Windham County, Connecticut - Chapter 3: Settlement, 1889
From History of Windham County, Connecticut .., published 1889. 6,568 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
6,568 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Windham County, Connecticut .., published 1889. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
First Attempts at Settlement. - The Inter-Colonial Route. - Purchase of Land by John Winthrop. - Indian Title and Subsequent Confirmation. - Dispute as to Colonial Jurisdiction. - Indian Claims Revived. - Laud in the Market. - Influx of Speculators. - First Lands Laid Out. - Boundary Disputes with Massachusetts. - Claims of Uncas to the Wabbaquasset Country. - Land on the Quinebaug Sold. - Owaneco Appoints James Fitch his Attorney or Guardian. - Makes over to him Mohegan and Wabbaquasset Lands. - Fitch Sells Land to Roxbury. - Joshua Bequeaths Land to Sixteen Norwich Gentlemen. - Agreement of the Legatees. - Windham Settlements Made. - Depression of Improvements under Andros - Slow Progress of Settlement. - Religious and Social Affairs. - Settlement of the Disputed Section in the Southeast Part of the County. - Some of the Early Settlers. - Early Days of the Quinebaug Country. - Settlement in the Whetstone Country and the Volunteer's Land.
IN the early commerce between the colonies of Massachusetts and Connecticut a popular route over the land was through the region now covered by Windham county. Remote from the sea shore, and possessing no navigable lakes or rivers, it was perfectly reasonable that this territory should be for a time overlooked, or rather that it should be passed by as a goodly land for the home-seekers in a new world to locate upon. Accessibility by water was to the first settlers an almost absolutely essential feature in any site chosen by them for the planting of a little colony. But we may well imagine that the fertile valleys and hills of this beautiful region, and the picturesque attractions of the future Windham did not long remain unnoticed. The land became known to the English about the year 1635. When, about that time, the early colonists began to traverse the " hideous and trackless wilderness," on the way from Massachusetts to the Connecticut river, tradition tells us their encampment for the night was on Pine hill in Ashford. A rude track, called the Connecticut Path, obliquely crossing the Wabbaquasset country, became the main thoroughfare of travel between the two colonies. Hundreds of families toiled over it to new homes in the wilderness. The fathers of Hartford and Ncav Haven, ministers and governors, captains and commissioners, government officials and land speculators, crossed and recrossed over it. Civilization passed to regions beyond but made no abiding place here for more than half a centurj'.
One of the most indefatigable land speculators of that period was Mr. John Winthrop. In Massachusetts, in Rhode Island, in Connecticut and upon Long Island his tracks may be seen, as, first in one locality and then in another, he obtained title more or less perfect to the wild lands occupied by the Indians. Here in the territory now occupied by Windham county he was the first Englishman to receive from the natives a deed for an indefinite quantity of land. This conveyance bears date November 2d, 1653, and purports to have been given by James, sachem of Quinebaug, and confirmed by Massashowitt, his brother, and also to have been made with the consent, " full and free," of Aguntus, Pumquanon, Massitiarno, his brother, and Moas, " and all the rest of the chief men of these parts." The confirmation by others than James was made on the 25th of the same month, the writings being witnessed by Richard Smith, Samuel Smith, John Gallop, James Avery and William Weloma. The considerations named were "great friendship formerly from Mr. Winthrop, sometime governor of Massachusetts," the father of the grantee, and the fact that the latter had erected a saw mill at Pequot, which the grantors consider as a great prospective means for developing the forest resources of the country. The description of land conveyed was as follows : " the bounds thereof to be from the present plot of the Indians' planting ground at Quinebaug, where James, his fort is, on a hill at the said Pautuxett, and so down towards Shautuxkett so farr as the right of the said James doth reach or any of his men ; so farr on both sides the river as ye right of ye said James doth reach or any of his men, with all the swamps of cedar, pine, spruce or any other timber and wood whatever." The name Pautuxett, a general name for " falls," here refers to the falls at Acquiunk.
