Windham County, Connecticut - The whole text, 1880 (part 2 of 17)
From History of Windham County, Connecticut, published 1880. 15,971 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
4 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,971 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Windham County, Connecticut, published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
The church out of consideration for such conscientious scruples and the possible heresies that might lurk in the inscnitable "prev Hedges," discharged the brother with "a gentle admonition." The support of the minister occasioned much discussion and trouble. According to Baptist theory and practice he was to be supported by '' free contributions." No precise sum was specified, but he was " to rise in proportion as the members in general do as to their temporal estate." Anything like rate-paying was most abhorrent to the primitive Baptist, but freedom in supporting the minister was hardly com|)atible with the means adopted for making each brother pay his proportion, viz. : -
<*Oct. 8, 1781, vote put whether the church mean to ennpect each member respecting the support of the Gospel amongst us when it becomes necessary? Voted In the affirnintlve.'*
Despite these vanous trials and hindrances the Ashford Baptist Church maintained a respectable standing in town and denomination, and gained a strong niemborshi)) though weakened after a few yeai*s by withdrawals to Willington and Mansfield.
The eastern inhabitants delayed separate organization till October, 1777, when upon petition of Benjamin Sumner and others, showing that they were of ability to support the gospel in two societies, they were endowed with distinct society privileges, " according to a lino previously agreed upon beginning at Bigelow liiver at Mansfield's north line, thence running up said river to the north line of the town." At a society meeting, Jan. 7, 1778, it was voted, "That Mr. EUsha Hutchinson be our gospel minister." Failing to carry out this enactment, a meeting was held, May 25, at the house of Lieut. John Rnssel, when Josiah Spalding, Benjamin Sumner and Jonathan Chapman were chosen a committee to hire preaching, with instructions 'Uo employ Mr. Andrew Judnon of Stratford, with a view of settling among us, provided he don't stay with us then to hire some other gentleman.'* Notwithstanding the heavy burden now laid upon all classes by the war, the number of absent citizens, and the many pressing public duties, the resi<lents of Eastford Society manifested great spirit and readiness in establishing public woi-ship. At this s^nne meeting it was also voted, "To build a meeting-house in Eastford Society, about four or five rods northwest from where CapUiin Benjamin Russel's old shop used to stand." Abiel Simmons was chosen collector ; Ingoldsby Work, " agent to pray out a committee to set a stake for a meeting-house spot ; also, a committee to treat with such committee as the County Court should send to stick the stake aforesaid." June 30, it was farther voted, " That the County Court's committee should stick stake on Ijeut. John Itussel's land." This being accomplished to the satisfaction of all a subscription was circulated, the society first agreeing, " That those that subscribe towards building a meethig-house have liberty to build it of equal bigness with Woodstock's West Society's meeting-house, i. e., 45x35."
Mr. Judson consenting to preach as a candidate, public services were held September 23, 1778, when "Andrew Ju<lson, Benjamin Sumner, Samuel Snow, Jonathan Chapman, Elisha Wales and Simeon Deane entered into church covenant in presence of the Reverends Stephen Williams, John Ston*8 and Elisha Flutohinson, making a solemn and fresh dedication of themselves, and being formed into a church." Few in number, they were all the more zealous for doctrinal soundness and purity, desiring to embody " according to the word of God, and in particular according to the light of the following texts, i, e., Deut. 20: 12, 13 ; Jer. 50 : 55 ; Second Cor. 8:5; Isaiah 44 : 5 ; Nehe. 9 : 38 ; Isaiah 10 : 28, 29, in an evangelical manner, and not in a legal frame of spirit." Oct 13, the church unanimously voted Mr. Andrew Judson to be their gospel minister, the society concurring in the call, and offering £500 settlement, £70 salary. Ordination services were held Dec. 1, when "it being through kind Providence a very pleasant day, the solemnities were performed to the pleasure and satisfaction of a large concourse of people." Rev. Ephraim Judson of Norwich, a relative of the new pastor, preached the ordination sermon, and neighboring ministers assisted in the other exercises. Benjamin Sumner, Esq., and Jonathan Chapman were ere long appointed deacons. Various members were received by a dismissive and reconnnendatory letter from the First Church of Ashford.
Ra8Tford Booirtt
Work on the meeting-house was greatly impeded by scarcity of men and money. The frame was raised in the summer of 1779, and partly covered so that business meetings were hehl in it, but religious services were conducted '* at the house of Mr. Aaron Tuffls, or Lieut RusseFs, or Captain Josinh Spalding's." It was voted, "To purchase about an acre of land of Lieut. Russel, in addition to the two acres thnt the same has promised to give the society for a meeting-house spot.*' A committee was appointed this summer to treat with Mr. Judson how he must have his Hilary paid in this paper money, which agreed upon " the rate of twenty pounds /or one" In 1780, voted, "To sell the pew ground at vendue, nnd the money used in finishing the meeting-house - the tier of pews within the body of seats." These pew spots were purchased by Dea. Chapman, Ebenezer Eastman, Jonathan Hayward, John liussel, Jabez Ward, Simeon Deane, John Scarborough, John Work, Benj. Sumner, Joseph and Ingoldsby Work, Ebenezer 13os worth, James Sumner, Benjamin Cates, Stephen Foster, Benj. Hay ward, Jonathan Bemis, John Frink, John liussel, Jun., Josiah Spalding, Noah Paine, Ensign Joseph Kendall, Peter Tuflfls and Samuel Snow, showing it to be a strong society. It was voted, " To purchase half a box of glass to glaze the meeting-house, and hire it under-))inned in the cheapest and best way." (Slass being found too expensive the order was countermanded, and the " windows boarded up " till times were more propitious. It was voted, " To abate the rates of all those Baptists that have brought a certificate and those that frequently attend the Baptist meeting." The following certificate procured exemption for two Quakers : -
*< Jeremiah Mory beloiijTS to the Friends' meethi!?, and so Danlc| Bartlett dotli sup of the snme cup with me, and we own him to be one of our brethren, an I take care of uiy fricudt. In the presence of us, which we are ready to answer to, this :
During these years of sectarian and political agitation, Ashford was also implicated in a prolonged litigation growing out of the ancient " Corbin land claims,** and carried on by Benjamin and Asliael Marcy as legal representatives of James Corbin. Elijah Whiton, Ezra Smith, Elisha Wales, Benjamin Clark and Ebenezer Byles were appointed in 17G0, "To search the book of records with respect to the town's commons and Corbin's land," who reported that 2500 acres were allowed to Corbin in 1719, and that over 4000 acres had been laid out to him. The Marcys carried their claim to the Assembly, who appointed Joseph Spencer, Benjamin Lowe and Captain Jonathan Welles a committee of investigation. A meeting was held at Clark's tavern, in Ashford, May
4, 1774, Elijah Wliiton and Ezra Sinitli appearing as agents for the town. Full details of the original purchase and subsequent agi'eements were presented, and a formidable array of deeds and figures showing plainly that Corbin had received some hundred acres more than his due, while the petitioners demonstrated with equal cettainty that a still larger number was lacking. The connnittee in due time reported, ** That Corbin's land had not been taken np, that 910 acres still remained due to his heirs ; also, that Corbin s partnera had failed to pay taxes, and their shares should revert to him." The Assembly, after consideration of the repoit, was of opinion that 910 acres were due to Corbin under the settlement of 1719, and 375 acres under the patent of 1725, and granted that the petitioners should take them up in the town's commons. They also afKrmed, that the patent granted to Corbin in 1725, should be considered as an addition to the claim of 1719. The town refused to accept this decision so contrary to the common understand ing of the case, and to the facts adduced by Captain Chandler and othera when the patent was granted, and when the Marcys entered upon land proceeded ^* to prosecute those who had got our oounnon land into their possession." The Superior Court gave verdict in favor of the town. Marcy again appeale<l to the Assembly, complaining of error in the judgment of the Sui>erior Court, whereupon it was resolved by that bo<ly : -
** That the said Superior Court in taking cognizance of said petition manifestly erred, and mistook the luw, and that the said judi^ineut Is hereby reversed and set :i»lde, and the petitioner restored to ihe eost, and the petition remain as before entered In the docket of said Superior Court."
The town debarred from farther action at court Wiis compelled to yield up its commons. So far as regards the right of juriadiclion in this case the decision may have been legal, but with regard to the ownership of the land a careful study of all the facts would give it to the town. That the settlement of 1725 granted Corbin an addition to his immense original claim seems especially untenable, and in view of all the circumstances of the case, suggests the query, if the art of lobbying be strictly a modern invention. One result of this controverey was the copying of the original **town book'* by the faitliful town clerk, Ebenezer Byles, in 1770.
In 1771, Ashford appointed a committee to pray for county reconstruction on the following basis: Ashford with Woodstock, Killingly, Pomfret, IFnion, Stafford, Tolland and Willington to form a new northern county, and " C'olchester and Hebron to be added to the remains of Windham."
CANTEUBURr was mnch occupied at this date in resettling her parishes and repairing her bridges. In 1760, her peace was greatly disturbed by the attempted secession of a number of her southeast residents, who asked to be incorporated with residents of adjoining towns into a new religious society. John llebard, appointed to oppose this petition, remonstrated : -
<* 1. That Canterbury had already parted with a mile or two of land on the north to help form Brooklyn parish, leaving; (IrHt society In Canterbury eight mile.H by five In extent - wKsely and cautiously done to accommodate two parishes within herself when planters should bo multiplied.
2. Inhabitants were settlefl all over said parish from cast to west, north to south bounds; that the distribution of said parish Into two parishes within themselves has been the governing motive to many planters to settle and build there; that winter preaching was allowed to the north and northwest quarter, and division to be made when public charges were less heavy; that dividing parishes into such small ones weakens the whole colony and Is hurtnil to Its civil and religious Interests."
Even this last consideration, nsnally deemed so weighty, was ineffectual in (his instance. The Assembly taking time for deliberation, Mr. Hebard farther urged, that the scheme would ^^ destroy one society in Canterbury, destroy the well-being of one in Newent, and ioound and weaken a third in Scotland." In spite of these dismal prognostications, the petitioners carried the day, and secured in 1761, the erection of the new society of Hanover from parts of Canterbury, Scotland Parish and Newent.
