New London County, Connecticut - Chapter 2: The Grant from the Duke of York, 1906
From Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society, published 1906. 2,950 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
2,950 wordsMachine-read from scans of Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society, published 1906. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 2: The Grant from the Duke of York
Fishers Island was included in the boundaries of the Duke of York's patent to Richard Nicolls in 1664, and John Winthrop, who had been elected Governor of Connecticut Colony in 1657 and again in 1659- 1676, procured a patent of confirmation in which he speaks of the Island as an " Intire Enfranchised Township, Manor & Place of itself & shall always from tyme to tyme & at all times hereafter have hould and injoye like and Equall priveleges & Immunityes with any Town Infranchis'd Place or Manour within this Goverm't & shall in no manner of way be subordinate or belonging unto, have any dependance upon or in anywise be under ye Rule order or direction of any Ryding, Towneship Place, or Jurisdiction within this Governm't » » & by fealty onely, yielding Rendering & Paying yearely & every year unto his Royall Highness ye Duke of York & his Heires, or to such Governour or Governours as from tyme to tyme shall be by him Constituted & appointed as an Acknowledgmt One Lamb upon ye first day of May if the same shall be demanded." To prove the payment of this, we quote the postscript of a letter written by Gov. Andros to Fitz- John Winthrop on June eighth, 1680 :
" Capt Hall asking me, ocasions this postscript, to repeate & acknowledge the receipt by him of ye lambe you paid him (as authorized) for acknowledgmt of ye tenure of Fishers Island and is in full to this time. Yours E. Andros G."
While he was Governor, Winthrop realized the insecurity of the Connecticut title and was delegated by the General Court in 1662 to obtain a charter from Charles II.
John Winthrop's father was a good friend of Charles I., who had given him a seal ring. This ring he gave to his son, when he went on his mission, as a means of identification to Charles II., and to further show his good will and friendship.
The charter was secured through Winthrop's tact and diplomacy and preserved to the colony by being hidden in a hollow tree - the famous Charter Oak.
Immediately after Connecticut received her charter, she claimed a complete jurisdiction over Fishers Island, and the towns on Long Island, and the General Court of Hartford on May twelfth, 1664, adopted this resolution : *' We declare that we claim Long Island expressed in our charter, except a precedent right doth appear approved by his Majesty," and took upon itself the appointment of all the officers to the towns not permitted by the charter to be chosen by the people. This union with the colony continued until the conquest in 1664, when it was reluctantly abandoned, but was hastily renewed on the recapture of New York by the Dutch in 1673. The Dutch Governor undertook to reduce them to obedience, but by the restoration of New York in 1674, several towns were anxious to continue under Connecticut jurisdiction. The island towns sent deputies over to solicit their co-operation, and on June thirteenth, 1674, Southold, in conjunction with South and East Hampton sent a petition to the king for permission to remain under the jurisdiction of Connecticut But Sir Edmund Andros, the new Governor of New York took effective measures and wrote in 1 680 as follows to Wm. Leete, the Governor of Connecticut :
'* Hon'ble Sr. - Being advised by an order on warrant from yourself and some assistants sent to ffisher's Island, I am much surprised att your Intrenching upon his MajTies Letters Patent to his Royal Highness, as well as the grant by Governour NicoUs to the Honoble John Winthrop, Esq. (late Governor or Connecticut) for sd Island ; which Island and Grant it is my Duty to assert, as much as this or any other part of the Govermt ; and therefore desire that you will, without delay, recall sd warrant or order, and forbear any the like proceedings for the future, to prevent great Inconveniencys ; and remaine your Eflfectionate Neighbour and Humble Servant E. Andros. To the Honble William Leete, Esq. Governour of his Maties Colony of Connecticut.*' ment over the Island, and prohibited obedience to Sir Edmund's request, but MaJDr Fitz-John Winthrop, the eldest son of John Winthrop, felt obliged to recognize the jurisdiction of New York. Although dissatisfied, Connecticut did not raise the unsettled boundary question until in 1878-9, when both states appointed Commissioners, for New York, Messrs. Allen C. Bead, Augustus Schoonmaker and Horatio Seymour, Jr., and Messrs. Origan S. Seymour, Lafayette S. Foster and Wm. G. Miner for Connecticut, to establish the boundaries. An agreement was made whereby the western boundary of Connecticut was fixed as the ex parte line surveyed by New York in 1680, which was the old line of 1731. Connecticut therefore gave up her claim to the twenty-six hundred acres in dispute, in exchange for which her Southern boundary was extended into the Sound, " beginning at a point in the center of the channel, about six hundred feet South of the extreme rocks of Bryan's Point, thence running in a true Southeast course three and one-quarter statute miles true South of New London lighthouse; thence through Fishers Island Sound and on so far as said states are coterminous."* The above agreement was ratified by both states. The only fast land gained by Connecticut in moving the Southern boundary was Mystic Island, which New York had claimed. The Connecticut Commissioners said, " In regard to Fishers Island, it ought by reason of its nearness to our coast to belong to Connecticut. It belonged to us, we think, under a fair construction of the charter of 1662, which by express words gave us the islands adjacent to the mainland; but upon familiar principles of law. New York has now the title, having had actual possession of it for more than a century."
