Litchfield County, Connecticut - Chapter 49: Bench and Bak.l, 1881 (part 1 of 3)
From History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881. 15,947 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,947 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 49: Bench and Bak.l
Among the prominent agencies which give shape and order in the early development of the civil and social condition of society, the pulpit, press, and bar are perhaps the most potential in moulding the institutions of a new community ; and where these are early planted, the school, academy, and college are not long in assuming their legitimate position, and the maintenance of these institutions secures at the start a social and moral foundation upon which we may safely rest the superstructure of the county, the State, and the nation.
The establishment of court and judicial tribunals, where society is protected in all its civil rights under the sanction of law, and wrong finds a ready redress in an enlightened and prompt administration of justice, is the first necessity of every civilized community, and without which the forces of society in their changeable developments, even under the teachings of the pulpit, the direction of the jiress, and the culture of the schools, are exposed to peril and disaster from the turbulence of passion and conflicts of interest ; and hence the best and surest security that even the press, the school, or the pulpit can find for the peaceful performance of its highest functions is when prDtected by and intrenched behind the bulwarks of the law, administered by a pure, independent, and uncorrupted judiciary.
The Litchfield County bar has from its beginning numbered among its members able jurists, talented advocates, and safe counselors. Here many have lived, flourished, and died, while others still are upon the stage of action who have been prominent in the advancement of the interests of the county and figured conspicuously in the councils of the State.
" Patridge Thatcher was the firet man who practiced the legal profession in New Milford. He was not educated to the profession, but took up the trade because there were none of the craft hereabout when this county was organized, which was after he came to middle age. He was a native, I have been told, of Lebanon, in this State, and came to New Milford I know not how long ago. He was, however, a married man at the time. He had no children, but a large number of negroes, whom he treated with kindness enough to put to shame the reproaches of all the abolitionists in New England. He was a man of strong mind, of rigid morality, and religious to the letter according to the strictest sect of orthodox Episcopacy. He adored Charles I. as a martyr, and he hated Oliver Cromwell worse than he did the evil one. Loyalty, unconditional loyalty, was the prime element of his political creed. Of course, his name f This chapter embraces the reminiscences of the late David S. Boardman, of New Milford ; the remainder, except sketches of living lawyers, being furnished chiefly by Gen. Charles F. Sedgwick, of Sharou, to whom wc are under special obligations.
Bench And Bae
was not found in any list of the wicked Whigs of the Eevolution, and had he lived in these days he would most thoroughly have eschewed Democracy and Abolitionism. On the breaking out of the Eevolutionary war his loyalty necessarily silenced his voice in court, and he died soon after its conclusion. Lawyer Thatcher, as he was always called, was undoubtedly a very odd, a very honest, and a very good man.
" Daniel Eveeitt was a native of Bethlehem, and settled in New Milford as a lawyer some time during the early part of the Eevolutionary war, probably as early as 1776 or 1777, possibly earlier, as from a record I have access to I see he was married to a daughter of the Eev. Nathaniel Taylor on the 1st of January, 1778, and I remember that he lived here some time before that event. He had not a collegiate education, but was a man of good education and received an honorary degree. He read law with Judge Adams, of Litchfield, and I remember to have heard him say that he occasionally officiated in Mr. Adams' place as State's attorney when he (Adams) was absent in Congress, which he often was during the war of the Eevolution. Mr. Everitt was a man of much wit, boundless extravagance of expression, quick conception, and in command of language and fluency of utterance unsurpassed, but not a man of much depth of mind, nor had he much legal learning, his library extending little beyond Blackstone and Jacobs' Law Dictionary.
"He had, I believe, a very good run of practice, when the court rca//yopened to do civil business after the conclusion of the war. His success in tliis respect was, however, of rather sliort duration, a number of younger lawyers having about that time commenced practice here, and otlier circumstances conspired to carry business away from liim, and he never recovered it. While studying law I heard him argue a case or two, keeping tlic court-house in a roar by his wit and sarcasm, but by tlie time I was admitted - viz., in 1790 - he had about given up attending courts at Litchfield, though ho was not fifty years of age, and indeed he was, I think, but fifty-seven when he died, in 1805. I met him, however, a few times before arbitrators and justices, and had enougli to do to parry his homethrusts of good-natured wit. Before him I often went, as lie tried almost all the justice ca.ses, which he always did with entire integrity and usually came to a correct conclusion. He represented this town, I think, tiirec times in the General Assembly, and as a member of the convention which ratified the Constitution of tliu United iStates. He was a man of strict honesty, entire moral rectitude of conduct, and a professor of religion. He was, however, much given to sociality, and to that conviviality which sometimes borders on a kindred indulgence. Mr. Everitt succeeded the late Col. Samuel Canfield n-s judge of probate in this district in 171K), and held that utBcu till his death, at the time above mentionetl.
" Tapping Eeeve.* - I saw much of Judge Reeve's practice at the bar for nearly five years, during which time he was engaged in almost every case of importance tried in the Superior Court at Litchfield, and never failed to argue every one in which he was engaged, if argued at all. In the County Court, after I became acquainted with him, he did not practice. His school had become numerous, and he gave up his practice in that court because (I suppose) it too much interrupted his course of daily lectures, and knowing as he did that he should have a part in every cause expected to be tried in the Superior Court. And, by the way, trials were then managed and got through with in a reasonable time, and not suft'ercd to be dragged out to the abominable and shameful length which they now are, to the disgrace of the profession for indulging in it, and of the courts for permitting it.
"I joined Judge Reeve's school in the fiiU of 1793, and he was not placed on the bench till the spring of 1796 ; so that I saw him at the bar during nine sessions of the Superior Court, and never failed to listen to him, if 1 could avoid it, with unqualified love and admiration through every speech he made to its conclusion. I say with love, for no instructor was ever more generally beloved by his pupils, and indeed entirely so, except it was by those whose love would have been a reproach to the object of it. As a reasoner he had no superior within the compass of my observation of forensic performances. I mean true, forcible, and honest rciisoning. In sophistry he was too honest to indulge, and too discerning to sutler it to escape detection in the argument of an adversary.
"As a speaker he wjis usually exceedingly ardent, and the ardor he displayed appeared to be prompted by a conviction of the justice of the cau.se he was adwpating. Hia ideas seemed often, and, indeed, usually, to How in upon him faster than he could give utterance to tliem, ami sometimes seemed to force him to leave a sentence unfinished to begin another, and in his huddle of ideas, if I may so express it, he was careless of grammatical accuracy, and, though a thorough scholar, often made bad grammar in public speaking. Careless as he was of his diction, and thoughtless as he wits nf ornament in ordinary eiLtes, yet some elegant expressions and line sentences would seem, as if by accident, to escape him in almost ever)' speech. But in such coses as atlbrded the proper field for the display ofeloquence, such as actions of slander, malicious prosecutions, etc., and in that part of such cases as usually prompt to exertions of tlie kind, his hurried enunciation and grammatical inaccuracies all forsook him, and then he never faileil to electrify and astonish his audience. Many of these used to bo recited to mc by tlioAC who had often heard him, and it fell to my lot to witness one such occasion. In an action for malicious prosecution, in closing the argument on entering U|K)n the subject of dumage.'t, he burst forth into such a strain of dignified and soultbrilling eloquence as neitlier before nor since has ever met my ear. The first sentence he uttered thrilled through every nerve of my entire frame to the very ends of my fingers, and every succeeding sentence seemed to increase in overwhelming effect. I was perfectly entranced during its delivery, and for an hour afterwards I trembled so that I could not speak plain. His manner was as much changed as bis language, and to me he looked a foot taller than before. The next day I went to him and asked him to commit to writing the concluding part of bis speech, to W'hich request ho said in the simplicity of bis nature, 'Why, if I should do that, perhaps I should make it better than it really was, and that would not be fair.' We told him (Mr. Bacon was with me) there was no danger of that, for we knew it could not be bettered. Well, ho said, he would try, but he did not know whether he could recall it to memory, for there was not a word of it written beforehand. A day or two after he saw me in court, behind his seat, and beckoned me to him and said he had tried to comply with my request, but it was so gone from him that he could make nothing of it.
" I believe I have said enough in regard to Judge Reeve as an advocate, and that is the e.xtent of your inquiry. As a judge you are acquainted with his reputation historically, though you probably never saw him on the bench, as he left it in May, 1816, to the regret of all admirers of legal learning and lovers of impartial justice.
