of her work suggests that the few known gardens are not her only examples. An article titled In Memorium, published in the California Historical Society Quarterly in contains this statement about Mabel Symmes: In this demanding profession of landscape architecture she built a name for herself in the San Francisco Bay area (Wickson).

Currently known designs by Symmes are listed below.5 Anson and Anita Day Blake Garden, Kensington. Architect: Walter Bliss. Drawings for the home and garden are in the possession of UC Berkeley. The home and landscape are owned by UC Berkeley and the landscape is used as a teaching and learning environment. 6 Edwin T. and Harriet Whitney Carson Blake Garden, Kensington. Architect: Walter Bliss. Drawings for the home and garden are in the possession of UC Berkeley. This garden was visited by UC Berkeley students of Katherine D. Jones in as part of their curriculum (Jones, Landscape Gardening 113 D). Marsh-Sperry Gardens, and Hawthorne Terrace, Berkeley. Henry H. Gutterson, architect. Drawings for the home and garden are in the possession of Carolyn McNiven.

The Harry Una Garden, 27 Tamalpais Road, Berkeley. Walter Ratcliff, architect. (Graham). Harold Spens Black Garden, 190 Alvarado Road, Berkeley. Clarence A. Tantau, architect (Graham). This garden was visited by students of the California School of Gardening for Women at Hayward (Smith). Frances D. Olney Garden, Claremont Berkeley. (Graham). The Charles W. Merrill garden, 407 Camino Sobrante, Orinda. (Weyeneth). The house (designed by William Ratcliff) and the garden 5 Information on the Spens Black, Una, and Frances Olney landscapes was generously supplied by Marlea Graham. 6 Anita Blake felt that the gardens lost their luster in the early days of the University ownership.

In later years, some areas lost their original designs, but some gardens close to the house have retained much of their character. MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 12 both retain character-defining features. Ratcliff worked closely with landscape architect Mabel Symmes to fashion a setting that jointed the residence with its rustic hillside setting. In this way, house and grounds were designed from the beginning to complement one another (Weyeneth). Symmes worked closely with the architect. The drawings show construction details and grading for the sloping site, and she also produced detailed planting plans. The plans are in the possession of the owners. An additional garden may have been designed for Mary Olney at Belrose Ave, Berkeley.

On Symmes death, Olney sent a condolence letter to Anita Blake, writing I bless Mabel always, surrounded as I am by her beautiful work (Olney). Certainly, the Blake Estate had some influence in the Bay Area, both for its design as well as the pioneering use of, and experimentation with, a great variety of plants, including many plants from Mediterranean climates that are now known to tolerate conditions in California (Haymaker). Anita Blake was an avid plant collector, constantly adding plants. In accounts, it s clear that an enormous and ever-changing variety of plants was incorporated into the Blake landscape at a time when experimentation with exotic plants in California was an exciting new world to explore.

At least one observer thought that it was Symmes hand at work in balancing the aesthetic qualities of the garden with an ever-changing collection of plants, making the extensive and complex gardens a successful, cohesive, and impressive landscape (Blake Estate oral history project: oral history transcript / p Symmes wrote a series of articles describing the Blake estate landscape and its plants for the Journal of the California Horticultural Society7 in Titled Adelante these articles reveal Symmes to be an intelligent, lively, and informed author, with a subtle sense of humor. Symmes was close to Victor Reiter, founder of the Pacific Horticultural Foundation, as well as influential Berkeley professors Katherine D. Jones and E. J.

Wickson, among other botanists, horticulturalists and landscape professionals. Her activities likely increased the use of the new species and varieties of plants in the region. Context Landscape architecture was still emerging as a profession when Mabel Symmes determined that she would be a designer of landscapes. A brief history of the profession in the United States generally starts Andrew Jackson Downing and his book about landscape gardening. Landscape gardening was both a craft and a profession with early practitioners straddling each. The architectural, engineering and structural aspects of the work were associated with the building 7 The journal s name was changed to California Horticultural Journal in MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO.

CA-172 PAGE 13 professions, the understanding of horticultural needs of plants with the sciences, and the required aesthetic sensitivities with the arts. However, during this time, women were not encouraged to become professionals, but to maintain a home garden, as they were thought unsuited to the work otherwise (Way, Learning the necessary skills was a self-guided endeavor in early days, benefitting from travel to foreign countries and guidance from mentors. The first courses for landscape gardening were offered in and by the a college education followed by training in an office was a preferred route, but not a necessary one.

