Hartford County, Connecticut - The whole text, 1928 (part 3 of 12)
From History of Hartford County, Connecticut, 1633-1928 : Being a Study of the First Makers of the Constitution and the Story of Their Lives, of Their Descendents and of All Who Have Come, published 1928. 15,957 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
5 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,957 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Hartford County, Connecticut, 1633-1928 : Being a Study of the First Makers of the Constitution and the Story of Their Lives, of Their Descendents and of All Who Have Come, published 1928. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
In a summer of pestilence, 1647, he was stricken and after a few days of suffering died on July 7. He was only 61. He had lived to know of Laud's incarceration, in 1641, and of his execution, in 1645 - to enjoy the success of his ecclesiastical theories and to witness the happy development of his design to secure government of and by the people.
Mr. Hooker's children, many of whose descendants continue to live within a short radius of his first meeting-house, were: Johanna, wife of Rev. Thomas Shepard of Cambridge, who died the year before her father; Mary, wife of Rev. Roger Newton, Farmington's first minister and later at Milford where she died in 1676; Anne and Sarah who died in childhood in England; John, who in his father's will was forbidden "from tarrying in England" after he got his education at Oxford but who did tarry and became rector of Lechampsted before his death in 1684; Samuel, graduated at Harvard in 1653, a preacher at Plymouth, who married the daughter of Capt. Thomas Willet, afterward first mayor of New York, was ordained in Farmington in 1661 and died there in 1697; and Sarah, wife of Rev. John Wilson of Medfield, Massachusetts.
Rev. Jonathan Mitchell was invited to succeed Mr. Hooker in 1649. After him as a candidate came Michael Wigglesworth occasionally in 1653 and 1654, John Davis in 1655 and John Cotton, son of John Cotton of Boston and formerly of the "Hooker party," in 1659. Meantime Teacher Stone and Elder Goodwin were conducting the affairs of the church. These two, so useful under Hooker, had such a falling-out over the candidacy of Wigglesworth, whom the elder favored, as nearly to disrupt the settlement. To Mr. "Stone's refusal to allow the society to vote on Mr. Wigglesworth, Goodwin took exception and started the breach. Mr. Stone sent in his resignation yet continued to discharge his functions and went so far as to have the church appoint a moderator, which in effect was the discharge of the ruling elder. Mr. Goodwin and his faction immediately withdrew. Ecclesiastical councils were held throughout New England, the Massachusetts churches appointed days of humiliation and prayer for Hartford, the interference of the General Court made matters worse, Mr.
First Church Of Christ, Hartford
Stone went to Boston as though he would remain there whence he wrote letters, and finally a council held in Boston in 1659 decided that Elder Goodwin and party were doing nothing wrong in withdrawing to Hadley, Mass., - whither they were accompanied by a few Wethersfield people - and that Mr. Stone should continue.
The year following this settlement, Rev. John Whiting, who was born in England in 1635 but had come to America as a boy and had graduated at Harvard in 1653, was chosen for Mr. Stone's colleague. He was the son of Maj. William Whiting, one of the foremost men of the colony from its founding till his death in 1647. Mr. Stone died July 20, 1663. His epitaph calls him "New England's glory and her radiant crowne;" the last line reading :
"Hartford, thy richest jewel 's here interred." He also was only 61. When Mr. Stone's first wife died in 1640 Mr. Hooker wrote to Rev. Mr. Shepard that she "smoaked out her days in the darkness of melancholy." His son by her was graduated at Harvard and later received his degree at Cambridge, England. His son Samuel went to Harvard and afterwards was colleague of Rev. Gershom Bulkeley in Wethersfield, preached in Simsbury and Middletown, became dissipated, haunted Hartford taverns and in 1683 fell into Little River after a carouse and was drowned - according to Rev. Mr. Whiting's letter to Increase Mather. Mr. Stone's daughters married well.
Again it should be kept in mind that no special incidents of the colonial days should be taken from their settings. The handful of immigrants had not conquered the wilderness in the first twenty or sixty years. Life was drab. A new element was sought to help in the physical labors; there had to be a lowering of "admission" tests. Reference has been made to the strengthening of the liquor laws and to the development of the house of correction. There were the beginnings of the evils which were to sweep the new Eldorado and constitute a problem of varied guise today. If there is any opportunity for comparison in modern ages, it must be with the development of the western regions and California, somewhat to the advantage of the eastern sections.
Intellectually and ecclesiastically, it should also be remembered, the original colonists had come to America for freedom of thought, and they intensively cultivated freedom of expression. The church convulsion which shook every town and hamlet in New England the latter half of their first century is as difficult to analyze correctly as certain of those today will be 300 years hence. The "Half-way Covenant" uprising can be set forth in volumes by theological writers when recurring to such excitement as there was in Hartford - and the same with the "New Lights" in the following century. For ordinary purposes of history, however, the whole may be summed up this way : The old church conception was that those baptized in infancy could become church members when old enough to profess their faith and to be examined by the church officials. In 1650 to 1660 the idea spread that children of such members could be baptized - indeed, would be baptized - and then when older could be admitted to membership without the old formality; they could own the covenant without giving proof of baptism. To the conservatives this had the appearance of a political device originating in Massachusetts where church membership was the qualification for suffrage, and there was surprise that such a notion could gain ground in free Connecticut. In 1664, the new conception had gained sufficient ground to warrant the General Assembly in urging its adoption by all the churches, though not all followed such respected advice.
In the Hartford church, after the death of Mr. Stone, the son of another distinguished citizen, Gov. John Haynes, had been chosen to succeed him. Thomas Haynes only recently had graduated from Harvard - in 1658. He was imbued with the new idea and in 1666 advocated its adoption by the church. Rev. John Whiting, senior colleague, emphatically objected; it was a blow at pure Congregationalism and let down the bars to Presbyterianism while lowering the standards of membership. "Saints" should be "visible," and they could not be "visible" unless warranted in the old way. Doctor Walker expresses it: "Half-way Covenant was filling the churches with people sufficiently religious to claim baptism for their children but not enough so to have or profess any experience of piety or to come to the Lord's supper." In other words, they had started well but they were in a state of education, free as to their future course, and therefore hardly congenial at communion with the "visible saints." Moreover this must lead to government by synod instead of government by self, an unthinkable thing for the church of Thomas Hooker. So reasoned Rev. Mr. Haynes. But the younger Whiting was persistent and led his flock of thirty-one away with him, after the General Assembly, though by close vote, had decided in February, 1670, that the church might be divided.
When the sharpness of this cleavage in the historic Hooker church is emphasized by many writers, one making a thorough study of the period can but recall the natural and then civic division between north and south sides of Little River, growing more noticeable every year, almost like two towns at the very beginning. "South" church instead of "Second" church has been the popular name of the new society ever since. It further can be remarked in this connection that an original church in any town frowned upon a division even for branches in remote places like East Hartford (from Hartford), since diminished membership meant decrease in indispensable revenue. Finally, it is to be noted that the Hooker church soon afterward accepted the halfway covenant principle.
By the code of 1650 colonists were taxed from 1 penny to 3 pence a pound for "encouragement of the ministry" but in 1677 the towns had to support their own churches. It was expensive to change ministers, for when one was chosen he was allowed two years' salary to begin with so that he might establish his home. In 1668 the General Assembly passed its first Toleration Act when it granted that "sundry persons of worth for prudence and piety amongst us * * * may have allowance of their perswasion and profession in church wayes." Nevertheless the support of the ministry continued compulsory and fines were demanded for absence from service. Repeated exhibition of the harm resulting from having every church disagreement brought to the General Assembly caused that body in 1708 to direct each of the forty-one churches to send representatives to a synod in Saybrook where the famous Saybrook Platform was adopted. Only twelve ministers and four laymen obeyed the call but their action was at once ratified by the Legislature, thereby creating a "government within a government," for there was to be a consociation or permanent organization, consisting of the minister and one delegate from each church "planted in a convenient vicinity." Disputes should there be settled in common communion. Delegates from all the consociations should meet annually. In this was a suggestion of Presbyterianism and the word became interchangeable with Congregationalism for many years. Only churches united by this platform were "owned and acknowledged established by law." There were two consociations in Hartford County. As will be seen in some of the town histories, there were instances of contempt for the plan. Unquestionably it did create a better working system and as Rev. George L. Clark, historian, says, it "may have been the best possible device to tide the churches over trying times."
In establishing the platform the General Assembly specifically provided that all who "soberly" differed from the United Churches could worship in their own way, according to their consciences. This gave the Quakers, intolerable as they had made themselves in Massachusetts, the Episcopalians, the Baptists and even the troublous Rogerines of New London no cause for complaint to the English government which was threatening to send a governor for all New England. The "outlanders" were not welcome but, as in the case of the Quakers who sought persecution, they were given fair hearing - twice in Hartford - and then urged to go elsewhere. Experience with bishops had left such a sting that toleration of Episcopalianism by the people was long in being brought about. The missionary priests out from New York were zealously encouraged from London and the taxation for Congregationalism aroused such ire over there that the General Assembly provided that dissenters could form distinct organization, as previously stated, provided they worked no injury to the established church. In 1727 this was followed by a law that in towns where there was an Episcopal church, those attending it could pay their taxes to it; and altogether, rocky as was their path, they admit that it was less so in Connecticut than in any other colony. Their own energies resulted in 1784 in the consecration of the first bishop in America, Samuel Seabury, at Woodbury. Meanwhile concessions were being granted to various sects.
years after the Second Church of Christ was established in Hartford an amendment went into effect by which people could contribute for the church they attended. After meeting in private dwellings, probably, the new society, being without power to hold real estate and not having a vote of the town for building, erected a structure on the unoccupied land of Lieut. Thomas Bull near the present southeast corner of Main and Sheldon streets near the schoolhouse which was in the highway. This had been completed by 1673. During the next fifteen years ten members of the congregation made handsome bequests to the society, and it may be added that the generous disposition so early displayed is as much in evidence today as it was then. The building was fifty feet square, fashioned much like that of the parent society.