John Winthrop thus retained his island possession during his life, although it is interesting to note in this connection that at one time he had some thought of selling it. Wm. Roswell wrote to him from New Haven, December, 1669 :
" You were pleased some time since to inform me that you have some inclination to dispose of Fishers Island. One Capt. Anthony Lane, a gentleman in the Barbadoes hath written unto me concerning it, desiring to know whether it is to be sold."
after this, as his interests on the mainland were various and scattered. When Winthrop was Governor he was urged to move to New Haven, where the town had purchased a house near the corner of Court and State Streets for him, but which he refused to take as a gift, agreeing to pay one hundred pounds in goats from Fishers Island. From this letter it is evident that goats were used to subdue the island, and must have been very profitable. We find no later reference to them.
It is evident that Winthrop also claimed the small islands lying near, now known as North and South Dumpling and the Hummock, for we find from a letter of Roger Williams to John Winthrop, at Nameaug: '' He prays you not to lose your right, but send for a skin of a moose, which was killed upon one of your hummocks by Fishers Island lately and carried to Wequashcuck."
After a full and noble life in carrying out the work to which he had dedicated himself, John Winthrop passed away in 1 676, leaving a most noble heritage in landed estates, among which were Fishers Island and its Hummocks and Goat Island.
Early War Scares And Captain Kidd
It will be of interest to note that Fishers Island was encumbered for the sake of the Connecticut colony, from the following letter written by Governor Leete to Stephen Chester, April seventh, 1677 -
'' I would entreat of your Honor and your associates to take into your worthy and serious consideration the affairs of the heirs of the aforesaid Gov. Winthrop referring to Fishers Island, which was encumbered for the sake of this colony (Conn.)." This island descended to Fitz-John and his brother Wait-Still and was possessed by them conjointly and undivided during their lives. Fitz-John having no sons, it was understood between the brothers that the principal part of the land grants should be kept in the name, and to this end preserved for John, the only son of Wait Winthrop. In i66a we find Fitz-John and Wait-Still Winthrop regular inhabitants of the New
Fishers Island. 1S7
London colony. Fitz-John received his military training in the English army, and was Governor of Stirling Castle and a general in Monk's army. When the Dutch recaptured Manhattan in 1673, *^^ made an expedition up the Sound, Captain Fitz-John Winthrop raised troops at Stonington and New London to meet them. There was a bloodless encounter at Southold in which a few harmless shots were exchanged, the English being left in possession of the town, while the Dutch, after making threats which they could not put into execution, sailed away. At this time he resided chiefly in New London, where he busied himself in raising stock on Fishers Island and in looking after his father's property, but he had a house at Fishers Island where he spent some of his time as is shown in a letter addressed to him at Fishers Island, by Edmund Andros, in 1680.
Labor troubles are usually referred to as of modern date, but we find that Fitz-John Winthrop had many, and for various reasons, in 1690, when there was an alarm caused by the anchoring of four sloops between the Hummocks and the harbor. They had been at New London for a considerable time flying the English colors, then French. Several shots were fired at them. Gurdon Saltonstall writes to Fitz- John Winthrop as follows :
" That night there came over from Fishers Island a small number of Indians, who give an account of a skirmish that they had with a small number of French. They have brought over a scalp with them and say they have left one dead there whose scalp they had not time to take. It is presumed (upon your report) that your house is rifled at your Island. What credit may be given to it I know not. The reports we have are very uncertain." Later he writes : " When I got home I found all your Islanders but Jonathan in a very great fright hurrying to Boston ye very next morning, and so could by no means come to a speech with them. You will percieve by this letter wt his inclinations are : I have used all the arguments I can think of with him, but cannot alter them. Your Honrs presence here would doe much, or (if that is not likely to be attained) your directions unto him. Whether you would have any of ye creatures removed from ye island ? If they must stay there, how ye should be provided for in ye winter ? I have urged Johnathan to mow & make wt hay will be needful for their keeping, and he tels mee he will doe whatever he is able. His negroe is still with him & he expects Peter up again dayly." A week later some English ships in pursuit of the enemy landed on Fishers Island, " which hath scared Johnathan & Peter off; Johnathan as Mrs. Betty tells mee, offers his share of graine to anybody that will secure ye rest, but will not venture himself upon ye Island without a guard."