Town affairs required much care and deliberation. Colonel John Dyer and others of the second generation of settlei-s were no longer in active life. At the town meeting, 1761, John Curtis was chosen moderator ; Captain Obediah Johnson, Stephen Frost, Josiah Butt, Captain J3enjamin Price, selectmen ; Stephen Frost, town clerk ; Deacon Samuel Huntington, treasurer ; Simon Forbes, constable and collector of excise; Timothy Cleveland, Obediah Johnson, Joseph Dyer, James Daley, William Bradford, Josiah Morse, Frederic Curtis, Gideon Cobb, Joseph Safford, John Hebard, Matthew Button, Zechariah Waldo, highway surveyors; Nathaniel Aspinwall, Samuel Adams, fenc^j- viewers ; Solomon Paine, Asa Cleveland, Ebenezer Spalding, Robert Ilerrick, Silas Cleveland, Jedidiah Dodge, listei-s; Kobert Ilerrick, Abijah Cady, leather sealers ; John Hebard, Nehemiah Ensworth, Ezekiel Spalding, Elisha Paine, Isaiah Williams, grand-jurymen ; Shubael Butts, Ilezekiah Pellet, Daniel Paine,
William Bradford, tithingmen ; Gideon Cobb, ganger and packer ; Aliaziah Adainn, brander and toller; William Bond, Ezekiel Spalding, key-keepers. Ezra Ensworth, having managed at great cost and labor to construct a dam across the Qiiinebaug in the south part of tiio town, was granted liberty to mend and *- keep in repair the same, for the benefit of his corn-mill where it now stands, the same highth and length as it now is." This unusual privilege was only obuiined by very strenuous efforts. Anything that obstructed the ammal ascent of shad and salmon on which they so much depended was most vigorously resisted by all the residents of the Quinebaug valley - and in addition to this great damage and loss this mischievous dam was charged with undermining and greatly damaging Butts Bridge just below it. This most convenient bridge, erected by Samuel Butts in 1733, had been kept in repair by private subscription, and now in 1760, the neighbura had again rebuilt it, '* supposing that Canterbury would order the dam removed." Their fears an<l forebodings were only too quickly realized. The very next winter, ice falling over the dam again carried off the bridge. The dam, it is believed, was also destroyed by the same flood and nevei* rebuilt ; but none the less <lid the aggrieved neighbors refuse to rebuild the bridge. The town, compelled to juin with IMainfield in maintaining Neviud l^ridge on the great public thoroughfare, and a ford way near Shepard s Hill in the north part of the town, and to keep up other bridges over Rowland's Brook and Little River, positively declined to assist in rebuilding Butts Bridge. So great were the inconveniences and difficulties resulting from this negligence, that a large number of petitioners from Plaintield, Preston and other towns represented the case to the Assembly, and prayed that Canterbury might be compelled to support said bridge, as a place of much travel. A special act of the assembly in 1763, thereupon provided that Canterbury shouhl build and keep in order a bridge at this place, under the direction of a county committee. Seth Pauie of Brooklyn Parish, Nathaniel Webb of Windham, and Asa Smith of Woodstock, were accordingly placed in charge of the work.
The increa.sing travel through the town made it needful to keep its highways in good order. Many of its own citizens were carried away by emigration. Abraham Paine, Elisha Cleveland, and others removed to Nine Partners, New York. Joshua Hide and Joshua Parke were among the early settlers of Vermont. Captain James Bidlack, Samuel Ransom and many other families joined the great out-flow to Wyoming. A jury was ordered by the County Court to meet at the house of Timothy Bar.kus, and lay out 21 highway from the dividing line between Windham and Canterbury, four and-a-half miles east, to the highway lending from Norwich to Canterbnry, and thence to the Great Bridge over the Quinebaug. This highway, thus relaid and carefully maintained, accommodated a great part of the travel from Providence to Hartford and farther westward. In 1778, Colonel Jabez Fitch was chosen agent by the town to oppose the memorial of Colonel Israel Putnam and others " for an open and public highway to be laid out through the towns of Killingly, Pomfret and Canterbury, in order the better to accommodate traveling from Boston to New Haven and New York/* - a project which its renowned advocate failed apparently to accomplish. A dam was allowed over Rowl:md*s Brook in the north part of the town, and various mills kept in operation. Tannery works were also carried on by Benjamin Morse.
The various taverns needed upon the ])ublic roads and other parts of the town, were kept by Timothy Backus, John Park, Ebenezer Spalding, Robert Ransom and David Reed. Dr. Gideon Welles continued his medical practice in Canterbmy and Plan field. A son of Canterbury, Dr. John Spalding, also established himself in his native town. Dr. David Adams, son of David A<lamp, rcsi<ling in Scotland and afterward in Preston, was often employed in his old home.
Rev James Cogswell continued in charge of the First church, which though weakened by secession and emigration maintained a respectable standing, and its old dislike of separation. A visit from Mr. Whitcfield in 1764, excited much consternation. This distinguished preacher had lost favor with the more rigid churches and |>a8tors. Mr. Cogswell was greatly exercised in spirit by the rumor of his coming, **not knowing how to conduct, viz: whether to desire hira to preach," - but, after deliberation and prayer, deterndned " to keep about his duty, viz: what would have been his duty if he had heard nothing of .his arrival." Tidings of his actual arrival and entertainment at Colonel Dyer's failed to change the decision of the timid divine, whose natural politeness and curiosity were quite overborne by fear of ministerial censure, but at the request of a nund)cr of his people he ventured to call upon the great preacher and held considerable discourse, which he thus recorded in his diary : -
*' lie professed much unconcerned ncss nt ye thoucht of death. He appeared a isrcat enemy to Sandcmnn. He wa« gross in body but poor In health and declined preaching; wisli I may be so weaned from tlie world and ready to die as he profussed to be; can't think, however, there is the greatest propriety in being fond of speaicing in hucIi a nnunier to ntran^ers.
Fel>. 14, Mr. Whitcfield came along; people seemed very fond of gazing on him. He rode In his chariot with a gentleman - had a waiter to attend on Idm, and Sampson Occam, ye Indian preacher, who rode on one of the horses, there being three to yu chariot. [Heverends] MesHrs. Breck and Whitney came and dined here. Mr. Hrcck said he did not know but I was ri^^ht in asking Mr. Whitettcld to preach ; however he believed he should not have done it."
If Mr. Breck of Spinngfield, always inclined to Artninianism and hetero<loxy, could thus scruple, it may be seen that the cautious pastor did indeed run some risk in extending civilities to the great pulpit orator.
Mr. Cogt^well's dinry gives us a parting glimpse of another oncefamed preacher and religious leader - his old antagonist, Elisha Paine, revisiting Canterbury atler many years absence: -
** March 26, 1769. Lawyer Paino sent for mo in the cvcniD«f, said that he wanted to sec me but did not desire I should tarry lecture, us Stephen Backus told luc; however, when I came there the old gentleman said he had nothing special to sny, and that ho only sent word that he was going to preach, and began lecture soon. But I thought I would not go away immediately - was not sorry I tarried as i have not heard a Separate teacher in a great while, lie is much more moderate than ftirmerly and indeed is a dull preacher; some part of his discourse was good but he preached many things erroneous as I thought, as that all religion which was established by civil authority was false; .... that all Christians have assunince, and those who think they have not are to be suspected of knowing nothing of Christ's beauty experimentally. That though men should live peaceably together yet it was a vain and wicked attempt to reconcile converted and unconverted men for they would always have implacable cneiniiy ; and tho' they should agree ever so well on an outward plan of church government which he called a hiarchee, meaning as I suppose an Hierarchy, it would be of no service unless men were converted - and several otlier exceptional things.
27th. Mr. lvalue visited me. Discoursed In a friendly manner. I mentioned to hiai his niedilling with Connecticut Kstabllshmeut in his sermon; he said he did not mean so umch Connecticut E.^tablishment as all Establishments. I mentioned his notion of saving faith consisting in assurance. He in etfect gave up the point, for he said lie believed many were good Christians who had not assurance but did not own he was wrong. He discoursed against several practices. - Presl)yterian ordination, ministers being supported by a salary, &c., but with a pleasant countenance and to appearance with a temper much less bitter and severe timn when he lived in town - but 1 believe he holds much the same doctrines."*
The Si'parate church once so flourishing had suffered many losses. The venerable Obadiali Johnson, one of the early settlers of the town, and a pillar of this church, died in 1765. Mary, wife of William Bradford and sister of John and Ebenezer Cleveland, - *'an ornament to her sex and indeed to till her Christian frietids," - died the satne year upou the birth of her fourteenth child, *' in a perfect calm resignation to the will of God and assurance of faith.'* Her father, Josiah Cleveland, dying some years previous had shown his love to this '^Congregational church in Canterbury " (as its members called it), by bequeathing to it his whole part of the meeting-house, and £200 in bills of credit. Deacon Johnson left "the improvement of a farm and buildings for the benefit of said church as for the poor of said church," and also twenty acres to supply firewood for the minister. But money
* The remaining years of the great Separate leader were spent in peaccfhl seclusion, preaching to his l>eh»ved floclc at Brlilgeluimpton, L. I., until within two weeks of his decease, which occurred Aug. 2G, 177u, at the age of eighty-four.
an<l land could not make up the loss in membership. Emigration and disaffection had carried away many. The vote by which they had gained society privileges and exemption from ratepaying, gave great offence to many ardent brethren, and after many stringent letters from Ebenezer Frothingham of Middletown, the church decided to i*oconsider the matter ; renewed their covenant one by one - during which God drew near and united their hearts in the love of the gospel - and appointed a committee, who reported : -
"May 21, 1760. 1. The Separate voting or acting with the society was wrong, as that civil budy acted in a matter of conscience, or in an ecclesiastic affiilr."
