BlockBefore

New London County, Connecticut - The whole text, 1890 (part 8 of 10)

From Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society .., published 1890. 15,963 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

8 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The text

15,963 words

Machine-read from scans of Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society .., published 1890. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

He was a member of the legislature and in 1861 he was appointed by the governor of the state to fill the vacancy in the United States senate created by the death of Col. Baker, who was killed in the engagement at Ball's Bluff.

After the expiration of his term in the senate Mr. Stark came to this city and took up his permanent residence here, ever after identifying himself with the city.

He was greatly interested in education, and rendered this city exceptionally valuable service as a member of the Board of School Visitors from early in the sixties up to a period quite close to the time of his death, his last year in the board receiving the compliment of election as its president in recognition of his long and faithful service.

The article on schools written by Mr. Stark is of such importance on that important subject that it should be read by all interested in the cause of education. The article, together with a portrait of Mr. Stark, will be found in Part II., Vol. II.

To the Protestant Episcopal Church Mr. Stark gave much of his time and a loyal service and support worthy of special attention. He represented the Parish of St. James' church as delegate to the Diocesan Convention from about the time of his making New London his home up to the time of his death and for twenty-seven years he was chosen for ten consecutive terms as a delegate to the General Convention and was at his death a member of that body.

of the Domestic and Foreign Missionary Society of the church, and as in all other places the trust imposed in him was fully justified by his work.

For many years he was a member of the State Board of Charities and in that capacity was of the highest usefulness to the cause and in the same line of usefulness, being interested in the subject of prison reform, he attended two international congresses, one at Stockholm and another at Rome, in 1878 and 1885 respectively, to participate in the consideration of reforms in prison management.

In 1878 the appointment was from the State of Connecticut and in 1885 Mr. Stark had two commissions, one from the United States direct from the president and the other from the State of Connecticut.

Of Norwich, Conn

John Turner Wait was born in New London, Connecticut, August 27, 181 1, and died in Norwich, April 21, 1899. It is impossible, within the limits of this brief sketch, to give more than a very meagre outline of his long and distinguished career.

Mr. Wait was admitted to the bar in 1836, and continued in active practice for more than sixty years. During this long period he occupied many positions of distinction. In 1842 he was on the military staff of Governor Cleveland, and during the same year he received the appointment of state attorney for New London county, which position he occupied for ten years. He was elected to the state senate in 1865, and in 1867 was speaker of the House of Representatives of Connecticut. On retiring from this position, he was honored by the presentation of a handsome service of silver by his associates. On the formation of the bar association, in 1874, he was elected its president, a position which, by successive re-elections, he held to the time of his death.

Mr. Wait received from Trinity College the honorary degree of A. M., in 1851, and in 1871 Yale University bestowed the same honor upon him. In 1883 he received from Harvard University the degree of L L. D., and in 1886, Trinity College gave him the same degree.

He was a member of congress by continuous re-elections, from 1876 to 1887, in which position as representative from the third district of Connecticut, he performed the duties of his office with marked ability and fidelity. It is particularly interesting to our society to note the fact that through his instrumentality an appropriation of $10,000 was secured from congress, one half of which was devoted to repairs upon the Groton monument, and the other half to aid in defraying the expenses of the centennial celebration at Groton in 1881.

Mr. Wait's marked success in his profession was mainly due to his eloquence at the bar. This same quality made him a leader among the public speakers of his day, on all occasions.

In social life he was noted for his genial spirit and his brilliant and entertaining conversation. His keen sense of humor gave a zest to the many entertaining stories which he related from an apparently inexhaustible store. He was a firm and loyal friend, and although he outlived most of his contemporaries, he cherished, to a remarkable degree, the memory of those with whom he had been on terms of intimate friendship.

In the local affairs of Norwich, Mr. Wait was also prominent. He was, at the time of his death, president of the trustees of the Eliza Huntington Memorial Home, and an original incorporator of the William W. Backus hospital. He was also one of the original incorporators of the New London County Historical Society, in which he retained both his membership and interest until his death.

Of Torkington, Conn

Elisha Turner, a former New Londoner, one of the best known citizens of Torrington and a leading manufacturer, died September 14th, 1900, at his home in that place, in the seventy-ninth year of his age.

Mr. Turner was born in New London on January 29, 1822, and received a common school education here. He also attended the academies at Surfield and Colchester. He entered a dry goods store in this city and went into business for himself before he was 21 years old. For some years he had considerable interest in whale fishing, in connection to conducting his dry goods store. In the spring of 1846 he moved to Waterbury, conducting a mercantile business there for two years, when, with the late Lyman \Y. Coe and Philander Hine, he formed the Waterbury Hook & Eye Company, and from that time gave his attention to manufacturing. He was very successful in his business enterprises and accumulated a large fortune. In 1864 the company above nun tioned was moved to Torrington and is now known as the Turner & Seymour Manufacturing Company. Mr. Turner had made his home in Torrington ever since this removal. He had been \ deepresident of the Coe Brass Manufacturing Company for twentyfive or thirty years, and was one of the original stockholders. He was also one of the organizers of the Excelsior Needle Company and was one of its directors up to the time it was turned over to the Torrington Company. He was president of the Turner & Seymour Company to the time of his death, and the largest stock- holder. He was a director of the Eagle Bicycle Company, The Torrington Manufacturing Company, The Miller Manufacturing Company, one of the organizers and a director of the Torrington Water Company, and a director of the Brooks National Bank of Torrington. Mr. Turner was one of the organizers of the Torrington Savings Bank, a trustee from its organization to his death and president of the bank for the last seven years.

Mr. Turner was particularly interested in the library at Torrington. He was one of its originators when it was formed as the Wolcotville Library Association, the name afterwards changed to the Torrington Library Association when the name of Wolcotville was changed to Torrington. At the time of his death Mr. Turner was building a handsome home for the library, at his own expense. It is a beautiful building and is to cost between $60,000 and $70,000.

Mr. Turner was of modest and retiring disposition and avoided public office, but he represented Torrington in the Legislature in 1868. He was a member of the Union League Club of New I York, and the American Geographical Society, the Connecticut | Historical Society, the Sons of the American Revolution and the Society of Colonial Wars. Mr. Turner never married. He lived in the home of the Hon. Lyman W. Coe, first at Waterbury and from 1868 at Torrington, for more than fifty years. He was hek in the highest esteem in the town where he lived and wherever h< was known. He was interested in everything that tended to promote the welfare of Torrington and of the people generally, anc was ready to contribute his time and means to worthy objects.

Mr. Turner's interest in historical affairs was also well evinced by his bequest of $2,500 to The New London County Historical Society of which he had been a life member for many years. His gift is gratefully appreciated by the society as its only income was from the dues received from its limited membership.

His Reception At Hartford In 1693

There is no period so important in the political history of the colony of Connecticnt as the half century following the issue of her charter in 1662. Within two years from that time Charles Tl had issued a patent to the Duke of York which ignored the charter rights of Connecticut as majestically as the charter itself had ignored the geography of the country. The colony was probably fortunate in obtaining a decree at this time which, while it surrendered Long Island and Fisher's Island to the Duke 01 York, retained what is still practically the western boundary of our state, thus avoiding the loss of our territory west of the Connecticut river, which had been granted to the Duke of York and settling forever the vexed question of union with the New Haven colony, for there can be no doubt that, of the two evils New Haven preferred to come under the jurisdiction of Connecticut rather than that of New York. From this time may be dated a continual conflict of authority between New York and Connecti cut, especially under the second and confirmatory grant to the Duke of York in 1674. Following this came the attempts of Andros to assert the original claim and the attempts of Gov. Dougan to bring about the absorption of Connecticut by New York. Then followed the famous Charter Oak episode, the resumption of government under the charter in 1689. the arrest and imprisonmenl of Gen. Fitz John Winthrop by Leisler, and other indignities, chiefly documentary, which that worth) heaped upon us 1 >uring all this time, Connecticut was pursuing her customary altruistic course by sending men and contributing money for the defense of the neighboring colonies of New York and Massachusetts in King Philip's war, and in the old French war. And if her continual difficulties with New York were not enough to keep diplomacy employed, she had her boundary disputes with her neighbors on the north and east, and the conflicting grant to William Penn in 1681, which resulted, nearly a century later, in the celebrated Susquehanna case.

Through all these disputes and struggles, the attempt was constantly to keep the charter intact and inviolate. The royal prerogative of annulling this precious instrument was a danger constantly to be faced, and the royal habit of issuing grants and commissions which conflicted with its privileges placed the statesmen and legislators of the day in such a continual attitude of defense that Connecticut's position was, during most of this time, critical in the extreme. Her colonial rivals in New York appear to have been foremost in representing her to their Majesties of England as rebellious and disloyal ; and in sore need of such restraining powers as could only be applied by annexation to their own colony. Much wordy explanation appears to have been needed of an official statement in Gov. Dougan's day that the government of Andros would be preferred to that of Dougan if a choice were forced upon Connecticut, which statement it was feared might be taken to mean that she was willing to submit to Andros.

Under these circumstances, it is surprising that, only with the exception of the short administration of Andros, the charter government was preserved intact against the danger of annullment by royal decree on the one hand and usurpation by royal grant and commission on the other. The times called for policy of varying kinds suited to various occasions ; now, tact, diplomacy and almost - yes, quite fulsome expressions of loyalty, and again, downright defiance and assertion of charter rights against those who undertook to invade them.