In the transactions connected with this conveyance we are told a Pequot Indian, well known by the name of Robin Cassaminon, acted as interpreter. One of the Indians named, Aguntus, was dissatisfied with the transaction and accused James, also named Hyems, of " selling land that was not his," and compelled him, in the presence of Winthrop, to pull off a coat which he had received in payment. Aguntus's dissatisfied spirit, however, was appeased by the presentation of " a roll of truckingcloth, two rolls of red cotton, wampum, stockings, tobacco-pipes and tobacco." According to Trumbull there was a small number of white families on the lands at the time of the purchase, but no trace of them has been recovered. An Englishman had attempted to settle in Quinebaug about the year 1650, but was driven off by the threat of Hyems, " to bury him alive unless he went away.
Governor Winthrop took great pains to secure legal confirmation of this purchase. The Narragansetts were precluded from prosecuting their ancient claim to this territory by an especial clause in the agreement made by himself and John Clarke as agents for Connecticut and Rhode Island, concerning the dividing line between their respective governments, which provided that "if any part of that purchase at Quinebaug doth lie along upon the east side of that river that goeth down by New London, Avithin six miles of the said river, then it shall wholly belong to Connecticut Colony, as well as the rest which lieth on the western side of the aforesaid river." The general court of Connecticut in October, 1671, allowed Governor Winthrop his Indian purchase at Quinebaug, and gave him liberty to erect thereon a plantation, but none appears ever to have been attempted under this permission.
As a result of its border location the territory of Windham was long in dispute as to jurisdiction. The northern part was for a long time held by Massachusetts. The patent of Connecticut allowed her territory to extend northward to the head of Narragansett river, but the prior grant to Massachusetts restricted it to the southern bound of the Bay Colony, " three miles south of every part of Charles River." In 1642 the southern boundary line was run out from a point on Wrentham Plain, which was settled upon as being three miles south of Charles river, to a point in Windsor, Connecticut, which was really ten or twelve miles farther south than the starting point. This was the famous Woodward and Saffery's line, and it was maintained by Massachusetts as her southern boundary for seventy years, even against the repeated remonstrances of Connecticut. By this the land now included in Woodstock and Thompson belonged to Massachusetts, and as a part of the vacant Nipmuck country awaited the action of that colony in its disposal, which.
on account of being weakened by the Indian war, was delayed for several years until she could recover sufficient pioneeringvigor to take hold of it.
After the scenes of King Philip's war had closed and quiet and confidence were gradually restored, many of the Indians, recovering from the shock of defeat, gathered again around their old homes and laid claim to various sections. To adjust these claims the general court of Massachusetts in May, 1681, appointed William Stoughton and Joseph Dudley, two men of prominence in public affairs there,' to investigate the basis of Indian claims in the Nipmuck country. A hearing was accordingly held by them in June, and Mr. John Eliot acted as interpreter on that occasion. Black James, the former constable at Chaubongagum, now appeared as claimant for the south part of the Nipmuck country. The commissioners found the Indians " willing enough to make claim to the whole country, but litigious and doubtful among themselves." They then adjourned to September, in the meantime hoping that some mutual agreement might bearrived at. Then they spent a week exploring the country, attended by the principal claimants. They reported Black James' claim as being " capable of good settlement, if not too scant of meadow, though uncertain what will fall within our bounds if our line be to be questioned." They further recommended that some compensation be made to the claimants and that the latter surrender all their lands to the government and company of Massachusetts. This advice was accepted and Stoughton and Dudley were authorized to negotiate with the claimants and enter into an agreement with them upon the best terms obtainable. As a result of these negotiations the whole Nipmuck country from the northern part of Massachusetts to Nashaway, at the junction of the Quinebaug and French rivers in Connecticut, a tract fifty miles long by twenty wide, was, on the 10th of February, 1682, made over to the Massachusetts government for the sum of fifty pounds. Black James received, for himself and some forty followers, twenty pounds in money and a reservation of land five miles square.