The church assented to this " as their minds, and wliat they meant to abide by, and acknowledged their fault in so far as any of them had been active in those things." Its relations with its pastor were next brought under consideration. This good brotlier was ardent and zealous to a fault, and offended many of his people by bluntness of speech and lack of discretion. Afler long labor and agitation a council was held, May 29, 1768, which decided " that brother Joseph Mai-shall be dismissed from the pastoral care of this church, on account of the contentions in church respecting his gifts and ordination, which renders his improvement unprofitable." Mr. Marshall then followed some members of his flock to the new settlements in Western Connecticut, New York and Vermont, where his labors were greatly blessed. The Canterbury Separate church did not succeed in settling another minister and steadily declined in numbers. Some of its members sigiiitied their desire to attend worship with the First society, provided they might pay their part of the expenses by way of contributing and not by rate, whereupon that body voted, " That we are willing and desirous that they should attend public worship with us, and will never levy any tax or assessment upon them contrary to their minds, but will leave it with them to give what, and in what manner, they please " The increase of Baptist sentiments was very annoying to the Separates as well as the standing order. Mr. Cogswell heard with great grief " that several of his people and many of the Separates had attended at Mr. Backus's to hear Ebenezer Lyon, the Baptist teacher," and hoped that God would "convince them of their folly." Not.withstanding this opposition, " Lyon, the Baptist," continued his irregular services for many years, edifying a small number of hearers. These Baptists with the Canterbury Separates held to what was called '* mixed communion," and oflen joined in worship and ordinances with Separate churches.
Stephen Frost, sons of Samuel Butts, and other influential families were among these residents, and in the spring of 1767, petitioned for society privileges. A measure and survey were ordered and divisional line run. The society accepted the report and voted to divide into distinct ecclesiastic societies by a north and south line at the centre of the parish parallel with the line between Windham and Canterbury - lino to leave 11,786 acres on each side; rate on east side £5,759; west side £4,251. With this vote the western inhabitants, viz: -
Stephen Frotit, lloberl and John Herrick, Solomon Adams, Ebcnezcr Deane, Ezra and Amos Woodward, Ebenczcr Gooden, Stephen Downing, Benjamin and Nathaniel Clcvclnnd, Samuel Parish, Matthias Button, Benjamin and Jolin Durfue, David Munro, Solomon Allen, Stephen Ftird, Jun., Joseph Burgess, Jotdah, Joseph and Sherebiah Butts, Joseph Leach, John Curtis, William Foster. Benjamin Jewett, David Canada, Eliphalet and Zebulon Farnham, William Hebard. Frederic Carter, John Lewis, Jonas Bondappeared before the Assembly, and secured a committee which reported in favor of division. A favorable decision was confidently expected when to the consternation of the petitioners opposition was manifested. Notwithstanding previous declarations and agreements, fifty remonstrants headed by £lijab Dyer, Jabez Fitch and John Bacon now represented : -
'< That the vote to divide was hastily passed; that the Inhabitants principally settled in the east; tliat a number or inliabitunts setlled uflerwards in the west, and, not considering that the contemplated division would inevitably ruin said society, voted it by a bare majority; list of whole, only nine thousand, exclusive of separate society; give a minister now but seventy pounds a year which by no means supports him, and we are very much put to collect that now In tills distressing time; people behindhand on account of great changes and scarcity of money, and to divide In the way proposed will certolniy ruin and break up the whole."
Residents near the centre of the town, viz., Thomas Bradford, Joseph Withe, Abijah Cady, Jacob Smith, John Wheeler, Jacob Green and John Pellet also remonstrated, declaring : -
** That the society will be eight miles In length and two and a-half In width, and that we live quite ut the east part of new society, and have a griod road to the meeting-house, and If we are stated to the west society shall be as far from their meeting house. If they ever build one, as we are now, with no road to travel on, and the way so bad that It Is impossible there will ever be a good one made, and pray to be allowed to stay In the east society."
To forestall division it was now proposed that a new meeting-house should be erected in the centre of the town, but no vote could be obtained for it. In May, 1769, the western inhabitants farther represented that their number had greatly multiplied and was constantly increasing, that the society would not allow them to be set off or build a new meeting-house in the centre, and begged for relief. Their request was continued till October, and thus answered : -
** Upon memorial of Stephen Frost, Robert llerrlck, Ebenezer Goodell and others, Inhabitants of first society of town of Canterbury, situated In west pftrt of 9ai(] society, showing to this Assembly tliclr groat distance fVom the established place of public worship In said society, whereby they and their numerous families are very unable to attend the same ; also, showing to the Assembly the vote of said society signifying their consent to have the same equally divided Into distinct ecclesiastic societies by a north and south line parallel with the line dividing between the towns of Windham and Canterbury, at the centre of said first society, ascertained by a late survey made by Seth Paine, county surveyor, approved by said society - praying this Assembly to make and constitute the men situate on the west side of said north and south line a distinct ecclesiastic society acconling to the form and extent of said vote, and to be invested with all the rights and privileges to such societies appertaining (except such Inhabitants as by law are exempt from contributing to the support of the established ministry). It Is resolved by this Assembly, that the inhabitants living within the limits aforesaid (excepting as before excepted) shall be, and they are hereby made, erected and constituted a distinct eccicslastlc society, endowed with all the powers, privileges and immunities usually belonging to ecclesiastic societies In this colony, and shall be known and called by the name of Westminster. October, 17(i9.**
The organization of the new society was speedily eflTected. The reports of the first meetings have not been preserved, bitt there was evidently no lack of spirit and enthusiasm. Arrangements were soon made for bnilding a mectiiig-honse. There wjis no owinsion here for quarrelling over its site. ** Natural fitness " at once assigned it to a broad hill-summit near the centre of the society. About four acres of land at tlio crossing of the roads were given by John Parks for meeting-house spot, burial ground and common. The bushes were at once cleared off and ground made ready for building. Capt Sherebiah Butts was employed as master builder, and served so efticiently that the house was made ready for occupation dtni ng the following summer, that same busy season in which the rival edifices of Brooklyn Parish were in progress. " At a convention of professing Christians belonging to Westminster society Nov. 2, 1770," arrangements were made for church organization. The neighboring ministers - Reverends Samuel Mosely, James Cogswell, Josiah Whitney - and Capt. John Howard, Dr. Jabez Fitch, Dea. Nathaniel Brown and Col. Israel Putnatn, messengers, comprised the council. A number of brethren appeared before it, and after professing their belief in the articles of the Christian faith revealed in the Word of God, and engaging to walk together agreeably to the directions of his word, signed the following covenant and were acknowledged as a regular church of Christ : -
'* 1. We do take the Iloly Scriptures as the only ultimate rule of our Ihlth and manners, and In subordination hereto, the confession of faith called the Westminster,* which we look upon to be agreeable to the Word of God
*lt is not Improbable that the society adopted Its stately name In honor of this venerable coulcsslon which held sohigh a place In their esteem.
Within a few months John Staples of Taunton, Mass., was called to the pastorate antl onhiined Apiil 17, 1772. Stephen Frost, John ller- I'ick and Jonas Bond were cliosen to serve as deacons; many were added to Che church, and the society pursued its way in much i)ea(^ and prosperity.
Although the Fii-st society in Canterbury managed to maintain its existence afler tiie division of its territory, it did not escape many of the evils so dismally foreboded. During the preceding controversy ani mosities had been engendered, and it was found impossible to efiect a peaceable settlement. Deal. Frost, for some unas.signed reason, chose to retain the society records and papers, and also the school fund money previously entrusted to him. John Felch was now society clerk and trexisurer; Jabez Fitch, Jun., Eliashib Adams and Joseph Woodward were the committee. At a society meeting Feb. 7, 1770, Capt. Dyer was appointed ** agent, to go immediately in the name of society and demand the record books and other papei-s belonging to the society now in the hands of Dea. Stephen Frost, and in case of refusal, prosecute." Asa Bacon was also empowered ** to recover loan school nu)ney in the hands of Dea. Frost." These efforts proving unsuccessful, the society committee was instructed to sue for school money. An agent was afterwards appointed to lay the case before the Assembly. Finally, April 22, 1771, the leading men in the society, viz., John Felch, Capt. Elijah Dyer, Dea. Eliashib Adams and Captains Elkanah Cobb and Aaron Cleveland, were chosen " to treat with Westminster society al)out an amicable settlement of the dispute between said societies res]>ecting loan school money, and also to make a iinal settlement and full conclusion of all other matters of controversy subsisting between said societies res|)ecting a part of Mr. Cogswells salary for the year in which said society was divided." Through their mediation the various diiHculties were in some measure surmounted.
The most serious evil resulting from society division was the loss of Mr. Cogswell. The First society was unable to raise what he deemed needful for his support, or even to pay arrearages in full, and consented ** to his quiet and peaceable dismission." The church, *^ taking into consideration our difficult circumstances, with much reluctance c(msent that our pastor be dismissed ; testify our sincerest regards and part with him not because we are dissatisfied with htm as to anything relating to his ministerial conduct, but think it may be for the good and peace of the society, and most cordially reconnnend him." Mr. Cogswell preached for a short time at East Haddam, where his good friend and adherent, Deacon Sanmel Huntington, had lately removed, and then returned to Scotland Parish. The Canterbury church remained for many years without a settled pastor to its great detriment. Mathaniel
Niles of Norwich, prcftchcil for a seHSoii but declincfl a call to settlement. Samuel Spring, Job Swift and £|)liraim Jiidson also served as supplies during this unsettled period. Eliashib Adams succeeded to the deacon's office on the removal of Dea. Huntington in 1769. Jabez Fitch, Jun., was elected deacon two years later. William Bingham, "William Darbe and Benjamin Bacon were made choristers. Though destitute of a settled pastor, public worship was maintained with considerable regularity. Jab<>z Filch, Esq., Timothy Baldwin, Jabez Ensworth, John Ikcon and Elijah Dyer looked after the proper seating of the meetinghouse, and ordered needful repairs, and '* if swept twelve times a year '* paid twenty shillings for it. Tixhall Ensworth held the responsible position of key -keeper. In 1773 the resources of the society were somewhat enlarged by the annexation of Black IlilK the lands in possession of Timothy Backus, Isaac Allerton, W^illiam Underwood, Joab Johnson, Curtis and Ezekiel Spalding, Jabez Fitch, Jun., William ]3inghani, John Hough, Elkanah Cobb and Obadiah Johnson being joined by act of Assembly *' with the First Society of Canterbury for society and ecclesiastic privileges, but not for schooling, military and other purposes."
