Windham County, Connecticut - Chapter 20: Windham County Churches, 1920 (part 2 of 7)
From A Modern History of Windham County, Connecticut : a Windham County Treasure Book, published 1920. 15,954 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
1 sectionThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,954 wordsMachine-read from scans of A Modern History of Windham County, Connecticut : a Windham County Treasure Book, published 1920. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
My mother was a Chaplin girl, "a Baptist born and a Baptist bred," and indeed she lived true to the other line of that old couplet - "and now she's gone, she's a Baptist dead"; for in her innermost soul she never lost her faith in the necessity of "immersion" as an act of complete submission to the will of the Lord and Master whom she ever faithfully served. (I give these intimate personal pictures because they so clearly reveal the religious life of that period). Her father, Deacon Origen Bennett, never attended the Congregationalist Church in Chaplin, but faithfully carried his family, summer and winter, to the Baptist Church on Spring Hill, Mansfield; often in winter making their way with difficulty, but with an old-fashioned warming pan filled with live coals, or in later fashion a hot soapstone, to keep their feet warm under the buffalo robe, in double sleigh or two-seated democrat wagon.
My father, like his father and grandfather before him, always staunch supporters of the church financially, was nevertheless inclined to be a "freethinker, ' ' and had little use for 1 ' doctrines ' ' ; but had full faith in my mother 's religion as sufficient for the family. Of his father, Capt. Dan Lincoln (so-called because of his activity with the old-time militia in training days on the flats west of Windham Green) and his wife Mehitabel Flint (known around North Windham as "Aunt Hitty") the saying then current regarding them was that "Dan did as Hitty said, and Hitty went accordin' to the Bible." But my mother couldn't get my father to join the Baptist Church, so she, with a purpose in her mind, joined the Congregational Church when they moved from Chaplin to Willimantic in 1864; and two years later my mother's purpose was realized and my father joined this church. And that's how we children came to be Congregationalists !
The Congregationalist Church of that day (built in 1828) is now made over into what is knowrn as the Melony Block, opposite the Hooker House on
Main Street. I well remember that old structure. I cannot describe it accurately, but it was the typical white frame building common to Congregational churches of that day, with the tall white spire pointing heavenward ; and similar structures may still be seen in the smaller towns of Windham County ; of plain, cheerless barn-like interior ; some of those still standing have been considerably improved in appearance in later days; but religion in those days was an austere thing. I recall that the main auditorium stood high up from the Main Street, approached by at least fifteen or twenty steep steps; and occasionally little children, who always had to go to church as well as Sunday school in those days, would tumble down those steps and get severely bumped. The vestry was underneath, at ground level, entered by a side door at the northeast corner, just off Main Street, and equipped with hard "settees," and a melodeon made by Deacon Edwin Barrows, father of the late Mayor D. Clifford Barrows of Willimantic. The auditorium above had galleries running north and south on either side, with built-in benches of fitting hardness and discomfort, probably to induce reflection on one's sins; while the equally hard and uncomfortable pews below faced north towards the old-fashioned, high-up, built-in pulpit at the north end; the ceiled railing of the pulpit standing up so high that the minister could be seen only from the gallery, until he stood up and raised his hand in the customary devotional attitude to pronounce the "invocation." The custom of many clergymen was to raise one hand for the invocation and two for the benediction.
Even more vivid than the minister, in my childhood's memory today, is the old sexton, J ames Martin, an energetic workman of the severe type - of rugged honesty and determined purpose, and a veritable terror to evildoers, especially to small boys and unruly youth; and woe be to any who whispered or giggled during the service. The sexton enjoyed the ancient prerogative of "tythingman," and was indeed the minister's right-hand reliance for the maintenance of law and order in the church. Tradition has it that this sexton sought no authority from the minister nor from any of the society's committee, but was a law unto himself, where matters of order and discipline were concerned. Occasionally some youthful disturber of the service would be led by the ear from the gallery to the street in full view of the congregation, and the effect was always wholesome. A story still survives, although suppressed as far as possible at the time, that one Thursday evening, when a rare thing occurred and the sexton was a minute or two late in ringing the bell for the prayer meeting, someone ventured to enter the dark vestibule to sound the call, only to find himself unceremoniously ejected, before the sexton realized that the offender was the minister!
Mr. Martin was also sexton of the Willimantic Cemetery on West Main Street for more than fifty years, being succeeded by his son James Martin, Jr.; who, counting the time he helped his father, has also served in that capacity for more than fifty years, and is still in the service - certainly an unique record for father and son.
Among the leaders in the choir in those days was Henry L. Hall, son of Horace Hall, the village magnate and trial justice. The drug store of the Elder Hall was then at the corner of Main Street and Walnut (Cunningham's Lane). Henry was a brother of the late John M. Hall, lawyer, political leader.
speaker of the house, judge and railroad president; and Henry was ofter spoken of as naturally more brilliant than his distinguished brother, but le^s ambitious, and content to serve his native community for many years as editor of the Willimantic Weekly Journal, which, under his unique guidance, was one of the best weekly newspapers of the state.