The "town bell" served for both churches till it cracked in 1725. It hung in the First Church belfry but it was felt that the repairs should be paid for by the town, that is by both societies. The question was complicated by the fact that both congregations needed new houses, and the First Church suggested that they reunite. In the interim it was using a red flag as a signal in place of a bell. The Southsiders, now nearly equal in number and wealth, believed there could not be agreement on a convenient site. After eleven years of discussion, the First Church voted to build on the southeast corner of the burying ground, the present corner of Main and Gold streets. The vote was passed in 1734. It called for brick but wood was substituted. The building was sixty-six feet long, lengthwise with Main Street, and forty-six feet wide, the steeple on the north end, the doors at that end, at the south end and on the east side, the pulpit with its soundingboard on the west side. One "great alley" ran from the east door to the pulpit and another from the north to the south. Rev. Daniel Wadsworth preached his last sermon in the old church July 31, 1737. Timbers from the honored structure were incorporated in the new building and are said to form part of the present one. Services were held in the State House till the new buildingwas ready, December 30, 1739.
It was ten years later that the Second Church voted to build. The General Court, still holding prerogative to that extent, chose a site in the highway which is now Buckingham Street. As the proposed edifice, the same size as that of the parent church, would practically fill the highway, and as the north side was under water in flood time, while a brook on the Main Street side would endanger the foundation, there was two years of hesitancy, then an appeal to the General Assembly, and finally an agreement reached for a site thirty feet east of the one indicated, two-thirds of the building to be in Main Street. Exterior and interior of the building, which was completed in 1754, closely resembled those of the First Church. The first sermon preached there was by Rev. George Whitefield, December 2, 1755. Rev. Elnathan Whitman was then pastor and continued as such for forty-five years. In 1762 the society received a deed to about four acres of land south of the church, given by Joseph Buckingham, son of Rev. Thomas Buckingham, former pastor to whom the society had conveyed the same in 1696. Both societies were to rebuild, as will be seen, on practically the same sites, and their continuing to occupy them is an important feature in Hartford's history.
In the history of the progress of civilization there is nothing more anomalous than the horrors committed under authority of the Scriptures as interpreted. Other contestants for the literal interpretation of the Mosaic code have had to yield to the demand of humanity, but in no particular with greater gratification to their descendants than in this. And when condemnations are flung at the American colonies, it is well to recall that for 300 years before the subject came up in the colonies there had been a fierce battle against those declared to be in collusion with Satan and that over 100,000 had been executed barbarously. For it is written in the Book of Exodus: "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live." A century after the frightful craze on the Continent, the mighty legal mind of Blackstone gave forth this opinion : "To deny the possibility, nay, actual evidence of witchcraft and sorcery, is at once flatly to contradict the revealed word of God in various passages of the Old and New Testament."
The horrors of Salem in Massachusetts are marveled at today. But they were in 1692. By that time the "craze" in Connecticut had yielded to common sense considerations and juries no longer were accepting ridiculous testimony of neighbors against odd characters who had fallen under suspicion. The vie- tims themselves were of a class who made trouble or enjoyed sensation at whatever risk, and the witnesses were of the class of professional talebearers, all mentally upset by the excitement of the hour. In Connecticut between 1647 and 1690 when the furore ended, there were but nine executions, of which three probably were in Hartford where the colony prison was located. The first victim - and probably the first in New England - was Alse Young of Windsor in 1647. The records furnish no details. Of Mary Johnson's case in Wethersfield the next year, Cotton Mather in his "Magnalia," referring to her having given birth to a child while in prison, wrote : "She died in a frame of mind extremely to the satisfaction of them that were spectators of it." In 1653 John Carrington, a Wethersfield carpenter, and his wife were hanged.
An illustration of how the evil spread is found in the instance of Ann Cole of Hartford and Wethersfield. She became religiously rabid and accused a neighbor who was sent to prison for a year and then removed to Rhode Island. Next to the Cole family lived Nathaniel Greensmith and his wife Rebecca. Rev. John Whiting wrote of the latter that she was of bad character. She caught the fever of confessing all the misdeeds accredited to witches and implicated her husband. In 1662 both were tried in Hartford. The two ministers, Haynes and Whiting, visited the woman in prison and sent her amazing confessions to John Mather who declared the evidence very convincing. Rev. Samuel Stone was deeply impressed with her accounts of how Satan appeared to her in various forms, as of a deer or fawn, and told her they would have "a merry meeting by Christmas;" her husband must be guilty because he brought in logs too large for a little man to handle. They were hanged in January, 1662, on Gallows Hill.
A supposed victim was Mary Barnes of Farmington whose case followed closely those of the Greensmiths. The most peculiar case was that of the well-to-do Katherine Harrison of Wethersfield in May, 1669. Governor John Winthrop, Jr., William Leete and Maj. John Mason were of the court. It was the usual charge of "familiarity with Satan, the grand enemy of mankind." She demanded a jury trial. When the jury disagreed, she was held for another trial in October. The testimony of the witnesses was wildly imaginative and grotesque, as it reads to us. She had appeared with the body of an animal ; she had tried to cut throats, to strangle, to break bones; she was a notorious liar and told fortunes. The jury having found her guilty, the magistrates advised with the ministers. Rev. Gershom Bulkeley of Wethersfield reported for them that whatever was beyond reason in the way of divination argued familiarity with Satan, "inasmuch as such a person doth thereby declare his receiving the devilPs instrument to communicate the same to others." This accused made no confession; she fought back and petitioned for relief. Becoming enraged, without losing her reason, she abused Michael Griswold who forthwith won a £40 damage suit against her. Eventually the court decided upon a year in prison. The General Assembly refused to concur and commuted the sentence to removal from the community, for her good and her neighbors'. The people in a New York town in which she took up her abode besought the governor to secure her banishment but he refused and bade her go wherever she chose.
A peculiar case is found in the manuscripts of President Ezra Stiles of Yale. In 1651, on the occasion of a military parade, Henry Stiles, eldest of the brothers who came to Windsor for SaltonstalPs proposed settlement in 1635, was killed by the accidental discharge of a gun in the hands of Thomas Allyn of Windsor. Allyn was fined £20 according to the records of the General Court, was put on probation for a year and was forbidden to bear arms during that time. At a Particular Court in 1654, Lydia Gilbert of Windsor was indicted for witchcraft and, among other things, for having caused Stiles' death. Stiles had been a bachelor and had boarded with Thomas Gilbert, a neighbor who was in his employ. Whether Lydia was the wife or daughter of Gilbert does not appear, but from the wording of the indictment it would seem that she had been a trouble-maker in her neighborhood and easily could fall a victim to those suffering from witchcraft hallucination. She was tried and convicted but there is no record of her execution.
Constitution And Charter
The method of the founders of 1635 in achieving their high purpose culminating in the Constitution was no less masterly, tested by the standards of whatever generation, than that of their successors in securing their charter from a restored monarchy in 1662. The Congregational Church itself was no longer the allembracing entity; it had been the nucleus for widely different and not always amenable elements, but it was standing the test of control during unprecedented experiences and was to continue to be the foundation of the government through many succeeding generations. In its efforts to adapt circumstances to itself, it was competent to detect its own errors, and, with population and territory increasing, wTas cautiously adapting itself to circumstances without yielding its principles. The vote was still the freeman's, pledged to fealty; church-membership was not his test ; the government was in his hands, with the promoters of the system carefully guiding and instructing him (in those first days of experiment) ; and if his tax, willy nilly, went to help maintain churches, it was because the name of the Almighty and his Word were still keenly recognized in public and private affairs, and it was believed they always should be. There was this much hold-over from the experience of generations in the land of their birth. Therein is a feature ignored by modern critics who see in the change from the union of church and state in the 1800s a fierce rebellion and not a step in sequence - a step impelled by changing conditions, creeds and population, and approved or acquiesced in by men themselves descendants of the founders.
American soil, through England's stormy periods of no Parliment, of the Long Parliament, of the overthrow of monarchy and of the great Protectorate. Could it cope with the new monarchy that had been set up - with Charles II, the successor of the beheaded Charles I whose judges had found their refuge in this New England? Diverting thought for the moment from the much-described achievements, no imagination is too feeble to picture the actual qualms. None of the qualms were written into official records, either then or when a new political peril threatened with the next change in royal government. Outwardly and barring their correspondence, the founders were stoics; "publicity" was not to become the rule and requirement in affairs public or private for many years to come. As for the people, in their small communities, they knew and trusted their leaders from the outset, and on the advent of John Winthrop, Jr., to the governor's office, they had repealed their law prohibiting two terms in succession. After testing by means of alternative terms, they had concluded that, a man's fidelity attested, his experience was worth much to them. Similarly with the magistrates, though would-be dispassionate writers in later years set forth that it was the system of balloting which compelled this.