Schools in Canterbury up to this date were receiving little attention, and the old system of ** squadrons *' was still maintained. In 1770, Ezekiel Park, Captain Elijah Dyer, Nathan Waldo, Joseph Clark, Joseph Woodward, Asa and Joseph Stevens were ordere<l, " To take care of the schools in their respective squadrons, and to hire suitable persons to keep the schools." A division into twenty-three districts was soon after effected and the number of schools increased. Private schools were often supported in different neighborhoods. A " night school " was kept at one time by Joseph Carter in *' the school-house nighent to Westminster meeting-house." After his mercantile ex|>eriment in Pomfret this young man returned to Canterbury, keeping store or school as occasion offered, and, like a true-born Yankee, turning his hand to anything. Succeeding in time to the oflice of deputy-sheriff, he combine<l with it a carrying trade, conveying letters and packages back and forth with his prisoners, and serving his neighbors with household supplies as well as warrants. With all rhis Yankee facility one duty came hard to him. He did not mind applying the lash to the bare back of a male culprit, but he hated to whip a womany and unfortunately for him the innnber of female offendei-s was very large. Stealing, vagi-aficy and worse offences brought many a hapless victim to the public whipping-post. The compassionate sympathy of the tenderhearted sheriff led him on one occasion to employ a substitute, but the neophyte in his zeal for justice inflicted the blows with so much more Bphit and cogency that he was fain to submit thercailcr to do his own whipping. One petty pilferer escaped with a lighter ])uni8hnient. A very respectable citizen living north of the Green was led to sns|>ect that one of his neighbors was helping himself to his hay, and keeping a sharp look-ont at last espied the oflfender creeping up to his barn one evening and coming out with a large bun<lle tied up with a rope. The good man might have roused the neighborhood with a hue-and-cry, but with sudden impulse he hurried into his house, snatched a blazing fire-brand, and managed unseen to overtake the thief, and thrust the brand into the bundle. Crackliikg Hames suddenly bursting over his head terrified the poor fellow almost out of his senses, and thinking that the Lord had sent fire from Heaven to consume him, he dropped the blazing hay and ran home as fast as his trembling limbs could carry him. The next day he sought his neighbor in great distress and peni< tence, confessing all his misdeeds and the punishment that the Lord had sent upon him, and promising never to do the like again. This promise it is believed was faithfully kept, and the story was never told till after the decease of the penitent offender.
John Felch usually served as town clerk during this period. John Bacon, Jan., was graduated from the College of New Jersey in 1765, and after essaying ministerial settlement in various fields removed to Stockbridge, Mass., and dislinguished himself in Becular service. Anron, youngest son of Josiah Cleveland, Elijah, son of Colonel Dyer, John, son of John Adams, were among Canterbury's rising young men at this date. Obadiah Johnson was colonel of the regiment which comprised the militia of Plainfield and Canterbury. Mr. Cogswell reports a public library founded by the citizens in 1771.
Life. Scotland Parish
WINDHAM as head and shire town of the county was now exceedingly prosperous and prominent, surpiissing, acconling to cotemporary ju<lgment, " every iidand town in the Colony in trade and merchandize." It had four well-trained military companies, four meetinghouses, a court-house, prison and jail, numberless stores and t:iverns, and many handsome private residences. The ofKcors retpiisite for the proper management of public affairs in 17G0 were five selectmen, five constables and rate coUectora, seven grand- jurors, ten tithing-men, seven listers, twenty-three surveyorH, four bnindiM'H and toilers, thn^e pound keepers, three packers, one weight-sealer, one measure-sealer.
two to lake care of provisions paid for colony tax, one excise collector, two surveyora and packers of tobacco.* The Rev. Stephen White remained in pastoral charge of the First Church and society. Samuel Gray served efficiently as town clerk. Nathaniel Wales, with his son Nathaniel, filled many public offices to great acceptance. £li))halet Dyer and Jedidiah Elderkin were actively engaged in the practice of law, and ranked among the prominent public men of Connecticut The excellent Jonathan Huntington retained his eminence and popularity as a medicnl practitioner, and while exhibiting ** marvelous skill '* in the art of healing, served ns judge of the County Court and member of the Governor's council. His cotemporary in years, Dr. Ebi'uezer Gray of Boston, probably brother to Samuel Gray, Esquire, also "practiced physick" in Windham and its vicinity. Dr. Joshua Elderkin, the somewhat erratic brother of Jedidiah, practiced medicine, engaged in trade and experimented in manufactures. In that revival of business and commercial enterprise following the close of the French war, Windham actively participated. James Flint, Ebenezer Backus and Ebcnezer Devotion, Jun., of Scotland Parish, engaged extensively in mercantile traffic, buying up domestic produce to exchange for West India goods and articles of t4iste and luxury. Under this stimulus, the products of the town were very largely incrcasod. Much attention was given to wool growing, the culture of hemp, flax and tobacco, and the making of cheese and butter. Great flocks of sheep and herds of cattle ranged over Windham pastures and commons. Wheat and other cereals were extensively grown and exported, and so biisk was trade in
*List of Officers: Dr. Joshua Elderkin, modcmtor; Snmuol Gray, town clerk (chosen first in 1755, "in room of Eliphnlct Dyer, (rone in ye army," and rettilned in ofllce more tlinn tlilrty years) ; Ctiptiiin Samuel Murdnck, Gcorj?e Marliii, Ciipt. Henry Silsby, Mr. Stunuel Webb, Lieut, rrhico Tracy, selectmen; llezckiiih Manning, Paul lli'bard, Ablcl Abbott, constnbles and collectors of town rates; Joshua Heed, Uezeklali Huntington, Nathaniel Lord, John Manning, grand-Jurymen; William Warner, Nathaniel Wales, 2d, Nathaniel Warren, John Clark, Joseph Burnham. Nalhan Luce, Joseph Manning, tlthln<;.men ; Heixjamln Lathrt>p, Jonathan Babcock, James Flint, Jonathan Bnrnap, Nathaniel Mosely, Andrew Bnrnham, Joseph Woodward, listers; Edward Brown, Ebenezer Fitch, Ebene/.er Bingham, John Bass, Isaac Andrns, Gideon Ilelmrd, Thomas Tracy, Samuel Mnrdock, Nathaniel lIuntingto>i, ])aniel Martin, Jerendah Clark, Zebadlah Cobnrn, Steplien Tark, Jerendali Utlcy, William Holt, JoHlah Hammond, Simon Wood, Joshua Farnham, John Manning, Joseph Woodward, Richard Kimball, Jonathan Luce, Joseph Ginnlngs, highway surveyors; Samuel Webb, Edward Brown, William i)urkce, Isaac Rlnge, John Webb, David Ripley, fence-viewers; Hez. Huntington, John Fuller, Ellsha Palmer, Jun., Eleazer Palmer, branders and tollers; Edward Brown, Isaac Riiige, Reuben Robinson, leather-sealers; Joseph Huntington, Joseph Sessions, Ellsha Palmer, Jan., ponnd-keepers; Joseph Huntington, Jeremiah Dnrkec, Joseph Manning, packers; Samuel Gray, town treasurer; Elijah Bingham and Thomas Tracy, to take care of the town bridge; James Flint, receiver of provision paid for discharge of colony tax; John Abbe, collector of excise; Hezekiah Manning and Shubael Palmer, surveyors and packers of tobacco.
all parte of the town thai it was proposed to petition the Assembly " for a free fair or market." When com|>cHed by English exactions to relinquish her foreign trade, Windham turned her energies to manufactures. John Brown, a highly respected and useful citizen, then occupyii^g the home farm on the Willimantic laid out to his grsindfather, C/apt. John Brown, in 1706, not only entertained travelers according to the fashion of the day, but cultivated his farm, manufactured potash and refined 8aU|>etre. Ezekiel Cary carried on his trade as a tanner and currier in this vicinity. Colonel Elderkin, among his other avocations, interested himself in silk culture ; and set out a fine orchard of mulberry trees in the south part of Wiiulham. In 1773, he wrote to Clement Biddle of Philadelphia, *' that he had a large number of trees fit for improvement, had made considerable growth of silk, spun and improved some, but failed for want of ')>roper reels and experienced workmen, aud desired a reel or caldron, and a young woman to teach them." With this aid he succeeded in making a strong, coarse silk, used for handkerchiefs and vestings.