"John Allen was born in Great Barrington, Mass., some time, I believe, in 1762, of respectable parents, though not distinguished in society, as I remember to have heard him say that he was the son of a joiner. There were but two children in ^e family, a son and a daughter, both much distinguisned in life for many good qualities, and especially for dignity of manner and deportment, but the winning and amiable accomplishments all fell to the lot of the female, gaining her many admirers, and among others a husband worthy of her in that excellent man, Elizur Goodrich, of New Haven. Their father died during the minority of both the children. Mr. Allen, having an excellent common-school education, though not a classic education, became a teacher, and, being impelled by a spirit of adventure, somewhat romantic as he was thought in those days, went suddenly, and without the knowledge of his friends, and while yet a minor, to Germantown, near Philadelphia, where he obtained a place as instructor of the younger classes of an academic establishment of some note at the time. How long he remained in the above-mentioned establishment I do not know, but soon after leaving that place, and I believe almost immediately, he came to New Milford, and taught a school for some six mouths, and from here went immediately into Mr. Reeve's law-school, and after the accustomed period of study was admitted to the bar, and immediately settled in practice in Litchfield, where he spent his life. He confined himself almost entirely to the practice of Litchfield County, though occasionally, when calted, in consequence of the eminence to which he soon attained in the profession, he practiced in other counties in some cases of importance, and especially in the Federal Circuit Court, in which, for a few years after the formation of the present Constitution of the United States, some considerable business was done. Mr. Allen, however, never went abroad in quest of business, thinking that the very great share of attorney business which he acquired in being always found in his otfice equal, at least in point of profit, to what counselor business he might obtain by attending courts in other counties, considering that all the counselor business flowing from the attorney business which he did he was sure to be engaged in. From the time I entered the law-school, in the fall of 1793, 1 occupied a room in his oftice, and had free access to his ample libi'ary, and boarded at the same house with him. During all that time, and all the remaining years of his prosperous practice, which indeed lasted till the apparent commencement of his rapid decline, soon followed by death, he was engaged in almost every case of any importance in the Sujoerior and County Court. He was certainly a very successful and powerful advocate, equally with the jury as with the court, a thoroughly read lawyer, equal in point of legal science to any one at our bar during the fore part of the time I am speaking of, except Tapping Reeve, who had no rival, and in the latter part of the period James Gould, of whom I need say nothing, as you knew him in his meridian light. Mr. Allen always made diligent and faithful preparation of all cases committed to his care, and made himself fully acquainted with every point of law and every accessible point of evidence which could arise in the case, and was, therefore, usually successful when the case deserved success.
" He was six feet four or five inches high, very erect, and with an attitude and walk well calculated to set off his full stature, and, though quite lean, weighed full two hundred and thirty pounds. His countenance was strongly marked and truly formidable, his eyes and eyebrows dark, bis hair dark, what little he had, for he was quite bald, far back, even before middle age, and indeed his whole appearance was calculated to inspire dread rather than affection. His manners and conversation were, however, such as to inspire confidence and respect, though little calculated to invite familiarity, except with bis intimates, of whom he had a few, and those, knowing the generous and hearty friendship of which he was capable, were usually much attached to him and ready to overlook all his harsh sallies, imputing them to the ' rough humor which his mother gave bim.' His feelings were not refined, but ardent, generous, and hearty. His friendships were strong and his aversions equally so, and, as I used to say of bim speaking to others.
Bench And Bar
' his feelings were all of the great sort.' He neither enjoyed nor suffered anything from many of those little incidents which so often affect, either pleasingly or painfully, minds of a more refined texture. As he had no taste for such things, nor, as it would seem, any faculty of perceiving, so he knew no language appropriate to their description, but in respect to those things and principles which he thought worthy of his regard he lacked no power of language to make himself fully and forcibly understood. For neutral ground, either in morals or politics, he had no taste, and but little less than absolute abhorrence. As a specimen of his feelings and language, better than I describe, I will give you the laconic answer to an inquiry of him, why he took the Aurora, the leading Democratic paper in the county, then under the guidance of that arch-Democrat, Duane ; he replied it was because he wanted to know what they were about in the infernal regions. And after giving this specimen I need make no further attempt to give you an idea of his humor, manners, and language.
" After Mr. Allen was married, which was not till he was towards forty years old, and went to housekeeping, I boarded at his house at his express solicitation for many years while attending court, though he took no other one, nor ever named to me any price, nor would he count the money I handed to him when leaving for home, seeming to receive it only because I refused to stay on any other terms. I therefore saw much of him in his family, where his conduct wiis always dignified, proper, and kind. He was proud, very proud, and justly so, of his wife, who was a woman of much jjcrsonal beauty, polished manners, and great and even singular discretion, and for whom he entertained, I believe, an ardent affection.
"Before his marriage and at the age of thirty-fivo Mr. Allen was elected a member of the Fifth Congress, where he distinguished himself at a time when Connecticut Wiw never more ably represented in the House of Representatives, and would undoubtedly have been chosen for as long a period as he would have desired to be a member of that body, but ho declined a further election. He was elected an assistant in 1800, and was re-electe<l for tlio five succeeding years, and as such was one of the judges of the Supreme Court of Errors. For several ycnrrt previous to his election to Congress he had represented the town of Litchfield in the General Assembly. His wife was a granddaughter of the first (loveruor Grisw old.
" Bahzii.lai SLoasoN. - In speakingof Mr. Slosson, I must first observe that I had Ibrnu'd a toleralily correct notion of him before I ever saw liini. When I was a boy his father was often at my father's house, intimately ac<|uainted there, and, I believe, scarcely ever pa.s.sed that way without calling and holding a pretty long chat, for he never was in a hurry, and his peculiar turn of mind, abundance of common .nense, and great fund of wit, joined to his singularly slow, emphatic, and sententious mode of talking, was such as to secure the attention of any one, and especially a boy. He used occasionally to speak of his children, and especially of his oldest son, Barzillai, of whom he was manifestly very proud, representing him to be always at the head of the school when small, and afterwards used to speak with high gratification of his industry and tact at acquiring the higher branches of knowledge without the aid of an instructor, and more particularly the knowledge of the dead languages, of which he knew nothing himself. And this account given by the old gentleman, from intimate intercourse and frequent conversation with his son when I afterwards became acquainted with him, I found was by no means exaggerated. And to his excellent and accurate common-school education he owed much, very ranch, of his character for exact accuracy and correctness in all that he said and did through life. He was about the best reader I ever heard, wrote a fair, handsome, and legible hand, and in the unfailing correctness of his orthography and use of terms no lexicographer excelled him, and in everything pertaining to mere English, home, and common-school education no one appeared to be a more thorough proficient. And in Greek and Latin I never saw his superior, except old President Stiles, nor, with that exception perhaps, his ei|uitl, unless it was old Parson Farrand, of Canaan, and in the other branches of collegiate education he was, to say the least, above mediocrity.
; I believe, did not even attend during the whole of that year, he could not, of course, expect to shine and did not shine in the college lionors depending upon the faculty, but availed himself of the right to become
I tuned the first premium for excellence in Greek and Latin in a class of unusually high reputation. This, I suppose, he did merely out of a laudable pride, for he did not avail himself of the ]iecuniary reward, which would have refpiired him to reside in New Haven ; for he went, immediately after his graduation, with one of his classmates (Mr. - afterwards the Rev. Dr. - Smith) to resiile in Shan>n as one of the
I instructors in the Sharon Academy, then in full and succe-Hsful operation. lie soon after became a student-at-law under Governor Smith's instruction, and the first County Court, which sat Bl\er his two years' clerkship had expired, being in Fairfield County, he
, This was, I believe, at the November term, I'Wi. It was not until he began to atteixl court at Litclifield, and while I wa.s in the law-school there, that I first became personally acquainted with Mr. Slixinon, though I had barely seen him onco or twice before. After my admission to the bar, being locateil in adjoining towns, wo often met each other before justictw, anil conHecpiently before the upper courts. From our frequent meetings and intercourse at Litchfield and finally for <a number of years he and I, with Southniayd for our constant companion, always occupied the same room at Catlin's Hotel during every court until his death, and there was the last time I ever saw him in life. Soon after the court adjourned, hearing of his rapid decline, I set out to visit him, and on the way heard that he had died the night before. I however went on and stayed with the family until I assisted in burying him. This was in January, 1813, and in that grave I felt that I had buried a sincere, and I am sure a much-loved, friend, on whose character and conduct in life I could reflect with melancholy satisfaction unmarred by a single reproacliful recollection or one which I could wish to have forgotten.
" Mr. Slosson's great fondness for ancient literature rendered him scarcely just in his comparative estimate of that with modern improvements. As a lawyer he was highly respectable in theory and remarkably accurate in practice ; as a pleader I do not remember that he ever had occasion to ask for an amendment or to alter a tittle of what he had written. As an advocate he was clear, deliberate, methodical, and logical in his deductions. He sjioke in much of the peculiarly emphatic numner of his fother above mentioned, though not with his unusual slowness. He was always cool and self-possessed, rarely warming into any high degree of animation or aiming at efi'ect to appear eloquent, but he never failed to secure a respectful and satisfied attention. Though not one of the most leading advocates, of which there are always some three or four at the bar, he might, at least, be estimated an equal to any of the second class of the Litchfield bar, which was then certainly a highly respectable one.
" Though not an aspirant after public preferment, and from his habitually modest and retiring habits not calculated to push his way when opportunities ofiered, he was yet at the time of his decease in a fair way of promotion. He was early and often elected to the Legislature from his native town, and indeed their usual representative until the October session, 1812, when he was elected clerk, which in those daj's was a sure stepping-stone to future advancement; and having myself been a witness of the manner in which he performed the duties of that office, for which no man was better qualified, I am sure he established a reputation, which, had Providence permitted, promised a solid and lasting existence.