(No accredited program existed until the The routes into the profession were many and various, and this flexibility allowed women several avenues into the profession (Way Despite the difficulties, a handful women did achieve professional status during the last decade of the and going forward into the These were almost universally women who had male mentors who encouraged their entry into the profession and provided support. It is notable that most women came from privileged backgrounds and most learned their craft through a combination of classes and mentoring. In some cases, the fledgling designers started by experimenting in their own family gardens, and then began designing gardens for friends. These women relied on their strong social connections as a source of work.

As noted by Tha sa Way, it was seen as gauche for women at that time to openly seek work, meaning that social connections played an especially important role in attaining design opportunities (Way, Women often worked out of their homes throughout their careers, and sometimes, but not usually, women operated offices with staff. In many cases during this time, they prepared planting plans, rather than full sets of plans, and collaborated with their mentors or other men. During Symmes entry into the profession in the early there were still limited numbers of women in the profession, but attitudes were changing. New generations of women who completed their training during the late and into the were opening offices in larger numbers than previously.

On the west coast, Ruth Shellhorn, in Southern California, opened her office in the and became an influential landscape architect, noted for establishing a Southern California style of landscape for commercial and residential landscapes. One of the first offices operated by women on the West Coast was 8 Just as the educational path into the profession was uncertain, terminology was not fixed. Common terms were landscape gardeners, garden architect, and landscape architect. Some professionals who limited themselves to planting plans preferred the term landscape gardener, but there was no common agreement on titles. Prior to her training at Berkeley, Symmes was listed in census records as having no profession but later did identify herself as a landscape architect Bureau of the Census).

MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 14 that of Edith Schryver and Elizabeth Lord. Schryver had worked for Ruth Shellhorn. Lord and Schryver were located in Salem, Oregon. Florence Yoch started her career with classes at UC Berkeley in transferring to Cornell, then to the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign in where she received her Bachelor of Science degree in Landscape Gardening. She opened an office in Southern California in These women were exceptional examples. By the New York Times featured an article on women designers taking the lead in Landscape Art (Way, but even now, books and articles on the history of landscape architecture often make little mention of the contributions and careers of women.

Mabel Symmes found her vocation later than most, meaning she had a short career, and she adhered to the more common examples of her time, working within the constraints of her social standing. Her currently known gardens were all designed in the with one exception in Context - Garden Styles The Mash-Sperry landscape contains both formal and informal garden areas. Symmes did give lectures on Italian garden styles, and clearly had studied them. Garden designs of the were heavily influenced by historic European styles, such as formal Italian gardens. Italian gardens were very popular, in which symmetry and restraint were prized.

Usually, the garden areas near the house were designed to be reflective of the structure s architectural form, becoming less formal and more pastoral at a distance from the house. This is the style associated most closely with Symmes, from the few known examples of her work. Flowery English-style cottage gardens, la Gertrude Jekyll had many adherents. Naturalistic designed landscapes were an idea still emerging in the but at that time, at a residential scale, only portions of landscapes would have had a naturalistic character.

Sources

503 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-172. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Architect & Engineer for Residences." San Francisco Examiner 2 Aug Bureau of the Census. "Fourteenth Census of the United States Berkeley Vers. The university should admit women on an equal basis with men. . 10 Apr Birnbaum, Charles A. and Robin Karson, Pioneers of American Landscape Design. New York: McGraw-Hill, MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 15 "Blake Estate oral history project: oral history transcript / Worldcat.org. Ed. Suzanne B. Reiss. Berkeley University of California. 20 Dec "Blake Garden Geology and Hydrology." UC Berkeley Environmental Design Archives, Blake, Anita D. "Letter to Anson Blake." Howell 14 May College Of Environmental Design, UC Berkeley. "Blake Garden." Graham, Marlea. "Mabel Symmes Timeline." Gutterson, Henry H.