Hooker had been blunt in his determination but tactful and wise in his planning, a bold pioneer and a noble intellectual leader. Ludlow had been a jurist and a builder, though perhaps justifiably impatient at the last; Haynes, a gracious executive, with prestige; Mason, a stern captain of the guard. Their generation was passing when the news came in 1659 that the Protectorate had ended, and it especially behooved a colony with a questioned patent and a record for independence to look to its standing. A crisis impended in which argument might not prevail; keenest felicity was demanded.
One man was recognized above all others to meet this requirement, a man whose name should be placed alongside Hooker's a man whose attributes were sufficiently different from those of Hooker, Ludlow and the others to exercise the diplomacy now necessary at the royal seat of all government. This was the younger Winthrop who had worked out the Warwick Patent understanding. He, if anyone, could stand for the dependability of that patent even when all patents were in danger; he was familiar by birth and experience with court ways and he, as governor,
Fitz John Winthrop
"As a child he had been the pride of his father's house; he had received the best instruction which Cambridge and Dublin could afford, and had perfected his education by visiting, in part at least, in the public service, not Holland and France only, in the days of Prince Maurice and Richelieu, but Venice and Constantinople. As he traveled through Europe he sought the society of men eminent for learning. Returning to England in the bloom of life, with the fairest promise of advancement, he preferred to follow his father to the New World, regarding 'diversities of countries but as many inns,' alike conducting to 'the journey's end.' When his father became impoverished, the son, unsolicited and without recompense, relinquished his inheritance, that it 'might be spent in furthering the great work' in Massachusetts; himself, without wealth, engaging in the enterprise of planting Connecticut. Care for posterity seemed the motive to his actions. Understanding the springs of action, and the principles that control affairs, he never attempted impracticable things, and noiselessly succeeded in all that he undertook. The New World was full of his praises. Puritans and Quakers and the freemen of Rhode Island were alike his eulogists. The Dutch at New York had confidence in his integrity, and it is the beautiful testimony of his own father that 'God gave him favor in the eyes of all with whom he had to do.' "
Narrative of facts brings out the romance of history, especially at a point like this. Winthrop was chosen to make the journey to London, and the way - it was supposed by the magistrates - was paved by two letters. Massachusetts, Plymouth and finally New Haven reluctantly had hailed the new sovereign, as in duty bound and with courtly words, but Connecticut pondered and remained silent till July 7, 1661, when it addressed the King. But a month prior to this petition the General Court had written Lord Saye and Sele, for years the spokesman of the Puritans, a letter which shows the conception at this time of certain important proceedings previously mentioned herein, chronologically. The letter referred to his "former encouragement" and his present interest "by value of patent power" and begged his assistance. It reviewed the purchase from Fenwick who "for reasons best known to himself" wished to return to England. The purchase was "exceedingly opposed" by several who said this would be distasteful to his lordship and the patentees, but it was pressed by Fen wick ("God removing some from us by death that were interested in the hearts and affection of several of those nobles and gentlemen, the patentees in England"). Fenwick insisted he had the power to sell, "the rest of the patentees deserting," and the matter "falling into his hands by agreement," and also declaring that he might sell to "noisome neighbors" (the Dutch), whereupon, for peace and security, agreement was made for about £1600 - a "great abuse at Mr. Fenwick's hands," considering the poverty of the people and the small advantage gained. Indeed, the condition was worse than if they had contented themselves with the patronage of the ""grand patentees," for there was no copy of the patent to secure standing as a commonwealth and assure continuance of privileges so dearly paid for; nor was there anything given by Fenwick which would bind him and his heirs as to rights above the professed Massachusetts border; and, being destitute of patent or copy, the purchasers could not maintain their claims even on the Narragansett side. The petition concluded by saying that Winthrop would call on him for advice and counsel and they would pray that "an inundation of mercies may flow in upon your lordship."
In the petition to the King the General Court said that it had not had the opportunity to obtain from the King such patent as would assure them of privileges and power to enable them to face the great hardships and hazards in this remote place where subsistence was to be had only as a result of infinite labor and Already the settlers had spent much on buildings and defenses to add to the honor and enlargement of the King's dominions. They had paid a large sum to Fenwick for a jurisdiction right which they had understood was from "true royal authority" and would submit a copy of a copy which, after the first had been lost by fire or in some other way, had sufficed till they could take up the matter of royal prerogatives. They besought the King to confirm those privileges or else the privileges under the old Massachusetts grant, encouraged by which such endeavor had been put forth and under which at first it was supposed Connecticut territory was covered. Also and moreover, there was the defensive war against the heathen which had cost much in life and means ("divers of our dear countrymen were treacherously destroyed") and still was the colony under great expense for maintenance, all of which, hopefully, should bring immunity from customs and promotion of commerce in the products this land could furnish. They subscribed themselves, without fulsomeness, loyal subjects and servants.
During the summer the court framed such a charter as the members thought would be proper, and Winthrop sent it here in August. The missing copy of the Warwick patent was found by Winthrop in England among papers that were left by Edward Hopkins after his death there. Doctor Trumbull in his "Colonial Records" expresses the opinion that neither before nor after the purchase did the colonists have rights in the territory other than by occupation, purchase from the Indians and by conquest of the Pequots, and that their purpose had been to buy off as quietly as possible any who might challenge their claims. Gov. Simeon E. Baldwin's theory concerning the original copy is that the Earl of Warwick gave the document to his heir, one of the patentees, and in the confusion of war and the extinction of the earl's family it was not strange that the copy of the copy was all that existed to support the claim prior to the charter of 1662.
Saye and Sele cooperated earnestly with Winthrop. There were many obstacles to be overcome. The secretary of state for the colonies, in a letter, expressed grave fear that the colony had altogether too much freedom, and there were those in the King's circle who agreed with him. But the gravest feature of all - a feature which ordinarily would have precluded the possibility of sending Winthrop on such a mission - had to do with Winthrop's own father-in-law, Rev. Hugh Peters. He had been the outspoken pastor of a church of exiles at Rotterdam, and crossing to New England, had begun his activities in behalf of the colonies as pastor of the church at Salem. One of the promoters of the federation of the colonies, he had been chairman of the commission on international affairs and, while fiery of temper, had been one of the strongest of the group which included Hooker, the elder Winthrop and Haynes.
when men like Stephen Winthrop, brother of John Winthrop, Jr., Capt. Israel Stoughton of Pequot war fame, George Fenwick of Saybrook, Edward Winslow of Plymouth and Gov. Edward Hopkins of Connecticut returned to England to help on Cromwell's cause, and when Hooker felt obliged to reject the petitions of eminent Parliamentarians to return to participate in reforming the church (because he would be in the minority among so many Presbyterians), Peters was among the first to improve such an opportunity. To his mind, England was then the field for the Puritans to cultivate; immigration having decreased, New England was suffering in agriculture and commerce, many were leaving the new country and not a few were returning to their old homes across the sea. And when the war was ended, he was the one chosen to preach "the funeral sermon to the King, after sentence, out of Esaias:" 'Thou art cast out of the grave like an abominable branch, * * * as a carcass trodden under feet * * because thou hast destroyed thy land and slain thy people." And only shortly before Winthrop appeared in London, when Charles II had limited to about ten the number of his father's executioners who should be put to death, Hugh Peters had been one of those selected. His memory ever was revered among the Puritans of the stamp of Milton, but the fullblooded Charles hardly could be supposed to have regained his equanimity.
Winthrop's education and genius carried the day against the opposition of many in court circles. A ring which had been presented to Winthrop's father by Charles I was received most gratefully by his majesty, and in various ways the governor-diplomat won the monarch's personal esteem. His preliminary address was skilfully couched. It voiced the lament of the colonists that they were separated by the sea from the noble seat of government and their gracious monarch; their grief over the wars in England and their feeling that they had been hidden behind the mountains like a people forsaken in a desert, not applying to an illegal government but waiting upon divine Providence. He besought the sovereign "to accept this colony, your own colony, a little branch of your mighty hemisphere" - and he obtained all the territory from Narragansett Bay to the Pacific, including the charterless colony of New Haven.
He wrote the happy news to Deputy Governor Mason in May and sent the precious document in August, he prolonging his stay because of other concern, including participation in the founding of the Royal Society. It was with regret that the King sawT him depart. The charter was issued in duplicate, a fact which was to make romantic history a little later on and to pique curiosity till 1898.
It is said, and appears evident, that Winthrop did not present the charter endorsed by the General Court but instead one that he drew up in connection with counsel employed by himself. It was the most liberal charter ever granted. In the main it perpetuated the principles of the Fundamental Orders, giving the colony under royal warrant that independence for which it had been founded. There were to be a governor, a deputy governor, twelve assistants and a House of Deputies, two from each town, all elected annually. Laws were not to be made contrary to those of England, but they did not have to be transmitted to England for inspection nor was there provision for royal interference of any kind. The charter was received with much rejoicing and was approved by the people in October. A charter also was obtained for Rhode Island.