Henry L. Hall had a wonderful bass voice, deep, musical, of round full tones, and he was not only the basso for the Congregationalist Church for many years, but as soloist was sought for many public functions. My memory retains a vivid picture of him as leading a chorus of men in singing political and topical songs at the old Methodist vestry on Church Street, during the famous Grant vs. Greeley campaign of 1872 (for Grant's second term), and amidst the greatest enthusiasm they were singing verses which Henry himself had composed, the chorus running like this, to the tune of the then still-popular Civil war song, "Tramp, Tramp, Tramp, the Boys Are Marching":
My boyish mind always visualized the elder James Martin as "the old sexton," whenever Henry Hall was called upon, as he often was, to sing the famous song of that title. Those vivid words have never gone from my mind, and are now written from memory after fifty-five years:
"Nigh to a grave that was newly made, Leaned a sexton old, on his earth-worn spade. His work was done, and he paused to wah\ The funeral train through the open gate. A relic of by-gone days was he And his locks were as white as the foamy sea. And these words came from his lips so thin, I gather them in, I gather them in."
Do you think I'm getting gruesome! Il may seem so in these days, when as a sort of psychological antidote to all our troubles, there is such a confident, cheerful note in the songs of religious life; but let me toll you that in those days we were ' ' fed up ' ' on solemn things ; and let me also say frankly that, as my memory recalls, there was no note of gTuesomeness in the teaching, but only that solemn feeling of personal responsibility to God which those old songs and similar preaching were intended to impress. Even as children we were taught to live in daily fear of that "summons into Eternity" which might come "at any moment," and which, if it found us unrepentant, or even failing to acknowledge Christ as our Lord and Master, would put us in danger of "eternal punishment. ' '
And yet, amid all those fearly lessons, the bright hope of a Heaven of eternal bliss for them who did repent, was held out so vividly and confidently that on the whole, especially in the environment of a faithful Christian home, the vision of a happy life here and hereafter was the impression that prevailed in our lives.
The minister of that day, or clergyman, as he was more commonly called, was the Rev. Samuel G. Willard, a scholarly gentleman of the austere type and of strict Puritan orthodoxy; and yet with a kindly paternal gleam in his eye. He came to this church in 1849 and it is a curious fact that there is no record of his ever having been "installed." I can see him now, with his dark-brown, fine-grained hair and reddish-brown whiskers, his finely-chiselled, classic features, as he stopped me one day on Depot Street (now Railroad) - I was probably about eight years old - and laying his hand gently on my head, said, with a kindly smile, 1 ' Allie, do you love the Savior ? " I stood transfixed, too scared to move ; and I don 't remember how I got away ; but I never forgot the blessing. We children surely did fear the minister in those days; I suppose as a part of the fear of God which was impressed upon us.
Mr. Willard was not only an efficient minister, but took an active interest in town affairs, serving especially on the school committee, as the ministers in those days were expected to do. He was known widely outside the town for his scholarly attainments, and became one of the Fellows of Yale College. He was later called to Colchester, where he served for many years and died there, full of years and deeply respected. His children are still active in the life of that community and with a wide range of benevolent influence radiating from their honored father and saintly mother. The son and eldest, Samuel Porter Willard, was my playmate, and many of you know him now as for many years purchasing agent and property custodian for the State Board of Education, having especially in charge the expense and supplies of the State Normal Schools, so that he visits Willimantic very frequently.
His two sisters have proved equally valuable members of society in their respective spheres; Miss Abby G. Willard, still resident in Colchester, and known throughout Eastern Connecticut and personally to many of you through her service for foreign missions; and Mrs. Mary Willard Cragin, whose husband, Dr. E. B. Cragin, lately deceased, became one of the most famous physicians in New York City - and he and his wife gave the Cragin Memorial Library at Colchester. Mr. Willard resigned October 25, 1860, but was persuaded to remain. August 23, 1868, he accepted a call to the church at Colchester.
The notion sometimes advanced that Puritan strictness in child training would often react in youth, who would then "sow wild oats," was true in comparatively few instances, which were naturally conspicuous as a whole. Puritan training, based on deep and genuine religious conviction, produced a high type of citizen, loyal and efficient. As a rule, the children of ministers' families "turned out well" and it is a pleasure to cite the Willard family as an illustration of the best types.
When the Parish Committee began to look for Pastor Willard 's successor, the need of a new church building was the uppermost thought in the minds of the people, and to that end they called as their new pastor the Rev. Horace Winslow, who had won fame as a church building promoter in several other communities.
Mr. Winslow began to preach here in the autumn of 1868, and from the rather indefinite records it appears that he was called to the pastorate January 26, 1869, and was installed April 28th. The first thing that Pastor Winslow did was to tear down that ancient high pulpit and establish an open platform of the modern type, whence he could address his people with direct and effective appeal. His ministry was naturally in marked contrast to that of Mr. Willard. The old-time traditions of doctrinal conservatism were soon replaced by methods of business vigor, not only to attain the new church building, but also affecting the regular church activities. The people of the entire parish were enlisted. The corner-stone was laid in July, 1869, fifty-one years ago - and one year later (July 20, 1870) the main structure was dedicated. Within another year the chapel was dedicated. The sale of the old property netted $19,578, the total cost of the new building and chapel was $46,700, and was all paid for and free from debt by October 1, 1872.
There are probably some living in Willimantic now who remember that brilliant and even gaudy interior of the new church, with its wonderful contrasts of blue and gold, with veritable stars of heaven studding the cerulean overhead. The purpose of Pastor Winslow and his society committee in those decorations was undoubtedly to provoke an atmosphere of cheerfulness; but it was generally agreed that the decorator got away from them. The stained windows, given by individual donors in memoriam, were considered really beautiful, and do now certainly stand out in fine contrast to the more modest interior colorings of the later-day renovation. The story of those windows has been told elsewhere in this volume by Pastor Winslow 's daughter. Miss Mary Winslow, who now lives near Rev. Mr. Croft in Simsbury. Her sister Fanny, now Mrs. William Smith, is an active factor in the community life of Simsbury, and was at one time postmistress at Weatogue. Another daughter, Lillian, whom some of you remember, married Dr. Charles James Fox, a former Willimantic practitioner, but she died in early life. Mrs. Winslow, during her husband's pastorate, was prominent in women's activities, especially in your Ladies' Society.