In these troublous times certain episodes occurred which do not appear in the official records of the colony, and from the nature of the case could not so appear, and to which the historian must refer only as tradition. They are, however, as important as indicating the spirit methods, and temper of our early colonists as, are their officially recorded acts. Of these, the episode of the hiding of the charter by Captain Joseph Wadsworth is the most striking, and has been most fully exploited. Partly for this reason, but mainly because it furnishes sufficient material for our purpose, the present investigation will narrow itself down to another tradition in which this same Captain Wadsworth is the leading figure, and in which his methods of cutting a Gordiau knot are exemplified as forcibly as in the hiding of the charter, and with a more direct and immediate result. This tradition is of his masterful prevention of the reading of Col. Benjamin Fletcher's commission before the trainbands assembled in Hartford in October, 1693.

The name of this same Benjamin Fletcher does not take to itself the odor of sanctity, although he was largely instrumental in the founding of Trinity parish in New York, and was the direct means of establishing William Bradford as the public printer oi that city and colony. Fletcher's education before assuming the government of Xew York had been the education of the camp, as he himself expresses it. He appears to have been duly impressed with a sense of his own importance as a colonial Pasha of many tails, for in his official proclamation to the people of Connecticut he styles himself "His Excellency Benjamin Fletcher, Captain Generall and Governor in Chieff of their Majesties Province of New York, Province of Pensilvania, Countey of New Castle and the Territories and Tracts of land depending thereon, and Vice Admirall of the same ; their Majties Lieutenant and Commander in Chief of the Militia and of all the Forces by Sea and Land within their Majtles Collony of Connecticot, and of all the forts and places within the same."

This somewhat lengthy and complicated official title goes far towards furnishing as complete a sketch of the man as is necessary for our purpose. There is probably no doubt that his commission gave him the command over the militia of Connecticut which he attempted to assert and there is equally no doubt that the bestowal of such a command upon him was in direct contravention of the terms of the long-suffering charter of Connecticut It is quite probable that Sir William Phips, who was previously in possession of a similar authority under his own commission saw

All accounts of Fletcher seem to agree that he was a pompous, dictatorial character, apparently a soldier of fortune of obscure origin, and given to extravagance and display to such a degree as to render him particularly obnoxious to the plain people of Connecticut, whose governor was receiving the modest salary of £ 150 per annum while Fletcher was receiving £780. His own view of these same plain people may be readily imagined.

After about a year of his administration in New York, in which he had taken occasion to assert his claims under his commission, he determined to come to Connecticut to proclaim and attempt to resume his authority over the militia. In pursuance of this purpose he came from New York in two sloops - presumably sloops of war - one of which contained his august person, and the other his horses and probably his imposing gilded coach, of which history makes mention. He had reached New Haven on Monday the 17th of October, 1693, but cannot be said to have arrived officially, as he writes on that date to the General Court at Hartford stating that his "horses and other coveniences" had been left behind on a slower or less skillfully navigated sloop. He therefore requests a delay in the adjournment of the General Court until he may be able to appear to that body in due official state "to communicate their Majesties commands." To this request he receives a courteous official reply stating that adjournment will be delayed until the following Friday, notwithstanding the inconvenience of prolonging the session. This reply reaching Gov. Fletcher at New Haven on Wednesday the 19th of October, his "horses and other conveniences" not having then arrived, he modestly requests the General Court to adjourn to New Haven for the purpose of hearing his announcements. Still courteously, but firmly, the official reply under date of the 20th informs him that adjournment to New Haven is impossible, but that the Court will be continued by adjournment until the following Tuesday, the 25th, although they have waited several days to attend his Excellency.

ticut. producing a commission under the great seal of England empowering him to take command of the militia of the colony. To this, the memorial says, he expects a ready compliance.

At this point, it is interesting to note that the official records of the Secretary of State discreetly mention that the General Court adjourned on the 23d, which was the day before the date of this memorial. The official correspondence of Gov. Fletcher states that "on the 28th the General Court broke up," and the same correspondence mentions the fact that his commission was read before this body, presumably on the day of its date. This, apparently forms an example of the importance which was attached to legal technicalities two centuries ago, as it offers an argument against the statement that this commission was presented to the General Court in regular session.

The official reply to this memorial is an interesting specimen of the legal lore of Gov. Treat, practiced, some six years before, in a similar experience with Andros. This reply states, among other things,

"That finding in your Excellencies Commission no Express, Superseding the Commission of the Militia in our Charter, nor Order to surrender the same : And being sensible of the great importance of this matter and finding it in several main things which do need a particular Explication, and Settlement, as we shall (God willing) manifest to their Majesties : cannot but conceive it our duty, both with respect to Their Majesties Service, and our own Seace and preservation in this time of War, to continue the Militia as formerly ; till by our Agent now sent for England we shall receive further Order from Their Majesties."

This letter expresses the utmost willingness to render assistance to Col. Fletcher for the defense of New York against the common enemy, for which purpose the sum of £5000 had been already expended. The letter, no copy of which remains on file, closes in the following words :

"And further; this Court does see reason to grant the Sum of Six Hundred Pounds in Country pay, out of our Country Rate, towards the charge of maintaining the Garrison at Albany, onwards of what shall be our proportion of that charge, in Obedience to Their Majesties Letter of 3d of March last."

This, however, does not appear to have the pacifying effect which it was intended to have upon the irascible Fletcher, for he promptly replies thatit is "noe answer" to his memorial, andcloses by saying, "I doe therefore in their Majesties name demand your obedience to this commission as you will. answer the ill consequences that will ensue and expect a speedy reply in two words, Yes or No."

This demand appears to be ignored in a brief communication by the Governor and General Court on the following day, in which a reply is asked to the offer of £600 for the garrison at Albany, which offer is amended by proposing to furnish fifty men for that garrison if the men should be more serviceable than the money.

In the meantime, Gov. Fletcher has offered to issue a commission to Gov. Treat placing him in command of the militia of Connecticut, to which offer no reply appears on file, although the references to it in various contemporary documents leave no doubt that the offer was respectfully declined.

The official correspondence in this affair forms no part of the record of the General Court, and is not mentioned in this record. In the documents which ensued, assurance is given by Col. Fletcher that he had no intention of interfering in the civil affairs of Connecticut, but should continue to "pursue the execution of their Majtles lettrs patent" till 'he finds "open violation of their Majties right by force and armes." The documents in the case end with a proclamation which he directed to be published, but which was not published, reciting his version of the state of affairs, and commanding all loyal subjects to yield due obedience to their Majesties Commission "as they will answer to the contrary at their utmost perills."

It should be remembered that Fletcher's object at this time was not only to assume command under his commission, but to enlist men, which he reports he succeeded in doing, to the number of forty. Before his visit, a vote of the colony had been taken on the subject of continuing the militia and all other charter privileges, and 2,182 persons had voted in favor of this view,expressing themselves ready to bear their proportion of the expense of maintaining these privileges. Under this vote, Gen. Fitz John Winthrop had been sent to England as the agent of the colony, furnished with an address to the crown on the subject, and with all necessary means for pursuing his mission.

For the remainder of the story of Fletcher's visit to Hartford, we must turn, from the documentary evidence thus far cited, to tradition, supported by such evidence as may be found.

With the exception of two rare contemporaneous pamphlets, which will be discussed later on, American literature appears to have been silent on the subject of Fletcher's visit for 104 years, which, singularly enough, was just 104 years ago, when the first volume of Dr. Benjamin Trumbull's History of Connecticut appeared, and added to the story we have gathered from the official documents, the following interesting concluding episode, which I quote in Dr. Trumbull's own words :

"The trainbands of Hartford assembled, and, as the tradition is, while Captain Wadsworth, the senior officer, was walking in front of the companies and exercising the soldiers, Col. Fletcher ordered his commission and instructions to be read. Captain Wadsworth instantly commanded, 'Beat the drums'; and there was such a roaring of them that nothing else could be heard. Colonel Fletcher commanded silence. But no sooner had Bayard made an attempt to read again, than Wadsworth commands, 'Drum, drum, I say.' The drummers understood their business and instantly beat up with all the art and life of which they were masters. 'Silence, silence,' says the Colonel. No sooner was there a pause, than Wadsworth speaks with great earnestness, 'Drum, drum, I say,' and turning to his excellency, said, Tf I am interrupted again I will make the sun shine through you in a moment.' He spoke with such energy in his voice and meaning in his countenance, that no further attempts were made to read or enlist men. Such numbers of people collected together, and their spirits appeared so high, that the governor and his suite judged it expedient soon to leave the town and return to New York."

all historians of Connecticut, if we except the veracious Samuel Peters, and is mentioned by Palfrey in his history of New England, by Lossing in his "Empire State," and by Holmes in his "Annals of America." Palfrey speaks of it as a ''more than doubtful tradition," Lossing recites it as an actual occurrence, and Holmes simply quotes Trumbull, but not at the point where he mentions it as tradition. Of Connecticut historians, Dr. Hoadley says the story does not rest on any good foundation ; Hollister regards it to be as true as if attested by undisputed evidence ; Sanford coincides with Dr. Hoadley and even with Palfrey ; Dwight and Carpenter and Arthur are neutral, and last, but not least, Alexander Johnston, in the most brilliant and scholarly historical sketch of Connecticut which has yet been written, treats the affair as an actual occurrence, and cites the most convincing proof which has yet been brought to bear on the subject. This is no less than a letter from the Deputy Governor and Council, under date of July 14. 1675 to Captain Thomas P>ull at Saybrook in which it is specifically mentioned that the proper preventive for the reading of Major Andros' commission to the garrison at Saybrook at that time would have been precisely the course which Captain Joseph Wadsworth, apparently in a spirit of receptive originality, adopted some eighteen years later in the case of Colonel Fletcher.