This Indian reservation was laid out in two tracts of land, one on the east of the Quinebaug at Myanexet, now included in the towns of Dudley, Webster and Thompson ; the other at Quinnatisset, now the south part of Thompson. Five thousand acres at Quinnatisset and a large tract at Myanexet, being a moiety or full half of the whole reservation, were immediately conveyed to Stoughton and Dudley for the sum of ten pounds. A deed for this was given by Black James and his associates, the native proprietors, November 10th, 1682. These commissioners, Stoughton and Dudley, thus became personally the first white proprietors of Windham's share of the Nipmuck country. Dudley retained for a long time his fine farm on the Quinebaug. The Quinnatisset land was ' soon subdivided to other purchasers.
Such a large tract of country being thrown into the market at once incited a rage for land speculation, and capitalists hastened to secure possession of favorable localities. June 18th, 1683, Joseph Dudley, for two hundred and fifty pounds, conveyed to Thomas Freak, of Hamington, Wells county, England, two thousand acres of forest land in the Nipmuck country, part of a greater quantity purchased of Black James. Two thousand acres in upland and meadow at Quinnatisset were also made over by Stoughton to Robert Thompson of North Newington, Middlesex, England, for two hundred pounds, English money. This Thompson was a very noted person, president of the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts, and a devoted friend of the colonies. The land was laid out by John Gore, of Roxbury, under the supervision of Colonel William Dudley, in June, 1684. This land remained in the family of Thompson for upwards of a hundred years, and the town which subsequently included it was named in his honor. Freak's farm included the site of the present village of Thompson. The line dividing it from Thompson's ran through an old Indian fort on a hill a mile eastward. Five hundred acres south of Freak's were laid out to Gore, and five hundred on the north to Benjamin Gambling, of Roxbury, an assistant surveyor.
These Quinnatisset tracts were not only the first lands laid out in the northern part of Windham, but are invested with additional interest by their connection with the disputed southern boundary of Massachusetts. Woodward and Saffery's line crossed the Quinebaug at its junction with the French river, and thence ran northeasterly to Rhode Island and Wrentham. It was intended to make this line the south bound of the Quinnatisset farms, but by an unfortunate blunder the greater part of Thompson's land and an angle of Gore's fell south of it, intruding upon what even Massachusetts acknowledged as Connecticut territory - an
A tract of twelve hundred acres lying between the Quinebaug and French rivers was sold by Nanasogegog, of Nipmuck, with the consent of Black James, to Jonathan Curtis, Thomas Dudley, Samuel Rice and others, in 1684 ; but other claimants apparently secured it. John Collins and John Cotton had each of them five hundred acres granted to them by the Massachusetts government, laid out on the east side of the Quinebaug in Quinnatisset. On the south of Lake Chaubongagum a tract of one thousand acres was granted to the children of Mr. William Whiting, sometime of Hartford.
In the adjustment of Indian claims Uncas assumed the right to a large share of eastern Connecticut. Massachusetts yielded to his claim the whole Wabbaquasset country. The tract confirmed to him as the hereditary territory of the Mohegans was bounded on the north by a line running from Mahmunsook on Whetstone brook to the junction of thfe Quinebaug and Assawaga at Acquiunk, thence westward to the Willimantic and far beyond it. The Wabbaquasset country was held by him as a Pequot conquest. It extended from the Mohegan north bound far into Massachusetts, and westward from the Quinebaug to a line running through the "great pondSnipsic," now in Tolland. This large tract was given by Uncas to his second son, Owaneco, while the land between the Appaquage and Willimantic rivers was assigned by him to his third son, Atanawahood or Joshua, sachem of the Western Niantics. The latter died in May, 1676, bequeathing the land between the Willimantic and Appaquage to Captain John Mason and fifteen other men " in trust for a plantation." His estate was settled according to the terms of his will, the general assembly of Connecticut allowing the Norwich legatees the lands bequeathed to them at Appaquage, which, as soon as practicable, was incorporated as the township of Windham.