Mr. Winslow bore an honorable part in the Civil war as chaplain of his regiment, and always carried an erect and militaiy bearing. He lived in retirement at Simsbury for the later years of his life, and died above age ninety. One of the last acts of his vigorous life was to march with erect and manly bearing in a G. A. R. parade in Boston when he was eighty-five. He was essentially a business promoter in all branches of church affairs - and he did know and love a good horse! The beautiful white mare "Pet," which the family drove, was a familiar and admired figure on the streets for many years. During his twelve years' pastorate Mr. Winslow was active in community Life, on the School Board, and in many public matters; of progressive civic spirit and always a hard worker for what he believed should be done.
When he resigned, April 28, 1881, the committee to secure a new pastor heard much about a so-called liberal preacher who was then serving the Con gregational Church at Stafford Springs, the Rev. Samuel R. Free. In the later days of Pastor Winslow's service much had been heard of the "higher criticism ' ' ; and it was beginning to be felt that possibly all the old-time Biblical legends and miracles and orthodox doctrines were not as literally true as had so long been believed. Pastor Winslow's period, as already indicated, had been more concerned with practical achievements in church and community action than with doctrinal points, and the mind of the parish was ready for something new. "Liberal thought" was in the air.
It was into an atmosphere of this sort that the Rev. Samuel R. Free was engaged by the Society Committee to come as acting pastor. He began preaching October 2, 1881, and the records say that November 6, 1881, "he commenced his ministrations with this people under an engagement for six months. ' '
In a very short time he became the sensation of the parish and indeed of the entire community and the country 'round. His most famous sermons, "Beliefs that Cannot be Believed," and "Beliefs that Can be Believed," shook the foundations of orthodox Congregationalism in these parts. There was a tremendous popular response to such preaching - the times were ripe for it. The church was filled to hear the "heretic," as his critics called him, and his Sunday evening lectures were especially popular.
Mr. Free preached a practical every-day morality with a genuine devotion and enthusiasm for the highest ideals of personal and civic living. His' faith was expressed in "the Fatherhood of God and the Brotherhood of Man," and he not only preached it but he lived it. He was a genial companion, a kind, thoughtful neighbor, a friend of the sick and needy, and a quiet but effective worker for the welfare of the people of his parish and of the community. He was frank and fearless in his criticism of theological pretense and social shams. But his pulpit influence was more destructive than constructive, so far as church organization was concerned; and after a few years of wide popularity, he had cleared away the ancient debris of the old-time orthodoxy - and his work here was done. He made two or three attempts to rally his followers for constructive progress on high ethical lines, but his destructive criticisms had sunk deep into the hearts of the followers of the old school, and they were grieved; while the devotees of the new thought were as yet too much enjoying their freedom from the hell they were brought up to fear, to enlist for constructive work. Hence, there was schism in this dear old church, of a serious sort, which for a time threatened to sunder it.
The still-orthodox clergymen of the neighboring Congregatioiialist churches, together with a few laymen of similar belief, called a conference with the purpose to discipline or perhaps expel the "heretic," and such a conference actually met in this church. But as the clergy and delegates were trying to devise some form of action, one of their number, himself a firm adherent of the old-time faith, but a man of practical common sense - the Rev. S. H. Fellows of Wanregan - rose to his feet and in a quiet, calm and convincing talk, told the members of the conference that in view of Congregational usage they were in danger" of exceeding their province if any attempt were made to discipline or condemn the Willimantic Church or its pastor, as the association of neighboring Congregational churches possessed no authority, but existed only for friendly fellowship and counsel, and for cooperative endeavor; and that in accordance with ancient polity each Congregational Church and parish was an independent body, and free to take its own course ; and much as they might regret the situation in the Willimantic church, it was really none of their business in any formal or authoritative way; and he therefore moved that the conference ' 'adjourn without day." His quiet common sense convinced the assembled brethren, and they forthwith adjourned - and thus ended all chance of sensational developments!
But the schism was widening, nevertheless, and it soon became apparent to the Free faction that it was impracticable to go on. Mr., Free therefore resigned February 2, to take effect April 1, 1888. But notwithstanding these differences, it is to be said to Samuel R. Free, this church and parish owe a deep debt of gratitude for the fearless, devoted and thorough manner in which he did here the work which he surely felt God had called him to do. It is rarely that a reformer possesses also constructive ability, his function is rather to agitate and attack until the fundamentals of the new order appear. Every minister who has come to this church since that day, Messrs. Croft, Dinsmore, George, Beard, Leavitt, Cooke, and I doubt not the present incumbent, will tell you that he found here among this people a spirit of freedom from theological bias which has enabled the preacher to bring out in clearer light the great underlying truths of the Christian faith; and that there is also here a spirit of Christian unity which makes for efficient parish and community work. The fearless criticisms of Samuel R. Free were a powerful influence for the establishment of this freedom, to a degree not found in many other churches, and have also made the pastorate of this church an opportunity for the development of strong men who have invariably been called hence to higher service elsewhere.
