BlockBefore

Fairfield County, Connecticut - Chapter 19, 1881

From History of Fairfield County, Connecticut, published 1881. 4,265 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

2 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

4,265 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Fairfield County, Connecticut, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 19

Idur iiiiK's l)eli)\v Xorwalk. Tlic harbor tliort' war* the best in that seetion, aiul would be acccssililc for the greater |)art of the most severe winter. From the Point to l)anl>urv the rail Wiis to run, and tliencc to West Stoekbridge, Mjiss., where the line would connect with what is now the Boston and Albany road, and whieli wa-s then liuilding from Albanj- to West Stoekhridge. This, of course, wa.s before the day of the Harlem road and in the beginning of railway enterprise in this country, - at a time wlien railways were mainly opposed on the very substantial grounds that cattle would get on the tracks and be killed.

" We shall speak first of the line from Danbury to tide-water, known in the charter as 'The Fairfield County Hailroail.' The survey was made by Alexander Twining, of New Haven, in the summer of lS;i5.

"Two surveys were made, - one along the Saugatuck River to Compo Point below Westport, and the other along the present route to Belden's Neck (Wilson's Point). The di.stanee on the Saugatuck route was about twenty-three miles, and on the Norwalk route to Belden's Neck it was twenty-six miles. In point of distance to New York, however, the latter route had tlic advantage in that it was seven miles nearer to that city by the cliannel than the former. It is not necessary to speak further of the Saugatuck route, as it was abandoned.

"The Norwalk survey, as first made by Jlr. Twi- , ning, was considerably changed before the work on the road commenced. At this end of the route it was first designed to leave Bethel out, running the road through Mountainville along the line of Simpaug Brook, and coming into the borough across South Street and parallel with Main on the east to Turner Street, where it was designed to have the station. Mr. Twining recommended, however, that, instead of following the Simpaug, the road branch to the east and run through Ura-ssy Plain into Bethel, and thus secure an important station with but a little increase in distance. The suggesti(m wa.s accepted so far as Bethel Wiis concerned, but the route at the south end of the village was not materially changed. Some one did speak of the line which is now occupied, but it was scouted at the time. The great flat between the lower bridge and Bethel was a bog, and some very wise citizen said at the time that two twelve-foot rails could be pushed down into it their full length without touching bottom. The route along the east of Main Street was strongly opposed by the owners of seventeen homesteads, who gloomily anticipated destruction to their cows and pigs by crossing the track. Mr. Twining hinted that the difficulty in building the road at Hubbell's Hill could be avoided by following the Norwalk valley into its extension Sugar Hollow and thus come into Hanbury on the west side; but this was not ftirther considered.

" While tlii'se surveys were going <in the frieu<ls of the project had thel* heads full of a through New York and .Mbany lim', and, although their charter provided for a road from Danlmry direct to tide-water only, they dreamed of the through-line and worked for it. It wiis, to speak mildly, a stupendous enterprise for a town of less than six thousand inhabitants to take hold of and attempt to carry through, for as yet there was no organized eftbrt in this direction outside of Danbury. But the progressive ones of that day worked hard for success, and earned it even if they did not receive it."

From New York To Albany Tm Danbury

" .Vs we have said, during the project of a road from Danbury to tide-water the projectors never lost sight of the feasibility of a through winter route from New York to Albany. This was a crying demand in both cities, and the Hudson River for a railway-line was not thought of ; neither, in fact, was the route through Putnam County, now known as the Harlem road. .\nd a railway-line between the two cities by way of Danbury was not so much out of the way, after all.

" The distance by the Hudson River, the most direct route, is one hundred and fifty miles; by way of Danbury it is but fourteen miles greater, as the following will show :

" Mr. Twining recommended this through-route and Messrs. .Varon Seeley, Eli T. Hoyt, and .larvis Brush, to whom the surveyor made his report, published a card indorsing the .same.