In the year 1679 some of the Mohegan Indians in a drunken carousal set fire to the New London county prison and destroyed it. The county court in September of that year ordered that Uncas and Owaneco should render satisfaction for the damage by surrendering their right to six hundred acres of land. The general court at Hartford in October confirmed this judgment and ordered the county treasurer; James Fitch, Jr., to dispose of the land. A tract of six hundred acres was accordingly selected lying on both sides of the Quinebaug, extending from Wanangatuck on the north to a brook, now known as Rowland's brook, on the south. This was included in Winthrop's purchase of 1653. It was sold for forty pounds to John, Solomon and Daniel Tracy and Richard Bushnell, the survey being made in June, 1680. A farm south of John Tracy's division, adjoining the river island, Peagscomsueck, which gave its name to this section of the Quinebaug valley, was given to James Fitch by Owaneco, and laid out during the summer of the same year.
Notwithstanding the general court had allowed Governor John Winthrop his purchase at Quinebaug, some nine years before, yet in May, 1680, that body ordered that " if Uncas hath right to any land about Quinebaug he may make it out and dispose of it to his son Owaneco and such gentlemen as he shall see cause. Under this sanction Owaneco assumed the right to the whole Quinebaug country as well as Wabbaquasset. Swarms of greedy land hunters now assailed the Mohegan chieftain, eager to obtain possession of these lands upon any pretext. Their chief friends and patrons were the sons of Major John Mason, the renowned conqueror of the Pequots, Mr. Fitch, the excellent minister of Norwich, and James Fitch, his son.
Uncas was now in the years of his decay and Owaneco was drunken and incapable of managing business affairs with prudence and skill. The latter, however, was induced to consent to place his land claims in the hands of the younger James Fitch, to act for him as a sort of guardian, and accordingly gave Fitch a writing in effect a power of attorney, to dispose of all his lands and meadows upon the Quinebaug river, according to his discretion. This was done December 22d, 1680. By a formal deed of conveyance which was further confirmed by the general court of Connecticut, Owaneco, in 1684, made over to Captain James Fitch also the whole Wabbaquasset country. The Mohegan and Wabbaquasset lands were then for the first time surveyed and bounded, and their bounds confirmed by the assembly. The whole of the territory now embraced in Windham county, with the exception of two tracts, was thus placed in the hands of one individual, who was destined to play a very prominent part in its early history and subsequent development. The two excepted tracts above referred to were that of Joshua's, between the Willi- mantic and Appaquage rivers, and a strip east of the Quinebaug which had been divided between the colonies of Massachusetts and Connecticut.
James Fitch, at first captain, and afterward known as major, was a man of great energy, shrewdness and business capacity. As soon as he gained possession of this land he threw it into the market. Personal interest, as well as the good of the public, led him to seek to dispose of these vast tracts to good and substantial settlers - to colonies and towns rather than to individuals and speculators. The northern part of the Wabbaquasset tract was under the jurisdiction of Massachusetts, and to a Massachusetts company Fitch sold his first township. This was the town of Roxbury, which had grown so large that it was considered advisable to send out some of its members to plant a new town somewhere in the wilderness. Accordingly, after extended deliberations and due consideration of the preliminary measures, .a tract about seven miles square was purchased, and about the first of April, 1686, thirteen pioneers began to break up the ground and prepare for the improvement of New Roxbury, afterward Woodstock. The further particulars in regard to this tract will be given in connection with the history of Woodstock in another part of this work.
Four months previous to the division and distribution of land for actual settlement in the upper end of Windham county, steps in a similar direction were being taken in the lower end of the territory. The fact that land here had been confirmed in title to Joshua, the third son of Uncas, has already been alliided to. By bequest this tract was granted to sixteen gentlemen of Norwich and adjoining towns. Their names were Captain John Mason, Lieutenant Samuel Mason, Lieutenant Daniel Mason, Reverend James Fitch, Captain James Fitch, John Birchard, Thomas Tracy, Thomas Adgate, Lieutenant Thomas Leffingwell, John Olmstead, Simon Huntington, William Hide, William Backus, Hugh Calkins, Captain George Denison and Daniel Wetherell.