" Mr. Slosson's political opinions were of the genuine Washingtonian political school. None of your heady, rash, and merely partisan notions found favor with him. He was a constant and honest adherent to the political views then prevalent in this State.
" The foregoing sketch of the leading incidents in Mr. Slosson's life may be a sufiicient indication from which to deduce his true character, but I must indulge myself in adding that I never knew or heard of a single act of his life, either in youth or mature years, that left even a shade upon his reputation. Cool and deliberate in his temperament, never hurried away by enthusiasm, - for enthusiasm never manifested itself in his nature except in his passion for ancient literature, - he was sure to think and act with propriety. He was nevertheless warm and faithful in his attachments, but not so far as to warp his conscientious regard for integrity. He was perfectly just and generous in his intercourse with the world, honest in his predilections, and uncompromising in his love of virtue and detestation of vice. In morality his principles were without a taint, and his practice through life in conscientious conformity with them. In religion he was a firm and steadfast believer in the great doctrines of the gospel, though not a public professor. His principles were those of true rational Calvinism, unswayed by vindictive zeal or hysterical weakness.
" He was a small man, not much, if any, under medium height, but of slender frame and countenance. Though not dark complexioned his countenance was rather dusky, his skin not clear; his features, though far from handsome, bespoke intelligence, and were therefore not disagreeable. His general appearance was more like that of the late Leman Church than any other member of the bar I can think of, though he was somewhat larger and more erect. J\r' Samuel W. Southmayd. - In the life, conduct, /nd cnaracter of Samuel W. Bouthmayd there were some peculiarities, such as render it a matter of difficulty to describe him in such a manner as to make them intelligible to one who did not personally know him.
"I never saw or heard of him until I became a member of the law-school, in the fall of the year 1793, of which he had then been a member about one year, I believe, and of which he continued a constant attendant during the eighteen months which I spent there. He was admitted to the bar the next term after I was, - to wit, September term, 1795, - and passed as good an examination as I ever heard there or elsewhere, he having been for the full period of three years under Judge Reeve's tuition. He was a native of W.atertown, where he settled in practice, and where he spent his life. Like Mr. Slosson, he had an excellent common-school education. Beyond that his acquirements did not extend far in an academic course, enough, however, I believe, to enable him to understand the homely law Latin used in our books. Few have entered upon the practice of law with a better store of legal learning than Mr. Southmayd, but the place in which he settled was not calculated from its location and the habits of the people, by no means litigious, to furnish much practice, and he was too honest to promote litigation ; and furthermore, he had no legal adversary there except an old gentleman who never had any more legal learning than was necessary for a church warden, and whose ignorance made him the victim of Southmayd's merry witchery and innocent cunning, of both of which he had a superabundance, though he never indulged in malicious or even very serious mischief, and indeed in none except such as would do to relate for the purpose of making fun in merry company. Anecdotes of that description used to be related in great numbers. As a pleader Mr. Southmayd was always sure to have all in his drafts which was requisite and pertinent to the object in view, and in all his declarations affording room for coloring circumstances to be inserted there was pretty sure to be found, slyly slipped in, some ingenious slang whang, or Southmaydism, as we used to call it. He was not ambitious of arguing cases in court, but when he did he always displayed much ingenuity, and attracted respectful attention from the audience as well as from the triers. And before arbitrators, referees, and committees a more formidable opponent could hardly be found. And although his practice was not large, and as was observed of Mr. Slosson he was not among the leading practitioners at the Litchfield bar, he was certainly a very respectable lawyer, upon a par with the foremost of the second class, and much beloved and respected by all whose good opinions are desirable.
" As was observed in the outset, there were peculiarities in Mr. Southm.iyd's private character and deportment which it is difficult to dcscril)c or reconcile. Though of a benevolent disposition and full of good nature and kind feelings, there was yet in him a vein of adventure after intellectual amusement, which, from it« very nature, could not be gratified but at the expense of others, and often to such an extent as to render them ridiculous in the view of third ))ersons to whom the result of the adventure wa-s related. I have many times joined most heartily in the laugh at the relation of the result of many such seemingly innocent pieces of roguery, though I could not help condemning the mischief while participating in its fruits. In all such indulgences Southmayd never cntcrtuined the loii-st malice, for his heart wivs a stranger to it, but his intense love of fun and enjoyment of the ridiculous often impelled him to go beyond the line of honest propriety. I used often to reproach him with it, but my admonitions were not well calculated to take ed'ect when given at the close of a hearty laugh.
" From what I have been saying of Mr. Southmayd you would, 1 presume, bo ready to concluilo that he was one of the most clicerly and happy of men. But the case was directly the reverse, and during a considerable period of his life, and that, too, the most valuable part of it, he was a very unhappy man indeed, and I have no doubt he had recourse to much of the indulgence of that peculiar propensity I have attempted to describe for the purpose of dispelling a mental malady which for a long timo opprc8.sed and preyeil upon his heart. Ho was for many years the victim of tlu^ strongest species of hypochondria that ever mortal man was. It never showed it.self in long tits of settled melancholy or monomania, but in sudden fits and starts. After hours of cheerful conversation, and while in entire health, he would suddenly complain of great distress, and exhibit unmistakable evidence of great terror and apprehension of immediate dissolution. One very extraoi-dinary instance I will relate. He and I had been alone many hours, conversing and reading together, and he not in the least complaining, when he at once sprung from his seat and with a scream as would have alarmed me had it been any other person, and pressing both hands upon his breast, he exclaimed that he was going to die immediately. I stepped to him and gently and calmly said to him, ' Don't be alarmed, you are not going to die' (for we never treated him as if we thought his distress imaginary), and put my hand gently upon him to lead him to the bed, when he raised one hand from his breast and thrusting his finger against the side of his head declared, with another outcry, that something was passing through his head. I persuaded him to lie down, telling him the feeling would pass off in a few minute.s, but he continued to groan for some time. I, knowing what would cure him, took up and began to read to him one of Uurke's finest essays, which lay by rae, and, turning to a passage of extraordinary eloquence, read it, on which he sprung up on end in the bed, and exclaimed, ' Was ever anything finer than that I' I continued on reading, and in the course of half an hour he wius well and cheerful as ever. This was the most extraordinary instjince I ever saw in him, but those in a degree like it were frequent. He always went to bed an hour or two before Slosson and I did, he saying that he never was able to get asleep until he had gone through a great deal of such feelings as he never would attempt to describe.
" Mr. Southmayd was greatly esteemed in his native town by, I believe, almost every one, both old and young. He was early in life sent to the Legislature, and that often, and was so, I know, the last year of his life. He ilied of lung fever in Xfarch, 1H13, about two months after the death of his friend Slo.sson. At the December term, ISl:!, the three who had .so long occupied the same room in perfect harmony were for the last time there together. At the February term of the Siiprome Court, Southmayd and I oceupiiil it, but felt that we were in solitude, and in the next term it seemed U> me most emphatically a solitude, and more like a family vault than like an abode for living men, and I believe I have never been into it since.
" .Mr. Southmayd was undoubtedly an honest and honorable man, of uncommon pleasing manners and much beloved, and I never heard that he hail an enemy. Indeed, the amenity of his mannem and the gentleness of his temper almost forbade it.
"The family to which Mr. Southmayd bclongeil was of the Congregational order, and two of bis sisters married Congregational clergymen. He, howover, joined himself to the Kpi^copal Church, o( which bo was a member after he settled iu life, and of which I believe he was a comiminicant, but am not sure. He died unmarried, ami I believe in the thirty-ninth or fortieth year of his age.
"Hon. John Cotton S^mith, the most eminent citizen of the town of Sharon, was a son of Rev. Cotton Mather Smith, and was born Feb. 12, 1765. He was graduated at Yale College in 1783, admitted to the bar of Litchfield County in 1786, and married to Miss Margaret Evertson, of Amenia, N. Y., in October of the same year. Their only child, the late William M. Smith, Esq., was born in August, 1787. Mr. Smith was soon introduced into the active duties of his profession in his native town by rea.son of the pecuniary embarrtissments of the community in consequence of the Revolutionary war, and particularly from the extensive and embarrassed affairs of his uncle, Dr. Simeon Smith, who removed to Vermont, leaving the management of his extensive and complicated concerns in the hands of his young and inexi)erienced nephew. Through unwearied exertions he was able to extricate the affairs of his uncle from a nearly hopeless condition by the full ]iayment of all just demands against liim, and leaving him at last in the enjoyment of a handsome estate. It is but justice to his uncle to .say that he, having no children of his own, made ample compensation to his nephew by the bequest in his will of a large and valuable estate. He was first elected to the Legislature in 17!).3, and was very frequently a member, and twice Speaker before 1800, when he was elected a member of Congress. There he remained six years, when the declining health of his father compelled his resignation. He was immediately elected to the Legislature of the State, and represented the town without intermission till 1809, and held the place of Speaker at each session. He was then elected to the Council, and in the October .session of the same year was appointed a judge of the Supreme Court. In 1811 he was elected lieutenant-governor, and in 1813 Governor, of his native State. In this office he was continued till 1817, when the public voice demanded a change in the form of the government of the State, and the substitution of a written constitution for the less stable provisions of the charter of King Charles II. Governor Smith, not sympathizing with the majority on this question, retired to private life, and lived, for nearly thirty years, a private citizen of Sharon. In jjublic life he was never appointed to a position which he was not fully competent to fill. As a presiding otficer in a deliberative assembly he had no peer, and although while he was member of Congress, except for one short term, he was associated in principle and feeling with the minority, he was called upon to preside in committee of the whole more frequently than any other member. The late Luther Holley, an eminent citizen of Salisbury, who had been a member of the Legislature when Governor Smith was Speaker, once remarked that he had never seen a man who could take a paper from the table
"In private life Governor Smith was a fine specimen of the polished Christian gentleman. He devoted some of his time to reviewing the studies of his early life, and in the preparation of useful and entertaining articles for the more elevated literary periodicals. He was for several years president of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions, and of the American Bible Society, which latter olfice he retained till his death, which occurred on the 7th day of December, 1845, when he had nearly reached the age of eighty-one years.