" It may not be uninteresting to our readers of thi.-- day to know what were some of the grounds on which was ba.sed a calculation in favor of a railway-line front Danbury to New York, and we herewith give the views of the gentlemen above named, as well atheir estimate of the through-business. It presentmost interesting reading, we think, to thisgeneratii>n, and the figures contemplated and those realized make entertaining comparisons. The committee advance these views in favorof direct rail-communication with tide-water : a cleiir giiin to the public. The proseiit mimiier of psissengers from Now York tu Piiiibniy, as iiscertaiiied by a reference 1o the books of the prupriotors of the staf^i'-liiies ami other sources, is l(i,riU(). The prirc of juiseage now paiil, siiul which It is not proposed to diniinisli, is one duHur. The number of piisHcnt^ei"s from the intermeilijite townj, we estim:i.tc lOOll more, f<n- which tliere is now pjiiil from fifty to seventy-five cents ; e?,timiiting the fare at the average price of sixty-two Jiml a lialf cents, ilir amount is SH25, - making the amount of revenue to l>o (h-rivi-il fmui passengers, Sl(i,i>2'). These e^stimates are based upon tlie fads ;is they now exist; but wlien wo take into consi«hM'ation the iniiea>ed atnount of trans(Kirtation and travel to be created by tlie increased facilities fur conimnnii-ation, it may safely be assumed that tin- in(orn<' from all sources of revenue will be greatly increased. For instaTice, we have stated that the present annual number of passengers fnun I)aid'ury to New York is lii,iiiH.i. This includes very few from the towns east of Itanhury, and n()ne from the southern portions of Litchfudd <_'oiuity and the eastern jiart of the counties of Dutchess and Putnam, in the State of New York. Itut the proposed road wouM undoulitedly draw to itselt -(// the travel from the entire regit)n, which, it is not uniejisoiuilde to peso, would increiLse the number of passengers to liO.iMHI, - tlius yicldini; from pjLssengers alone an income of S20,(hXi per annum. A rapid fxtetision of business ahuig the whole line of the road, and throughout The ]ioi tiou of country within the sphere of its influence, may also be confidently anticipated. In the instance of heavy articles also the increiL^ed amount of transjiortation will, in our Judgment, far exeeeil tlie estimate here made. We refer especially to the articles of coal and plaster, the former of which is now used in the interior ti) a very limited extent, but would, upon the opening of the proposed roa<l, be extensively substituted f(U- Wood. In relation to the annual expenditures, the experience of other roads enables us to i)resent an estiLiuite upon whieh we may safely rely. The annual expense of repaii-s may be i)ut at SJ'>ii(i. The cijstuf transporting freight to the amount with which this road will r.iuimeiice will not exceed thirty-five cents per ton. One trip and i>iie ictiirntrip jier day will be sufficient to accommodate all the jjassengej-s with the roarl will open, which, at S7.on per trip, for :ii:j days, makes for the year $H;!r.. The salaries of the othcei-s in the employ of tlie company may be set down at S^idOU per annum, the exjiense fur drivers and keeping hurses,* fur freight-wagons, i-tc. cxilusivi- uf passeturer-ciirs. $;i5(Ki, making in the aggregate, lor all exii.iiscs uf the cuiiipany, $V.i,mo.

is, however, another ami more enlarged view which we take of this subject. The road, aiconling tu tlie original design of its projectors, ends at Danbury. and the company, by their charter, are authorized to construct it to that place only. Hut in the courseof their in. piiries, the under>iigned have become convinced that this road is in the liin' «f the very nearest practiciible route fnr a railinnj between the cities of AVir York awl AllKmy.umi that by extending it northward through the valley of the Housatonic to West Stockbridg.-, - a distance of sixty-eight miles only, - and intersecting at that place the railri)ad from Albany to West Sturkbridge, already commenc-d, the great objei.t, su h.ng desire.l, of ejecting au open wintrr-cuuimunication between the cummercial and pulitical capitals of tlie Empire State will be ai^complished. With a view tu this object, Mr. Twining, the engineer by whom our road wsis surveyed, has examined the country between the northern termination of the Fairfiehl County Railroad and the prui)used point of intersection with the Albany and West Stockbridge Railway. The result of his examination will be found in his report.

" ' Actual surveys have demonstrated that a raihoad betwrrn the tu-. <:itieB must, fur a portion of the distance, pass through the valley of the HousaUuiic. And it has never be.-u prop. .sed, nor is it indeed posMbb-, to enti-r the valley with such road at any point farther north than at or near Caniuin Falls, forty-four miles north of Danbury. It is immaterial, however, at what point any other practicable route enters that valley, becanee it being true tliat it must be bnmght thus far east proves that

"'That the business of this purliun ut cuiintry wlii'h llie road wuuld intiusect will afl^Lud an ample reiuuucratiun to the stuckhohiers there can be no re;u<onal)le iloubt. Of its value as a channel of intercourse between New York and Alliany rm estimate has been or can bo made. \\'luii ue look at the imuH lis.- iiuiiibei"s daily jiassing between the two ( ities, and retlect that this uuniliei-, great as it now is, is daily augmenting by the increase vf population and wealth thruugbuut the coiintiy and by the opening of new lines of i-oniniuniralion tu ;iii inditirdte extent at the noi'th and west, we are admonished that its value lannut be c'alcuiated, and that all attempts to make an estimate must fail.'