Possibly a reason why New Haven territory was included in the charter was that that colony had harbored the regicides, Goff , Whalley and Dixwell. Deep and severe were the reproaches of John Davenport and his followers. After four months of rebuffing overtures, the New Haven General Court voted to continue its own government. Winthrop had not yet returned. In a letter to Deputy Governor Mason he urged that matters should not be pushed too hard and had hoped from the beginning that New Haven would exercise its option, but the General Assembly (as it was now called) disregarded the advice, recognized the outlyingtowns that had come into the fold, appointed magistrates and requested that deputies should be elected, sending notices to the towns outside of New Haven itself. The next year the subject was foremost at the meeting of the federation commissioners in Boston. Massachusetts and Plymouth decided that "by act of violence" New Haven could not have her rights infringed upon by any other of the United Colonies without breach of the articles of confederation; the "act of power" should be recalled and New
Since her voters must be church members, New Haven's electors were only 60 per cent of her men ; the other 40 per cent were in favor of the union of the colonies. All but three towns seceded which left the others in financial straits and governmental dilemma. It happened at this juncture that an order from the King relative to navigation was addressed to the governor of New Haven, on the strength of which action the demand was made upon the seceding towns to return to the jurisdiction, while the New Haven court sent a document to Connecticut's General Assembly reviewing the situation and asking that union be not insisted upon. Connecticut remained silent but Massachusetts advisers said that, having made this statement, New Haven could yield with dignity. Simultaneously it appeared that the Duke of York, brother of Charles II, was planning to assert his authority under a charter granted by the susceptible Charles, covering Long Island, New Netherlands and all the territory from the west bank of the Connecticut to the east side of Delaware Bay. This looked to New Haven like a second robbery, and altogether it was better to join with Connecticut. The broken-hearted Davenport declared that his dear colony's independence was "miserably lost." Winthrop put forth no claim to Long Island but arranged to have the western boundary about as it is today, barring a few changes which were to come out of several controversies in subsequent years.
The now comprehensive General Assembly was to meet alternately in New Haven and Hartford. Winthrop continued as governor till his death in 1676. The marvel of his success had become greater as the years went by, for the King's advisers and their successors were more and more outspoken in declaring that he had exceeded his powers in granting an independent state. And in action the colonists did not hesitate to exercise independence in excess of their charter rights. Certain changes were made to suit their convenience. Thus the charter required that colony officers should be elected by the freemen assembled in one mass meeting; it had become customary for the outlying towns to send their votes to Hartford by their deputies, and as the same was true in New Haven, a law was passed authorizing such action, in 1670, but not till 1750 were the words "in person" struck out. This was contrary to the English law and would have been taken as a violation of the charter had attention been 'Called to it.
In 1698, the Legislature was divided into two houses, the governor and assistants (or "council") constituting the "upper house." "That there be no fraud or deceit," balloting in town meetings was as follows : Twenty nominations of colony officers were made at the preceding session of the Legislature. As the nominations were read, ballots were taken for governor, deputy governor, secretary and assistants, in order. The nominations for assistants were taken in order, each separately, the twelve having the most votes being declared the choice. Anyone could put in a blank ballot without making himself known, but unless all were blank it would have no effect. The criticism of today is that a nomination was an election, with the result that the votes of the freemen counted for naught. But such was not the case. The "convention" or "caucus," to be sure, was in the preceding session, where, as time progressed, there could develop divergences of opinion although as yet there was no division into parties; then if results were still unsatisfactory, enough blank ballots would appear at the election to make a renomination verv uncertain - and elections came every year. In general, however, nothing occurred to make more than one party, there was fair unanimity and a desire to continue those who served well. In 1689, when an elector must have an estate worth 40 shilling's a year, the experiment was tried of having a direct vote of the freemen for the nominees at the nominating session of the Legislature, each ballot with twenty names to be written out, but this was abandoned after three years.
The first distinct property qualification for a voter was made in 1657 when the character of some of the immigrants seemed to demand it. In that year, voters for colony (not town) officers must be householders at least 21 years old, have held office or have an estate of £30; ratable estates then averaged £60. In 1679 the law was that each voter for town or county officers must have an estate of at least 50 shillings. There were four counties, Hartford, New Haven, New London and Fairfield, each having three assistants and two commissioners or "justices of the peace."
When the Dutch were threatening in 1673, it was decreed that there should be a "Grand Committee" - the first Council of War - to deal with all matters in case of emergency between sessions. This committee should consist of the governor, deputy governor and assistants and such others as were named, mostly military men, and generally so after the first year of the law. The Hartford County men on this responsible committee, which was to be of great value in the dark years ahead, were Capt. Benjamin Newberry of Windsor, (and later) Captain Wells, Capt. John Wadsworth and Richard Lord.
Annihilation Threatened
The enactment for a War Council, so useful for another hundred years, must seem anomalous to him who only pores over the records and stilted correspondence of thirty years up to this time. Aside from consideration of the Dutch threat, attention of those who wrote was devoted to affairs of state, of government and of internal legislation along the paths of peace. Absorbed in such reading, one comes to think that now the colony was sure of its footing and went forward steadily to the final union of states. But among the people themselves it was items like the War Council legislation that reflected a constant and growing sense of wariness, a necessity for keeping prepared, and yet no premonition of what the next century was to bring.
The first act of distinct colonial aid to the mother country was in 1664 when Charles II sent Col. Richard Nicholls who, supported by reinforcements from New England and Rhode Island and accompanied by Governor Winthrop, secured Stuyvesant's capitulation of New Amsterdam. Almost immediately thereafter was confidence in peaceful colony-building to be shaken when Governor Andros sailed from New York to fix the Connecticut River boundary line of the territory given the Duke of York by Charles. With his fleet and brave soldiery he appeared at Saybrook July 8, 1675. The General Assembly had exercised foresight. Capt. Thomas Bull of Hartford, redoubtable, had arrived at the fort with well-equipped men. The flag of the King to whom the colony had pledged fealty was aloft. Andros and his attendants in all their finery were courteously permitted to land and even to read the duke's epistle. But Bull
- who Andros said should have "his horns tipped with silver" - abated none of his warlike attitude. As it would be imprudent to fire upon the King's flag, there was nothing for Andros and his retinue to do but to sail home again. Bull was lionized by a much-agitated people, but the stern General Assembly told him that he should have interrupted Andros' reading "by shouts or sound of drum etc., without violence."
In the fall of that same year all anxiety imposed by white men, whether of their own blood or other, dropped into insignificance before the outburst from Massachusetts. With no aid from the mother country, war was on, brief in its duration, little more than itemized for the casual reader, but a war whose fearful intensity caused the General Court of Massachusetts to declare at the close :
There died many brave officers and sentinels, whose memory is blessed and whose death redeemed our lives. The bitter cold, the tarled swamp, the tedious march, the strongfort, the numerous and stubborn enemy they contended with, for their God, King and country, be their trophies over death. Our mourners, over all the colony, witness for our men that they were not unfaithful in that day.
In retrospect the government of Massachusetts ascribed King Philip's war to God's indignation over the sins of the people who had become lax in church discipline, had forgotten to train their children aright, had forsaken the paths of their fathers and had permitted their women to expose their bosoms, to dress their hair indecently and to wear too many ribbons. History ascribes it more nearly to application of Puritan ideas of deportment and government to proud and sensitive Indians who had not been made instruments of aid as in Connecticut. For unchristianized natives there was only Anglo-Saxon justice interpreted by the red men as contempt. The Wampanoags had not been Christianized; their chief Massasoit had shared all he had with the newcomers, but his successors, Alexander and Philip, found their people pushed to one side and downward and vaunted pledges violated, according to their interpretation, as when Miantonomoh of the Narragansetts had been allowed to go to his death at the hands of him they called renegade, Uncas of the Mohegans. Alexander's sudden (but natural) death they ascribed to poison;
Philip, young, lusty, supple, came to the chieftainship, bitter of heart. Thrice was he summoned to Boston for investigation, and returned marveling at the exhibition of firearms he had seen. Ordered to surrender his own till signs of an outbreak should disappear, he remarked that he saw that those he did turn in were distributed among the individual colonists and he reminded the government of the spirit of amity which had been promised to the fathers.
For four years breach of faith was charged again and again, till at last the fires were lit and the Wampanoags and the Narragansetts and their associates, to the number of over 3,000, were on the warpath. Connecticut, with more methodical preparation and with greater confidence in her local Indians, was the first to take the field. The Podunks alone favored the enemy; Uncas, whose home now was with the Mohegans on the Narragansett border, had been having quarrels with his eastern neighbors; and his followers, chiefly as scouts and guides, were of great assistance. Heedless of Andros' threat, the troops were on the march for New London, Stonington and Saybrook July 1, 1675, under command of Capt. Wait Winthrop and Thomas Bull. Shrewd in generalship, Philip's first blow fell on the Connecticut Valley in Massachusetts, and Brookfield was burning on August 1. Capt. Thomas Watts of Hartford and Capt. Roger Newberry of Windsor with troopers and Mohegans, were hurried to the support of the Massachusetts men, followed soon by Maj. John Talcott of Hartford at the request of Major Pynchon of Springfield, for a conference. At Deerfield, September 1, Watts was able to protect the people but could not save their homes. Maj. Robert Treat, formerly of Wethersfield but now of Milford, hastened to the relief of Northfield, where brave Massachusetts men had paid the penalty of lack of vigilance, and escorted the people to Hadley. His force was too small for battle. Recalled by alarm at Hartford, he returned, scouring both sides of the river.