"By yors of 16:5 -.75* we are certifyed of Major Andros his attempting to use his Majties name to command his Charter and commission to be read there at Saybrook shore, and to proceed in so reading notwithstanding yor countermand in like manner. TJwugh we tvish he had been interrupted in doing if least thing under pretence of his having anything to doe to use his Ma"es name in commanding there so usurpingly, wQh might have been done by shouts, or sound of drum &c. wth out violence ; but yet seeing it was so performed in the opposition .' "

This last sentence is underscored in the original draft, as if to emphasize it for future use. At this time Robert Treat was an assistant in the General Court, and thus one of the council by whose authority this letter was written. He was then a man of fifty- three, and it is but natural to infer that the suggestion to Captain Bull was quite forcibly impressed upon him at the time, so that when, eighteen years later, he occupied the position of Governor, it would readily occur to him as a most effective and politic means of meeting a situation which was precisely similar in Governor Fletcher's case. Although this furnishes presumptive evidence that drums would be used when occasion might require to silence the reading of the commission, we have yet to show that an attempt was made to publish or proclaim the commission elsewhere than in the General Court, that Fletcher was threatened with personal violence, and that something was done to prevent him from proclaiming his commission.

For the evidence bearing on these points, the only available documents known to me are the official reports of Fletcher to be found in Brodhead's "Documents relating to the colonial history of New York," and in pamphlets issued at the time of Fletcher's visit. Within six months from the time of the traditional episode of the drums the pamphleteers of the day had taken up the general subject of the political situation, both sides of which appear to have been fully discussed. Some time previous to April 23, 1694, a pamphlet, generally attributed to Gershom Bulkeley was printed in New York, entitled "Some Seasonable Considerations for the Good People of Connecticut," in which these good people were quite severely taken to task for their reception of the claims of Sir William Phips, and later of Governor Benjamin Fletcher, to assume command of the militia of the colony. On the 23d of April, 1694, the Governor and Assistants gave their imprimatur to a reply to this pamphlet entitled "Their Majesties Colony of Connecticut in New England Vindicated from the Abuses of a Pamphlet Licensed and printed at New York, 1694. Intituled (&c.

It appears quite certain that Fletcher's commission was read in the General Court on the 24th of October, as the memorial of that date, a letter from his secretary dated the 27th, and his own report of the same date testify. No indication can be found that there was any opposition to the reading of the commission at this time. The answer of the General Court already quoted refers to the commission as if it" had been unhesitatingly received for the consideration of that body. This being the case, the following quotation from the pamphlet entitled Seasonable Considerations, leaves only the inference that an attempt was made to publish or proclaim the commission elsewhere :

"What Construction do we think it* will have, If we shall be found to Rise in Arms against the King's Lieutenant Publishing His Commission and Commanding Obedience unto it ; and by Force and Arms to with-hold the Militia, and all Forces by Sea and Land, and all Forts and places of strength, in a whole Colony or Province, from the King against His plain Commission Published under the great Seal?"

The charge of rising in arms against Fletcher and his proceedings is several times repeated, and is denied in the answer, which refers to a training that was in progress at the time of Fletcher's visit, "but put by, by the Governour's order," though the soldiers engaged in this training are enumerated among the men under arms in the colony at the time.

When we couple this statement with Fletcher's own report, it hardly requires a strained interpretation to show that some attempt other than that which the documents show was made to assert his authority. In a letter to Mr. Southwell under date of October 30th, he says :

"I could not force obedience, having no companie but a few servants and two friends, nor did I think it the king's service to carry on the contest to Blonde, though they threaten to draw mine for urging my master's right."

*The answer is also a very rare pamphlet, but two copies of which are known to exist. It is reprinted in the Collections of the Conn. Historical Society.

The charge that threats of personal violence, "vile indignities" and "scurvy little tricks'" were resorted to by certain persons not specified is so frequently made in the pamphlet entitled "Some Seasonable Considerations," that it is not necessary to refer to the quotations in which they appear in detail. From all these, it appears that something outside of the General Court occurred which led Col. Fletcher to make his departure on or about the 30th of October.

It is not to be expected that he would refer specifically in his official report to the episode of the drums, but it is most certainly to be expected that he would gloss his discomfiture with general terms as we have already seen that he did, in the extracts quoted from his reports, and in the following official statement :

The evidence, both circumstantial and presumptive must naturally lead to the belief that tradition has supplied the missing details of this interesting occurrence with a fitness and exactness which can scarcely be questioned. We must remember, first ot all, that Fletcher was one of many New York governors who had attempted to usurp the rights of Connecticut, even to the extent of absorbing the colony, so that his official position made him a traditional enemy of the colony, to be viewed with suspicion and opposed with vigilance. The story which we are investigating possibly remained an oral tradition down to the days of Dr. Benjamin Trumbull. We must remember, however, that this historian was born only forty-one years after Fletcher's visit, and might have heard the story from men who actually witnessed the ( iccurrence.

By what "other means Fletcher could have proclaimed his authority outside of the General Court than by the reading of his commission before the trainbands assembled in Hartford, it is im- possible to conceive. He was, as we have seen, a military man, bearing the title of Colonel in the British army, so that military custom on the one hand, and military courtesy on the other would doubtless place the trainbands in review before him during his visit. Whether the reading of his commission was a form prescribed by law or merely the most effective way of asserting his command is a question which does not alter the fact that serious objections existed to such a proceeding.

There appears to be no doubt that Captain Joseph Wadsworth would have been in command of the training which was then in progress, or at least in sufficient authority to order the drummers to strike up at the proper time. And from such indications as we gather both from tradition and record regarding this same Captain Wadsworth, there is not the slightest doubt that he was a man who had no hesitation in taking prompt action and in speaking his mind on occasion. Tradition gives him the credit of hiding the charter in the famous old oak in Andros' day, and the official record shows that some ten years after the visit of Gov. Fletcher, he was fined ten pounds for using language in the General Assembly reflecting upon the Governor and others, which fine was remitted a year later, "he having made reflexions on himself," as the record reads. He appears after this to have kept his temper within parliamentary bounds for a period of twelve years and more, until it is recorded that he was publicly censured for his public criticisms on the acts of the General Assembly, and made to read a confession which had been prepared for him, and to receive an admonition from the Governor. When we take into consideration the character of the two men, we may imagine that a conflict of authority between Gov. Benjamin Fletcher and Capt. Joseph Wadsworth would form a rather striking solution of the ancient problem of an irresistible force coming in contact with an immovable body.

That such a conflict of authority took place is the general belief of the average patriotic citizen of Connecticut, principally for the reason that state pride loves to add to the score of Connecticut victories of all kinds. It must be confessed that this little study of the evidence in the case has been made in the hope that such state pride may at least have the satisfaction of placing the tradition on a firmer basis than heretofore. In itself, after the cooling influence of two centuries has had its effect on the destructive wrath of Fletcher and Wadsworth the incident seems, perhaps, almost trivial. But we must remember that underneath all these records, pamphlets and correspondence, a current of events was running its course in Connecticut history which gave a vital significance to the defeat and discomfiture of Benjamin Fletcher. To yield to his authority would have been to stultify an address to the crown, asking that the rights of Connecticut under its charter should be defined.

It so happened that the mission of General Fitz John Winthrop to England was promptly successful, so that, in April, 1694 a royal decree was obtained limiting the quota which the Governor of New York could demand from Connecticut to one hundred and twenty men. which force he could have the privilege of commanding only in time of war.

Thus, before either of the pamphlets in the case could have reached England, the conflict between Benjamin Fletcher and the authorities of Connecticut was happily terminated. The merits of the contest, and the principles it involved, would furnish material for a much more extensive treatise than this little contribution towards a search for evidence of what Connecticut actually did in the matter. The official record is certainly quite creditable to her courtesy and statesmanship. And if, as tradition and evidence both indicate, Captain Joseph Wadsworth brought the contest to an abrupt close by proceedings which appear rather high-handedj it is quite probable that he was more than forgiven at the time, and remains so to this day ; for it appears to have been a case in which great provocation worked upon a man who could brook no opposition.

It is interesting to note that, even at this early period of our history, the cry of "no taxation without representation" was already in the air, as Fletcher himself reports officially ; and it is scarcely too much to surmise that this cry may have been passed on from one generation to another down to the days of the Stamp Act and the Revolution.

himself with making many needless and unreasonable demands on the militia of Connecticut for forces which no sooner reached their destination than they were sent back owing to false alarms, a report which probably lost nothing in the telling at the time, since we may well imagine that Fletcher had succeeded in making himself particularly obnoxious to Connecticut.

His career as a colonial governor ended some two years after his memorable visit to Hartford, owing to his recall to England under charges of malfeasance in office, and of questionable dealings with some of the pirates of his day. Mr. Charles Besot Todd, who appears to have studied the documents in the case, insists that he never had a fair hearing, much less a trial, and that the charges against him never were brought to a final decision. His own statement accuses his enemies of plotting against him, and we may certainly go so far as to admit that he was a man who had a genius for making enemies. Let us surmise, then, that he finally became the victim of this genius, until he at last rested in peace in the now unknown grave which claimed him.