" Thrrc an.' some figures in tlir rrport ut Mr. 'J'wiuiuL-^'s surviy t'roin Danlmry to tiiK'-watfr whirh arc ot full as niueli interest to us of tn-ilay as they were to those who watehed the l)ro,oTess of the sehenie. It must he borne hi mind that this was not a steam-railway, but really a horse-railway. In tliat ilay locomotives were in l)ut litth' use in this eonntry. and nothing, eomparatively, was known of tbem in \rw Eughind. My. Twiniui^V estimate for the oradino- of the road was $78(i9 a luik', or $20;i,;iS*) for the entire distanei'.

"In his estimate for the superstnuture - that is, the traek - is an item, ' Horse-])atli.' wliieli was to cost $]-2'', a mile. The horse-path was to of plank. The followiu^^ is his estimate for tiie ajipointments of the HKul:

" Jt was projioscd to make two trips tulay caeli way. The ears were to be drawn by horses, two to etieh ear. The time re(|uire(l to intike the trip was estiintited to lie three hours. As to how the I'reight-wtijioiis were, to run, or how many to a train, w:is not ileterniined on, as the roa<l was but then in its inception, and before matters prouresseil to tiiiy dei;ree locomotives came into use.

"While these estimates were being maile the 'through-line' was worked :it. Mr. Twining ami the origimitors of the road were firnily convinced that the line wonld pay and thtit it was a necessity. There was no rail-route between New York and Albany, tirnl in the winter, when navigation Wiis closed in the river, there was no eonnuunication between the two cities except by stage. The Danlmry people >oiight lo stir up enthusiasm at points along the projioseil route.

" In December, IS.'Jo, a public meeting w;is lielil in Kent, the next town above New Millbrd. It wtis a hirge meeting. Delegates were present from all towns along the proposed line from Danlmry to West f^toekbridge. A projtosed charier (granted the tidlowing year) had been draltcd, giving to the eomptiny i-h;ir- tered the right to construct a road to Bridgeport, or to the New York State line in the town of Ridgefield, or to Danl)ury. The Kent meeting determined on the route to Danhurv, and appointed Aaron Seeley, Peter Pierce, and Jay Sliears a eonimittee to employ an engineer and have a survey made and an estimate of cost prepared.

"In March following the committee secured the services of E. H. Brodhead, an experienced civil engineer, to make the survey. He entered ujion his dutie-s as soon as jjossible, and was accompanied along the course hy 5Ir. Seeley, of the committee.

" Twenty-one days were employed in this work. Not only the line proposed, but several diverging routes, at tlie suggestion of citizens living off' the line, were looked after. The line was carried, also, south of'Danbury to the New York State line in Ridgefield, at the place of E. Bouton, a distance of about eleven miles from here. The line in Danbury began at the Main Street Bridge across Still River, and Mr. Brodhead's survey ran it through Beaver Brook District, thence along the line of the Still River to its confluence with the Ousatonic (Housatonie) at New Milford. From there it followed pretty much the line now occupied by the Housatonie road to West Stockbridge, where wa.s met the railway known iis the Boston and Albany.

"The route from Danbury to the New York State line followed the course of the Still River, ])assed through Miry Brook District and entered the Sugar Hollow. Tlie ascent through the Hollow was, according to Mr. Brodhead, thirty-five feet to the mile. At Sugar Hollow Pond the line diverged to Bennett's Ponds, and thence passed through Titicus- to the neighborhood of South Salem. This route was not, however, an important item in the consideration of the road. The main thing was to get the line to Danbury through the (Jusatonic Valley, where it would connect with the Fairfield County road, to tide-water. The line from Ridgefield to West Stockbridge was eighty-one miles; from Danbury to West St<)ekbridge, seventy miles. A[r. Brodhead estimated the entire cost of the road, the longer distance, to l)e $l,247,50i).

"These figures exceeded the exi)ectation of the committee, but did not dampen their ardor. They made up their report and presented it to the convention, and with it a circular which was to go before capitalists who were looking for investments.

"The cin'ular a.ssumed that, viewed in connection with manufactures, the unusual watcr-i>ower, and the cheapness of the land thereto, the Ousatonic route was to be preferred to any other route, especially one nearer to the Hudson River (this referred to the Harlem and .Vlbany scheme). But the committee, wishing to make no uncomplimentary eomjiarison, simply say that, feeling confident that wliile the counties of Putnam and Westchester undoul>te<lly surpass the Ousatonic Valley as m agricultural country, yet they feel confident it is numufactories that must give business to a railway and profit to the stockholders, and so, without comparing this route with the one farther west, they invite capitalists to examine for themselves.