Joshua's will, granting the very extensive tract, which will be presently described, was allowed and established by the general court of Connecticut in May, 1678, and the persons named were allowed to possess all of Joshua's rights in the land, provided they should comply with the conditions therein named. Though the legality of Joshua's title to various other tracts conveyed. by rtliis will occasioned much subsequent controversy and litigation, the Norwich legatees secured their portion with little difficulty and no apparent opposition. Robin Cassasinamon - governor of the surviving Pequots - was commissioned by Uncas to show these men the bounds of their tract, and soon after its confirmation by the general court he set out with a party of the legatees and a surveyor by the name of Bushnell into the wilderness north of Norwich. Passing through Mamosqueage, a strip north of Norwicli reserved for Joshua's children, they followed an old Indian trail eight miles northward, the trail being known in those days as the Nipmuck Path, to a flag meadow which was called Appaquage. Here their bounds were to begin. After
encamping for the night, the next morning they struck through the woods ten miles to the Willimantic river, where they spent the second night. Thence they followed Robin down the Willimantic to Mamosqueage. Soon after this priliminary exploration Bushnell and Joseph Huntington were sent by the legatees " to measure down eight m.iles from Appaquage, by the said Nipmuck Path," which they did, " and marked a white oak at
' Thomas Leffingwell, Jr., and Richard Bushnell, under the direction of Uncas. In October, 1681, Captain Robert Chapman, Captain James Fitch and Thomas Buckingham were appointed administrators of Joshua's estate, and they, during the following winter conveyed according to the terms of the will, "a tract of land lying to the -west of Appaquage, east from Willimantic River, south from Appaquage Pond, eight miles broad," to the legatees whose names have already been given.
. character and standing. Samuel and Daniel Mason resided in Stonington, Mr. Wetherell in New London, and the others in Norwich. The following agreement was signed by the legatees February 17th, 1682:
" I. God willing, plantation work shall be carried on and a town settled within the space of four years, that is to say, we, after the above-mentioned time is expired, will bear all such public charges according to our just proportion for the carrying and end of a plantation shall resign up their allotments to such wholesome inhabitants as the said company shall see reason to admit, upon reasonable and moderate terms.
"III. We having received the land, and upon a view judge that it will afford an allotment for every thousand acres, according to the distribution made by Uncas (who was appointed by the deceased son to act), with some other allotments for public uses in the several divisions, first, second, and third of the land bequeathed to us.
" IV. It is agreed that the allotments be laid out in an equal manner, every one contenting himself with the place where God by his providence shall determine, by a lot drawn for that end, and the drawing of one lot shall answer for the home-lot and for the first division of upland and meadow. It is also agreed that Simon Huntington, William Backus, John Post and John Birchard shall lay out the same according to the order and manner above specified."
Three years passed without any material progress being made toward the settlement of this large tract. In February, 1685, it was agreed to make settlements in three different places, for the convenience of lands and meadows. By the following spring the surveys and divisions were completed and the land was ready for distribution. Beginning at Appaquage - " a flaggy meadow," - now at or near the southeast corner of Eastford, the boundary line of the tract ran south eight miles, large measure, on the west side of Nipmuck Path ; thence due west to the Shetucket, running a little south of the present site of Windham Green ; thence eight miles northwest, up the Shetucket and Willimantic, and thence ten miles east to Appaquage. A large part of the present territory of Windham, Mansfield, Chaplin, Hampton and Scotland townships was comprised in this royal gift, which was laid out in forty-eight shares, each containing a thousand acres. Each share included a home-lot in one of the three villages planned, and portions of meadow, pasture and upland in different localities. The three village sites selected were the Hither-place or Southeast Quarter, now Old Windham, village ; the Ponde-place, at Naubesatuck, now Mansfield Centre ; and the valley of the Willimantic, near the site of the present borough of that name. Fifteen home-lots were laid out at the Hither-place, twenty-one at the Ponde-place, and twelve at Willimantic. Highways were laid out through each village plat and from the Hither-place to the Ponde-place. The committee spent five days in making the surveys and measurements, and were paid for their services at the rate of three shillings a day, but those who ran lines received an extra shilling a day.