Samuel R. Free was born at Clinton, N. Y., in 1843; educated at Amenia Seminary; ordained to the Congregational ministry, and in that denomination held pastorates successively at Winsted, Conn., Hartsville and Rutherford, Mass., then in Connecticut again at Stafford Springs and at Willimantic. After his Willimantic experience he withdrew from the Congregational denomination and associated himself with the Unitarian Church. He was then for several years pastor of the Unitarian Church at Chattanooga, Tenn., then returned for a time to Willimantic to preach to a body of "liberals"; but not enough support was received to warrant the continuance of this movement. Mr. Free returned to his old home in Amenia, N. Y., accepting occasional engagements to preach or lecture. He was twice married: his first wife, Jeanie B. Ingraham, daughter of George W. Ingraham, at the time of her marriage was preceptress at Amenia Seminary. During his Willimantic pastorate, Mrs. Free shared with him the high esteem of the public. She died at Amenia in 1900. Later he married her sister, Phoebe W. Ingraham, and she survived him only a few months. He died in August, 1916.
During the controversy over Mr. Free, and because of the threatening attempt of outside churches to bring pressure to bear to oust him, a vote was passed June 28, 1887, "To declare oursekvs an independent Congregational Church"; but later, after it had appeared that the proposed disciplinary council adjourned without day, as confessedly having no authority, the above-quoted vote was rescinded, by vote of the church in November, 1SSS. Because of the serious nature of the schism, however, it was difficult to secure a now minister. Yet in a remarkably short time, by August 7, 1888, a call was accepted by the
Rev. Andrew Jackson Sullivan. It proved "too sudden," however, and solely because of the situation, which probably no one could have handled successfully so soon after the trouble, Mr. Sullivan's stay was very short. He began preaching September 2, 1888, and resigned January 20, 1889.
After an interval of reflection and various supplies, the Society Committee finally secured the services of the Rev. Charles P. Croft of Simsbury, an able preacher who had a considerable reputation as a harmonizer of local church difficulties. It appears that in his early manhood Mr. Croft had begun a brilliant career as preacher in Terre Haute, Ind., but through ill health lost his voice and was compelled to relinquish the pulpit. He returned to Connecticut and became confidential business adviser in the management of large properties, for which a natural business ability qualified him. Later, in response to calls, he resumed preaching occasionally, but never returned to any regular charge, because of business engagements. He was a preacher of unusual ability and power, and possessed withal a magnetic personality, with rare tact, which enabled him to speak the truth plainly and in love, wherever frank counsels were needed. He proved just the man for the Congregational crisis in Willimantic. He came for Sundays only, returning to Simsbury for the week days.
For a time he preached sermons of splendid eloquence on general themes, and thus gained the confidence of the people, and they forgot much of their theological troubles. Then he began his work on the delicate problem of really re-uniting the parish. Some of the parish people will remember well how he did it. One Sunday he would glorify the old-time doctrines of the orthodox faith, pointing out their saving power unto salvation, until he warmed the hearts of the elder school ; and then he would kindly indicate that nevertheless it was to be expected that some new views of faith and doctrine would appear as time passed on, and they of the ancient faith must be willing to consider such advances with charity and hope, remembering that even in their own earlier days they had not thought quite as their fathers did; and that after all a faith that brought good works was perhaps acceptable unto God. And so they of the orthodox faith would go home from that service gratified, but more tolerant.
Then on a later Sunday this same preacher would welcome the enthusiasm of the younger and more liberal portion of the congregation, telling them that in them rested the hope of the future; that changes in religious ideas were inevitable, and that many were feeling that there should be some modifications of ancient ideas ; and having thus won their attention and confidence, he would forthwith remind them tactfully that there had been some wisdom in the world before they arrived on the scene ; that after all, we were greatly indebted to the fathers in Israel for the great fundamentals of our faith; and that careful reflection would reveal in every one of the old doctrines some kernel of sacred truth ; and it was well to take care not to reject the substance of ancient faith while becoming impatient with the shell of outworn ceremony or form or profession. And so the younger and more liberal among the congregation would, go home from that sermon, gratified by the recognition of their progressiveness, but reflecting that the old fellows might have some merit after all !
Somewhat after this manner, sometimes expressed with incisive and critical emphasis but with that characteristic genial and winning personality which many of us still know and enjoy, Mr. Croft, during nearly four years as acting
For that splendid work of reconciliation and reconstruction, the people of this parish owe a deep debt of gratitude to Charles P. Croft ; and that the people of the parish still feel this sense of gratitude is evidenced by the fact that he is still called here frequently to preach and to counsel.
Then came Charles Allen Dinsmore (he began preaching here January 1; installed February 17, 1891), who possessed the rare faculty of clothing the old-time fundamentals of the faith in modern language, and thus he soon won the confidence of both factions - factions no longer, and all responsive to the truth in Christ Jesus, as Dinsmore would express it. He was a deep thinker, and sometimes they said he preached over the heads of his people; but his tremendous earnestness availed to drive home the vital truths of the gospel, and before long the people were awakened to the fact that a preacher of unusual spiritual power was among them. His influence upon practical business men was marked, and he showed the vital necessity of religious faith in daily living. He built, broad and deep in this church and community, a strong and abiding faith in God and in Christian brotherhood.