Pynchon as commander-in-chief and Treat as second in command then planned a campaign which they were unable to execute because of the interference of the commissioners at Boston who demanded annihilation in the open. A careless convoy of provisions near Northfield, their guns on their wagons, were
Terror hereabouts was greatly increased by the burning of Springfield October 5, 1675. General massacre by the hitherto friendly Agawams would have been included had it not been for information from an Indian employed by H. Wolcott, Jr., a Windsor farmer who brought warning at the risk of his life. Pynchon from the north and Treat from Westfield arrived too late. More Connecticut alarms, especially around Wethersfield, where, as in the other towns, all able-bodied men were taking turns in guarding the homes and the crops, caused the temporary recall of Treat. Disgusted with the interference from Boston, Pynchon resigned and suggested Treat for his successor, but as he was in Connecticut, Major Appleton was named. The small body of fighters was becoming demoralized by foolish orders. Treat's return inspired confidence but almost immediately he was recalled because of reports from Glastonbury, and was held in Connecticut pending an attack upon Hartford which Governor Andros of New York wrote he had learned of. This danger passing, Treat hastened to the aid of Appleton, now bottled up at Hatfield with the redskins tearing at will through all the country north of Springfield, cutting off farmers and destroying crops. At the approach of winter, falling leaves were making it possible to scout through the woods when Treat was summoned to Hartford and Appleton to Boston to receive the plan of the commissioners of the United Colonies for an attack on winter quarters of the Narragansetts, who had not taken the trail but were harboring the families of their friends. Their chief, Canonchet, had signed a treaty but that was drafted "by old men" in his absence and he refused to comply with the agreement to turn over the alien Indians in his territory.
The commissioners issued an ultimatum and then, on November 2, a call for 1,000 additional men to invade the Narragansett land. Of Connecticut's quota of 215, Hartford sent 110. Gov. Josiah Winslow of Plymouth was chief in command with Treat next to him. Capt. Benjamin Newberry of Windsor having been disabled was succeeded by Capt. Samuel Marshall. Other Connecticut officers who were to distinguish themselves were Captains Thomas Watts, Nathaniel Seeley, John Gallop,
John Mason 2nd and Lieutenants James Avery and John Miles, while Rev. James Fitch was to organize Mohegans and Pequots as auxiliaries. On December 18, this the largest army ever assembled in the colonies, after a day of fasting and prayer on the 2nd when the people were told by the government of the Bay Colony that they were suffering judgment for their sins of frivolity, started at daylight for the Narragansett swamp where some 1,200 warriors were fortified with their women and children. And it was Sunday. That such an expedition should be undertaken with untrained men, badly equipped, through snow and into pathless woods, seeming to invite defeat and so contrary to the first principles of campaigning, is abundant proof of the desperation. They believed the fate of the colonies was at stake; this blow alone could give them hope. Homes were few and they and their occupants were being destroyed; approaches were being made even to the environments of the equally unprotected larger settlements; whether this was to be white men's land or Indians' must be decided. Hartford no less than Boston can count this as one of the gravest moments in its history.
Guided to the one weak spot in the doubly strengthened palisade, the Massachusetts men led the assault but were stopped with heavy loss. Connecticut followed, and there fell immediately Gallop of Stonington, Marshall of Windsor, Lieut. John Steclman of Wethersfield, commanding the Hartford County Dragoons, and Seeley of Fairfield, and Mason was mortally wounded. Exhausted by their long march and dazed with the novelty of their surroundings, the new men were about to become the easy victims of the warriors who were defending their homes when the wigwams caught fire and the flames, swept by a swift wind, drove all before them down the large enclosure. Six captains and twenty-five men had been killed and 150 wounded in brief space of time. The English retreated before the flames to the swamp. How many of the Indians had perished could not be surmised, but it must be that the force had been greatly reduced. The position could not be held; the alternative was almost as impossible but had to be accepted and, accordingly, in a fierce snowstorm which beat down many of them, they worked their way in the darkness over the rough trails to their base near present Wickford. Twenty died in their improvised
Canonchet would have no parley till his hostage brother was returned from Hartford. The army was speedily recruited up to 1,400, Connecticut furnishing 300. With all the red men he could assemble from any source, Canonchet was striking out through a corner of Connecticut towards the center of Massachusetts where presumably were the headquarters of King Philip, but no one knew; at all events the union of such forces must be prevented. A premature blow by Winslow proved disastrous. The slow pursuit through snow and over roughest terrain, without the chance of a shot, was ever after known as the "hunger march" when the white men had to kill their few horses for food. On through Woodstock to Marlboro, in the heart of the Indian country, they had pushed when Winslow made the costly error of disbanding his forces. The Indians, nearly starved after the arrival of the reinforcements, raided farms more boldly.
To the call for 600 men, with Mohegans, Major Treat responded generously for Connecticut, but before they could be assembled one of the most frightful blows of the war fell upon Lancaster and it was wiped out February 10, 1676. Among the wounded prisoners spared was Mrs. Joseph Rowlandson, wife of the minister who at the time was in Boston begging for a guard for his town. The ball which passed through her side mortally wounded the babe in her arms. Her written story of her captivity and the considerate treatment she received was given out after her removal to Wethersfield and is one of the most valuable human documents of colonial times. More recruits were brought up. With 200 Major Treat, in March, rescued Capt. William Turner who, with his garrison of seventy-eight, at Northampton, had given up hope.
March 17 the valley tribesmen stole down through Pine Meadow (Windsor Locks) where they killed one man, over to Simsbury where they plundered and burned houses the settlers had abandoned. Fiction marks a cave on the west side of Talcott Mountain as the aerie from which King Philip himself watched the flames; since the cave was on the farm of the Phelps family,
Again Treat was called back to search for vagabond Indians who killed or wounded a colonist here or there and increased the anxiety. Philip himself was rejoicing in his freedom from attack, and was planning a combined invasion of the Boston territory, where farmers and villagers were huddling in despair, when Treat led a band of Connecticut men into Rhode Island, by strategy on April 3 annihilated one band of Indians and soon brought back the Narragansett chief Canonchet. To the offer of his life if he would secure peace, Canonchet replied that he wished to die before his heart was made soft and before he had spoken words unworthy of himself. On April 8, the council at Hartford formally acknowledged the receipt of his head from the Mohegans and Pequots to whom he had been turned over for execution.
Treat had resigned about that time to accept the position of deputy governor and had been succeeded by Maj. John Talcott. The Connecticut troops were ordered to join Henchman and his Massachusetts men for a final attack on Philip in his stronghold on Mount Wachusett in Massachusetts. Henchman having been misled and Talcott alone not being strong enough for the attack, the Connecticut commander took his own course westerly and did that thorough work up through the Connecticut valley which has caused him to be memorialized there. Unknown to the Indians, he was inside the stockade at Hadley the night of June 11 when they had assembled for their massacre, and from that time on, he and Henchman who had come up with him gave them no rest. Philip was oif for the Narragansett country but Talcott, with Newberry and Denison, were there ahead of him. Striking as he went, Talcott reached Providence where he learned that peace was being talked of, "upon which information," he reported, "being willing to set our seal upon it, we posted away and drest Providence's necks, killing and capturing sixty-seven Indians we found there."
Meantime the Massachusetts troops, convinced at last that Indian scouts were an essential, were pressing the devastators hard throughout eastern Massachusetts. Having learned of Philip's lair near Bristol, they hastened down into Rhode Island nor rested till they had surrounded him. On August 12, one of the Indians shot and killed him as he was escaping from his hiding place. Bands making their way westward terrified again the up-river region whither Talcott hurried in August to give them their final blow.
Hartford County activities during the period had been constant. As early as 1674 it had been ordered that certain houses in each community should be fortified to afford place of refuge in case of attack. In July, 1675, 150 dragoons and troopers were operating between here and New London. After John Colt had been shot by skulkers in the South Meadows in September, Major Treat kept a patrol of thirty dragoons there for some time. When 110 men were called for in November, to report to Major Treat, Hartford's quota was 30, Windsor's 28, Wethersfield's 20, Farmington's 15 and Middletown's 14, with a horse to every third man. At the Swamp Fight, Wethersfield was represented by Lieut. John Stedman who was killed and by Lieut. Samuel Martin, Capt. Samuel Welles, Lieut. John Chester, Lieut. Thomas Hollister and Rev. Gershom Bulkeley, chaplain and surgeon, who was overcome. After that fight, in the expedition into Rhode Island, John Fitch of Wethersfield commanded the county dragoons; Samuel Martin, Sr., was a lieutenant in Captain Watts' company. In February, 1676, eighty from the county went with Major Talcott to Rhode Island. William Hills of East Hartford was shot in the Hockanum meadows. A garrison was established in Glastonbury and the Indians were told to build a fort. John Kirby was shot between Wethersfield and Middletown. In March of that year eighty were sent to Captain Newberry's command in Northampton. The Council of War ordered the release of Sachem Turramugas, Sowheag's successor, who had been held for conspiracy. In June, 1676, the Hartford company was divided into two parts, the southern section under the command of John Stanley of Hartford; Thomas Hollister of Wethersfield lieutenant and John Wyett ensign. After King Philip's death, Hollister was authorized to return ten prisoners to the Mohegan allies; the rest of the prisoners were sold as slaves by order of Major Talcott. Henry Denslow of Windsor and Edward Elmor in South Windsor were shot in the summer of 1676. To meet
After this war, Indians ceased to be a serious problem in local government barring an affair with Minigret and the Long Island Indians. Tribal control, independent settlements with a governor in control, in this place and in that, with no one wanting them for neighbors, the remnants of the Pequots spent their last days in comparatively modern times near Groton and Stonington, aided by the state. The Mohegans, lords over wide territory, sold plots of ground first to one white man and then to another, often for a drink or a trinket, until there was confusion that occupied the attention of courts in England and in Connecticut for seventy years. Major Mason had accepted from Uncas the large tract known as "Sequestered Land" which never was encroached upon till after Mason's death in Norwich in 1672. He considered it the property of the colony as by deed, a contention earnestly presented by those who bought into lawsuits and eventually so maintained by the colony.