Travel and trade, and the increased and cheapened supply of liquors, made many taverns needful. License was granted in 1760 to James Lasell, Paul llebard, Ann Warner, Elias Prink, Ebenezer Bingham, David Hipley, Jacob Simmons, Ebenezer Griilin, Stephen Fitch, Jabez Kingsley, John Parish, Samuel Silsby. Mercy Fitch of Windham Green was also allowed to reUiil strong drink to whomsoever asked for it. liicenses were granted in following years to Abner Flint, Elenzer Cary, John Howard, Nehemiah Tinker, Edward Badger and Nathaniel Linkon. These numerous taverns were all well patronized, especially during the Court sessions. Jonathan Trumbull of Jjebauon, was now judge of the County Couit ; Shubael Conant, John Dyer, Jabez Fitch and Joshua West, associates ; Samuel Gray, clerk ; Eleazer Fitch, \\i<rh shcriif ; Paul Jlebard, sheriff deputy. Due care was taken of the court houne and jail, and certain limits assigned to such as were imprisoned for debt Debtors unable to pay were made to work out their debts in various service. In 1762, the prison-yard was repoited in a decaying state, and the sheriff ordered to take the same down. Twelve yeara later, assistants and justices met at the court house *' to take into consideration the state of the county jail." A large number of prominent men from all the towns were present It was judged that repairs were needful, and a farthing tax ordered upon polls and ratable estates. Sanuiel Gray, Nathaniel Wales and Capt James Stedman were ai>- pointed to make repairs. A collector was appointed for each town, \iz. : Jabez Huntington, Windham; Samuel Eaton, Ash ford ; Nathaniel Marcy, Woodstock; John Hough, Canterbury; Seth Grosvcnor, Pom-
Windham's alertness in promoting home interests was surpassed, if possible, by her activity in all public affairs. Her citizens were fully imbued with the spirit of those stirring times, and were ready not only to participate but to lead on '* all emergent occasions." The grand colonization scheme, so happily inaugurated within her borders, still enlisted her warmest sympathies, and after the return of peace, renewed effoits were made to cjirry it into execution. After a lapse of five years, the Susquehanna company resumed active opemtious. At a meeting in Hartford, March 12, 1760, Col. Tolcott was chosen moderator ; Samuel Gray, clerk. It was recommended that the committee previously appointed, "with all expedition carry into execution the several betrustments reposed in them ;'* also, that this committee should join with the committee of the Delaware Purchase in sending home to England. In the following year, it was voted to send an agent for both companies, and add two hundred more shares to pay expenses. Eliphalet Dyer was chosen as this agent with a salary of £150. The object of this mission was to procure confirmation of the Wyoming territory from the Crown. Jonatlian Trambull, Ilozekiah JIuntiiigton, David Edwards, Samuel Gray, Jedidiah Elderkin and George Wyliis were appointed to collect materials and make all necessary preparations to help said agent A committee waS also empowered to treat with Indian Chiefs, and liberty given to settle two townships. This liberty was improved by several Connecticut families, who effected a settlement in the Wyoming valley in 1762-3, but were soon attacked and butchered by the hostile savages. The Promised Land was not to be possessed without an arduous conflict. The government of Pennsylvania, holding the territory by formal treaty and purchase, scouted the claim of Connecticut and prepared to resist her every effort at settlement. Powerful Indian tribes contesting the land were also arrayed against her. Dyer's mission though urged with great eloquence and persist^Micy was unsuccessful. The King forbade the settlement of the disputed territory. Both companies were summoned to Windham Court-house, Jan. 16, 1765, to hear the report of their agent, returned from Great Britain with many things of importance to commtinicate. Jabez Fitch, John Cuitis, Isaac and Elisha Tracy and Ebenezer Backus served as committee for the Delaware company; Eliphalet Dyer, Jedidiah Elderkin and Samuel Gray, for the Susquehanna. Undeterred by rebuff and threatened opposition, the latter company continued its efforts, lieuewed attempts were made to gain the sanction of Connecticut. Colonel Dyer in particular so warmly pleaded its cause, and so
But though greatly favoring the colonization scheme, and most anxious to establish its claim to all the land prescribed by its Charter the government of Connecticut was too wise and wnry to expose itself to collision with Pennsylvania, and discreetly withheld its formal endorsement of the enterprise. The Susquehanna company was, however, too powerful an organization and too strongly entrenched in popular favor, to be repressed by lack of ofHciul aid or recognition. At a meeting in Hartford, 1768, it was voted, that five townships, five miles square, should be suiTcyed and granted each to forty settlers, being proprietors, on condition that these settlers should remain upon the ground and defend themselves and each other from the intrusion of all rival claimants. As farther encouragement - the sum of two hundred pounds was appropriated to provide implements of husbandry and provisions. Great as was the risk many were ready to meet it. The chance of gaining a home in the bc.iutiful valley, was worth a contest, and indeed to some who had shared in the exciting service of the French war, the prospect of a brush with the "Pennymites" may have furnished an additional incentive. Early in 1769, forty adventurous Yankees de8cende<l upon VVyoming. Kiuemost among them were old French war campaigners, Captain Zebulon Butler of Lyme, and Captain John Durkee of Windham, now removed to Norwich. Thomas Dyer, Vine Elderkin, Nathaniel Wales, Nathan Denison of Windham, and Timothy Pierce of Plainfield, were among this heroic ** forty." They found the *' Penny mites " already in possession, and after a sharp and spirited contest were obliged to quit the field, leaving Durkee and other lead mg men in the hands of the enemy. Colonel Dyer and Major Elderkin were equally unsuccessful in attempting to negotiate an amicable settlement with the Proprietary Government of Pennsylvania. Ebenezer Backus, Captains Joseph Eaton and Robert Durkee acted with gentlemen from other parts of the Colony in raising funds for the relief and support of the prisoners. In 1770, a still larger force of Yankees returned to the charge and after a yet more serious contest was ^so compelled to retire with loss of life and great destruction of property. After taking and losing Fort Durkee in the course of the following winter, the Yankees opened the siege in the spring of 1771, with fresh forces and leaders, resolved to carry on the war to the last extremity. The ** Peunyinites ** met them with their nsual spirit and gallantry, though greatly crippled in resources. The Proprietjiry Government, unpopular at home and unsupported by Great Britain, was unable to meet the demand, and declined to continue so costly and fruitless a struggle. After gallantly defending Fort Durkoe for several months, Captain Ogden was forced to accept articles of capitulation, and> with all the Pennsylvania troops withdrew from Wyoming, leaving the rejoicing Yankees in possession of the land so valiantly contested.
Organization was now speedily effected. The towns already laid out were divided into farms and distributed. Those who had fought for the prise were rewarded by bountiful homesteads, and many other families from all parts of Connecticut eagerly sought a share. Windham County, so active in proposing and promoting the settlement of the Susqnehaima valley, was equally ready to take possession, and scores of valuable families removed thither in the course of a few years. Stephen Fuller, John and Stephen Abbott, John Carey, Blisha Babcock, Robert Durkee of Windham; Simon Spalding, Ezekiel Pierce, John Perkins of Plainfield ; Capt4iiu Samuel Hansom, Captain James Bidlack and Elisha Williams of Canterbury ; George and John Dorranc^ llobert Jameson, Cyrus Kinno of Voluntown ; Anderson Dana, Joseph Biles, Stephen Whiton of Ashford, were among the many who emigrated to Wyoming valley. Many of these were men in the prime of life with large families, accustomed to the management of public affairs, and eminently fitted to aid in laying the foundation of social order, and moulding the new State after the j>att<»ni of Coimecticut. The fertility of the soil, the mildness of the climate, the beauty of the country and the abundaiuje of its resources far exceeded expectations, an<l such glowing reports came back to the rocky farms of Windham County, that emigration raged for a time like an epidemic and seemed likely to sweep away a great part of the population.
The burthen of bridge-making, always heavy in Windham, was b6 augmented by the increase of travel consequent to the great emigration to Wyoming and other new countries, as to be quite insu|)portable. An ** extraordinary flocid " and great nccuinulation of ice in 1771, demolished and carried away nearly every bridge in Windham County, making a clean sweep of (he Nnchaug, Williniantic and Shetncket. As these briilges were upon public highways, "abundantly used "by great numbers of families with cattle and teams from PlainBeld, Voluntown and the south part of Rhode Island, " traveling to the west part of Mass.tchnsetts Bay, New Hampshire an<i north part of New York," the aulhorities of Windham refused to reconstruct them without aid from other quarters. Several roads were thus rendered impassable, travelers were forced to travel many miles out of their way to Hud suit* able fording-places, and then were flung from their hoi-scs and exposed to drowning. Complaints were laid before the General Assembly that Windham refused to rebuild her bridges, or do anything about the same, so that peo|>le were likely to be subjected to great hardships. Dyer, Elderkin and Nathaniel Wales, Jun., were deputized by the town to represent " that these bridges were on the edge of the town ; that Jive large bridges had been built within a few years at the eac|>ense of £800 ; all carried off by extraordinary floods which seemed to be much increasing ; that this expense was heavy and intolerable, as several of these biidges were more to accommodate other towns and the public, and beg relief." Their i*eqnest was refused and a bill passed, " That Windham should build and maintain a good and suflioient caitbridge over each of said rivers at the places designated by |>etitioners, viz., one over the Shetueket, on the road from Windham to Hartford, known as Old Town Bridge, and one over the Willimantic, called the Iron Works Bridge. Mansfield was directed to rebridge the Nachaug. In 1774, the town of Windham was ordered to build and maintain a bridge across the Shetu(iket upon a road lately laid out to New KIam|>- shire, to accommodate tlio travel to the new colloge in Ihuiover. The selectmen of Windham were now required, **To provide suitable houses for the poor, and persons to take care of them, rates for the same to be paid in provisions."
Social life in Windham was still characterized by exuberant hilarity. ^'Jaunting and junketing," feasting and merry-making were more and more in vogue. A very fi*ee and generous style of living had been adopted by the upper circle, rivaling that of the leading families in the larger towns. Windham's relations with Norwich were es|)ecially dose and cordial, and were marked by continual interchange of hospitalities and festivities. Entertainment was made easy by the great number of negroes. Nearly every household owned its servants, generally a man and wife, with a great brood of children. They were a careless, happy set, fond of joking and fiddling, and added much to the general jollity. Colonel Dyer's body-servant Jack, the son of an African prince, was chief among these negroes. He accompanied his master upon many public missions, and was distinguished for gentlemanly demeimor. Colonel Dyer had a houseful of negroes, great and small, and entertained much company in fine style. Pictures and rarities brought from abroad adorned his handsome residence. A very prominent and popular household at this time was that of Colonel Eleazer Fitch, son of Joseph Fitch of Lebanon. Remarkably distinguished in pei-son, being six feet four inches in height, and three hundred pounds in weight, and called " the best-looking officer in the American army," he was still more noted for social attractions and elegant accomplishments. Inheriting an ample estate, he had enjoyed superior educational and social advantages, and was especially distinguished for musical taste and acquirements, and appreciation of art and literature. Entering early into public life he had served as an officer in the French war, aided in negotiating the Delaware purchase, and secured the position of high sheriff of Windham County. His stiitely mansion, built in 1769 on Zion's Hill, was one of the most tasteful residences in Eastern Connecticut Here many daughtei*s wore growing up and taking their place in society, distinguished like their father by beauty, gi'jice and musical culture. The daughters of Mr. James Flint were ranked among the Windham belles of this date.
In schools Windham was still deficient. The grammar school enjoined by law upon towns of her standing and population was not maintained with any degree of efficiency. Those brilliant young la<lies were indebted for their training to "a dame's school " on the Green, and a few months "finishing" in Hartford or New London. Moses Cook Welch of Mansfield, opened a grammar school on Windham Green after his gra<luation from Yale in 1772, but soon relinquished it to study law wilh (colonel J>yer. The yotnig men of the wealthier families were usually sent to college after preparatory study with Mr. W^hite, or Dr. Wheelock in Lebanon. Windham was deeply interested in the various educational movements initiated by the latter. Ono of his early Windham neighbors and playmates, Joshua More, gave a house and land in Mansfield to be appropriate<l to the training up of Indian youth for ministerial and missionary service, and a good Windham lady left a legacy in behalf of this Christian enterprise. Windham made earnest but unsuccessful effoits to retain this school. Her ministers, llev. Messrs. White and Mosely, were members of the convention for considering it« removal, and Windham students accompanied President Wheelock on his nn'gration to the wilderness, and were among the first graduates of Dartmouth College. Samuel Gray, Jun., was graduated (vith the first class in 1771, and Augustine Hebard the following year. The Ijitter soon went out to Canada on a mission to the Indians. Hezekiah Bissell, Joseph Huntington, Vine Elderkin, Ebenezer (4ray, Hezekiah Hipley and Shubael Abbe were also gradu* ated from Yale College during this period. Most of these young men remained in Windham, filling the places left vacant by death and emigiation. Dr. Ebenezer Gray died in 1773; Dr. Jonathan Huntington in 1777. After a life marked by "piety to God and benevolence to mankind,'* this distinguished and beloved physician endured the most intense sufferings without a murmur or comphiint, exhibiting to its close
''a Striking picture of that fortitude and patience which Christianity alone win inspire." They were succeeded in practice by Dr. Samuel Lee of Goshuii, a young man of ^* herculean strength and agility " and ardent patriotism, who had enjoyed the professional training of Dr. Ezekiel Porter of VVethersfield.