"Plot Plan: Residence for Marsh, Hawthorne Terrace, Berkeley, Calif." 19 July Haymaker, Linda. "Blake Garden." Pacific Horticulture Spring p . "The Historical Validity of Blake Garden." Pacific Horticulture Spring Inspirock. Blake Garden, Berkeley. 19 Dec a45518019>. Jones, Katherine D. "Landscape Gardening 113 B." Apr 16, . "Landscape Gardening 113 D." Berkeley, 16 April Krall, Daniel W. "The Illusive Miss Bullard: First Professional Woman Landscape Architect." Landscape Journal, vol. 21, no. 1 116 19 Dec Library, Bancroft. Finding Aid to the Donald H. McLaughlin papers, 11 04 McNiven, C. F. Personal Interviews and Correspondence Janet Gracyk. McNiven, Carolyn F. "Marsh-Sperry House and Garden; Landmark Application." 19 Oct .

"Sperry-McLaughlin House and Garden; Landmark Application." 23 Sept McNiven, Marion. Personal Interview Janet Gracyk. 8 Dec Olney, Mary. "Condolence Letter." Berkeley, 5 Feb Page, Robert R and Cathy A. Gilbert and Susan A. Dolan. A Guide to Cultural Landscape Reports: Contents, Process, and Techniques. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Register, National Trust Heritage. Geelong Botanic Gardens And Eastern Park. 25 Apr 22 Dec San Francisco Chronicle. "Waterfront News and Maritime Intelligence." 29 May Smith, Laura Mercado. "The California Shcool of Gardening for Women: a History." California Horticultural Journal MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 16 "Sylvia McLaughlin Mourned and Celebrated by Save the Bay." Independent Coast Observer 22 Jan 9.

Newspaper. 11 04 Symmes, Mabel. "Adelante." Journal of the California Horticultural Society April . "Katherine Davies Jones Madro o 184 Symmes, Mabel. Katherine Davies Jones Madro o, vol. 8, no. 6, pp. 184 JSTOR, JSTOR, The Huntington Library. "Florence Yoch Papers: Finding Aid." San Marino, U.S. Department of the Interior. The Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties With Guidelines for the Treatment of Cultural Landscapes. Ed. Charles A. Birnbaum and Christine Capella Peters. Washington, DC: Interior Department, National Park Service, "U.S. Passport Application." 28 Jan University of California. "The Blue and Gold University of California, 20 Dec Way, Tha sa. Unbounded Practice: Women and Landscape Architecture in the early Twentieth Century.

Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, Weyeneth, Dr. Robert R. "National Register of Historic Places, Charles W. Merrill House, Contra Costa." Jan Wickson, Gladys C. "In Memorium: Anson Stiles Blake, Anita D. Symmes Blake, and Mabel Symmes." California Historical Society Quarterly June Woodbridge, Sally, ed. Bay Area Houses. Layton: Gibbs M. Smith, Inc.,

Written history

155 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HALS CA-172. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Janet L. Gracyk, landscape architect Aug 28, MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO. CA-172 PAGE 17 View from the back of the garden to the two homes. The property is divided up the center of the garden. Differences in care and plant choice have softened the formal lines, but the earlier garden design persists in the layout and much of the hardscape. The shared patio and vine-covered pergola is located between the houses, beyond which is the drying yard and the garages. The apartments that are above the garage are visible beyond the pergola. Photo by Janet L. Gracyk, May 2, The rear garden connects to each private garden. Here the path leads to the yard at and shows the subtle management of the sloping site. Photo by Janet L. Gracyk, May 2, MARSH-SPERRY GARDEN HALS NO.

CA-172 PAGE 18 The rhyolite stone wall on Vine Street predates the fire. Photo by Janet L. Gracyk, May 2,

In context

Berkeley, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
Alameda County, California 231 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Berkeley

10 records

The federal surveyors worked through Berkeley building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
University of California Radiation LaboratoryHAER CAL,1-BERK,4-32,726 words
Fleming GardenHALS CA-4327,081 words
Berkeley Public LibraryHABS CAL,1-BERK,5-8,536 words
University of California Radiation LaboratoryHAER CA-186-B5,575 words
Berkeley Women's City ClubHALS CA-464,816 words
Davis-Byrne BuildingHABS CAL,1-BERK,3-4,695 words
Piedmont Way & the Berkeley Property TractHALS CA-23,878 words
Berkeley City HallHABS CAL,1-BERK,2-2,601 words
Greenwood CommonHALS CA-12842 words
Peralta HallHABS CAL,1-BERK,1-34 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HALS CA-172. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.