Mary Eddye Benjamin

The Act of Incorporation allows the New London County Historical Society to hold property, and any bequest may be made for specific purposes, as a fund for permanent building, for printing, or for the general expenses of the Society.

The minutes of the last meeting were read and approved, also reports of the secretary and treasurer. The question of opening the rooms of the society on other days than those regularly appointed, and the use of books and manuscripts of the society, for purposes of research, was discussed at length ; and a committee, consisting of the president, C. A. Williams, Miss Cornelia W. Chapell, and Mrs. William Saltonstall Chappell, were appointed to consider and report.

The Hempstead Diary publication was considered, and Rev. Dr. S. L. Blake was appointed a committee to draft a prospectus for the purpose of soliciting subscriptions to meet the cost of publication. The regular officers were elected, and the meeting adjourned.

July 1st, 1897. On the first of July of the current year, by authority of the advisory committee, the undersigned, assumed the office of secretary. The roll of membership of the society, for the year ending September 1st, 1897, contains the names of twenty-six life members, eighty-three annual members, and six honorary members.

Rhode Island Historical Society, New England Historical and Biographical Society, The Dedham Society, Western Reserve Historical Society, Wyoming Historical and Genealogical Society, Connecticut Historical Society, Historical Society of Montana, Buffalo Historical Society, West Virginia Historical and Antiquarian Society, Wyoming Commemorative Association, Westn Chester County Historical Society, Leland Stanford, Jr., Yale and New York Universities, ' Trustees John F. Slater Fund, American Congregational Association, Connecticut Sons of the American Revolution, United States Commissioner of Education, United States Commissioner of Patents.

Worthy of particular notice is the gift to the society from Hon. Robert Winthrop, Jr., of an elegant volume, entitled "Winthrops of Groton Co., Suffolk, England, and Allied Families."

Gifts have been received from persons as follows : Mrs. Josephine Greenleaf, Mr. George H. Stayner, Mr. Daniel C. Gilman, , Mr. J. A. Searight, Mr. R. B. Swift, Mr. H. R. Bond, Mr. Chas. Fish Williams.

The publication of Part III, Vol. II of the society's papers, has been completed, containing the proceedings of the 250th anniversary of the settlement of New London, Connecticut, May 5th and 6th, 1895, compiled and edited by Rev. S. Leroy Blake, D. D.

of the society that the members to a greater number purchase the society's publications, as the funds thus contributed are greatly needed. Frequent enquiries are made by visitors and by letters, as to the time of the publishment of The Hempstead Diary, with request for circulars to send to persons interested in the work and one name has been left as a subscriber.

The rooms have been well attended, on the days of opening, both by members and strangers and much interest has been shown in the society's collection.

Miss Annie Wheeler's resignation having been accepted, I, bv request of Hon. C. A. Williams, assumed the charge of The New London County Historical Society, as secretary, February 25, 1898.

Seventeen who were members last year have not renewed their membership this present year. Memberships taken since February, this year, are as follows :

Mrs. Pierre Wildey, Mr. John L. Branch of New York; Mr. Jonathan Trumbull of Norwich ; Miss Lucretia W. Smith, Mr. Newton Fuller, Mr. Peleg Williams and Mr. George E. Starr of New London.

Two ancient books were received from S. D. Warriner, also the photograph of a pitcher, with pictures representing the United States frigate Guerriere, Commodore McDonough in 1814 at St nington, Conn., from Hon. Elias P. Randall, Mystic, Conn.

The subcriptions to The Hempstead Diary have not increased as rapidly as might be desired. There are one hundred and fifty-two subscribers and all earnestly desire the early publication of the same.

The rooms of the society have been well attended on the days of opening, perhaps, however, not as many visitors from other places, on account of war disturbances.

The annual meeting of The New London County Historical Society was held in the rooms of the society, in the New London Public Library building, New London, Connecticut, on Monday, September ist, 1898.

It was proposed, in view of the cost, to publish the Diary in three sections. Miss Cornelia W. Chapell desired to be informed if the expense would be the same as if published entire.

Mr. C. B. Ware thought it would be expedient to notify subscribers if they would approve of this manner of publication, if so it would greatly expedite matters.

Miss Chapell thought it an excellent plan to substitute the Joshua Hempstead Diary for the regular papers of the society, for the past two years, and one, for the coming year. Mr. C. B. Ware then offered the following resolution :

The vote was taken and carried. Mr. C. A. Williams spoke regarding the use of the valuable manuscripts of Miss F. M. Caulkins, and read the report of the committee as it now stands :

"As there has been no change in fees (a fee having been fixed at the last annual meeting) although there has been remonstrance, the papers are too valuable to be worn out, and those who use them ought to be willing to pay for the privilege."

A committee consisting of Hon. William Belcher, Mr. John McGinley and Major B. P. Learned of Norwich, Conn., were appointed to prepare suitable resolutions, at length, on the death of Hon. John T. Wait of Norwich and Hon. Benjamin Stark of! New London, Conn., to be submitted to the adjourned meeting; said meeting to take place at the call of the president ; also a com- j mittee consisting of Rev. S. Leroy Blake, Mr. John McGinley and Mr. Ernest E. Rogers, to nominate candidates to fill vacancies caused by the death of Hon. Benjamin Stark as vice president and Hon. John T. Wait, on the advisory board.

George F. Tinker to take the place of Hon. Benjamin Stark as vice president and Miss Cornelia W. Chapell to take the place of Hon. Benjamin Stark on the advisory board, also Mr. Ernest E. Rogers to fill the vacancy caused by the death of Hon. John T. Wait.

As your secretary, I am pleased to report that the roll of membership of this society September 1st, 1899, contains the names of twenty-six life members, sixty-one annual members and six honorary members. Four have been removed by death and several have not renewed their membership. Since the last annual meeting the following new names have been added to our list of membership : Miss N. A. Wightman of Philadelphia, Mrs. M. M. Comstock of New London, Conn.

Books and pamphlets have been received from the Rhode Island Historical Society, Leland Stanford University, Dedham- Register, Smithsonian Reports, New Jersey Historical Society, New England Historical and Genealogical Society, Connecticut State Register, Buffalo Historical Society, Official Records of the War of the Rebellion, Reports of Yale University, Connecticut Historical Society, Wyoming Historical and Genealogical Society, American Numismatic and Archealogical Society, Swedish Literature, History of The First Church of Christ by Rev. S. Leroy Blake, D. D., Trustees of The John Slater Fund, etc.

The society has been the recipient of the following gifts, viz.: A forty shilling currency of June, 1775, from Mr. Elisha L. Palmer ; a $2.00 bill on Merchants' Bank of Norwich ; also vol- umes of Fifteenth Connecticut Volunteers, and Fifth Connecticut regiments, gifts from Mr. C. B. Ware; the Van Alstyne Genealogy, Graveyard Records of Hanover, New Jersey ; Marriages and Baptisms of Hanover, New Jersey, gifts of Mr. W. Ogden Wheeler, of Sharon, Conn.

But worthy of particular notice is the gift of a Spanish projectile by Lieut. Dion Williams of the United States marine service, said projectile having been taken from the magazine of the Spanish war vessel "The Castilla," sunken in the harbor of Manila ; and also the very valuable gift of the Spanish coat-ofarms, taken from a schoolhouse in Guantanamo, and presented to this society by Capt. Colby M. Chester, in command of the battleship Cincinnati, in the late war with Spain. Captain Chester being a New Londoner by birth makes us especially grateful that in his wanderings in foreign lands his heart turns back to "home, sweet home."

It is my painful duty to call your saddened attention to our loss by death of four prominent members. Hon. John T. Wait, of Norwich, Conn., whose death occurred April 21st, 1899, ne was one of our most valued members, from the inception of the society; also Hon. Benjamin Stark, our first vice president and one of our most interested officers, and one to whom the society referred on momentous questions ; also Hon. Elias P. Randall of Mystic, Conn., who took great interest in our collections, and contributed valuable articles ; also Mr. George T. Marshall, of this city, an interested member.

The perplexed question of the publishment of the Hempstead Diary has not as yet been satisfactorily solved, but ere long it will probably be brought before the public.

The rooms of the society have been well attended by citizens and strangers, and particularly the young take great interest in our collections.

our rooms were opened more frequently as the limit of time does not always accommodate visitors from abroad, but even in the limited hours we have the names of three hundred and eightythree on our yearly register.

January 12, 1900. A special meeting- of The New London County Historical So- I ciety was held in their rooms in the public library building, January 1 2th, 1900, to take some action regarding the death of our 1 honored president, Hon. Charles Augustus Williams. 1 The meeting was called to order by Mr. Charles B. Ware, treasurer, who spoke very touchingly of the death of Mr. Williams and also of the death of our first vice-president, Hon. Benjamin Stark, and recommended that some resolutions be prejsented to go on file.

Rev. Dr. Blake spoke of meeting Mr. Williams on his early arrival in New London. He was always impressed with his geniality of manner, and considered him as one of the type of old school (gentlemen whose place would never be filled. He then offered 'he following resolutions :

Since, it has pleased God to allow the departure from our midst by death of the Hon. Charles Augustus Williams, the honored president of The New London County Historical Society, we desire to put on record our deep sense of personal loss and our sorrow, that we shall no more see his face, nor enjoy he benefit of his wise counsels.