The allotments were made to individuals by drawing, on the 1st of j\lay, 1686. The common owners were probably all present, either in person or by representatives. Captain John M ason, William Hide and John Olmstead, having previously died, were represented by their heirs or administrators. It is a fact worthy of note that these men assembled on this occasion recognized the superintendence of an all seeing Providence, and impressed with the thought that this was serious, earnest business, and that consequences far greater than they could foresee might hang upon the results of their work, did not enter upon that work until " after prayer for direction and blessing." They then drew lots for their respective portions ; some receiving one and some six shares, according to the royal pleasure of Uncas, who had ordered the distribution. Three shares were reserved for the ministry and other public purposes, according to previous agreement.
The settlement and improvement of this great tract was at first slow. This will not seem so strange when we remember that the events which we are noticing occurred about the time when the status of liberty in the colonies was wavering in the balance. Connecticut, like other colonies, was suffering from the encroachments of King James. Her privileges were cut off, her charter demanded, and her government assumed by that unsavory administrator. Sir Edmond Andross. Under his arbitrary rule attempts at settlement were discouraged. He considered an " Indian deed worth no more than the scratch of a bear's paw," and would have scouted the right of the legatees to land bequeathed by an Indian chieftain. There is no record of any attempt to secure confirmation of title from Andross. It was doubtless thought more prudent to wait in silence and in the meantime make what few improvements might be practicable until some turn of political affairs should bring them better opportunities.
John Brown. In 1686 Captain James Fitch sold a similar right to Josiah 'Standish, of Duxbury, who convej^ed the same to Jacob Dingley, of Hingham, two years later. May 26th, 1688, Richard Bushnell sold to Jeremiah Ripley, also of Hingham, a similar share. Daniel Wetherell at the same date sold to Joshua Ripley an allotment. ' During the same summer also Calkins sold a right to Jonathan Hough, and Backus a right to Hough, Abel and Rudd. In this way the different shares and rights began to be transferred and their ownership divided and subdivided until in a short time one who should attempt to follow them would find himself in a perplexing labyrinth of titles.
For many years this tract appears to have been uninhabited and unoccupied except as an occasional hunting ground. The Indians had left it many years before, and the white settlers were slow in improving it. John Gates is said to have been the first actual settler upon it. Having bought an allotment of Daniel Mason at the Hither-place, he built a house upon it in the summer of 1689. Some other lots were fenced in, ground prepared and timber made ready for building during, that summer. A division of pasture land was also laid out and distributed. The second settler is said to have been Jonathan Ginnings, who bought land of John Birchard, and took possession in 1690. Other settlers soon followed, but it is a fact which may be mentioned as somewhat a curiosity that none of the original legatees made any actual settlement or improvements upon their rights. The nearest to such a thing done by any of them was that the share of Reverend James Fitch was improved by his son John ; William Backus resigned his rights to his two sons ; Huntington's right was made over to a son and nephew ; and John Birchard's land was occupied by two of his sons. The other legatees sold their rights, in accordance with the compact, "to wholesome inhabitants."
Some improvements were made during the year 1691. Joshua and Jeremiah Ripley, John Crane, Richard Hendee, Thomas and Joseph Huntington, William and Joseph Backus and John Larrabee, had broken land, built houses and established themselves in the Hither-place. This was on what is now the west side of Windham street. Crane was a blacksmith and bought land of Calkins. Hendee bought land of Captain James Fitch. It is somewhere recorded that the young Backus brothers sold their accommodations in Norwich " to remove to the new, nameless
The social conditions soon began to run in the cbanrels usral to civilized communities, as nearly as the peculiar surroundings would permit. Family affairs were not forgotten. The first child born in the settlement was a daughter to Jonathan Ginnings, and the date was February 10th, 1691. The first public meeting of the settlers of which we have any knowledge was on -the 18th of May, 1691. Joshua Ripley, Jonathan Crane, William Backus and Joseph Backus were then directed, " To run the town lines from Appaquage eight miles south, and thence south west to Willimantic River." This work was accomplished by the 28th of the same month. During this summer a grist mill was established and set in operation by Jonathan Crane. This stood on the site of the present Bingham's Mills. A pound was .also constructed on the Hither-place, and preparations were made for settling at the Ponde-place. Religious services were held occasionally by the Reverend Mr. Fitch and his son Jabez. On such occasions the settlers and their families, with whatever wandering natives happened to be with them, assembled under a tree to listen to the preaching and engage in the other exercises of the hour. These settlers were mostly connected with the Norwich church, and attended divine worship there whenever practicable. The old Nipmuck Path, on the east of the tract, and a rough way made by the first surveyors, connected the settlements. In the fall of that year (1691) the prospects of the settlement becoming permanent were sufficiently bright to encourage the settlers to petition the general court of Connecticut to grant them a charter as a town. This resulted in the organization of the town of Windham under authority of an order -of the court granted May 12th, 1692, and consummated by the act of the people on the 12th of June following. Further particulars of this will be found in the chapters of this work devoted to the history of Windham town.