Windham's First Church was less prosperous than in previous periods. Its numbers wore lessening, and its stated worship was losing its hold upon the public mind. The mild and gentle character of Mr. White's preaching and intlnence was little fitted to cope with increasing worldliness and many opposing elements. Deacon Nathaniel Skift* died in 1761. Nathaniel Wales, Sen., and Joseph fluntington still served in the deacon's office. Jonathan Martin and Elijah Bingham were chosen junior deacons in 1765. The numerous ** sectaries" continued their opposition to the standing order. Those in the first society had now become very much imbued with Baptist sentiments. ]\Ir. Benjamin Lathrop, a worthy and respected citizen, obtained ^S>rdination in that line," and had a small number of followers to whom he administered religious ordinances, but had no Bxcil place of worship. Elijah Bibbins served as its deacon.
Scotland Parish shared in the secular prosperity of the town. Rev. Ebenezer Devotion wais held in high reputation throughout the colony as ''a great divine, a pious man, an able politician, eminent for every kind of merit." So great was tlie public contidonce in his judgment and wisdom that alter the passage of the Stamp Act he was sent by Windham to represent her in the General Assembly, as the man most competent to advise in that great ciisis, "a very singular instance," according to President Stiles. While strongly favoring the popular side in politics, and encouraging his fellow-citizens in their resistance to arbitrary enactments, he never forgot the respect due to constituted authorities, nor omitted his public prayer for the King and Itoyal Family. Still less did he waver in his hostility to religious sectaries or favor any dissent from the ecclesiastic constitution of Connecticut, or fail to send his negio every Sabbath morning with a written order for liev. John Palmer, forbidding him to preach within his territorial limits. Although this Separate Brunswick Church had been for many years organizuil, and uiHintained its regular worship, its meml>ei*s were still forced to pay rates for Mr. Devotion, or sulfur the loss of cattle and go(Mls, or imprisonment in Windham jail. In 1765, Deacon Edward Waldo made confession for unlawful separation, and was restored to his former standing in the First Church. Deacons Cary and Kingsley continued many years in active service. Mr. Devotion died while yet iu the prime of life to the great grief of ehurch and community. An elaborate epitaph on the monument iu Scotland's burying-ground testified to the high character and reputation of the deceased pastor, and is pronounced by most competent authority* "not beyond the truth:" -
" To the memory of the great and good man - the Rev. Ebenezer Devotion, flrat Pastor of the Congregational church In Wludhani. He was born In Suffleld, May 8, 1714, ordained, Oct. 22, 1785, and died July, 1771. Descended from* venerable ancestors, he Increased the honor of the family. His genius was universal, which being cultivated with diligence rendered him eminent in the various branches of science and most peculiarly as a Politician and Divine. He was an example of benevolence, gravity, foriltude, sobriety, cheerfulness, prudence und liospltality ; an unshaken friend, a kind husband, a tender parent, a sincere Christitin, a wise and fnithful minister of Christ. Greatly esteemed by all good judges ot his accxualntance and beloved by his flock.
Mr. Devotion was Buccceded in the pastoral office by llcv. James Cogswell, then recently dismissed from Canterbury, who received a unanimous call from church and society, with the oiFcr of £00 settlement, £S0 salary, and " the liberty of getting his firewood on the lot the society had of James Manning." Notwithstanding many doubts and (pialins as to his ability to till the placet of so distinguished a personage, Mr. Cogswell personally appeared and accepted, and with the countenance and aid of his most valued ministerial brelhren, was happily installed Feb. 19, 1772. The Keverends Throop, White, Whitney, Ripley and Ijcc were present, together with Joseph Huntington, a son of the Scotland church, John Devotion, brother of the former pastor, and an honored deacon or leading brother from each church represented in the council. Ebenezer Devotion, Experience Robinson, Nathaniel llebard, Jeremiah Ringham, Joseph Ginnings and James Gager served as providing connnittee. With far less strength and decision of character than his predecessor, Mr. Cogswell was probably not his inferior in culture, or in pulpit ministrations, and his kindliness of temper and gonial manners soon won popular favor. Scarcely had he removed to Scotland when he was called to severe afUiction, in the loss of his wife, Mrs. Alice Fitch Cogswell, and their only daughter, Alice, who, in the twenty-third year of her age, May 11, 1772, "departed this vain transitory life in firm hope of a glorious immortality.*' Her funeral sermon was preached by Rev. Mr. Harl^ who touchingly bemoaned this only daughter of her dear mother now no more, who had grown up from infancy with great promise, making most uncommon progress in the useful as well as ornamental parts of female learning. Following the example of many of his ministerial associates Mr. Cogswell in dne time married the widow of his predecessor - IMrs. Martha Lathrnp Devotion - and occnpicil her pleas;mt homestead. Her children were now mostly settled in life. Ebenezer, the only son, had married a danghter of Dr. Jonathan Huntington, engaged in trade and held many public otlices. One danghter was married to Samuel Huntington of Norwich, another to Hev. Joseph Huntington, and a third to John M. Breed of Norwiiih. Two bright young daughtera still cheered the family mansion. The linconnnon social accomplishments of Mr. Cogswell and his three promising sons made them a welcome acquisition to this large family circle, and the Scotland parsonage with it« agreeable inmates and throngs of distinguished visitants became one of the most attractive of Windham s many famous social centres.
With a new minister, Scotland aspired to a new meeting-bouse. After having been compelled " to mend tlie glass when much broken, by Uiking from other windows and boarding them up where least useful" - it was voted, Nov. 9, 1772, to build a meeting-house for the public worship of God, and tliere were ninety-eight yeas and twenty nays. Elisha Lillie, Captain Joseph Ginnings, Seth Palmer, Experience and lieuben Uobinson, wore chosen ** to draw a plan of bigness of meeting-liouse.*' It was agreed to give Mr. Elisha Lillie £7'^0, for building the house, walls clapboarded with rived pine clapboards, and colored with a decent color; but it was not till June, 1774, that a committee was chosen to procure the necessary rigging and help, together with suitable provisions for raising the frame. The opposition of the Separates was one cause of this delay. Finding that they were about to be taxed heavily for this new house of woi*£h]p, they appealed to the General Assembly, showing : -
** That iu 1749, bcHcving in good conscience tliat tlic principles an<1 articles and some of tlic doctrines adliered to by tliu Scotland cliurcti and people, were not agreeable to the gospel, and as they or most of them hoped they were enlightened by the light of God's countenance, and found by repeated trials that they could not prodt by the ministrations of Mr. Devotion, and lu 1749, confeditrated together separate from said minister and people, and set up a religious worship according to the dictates of their own consciences, and called Mr. John Palmer as elder or teacher, who was ordained over them and has continued preaching the gospel and administering the sacraments to your memorialists, and they have freely contributed to his support, and built a comfortable house to accommodate those who join with ihem in divine service, and all this time have been forced to pay for the support of Mr. Devotion and Mr. Cogswell, aud repairing the meeting-house, and other society charges, although they have earnestly requested relief in vain, - wherein they beg you to consider if it is agreeable to the laws of Christ or consonant to the rules of equity for your memorialists and their children, to have their eflects by force of law taken from ihem to support a minister with whom they never did nor can join iu worsliip, aud support their own
This reasonable request obtained a favorable hearing, and Brunswick church was at last released from its heavy burden. The standing society was greatly aggrieved at this curtailment of their powers and privileges, and bitterly bemoaned this " act of Assembly, taking a number of inhabitants, and discharging them from paying taxes." At a society meeting called to consider how to make up the deficit, it was voted to lay a tax for that purpose. " All inhabitants over ten years old** were ordered to be listed, and a rate of twelve-pence of the pound found needful. The school house seeming likely to endanger the meeting-house by (ire, was moved a suitable distance. Pews were built as ordered, and the meeting-house seated by a competent committee in December, 1778, and in the succeeding May, it was formally accepted "as built by Elisha Lillie." The old house then " put upon sail," brought back seventeen pounds.