Not far from Mason's grave is that of Uncas who lived ten years longer than he, meantime distinguishing himself again in King Philip's war. In the cemetery set apart for the royal family of the Pequots and Mohegans stands his monument, the foundation stone of which was put in place in 1833 by President Andrew Jackson, who was accompanied by Vice President Van Buren, Governor Edwards and members of the President's cabinet.
The Podunks and the other Indians of Hartford County, as will be seen in some of the town histories in this work, faded away rapidly. A number of them removed to the western section of the county whence they were taken to Stockbridge, Mass., and eventually, with other wanderers, to Stockbridge, N. Y., to jurisdiction of the Oneidas. The tribe was called the Brothertons. Samson Occum, the Mohegan Indian minister, one of the Indian pupils of Doctor Wheelock whose attainments inspired the founding of Dartmouth College, was their pastor and died there in 1792. They moved on to Calumet County, Wisconsin, where their descendants, admitted to citizenship in 1839, became a prosperous community.
Four years after the war favorable report of conditions was sent to England by the colony. The militia numbered 2,500 and one troop of sixty horse. Of Indian neighbors there were 500 fighting men. Trade was chiefly with Boston and the commodities were provisions, lumber and horses. Imports amounted to £9,000 annually. Wheat crops were failures. There were twenty "petty merchants," few foreign merchants, few servants and fewer slaves - not over thirty. There were so few English, Scotch and Irish coming in that no account could be made of them. Nearly all the people were Congregationalists with a few Presbyterians and four or five "seven-day" men and the same number of Quakers. In the twenty-six towns there were twenty-one churches with settled ministers whose stipend was from £50 to £100. The poor were well cared for, labor was "dear" - two shillings or more a day, and provisions cheap. Beggars and vagabonds were not allowed.
Rhode Island invaders were driven back over the line while Connecticut claimed her boundary by charter and also by conquest in the late war, in which Rhode Island had done nothing. Rhode Island's claim to part of the Connecticut territory was set aside by commissioners appointed by the King. This dispute was revived again under the claim of the heirs of the Duke of Hamilton and fruitless litigation continued many years.
The Andros Usurpation Militia Maintained
In the short breathing spell for quiet, independent yet loyal expansion, another crisis was impending. It was unlike that which the barbarians had created because it was imposed by those then in control in the mother country and therefore unnatural, and it was to find its culmination in freedom with independence a hundred years later. Charles II could be gracious; he could be flattering in correspondence, as when comparing this colony with that of the Bay, but he also could "play" favorites. His grant of previously granted territory to his brother James, Duke of York, was only one example. Also there were men who could take advantage of his good nature.
Foremost among these was Edward Randolph. From commercial and imperialistic standpoint, the program for combining territory under one control was much in line with the programs of later years and later colonization, but the fallacy here lay in the misconception of the disposition of fellow Englishmen and men who had gone out to secure freedom of thought. To prepare the way for such large combine as he would like, Randolph cast aspersions upon New England and especially upon the Bay Colony. For Connecticut he made good use of the Saybrook incident to demonstrate the haughtiness of this colony at the time Governor Andros had sought to assert York's title. When York himself came to the throne upon his brother's death in 1685, England's Board of Trade had reason to expect early amalgamation, under gubernatorial control, from the Delaware to Canada.
reign, however, such established principle was ignored. The form of a hearing in English court was outwardly recognized, as here seen, but in reality was brushed aside. Charter or no charter, as the colonists knew from their counsellors in London, the government of Andros alone would be endorsed by the King ; the holder of a charter in 1687 could not stand against such supreme authority; nor were rights of subjects in the colonies to be established through later reigns until there was recourse to arms, in 1775. Then it was to be the sentiment of genuine English people at home as well as here which prevailed against un-English monarchs and influence.
Hartford County history has to do only with Hartford features of the coercion now employed, the most spectacular of all of them inasmuch as here was the seat of the only free constitutional government. Here was the best exemplification of the principle of assemblage in town meetings, which James especially abhorred. The "town" is traceable back into the history of European races. In England it was the "parish." In the Bay Colony, indicated in its original charter, it took the form of a governmental system, and the first regular town legislation in the General Court was at the time of the Hooker arguments there in 1635. The town meeting was to infuriate Andros till his overthrow and imprisonment in 1689. It was to remain down through generations a distinctively New England institution of which Jefferson said: "It is the wisest invention ever devised by the wit of man for the perfect exercise of self-government, and for its preservation." It gave a voice to freedom which at times was inharmonious with the environment of the sanctuary in which it usually was held, or may have threatened the foundations of the "town hall" later erected for it, like a palladium, but it kept the interest of the individual at a white heat.
What King James and Andros would not suppress but would control from their royal seats was the soldiery. It was through fear of such monarchical conception that foresighted Connecticut from the first had quietly provided that control must remain under the colonial and subsequently the state government. Persistence in this is deeply marked throughout Connecticut history, as a colony and as a member of confederated and then of united states. The reasons will appear in regular order.
With these points in mind, the events from 1685 to 1700 become more than incidents in historical narrative. Andros came to Boston as governor of New England in December, 1686. Randolph as collector and tale-bearer had been stirring up the indignation of all the colonies and in 1684 had secured the annulment of the Massachusetts charter in court. In 1685 he issued writ of quo warranto because Connecticut was in the hands of an "independent party." He wrote to Hartford that nothing now remained on Connecticut's part but to think of humble submission and dutiful surrender of the charter ; if there were resort to law, the colony would be attached to New York, a great "calamity;" and with the jocularity of a Caesar Borgia - also of great persuasive eloquence - he added : "Bless not yourselves with vain expectation of advantage and spinning out of time by delay. I will engage, though the weather be warm, the writs will keep sound, as good as when first landed."
It chanced that the writs were served too late and hence were defective. A third was issued and when delivered was accompanied by a letter from AncLros saying he would receive surrender of charter if tendered. Under the tyranny of James, that signified that the surrender was merely a matter of form; the result would be the same one way or the other. The colonists realized this but preferred to adhere to form. Governor Treat replied that William Whiting was then in London as attorney; therefore he asked for time but said, of course, that he was "in duty bound" to submit to the King's demands. Some of the few local supporters of Andros, like Rev. Gershom Bulkeley who in 1692 wrote the document "Will and Doom," insisted that Connecticut should be willing. Others were disturbed by the threat of being joined to New York. The majority calmly bided the outcome. In October Andros wrote the governor that he had orders to compel annexation to Boston and he would soon be in Hartford. Receiving no reply, he set forth October 26, 1687 (according to Judge Sewall's diary), with sundry of his council, justices and other gentlemen, four blue-coats, two trumpeters, fifteen or twenty red-coats, with small guns and short lances in the tops of them, by way of Providence and the Wethersfield ferry (where he was greeted by Gershom Bulkeley). Thence he was escorted by the Hartford County troop under command of Capt. Samuel
Governor Andros was ushered into the chamber of the General Assembly in the old inn on Main Street. His retinue and soldiers and the colony's escort remained outside. The inn-keeper's entertainment for those without, on this grand occasion, was even more lavish than usual. With austere respect Andros - he who had met one defeat at the hands of Captain Bull at Saybrook - was escorted to the governor's chair. Patiently he listened to the defense arguments. They were prolonged by distinguished colonists till the hour for lighting candles. The charter lay exposed in its box on the table. To him as he listened quietly, without wasting breath, it was but a piece of sheepskin ; to the colonists, studiously gracious in their manner though they were, it was the symbol of sacred rights inherited from Hooker and perpetuated by Winthrop. The room, lighted by the flickering "dips," became close and uncomfortable. A window was opened to clear the tobacco smoke and cool the tired brains. An October puff and the feeble lights were extinguished, but quickly restored out of respect for His Majesty's representative. No record was made of what had happened in the moments of darkness; it was not a subject to be bruited around and published in King James' England. Andros had caused his royal commission as governor to be read and he appointed Governor Treat, with rank of colonel, and Capt. John Allyn, who was the secretary of the colony and of the meeting, to be members of his council which was to sit in Boston and make the laws. The secretary handed the seal to Sir Edmund, and at some time later closed his report with these words :
His Excellency, Sir Edmund Andros, Knight, Captain- General and Governor of His Majesty's Territory and Dominion in New England, by order from His Majesty, King of England, Scotland and Ireland, the 31st of October, 1687, took into his hands the government of this colony of Connecticut, it being by His Majesty annexed to the Massachusetts and other colonies under His Majesty's government. Finis.