We have now reviewed in brief the purchases from the In- <iians a;nd the first steps toward settlement in the two great and -early sections of Windham county civilization. These are the north end and the southwestern part. There was still a large tract of undeveloped land in the southeastern part, called the Quinebaug country. Here was the third center of civilization in the present limits of the county. This Quinebaug country, extending from the junction of the Qninebaug and Assawaga rivers to the north bound of Norwich town, and from the Appaquage or Little river eastward to Egunk, was claimed by two powerful parties - the heirs of Governor John Winthrop and Major James Fitch as guardian of the Indian Owaneco. The Winthrop claim was founded on the deed of 1653, which has previously been noticed in particular ; while Fitch was the advocate of the hereditary title of the Mohegan sachems. The general court of Connecticut had to some extent recognized both claims. It had " allowed the Governor his purchase, and it had also allowed Uncas to dispose of Quinebaug lands to Owaneco."
The first land laid out in this disputed section was the six hundred acres, already mentioned as being sold from the possessions of Uncas to make restitution for damages committed by his men in burning the New London county prison. This tract comprised some of the richest land in the Quinebaug valley, on both sides of the river. By deeds bearing date June 23d, 1680, it was conveyed to John, Daniel and Solomon Tracy and Richard Bushnell. They at once took possession of it and their occupancy was undisputed. A neck of land, below the river island, Peagscomsuck, granted by Owaneco to Fitch, was also laid out in 1680. Other large tracts in this territory were given by Owaneco to Fitch. The boundaries in these are described as follows, in part: - "Land and meadow east of the Quinebaug, bounded south on Norwich town line, thence northeast to the great brook that comes in at Peagscomsuck," (excepting that already sold to John Tracy) ; " Land both sides the Little River that comes in at Wequanock, bounded south on Norwich town line, west on New Plantation, land of Joshua, deceased," &c.; and " Land east side of Little River, taking all the corne and plaine, improvable land, a mile in breadth from Appaquage to the Quinebaug, bounded north on the Wabbaquasset Country, east on the Quinebaug, west on New Plantation and south on common land."
Neither Fitch nor the Winthrops attempted settlement of this land during the troubled years of the Andross administration, but as soon as practicable after the restoration of charter government, both were in the field. This conflict of claim was a hindrance to settlement. No organized company would venture to settle upon such ground. But the natural features of the ter- ritory were attractive, and venturesome individuals, in a haphazard way assumed the risks and began to improve the land. The confusion of titles forbids tracing the order of settlement, as deeds subsequently pronounced invalid were not recorded on the books of the town afterward organized. The Winthrop sons, Fitz John and AA'ait, in October, 1690, asked the general court to confirm their title, for the benefit of those about to settle there, but no action was taken in that direction by the court. The plantation, however, was begun. A number of Massachusetts families took possession of Quinebaug land, east of the river, purchased of the Winthrops soon after 1690. The greater part of them located south of the present village of Plainfield, though some took up land as far north as the mouth of Moosup river. Most of them received deeds for their land from the Winthrops, but a few bought land from Fitch. Connecticut families were also represented in the settlers of this section. It will be interesting to know who some of these early, independent settlers were, and where they had come from.