He combined firmness and decision of character with the utmost kindness in in unusual degree, and never forgot to be a gentleman in all his intercourse 'with his fellow men.

His interest in this society, whose head he was for so long a period, secured or it prosperity and his absence from its councils will be deeply felt.

We desire hereby, to express our sympathy with the bereaved family and asure them of our deep regard for one who was so universally honored and Esteemed.

Rev. Dr. Grint proposed that the filling of the vacancies caused by the death of Hon. C. A. Williams and Hon. Benjamin Stark be deferred till the annual meeting September ist, 1900.

The. adjourned annual meeting of The New London County Historical Society of September ist, 1900, was held September 7th, 1900, in the rooms of the society, in the New London Public Library building.

The name of Hon. George F. Tinker was proposed to fill the; vacancy of the presidentship, caused by the death of Hon. C. A,! Williams, which Mr. Tinker declined and proposed the name off Mr. Ernest E. Rogers to fill this office. This motion was sec-; onded by Rev. S. Leroy Blake, D. D., and the following names were also proposed, viz. : Vice-presidents, first, Mr. Frederic Bill,

The following names were proposed to fill vacancies on the board of directors : Ernest E. Rogers, New London, Conn. ; J. Lawrence Chew, New London, Conn. ; Sebastian D. Lawrence, New London, Conn.

Regarding the Hempstead Diary, Mr. C. B. Ware made the following motion : That the publication of The Hempstead Diary be placed in the hands of the advisory committee. Seconded and voted.

Motion was then made that Rev. S. Leroy Blake, D. D., have access as he desires to the manuscripts of the Hempstead Diary. Seconded and voted.

The names of S. Vernon Briggs of Boston, was proposed for honorary membership, and Miss Fannie Potter and Miss May Kelsey Champion for life membership.

They were unanimously elected to such membership. It was moved and seconded that the day of opening the rooms be Wednesdays from 2.30 to 4.30 p. m. Moved to adjourn.

As secretary, I am pleased to report that the roll of membership of this society on September 1st, 1900, contains the names of sixty annual members, twenty-five life members and five honorary members.

siderable interest has been shown by the public we have met with an irreparable loss in the death of our highly honored and esteemed president, Hon. Charles Augustus Williams, who had filled the office for seventeen years in the most acceptable manner ; also two years since by the death of our first vice-president, Hon. Benjamin Stark ; also Hon. John T. Wait of Norwich, Conn., from our advisory board; Hon. Elias P. Randall, of Mysic, Conn., and Judge Charles Turner of Alabama, from our life membership ; all men of unquestionable ability and character ; also Mr. George T. Marshall of New London, Conn., who took great interest in our progress and contributed many valuable articles.

Books, pamphlets and papers have been contributed as follows : Record of The War of the Rebellion, Publications of the Rhode Island Historical Society, Memoirs of William Kelly, librarian of New York Historical Society, Dedham Institute Register, Bibliography of Massachusetts, Swedish Literature, Smithsonian Reports, Early History of The First Church of Christ, by Rev. S. Leroy Blake, D. D., New Jersey Historical Society, New England Historical and Genealogical Society, Journal of Michael Walters, The Christian Science Movement, Sketch of King's Chapel, Boston, Mass., Biography of Joseph Hills of Maiden, Mass., Connecticut State Register, Buffalo Historical Society, Leland Stanford, Jr. University, Address before The Wyoming Sons of The Revolution, Report of Yale University, The American Numismatic and Archealogical Society, Proceeding of The John Slater Fund, Civil Service Commission, A Sketch of John Winthrop, the younger, Marion Beckwith and Wife Genealogy, Lake Mohawk Conference, The Essex Antiquarian Catalogue of Trinity College, Memoirs of Maj. John Sedgwick, New York State Library, The Ohio Archealogical and Historical Society, West Virginia Historical and Antiquarian Society, Colorado Society, Sons of The Revolution, Wisconsin State Historical Society, The International Monthly Vital Statistics of Rhode Island, North American Notes and Queries, The Old Northwest Genealogical Quarterly, Dedication of Ministers Monument, Hopkinton, Rhode Island, The Allerton Family, Yale Forestry School, pamphlets from Commodore George Melville, Obituary Records of Graduates of Yale University,

Barkhamsted Men, who served in the War, Avery Notes and Queries, and especial mention is made of the most valuable and historicall> interesting portrait of Jonathan 15 rooks, who was always conspicuous for his patriotism, gift of Mr. William Ellis, also arrow-heads from Long Island, gifts of Griswold Bragraw, M. D., and the valuable work The Averys of Groton, contributed by Mr. Frank Montgomery Avery of New York.

The question of the publishment of The Hempstead Diary has been unavoidably delayed and has not yet reached a satisfactory conclusion, but will undoubtedly soon be brought before the public.

The rooms have been well patronized by both citizens and strangers and the children and youth have been greatly interested in our collection which is to them a pleasure and education.

Maj. Bela P. Learned of Norwich moved that the society publish the Hempstead Diary on the estimate submitted by Mr. C. B. Ware, at an expense not exceeding $900, being covered from the publication fund, and the advisory committee hereby agree to reimburse said fund for any deficiency by assessment among its members, said deficiency not to exceed $100.

A meeting of the board of directors of The New London County Historical Society was held in their rooms in The New London Public Library building, Saturday, Jan. 26, 1901.

The Lucretia Shaw Chapter, D. A. R., New London; The Anna Warner Bailey Chapter, D. A. R., Groton; The Faith Trumbull Chapter, D. A. R., Norwich ; The Fanny Ledyard Chapter, D. A. R., Mystic ; The Nathan Hale Branch, S. A. R., New London ; The Israel Putnam S. A. R., Norwich, Conn., and The New London Board of Trade, to be present at Norwich, Conn., on January 30, 1901, to participate in the exercises to be held in the Peck Library, Slater hall building, by The New London County Historical Society.

The president, Air. Ernest E. Rogers, spoke of the proposed Winthrop monument and desired that a committee be appointed to present the subject to the Legislature.

That the president of this society be empowered to appoint a committee of five (5) whose duty it shall be to draft and present a petition to the State legislature, for an appropriation for a statue of "John Winthrop, the younger," to be erected in New London, Conn., on Winthrop Square, the pedestal of which The Xcw London County Historical Society will furnish.

Hon. M. Wilson Dart, Hon. Robert Coit, Alfred H. Chappell, Walter Learned, John McGinley, president of the Board of Trade, all of New London, Conn.

Norwich, Conn

The New London County Historical Society held its winter meeting at the Peck Library, in Slater hall, on Wednesday afternoon, January 7, 1901, at which there was a large attendance of members and friends. A number were present from New London. The meeting was of especial interest by being the first ever held in Norwich.

Tn the absence of Major B. P. Learned, who was to deliver the address of welcome, Dr. R. P. Keep made a few remarks in the way of greeting the members and guests. He spoke of the benefits of twin cities in various parts of the country, and thought this co-operative spirit might profitably be carried on in Norwich and New London. Two cities of the size of. Norwich and New London can perhaps accomplish but little in literature, art or archaeology alone, but together they may do much. Norwich is very glad to welcome the members of this cociety, and it is to be hoped that much good may come of the meeting.

The president, Ernest E. Rogers of New London, responded for the society. He thanked Dr. Keep for his gracious words of welcome, saying that the historian of Norwich, Miss Frances M. Caulkins, was also the historian of New London, and in this way the two cities are nearly connected historically. He spoke of his pleasure at being in Norwich on this occasion.

coming year. It was planned to hold quarterly meetings, ot which only one, the annual meeting, is to be held in New London. It is hoped by this method to add to the interest in the society and increase the membership, which is at present low. It is believed that by a progressive policy the ancient traditions of the society may be maintained.

George S. Porter of Norwich was then introduced and read his comprehensive paper on "< >ur French Revolutionary Allies in Norwich," prepared for the Daughters of the American Revolution. It is to be printed in pamphlet form. Mr. Porter said in part :

Of more than local interest is an episode of Revolutionary days of which Norwich was the scene. During the autumn of 1778 a fragment of Lafayette's army, then in Rhode Island, was ordered to join the American forces at that time operating in the south. These troops marched from Providence along the old road of that name, and in time turned into a lane at the end of which the Shetucket was crossed near the spot where the Taftville mill now stands, and thence passed to the old Canterbury road ; else they crossed to this side of the river at the point where is now the railway bridge, filed by the site of Mr. Samuel Prentice's house, thence through a lane extending to his shop, so passed the spot where today stands the Maennerchor Club house, thence marched by what is known as the old Elijah Pitcher place, into and through a now discontinued road, when they continued beside the present McEvoy farm and along the road which lies to the left of Mr. William H. Bushnell's farm of our day, so by the old Canterbury turnpike to the spot we know as Peck's corner, and thence through the town highway to the plain in that section which has been known as Norwich Town since 1836.

As the troops debouched upon the plain, which at that time was the locality around which centered the interests and activities of the community, the scene presented an aspect materially different from that of the present day.

The white tents of the visitors dotted the plain, and the tricolor of French waved in the Norwich breeze, when it was learned that, because of sickness among them, the troops would not at once march to New London and there board schooner for

New York. The court house was soon converted into a temporary hospital. In a number of instances success resulted, and the invalids became convelescents.