In the interval of darkness in the meeting, the charter had disappeared. Andros may have made no stir; he had learned something about these people since he met Captain Bull at Say- brook; on that humiliating occasion he had spoken in the name of the Duke of York; today he had spoken in the name of the same man but "His Majesty," and he was conscious of his victory; nothing more need concern him. But the symbol of liberty had fallen into the hands of Joseph Wadsworth, an officer in the militia who probably was one of the colonial escort and whose brother John was a member of the Assembly, from Farmington. By him it was hurried to a place of safety, a hole in a great oak in front of the house of Magistrate Samuel Wyllys. This is on the authority of the historian of the next century, Dr. Benjamin Trumbull of New Haven who got such traditions at first hand or very nearly. In the better days of 1715, a resolution was introduced in the lower house of the Assembly to give the captain £4 for his "securing the Duplicate Charter of this colony in a very troublesome season when our Constitution was struck at, and in safety keeping and preserving the same ever since unto this day." In the upper house, where the captain was not popular because of contemptuous words for which he had been publicly reprimanded, the amount was cut to 20 shillings, and the resolution so passed.
This parchment ever after was sacredly guarded. Eventually it was framed in wood of the tree in which it had been hidden, and then hung in the secretary's office. Now in its beautiful carved frame it rests in a special safe, open for public inspection, in the Memorial Hall of the State Library Building, beside Stuart's portrait of Washington. What had become of the other charter? In the fighting of wars of European origin and endeavoring to catch up with their own affairs meantime, the colonists must have been too engaged to think about it. If there was inquisitiveness during the reign of James, there were reasons for suppressing it. Treat in the council was saving Connecticut from most of the ills that were meted out to the other colonies, and it was best to let a sleeping dog lie. After James was driven from the throne in 1689 and King William had restored the colony's rights - which indeed had scarcely been suspended except in name - there was constantly enough besides the charter to command the thoughts of the colonists, and the duplicate was all sufficient. The only mystery thereto attaching is how they knew this was the "duplicate" unless it were by private statement of one of the guardian committee who had known the whereabouts of the original. The committee had been composed of Samuel Wyllys, John Talcott and John Allen. Wyllys was one of the foremost citizens of the town; on his land it was that the oak stood in which the charter was hidden. The descendants of Wyllys were no less distinguished than he. His namesake (1739-1823) was the first captain of the Governor's Foot Guard, colonel in the Revolution, town clerk, secretary of the state and major-general in the militia. He maintained the old homestead.
The colonial government had acknowledged the receipt of "the charter, the duplicate and the old copy of the former charter" - meaning doubtless the Warwick Patent which Winthrop had unearthed. It had been understood that Winthrop would bring over the duplicate of his charter when he came. The acknowledgment can then be interpreted to mean "the charter" (duplicate form) and the two copies of the old one, no trace of either of which had been found when wanted (or not wanted). The copy which the committee had had in charge till Andros came was in all probability the only charter the colony had, for it can be assumed that the Assembly would not have rewarded Wadsworth in 1715 for saving a copy if it already had the original. Roger Wolcott was chairman of the committee that framed that resolution. He was a boy at the time of Andros' visit. When well on in years, in 1759, he gave reminiscences of the affair and was quoted as saying that Nathaniel Stanley took one copy and Governor Talcott the other. Talcott was governor from 1725 to 1742.
But on August 26, 1686, the government had sent a letter to Counselor Whiting in London, according to the "Colonial Records," instructing him to appear at the next term of court in London, to be held in February, 1687, when writs would be returnable in the action of quo warranto; within six months he was to be prepared and have the "duplicate of our charter ready to be established," * * * "(which by Governor Winthrop was left with Mr. James Porter of London and since by us he was ordered to deliver it to you.)" If there were to be any charges against the colony, he should request sufficient time to make answer and decide whether to go to the court or to the King. Delay, it evidently was reasoned, might prevent the worst of alternatives - annexation to New York or Massachusetts. The King's Council appears to have considered it in the nature of a waiver and dropped the quo warranto threat against the charter itself. The point here is that this definitely locates a charter parchment in 1686-7. It remained for Librarian Albert C. Bates of the Connecticut Historical Society in very recent years to trace this out. When the copy then in England reached Hartford cannot be determined; it might not have been till a number of years thereafter, for experience had taught that it was well to keep a copy in London for reference. It made no stir when it came, playing the part of "second fiddle" to the one that had been so joyously greeted and had been hidden in the oak.
A young Trinity College student who became secretary of the state in 1858, unwittingly revealed it after rescuing it from mutilation in the interests of feminine art. The student was John Boyd of Winsted. He was boarding in the family of Rev. Dr. Flint of the South Church. One day he saw a piece of old parchment on the sewing stand of the doctor's mother. She told him it had been brought to her by Mrs. Wyllys to use as cardboard in making over a hat and gave it to him in return for a simple substitute. Not till eight years afterward did he inspect it and discover that it was a large remnant of the charter, already started on the road to ruin.
What has added to the misapprehension in history is the use of the word "duplicate." Both charters were "duplicate" according to custom and as appears on the face of each. It was as though the issue had been: "One charter in duplicate." The question of which was the technical duplicate was not settled till 1898, when Rev. Dr. Love obtained a copy of the record of May 10, 1662, from the accounts of the Hanaper in London, showing that the fee for the original was £5 and for the engrosser's copy "XXs - iiij." Comparison with the marginal notations on the parchments made it clear that the duplicate which Andros would have seized was the one that had been honored in history and romance and that the one that had stood ready for duty in England was the original duplicate. Withal in the second duplicate a small word had been omitted by the copyist, and it is omitted in the various copies that have been made by students, indicating that the first duplicate was still in oblivion. Winthrop's purpose in leaving the first duplicate in London quite likely had been to furnish the strongest evidence should question arise about the wording, as was possible in those times, considering the sweep of its liber-
The Charter Oak had been prized by the Indians before the white men came and had been spared by the settlers at their request. The natives said it long had indicated to them by the size of its new leaves the time to plant their corn, while under its branches they held their councils. The Wyllys estate passed to Stephen Bulkeley, descendant of Gershom Bulkeley, and then to his daughter, wife of Hon. Isaac W. Stuart. Mr. Stuart cared for the oak diligently till a strong wind blew it down August 21, 1856. Its rings, it is said, indicated a life of 1,000 years. Pieces of the tree were highly prized. One large section was given to the state, from which Albert Entress carved the lieutenant governor's chair which ever since has adorned the platform in the Senate chamber. A tablet, placed by the Society of Colonial Wars, now indicates where the majestic tree stood.
Governor Treat wrote the new King, rejoicing in his having come to the throne and saying that government was continuing under the charter though with some uneasiness because of the methods adopted by the late King, but reminding His Majesty that "we never resigned our charter, nor was it condemned;" therefore he entreated that the instrument be formally confirmed. While the request never was granted, the law officers of the realm declared Andros' usurpation illegal and the charter intact. Plymouth lost her colony independence to Massachusetts, which also included Maine, all under the governorship of the sailor adven-« turer, Sir William Phipps.
However it was not to be long before there came the much-tobe-resented demand for control of Connecticut's militia. When King Louis of France had been aroused by the dethronement of his friend King James, and England saw design to spread the power of the Roman Catholic Church, Connecticut, retaining her control, responded graciously. Governor Leisler in New York feared French and Indian attacks to the extent that Capt. Thomas Bull of Hartford with a few men was sent to Schenectady to help the New York defenders. In the massacre that followed five of Bull's men were killed and others captured, through no fault of their own. The next spring Hartford County men joined the contingent for the expedition against Quebec, FitzJohn Winthrop
In 1692, Benjamin Fletcher as governor of New York maintained the royal prerogative to control all the soldiery of the colonies and therefore treated Connecticut's sentiments with contempt. He came himself to Hartford in October, 1693, to make demand upon the General Assembly, and when the train bands were assembled and Fletcher ordered that his commission and purpose be read to them, tradition has it that Capt. Joseph Wadsworth again distinguished himself by causing the drums to make a deafening roar and by threatening Fletcher personally. The tradition has far outrun an official pamphlet published by authority of the General Assembly in 1694, under the title "Connecticut Vindicated," in which it was asserted that the royalists in New York, after the fashion of the day, were publishing pamphlets to bring the colony into disrepute in England and that it was they who were trying to create the impression that the colonists at Hartford were discourteous to the King's representative. In "vindicating" Connecticut, the General Assembly's pamphlet said that there were "no armed men" on that occasion. "A training was in hand" but not by the governor's order; no one rose against his excellency and matters were not at all "as suggested to strangers."
In 1693, 150 men were sent from Connecticut to assist Governor Fletcher, and on his appeal the following year, supplies of food and £500, - from the people who successfully resisted his attempts at military control over them. By the time of the peace in 1697, the colony had spent £12,000 or a sum equal to one-tenth of its grand list. Among the minor relief expeditions were those of Capt. William Whiting with sixty fusileers and forty Indians for the northeastern frontier at request of Governor Phipps, and the same Hartford County officer with a company of dragoons for the defense of Albany. Lieut. Stephen Hollister of Wethersfield led an expedition of forty men to quiet an up-river alarm.
