BlockBefore

Litchfield County, Connecticut - Chapter 49: Bench and Bak.l, 1881 (part 3 of 3)

From History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881. 2,161 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

4 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

2,161 words

Machine-read from scans of History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

"At a meeting of tlie bur held Dee. IS, 179:),..f whi. h Ailoiiijah Stning, Ksq., was chairman, it was vttleO, * that Frederiek Wolentl, K-*q., of Litchfield, be Clerk of this Uurr, and have iiouer tu make lU'corda of ail Resolves of this Rarr, to make and certify Copies lliereof, and to jturform all other Duties incident to sui.l Onlcc.'

" Itetohed, That in future tho Fe*t to lie ehargo<l by each Momlwr of this llarr in all Causes iu which ho may IfO employed bo eetllUUhed aa follows, vlz<:

"Tho MenilK'f* presout and who stilM.'rll-e.t to the alN)ve table of fe»« are aa follows: Tnpplnc Keeve, .\doiilJah Stnuig. I>»iil<-1 Rverilt. Ihivld N. Diiusuiade, iraac lUldwiu, Jr , EptirMlni Kirb\, itonjamln Stilea, Jr., Nathan Proatun, JudK>u (.'anltrhl, Samuel Ibailnlck, John C. ^Smilh, Nicholas S. Master*, John Allen, I'llel IIuIiuck, Nathan Smith, John Elmore*, Jueeph Canfleld, Augiittus Pettibone.

THE COURTS I\ 1S20. Under the old goverument the Superior Court consisted of nine judges, and they were selected annually by the Legislature. Under the constitution the number was reduced to five, and they held their office during good behavior or until they reached the age of seventy j'ears. In like manner the judges of the County Courts were reduced from five to three. Formerly these judges held the Superior Courts, but now they are holden by one judge.

The Superior Court

Tlicrc were sessions of the Superior Court in each year, holden on the third Tuesdays of August and February, and the terms rarely extended beyond two weeks. If they reached to the third week, they were deemed to beof extraordinary length. The Superior Court had no original jurisdiction except as a court of equity. All iis actions at law came up by ajipeal from the County Court, and generally important cases were carried up without a trial in the court below. The party wishing to appeal his case would demur either to the declaration or plea, as the case might be, suffer a judgment to be entered against him, and appeal from it, and then change his plea in the Superior Court as the exigencies of his case may require. The making of copies iu the case appealed was a very profitable item in the business of the clerk. All cases at law wherein the matter in demand exceeded seventy dollars were ajqiealable, and all matters in equity in which the sum involved exceeded three hundi-ed dollars were l)rouglit originally to the Superior Court. In criminal matters the jurisdiction of both courts was concurrent, except in crimes of a higher grade, which were tried exclusively in the Superior Court. A case was pretty certain to reach a trial at the second term after it was entered in the docket unless special reasons could be shown for its further continuance.

The Countv Court

The County Court had an important agency in the administration of justice fifty years ago. Under the old form of government it consisted of one judge and four justices of the quorum; under the constitution, of one chief judge and two associate judges.

There were three sessions of the old County Court iu each year, in March, September, and December. The September term was generally short, merely disposing of the criminal business and such other preliminary matters as could not be passed over. The March term lasted three weeks, and the December term from four to six weeks, as the business might demand. The first half day was always taken up in calling the docket. Mr. Woleott had his files arranged alphabetically, corresponding with the entries (jn the docket, and of these some member of the bar, usually one of the younger, had charge. The sheriff took his station in the centre of the bar, and as the eases were named by the clerk the proper entries were made both on the docket and on the file, and then the file was passed to the sheriff, who delivered it to the party entitled to it, and thus, at the close of the proceedings, all the files had passed into the hands of the members of the bar, where they remained until the case received final disjjosition. Three hundred cases were considered as constituting a small docket, and there were as many as nine hundred entered at a single term.

In 1820 there were two grades of lawyers in the State. The first admission only authorized the candidate to practice at the County Court, and a service of two years was required at that bar before he was allowed an examination for admission to the bar of the Su)ierior Court. The statutes of the State were subsequently revised under the superintendence of Judge Swift, and many and material alterations had been made to conform the provisions of the law to the new order of things under the constitution. The question came before Judge Mainard, and he decided that under the revised statutes an admission to the bar of the County Court gave the candidate authority to practice in all the courts in the State; and that decision was assented to by all the judges.

The matter of examining candidates for admission to the bar was, in those days, an imposing solemnity, and the day for that proceeding was a marked day of the term. All the members of the bar were expected to be present, and few failed of attending. The committee of examination occupied the judges' seats, the chairman, holding the place of the chief judge, indicating to each separate member of the committee the subject in which he was expected to examine the candidate, and thus a thorough and searching examination was had. After the examination was closed the candidates retired, and the members of the bar gave their opinions seriatim on the question of the admission of the applicant. Sometimes candidates were rejected. It had been the practice in early times to have an entertainment at the close of the examination at the expense of the successful condidates, but this had been dispensed with when I was examined. Stories were told of some eminent members of the bar who, on such occasions, indulged in practices which were not credible to their reputation for temperance and sobriety. Perhaps it was for this reason that the practice was abolished.