In November, 1895, Mr. Dinsmore received a call to the Phillips Church in South Boston, which he accepted. He resigned December 8th, to take effect January 1, 1896. Doctor Dinsmore has become one of the leading ministers of the Congregationalist faith ; and a religious philosopher of world-wide reputation, especially as a student and interpreter of Dante. His books on Dante have been used as text-books in England and on the Continent, and his "Life of Dante," issued in September, 1919, is pronounced by eminent critics the best life of Dante in any language. He has done much to bring about a more popular appreciation of the meaning of the philosophy of the mythical Florentine, and it was this fact that led one of the Boston critics to declare, ' ' Great is Dante, and Dinsmore is his prophet ! ' '
It is worth while to tell here the remarkable story of how Mr. Dinsmore came to be a Dante scholar. Humanly speaking, it was an accident; our good old grandmothers would have called it ' ' providential ' ' ; and certainly the outcome may well strengthen our faith in the proverb that there is a divinity that shapes the fate and fortunes of men. While on a vacation from the Phillips Church in South Boston, whence he was called from Willimantic, he was visiting at the home of a friend ; and wishing to escape from the excessive heat of an August afternoon, he sought from his friend's library some light or even frivolous book to take with him into the shade of neighboring woods. But chance or destiny put his hand upon a translation of Dante 's Inferno ; and as he had for many years a latent desire to know more of that great if not greatest of poets, he took the volume along with him into the woods. He became intensely interested at once, and read with a fascination that caused him to forget the heat and even the passing hours. That was the beginning of an interpretation of Dante which has now brought to Doctor Dinsmore the reputation of being one of the foremost of Dante scholars among English-speaking peoples. His books have been also translated into Chinese.
I am going to take the liberty to tell here a little incident which Illustrates the very human side of Charles Allen Dinsmore. One summer day, soon after his first Dante book appeared, he came down from Boston to New London for a meeting of a committee of the National Congregational Council Late in the afternoon I met him on the street in New London, and as he was to remain overnight in the city, I persuaded him to go out with me to Pleasure Beach, where my family was stopping. The next morning early we went out in an old sharpie to try our luck for blackfish or porgies or even cunners - whatever might bite! Often reticent in those days, Dinsmore said little that morning, and after several ineffectual attempts to draw him into conversation about ordinary affairs, I gave it up, and we sat fishing in silence, as I suppose all true fishermen should.
Observing the apparent deep preoccupation of Dinsmore, I thought to myself, ' ' Well, even if he would talk, probably I couldn 't keep my end up ; I don 't know anything about Dante ' ' ; and then Dinsmore rose up in the boat, silently drew in his fifty feet or more of line, put a fresh clam on the hook, and then, swinging the heavy lead sinker around his head in the usual manner, he flung it far out over the water and broke out, 1 1 Do you love me, Molly darling ? ' ' and without further sound sat down and resumed his fishing and silent meditation.
Doctor Dinsmore was born in New York City in 1860, son of L. H. Dinsmore, M. D. He attended schools in Woodstock, Vt., Monson Academy, was graduated at Dartmouth '84, Yale Divinity School '88. Dartmouth gave him the degree of Doctor of Divinity in 1906 and Yale in 1916. Two of his books have been translated into Japanese and two are published in England.
First, revision of the requirements for church membership, eliminating much of the old-time doctrinal phraseology, and asking only a simple pledge of ' 1 desire to follow the teaching and example of our Lord and Master Jesus Christ," and leaving the matter of " beliefs" to individual interpretation. He pointed out the injustice of the notion prevailing with some that they were "not good enough to join the church," and insisted instead that because of our human weakness we needed the pledge and associations of the church to make us better by the constant influence of its ideals in our daily lives. 1 1 Do you believe in the church ? - not as a doctrine, but as an institution for the welfare of humanity and for the inspiration and upbuilding of life and character" - he would ask of non-members. Of course the reply was, yes. "But so far as you are concerned, if a non-member, there would be no church. You are failing to sustain and uphold the institution you believe in. Why not join, for its influence upon your own life and also because of your obligation to help maintain this vital institution?" The appeal was effective with many who had not before realized this point of view.
Secondly, he replaced the old-time Sunday evening meeting of "prayer and conference" by "the Young Men's Sunday Evening Club," with popular programmes of high class and entertaining music, with some special feature of soloists or quartet, with rousing congregational singing, and a fif-teen-minute talk by the pastor, which never failed to inculcate a spiritual message of deep earnestness and of lasting influence.
Third, organization of the Boys' Brigade, with military drill and rules, real uniforms and real guns; hikes and camping, with games and sports; and one requirement to secure and retain membership in the brigade was regular attendance at Sunday-school.
Mr. Dinsmore also introduced the plan of systematic giving to church organizations and activities, and introduced a new hymnal. The membership of the church was more than doubled under his leadership and altogether he did
The masterly scholarship and deep spiritual inspiration of his thought, with his ability to make the divine message plain to the rank and file of the people - the same qualities which he was developing here at Willimantic - have in later days won recognition from centers of religious education at Harvard and at Oxford, and have now resulted in a call to become professor of religious education at Yale University, to accept which he has resigned his Waterbury pastorate (May, 1920). It is not too much to say that Charles Allen Dinsmore is among the foremost of those of his day and generation who, amid the wreck and despair following "the greatest of all wars," are now helping to remold and retain and advance the great essentials of faith in spiritual immortality which have ever been the confident reliance of "man's unconquerable soul."
After the departure of Mr. Dinsmore, there came again the task of hunting up a new pastor. It was fine to have picked out one who had been so signally successful in the work of modern reconstruction; it was something of a job to find a worthy successor, but it is to be said that the record indicates that this First Congregational Church of Willimantic has been very successful in this regard.
This time they soon heard of a brainy young fellow by the name of George who was preaching up in Newport, Vt., near the Canada line. He was very highly commended by Prof. Lewis Brastow of the Yale School of Religion. As a result of this visit and recommendation, the Rev. E. A. George was called to succeed Mr. Dinsmore. He was a son of Postmaster Charles H. George of Providence, R. I., and a graduate of Yale, '85 and Yale Seminary '87. He accepted the call February 28, 1896, began preaching Easter Sunday, April 5th, was installed June 18th.