" Nathaniel Smith.* - I received a line from my friend, Gen. Sedgwick, stating that it was your desire that he would ask of me, in your behalf, to furnish you with some facts in relation to the late Nathaniel Smith, and my views of his character, which might be of use to you in the preparation of the work you have in hand.
" I am, of course, aware that this application is owing to the accidental circumstance that I am the oldest, if not the only, member of the profession now living who had much personal acquaintance with that truly able and excellent man, or saw much of him in the exercise of his forensic or judicial talents. Judge Smith was indeed one of nature's nobles, and, considering the limited range of his early education, he had few equals and perhaps no superior in the profession which he chose, and which he eminently adorned. You are doubtless aware that Judge Smith had only such an education in childhood and youth as the common schools of the country afforded at the time. It was such, however, as a boy of unusual capacity and industrious habits would acquire from such a source, and such as, under the guidance of uncommon discretion through life, rarely permitted its defects to be disclosed.
" When I first went to the law-school in Litchfield, which was in the fall of 1793, Mr. Smith, though not over thirty years old, was in full practice, and engaged in almost every cause of any importance. Indeed, he was said to have established a high reputation for talents in the first cause he argued in the higher courts. It was upon a trial for manslaughter, which arose in his native town, and in which he appeared as junior counsel, and astonished the court, the bar, and all who heard him. Not long afterwards, in the celebrated case of Jedediah Strong and wife, before the General Assembly (she having applied for a divorce), he greatly distinguished himself again, and thus became known throughout the State as a young lawyer of the first promise, and the reputation thus early acquired was never suffered to falter, but, on the other hand, steadily increased in strength until his elevation to the bench.
mission to the bar, I of course saw Mr. Smith, and heard him in almost all the important cases there; and as I was located in the southwest corner town in the county, adjoining Fairfield, I almost immediately obtained some business which, though small, was such as during nearly all my professional life caused me to attend the courts in that county, where I found Mr. Smith as fully engaged and as highly esteemed as in his own county. In New Haven I also know he had a very considerable practice.
" It is worthy also to be observed, in forming an estimate of Mr. Smith's professional talent and character, that there never at any period was an abler bar in Connecticut than during his practice. In Litchfield County were Judge Reeve, Judge Adams, Gen. Iracy, John Allen, Judge Gould, N. B. Benedict, and others ; at the Fairfield County bar were Pierpont Edwards, Judge Ingersoll, and Judge Daggett, constantly from New Haven, Judge Edmunds, S. B. Sherwood, R. M. Sherman, Judge Chapman, and Governor Bissell ; and in New Haven, besides the three above named, were James Hillhouse, Judge Baldwin, and others.
"As I suppose it not probable that you ever saw Judge Smith, as he ceased to attend courts in 1819, and died wlien you were very young, I will observe, what you have doubtless heard, that he wa.s a large and fine-appearing man, much of the same complexion of the Hon. Truman Smith, his nephew, with whom you are so well acquainted ; less tall than he, but of rather fuller habit. His face was not only the index of high capacity and .solid judgment, but uncommonly handsome; his hair wa< dark and tliin, thougli not to baldness, e.\ce|)t on the fore part of his head, and was very slightly sprinkled with gray. His fine, dark eyes were remarkably pleasing and gentle in ordinary intercourse, but very variable; always kindling when highly excited in debate, they became almost oppre.-isive. His voice wa.s excellent, being both powerful and harmonious, and never broke under any exertion of it.s cajiacity. His manner wa.s very ardent and the seeming dictate of a strong conviction of the justice of liis cause, and his gestures were the natural expression of siu-h a conviction. Mr. Smith's style was jiure and genuine Saxon, with no attempt at classic ornament nr allusion. His train of reasoning was lucid and direct, and evincive of the fact that the whole of it was like a map .spread out in his mind's eye from the beginning. IFis ingenuity was always felt and drea<led by his opponent. He spoke with much fluency, but with no undue rapidity ; lu^ never hesitated for or har/i/lcit at a word, nor did he over tire his audience with undue prolixity, or omit to do full justice to his ca.se for fear of tiring them ; and indeed there was little danger of it. Though certainly a very fine speaker, he never achieved or aspired to those strains of almost superhuman eloquence witli which hiw old master Heevc sometimes electrified and astonished his audience, and yet, in ordinary cases, he was the most correct speaker of the two, though Judge Reeve was, and he was not, a scholar. Mr. Smith, though quite unassuming, and often receding in common intercourse and conversation, was, when heated in argument, it must be confessed, often overbearing to the adverse party, and not only them, but to their counsel. Upon all other occasions he appeared to be, and I believe was, a very kind-hearted, agreeable, and pleasant man. To me he always so appeared, and I have been much in his company.
" Mr. Smith came early into public life, and was frequently elected to the General Assembly from Woodbury. In 1795 he was elected a member of the Fourth Congress, and in 1797 he was chosen to the Fifth Congress, but declined further election. In May, 1799, he was made an assistant, and was re-eleeted for the five following years, when he resigned his seat at that board in consequence of the passage of the act in 1803 i)rohibiting the members of the then Supreme Court of Errors from practicing before that court. He remained in full practice at the bar until October, 180G, when he was elected a judge of the Superior Court and continued to fill that office until May, 1819, when the judiciary establishment of that year went into operation, from which time he remained in private life until his death.
"In every public station in which Mr. Smith was placed he distinguished him.Helf He did .so in Congress, at a time when our representation was as able, perhaps, as it ever has been, and when the character of the house to which be belonged was far higher than it now is. In the Superior Court he was certainly very greatly respected and admired as an able and perfectly upright judge.
" In private life his name was free from all reproach. A strictly honest and pure life, free from any of those little blemishes which often mar the fame <if distinguished men, may, I think, be fairly claimed by his hiogrnpher to be his due. As a husband, a parent, a friend, a neighbor, a moralist, an<l a Christian, I believe few have left a more faultle.-w name."
" Jame.>* Gori.i), the son of Dr. William Gould, an eminent jdiysician, was born at Brandford, in this State, in the year 1770. The goodness of his common-school eiluention is inferable from the perfect accuracy of it, which showed itself in all lie did or said in after-life. He graduated, when a little over twenty -one, at Yale College, in September, 1791, with distinguished honor in a class distinguished for talents.
" The year next following his collegiate course he spent in Baltimore as a teacher. He then returned to New Haven and commenced the study of law with Judge Chaunccy ; and in Se|>tenibcr of that year he was chosen a tutor in Yale College, in which office he continued two years. He then joined the hiw-schofd of Mr. Reeve, at Litchfield, and witt soon at^er ad- ' mitted to the bar. Imuiediutelv atler his adiuissioii
"On his first appearance as an advocate he evinced such an apparent maturity of intellect, such a selfpossession, such command of his thoughts and of the language appropriate to their expression, that he was marked out as a successful aspirant for forensic eminence. His i^rogress in the acquisition of professional business was steady and rapid.
" Fortunate circumstances concurring a few years before his choice of Litchfield as the field of his ))rofessional labors, in the removal by promotion of two very distinguished i)ractitioners at that bar, opened the way to such a choice, and by like good fortune a similar event removed one of the two only remaining obstructions in that town to his full share in the best business as an advocate, the only business to which he aspired. As a reasoner Mr. Gould was forcible, lucid, and logical ; as a speaker his voice was very pleasant and his language pure, clear, and always appropriate. He never aspired to high strains of impassioned eloquence, and rarely, if ever, addressed himself to the passions of the court and jury, but to their understanding only, and was a very able, pleasing, and successful advocate. His argument was a fair map of the case, and one sometimes engaged against him, l)ut feeling his superiority, observed that he had rather have Gould against him in a case than any other of j anywhere equal powers, because he could perfectly understand his .argument, and if suscejitible of an answer could know how to apjily it. In his practice at the bar he was always perfectly fair and honorable. Within some two or three years after Mr. Gould commenced jiractice, Mr. Reeve, the founder and until that time the sole instructor of the Litchfield Law- School, accejited a seat upon the bench of the Superior Court. This court made it necessary for him to give up the school or to associate some one with him in its management, and to deliver lectures in his absence upon the circuits. The judge selected Mr. Gould as that associate, and for a number of years they jointly conducted and received the profits of the school ; and on the final retiring of Judge Reeve from any participation in the instruction of the school, Mr. Gould became its sole instructor and so continued until elevated to the bench of the Superior Court in the spring of 1816, when lie in turn had to have recourse to temporary aid for the short time he remained on the bench. But a thorough political revolution having taken place in this State, and a new constitution formed which entirely new-modeled the courts of law, Mr. Gould took no further share in public employments ; and, his health being greatly impaired, he never resumed practice at the bar, but confined himself wholly to his school during the remainder of his life, as far as severe infirmities would permit. He died, as appears by the college catalogue, in 1838.