" The committee were very much in earnest, even to the extent of using italic. 'Should the capitalists of the cities of Albany and New York prefer the western route,' say the committee, 'we appeal to the peopleof the Ousatonic Valley to come forward in all their strength, and, relying upon their own resources, to construct it road to tide-water.'

" The people of the valley eventually came forward in all their strength and constnicted a road to tidewater, but not as the committee expected, and certainly not a.s they de-sired.

"Messrs. Hoyt and Seeley attended a big railroad meeting in Albany just previous to the Kent meeting. They went there to present the Ousatonic Valley route, and to learn what could be learned of the condition of the railroad pulse. Hi Barnes drove them there in a carriage. While in Albany a heavy snowstorm fell, and made it impossible for them to get back as they went. 5Ir. Barnes was equal to theemergency, however, and very soon succeeded in trailing oft" his carriage for a sleigh, hy which the returntrip was made. At any gathering of railway sympathizers which presented an opportunity to ventilate their favorite scheme these two men might be founil

"While these movements were being made, Bridgi port, which was not thought of by any one as a railroad point, began to realize that there was danger ol losing something. The something in question was all the business of the Housatonie Valley.

" When Bridgeport got on high ground where it could look ofl' some other direction than seaward, it saw that by way of Danbury and Norwalk was so much more direct for a line to New York than liy way of itself that should the road be built thenwould never be the ghost of a chance for it to get thi' business of the upper Housatonie Valley. It wouM all go the shorter route.

" Danbury as yet had no road to tide-water. If Bridgeport could Imild a road from New Milford to itself, then it would stand a very good chance to takithe business of tin- Housatcmic Valley should a road be put through it. Alfred M. Bishop, father of William D. Bishop, was considerably interested in the ])roposed road, ami eanu' to Danbury to talk over the matter with our jieople. He oflered to carry through the Fairfiehl C'ounty railway if DaTd>ury would raise one hundred thousand dollars for that purpose. There were those in favor of doing it, of course; but there were so many more op])ased to it that the scheme fell through. He next tried Bridgeport, and that city, being a trifle more awake than we, or a trifle less honest,* we are not sure which, pledged two hundred

"The reader remembers, jierluqxs, that there were two objeetive points at tiile-waler, - one at AVestport and the other below South Noi-walk. This end of the line was rampant for the road, but there was not so much interest taken below. Jt was desirable to get one hundred thousand dollars from the other end, and our railway eonimittee made several journeys with that objeet in view. W'estjiort wanted the road, but its anxiety was not a liundred thousand dollar,^' worth. Xorwalk felt lln' same. Year after year pa.ssed away in this state of affairs, and then Xorwalk peoide awoke up to tlu' lull iniportanee of the line, and the money was suliserilu'd.

"Work on the road was b(;:un in the fall of ],s.')(). Beard, C'hureh & Co, were the contractors. Deacon John F. Bearil being the senior of tin' tinn. The total cost of constrnctiug ami ec|ui]ipinir the road was three hundred and seventy thousand ei,nht hundred and twenty-one dollars. The ecpiipment consisted of three locomotives, four fii'st-class and two secondclass pa.ssenger-cars, eight box-, sixteen plattbrm-, and three hand-cars. ( )n tlie 1st of JIarch the road was so far completed as to lun tiains. The station in Danbury was a subject (d' considerable discussion. The down-town subseriljers wanted it in that neighborhood, while the up-town subsi-riliers wanted it where it now is. As the hitter's stock was nim-h more than the former's, they carrieil the day : whereupon the dis.satisfaction was so great among the disapjjointed that the successful ones took tlieir stock otf their hands.

"We of this day, enjoying tlu' coni|jlcted line, little realize what the tbunders endured and had to contend against to get the road through. There was trouble in securing tln' right of way, in the construction, and in the payment of the subserijitions. ( >ne notable ca.se in the last-named class is worthy of mention. Down at Beldeu's Xeck lived a Xew Y(irk nu'rchant, and in Xorwalk village lived another. The former we will call W,, ami the latter 8. 8. subscribed five thou.sand dollars. W. was then seen, and was told what S. had done. He said S. could take twenty thousand dollars' worth of stock just as well as not, and, if he did so, he, W., would guarantee him six per cent, from the earnings of the road, providing S. would let him vote on his stock. W. then took five thousantl dollars' worth. S, was seen, and tohl what W. had .said. Lpon that he made his subscription twenty thousand doU.us. When the money was called tor the eager W. refused to jiay, ami suit was brought by the company to forie him to k. ei) his word. W. claimed that the din'ctors had violated the terms id' agreement in several ]iarticulars, and l>elic\iil he could annul the snbseri]ition ; but he failed, and the comjiany rccovcreil.

