New London County, Connecticut - In the Days of Madam Winthrop, 1906
From Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society, published 1906. 2,279 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
2,279 wordsMachine-read from scans of Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society, published 1906. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
In the Days of Madam Winthrop
After Fitz-John Winthrop's death in 1707, he leaving no male descendants, and the landed estates which they had inherited from their father having never been divided, Fishers Island descended to his younger brother, Wait- Still Winthrop. He was Chief Justice of Massachusetts Bay Colony, and Major-General of the militia of that province. We know little about his connection with the island, except that he visited it occasionally, but from papers in the posession of one of the later Winthrops, it appears that an attempt was made by him or his son John in the year 171 2 to transport a pair of moose deer from the island to England, as a present to Queen Anne, which failed by reason of one dying and the other breaking its leg, and Her Majesty was finally presented with the horns only. It is evident that he had trouble, in 171 2, with the tenants on the island over the delivery of stock, and in 1714, George Havens hired a part of the island.
In a letter of Wait Winthrop, at Boston, to his son John, at New London, in 171 7, he writes: " I have some red cedar bengles which I gathered at Fishers Island ; they say Mr. Brenton sowed some at Rhode Island and has a young grove of cedars now on his farm. Many people hereabouts carry them in their pockets and eat them as bei&g very wholesome and strengthening they say to the vitals, and good for all sorts of ails the indians say." This was the writer's last letter. He had long suffered from occasional ailments, but was on the whole a vigorous man for his advanced age. Only a few years before, his son describes with pride his father's activity of limb and accuracy of aim during a day's shooting on Fishers Island. In 1717, John came in active possession of Fishers Island after much litigation in the Connecticut courts with his sister, wife of Thomas Lechmere, Esq., of Boston. His sister claimed an equal share of their father's landed estate, which claim was sustained by the Connecticut courts. Winthrop went to England to plead his cause, and before going, in July, 1 726, made the following will :
" I give and bequeath unto my faithful kind and most dear wife ;^ioo per annum out of the rents of Fishers Island during her natural life with her living in my mansion house at New London." To his eldest son John-Still he leaves Fishers Island " forever to be and abide to him and his heirs male forever."
In England he was well received, and suceeeded in obtaining a favorable decree from the king in council, which grounded this decision on the English law of primogeniture. In Connecticut this decree was considered a public calamity, inasmuch as it involved the abrogation of the colonial law respecting interstate estates. By the intervention of friends and agents of the colony, a decision was finally obtained confirming Winthrop in his possession, but allowing the law of inheritance in the colony to remain as before. Winthrop was so estranged from the colony that he never returned, and died in England in 1747. During Winthrop's absence in England, his wife, Madam Winthrop, as she is called, managed the island affairs from New London. On February twenty-eighth, 1726-27, Joshua Hempstead says: "In the afternoon I was at Madam Winthrop's writing a lease for Fishers Island." And on April twentieth he says : " I was sent for to Mrs. Winthrop to go to the Island & receive ye stock, but ye wind & tide not suiting Peter Williams did not go." The next day he writes: " I went to the Island & we drove it & got up the sheep." The following day, Saturday : " we drove the Island again, we drove out^e sheep & stock of Cattle & Horses kine & I gave her a rectt" Mondly he returns home with Sam Rogers. In November of the same year, Hempstead again writes that he went to Fishers Island in Madam Winthrop's boat with Madam Winthrop, Mr. Wanton, Molly, Kate, Peg., Jno. & Bazill. The following day they drove about the Island to east end and found things in good order. Mr. Wanton killed a young Buck in the forenoon which we brought over.
The island was again leased to Chas. Dickinson, Sr , in 1728, upon his giving new bonds. In 1731, Hempstead says he went to Fishers Island with justice Richmond to receive the stock of Mr. Dickinson, and that Mr. Mumford was also there. " We got over there before eight o'clock and counted out 1350 sheep and 42 cows and 20 swine 16 of them sows and i boar, 8 mares with foal 4 oxen etc. All the rest of the stock is in good order and lodged there." On Saturday : " I went to Fishers Island with Mr. Mumford and I received all the stock and gave a receipt. I viewed the house at the East End and finished.** This is the first reference we have to a house at the east end. Tradition says that the bricks for the main portion of the house were imported from Holland, which is partially confirmed by judges of brick, who claim they are different from any made about here.
George Havens, a former tenant of Fishers Island, died here March sixteenth, 1734, and was buried inGroton. Joshua Hempstead says : '* I borrowed and received of Jasper Latham ;^2o in bills of credit to be paid upon demand, but if I can get him Fishers Island for ;^6oo a year or as others will give, then I am to have this ;^2o gratis and more also."
It is evident that Joshua did not get his promised fee of ;^2o, as Mumford was a tenant in 1738. "Here we staid all night with him and were entertained very courteously and he would take nothing of me or mine."
On the third of October, 1 739, a sailing party was organized, composed of Madam Winthrop, wife of John Winthrop who was then in England, her son John, and daughter Ann, Col. Saltonstall and wife and two children. Col. Browne, of Salem, with his wife and child, and Mr. Joshua Hempstead. They were entertained by Mr. George Mumford, the lessee of the island. The whole party crossed in Mumford's sailboat, and remained four days on the island. The first day was diversified with an excursion to the east end of the island. The second day a fierce storm confined them to the house. On the third day, they had a morning drive to the west end and a visit to the woods. In the afternoon, a famous deer hunt. Saltonstall brought down a doe, and Mumford two bucks, one of which was immediately dispatched by a carrier to Mr. Wanton, of Newport, as a present from the party. On the seventh of October they started for home at nine in the morning, but were becalmed, the flood failed them and they ran into Mystic. Landing near the house of Mr. Burrows, all walked from thence to John Walworth's, where they obtained horses, and reached home in the evening. The good shooting above referred to is accoun ted for, as the island was kept as a preserve by the Winthrops. Just before this a white man and an Indian were fined for killing a deer.