Mosely. Voluntown
CANADA Parish continued to increase and prosper though subjected to the usual secular and ministerial controversies. The venerable Deacon Thomas Stedman generally presided at society meetings ; Stephen Durkee served as clerk ; Captain John Howard of Howard's Valley, David Fuller and Joseph Biirnham as society committee ; Jeremiah Durkee and Jacob Simmons, collectors ; Ichabod Downing, Capt. William Durkee and Lieut. Jonathan Kingsbury, school committee. Ten pounds were added in 1762 to the salary of llev. Samuel Moeely. The congregation and community were much disturbed at this date by a difficulty in seating the new and elegant meeting-house. The persons entrusted with this delicate office had not exercised duo judgment Not only did they seat six grown pei-sons in one pew - and persons grown in this goodly neighborhood attained capacious dimensions - ^bnt they allowed " men of little or no estate to sit very forward and in lugh )>ews/' while others of good estate and high in pnblio esteem were compelled witli shame to take a lower seat. Galleries and body-seats were left very thin compared to these coveted pews, and the gsdleries were so given over to light-minded yonth that the tithing-men were obliged to leave their seats below to keep them in order. This sUite of things created much talk and uncjisiness especially among the foremost men, that they should be so crowded and misplaced in order to get men into the pews that never paid enough for the meeting-house to build one pew, and after enduring thi.s grievance several yeara a meeting was called, Dec 9, 1762, to rectify it William Bennett was chosen moderator, and it was voted by a great majority, "To sell the pews at public vendue, no man to buy no more than one, and no nian out of the society to buy one ; Capt. Robert Durkee to serve as vendue m.ister.*' This action greatly increased the public excitement. The older members of the society wei*e at once aroused to the inexpediency and danger of allowing private individuals to select their own seats in the house of worship, and become proprietors of a part of the sacred edifice. In spite of remonstrance and opposition the vote was carried out, and the valiant Captain who had served so bravely in the French and Indian war, now sold the pews in the face of the opposing enemy. Twenty-five pews on the floor of the house were assigned to the following purchaser, at prices ranging from fourteen pounds to three, viz.: Jeremiah Utley, John Fuller, llezekiah Hammond, Stephen Durkee, Timothy Pearl, Zebediah Farnham, Ebenezer llovey, Capt. John Howard, Dea. Ebenezer Griffin, Henry Durkee, Daniel Farnham, Thomas Stedman, Jun., Isaac Bennett, Jephthah Utley, William Farnham, Joseph Burnham, John Hammond, Benjamin Cheddle, Stephen Arnold, John Sessions, Jonathan Clark, Samuel Fuller, John Smith, Gideon Martin, Isaac Clark. Although many of these purchasers were the leading, solid men of the society, the clamor was not in the least abated. Some with no families, but single persons - " bachelors, who /lad never paid rates for more than one head and a horse" and some not qualified voters had presumed to bid oft* pews and gain possession of an uppermost seat in the synagogue, " whereby the society was thrown into the most unhappy contention." Another meeting was called, and Lieut. Kingsbury appointed agent, "to take advice concernhig the difticulty concerning pews," who straightway laid the case before Colonel Dyer, Major Elderkin and Major Griswold. By their advice another society meeting was held April 21, 1763, the vote for selling the pews was set aside by a large majority, and Jacob Simmons deputized to represent the aft'air to the General Assembly and secure confirmation of their proceedings. The purchasers of the pews attempted to show that the vote to sell the pews was not suddenly passed ; that no 0|>en objections were made till after the sale ; that only five of them were young men without families, and that nine societies in Windham County already held pews as pdvate property. These representations were ineffectual, and the famous pew vote of December 9, an<1 proceedings thereupon, were made null and void by Act of Assembly. The society resumed possession of its much valued pews, appointing Abiel Abbott, Joseph Marnh and Ebenexer IFovey to seat the congregation therein with the reipiisite order and formality. Sundry residents of Canterbury, vix. : Jethro Rogers, James Bidlack, Aaron Fuller an<l Zobcdiah Farnham were now admitted to society privileges in Canada. Captain William Durkee was directed ** to search after the right (if any we have) to the lot of land called the Ministerial Lot in Windham ;" the society committee " to distribute the books culled Saybrook Platform sent to the society by Government ;" and Robert Holt '' to bring and take care of the christening basin as occasion shall require."
In 1768, Captain William Durkee, Lieut. Kingsbury, Nathaniel Ford, Zebediah Farnham, Abiel Abbott, John Sessions and Joseph Burnham were a|)pointefl a committee to set out school districts, which was accompliRhed within two years. The First or Central district began very properly by ** taking in the Rev. Mr. Moaely and ranging so as to take in Mr. Joseph Sessions, and from thence west to Burnt Cedar Swamp, and then following the main stream of Cedar Swamp Brook till it comes to the road below Benjamin Burgess*, and from thence to said Mosely's." Number Two extended " from old Mr. John Perkins* to Mr. Joseph Burnham s, and all east and south of Cedar Swamp Brook." Number Three ran **from Jonathan Holt's, taking in Holt's house, and north, taking in all the inhabitants situated on the road to ' Mr. Joseph Marsh's, taking in said Marsh*s house, and from thence taking in Mr. William Al worth's and James Al worth's house, and ranging north to the easternmost extent of the society." Number Four took in ** Mr. Stephen Clark's hotise, and then south all the inhabitants west of C.Vdar Swamp, and so far as to take in Mr. Jonathan Fish's and Mr. David Canada's houses, and so south and west to the extent of the society." School-house sites were affixed by William Osgood and Seth Paine of Pomfret, and Benajah Cary of Windham, viz. : one in the nortlieast district near Deacon Griffin's house, and two in the northwest or fourth district, one nine rods south of William Holt's ; another eight rods west of John Fuller's. " Eleven months schooling by a master, to be kept in each district according to its list," was thought sufficient for the whole society in the winter, and school-dames were engaged for the little ones in the summer. Upon the humble petition of Joseph Durkee, Jonathan and David Fish, Benjamin Flint, Edward and Samuel Coburn, Jonathan Holt, William Neif and Joseph Utley, a fifth district was set off in 1774, in the northeast section, known as Appaquage.
Elforts were now made to secure greater local privileges. Connection with Windham was in many respects burdensome and inconvenient. The distance was great, and town and parish had few interests in common. In 1767 it was voted, "That this society is desirous to be made into a district, to be allowed all the powers and privileges of a town, except choosing our own dt^puties and other business of freemen's meeting." Jacob Simmons, Ebenezer Ilovey and Abiel Abbott were chosen to apply to the selectmen of Windham, and to endeavor to obtain consent of town, and to consult with counsel and procure necessary preparations in order to obtain our request. Captain John Howard was also empowered to aid them in preparing a petition. This proving fniitless in the following year it was further voted, '^ That this society is desirous to be made into an entire and distinct town, and will apply to the General Assembly.*' Captain Jonathan Kingsbury was ap- ]>ointed ngent in their behalf, but his pleas though re|>eatedly urged were unsucci*ssful.
In 1 7G8 the society voted to repair and new color the meeting-house. Captain Kingsbury, Abiel Abbott and Thomas Fuller were appointed a committee to color said meeting-house as aforesaid, and - in order to be in the highest stylo of fashion - they were farther ordered, *' To color the same something like the color of Pomfret meeting house." Captain John Howard was added to this committee in 1771, in place of Capt. Kingsbury, deceased.
The prosperity of Canada Parish was somewhat checked during these years, by a very unpleasant controversy with Mr. Mosely. Possessing a strong will and very positive opinions, he had assumed with advancing years more and more authority over his people, and by excessive use of the negative power allowed by Saybrook Platform was able to exercise supreme control in all church affairs. A large majority of the church were opposed to Saybrook Platform, and especially the ministerial negative derived from it, but, esteeming their pastor an eminently holy and godly minister, silently acquiesced in his administration. A few of the leading men, warmly imbued with the revolutionary spirit of the times, resented this infringement of their religious rights and resolved to resist it. The original covenant of the church by which they simply took the Scriptures for their guide, allowed, they thought, too great latitude to the pastor. A more explicit covenant and plan of di8ci[)line were suggested, and also " a body of ruling eldera " to balance the power of ** the teaching elder," but as Mr. Mosely was much opposed to any innovnlion nnd would only warn church meetings at his own pleasure they found it very difficult to bring the matter before the church. They therefore requested Mr. Mosely to call a church meeting, " to learn the mind of the church about dealing with baptized persons, and about choosing some of the fathers to assist therein." At this meeting, Feb. 9, 1709, the cliurch unanimously voted, to proceed to deal with baptized, ». «., " Half-covenant " membere, but when the second article was proposed " one and another went off from it and spoke for a Platform and ruling elders," to which Mr. Mosely replied, that they were settled on the Word of God for their Platform, that with their different sentiments they should not agree on any Platform of human composure, that if agreed in the great essential things to bear down sin and promote holiness tliey nmst exercise mutual forbearance in their different sentiments about lesser matters; that he was thankful to God they were so well agreed in said important articles and thought he should sin if he indulged in debate about Platforms, - and " being nmch overcome with cold," straightway dismissed the church. Thus debarred from discussion or opportunity of further action, the indignant brethren appointed five prominent church members, viz. : William Durkee, Jonathan Kingsbury, Jonathan J3urnap, George Martin and William Foster, to remonstrate the matter with their pastor, who entreated him as a father to look into the subject, and consider the expediency of having an explicit model or Platform of church discipline deduced from Scnpture and introduced peaceably as soon as might be into their church, according to the commendable example of the best Reformed churches in Christendom. They also entreated him to satisfy them and the church they represented, by what authority, divine or human, his claim and exercise of a supreme and sole ])ower over the church of Christ met in his name was warranted. "This exertion of the teaching elder's power and authority, in opposition to almost every other church in New England, abundantly convinced them of the necessity of having other oflice bearers in the church, viz. : rtiling elders - joined in ruling and governing the church with the elder that labors in word and doctrine. The brethren of the church had usurped no authority, nor encroached in the least upon the prerogative, office or dignity of the pastor, but in a modest and peaceable manner moved to confer upon the duty and expediency of a Platform without pretending to say upon what model it should be formed; whereupon the pastor did dissolve the meeting, contrary to the duty of a moderator in all meetings civil or religious, contrary to the law of the Colony which prohibits their adjournment without consent of the majority ; much less to dissolve the meeting without such consent"
" We entreat you," contlnueil the remonstrants, " to consider whether this Alarming exortloa of authority doth not carry in it some appearance oC lording It over God's heritage, so detested hy our fathers that It drove New EiiJ?- land out of Old, to avoid a yoke that neither we nor our fathers could bear. . . . We entreat you« timely to consider, that If after such an unprecedented dissolution of the church meetln;;, you are pleased to take advanUi|;e thereof, and refuse to be entreated by us because you have disabled the church to appear by a leanl representation, and will no more warn a church meeting to treat with them upon the premises. Sir. your triumph upon a victory so gained will be short. Can yon think, sir, In this day of struggle in deffuce of civil lil)erties and rights In America, this church will tamoly hubmit to be deprived of their divine and sacred privileges, so preferable to all our inheritance besides, and give such an examplu of hlavery and dependency as to submit to such a supreme authority in the ministry over tlte church. Was the church made for ministers or ministers for the church ? Think you there are none who will appear on the Lord's side in this cane, and all other sidings we detest and hold In contempt. Are not all the constitutional clergy and churches and cloud of witnesses In New England and throughout the Heformed Protestant churches listed undt^r this banner, whose footsteps we are essaying to trace out. Would you have us stand still and be n>bbed of those sacred liberties and privileges that have flowed to the church In tlio blood of Christ, the Supreme Head thereof. Sir, the Lord forbid that wo should give ttie Inheritance of our fathers unto thee. Shall not we possess what the Lord our God hath given us to possess. Finally, sir, we entreat you to let us, and the church by us know, what we are to expect from yon for the future in this matter, and if upon cool reflection you And . . . yon have unadvisedly dissolved said church meeting, you would be pleased without loss of time upon better advisement to warn another meeting for the purpose and end aforesaid, wherein we desire you to go before us In the good work aforesaid, according to tlio duty set forth by the propliet Kzeklii. * Tliou son of man, nIicw the house to the house of Israel, and shew them the form of the house.* Windham, Feb. 20, 176D."