Two weeks later Saltonstall writes as follows : " The news of the French fleet designed upon this coast made me think you would be here to take some order about Fishers Island. If the French intend for York (which may I think be supposed) that Island will be convenient for them : and methinks it would not be amiss to draw off what stock might be fit for market this summer before they come."
Another account says : " Some French vessels came to Block Is. determined to attack New London - found New London harbor too hot for them and drew off to Block Is. to receive plunder and spoUs there. Some of their company went on to an Island called Fishers Island lying near New London and among others this treacherous fellow - Trimming - upon which 1 7 men went from Stonington. There was but one house on the Is. though about nine miles in length where this party of Frenchmen were at that time. The Englishmen came near the house before they were discovered. Trimming came out to them in a pretended friendly manner, drawing his gun behind him. They demanded whence and who they were. He replied they were castaway men. One of the Englishmen replied : * If you are friends lay down your gun and go behind us.' Immediately Mr. Stephen Richardson as was supposed through surprise shot him dead on the spot, for which act he was much blamed. Thus he that delighted in a falsehood in his life died with a lie in his mouth and received a just reward of his perfidious villanous and multiplied treacheries."
These war scares and labor troubles evidently caused so much annoyance to Fitz-John Winthrop that he induced Wm« Walworth, a family friend, to come here from near Ix)ndon to introduce the English system of cultivation, with which Walworth was known to be well acquainted. Thus Wm. Walworth became the first lessee. To this place he brought his young wife and here his four eldest children were bom, the first white children born on the Island. The feelings of this young wife and mother in this lonely place, exposed to the danger of Indians and French privateers, can only be imagined. Of greater dread than either was Captain Kidd, who at this time frequented the coasts of Gardiner's Island and Fishers Island opposite. Here in the sheltered harbors and coves they would wait in their low, black schooners, until some merchant vessel appeared in sight, when they would pounce upon her and seize such parts of her cargo as they wished. Fishers Island has its share of traditions regarding the buried chests of gold, for which many a spadeful of earth has been turned. Divers have even been employed to search some of the numerous ponds. The terror which Captain Kidd inspired at this time along the New England coast seems out of proportion to the length of his career, which was terminated in 1699. That the terror existed is certain, and caused Walworth to move his family and household property to Groton. These being made secure, he was left free to work his farm on the Island as well as a new one on the mainland.
The war between England and France which was being waged at this time was felt also by their respective colonies in this country. French privateers harassed the New England coast, and interfered greatly with the commerce of those early days. Miss Caulkins says : '* New London in this war suffered considerably in her shipping, several of her merchant vessels being cut off by French privateers."
Thus was seen the necessity of New London's being warned of the approach of an enemy, then as in more recent times. The location of Fishers Island became of great stragetic advantage, and the necessity of placing a beacon upon Mt. Prospect, the highest hill lapped by the waters of the Atlantic between Maine and Florida, was reahzed at this time. The importance of this point was first called to the attention of the Connecticut colony by Major Plumes Gurdon Saltonstall writes to Fitz-John Winthrop, in 1690, as follows : '* There hath been proposal made concerning a beacon to be placed on Mount Prospect on your is- land, and that a watch and ward be kept there, which I would desire your judgment of, if you think meet." Apparently nothing was done about the beacon at this time, but in 1 704 when Winthrop was Governor of Connecticut, Richard Christophers and G. Saltonstail of the Committee of Safety of New London make the following petition to him : " It is humbly offered for the safety of this Port of New London it is so much exposed to an enemy in the time of the present imminent danger.'* " That care may be taken by Beacon or otherwise to have notice from Fishers Island, or otherwise of approaching danger." In a later letter dated June nineteenth, 1706, to Fitz-John Winihrop, Governor, appears the following : "And whereas there is a former order of council for the keeping a ward upon Fishers Island for the discovery of an approaching enemy in order to give a more timely notice to New London by fixing one or two beacons made on said island for that account it is now ordered that the Beacon made on the west point of Fishers Island shall be fired upon discovery made from Mount Prospect of one ship, or two other topsail vessels standing in towards said island from the southard or northard of Block Island or upon discovery of five ship standing in from the southard or five from the northard of Block Island, and that both beacons on Fishers Island shall be fired upon the discovery of a greater number of vessels standing in as aforesaid."
During the latter part of Fitz-John Winthrop's term of office as Governor of Connecticut, little attention seems to have been paichto his island property, at least we find no reference in any letters to or from him during this period.
Provenance
Text from Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society, published 1906, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.