The winter of 1740-41 was noted in the annals of New England for intense cold which commenced at Christmas with a violent snow storm. The intense cold continued uninterrupted until the middle of March. The ice extended into the Sound toward Long Island as far as could be seen, and Fishers Island was united to the mainland by a solid bed.
On the seventeenth of November, 1744, Joshua Hempstead called on Madam Winthrop and found the sheriff of Suffolk county there for taxes of Fishers Island for 22 years.
Fishers Island
pound cheeses per day. They also made butter. Mr. Allen kept one hundred cows and two thousand sheep ; he bred horses and mules, and raised rye, wheat and oats. He hired a man named William Westcore, to be both teacher and chaplain for his own and his tenants large families. He was much beloved by all under him; one man worked for him twenty-eight years, and others nearly as long.
Mr. Allen attended St. James Church, New London, Conn., with as many of his family as could conveniently accompany him. They went in his sloop Betsey, on Sundays and Christmas Day. During the holidays he always invited all his tenants and their families to visit him, providing an excellent dinner and supper for them, and afterwards sent to the aged, sick and those unable to be present, a liberal portion from the feast. All looked forward to the Christmas gatherings, for they had a nice time; a dance and games for the young people occupied the evening, when Jack (the colored boy) played on the violin. Mr. Allen lived nineteen years on the island. When he moved away all his tenants also left, as they said they did not wish to live there without him.
Five of Thomas and Amelia Allen's children were born on the island ; three, Samuel Taber, Pardon and the youngest, died and are buried there.
Thomas Allen, Jr., was made justice of the peace while he lived there, and was always called either Squire Allen, or Captain, as he had been to sea, in 1775, as supercargo; their trade was with the Island of Madeira, where his father made a large fortune. He was also, I believe, a captain of the militia."
By the will of Francis Bayard Winthrop, Fishers Island was left to his four sons in common. William H. Winthrop in 1818 purchased his three brothers' interests and thus became the sole owner of the island. The character of the island was changed very much by the great September gale of 181 5, which swept down the great oak and the little birch alike. While the island was probably not very densely wooded, except in protected places, we know that Clay Point was covered with oak, which is recalled by aged persons still living, and evidences of which appear on the edges of swamps and marshy places. In 1838 we find Ruel R. Strickland in charge of the island for Mr. Winthrop, where he remained eight years. The stock at this time consisted of 100 cows, 5 yoke of oxen, i driving horse, 25 horses and colts, 1200 sheep.
William H. Winthrop, Jr., lived in the east end farm house in 1843, and later in the Mansion House, in all a period of eleven years. Several of his children remember distinctly the wreck of the steamer "Atlantic," which went ashore on North Hill, in 1846.
The first tract disposed of was the small island called North Dumpling to the United States of America, for the purpose of a lighthouse, in 1847. William H. Winthrop had been in the descending financial scale for some time, and when he died, in 1 860, it became necessary for the heirs - William H. Winthrop, Jr., Thomas P. Winthrop, and Francis B. Winthrop, and two daughters, Jane P. Chester and Mary T. Pratt - to dispose of the property, after the death of their mother, who died in 1863. The property was deeded to George F. Chester, who immediately reconveyed the property to Robert R. Fox. Mr. Fox had disposed of his business as a ship chandler and manufacturer of cotton duck, in New York city, in which he had been very successful and accumulated a small fortune. The island for many years had been cultivated but little, and Mr. Fox had in mind to develop it in an agricultural way. He erected a grist-mill for grinding com and purchased improved agricultural implements, in New York, which he transported to the island in his sloop " Richard Smith." In the spring of 1864, there were some two hundred acres under cultivation, much of which was of a rugged character. Mr. Fox was making many improvements in the property when a sudden illness overtook him, and he passed away in the summer of 187 1. He was buried on a little knoll south east of Union Chapel, but his remains were afterwards removed to Greenwood Cemetery, Brooklyn, N. Y. By the will of Mr. Fox, Joseph S. Fay became the executor of the Fishers Island estate, which was transferred by him to James H. J^yles, in 1875. Mr. Lyles acted as trustee for the heirs until 1 889, when the island with all its small contiguous islands was sold to Edmund M. Ferguson, with one hundred and one exceptions, which tracts had previously been sold by Mr. Lyles.
Mr. Ferguson was a prominent citizen of Pittsburg, Pa., who with his brother, was one of the pioneers in the coke industry. He was also president of the Merchants & Manufacturers Bank of Pittsburg and interested in many other large enterprises. Mr. Ferguson continued his interest in the development of the island until his death in June, 1904. Shortly after the purchase of the island, £. M. Ferguson deeded one-half undivided interest to his brother Walton Ferguson, and it continues in these names to the present day.
Mr, Walton Ferguson is a New York banker and broker, in addition to which he has extensive manufacturing and railroad interests. His residence is at Stamford, Conn. By the terms of his brother's will he was made trustee, thus leaving him the active proprietor of the island's interests.
Provenance
Text from Records and Papers of the New London County Historical Society, published 1906, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.