Mr. George very soon manifested an especial interest in the younger people of the parish, and set out to arouse in them a new and active interest in the church. Interest in the mid-week prayer meeting and in the Sunday evening prayer and conference service seemed at low ebb; and he also felt that the Sunday school could not do its best by studying only the set "quarterlies." So he changed the programme of the mid-week meeting to a series of practical talks on scriptural themes as related to everyday life, inviting informal expressions from those attending, in lieu of the old-time "prayer and praise"; and he made marked changes in the Sunday evening programme and in the Sunday school lessons.
He appointed a special committee from the Sunday school to cooperate with him in preparing a special series of lessons which should make the practical every-day meaning of the Bible more intelligible and effective in the lives of the children. This committee met with him at his home, and the new lessons there prepared by him and approved by the committee were printed and used in the Sunday school with marked increase of interest among the teachers and pupils.
For Sunday evenings, he instituted the "Pleasant Sunday Evening Hour." -He invited the young people especially, saying frankly that the future of the church rested with them; and yet he assured the older ones that the}' would be no less welcome, and he believed they would find the meetings interesting and helpful. At the first of these "Pleasant Sunday Evening" meetings, the at 1 cudants found that the usual arrangement of settees had been changed, some of them set back against the walls of the vestry, and an informal array of chairs and settees drawn up in an attractive informal way about a center table, which had a bright red cover and a big bright center reading lamp, with song books and other interesting volumes scattered around. All who entered were greeted cordially and very informally by the pastor, and they chatted together in groups while others were coming, being invited to seat themselves as they chose. One of the young ladies sat down at the piano and played several selections of a high-grade but attractive sort, and soon the pastor suggested a "sing." The pastor made an earnest prayer, then read a selection from the Bible, having in mind a certain topic; and as he read he would suddenly ask some question suggested by the reading, and very soon the entire company, which at first was small, was earnestly talking together, and without realizing it, became interested and would talk in an intimate personal way of some of the deep spiritual things of life.
As these meetings proceeded, on successive Sunday evenings, the pastor encouraged discussion of personal problems ; drew out some of the objections or misunderstandings as to what some of the young people felt to be oldfashioned notions of belief and doctrines and the customary prayer meetings and the like. Intense interest in the spiritual life was developed; the meetings grew in attendance and influence; and finally the attendance became so large that their original character was somewhat overshadowed. As a result, the pastor was finally able to transfer the meetings to the main auditorium of the church, and by broadening the programme to include more of popular interest, the Sunday evening service was given new life. But the best result was that a number of the leading young men and young women of the parish were led by those earlier informal meetings to join the church. Another result was a deepening spiritual interest on the part of the pastor himself.
During the first two or three years of his pastorate, his sermons, though entertaining and instructive, and of a peculiar didactic quality which left a marked impression, were yet characterized by some as "more intellectual than spiritual." It was during this earlier period, also, that the pastor was somewhat criticized by the elder or more ' ' orthodox ' ' portion of his people because he was so active in the newly-organized Willimantic Golf Club. Some of these thought that he would better spend his time making parish calls, or even ' 1 praying with unconverted souls, as ministers used to do. ' ' One dear old lady, whose early training had taught her that the minister's chief business was to "cry aloud and spare not ' ' and ' ' bring sinners to the mercy seat, ' ' was quite incredulous when they told her that "our minister has been chosen president of the golf club." But it soon appeared that the minister was getting a strong hold on the young people ; the Pleasant Sunday Evening Club was getting in its work, and the final results were proving the wisdom of the pastor's move. Mr. George frankly attributed his own renewed spiritual inspiration, in the latter years of his Willimantic pastorate, not only to his deepening realization of the needs of his young people, but to a certain session of the Yale Convocation of Ministers, where sermons of special impress were preached by Lyman Abbott and other religious leaders. At all events, the latter half of his Willimantic ministry was marked by a deepening spiritual influence upon his parish, and the young people with whom he was so companionable and whom he led into the church still hold him in fond affection.
and lie resigned February 14, ending his pastorate here March 15th. Mr. George remained in Ithaca until about two years ago, when he resigned. He then preached for a time at Concord, N. H., in the church to which the Rev. Ashley Day Leavitt was called when he left Willimantic.
Recently Mr. George has been called to preach at the United Church in New Haven, while that society is seeking a successor to the Rev. Robert C. Dennison. In fact, Mr. George is developing a rare ability to follow the lines of constructive work so successfully done in former years by the Rev. Mr. Croft, as an interim pastor, and his services are so constantly sought for that .valuable work that he is urged by the leaders of his denomination to continue therein.
A successor to Mr. George was promptly found. As soon as Mr. George had signified his intention to accept the call to Ithaca, the committee of church and society to secure a new pastor were advised to look up a brilliant young preacher who was assistant pastor of the Rev. Dr. Edwin Pond Parker at the South Church in Hartford. The impression of several visitors who went to hear him was uniformly favorable and within less than a month a call was sent (April 5, 1904) to the Rev. Ashley Day Leavitt, who accepted the call, and entered upon his new duties May 1st, being installed May 25th. The fine promise of his record at Dr. Parker's Church was fulfilled, and for four years he developed his unusual power as a preacher, to the great enjoyment of this parish. He and his wife, nee Myrtle Hart of Hartford, were very popular with the young people. Leavitt came of a family of preachers, and he has since steadily advanced in position and power and influence in the pulpit. He was called from Willimantic to Concord, N. H., resigning in January, 1908, council . of dismissal held in February. From Concord he was called to Portland, Me., and in October, 1919, was installed as pastor of the Harvard Church at Brookline, Mass.