" In person Mr. Gould was very handsome. Of about medium height, or perhaps a little over, but r.ather less in body and limbs than medium size; his complexion fair, with fine dark eyes and beautiful brown hair; all his features good, and in connection indicative of much intelligence and good nature, and his form for symmetry and gracefulness could hardly have been mended ; and in all respects, in body, mind, and education, he may be fairly styled a finished man. In private and social intercourse he was highly pleasing, facetious, and witty.
" Soon after his settlement in Litc'.ifield he married the eldest daughter of the Hon. Uriah Tracy, so well known for his long and distinguished services in the councils of the State and nation.
"Mrs. Gould in person and mind was a fit wife for such a husband, and partook with him in the happiness of raising a very numerous and promising family of children.
" Judge Gould wrote and published a volume of pleadings, which, together with his fame as an instructor, gave him a distinguished name among the eminent jxirists of the country."
" Ho>f. Noah Bkxnet Bexedict was a native of Woodbury, in which he resided during his whole life. He was the son of the Rev. Noah Benedict, long the pastor of the First Congregational Church in that town. Mr. Benedict's early school education must have been correct and good, as its fruits invariably showed itself in after-life. He graduated at Yale College in September, 1788, when a little short of eighteen years of age. His legal studies commenced soon after his graduation, which were, I believe, pursued principally, if not wholly, in the oflice of his brother-in-law, Nathaniel Smith, afterwards so highly distinguished as a jurist, which was near the residence of Mr. Benedict's father. As soon as he arrived to lawful age Mr. Benedict came to the bar, and for the remainder of his life - to wit, about thirty-nine years - it is believed he never failed to attend every regular session of the courts holden at Litchfield ; and, though he never habitually attended courts in other counties, he occasionally did so for the purpose of arguing a particular case. During the long course of his practice Mr. Benedict had an ample share of business, and for the latter half of that period he was, especially in the Superior Court, the leading advocate on one side or the other in most of the trials either to the court or to the jury. His management of a trial was discreet, his arguments sgund, sensible, and, being aided by the well-known and generally esteemed integrity of his character, had their due etTect. He never attempted to play the orator or to attract attention by fine turned periods, but contented himself with plain reasoning, of which he was no indifferent master.
" At a very early period Mr. Benedict was a member of the Legislature. But the political majority of the voters in Woodbury, becoming about this time and for long afterwards decidedly Democratic, proved an effectual bar to his political promotion, as far as depended upon that town, but by the vote of the State at large he was elected in 1813 one of the twelve assistants (as they were then styled who composed the upper house of the Assembly), and was re-elected the two following years ; but in the year 1818 an entire political revolution took place in Connecticut, and Mr. Benedict shared the fate of almost every one who held any post of dignity or profit depending upon public suflrage at large in the State. He was subsequently many years later elected once more to the lower house. He was also for several years judge of probate for the district of Woodbury, an appointment then depending upon the Legislature. Mr. Benedict was twice married, but left no living issue. He died in June or July, 1831, at the age of sixty, or in his sixtieth year.
"In private life Mr. Benedict was entirely unassuming, and a very pleasing companion to all who could relish purity of moral character and conduct, which his whole life was an eminent example; his feelings were peculiarly sensitive and delicate; a loose or profane expression never escaped his lips ; and indeed so fastidious was he in respect to the former that it used to be a matter of amusement with his less scrupulous associates in jocose conversation to tease his feminine delicacy upon sucli subjects. Tiiough wlien alone and unoccupied he had a propensity to indulge in somewhat gloomy reflections, yet he was not averse to participate in facetious conversation when due delicacy was observed. He liad a profound respect for religion, and was in all respects a gooil, a very good, nuoi.
" Hon. Jabez W. Huntington, son of the late Gen. Zachariah Huntington, of Norwicii, and grandson of the Hon. .Tabo/. Huntington, of that place, tlie tHKsistant and a.ssociato of the first (tovcrnor Trumbull, was born in Norwich in the year 1787 or 1788. He received his early training and in.struction in his native town, which after-times evinced to be accurate and good. He became a member of Yale Oolloge in September, 18((2, ami gnuluatod in September, ISOC), with the reputation of a good scholar. Soon after his graduation he became a teacher in an academic school under the government of it.s founder, Esquire Morris, of Litchfield South Farms, as then calleil, miw the town of Morris, named after the founder of saiil school. After about a year thus employed, Mr. Huntington entered Judge Heeve's law-school, in which he continued a diligent .student until admitted to the bar in Litclifield County, of wliich ho soon showed himself to be a worthy member, and in due time a distinguislied one, lie having commenced the practice of his profession in F<itchfielil, and there continueil it until its final termination by an ofiico conferred upon him incompatible with its further pursuit. In practice his whole aim and ambition was to become an advocate, and had no desire to obtain any share of collecting business, though in many hands not less lucrative, and, as he was always ready to aid the less ambitious of speaking, he early acquired a very considerable share of the portion of practice of which he was ambitious, and which was improving to him. His forte as an advocate was in detecting error in declarations and other parts of pleadings, and in a lucid manner of pointing them out. Upon the whole, he was an advocate clear and accurate, rather than peculiar for the gracefulness of manner or refinement of diction, though his manner was by no means disgusting, and his language entirely free from any approach to vulgarity. His manners were pleasing and popular, and he repeatedly represented Litchfield in the General Assembly, and distinguished himself there. He was elected to the Twenty-first Congress, and re-elected to the Twenty-second and Twentythird Congresses, and near the expiration of the last of his congressional career he was chosen a judge of the Superior Court, and held that office until 1840, when, being chosen a senator of the United States, he resigned the judgeship and accepted the latter appointment, and continued to hold it by virtue of a second ap))ointment until his death, in 1847, in all which stations he performed the duties thereof with honor to himself and to the entire satisfaction of the public. His moral character was irreproachable ; a professor of religion and an observer of its precepts. Late in life he was married, but it is believed left no issue. Soon after election to Congress he removed to his native town, and ilied there.
" PiuxEAS MiXEK, a very respectable and somewhat eminent member of the Litchfield County bar, was a nativeof Winchester, in that county, and there, and in that region, as far as by the writer hereof known, received his entire training and education in all respects. At an early period in life he commenced the practice of law in the place of his birth, in the society of Winsted, as is believed, a place of a great deal of active manufacturing business and furnishing an ample share of employment for gentlemen of the legal profession, of which Mr. Miner soon acipiired an ample share, and at no distant period an engrossing one, with wliich he appeared in court from term to term until ho felt warranted in the expectation of drawing after him an engagement in all the disputable caseH from that fruitful (piarter, when ho removed to Litehfied, and wiut much employed as an advocate for a number of years, ami until his health rather prematurely failed, and he became the victim of great ment4il and bodily sutfering, until relieved by death before reaching the ordinary period at which old age begins til make its elleets much perceptible in the human frame. As an advocate Mr. Miner was ardent, impassioned, and Huent, but in his apparent great ambition to be eloquent he often made use of figures of speech w]iich a more chastened and correct training in youtli would have taught him to avoid, and less wounding to an ear of taste, but the fault apparent to all was the extreme prolixity of his arguments, but, these faults notwithstanding, Mr. Miner was a respectable and able advocate.
" Before his removal to Litchfield, Mr. Miner was an early and frequent member of the Legislature from his native town, and after his removal there a member of the State Senate for the Fifteenth District, and was also elected to fill a vacancy in the second session of the Twenty-third Congress.
" Mr. Miner was twice married, but, it is believed, left no issue, but of this the writer is uncertain. He led a strictly moral life, and was justly esteemed a good man.
" Leman Church, a late member of the Litchfield County bar, was a native of Salisbury, in this county, a son of an opulent farmer of that town, and in it, it is supposed, he received his education, both scholastic and professional, the latter in the office of his halfbrother, Samuel Church, afterwards a judge of the Superior Court, and finally chief justice of the same; and after his admission to the bar he opened an office in North Canaan, where he resided during the remainder of his life. Mr. Church was successful in acquiring at an early period a promising share of professional business, which steadily increased, until by the middle of professional life he occui)ied a stand among the leading advocates at the bar ; and towards the close of life there was scarce a cause, especially in the higher courts, of considerable importance, discussed in which he was not engaged.