Other members of the detachment were not so fortunate, and, despite the skillful treatment of physicians and the solicitous care of nurses, they passed away one by one, until perhaps twenty had gone to "that bourne from which no traveler returns." The spot in our quiet old burial ground selected for their interment lies within the rustic gate which now guards the entrance from the green, is immediately east of the indicated grave of Edward Conoy, a Revolutionary soldier, who died in 1791.

In Norwich and its immediate vicinity stand five public monuments, tributes of respect and honor to the memory of savage and civilized worth. The first was erected in 1841, stands on Sachem's Plain and is commemorative of Miantonomo ; tlr* second presents only the name of Uncas, may be seen in the royal Indian burial ground in this city; the third, in honor of Major John Mason, occupies a position near the old Post and Gager burial place at Bean Hill ; the fourth, known as the Soldiers' monument, was placed in position in 1873 near the apex of the Great Plain, bears on its four tablets the names of 156 union dead; the fifth, at Shantoc Point, Mohegan, the result of the initial efforts of one of your members, Mrs. Bela Peck Learned, and was dedicated to the memory of Lieut. Thomas Leffingwell.

There is room for a sixth, and in our old burial ground may be found the fitting spot, where for 12 decades our French allies have slept in nameless, unmarked graves. The time is ripe, the spirit is willing and to us is given the privilege of initiating a movement whereby these repositories of the soldier dead, which, during a period of 122 years, have been bathed in Norwich sunlight, watered by Norwich dews and blanketed in Norwich snows, may at last be indicated ; whereby the deeds of those brave men who forsook home and friends, crossed the seas and in a strange land yielded their lives, not for conquest and subjugation but that an alien race might be freed from oppression and thus enjoy the blessings of liberty and independence, may be appreciated by the descendants of those so signally aided and may be, evidenced by the erection of a memorial, fitting and enduring.

Mr. Porter supplemented his historic narrative by a very complete description of manners and customs of the time which added much to its interest. The paper was discussed to some extent at the close of the reading.

President Rogers then presented Jonathan Trumbull of Norwich as one of the few descendants of famous men who could add luster to the names they bore, to which Mr. Trumbull said that his only reply could be to blush.

In a brief discussion which followed, Mr. Trumbull explained that the reason for writing this paper was part of a plan he had of studying what might be called "The Myths of Early Connecticut History."

In closing the very profitable meeting the president expressed his thanks to Major Learned and Mr. Trumbull who comprised the local committee and also to Dr. Keep.

A communication from the trustees of The New London Public Library was read informing The New London County Historical Society that they would need for library purposes the rooms which had been used by them for some years.

A discussion of available places followed. Mr. Ware said that Mr. Henry P. Haven, one of the incorporators of The New London County Historical Society, and from whose funds left in trust the library building had been erected, had said he hoped some day the society would have permanent rooms.

The matter of publishing another number of The Records and Papers of The New London County Historical Society was discussed and approved. That such number should be compiled, published and ready for distribution at the annual meeting September i, 1 90 1.

That the New London County Historical Society hold a summer meeting at Old Lyme, June 7, 1901, at 2.30 p. m. in the Phebe Griffin Noyes Memorial Library, said meeting having been suggested and approved by Lyme members.

A nominating committee, composed of Hon. George F. Tinker chairman, Rev. S. Leroy Blake, D. D., and Mr. John McGinley be appointed to nominate officers at the September meeting.

Lyme Meeting

A public meeting of The New London County Historical Society was held in the Phebe Griffin Noyes Memorial Library building, in the town of Old Lyme, June 7, 1901, at 2.30 p. m.

The meeting was well attended by the residents of Old Lyme and delegations from North Lyme, Niantic, Blackhall and New London, numbering in all about 80, were present.

The interesting program was carried out as. planned which consisted of an Address of Welcome by Gen. Joseph G. Perkins ; Response, by Ernest E. Rogers ; Paper, Unpublished Documents, by Harry Griswold; Historical Sketch of Old Lyme, by Joseph S. Huntington; Remarks, by J. R. Warren.

Gen. Perkins, in a few well chosen words welcomed the society to the ancient town of Old Lyme, and expressed the hope that this the first meeting, would not be the last.

plan of holding public meetings in several towns of the County, and stated the pleasure of holding the meeting in this town, whose inhabitants were noted for their hospitality, learning, intellectual attainments and refinement of life and of thought.

Mr. Harry Griswold presented an interesting paper. He referred to the numerous unpublished documents, papers and letters in the possession of many families in this vicinity, and read letters belonging to the Griswold family, written during the Revolutionary period.

The address of the day was delivered by Mr. Joseph L. Huntington. In his admirable historical sketch of Old Lyme, he spoke historically and humorously of the history of Lyme from its earliest days, touching upon bits of family and individual history so largely interwoven with that of the town.

Mr. J. R. Warren of North Lyme spoke very acceptably upon historical items of interest concerning both North and Old Lyme. During his remarks it was learned that in all probability North Lyme was the birthplace of the celebrated writer, Mrs. Lydia Huntley Signourney. Mr. Warren is now collecting facts and proofs concerning this matter.

At 4 o'clock the session was adjourned and all were cordially invited to an afternoon tea and hospitably entertained by the reception committee composed of Miss Elizabeth Griswold, Miss Anna Huntington, Mrs. T. B. Farwell, Miss Augusta Griffin, and Miss L. G. Perkins.

The annual meeting of The New London County Historical Society was held in the rooms of the society in the New London Public Library building, September 3rd, 1901.

The report was adverse to an appropriation this year from the Legislature, but the appropriation committee would recommend the resolution at the next session.

On motion of Hon. George F. Tinker the report was accepted and the same committee continued to make renewed efforts at the next session of the Assembly.

Mr. Charles B. Ware suggested that the Elisha Turner fund be set aside, the society using only the interest, until the principal should be needed for some specific and important purpose.

The report of a secretary ran only be a resume of the same general affairs year after year. A former secretary, Hon. William H. Starr, wrote that "New London did not appreciate its own, nor understand how useful and important this institution wa> and how increasing in importance, usefulness and interest it would be to coming generations."

The present year has not been frought with as important events as the last year, although death has claimed its own, and removed one, who had our interest at heart. This has been especially evidenced in the bequest of Mr. Elisha Turner of Tor rington. Conn, (a son of New London) who was always interested in the days and years of former times.

The secretary is pleased to report that the affairs of the society both financially and as regards membership are in better condition than for years.

The membership was never greater than at present, the reduction fees for six months bringing in many new members. The meetings held at Norwich and Lyme awakened new interest.

Especial notice might be made of the New York State Library books most beautifully illustrated of the monuments erected to Xcw York regiments in the War of the Rebellion, also Journal of the New York Botanical Garden, Avery Notes and Queries, Kent Genealogy Records of Marriages, Births and Deaths of Hanover, Mass.. The Alhambra, The Republic of San Marino Slater's Telegraphic Code, Webster's Dictionary, Franklin Arithmetic Zenephon, five French books, Newspaper and Periodical Press of [884,Dedham Historical Register, publications of The Rhode Island Historical Society, tin American Xumismatic and Archealogical Society, Report of Lake Mahonk Conference

Clearing Houses, Letters of Ebenezer Huntington, Public Papers of General Clinton Vol II and III, Report of Commissioner ot Education, 1898-9, Wyoming Commemorative Association, Ohio Archealogical and Historical. Society, State Historical Society of Wisconsin, documents from Smithsonian Institute, Catalogue of Trinity College, New York at Gettysburg, Catalogue of Yale University, State of Connecticut Public Documents for 1899, f°ur volumes Story of the Twenty-first Connecticut Regiment Volunteers, St. Joseph Kankakee Postage Home Education Department of University of Virginia, New York in the Spanish- American War, Vol. I, II, III., Archealogical Collection of Western Reserve Historical Society, Annual Report of Vineland Historical Society, New Hampshire Historical Collection, Vol I., Vol. II., Vol. VII., Vol. IX., Vol. X., New Hampshire Historical Society Proceedings, Truman Leaflets, Connecticut State Register, Historic Quarterly, Manchester, New Hampshire, an ebony easel from Miss Alice Turner, Connecticut Colonial History, Constitution and By-laws of New York Historical Association, The West Virginia Historical Magazine, The History of Stony Point, John Slater Fund, British Invasion of New Haven, Conn., Gen. Israel Putnam and Battle of Bunker Hill, By-laws of New London and Lyme Turnpike Company, etc.

Another volume of "The Records and Papers of The New London County Historical Society is being compiled and will be ready for distribution at an early date. This will be especially interesting, as a tribute to the memory of some of our most valued members.

The attendance at the rooms has been good and a new interest seems to have arisen by the meetings held in Norwich and Lyme, where the members of the society were most courteously received.

Publication Committee

The Act of Incorporation allows the New London County Historical Society to hold property, and any bequest may be made for specific purposes, as a fund for permanent building, for printing, or for the general expenses of the Society.

Jonathan Trumbull, Governor Of Connecticut A Paper By Jonathan Trumbull Of Norwich, Conn

The origin of the Scottish clan Turnbull may be read in story and song, and is attested by the still more authentic lines of the official record, where King Robert the Bruce, in 1315, grants to "Willielmo dicto TurnebuH" a "reddendo of one broad arrow at the feast of the Assumption of the Virgin Mary."