During Mr. Leavitt 's pastorate here the church organ was rebuilt by funds primarily provided by the will of Miss Jennie Ford, a life-long member of the church. The individual communion-cup service was installed. Mr. Leavitt was active in civic relations, especially in addresses at Board of Trade meetings and at school graduations. For several consecutive years he was chosen to give the baccalaureate address to graduating classes at the high school.
An interesting and unusual situation developed during the quest for a successor to Mr. Leavitt. At the time Mr. George left, Mr. Dinsmore had suggested the name of Rev. William S. Beard, then at Durham, N. H., but an inquiry developed the fact that Mr. Beard was not ready to leave Durham. The prompt discovery of Mr. Leavitt also terminated further quest. But now the name of Mr. Beard was again brought into consideration. Committees visited his church and came back with very favorable reports ; but also learned that he had just refused a $3,000 call to Boston, because he believed he was needed at Durham ; so it was inferred that the $2,200 salary at Willimantic would not attract him. An active inquiry was begun, and no less than forty clergymen, most of them candidates, were looked up, although in fact very little attention was paid to those who sought the job. The old-time plan of calling candidates to the home pulpit to preach on trial and undergo personal inspection had gone out of date many years before, as the committees had found it far more satisfactory to look up good men on the field where their work was in progress. Two or three favorable trails were followed without satisfaction or success. Finally the joint committee of church and society met one evening to face the fact that after weeks of inquiry they were without a prospect, and the outlook for finding the right man was discouraging. At this juncture Gen. E. S. Boss, chairman, inquired: "What about this man Beard; they all speak well of him - why can't we get him?" It was found that no decided attempt had been made, as it had been assumed for the reasons above stated that he would not leave Durham. It was decided to address a letter to the Rev. Dr. E. C. Hall of Manchester, N. H., asking him to "sound out" Mr. Beard and see if he would not consider the Willimantic church. It was pointed out that his father and uncle had served long pastorates years before at East Killingly and Brooklyn respectively (these pastorates are sketched elsewhere in this volume), and that a Windham County field should appeal to him, and that there was peculiar opportunity for usefulness in the Willimantic field. It was suggested that he had been ten years in Durham, and if he was ever going to move to a larger field it was about time he was considering it. In response to this appeal, Dr. Hall sent for Mr. Beard to confer with him at Manchester, told him of the special appeal from Willimantic, and advised him to give it very careful consideration. Mr. Beard talked it over with his Durham people and decided to take the Willimantic inquiry into consideration. Meanwhile a member of the Willimantic committee had been delegated to write him direct. Mr. Beard thereupon wrote, expressing his appreciation, and stated certain definite plans for the cooperation of the people with the minister which, if approved, would form the basis of his favorable consideration of a call to Willimantic if it should come.
Out of these preliminaries the Willimantic church and society not only framed a call to Mr. Beard, but by formal action pledged him definite support along the lines he had indicated. These facts are here recorded as indicating the basis of the unusual sucess of Mr. Beard's pastorate in Willimantic, because at the very outset both minister and people were pledged to a definite constructive programme.
The call to him was dated June 8, 1904, and he accepted, naming September 20th as the date to begin his service. He was installed December 2d. He remained in Willimantic until February 20, 1916, resigning to accept a position as assistant secretary of the Congregational Home Missionary Society, with headquarters in New York City, a position he still holds, although the scope of his work has been much enlarged in recent years, and he is now active in promoting the church extension work in the national field. He was released from his duties at the New York office in the fall of 1919 to take charge of the campaign for the Pilgrim Memorial Fund in Connecticut, the quota of this state being $660,000 of the national total of $5,000,000. Mr. Beard met with signal success and with the hearty cooperation of a group of fellow clergymen, several of them just returned from service in France, he not only raised Connecticut's quota, but carried the Connecticut pledges well beyond the $1,000,000 mark. He was then asked to go to Seattle to lead the campaign for the quota of Washington and Oregon for the same fund, where he met with similar success, returning to his New York duties April 1, 1920.
Some of us down in New Haven knew Vernon W. Cooke several years before you discovered him, and we could have told you that he was a pretty vigorous proposition to turn loose in Willimantic. He was a live westerner, a big football player, and while in Yale School of Religion did splendid service among my own clubs of Italian boys in teaching them clean hard-playing football and clean vigorous manhood, and in this relation I came to admire him greatly. He was certainly a noble influence among those impressionable Italian boys. He was very highly esteemed by church and parish during his two-years' pastorate in Derby, and they were sorry to have him go. He was called from Derby to the Willimantic church, April 13, 1916, and began his duties here. He soon manifested his breezy western vigor. It did not take him long to realize the moral inertia prevailing in civic affairs in Willimantic. He began to rally the men of his church for a municipal house cleaning. He preached a notable sermon in which he told the plain truth about the local situation. It was pretty strong meat and caused local indigestion. Soon after America entered the war, Mr. Cooke resigned the local pastorate to enter Y. M. C. A. service in France. His resignation was read January 26, 1918, effective February 1st, and leave of absence for four months was granted by the church with continuance of salary. A council of dismissal was called for June 26th. Mr. Cooke sailed for France March 18, 1918, returned June 22, 1919. His service overseas was warmly commended by the National Council of the Y. M. C. A.
Cooke was born in Klickitat County, Washington Territory, October 25, 1882, attended Portland, Ore., Academy, graduated from Whitman College 1911, Yale Divinity School 1914; was pastor at Derby, Conn., before coming to Willimantic. He is now pastor of the First Congregational Church at Western Springs, 111., just outside Chicago. He was married shortly before coming to Willimantic to Hazel Mildred Watts, whose home was near Portland, Ore., and they have a son Vernon Watts Cooke, born May 5, 1918.