" In September, 1833, Mr. Church was appointed by the court State's attorney as successor to his brother Samuel, on the latter's elevation to the bench of the Superior Court, and held that office by annual reappointments until September term, 1838, when by a political change in the court he was required to yield the place to another ; it is believed, however, that he afterwards for a time reoccupied that place, but not positively recollected.
" As a speaker he was cool, unimpassioned, and ingenious ; he never attempted to affect the passions of those he addressed, and, being destitute of passion himself, was consequently incapable of moving the passions of others ; he never attempted to be eloquent or made use of a merely ornate expression, his object in speaking was effect, and that wholly directed to his cause and not to himself; in the management of a case he was always cool and self-possessed ; no sudden and unexpected turn in the progress of a trial disconcerted him or appeared to be unexpected by him ; no collision at the bar ever appeared to affect his temper in the least. With such a temperament, it is obvious that the legal profession was of all the professions the one for him, and that in which he was calculated to excel. " Mr. Church was always entirely regardless of personal appearance and dress ; he was very small, meagre, and. ill formed, his features quite ordinary, but all this very indifferent appearance was rescued from inattention by a most remarkably attractive and intelligent eye.
" Mr. Church was frequently a representative to the Legislature from Canaan, and never failed to make an impression upon that body ; and to his sagacious management is attributable the preservation of the Housatonic Railroad from ruin, as a commissioner thereon appointed by the Legislature, with power, together with his associate in office, Mr. Pond, to sell and consequently to destroy the road, which seemed to be a favorite object with them for a time.
The Hon. Ansel Sterling was born in Lyme, Conn., Feb. 3, 1782, the seventh son of William Sterling, a man of position and considerable wealth in that town. His grandfather, Joseph Sterling, born in 1700, was one of the early settlers of Lyme. The name originally was spelt Stirling, as seen in the old cemetery in that place.
On the maternal side Judge Sterling is descended from William Hyde, whose name is on the monument in the old cemetery at Hartford, Conn., as one of the original settlers of 1G3G, and one of the original proprietors of the town of Norwich, Conn.
Mr. Hyde's great-great-great-granddaughter, Jemima Sill, married Capt. William Stirling, Jan. 3, 1763, the subject of this sketch being their tenth child and seventh son.
Judge Sterling, at the early age of twenty-three, was a iiracticing lawyer at the bar of Litchfield County, and for fovli/ years there were no interruptions to his attending each session of the different courts. He studied his profession with his eldest brother, Hon. Elisha Sterling, of Salisbury, Conn., who was a graduate of the class of 1787 of Yale College, " a man of a high order of talent."
Judge Sterling settled in Sharon in );he year 1808, where he spent his life. Oct. 8, 1804, he married Isabella Canfield, seventh daughter of Hon. John Canfield and Dorcas Buell, of Sharon.
Hon. John Canfield was a son of Samuel Canfield, Esq., of New Milford, Conn., a judge of the court of Litchfield County, and deacon of the Congregational Church in that place. Samuel Canfield's wife was Elizabeth Judson, the great-great-granddaughter of William Judson, who came from Yorkshire, England, in 1634.
The Hon. John Canfield was born in New Milford, Conn., 1740 ; was graduated at Yale College 1762. He was a great-grandson of Matthew Canfield, an original settler of Norwalk, Conn., a judge and leading man in the colony. Hinman says, -
*' As a proof of liia. standing, I may only mention lie was one of the nineteen signei-s of the petition to King Cliarles II. for the Charter of the colony, and his name is mentioned in that invaluable grant to Con- necticut in 1C02. TUis is ample proof of liis exalted standing in the colony, as no gentleman would have been called upon to sign the petition but sucli men as had sustained a high reputation in England before they came to New England."
He fitted for the legal profession several gentlemen who afterwards rose to eminence; among them his son-in-law, Ambrose Spencer, chief justice of the State of New York, Hon. John Cotton Smith, and Noah Webster.
"Mr. Canfield enjoyed a most enviable reputation and was held in the highest estimation by his fellowcitizens. He represented the town in the Legislature at ten different sessions." In 1786 he was elected a member of the Continental Congress, but died on the 26th of October of the same year. Not living to take his seat in that body, his name is omitted from the honorable roll of those early days.
Mr. Canfield wa^ a friend of Benjamin Franklin, with wliora was held many earnest consultations, the ' "ta.\ on tea" being at one time a subject of special interest. His wife, Dorcas Buell, was the only daughter of Solomon Buell, eighth son of John Buell, and grandson of William Buell, who came from England in 1643. Their children, eight in number, were Laura, wife of Ambrose Spencer; Annis, wife of' Andrew Adams, Jr., son of Chief Ju.stice Adams, of Litchfield; Eunice, wife of Samuel Rockwell, M.D. ; Avis, who died aged thirteen years; Alma, wife of' Hon. Elisha Sterling; Almira, wife of Gen. Elisha Buel ; John Montgomery, married Fanny Harvey ; Isabella, wife of .\nsel Sterling.
Judge Sterling was a man of unimpeachable integrity, "of diversified talent. As a lawyer his forensic ability was of a high order, nor wa.-i he deficient in legal science. His language flowed rapidly, and at times his appeals to the jury were verj' cflective."
"This dhtiugiilshwl gentleman wiu lung an active and prominent member of the bar of LltchflelU County, for many tcMlons an tnrtuentlal member v»f the (Jeiieral A«embly of the Sliito of Connwiicut, a circuit Judge uf Die County Court, a nienil>or of Congreaa for two M«>lon«, and an estimable man hi all tlio relalluiia uf loclal and doniesllc life."
Judge Sterling died Nov. 6, IS.W, aged sevonty-onc. His wife died July 2G, 18-')5, aged seventy-four. Their children, eight in nuinhor, are Laura Spencer; George Aupustino, who graduated at West Point, served for a time in the I'nited Stati-s army stationed at Fort Gibson, in the then Territory of Arkaii!*a.t, resigned ami entered the ministry of the Kjiiicopal Church. He died at Sharon, Oct. 17, IWl". He married Flora J. Chamberlain. Their children were Mary Isabella, wife of Walter M. I'atterson, E"M|., who died Feb. 18, 1864; George Ansel, M.D., married Mary 1'. Havens.
Charles Ansel, third son, married Augusta A. Shelton. Two children : Charles Frederick, M.D., wife, Mar}- C. Anthony ; Isabella Canfield, wife of William C. Atwater.
Eev. John Canfield, fifth son, was graduated at Trinity College, Connecticut, a clergjman of the Episcopal Church; died at Hartford, Conn., Dec. 10, 1874. He married Caroline Sargent L'pson. Their children are Caroline, Isabella, Alice, Clarance Canfield.
For notices of Ephraim Kirby, Uriel Holmes, E. C. Bacon, Francis Bacon, and John Bird, see Litchfield history ; and for John and Judson Canfield, see history of Sharon.
" Stephen Titus HosMER was a lawyer of eminence in his peculiar way. He had no very high standing as an advocate, but, as a lawyer learued in elementary principles, his position was a very good one. A gentleman who had heard him told me that his manner was hard and dry and his elocution very defective, but in some branches of legal science he had few superiors. He seemed to delight in e.vploring ancient paths in search of legal principles, and in getting up old legal tracts and dissertations. In the first volume of Day's Reports there is a note of forty pages of fine print containing an opinion of Lord Camden, of the English Court of Common Pleas, which has hardly a rival injudicial learning or eloquence. Mr. Day informed me that this was presented to him in manuscript by Mr. Hosnier, there being then no printe<l copy of it on this side of the Atlantic. He was appointed a judge of the old court in 1815, but, being one of the younger judges, it never fell to his lot to preside on the trial of a ca.-<e until his accession to the chief justiceship. His career on the whole was very successful, both at niti priut and on the bench of the Supreme Court. His opprehension of the points involved in the case before him wa.n very (|uick, anil the (irst intimation he gave on incidental matters occurring in the course of the trial was a sure indication of what the result would be, and, although he would take special pains to soy to the counsel that ho had formed no opinion, the party against whom he leaned knew that his fate was sealed. His labors in his otllcial iliities must have been immense. It fell to his lot to give the opinion of the court in neorly all the cases tried in the Supremo Court for sovenil years after his appointment, and nearly all the material of the third, fourth, and fifth large volumes of the Connecticut RoporU ore the result of his study of the ciuses belbre the court, and some of them arc very learned uud labored. His illustrations in the case of Mitchell vs. Warner, in the second of Connecticut Reports, of the extent of tlie obligations incurred in the covenants of a deed, explained the subject to me when I was young better than anything I had before read on the subject.
" It seemed to be his object to render himself as agreeable as possible to the members of the bar, sometimes employing his leisure moments on the bench in furnishing prescriptions for human ailments, such as corns on the toes, and handing them over to such members as stood in need of them. Then he would hand over a formula for making, as he said, the best kind of liquid blacking for our boots. In fact, everything which he had prescribed he always designated as t/ic very best. At one term of the court, Phineas Miner, Esc)., who had lived a widower for several years, was about being married, which fact was intimated to the judge. While he sat waiting on the bench for the preparation of some business, he s])oke out suddenly : " Gentlemen, is there a vacant cell in your jail ? Won't it be necessary for me to commit Mr. Miner to prevent his doing some rash act?" The laugh was thoroughly turned upon poor Miner, and the whole scene was very enjoyable. He employed all his leisure hours in obtaining all the relaxation which was within his reach. He played on the piano and violin, and sang with great power and effect.