From the researches of Mr. J. Henry Lea, this appears to have been a grant of land in Philiphaugh, a short distance west of the Rule, where the peasant afterwards called Turnbull saved the king from the attack of an infuriated bull, and was for this service granted an estate and a coat of arms with the device of three bull's heads, and the motto Fortuna favet audaci.

Nearly five hundred years after this event Dr. John Leyden treats the story with a poet's license in his "Scenes of Infancy," making of the bull a "bison" with a "yellow lion mane" and speaking of the peasant as one

"Between red ezlarbanks, that frightful scowl. Fringed with grey hazel, roars the mining Pvoull; Turnbulls once, a race no power could awe, Lined the rough skirts of stormy Eubieslaw. Bold was the chief from whom their line they drew, Whose nervous arm the furious bison slew, The bison, fiercest race of Scotia's breed, Whose bounding course outstripped the red deer's speed.

From this peasant, mythical though he became, originated the once powerful Scottish clan of Turnbull, whose deeds, both in legitimate warfare and in border reiving and ruffianry may still be read in the old chronicles. The clan was dispersed and broken up by the summary process of sixteenth century justice and by neighboring rival clans, some survivors being scattered through England, and some remaining on. their native heath up to the close of the seventeenth century, or longer.

A rather ingenious and perfectly reasonable theory of the late Dr. J. Hammond Trumbull accounts for the corrupted spelling of the name, by the surmise that the Scotch pronunciation gave such prominence to the letter r that it first caught the ear of the scrivener, who, in pursuance of the usual phonetic spelling of the surnames of the day, wrote Trumbull for Turnbull, and even went further by spelling the last syllable b-l-e, as it is usually found in the English and American records of the sixteenth, seventeenth, and the first half of the eighteenth centuries.

In this brief outline, we have all that can be done at present towards tracing the evolution of the Connecticut patriot Jonathan Trumbull from the Scotch peasant who founded the rather disreputable clan from which he is supposed to derive his name. It may also be added in doubtful confirmation of this origin that we. may find in the Connecticut patriot indications of Scotch tenacity of purpose which was doubtless a marked trait of "the man who turned the bull."

of Jonathan Trumbull was John Trumble, a cooper of Newcastleon-Tyne, who married Ellinor Chandler in 1635, came to this country in 1639, w^tn h*3 w'^c and son -John, and settled in Rowley, Mass. This son, baptized at Newcastle-on-Tyne in 1639, had four sons, one of whom, Joseph, born in 1678, removed to Lebanon in the early days of the settlement of that town, where, on the 12th of October, 1710, his son Jonathan, the subject of this brief sketch, was born.

A glance at this date shows us that Queen Anne was still on the throne of England, at a time when the brilliant campaigns of Marlborough were drawing to a close, and England, satiated and sickened with war and conquest, was ready and preparing for the peace of Utrecht and the peaceful and prosperous administration of Walpole with George I. as the figure on the throne.

The fast-growing population of Connecticut at about this time had only reached a total of about 25,000 and the town of Lebanon was in its infancy, having seen but ten years of corporate existence at the time of Trumbull's birth. A period of prosperity and development was opening before the little Colony of Connecticut. For fifty years she had been engaged in a struggle to establish her rights under the charter of 1662; and those rights, with perhaps some wrongs, had now been established by the absorption of New Haven, the fall of Andros, the discomfiture of Fletcher, and something like a final decision regarding Connecticut's boundaries, if wc leave the South Sea out of the question. The absorbing interest of home affairs appears at the time to have diverted the attention of the mother country from active interference in the affairs of the American colonies, so that the little communities of trading farmers composing the towns of Connecticut were left comparatively free to direct their own affairs in frequent town meetings, freemen's meetings, proprietors' meetings and patentees' meetings, with representation in and appeal to the General Court or Assembly when needed. None the less, but rather the more, these times called for men of intelligence, patriotism, energy and devotion. It is the career of one of these men, who, trained in the political and social school of these times, forms a conspicuous figure in the history of his State and his Country, that we are briefly to consider.

Of the boyhood of this man but little is positively known. It was, no doubt, quite similar to the boyhood of many a lad of his day. His father appears to have been a sturdy, trading farmer, of whom traditional stories are related showing his independence of character. He appears to have afforded his son rather unusual educational advantages for the time. The mother was of a good family, the Higleys, and is said to have been a women of marked individuality and high principles. Under the training and influence of such parents, he grew up in the rich farming lands of Lebanon, instructed, no doubt, in the arts of agriculture by the practical methods of the day, which made it no disgrace for a leading citizen to till his own land, and raise and personally care for his live stock. At the age of thirteen, we find the boy Trumbull sufficiently equipped in Latin and Greek, probably under the tuition of the Rev. Samuel Welles, to enter Harvard College, where he was matriculated in 1723. It may be a source of regret to us of Connecticut that he cannot be counted as one of the sons of Yale ; but it must be remembered that at this unfortunate period in the history of Yale, then a college of but twenty-two years' standing, the institution had not recovered from the shock occasioned by the alarming conduct of Rector Timothy Cutler, who had gone over to the Episcopal faith during the previous year, to the no small horror and amazement of the sturdy Congregationalists of the time.

The age of Trumbull at the time of commencing his college course is not cited in the expectation of proving him to have been an infant prodigy. It is better to regard him as a normal product of his time. His classmate Thomas Hutchinson was his junior by a year, and though both of these lads may have had a natural taste for study, the college records of the clay show that their ages were not much below the age of the average freshman of the time. From the testimony of his son John, we learn that Trumbull acquired "a sound knowledge of the Hebrew, as well as the Greek and Latin languages, and of all the other studies of the day" and that during his college course, he became "a distinguished scholar."

formed his whole public and private life. In his freshman year, he became a member of a secret religious organization, whose simple Articles of Asociation may still be read, breathing a spirit of deep devotion and Christian charity.

In pursuance of his own choice of a profession, he commenced, soon after his graduation, the study of divinity under the Reverend Solomon Williams of Lebanon, and became in due course a licensed clergyman. A call was extended to him from the Congregational Church at Colchester, and it was just at this time that an event occurred which changed the entire current of his life. His elder brother Joseph, who was associated with his father in business, was lost at sea. The voyage on which this son was lost was one of the business enterprises which had been undertaken by the firm composed of father and son. The father, then a man of fifty-four, found himself thus bereft of one on whom he had relied in the active management of a growing business. He could only look to his son Jonathan to fill the sad gap occasioned by the loss of the elder brother.

Thus it came about that the young clergyman of twenty-two became the young merchant, embarking upon a career which he pursued, with varying fortunes, for more than thirty years. There is, probably, no doubt that in declining the call of the church at Colchester to enter upon a mercantile career, he was actuated by a sense of duty which led him to sacrifice his own choice. Five years had now been spent in the study of divinity, apparently to no purpose. It is just possible, however, that, in the mercantile customs and usages of his times, such studies might have a more direct bearing upon a business life than in our own day. Certain it is that the deep and abiding religious faith which he espoused during his college course had now become rooted and grounded in his life, to appear subsequently in many of his official utterances. And if we cannot altogether agree with some of his interpretations of the dealings oi Providence, in the light of the constantly changing theology of to-day, none the less need we respect and revere the calm and unwavering faith and Christian charity which so conspicuously guided his career.

personal characteristics, and though such descriptions only apply to him at a time when he had reached an advanced age, and closed an arduous career, we may gather from them some of the inborn and inbred traits which the young man must have possessed ; and some slight idea of his personal appearance.

In his Voyages dans V Amerique Septentrionale, the Marquis of Chastellux, gives some account of two casual meetings with Governor Trumbull in 1780 and 1781, from the point of view of a nobleman of the gay court of Louis XVI. He says :

"Another interesting person was then [in 17S0] at Hartford, and I went to make him a visit; that is, Governor Trumbull, governor par excellence, for he has been so for fifteen years, having been re-elected every two years, and having equally enjoyed public esteem under the government of the English and that of Congress. He is seventy years old, his entire life is devoted to affairs, which he loves with a passion, whether they be great or small; or, rather, there are for him none of this latter class. He has all the simplicity of dress, all the importance and even pedantry which belong to a great magistrate of a little republic. He reminds me of a burgomaster of Holland in the days of the Hensiuses and Barnevelts."

A visit to Lebanon about a year later is described by the gallant marquis, in which he mentions the - to him - ludicrous scene in which the good old Governor pronounces an old-fashioned blessing at dinner to which twenty French huzzars respond in a courteous but very insincere Amen. The Due de Lauzun is then quoted as describing this "little old man" as one who makes great affairs of small ones, and who seems only happy when business of some description is at hand. The good marquis is gracious enough to add these words :

"Thus, in the two hemispheres, excepting only Paris, what is ridiculous need not exclude aptitude for government; for it is by character that one governs, and by character also that one is ridiculous."

Turning from a description made in a spirit of national prejudice in the light of the greatest possible national contrast, we find another, still more prejudiced, in the Political Magazine of London for January, 1781, where we may read among a mass of fabrications and libels, actuated by political enmity, the following :

"Jonathan Trumbull, the rebel governor of Connecticut, a man of desperate fortune, with an abundant share of cunning, is about five feet, seven inches high, has dark eyes, a Roman nose, sallow countenance, long chin, prominent forehead, high and hroad check bones, hollow cheeks and short neck. He is, in person, of handsome figure, and very active."