Mr. l^Iosely thereupon called and held a church meeting, March 8, to consider these matters, and so "teiTified" the weaker brethren by representing to them tiiat they would liave to siipport their ruling as well as teaching eldei*, and might have to settle a new minister and pay damages to the old one by insisting upon a church Platform, that a majority voted against the proposed changes. The minority thereupon drew up a paper far more inflammatory and bitter than the previous ** remonstrance," in which they alleged various S[)ecific charges against the pastor, as follows : -
<* I, The power and right you claim in negativing the church we deny, and say the key of discipline was given to the churcli by Christ . . . and ctm And no rule In Scripture for your prerogative power except you take it from Diotrephes, who loved to have preeminence . . . and the apostle saith he wrote to the church there, and that his evil example ant to be followed.
2. Your dissolving church meetings in the midst of business without the consent of the church we say Is an error, and there is no scripture warrant for such a prerogative power.
3. We think you exert unreasonable and unscrlptural power In conflning the church in their meetings to what you have put in the warning, and your taking the power of putting In what you pleased, in this you are more arbitrary than any of our civil powers . . . Sir, we do think the church ought to enjoy as great a privilege in their meetings as towns and societies do, ftir if wu may bitlicve Christ and the apostles, no men on earth have greater liberty than the church of Christ.
4. We think, Sir, tiiut you err nmch as moderator in our church meetings, for you will have the chief of the talk, and so lay your plan and scheme and t>. We think you very much err in openin<; the door so wide Into the church as to ndmit menil)ers without some satisfying account of a work of grace on tljcir hearts, nnd without the consent of the church, merely because tliey say they are a mind to come. We think, sir, it Is tlie riglit way to let Anti-Christ into the church full breast, for certain unclean persons and hypocrites have no right in Christ's church.
10. Sir, your taking the key of the meeting-house and holding it, we say is contrary to God's word, and you have no right to It, and not content with that, you rob us of the key of the whole society. Sir, we arc bold to say Christ never gave you them keys nor no other n)an on earth, for he knew how Aill the world always was and would be of false prophets and teachers that would turn the key against his disciples. Pray, sir, to what purpose had it a ben for our Saviour to have sent out the apostles as he did to preach the gospel to every creature, if these keys had been given lo the nilnlstei's? Why they must truly have turned buck without preaching to an j^ creature, with tliLs coniphilnl. Lord, thou sent us out to preach the gospel to every creature but had given the keys of every city, town and house to the ministers, and they forbid us. Sir, are you wiser than Christ ? Do you know how to manage the keys better than Christ ? He never gave them to you. For God's sake give thi m up, for thou hast nothing to do with them. Can you think, sir. that such a power as you claim Is from Christ ? No, assuredly you cun't unless you make this addition - Anti - for darkness and light are as near alike as your power and the spirit of Christ - and do consider. Sir, your ingratitude to a people that maintains and supports you ; that you should chastize us with scorpions and rule us with a rod of iron and put such chains and Imnds on us that we nor our fathers were not able to bear. * Tell it not in Gath ! '
12. Sir, we should be glad to know the reason of your parting Cuff and his wife, and as she was a sister in ye church and in regular standing as far as we know, yet we understand that you did deny her partaking with us.
18. And there are others who have withdrawn fk-om the church these many years and hant been called to no account, and we know not the cause of such a separation. Pray, sir. If you think the key of discipline lielongs to you we think you have much neglected your duty. Sir, for you to rob us of ye keys and not use them can't be right.
14. We think you are much to blame In denying people copies of the church record when the church has been a dealing with them .... and unless you reform we think It duty for this church to appoint some otherinau to hold the records
16. We think, sir, you are very partial in your visits for some houses you visit not for years, others you visit much. Pray remember Christ and his Apostles' commands, and do nothing by partiality, for God Is not a respecter of persons.
17. Sir, we desire the churcli records may be read in this church, even as fur back as your ordination, that we may search after the Aclian that troubles us, and who can tell but that God will discover it to us, and save us, as he did Israel by Phlnehas, or as he did the nation of the Jews by means of the King's hearing the Book read .... On that night could not the King sleep, and he commanded to bring the book of the Chronicles, and they were read before the King.'"
This paper, embodying the prinGii)a1 charges against Mr. Mosely, was read before a number of brethren of the church, but ns some thought the charges laid too high it was not formal )y adopted, but kept to aid in preparing something that miglit be suitable to lay before church and minister in due season. The report of its existence and private circulation greatly exasperated Mr. Mosely, who attempted ** to deal " with the chief offenders both publicly and privately. As usual in 8uoh afTairs many hard things were said on both sides, and charges of misrepresentation and lying were freely interchanged. Each party accused the other of promising copies of votes and documents, and then withholding them. William Foster, who was especially zealous in defending the church against ministerial usurpation, not' only afHrmed openly, *' that Mr. Mosely had lied and he could prove it," but, when reproved by him, replied, " Tliat he saw the Pope's horns begin to bud some yeai-s ago, and now they were grown out." Mr. Mosely's method of defiling with these offending brethren was certainly not unpapal. After bickering through the summer, they c:dled a council of ministers and delegates in October, which agreed *' That the aggrieved brethren might rationally expect from an undoubted right founded on reason and the Word of God, and agreeable to the general sense and practice of churches in New England, a church meeting for a full, free and open conversation respecting the introduction of some platform of ecclesiastical discipline and government into the church in which it had been too long deficient." But when in accordance with the advice of this council, the aggrieved Ik ethren in a decent and becoming manner, without heat or bitterness, earnestly and unitedly besought and entreated their pastor to call a church meeting for a conference upon this important subject, they were answered by a summons to appear before the church for trial : -
Hi. For abomiuable deceit in aslcing their pastor to warn a cliurch meeting to consider dealing witli baptized persons, when their true object was to introduce this question of a Platform."
These charges were tried before the church, Mr. Mosely himself acting as modeiator in spite of the protestations of the accused brethren. About foity members of the church were present. Seven voted iu favor of censure and seven against it. Again the pastor asked if they should proceed to censure, and adding his vote to the seven, pronounced the question carried, refusing to call the negative. Eight votes, including those of the pastor, his brother, and nephew, decided the case in a male membership of over fifty denied the liberty of expressing their non-concurrence, an act of ministerial domination rarely surpassed in audacity. The negative power, according to Mr. Mosely, was solely intrusted to ministera. In accordance with this vote, Ebenezer liovey, Dea. Ebenezer Griffin, Jonathan Burnap, Capt William Durkee, Jonathan Kingsbury, George Martin, John Clark, Jun., and William Foster were pronounced "guilty of scandalous violation of the third conunandment, of publishing a false and scandalous paper, of abominable deceit, contemptuons abuse of the divine institution of discipline, sciindalous violations of gospel injunctions," &o., and it was adjudged that these offenders ought to make a public acknowledgment of their sins, or otherwise be proceeded with in a way of censure, and this charge and sent-ence were publicly read on the Lord's day before church and congregation.
Nothing but the sterling virtues and high Christian character of Mr. Mosely saved him from the storm that followed. The outraged brethren i*efused to submit to the censure, and insisted upon its retraction. Public opinion and ministerial counsel sustained them in this demand, and in almost any church a rupture and separation would have been inevitable. But in spite of his wilfulness and arbitrary government, Mr. Mosely was greatly beloved and respected by the majority of his people. Many who disapproved of his conduct chose to retain him as their pastor, and by their conciliatory efforts both parties were brought to intrust decision to a council. The Ileverends Solomon Williams, David Hall, Benj. Throup, Aaron Hutchinson, Aaron Putnam and Levi Flint, with delegates from their respective churches, were convened in Windham Village, May 22, 1770, "to hear, judge and advise between the pastor and major part of the church and a number of aggrieved brethren," and decide<l, " That the charges against the aforesaid brethren were not sustained ; that they ought to be acquitted from censure ; and that the church should accordingly release them from the censure they had laid them under and restore them unto their charity." This advice was followed, and the brethren restored to fellowship. Still, the breach was far from healed. Violent recriminations had been interchanged between the combatants. William Foster pei*si8ted in reiterating that " Mr. Mosely had lied," whereupon he was again airaigned before the church to account for his false and scandalotis language. Foster offered to submit to trial under an impartial moderator nnsnbjected to the pastor's negative. The church voted to go on with their pastor for moderator according to their custom, upon which Foster "left the meeting, refusing trial." Mr. Mosely innnediately led the church to vote him guilty of contempt of that authority which Christ had placed in the church, and proceeded to excommunicate him. The aggrieved brethren called another council, ». «., Dr. Hopkins and Dr. Stiles of Newport, Leonard of Woodstock and Fuller of Plainfield. These gentlemen " might have cleared them ** on the same ground that the previous council had done, but disapproved of the severe and bitter expressions against the pastor, and deferred decision. A second attempt was more successful, and a general concession and forgiveness on both sides agreed to, William Foster, the chief offender and sufferer, declaring : -
M Iii6Toky Op Windham County
'* That nUliough in the time I did thinic I hnd occnsion to think Mr. Mosely did In ttonie nieuMiru evade tlie truth, yvl tipuu a iiHire iiiniuie (U'lihuratlou I nui sea.«4ible 1 prderred uiy charge a^^aliist hlui witli an undue temper ot* mind, and unnece^8arily published the same, and especially in tell in;; him, ' lie knew he lied,' in his own house, but on a further consideration of the matter I would charitably hope and believe that Mr. Mosely was not guilty of wilfully departing from the truth, and then^foro ask forgiveness of Mr. Mosely and my oflended bruthren, and pray them to receive me into their charity.
In spite of these concessioDs and retractions the controversy soon broke out afresh. Tlie root of the diitictilty hnd not been readied. An explicit cliurch covenatit had not been secured nor Mr. Mosely's power restricted. A majority of the aggrieved brethren accepted the decision and walked in harmony with the church, but Capt^ Dnrkee, Jonathan Btirnnp and William Foster still resisted and remonstrated. Each side accused the other of violating the agreement. The old charges were interclianged, civil suits instituted. After some years of strife and violence, the following complaint against Mr. Mosely was laid before the Windham County Association : -
Provenance
Text from History of Windham County, Connecticut, published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.