" There was no perceptible waning of his powers, physical or mental, during the time of his service on the court. He retired from the bench at the age of seventy years, in February, 1833, and died, after a short illness, in less than two years thereafter."
"John Thompson Teters was the senior associate judge of the court, and he held his first circuit in this county. He was a native of Hebron, and a lawyer of respectable standing. His fellow-citizens had often honored him with a seat in the Legislature, and thus he had become tolerably well known in the State. When the United States direct tax was laid, in 1814, he was appointed collector for the First District, removed to Hartford, and held that office when he was appointed judge. He had been one of the leaders of the Democratic party from its formation, and as an Episcopalian had opposed the claims of the 'Standing Order' to ecclesiastical priority, and some apprehensions were felt lest his well-known views on these subjects might temper his opinions on those questions incidentally involving them. Many fears were entertained as to the stability of ecclesiastical funds which existed in almost every Congregational parish, and those who desired to break them down looked to Judge Peters and to his influence with the court to aid them. But those who entertained such hopes were destined to an early disappointment, as their past experience of his administration on such questions showed him to be disposed to stand firmly on the old paths. He used to tell an amusing anecdote relating to his first trial of such a case in one of the eastern counties of the State, where he was appealed to very strongly to decide that a promise to i)ay money in aid of such funds was without consideration. But he told the parties that the law on that subject was well settled, and, in his opinion, founded on correct principles, and that if he had the power he had not the disposition to change it. It had been the practice of the Congregational pastor of the village to open the proceedings in court with prayer, but, considering Peters to be a heretic (I use the judge's own language), he had never invited Divine favor for him, but after that decision every prayer was charged with invocations of blessings upon ' thy sarvant, thej^idge.''
" He was very severe in meting out the punishments of the law to convicted criminals, generally inflicting the severest sentence that the law would allow. One case was tried before him which excited much remark and some reprehension. A man had been convicted before Judge Lanman of a State-prison offense;' had been sentenced to four years' imprisonment, and had served a part of a year, when he obtained a new trial. He was tried again, before Judge Peters, and again convicted. When the time came to pass sentence on the last conviction, his counsel asked for some mitigation on account of the imprisonment already suffered. Said the judge, ' He must settle that account with Judge Lanman. He owes me five years' imprisonment in State prison,' and such was the sentence. One prisoner who had received a severe sentence at his hands after the expiration of his confinement burned the judge's barn, and he petitioned the Legislature of the State to pay for it in 1831, but they declined to make the compensation.
" For a few years the services of Judge Peters on the bench were very acceptable. His decisions were prompt and generally founded on a sensible view of the matter before him, without any affectation of learning or a display of oratory. His entire candor and fairness were never called in question, and the decay of his powers, which was very apparent towards the close of his career, was observed by the bar with sorrow and regret. I witnessed an aff'ecting scene connected with his experience on the bench which excited a deep feeling of sympathy. He had a favorite son, Hugh Peters, Esq., whom he had educated at Yale College, and in whom all his hopes seemed to centre. This young man, in connection with George D. Prentice, the noted editor, had much to do in conducting the New England Weekly Review, a paper just established in Hartford, and which was the organ of the party which elected William W. Ellsworth, Jabez VV. Huntington, and William L. Storrs to Congress. He had acquired a wide reputation as a writer of brilliant promise, and after a while went to Cincinnati to go into business as a lawyer. On his way across Long Island Sound he wrote a farewell to New England in poetry, which was published with great commendation in most of the newspapers in the country. Soon after his arrival at Cincinnati his dead body was found floating in the Ohio, several miles below the city, and circumstances were such as to create the belief in some minds that it was a case of suicide. The intelligence of this sad event was brought to Litchfield while the Court of Errors was in session, in June, 1831. It was first communicated to Judge Williams, who sat next to Judge Peters, and he, with all possible tenderness, informed the latter. The reporter, Mr. Day, in giving the report of the case on trial, closes it by saying, ' Peters, Judge, having received, during the argument of this case, intelligence of the death of his son, Hugh Peters, Esq., of Cincinnati, left the court-house, ' multa gemens casuque animum concusstis,' and gave no opinion.' I witnessed the mournful scene, and I well remember the loud aud plaintive groans of the afflicted old man as he passed out of the court-room and down the stairway to his lodgings.
" When Chief Justice Hosmer retired from the bench, the Legislature, by a very strong vote, elected Judge Peters' junior. Judge Daggett, chief justice. Pie felt the slight, but did not retire, aud held his place till his death, in August, 18.34. A few weeks longer and he would have reached the age of seventy years. '
" Asa Chapmax. - The next judge in seniority was Asa Chapman, of Newtown, in Fairfield County. For several years before he received the apjioiiitment he practiced to some extent in this county, and was, of course, well known here. He was the father of the late Charles Chapman, of Hartford. He was somewhat taller than the son, and, with his bald head, white locks, thin face, and gray eyes, he resembled him not a little in persona! appearance, but lie hail none of that bitterness of nuinncr or spirit whicli cluiracteri/ed the efforts of the younger Chapman. He was an Episcopalian in religious faith, and he Iiad very naturally fallen into the ranks of tiie new party, and, being well (jualified for the place in point of legal ability, he made a very acceiitable and popular judge. He was a man of good humor, genial temper, and great colloquial powers, which lie exercised very freely on the trial of cases. If a lawyer undertook to argue a case before him, he soon found himself engaged in a friendly, familiar conversation with the judg(', the evident intent of the latter being to draw out the truth and justice of the case. His ndniinistrntion was very popular, and his early death was greatly deplored. He died of consumption, in 1826, at the age of fifty -six years.
" Jekkmiaii Oaths IJitAiXAun, of New London, the fatlur of the poet ISraiiianl, was next In seniority on the bench. He ha<l been a member of the old court from 1807, and he wa-s elected to the new court under the circumstances which I have mentioned. He was a man of no showy pretensions, verj* plain and simple in his manners, and very familiar in his intercourse with the bar. He affected very little dignity on the bench, aud yet he was regarded an un excellent judge. He despatched business with great facility, and implicit confidence was placed in his sound judgment and integrity. He resigned his place " on the bench in 1829, his health not being equal to the duties of the office, having served as judge for twenty-two years.
" WiLi.iAM Bristol. - Of all the judges on the bench, William Bristol, of New Haven, was the youngest in years as well as in rank. He had not been much known as a lawyer out of the county of New Haven, and, of course, his coming here was looked for with considerable interest. He evidently had a high sense of judicial dignity, his manners on the bench being very taciturn, approaching severeness, very seldom speaking except to announce his decisions in the fewest possible words, and I doubt if any one ever saw him smile in court. His decisions were sound and well considered, and upon the whole his administration was respectable, although he could not be said to have had much personal popularity with the bar.
" David Daggett. - The decease of Judge Chapman and the resignation of Judge Bristol in 1826 created two vacancies in the court whicli were to be filled at the session of the Legislature of that year. The same party which had effected the change in the government of the State and in the constitution of the court was still in power, but nearly all the eminent lawyers in the State adhered to the Federal party. Probably the most obnoxious man in the State to the dominant party was David Daggett, not so much from personal dislike as from his prominence in the ranks of his party. His talent.s, integrity, and high legal abilities were conceded by every one, but when tlic Legislature assembled there was probably not a man in the State who looked to his election as a judge.
"There were a few men in the State belonging to the toleration party who felt deeply the importance of having a reputable court, and who, on this ijuestion, were willing to forego all party considerations. Morris Woodruff, of Litchfield County, Thaddeus Belts and Charles Hawlcy, of Fairfield County, Walter Booth, of New Haven County, and Charles J. Mc- Curdy, of New London County, were men of that stamp; and it was through the influence of these men, and of othera of k-ss pmmineru-e, that David Daggett was elected a judge of the Supreme Court. The same influences, exerted by the same men, secured the election of Juilgca Williams and l<is.sell, three years later.
" .\fler the election of Judge Daggett was effected no one seemed to care who the other juilge might bo, OS with Chief Justice Hosmer at the head of the court, and Judge Daggett as an a«8ociate, it was felt that it could have a highly respectable character. The Hon. James Lanmun received tlie nj>|Hiintment, but af^er a short term of service resigned.
was the Hon. John Welch, of Litchfield. He was a native of the parish of Milton and a graduate of Yale * College in the class of 1778, - a class which is said to have produced more eminent men in proportion to its numbers than any other which ever graduated at that institution. Joel Barlow, Zephaniah Swift, Uriah Tracy, Noah Webster, and the last Governor Wolcott, with many other distinguished men, were of the class.
" Judge Welch never entered either of the professions, but he lived to a very great age. He was appointed a judge of the County Court in the place of Cyrus Swan, Esq., of Sharon, who had resigned his position on the bench of the court in 1819. Judge Welch continued on the bench till lie became disqualified by age in 1829. He made no pretensions to legal learning, but his decisions were based on a fair, impartial view of the questions as they came up. He always gave reasons for the opinion he had formed, always made himself well understood, and his candor, fairness, and sound judgment were admitted by all.