More reliable, but still very meagre for our purpose, are a few words in the funeral sermon delivered by the Reverend Zebulon Ely. He says :

"As a man he possessed the amiable grace of condescending with dignity - the characteristic of true greatness. He knew how to adapt himself to persons of the greatest diversity of circumstances and conditions of life. having learned to please all with whom he conversed to the:r edification. There was nothing of that magisterial loftiness and ostentatious parade too often attendant on men of rank and elevated stations in life.

"His temper was uncommonly mild, serene and cheerful; his words weighty and instructive; his speech rather low, and his whole carriage graceful and worthy.''

Although more may be learned of his character by inference through the long public career winch, at the point we have reached, was opening before the young man, the descriptions I have quoted, meagre, inadequate and prejudiced though they are, are important especially in these days when popular biographies already profess to have given us the "True George Washington" and the "True Thomas Jefferson."

It requires no stretch of the imagination to go back to a time fifty years before the e descriptions were written, and picture the young man of twenty-two as rather below the medium stature, active, alert and graceful in his movements ; a thoroughly democratic man of the people, with a pleasant word of greeting, and with kindly ministrations to his neighbors of high and low degree. His serious and earnest attention to matters both great and small, which appeared so ridiculous to the gay Frenchmen of the time, was doubtless an inborn trait with him, and may also be noted as a marked trait in the great Washington. It was, no doubt, with Trumbull, a spirit of indomitable industry, which, trained in the rough school of a Connecticut colonist and patriot, was something incomprehensible to the Parisian courtier. The "abundant share of cunning" of which his British enemies speak, may without much doubt be found to be the adaptability

"to persons of the greatest diversity of circumstances" of which his pastor speaks. As we glance through his career, too, we shall find this same characteristic developing into diplomacy in the best sense of the term, as when, at the opening of the Revolution, he urged the postponement of the trial of the Susquehanna case for the reason that nothing should be allowed to prevent the harmonious relations which should exist between the colonies at the time.

But we have been obliged to anticipate the career of the man, too much already, in order to learn with what manner of man we had to deal at the point in his career where we left him a few moments ago.

Within a year from the beginning of his business career, his public career also began; for we find him in 1733, at the age of twenty-three, elected a deputy from Lebanon to the General Assembly; again elected annually from 1736 to 1739, in which year he was, at the age of twenty-nine, chosen Speaker of the House of Representatives. From this time on, for eleven years, he was continuously an Assistant, during five years of which time he was Judge of the County Court for Windham, in addition to which he was, from 1749 to 1753, Judge of Probate for the district of Windham. His membership in the General Assembly was continued uninterruptedly by his election as Deputy in 1752, '53, and '54, during two of which years he. was again made Speaker ; after which he was continuously elected Assistant until 1767, when he was made Deputy-Governor. During these years, too, he was almost continuously Judge of the County Court of Windham, and Judge of Probate ; relinquishing the office of Judge of the County Court in 1766, to take the position of Chief Justice of the Superior Court, which position he occupied until his election as Governor in 1769.

During all this period, in addition to his judgeships and his attendance in the semi-annual and frequent extra sessions of the General Assembly, he was actively engaged in mercantile pursuits ,and conducting a large, increasing and profitable business up to 1766, when a quick succession of reverses and marine disasters brought failure and financial ruin to himself and his eldest son Joseph, who was associated with him at the time.

At the time of his election as Governor in 1769, we find him a man of fifty-nine, with a wife and family of six children. In 1735, on the ninth of December, he had married Faith Robinson, daughter of the Reverend John Robinson of Duxbury. It is asserted by Trumbull's biographer, Stuart, that she was a greatgrandaughter of the Rev. John Robinson of Leyden. the famous Puritan leader, but careful researches have always failed to establish this statement, which appears to have been made by Stuart without authority. She was, however, a great-great-granddaughter of John Alden, the pilgrim.

Of the public services of Trumbull during the period from 1733 to 1769, it is impossible, within the present limits, to speak with the fullness they deserve. The peaceful times in which his boyhood and early manhood were passed, soon gave place to the long Spanish and French wars of T739 to 1748, and again to the French war of 1755 to 1763. Like most of the public-spirited citizens of his day, Trumbull, in addition to his engrossing civil duties, bore several military commissions during this period. In 1735, he was a Lieutenant; in 1739, a Lieutenant Colonel, and in 1753, Colonel of the Twelfth Regiment of the militia of the Colony. He does not appear to have taken the field during the wars of the periods covered by his commissions, but we may infer, from his close attention to other public duties that lie was prompt and punctual in his attendance upon the numerous trainings and other duties to which his regiment was called. His early habit and love of study, his business training, and his natural endowments appear to have fitted him more particularly for the civil than the military service.

Certain it is that the most insatiable appetite for work, and for public affairs great and small could hardly ask for more than was allotted to him during his career as a judge and as a member of the General Assembly. Referring to the records, it is safe to say that from T737 to 1767 no member of the General Assembly was appointed on as many committees or assigned to as many special duties as he ; from the locating of a meeting-house in New Concord, which soon became New Discord, Parish in Norwich, to a membership on the commission to accompany the Governor to Boston to meet the Earl of Loudoun for conference on war measures. We find his business training frequently turned to public account by his appointment as auditor of the annual statements of the Treasurer of the Colony ; and his legal lore and literary talents similarly used by his appointment to revise the laws of the colony for publication. Twice during this period - in 1756 and 1758 - he was appointed colonial agent to represent Connecticut in the court of the home government at London, both of which appointments, for reasons best known to himself, he declined. It should be noted that his father died in 1756, and that the new responsibilities which this event entailed upon him may have made it impossible for him so to adjust his many affairs public and private as to enable him to make a long residence in England.

A particularly important case of a purely civil nature was entrusted to him in 1753, when, with Roger Wolcott jr., he was appointed to investigate and report upon the matter of the Spanish snow San Jose' y Santa Elena, which vessel had put into New London in distress, and discharged her cargo at that port. In some mysterious way, a portion of the cargo and treasure had disappeared when the time came to reload it. The affair assumed almost international importance, and upon Trumbull appears to have devolved the lion's share of the work, which, so far as he was concerned, was performed with tact and fidelity, giving him a valuable experience in the school of diplomacy.

Time fails us" to tell in detail of many other commissions, especially in connection with military affairs, of equal, or greater importance lhan those to which reference has been made, in all of which he bore his share of responsibility, and for many of which he was solely responsible. Suffice it is to say, that his scholarship, his business ability, his inborn industry, vigor and diplomacy were, during these thirty years and more, constantly at the service of his country, giving him a wealth of experience which formed his equipment for the important duties of Deputy Governor from 1767 to 1769, and of Governor during the fifteen momentous years which followed.

We find him, during these thirty years and more of service, deeply interested in the study of history, especially the history of Connecticut, and a promoter of every scheme at his command for the enlightenment, education and material benefit of the community in which he lived. A quaint old document endorsed "Philogrammatician Covenant," which appears to have escaped the notice of his careful biographer, Stuart, shows him to have been, as early as 1739, one of the originators of a library company in Lebanon after the exclusive fashion of the proprietary libraries of the day. He was, apparently, too, the originator of market fairs in Lebanon, and one of the founders of the celebrated school of Master Nathan Tisdale.

In the course of his official duties in prosecuting the celebrated Mohegan case and the equally celebrated and complicated Susquehanna case, his indefatigable researches led him to become the first discoverer of that history which forms a contribution of such inestimable value to the chronicles of early colonial New England, the Journal of John Winthrop, Sen. The first copy of the only portion of that history then known to exist was made by himself and his secretary. Another important contribution to colonial history which he discovered and preserved at about the same time, and in the same connection, was Lion Gardiner's account of the Pequot war. From the Trumbull Papers in possession of the Massachusetts Historical Society, we find that he was engaged in an extensive correspondence with his cousin, Benjamin Trumbull, regarding the history of Connecticut written by the latter, which has served for more than a century as the standard colonial history of Connecticut. A paragraph in the preface of this history tells of the assistance and encouragement which the author received at the hands of his cousin, and makes appreciative mention of his familiarity with Connecticut history.

These facts are particularly noted here, because they may help us to explain why this man, at the age of sixty-five, when every other governor of the thirteen colonies of Great Britain espoused the cause of their king, stands out in bold relief in history as the only one who espoused the cause of his country.

Trained as he was by his long career on the bench and in the General Assembly to a judicial view of affairs, attached as he was to his native soil through careful study of the history of his commonwealth, and through long and arduous service in her behalf; fortified and animated by a deep and devout conviction of the righteousness of his country's cause, it is to be expected that such a man as he would do as he did. It was with no uncertain sound that he uttered his views on the injustice of the stamp act, and with no uncertain step that he indignantly retired from the council chamber when Governor Fitch insisted upon taking his official oath to support this odious measure.

Fixed and unalterable as were his convictions, he still felt it his duty to use every argument and every means in his power to avert the conflict which was impending in 1775. His official letters to the Earl of Dartmouth in March of that year, and to General Gage on receipt of the news of the battle of Lexington are models of diplomatic correspondence, waiving no iota of the rights of American citizens, yet offering every possible and reasonable expedient to avert the impending crisis. These letters, written as the result of deliberations of the council, show no wavering on the part of the governor of his colony ; and though the letters, or rather, the embassy from Connecticut to General Gage was severely criticized by Massachusetts at the time, it can readily be seen that not only Connecticut, but the neighboring colonies were placed in a better light by the means.

Provenance

Text from Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society .., published 1890, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.