Timothy and Thomas Pierce came from Woburn ; Thomas Williams from Stow; Joseph Parkhurst, Jacob Warren, and Edward, Joseph and Benjamin Spalding from Chelmsford; Matthias Button and James Kingsbury from. Haverhill ; Ebenezer Harris and John Fellows from Ipswich ; Isaac AVheeler, Isaac and Samuel Shepard, and their stepfather Nathaniel JcM^ell from Concord ; Peter Crery, James Deane, AYilliam Marsh and Edward Yeomans from Stonington : William Douglas and others from New London and that vicinity. Several sons of Captain John Gallup, of Stonington, purchased land here, and perhaps settled upon it. James Welch, Thomas Harris, James and John Deane, and Philip Bump purchased land of Fitch and John TrsLcy. The most northerh- settlers were the young Shepard brothers, who were sons of Ralph Shepard, of Maiden, then deceased. Their land at the mouth of the Moosup river was that which had been given by Owaneco to Samuel Lathrop, of Norwich.
Very little is known of the early days of the Quinebaug plantation. No organization was effected, nor indeed was an}- attempt made in that direction for several years. The settlers broke up their land, built rude habitations and made some few improvements. The valley of the Quinebaug was found to produce very good crops of corn, and in spite of Fitch and Tracy injunctions, was used by the settlers as a common cornfield. Parts of this field were set aside for their Indian neighbors, who were then quite numerous, but peaceable and friendly. Fears were at first entertained on their account, and garrison houses were provided, but it does not appear that they were ever called into necessary use. No attempt was made to lay out any public highways. The old Greenwich Path had then been trodden out and led from here to Providence on the east. A continuation of it westward to Windham, became in ^fter years a much used thoroughfare between Hartford and Providence. Besides this, rough paths were trodden out to Norwich and New London, and by means of these communication with the neighboring towns was maintained.
The double land claim of Fitch and Winthrop kept society for a long time in an unsettled condition. The friends of these conflicting claimants were at open war with each other. There was no local organization, and consequently no law to protect local interests or secure the peace of the community or the protection of individual rights. The court of New London county was the nearest tribunal that had any jurisdiction here, and much violence and misdemeanor might be practiced before redress could be obtained through appeal to that body. Its protection was, however, frequently appealed to. Cutting grass on land claimed by another, gathering crops of grain belonging to others, personal assault, refusal to pay rent, profanity and threatening the life of another, extortionate demands of landlords and creditors, oppressive acts of officers of the law, stealing timber, hay, logs, rails and other depredations upon property and person were among the charges brought against individuals by others who had suffered from their injustice. The New London court was largely occupied with cases from the Quinebaug country. Fines were levied and whipping and imprisonment inflicted. The Gallups were leaders of the Winthrop faction, and the largest resident landowners. One of them, according to tradition, gave such offense to the planters, by greed and overmeasurement, that he was driven out of the plantation as a " land grabber." In 1699 the Winthrops attempted to bring the question of proprietorship to an issue by entering complaints against Major Fitch and Judge Tracy for entering upon lands belonging to the plaintiffs. The cases were tried before the court of common pleas for New London county, and resulted in a verdict for the defendants. An appeal was taken and the question remained unsettled indefinitely, while each party continued to sell and occupy what land they could. In spite of these disturbances the Quinebaug plantation gained in numbers and strength.
We have now noticed the three first settlements of Windham county territory while in their first or unorganized condition'. The brief glance which we have given to the subject of the acquirement of Indian ti^le covers the whole territory of the county, with perhaps a few unimportant exceptions. Fitch, as the representative of Owaneco, claimed the northwestern part of the county, by virtue of the conveyance of the latter in 168.4. More particular delineation of the acquirement of title, division of land and organization of government will be given under the particular head of each town. It may be proper to mention before dismissing the subject, however, that the Whetstone country, a considerable tract on the east of the Quinebaug, was owned by the colony of Connecticut and remained unoccupied for many years, though grants of land, in consideration of services rendered by individuals, were occasionally made with very indefinite descriptions. On this territory Killingly was laid out in 1708, and about the same time Voluntown was surveyed and distributed to a large number of military volunteers.
Provenance
Text from History of Windham County, Connecticut .., published 1889, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.