.Mr. Tweeily continued as secretary uidil Aug. ii, lS(i4, when Harvey Williams was elected to the otHce. Mr. Ives served as treasurer until that ]ieriod when the two offices were merged in one, Mr. Williams being both secretary and treasurer, and continues as suidi at this writing.

" ^Ir. Smith served as supcriidcmlent until ]>rostrated by a paralytic stndvc in l.S.")!(. .John W. Bacon was appointed in his place July 14, ls."ill, and served until Jan. 1, 1X7C>, wdicn L. W. Sandiforth, the present incumbent, was chosen.

" Wlu'U the road was opened the rails for some distance this side of Redding were laid on the ground, the earth being frozen .so hard as to bear the weight id' the train. This was done because the iiim|dction had been delayed for a considerable time beyond that set for its finish, and people were anxious to see a train go through.

"The first conductor was Henry Panks, who died sonu' years ago. He was a nmn of nuirked suavity of manner and .speech. Many anecdotes are told of him illustrating this jjlea.sant quality. ( )n leaving Xorwalk he would observe, 'Those who are about to proceed on the train will ])lease take their seats.' X"owa-days it's ' All 'board 1'

"When coming to Xorwalk station it was his custom to notify the passengers of th(> fact by impressively rcnuirking, as if in the presence of some great mechanism, 'The train will ])re.sently reach Xorwalk Bridge.' After leaving liefhel he would explain, ' We are now approaching the village of Danbury, which is the terminus of the road.'

" In 1844 the New York and Ilartfonl mad was projected. It was to pass throufrh Danbury and thence to New York rin >\'hite I'lains, N. Y. We can now see what a splendid piece of iirojierty it would have become had it lived. But it fell through, and a goodly portion of the contemplated line between here and Hartford is now occupied by the survey of the New York and New England Railway.

" The committee appointed to secure the survey of the roa<l made an estimate of the business in the circular to the public which they issued. Our readers remember it. Tliese figure.s, made in 1835, are interesting comi)ared with what the road did the first year after it was finished, 18r)2 - 5.3. The circular estimated its first year's business in freight to be $32,000. The passenger-traffic the circular fixed at $10,()2o, making a total of i-'42,62o. The first rei)ort of the business of the road showed that the earnings for the first fifteen months of its existence were §51,237.70. So the authors of the circular had made a remarkably close estimate. The second rejjort covered a period of eleven months, in which the earnings were $52,- 706.68. The through-fare was seventy-five cents.

" It is not often a new road so fully answers the expectation of its projectors as did the Danbury and Norwalk road. The directors, in the report referred to above, say, -

" ' T!ic result of the ox|Mjrience of tlie eompany since the cominoncemcnt of the operationR upon the road hiu been fully to corrotiornte theopinioD uniformly expresaod by the tlireclors, llmt the Piinbury and Norwalk Railroad will prove a ttnccessful and prolltable enterprise, and the fuvornblc incronse of the iMwt year demonstrates that, but for the disa^itrous AoimIh And the unusual expcndilurc« rendered necessary thereby, the net earnings for the year would have warranted two divideu<ls of three per ceut. each, paid interest and taxes, and left a suqilns of ^VJ4U.*

" The floods referred to were three in number. The.se occurred iu the fall of 1853 and the spring of 1854. They were disastrous in effect, delaying travel for sixteen days, and causing an expense of four thousand dollars for temporary repairs, and nine thousand dollars in addition for a thorough reconstruction of the damaged i>ortions.*

" RuUjefirhl Brniirh. - In 1870 a branch road from Branchville to Hidgefield Village was built, with a view to accommodating the business of that place. Heretofore the connection had been made by stage. The distance is four miles.

"In 1872 another l)ranch was built, running from Bethel to Hawlcyville, to connect with the Shcpaug Railway, which runs from Litchfield to Hawlcyville. This wius done to control thi' business of the Shepaug valley. The length of the branch is six miles. The cost of both these extensions was at the rate of forty thousand dollars a mile.

Provenance

Text from History of Fairfield County, Connecticut, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.