Practice

Statutory provisions and the advance of legal science, as well as a more just sense of what is due to the best interest of litigation, have made great changes in the course of proceedings before the courts during the last fifty years. Then it was customary for counsel to take advantage of any trivial omission which could be found in the proceedings, and a case never came to trial until every possible effort for abatement or delay had been exhausted. Our statute in relation to amendments had not then received so liberal a construction, nor was it in itself so liberal in its provisions as it now is ; and thus opportunity was aftbrded for the display of much ingenuity in the prosecution of dilatory pleas.

Then there were no statutory provisions relating to injunctions, all the power which the court had in that matter being that with which it was invested by the common law as a court of equity, and hence very little will be found in our reports on this subject until about 1826, after the statute authorizing the judges to grant temporary injunctions had been passed. This statute was introduced into the Legislature by Judge Swift, who was a member for several sessions after his retirement from the bench. Since then many cases relating to this branch of jurisprudence have been before our courts.

Probably more than half the suits commenced in our County Courts fifty years ago were brought to enforce the collection of debts, and in some localities this was a ]>rofitable business. The County Court then had jurisdiction in all cases where the matter in demand exceeded the sum of fifteen dollars, and this brought into it a great number of suits now tried by single justices, and accounts for the great diminution in the number of cases now brought here.

Piles of learning were devoted to destruction by the edict of the Legislature admitting parties and other persons in interest to be heard as witnesses. The nicest and most refined legal questions were frequently brought before the courts for decision in matters relating to the interest of witnesses, but now they are almost forgotten by the most learned of the profession.

The Autuorities Then In Use

The statutes then in force were the revision of 1808, by far the most elaborate and complete of any ever publislu'd. It contains a complete history of the legi.slatioii of Connecticut on all subjects of statutory enactment from the first, and is still a useful hook for study by the profession. The principal labor of its preparation for publication was performed by Thomas Day.

Comparatively few American authorities were cited in our courts tlien. Mr. Day had published four volumes of Day's Reports, and then had suspended further publication for want of encouragement. The Legislature, in 1815, had authori/.ed the court to appoint a reporter, and had given him a salary. Under such an uppointment .Mr. Day had commenced publishing the Connecticut Heport.s, and had published three volumes of them when he j>ublisheil the fifth of Day, thus filling the gap between the fourth of Day and the first of Connecticut. The New York Reports, by Caine and Johnson, down to the twelfth of Jolinsoti, and twelve volumes of the Massachusetts Reports were out, and these, with our own reports, were about all the American authorities which were cited in our courts. Not a single American elementary work had then been published except Swift's (System and Swift's Evidence. The Engli.sh Reports from Burrows down, including Douglas', Cowper's, Term, and East's Reports, down to the twelfth volume, with Blackstone's Commentaries, which were always on the table, were the staple authorities of the times. Judge Reeve said that he considered Cowper's Reports the best that had then beeu published of the decisions of the Court of King's Bench.

Litchfield. - George C. AVoodruff, George M. Woodrufi" (railroad commissioner), Origen S. Seymour (does not appear in court as counsel), George A. Hickox, Henry B. Graves, Henry H. Prescott, Dwight C. Kilbourn, Wm. L. Ransom (clerk of the Superior Court), Charles B. Andrews, Frank AV. Wessells, Edward W. Seymour.

Winchester. - 'R. Hitchcock (judge of the Superior Court), Augustus H. Fenn, Hiram P. Lawrence, Wellington B. Smith, Samuel B. Home, William H. Ely, William F. Hurlbut, Florimond D. Fyler, Samuel A. Herman.

The senior member* of tlie bar of this county have, many of them, made up their records; those still left arc soon to follow, and the juniors arc to a.ssume their places at the bar and on the bench ; to them will soon be committed these great responsible trustii. The perpetuity of our free institutions is committetl to the guardianship ami keeping of the bar and judiciary of our free country, for the history of the world teaches, and all free government illustrates, this truth, - treat the subject lightly as you will, - that to the profemioii of the law civil government is indebted for all the safeguards and intrcnchmeiits with which the liberties of the people are protected ; that legislation is shape*!, eoDstitutious eularge<l, amended, and adopted by the enlightened administration of the statesmen, both of England and the United States, who have been in both, and are in all free governments, educated for the bar, and, ascending by the inherent force of their disciplined, professional life, they become the directors of the destinies of states and nations.

Military chieftains may spring into power, tyrants may dazzle with the glamour of military parade and the pomp of war an oppressed and frenzied people, but they turn as the cannonade dies away to the statesmanship of the country, and call to the parliaments and congressional halls for final debate the arbitraments of the liberties of the people.

From the days of King John to the present hour the bench and bar have furnished the statesmen who have erected the bulwarks of constitutional law, and extorted from tyrants the Magna Chartas which have secured to the oppressed the guarantees of free institutions.

Imbued with the historical traditions of their predecessors, and tracing the paths they have trod, emulating their good example, it should become more and more tlie resolute purpose of the Litchfield County bar to so walk in the light of their professional teachings that when they are called to follow them to that ujiper court, and file their judgment-roll of the great trial of life with that (Supreme Judge from whose bar they can take no appeal, -

" Thou go not like the quarry-slave at night Scourged to his dunpeon, but, sustnined and soothed By iiu uufiiltpiing trust, upproach thy grave Like one who wraps the drapery of liis couch About him aud lies down to [deasaut dreams,'*

Provenance

Text from History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.