The colony's devotion to Gov. John Winthrop's son was strong, especially after the Schenectady affair when Leisler, who had ruined the campaign, put Winthrop in confinement for court martial, from which he was released by the wrathful Mohawks. Moreover he was a good soldier, having had experience in the
Parliamentary army in Scotland, and also he was the man who had preserved the colony's rights. For it was in 1693 that he had gone to England to argue against Fletcher's usurpation of rights under the charter his own father had secured. He won the decision of the court that the charter never had been invalidated and his reply to Fletcher formulated the Connecticut sentiment which has remained constant. It said that whoever commanded the persons in a colony would also command the purse and be the governor; that there was such a connection between the civil authority and the command of the militia that "one could not exist without the other." While the colony was willing to grant use of the militia, there could be no conscription under royal order, and troops must be officered by men named by the colony's authorities.
King William's war was the first but far from being the last in which the colonists attested their loyalty to England. History must bring out the harsher events of the ages but it is not complete if it does not furnish the reader's mind with a conception of general mental attitude throughout each of its periods. These people who established and maintained their free government loved the ties of kinship with those across the water. Their sentiment was deeply reciprocated by the masses and also by certain of those in high positions through the various changes in governmental control. Colonization was a comparatively new thing for what was to become the mighty empire. The judgment of one generation was not that of another. While there seemed to some to have opened up a wholly unsuspected field for graft and aggrandizement, others, of the noblest of the realm, brought to the subject of American colonies their most constructive ability, gave of their sympathies and in person braved the self-denial if not actual hardship in the new land.
As a whole the English people were heart and soul with the pioneers, eager for every item of news from them, while the frequent official reports to the Board of Trade were solemnly discussed and carefully preserved. The reports would make dry reading, but in them is the complete story, quaintly told, of the growth of business and commerce, of the increase in population and of their method of taxation. There was no more clashing of creeds than there was in the home country, and matters of this sort could not figure in material reports, being left, rather, to those who were active participants and could write their own statements to those similarly interested across the water. The old nation and that which was to be the new were feeling their way, impeded at times by foolish hands not always of their own blood but never with such persistent and far-reaching blunders as have proved the destruction of other states. At the close of its birth-century, the outlook for Hartford County, even in its Connecticut independence, even in its respectful adherence to free thought and resolution, was favorable. It owed fealty to no flag but England's. This must be remembered by those who study the events of the following century which led to separation.
POINTS ESTABLISHED IN MOMENTS OF PEACE - LAND AND EDUCATIONAL QUARRELS - LAWYERS AND COURT SYSTEM - FERRY AND "GREAT BRIDGE" - MINING AND SHIPPING - MASONIC LODGE - FIRST TIN PEDDLER - THE "GREAT AWAKENING."
In the intervals of peace in the eighteenth century, the county rather better than the rest of the colony gradually worked itself out of the condition of what was known colloquially in New England as "hard scrabble." The appeal of the General Court for raising the means to pay the expenses for procuring the charter is an illustration of the every-day struggle for subsistence when English currency was scarce. The colonists were besought, in a matter-of-fact way, to get together all they could of agricultural products, tar and other material for shipbuilding and whatever else the wilderness could yield, and send it to New London to be shipped to England.
Taxes yielded barely enough for routine needs; in cases of emergency there had to be recourse to what now are known as "drives," and at each one every man gave "till it hurt." Those who like Winthrop, Haynes and Hopkins had comparatively independent means were generous, but it was part of the principle of the government that all should share the burdens. The demands came to increase heavily with the expenses for King Philip's war, and in 1676 the General Assembly appointed a committee to fix valuations. The rate then was raised from 1 pence to 18 pence. In Hartford, home lots were valued at 40 shillings an acre; improved uplands at 25 shillings on the "north side" and 20 shillings on the "south side," and the meadows at 50 shillings for one-half and 40 shillings for the other. Paying taxes was somewhat like buying stock in a corporation; distribution of undivided land or land forfeited through failure to utilize it or inability to bear the tax was made in proportion to the amount each man paid in taxes, thereby relieving the poorer inhabitants and, while placing the
The General Court had come to permit individual towns to make their own distributions among inhabitants, as in the case of present East Hartford, but one result was that in 1723 it was necessary to pass a healing act, confirming old titles which had become uncertain because of the original method of assigning certain amounts to "proprietors" or to others as free gift "in courtesy." When the word "inhabitants" began to assume its present meaning, they felt a right to obtain and hold ownership, by allotment after joint purchase. Such was the case in East Hartford when land was bought from Uncas' son-in-law in 1682 and later along the Bolton border, as will be seen in the history of that region; that not assigned pro rata was held as commons. A similar idea in Hartford's western division created litigation in 1754 that was long and searching. Measurement according to the amount of taxes paid let in inhabitants not heirs of early proprietors, and the litigation was between them as claimants and the heirs as owners since early days.
But a new feature had developed in this instance, namely, that when Andros was about to come to take over all New England, the General Assembly saw that he would have a right to assert specific and particular royal control over all undivided land; therefore the Assembly appointed committees in each town to arrange to receive that undivided land, which included much in the territory to the west of Hartford County's confines - to be mentioned further on, - and have it taken up in order by the inhabitants. One purpose of the law of 1723 was to confirm that cleverly devised plan. Along Hartford's western border was a strip a mile and a half long which in 1672 it had been voted to divide, leaving the rest a commons - "forever." The lots were laid out in 1674. By 1753, steps were taken to lay out the "commons." Heirs and plain "inhabitants" clashed. The litigation ended in the upper court by a jury decision for the heirs if the law provided that those who had purchased the land were invested with the fee thereto, and in 1755 it was found that the law did so provide. This was a precedent for other cases till finally, it is understood, the inhabitants whose allotments had been questioned, including some of the original heirs themselves, bought the heirs' rights, and ownership thereafter could pass freely.
Prior to this incident of Hartford litigation was the more sensational matter of the distribution of the large and more western territory snatched from Andros' grasp. For a time it shared in importance if not in peril with the French-Indian alarms. The ambition of the county to be putting its possessions in better shape was clearly indicated by the little that was done during this war period. After Wethersfield had been divided in 1690 by setting off Glastonbury on the east side of the gnawing Connecticut, it had been the intention to open up the western holdings for the orderly settlement which pioneering and Indian buying was making essential. The territory, running west from Farmington and Simsbury to the Housatonic, was bounded on the north by Massachusetts and on the south by Woodbury and Mattatuck (Waterbury). Steps were taken in 1707 to make the survey and arrive at agreements, but nothing substantial could be done till after Queen Anne's war and the Indian terror. New committees were appointed in 1713 for Hartford and Windsor, the towns to which the territory had been assigned, and four years later New Bantam (Litchfield) was laid out. After settlement with Farmington men who forehandedly had made purchases from the Indians, this layout was confirmed but with proviso that the section north of Woodbury and Litchfield should be left for further disposal by the Assembly.
Request by Hartford and Windsor to settle more of the western sections met with no recorded response from the legislators. Nevertheless in 1720 Ensign Thomas Seymour and Sergeant James Ensign were sent to buy of the natives, and then a list of the purchasers in the towns was made with view to future apportionment. By 1723 the committees reported another tract ready to be laid out - in sixty-seven allotments to be sold at £6 each. The committees were among the prominent men of the colony but the Assembly, suspicious of graft, ordered their arrest, and that too not by the King's attorney of Hartford County but of New Haven County. Hartford County rose in protest; New Haven officials were ordered to make the arrests forthwith; Hartford parried by directing Joseph Talcott (son of Col. John Talcott and later governor), Capt. Hezekiah Wyllys, Lieut. Thomas Seymour and James Ensign to present the subject before the Assembly. Their compromise plan being rejected, it was voted in 1726 that Hartford and Windsor should have only the eastern part of the tract and the colony the western part, Litchfield to belong to the "proprietors." This gave the two towns the present Colebrook, Hartland, Winchester, Barkhamsted, Torrington, New Hartford and Harwintown, and also Litchfield, for the proprietors, a total of 326,800 acres. The colony's portion was only 120,000 acres, but the thought was to get settlement under way without more dickering.
The lands having been annexed to the county, Capt. Thomas Seymour and Lieut. Roger Newberry as a committee prepared the layout by which Windsor received Colebrook, Barkhamsted, Farmington and the western half of Harwinton, and Hartford the rest. Each taxpayer of the two towns received, by his list of 1620, a share in the new townships, in proportion to his list at the rate of three acres to the pound. The colony's portion was sold and the proceeds devoted in perpetuity to the schools in the towns then settled. Litchfield County was established in 1751.
Hartford County was decreased in size when Windham County was established in 1726; in 1728, Waterbury's request to be annexed to New Haven County was granted. Norfolk and Salisbury were sold at auction in Hartford in 1738.
The possibilities in reaches of territory were constantly in mind as when in the '50s Phineas Lyman, of Sumeld, who had been a leader in the Massachusetts boundary affair, Roger Wolcott, Jr., and others obtained from the Assembly rights to form the Susquehanna Company to go out into Pennsylvania's neighborhood, but within the region named in the charter, and establish Wyoming, since tillable land in Connecticut had been well taken up.
Provenance
Text from History of Hartford County, Connecticut, 1633-1928 : Being a Study of the First Makers of the Constitution and the Story of Their Lives, of Their Descendents and of All Who Have Come, published 1928, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.