MAN. - In 1829, when Judge Welch must retire on account of his age, it was deemed jjroper by the Legislature to make new appointments of both associate judges. Judge Strong had been twelve years on the bench, and in his place William 51. Burrall, Esq., of Canaan, was appointed senior associate judge, and Gen. Morris Woodrurt" tonk the |ilace of Judge Welch. The court continued thus organized till the resignation of Judge Pettibone, when, not only with the consent, but with the decided approval, of both associate judges, David S. Boardman, Esq., of New Milford, was taken from the bar and installed chief judge of the County Court, which as then constituted held a high position in public confidence.
" Jauez Swift was the first lawyer who settled in Salisbury. He was a native of Kent, and upon the breaking out of the war of the Revolution he joined the army in Boston, and there died.
" Adom.jah Strong was a pupil of Mr. Swift, and succeeded him in practice. Col. Strong was a man of vigorous mind, had a large practice, but possessed none of the graces of eloquence. For many years he was an efficient magistrate, and a member of the General Assembly. He died in February, 1813.
" Joseph Canfield, Esq., commenced his professional studies with Col. Strong, and finished them at the Litchfield Law School. He commenced his practice at Furnace Village, in Salisbui-y, about the year 1789. Mr. Canfield was a gentleman of graceful manners and good talents; he died in September, 1803, having been several times a member of the Assembly.
" Martin Strong, of Salisbury, son of Col. Adonijah Strong, of that town, was a lawyer of the olden time, of whose wit, as well as blunders, many stories were rife fifty years ago. Col. Strong had four sons, all of whom entered into professional life, - two as clergymen, and two as lawyers. His son, the Eev. William Strong, was father of the Hon. William Strong, of Pennsylvania, now one of the associate justices of the United States Supreme Court. Judge Martin Strong had been a member of the bar for several years, but had never made a very high mark in his profession; in fact, he had never devoted himself assiduously to the discharge of its duties. He owned a very large and valuable farm on the town hill in Salisbury, and his principal business was to attend to that. When he came upon the bench he seemed to have a recollection of a few plain legal maxims, but his method of applying them to cases was not always the most skillful. He was a man of immense physical dimensions, and when he had taken his seat on the bench he sat in perfect quiet until the loud proclamation of the sheriff announced the adjournment of the court. He remained in office till 1829, when William M. Burrall, Esq., of Canaan, took his place.
" Asa Bacon was a native of Canterbury, and came to Litchfield as early as 1806, after a short period of practice at East Iladdam, and for a while was a partner of Judge Gould. lu 1820 he had become a leading spirit at the bar. He had a fine personal appearance, being tall and well proportioned, and usually richly dressed. The first time I saw him before the jury his head was well cased in powder and jjomatum, and a long queue was dangling at his back; but he soon laid aside this conformity to old-time fashions, although he was the last member of the bar to do so. He was undoubtedly a very hard student, and his briefs were the result of extensive and faithful study. He was not a very fluent, but was after all an interesting, speaker. He would sometimes interlude his arguments with specimens of drollery and flashes of wit, and the expectation that these would be put forth secured a very strict attention from all his hearers. He frequently quoted passages of Scripture and commented upon them, not always irreverently, but sometimes with rather unbecoming levity. He was a mortal enemy of universal suffrage, and once in commenting upon the parable of the talents he called the bailee of one talent who had hid it in the earth a universal suffrage man. He was a genial, jolly, companionable man, and, although not addicted to excessive liberality in his benefactions, still kept himselfin good standing while he remained here. When he had reached the age of sixty years he was appointed president of the branch of the Phoenix Bank, located in Litchfield, and after that was never seen professionally engaged in court. The last years of his life were spent in New Haven, where he died at a very advanced age.
"Gen. Elisha Sterling was a native of Lyme and a graduate of Yale College in the class of 1787. He studied law with the Hon. John Canfield, of Sharon, who was his father-in-law, and settled in Salisbury iii 1791. He was a man of a high order of talent, and had he addressed himself solely to professional points would probably have stood at the head of the bar in this county. But he loved money and gave much of his time to different kinds of business, and acquired great wealth for those times. Notwithstanding this propensitj' he had an extensive practice and was engaged in most of the cases coming from the northern portions of the county. He was a ready speaker, not very select in tlie clioice of his words, and not eloquent by any established rule of elocution, but there was a kind of impetuosity in bis manner, accompanied by a rapid but distinct utterance of language, which gave him, popularity as an advocate. He was appointed State's attorney in 1814, and held the office six years, when Seth P. Beers, Esq., was appointed in his place. He retired from practice soon after, and died in 1836, at the age of seventy-two years. His wealth enabled him to indulge the strong taste he had for a handsome style of living and equipage, and in that direction his mind had strong aristocratical tendencies.
"David S. Boardman was a native of New Milford, and settled there in the practice of law after bis admission to the bar, in 179o. He wiis a man of retiring disposition, in no way giving showy display of his powers, but he was a finished legal scholar, and was deemed a very safe and prudent professional adviser. He had a very nice literary taste, and the least grammatical blunder by a judge or lawyer attracted his attention and frequently liis ridicule. His arguments were pointed specimens of pcrs))icuity, precision, and force, but he failed to attract much attention as an advocate tlirougli a defect of vocal power. His voice was feeble and could scarcely be heard except by those who were near him. Ho had a high character for moral rectitude, and his four or five years' service at the liead of the County Court gave it a dignity and moral power whicii in other years it had scarcely obtained. Sketches from Iiis pen descriptive of some of the members of the bar in this county of the last century may be found in the beginning of tliis chapter. He was a college classmate of Asa Bacon, and they wore warm personal friends. He lived to the great age of ninety-seven years.
" Ehineha.s Mixer, the last, because tlie youngest, of the class of lawyers to whom I iiave referred, deserves a much more extended notice than I sliull be able to give him. His amiable and genial temper as a man seemed to make him very popular iis a lawyer. Fidelity to his clients and a laborious attention to their interests was a marked trait in his professional career. He commenced practice in Wincliester, his native town, and had there acquired a good standing in his profession, when he came to Litchfield in 181(i. He had an extensive practice and was notrd for the diligence with whicli he pressed every jmint, however unimportant, which could be made to tell In favor of his client. His arguments were generally extended to a great length, and I have known him to receive a gentle hint from the Judge recomuicudiug a condensation of his thoughts. He died in 1839, at the age of sixty years, and Mr. Day, the reporter, gives a flattering estimate of him in a foot-note on 134th page of the 18th volume of Connecticut Keports.
" William G. AVilliams, of New Hartford, stood as high as any member of this class. He belonged to the eminent and reputable Williams family, of Massachusetts, his father being a nephew of Col. Ephraim Williams, the founder of Williams College, and himself the first cousin of Bishop Williams, of the Episcopal Church of Connecticut. As a special pleader he had no superior at the bar. He had a tolerably fair standing as an advocate, and was indefatigable in pursuing to the last possible effort any purpose he had undertaken. If he failed iu one form of action he would try another, and never gave up till further persistence was hopeless. He commenced business as a lawyer in Sharon, where he married, but after a few years he removed to New Hartford, where he remained during his life. He had scarcely reached the age of sixty years when he died.
" John Stkoxg, Jr., of Woodbury, his native town, was a lawyer of very fair standing. I remember once to have heard Judge Boardman say ' that if he found John Strong differing from himself on a law point, he always doubted the correctness of his own conclusions.' He was a ready speaker and had a peculiar habit of looking all over the hall, frequently directly behind himself, while he wiw addressing the jury. His arguments were clear and logical, and he was always listened to by the court with attention. He had scarcely reached the age of fifty years when he died.
" Calvix Bl'TLER, of Plymouth, had a very good reputation as a lawyer. He also stood well witli his fellow-citizens of Plymouth, as he was often a member of the Legislature, and he Wius nl' the convention of this State. He was also a member of the Senate in 1832. He had a part in all cases which came from that town and managed a trial very well. He was earnest iu his manner of addressing the jurj-, and he was in full practice up to the tinu' of his death, when he had reached the age of seventy-two year^. He died suildenly while away from hi>me, and left behind a good record as a faithful lawyer and an honest num.
"Cyhis Swax, of Stonington, cunie to the bar of this county in 17'.>S. He -settled in Sharon, and continued in full practice for twenty years. He wa.s appointeil a judge of the County Court in 1S18, and reappointed for the succeeding year, but resigneil the office before the close of the term. His health becoming intolerant of sedentary liabits and ropiiring outdoor pursuits, he never resumed full practice, although he occasioiuilly appeared in trials where his old friends denuuided his aid. His arguments were clear, sound, and sensible, and were listeiu-d to with attention. His mind was well stored willi sound legal maxims, and his aim seemed to be to make a sensible application of these to the case in hand. He died in I5si5, at the age of sixty-five years.
Provenance
Text from History of Litchfield County, Connecticut, published 1881, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.