An especially valuable achievement of Cooke's brief pastorate was the establishment of the summer camps at Crystal Lake, Eastford, for the young people of the Willimantic church. Mr. Cooke not only planned the work and raised the funds, but actually, with the help of several men of the parish, did a large share of the construction work, putting in many days of hard labor at the camp.
When I think of Cooke's outspoken attack upon civic indifference and moral laxity in the public service of this city, I am reminded of a Civil war story, an authentic instance of a certain brave color sergeant who in the enthusiasm of battle advance carried the standard too far forward, where it was in danger of capture. ' ' Bring those colors back to the line ! ' ' was the message sent to him by his captain. But the intrepid color bearer sent back the reply, "Bring your line up to the colors!" - and it was done and a memorable victory won. A splendid achievement and true for that emergency; but as a rule the colors cannot be sustained beyond where the line can steadily advance. Cooke did not understand Willimantic, and he planned too far ahead of the line; but the fact remains that the civic work he outlined ought to have been done long before - and it has not been done yet! (1920). I am not advocating the active participation of any church in politics - it is always unwise. Doctor Dinsmore maintained that it is the function of the preacher to give such spiritual inspiration to the members of his flock as will effectually permeate their civic as well as their church activities with fearless moral conviction and power. Dinsmore himself once preached a vigorous no-license sermon and put straight to some of his church members their responsibility for the liquor traffic when they voted for license. The sermon created considerable consternation, but Dinsmore told me afterwards that I was the only man in the congregation who congratulated him on that sermon! Another instance of taking the colors too far ahead of the
A considerable interval of supply followed the departure of Mr. Cooke, but the fall of 1918 a call was extended to the present incumbent, Rev. Harry S. McCready; he began his pastorate October 1, and he was installed June 17, 1919. He has already demonstrated that he is a worthy successor in this long line of unusually successful pastorates. He is a native of Pawtucket, R. I., attended public schools in Providence, trained at Brown University, and at Newton Theological Seminary; graduated at the latter institution in 1905. He entered the Baptist ministry and was ordained at First Baptist Church at Wallingford, Vt., August 22, 1905. He has held Baptist pastorates at Manchester Center, Vt. ; Roger Williams Church at Providence, R. I. ; First Baptist at Livermore Falls, Me. From the last named place he was called to the First Congregational Church at York, Me., and thence to the First Congregational Church at Willimantic. His pastoral work has developed along lines of broad social service in the essentials of religious faith, without denominational emphasis. Special features of his work at Willimantic are the Men's Forum at the Sunday noon hour, where current problems are discussed; a weekly play and picture night for the children of the community during the winter months ; a Sunday evening church school session, with educational classes for young men and women, also for mothers, and a class in pageantry or dramatics for the young people ; in brief, something of an institution for Christian culture and the development of wholesome social life. The educational classes are followed by a social hour.
Under Mr. McCready 's lead also a plan has developed to place portraits of former pastors on the walls of the parish house, beginning with that of Mr. Willard, presented by his daughter, Mrs. Mary Willard Cragin. The portrait of Mr. Free was given by Mr. and Mrs. Homer E. Remington; that of Doctor Dinsmore by Samuel Chesbro ; of Mr. George by Austin D. Boss and Helen Boss Cummings; of Mr. Beard by George S. Elliott and Mary Elliott Collyer,. and up to date assurances have been received of portraits of Mr. Winslow and Mr. Leavitt to be placed later.
Plans are on foot for the re-decoration of the church interior, and of certain new furnishings. A memorial pulpit and chairs will be given by Mrs. Jane Porteous Murray in memory of her late husband, Hugh C. Murray; a set of communion chairs in harmony with the Murray unit will be placed on the lower platform, the central chair given by Rev. Wm. S. Beard in memory of his father, and the donors of the remaining six chairs are, Mr. and Mrs. John M. Gager, in memory of their son, Harold; Louis Arnold, in memory of his wife ; Mr. and Mrs. William A. Buck, in memory of their son, Philip ; Mr. and Mrs. C. F. Risedorf, in memory of their daughter, Ethel; and by his sons and daughters in memory of their father, Deacon Benajah E. Smith.
Albert N. Colgrove, son of the late Dr. Charles H. Colgrove, and Lelia Moulton Colgrove, was born in Willimantic in 1876, and for many years local editor of the Chronicle, member of the town school board, active in local politics and withal a young man of fine influence in the community." Ten years ago he was called to Waterbury to become city editor of The American and has made a record in that city highly creditable. He was actively identified with the Congregational Church and the editor of this volume made special request that he write his recollections of the church life, with special reference to the ministry of Edward A. George. Mr. Colgrove has responded with the following article.
The first " church experience" which I can remember was in connection with the Rev. Horace Winslow. My mother had taken me with her to the church to attend an afternoon meeting, probably a meeting of the Ladies' Aid Society. During the afternoon I wandered away from the ' ' apron-strings ' ' and found myself in a terribly long and terribly dark passageway. Seeking to escape from the awesome place, I pushed open a door that happened to be ajar and toddled into a room which I came to know later as the pastor's study. And there was the pastor himself - the dignified, scholarly Horace Winslow. That dignified, scholarly man took me on his knee; told stories to me; showed me his watch ! And after all these years I still carry with me as my only mind picture of that splendid man the impression then indelibly imprinted - dignified and studious, but kindly, willing, nay glad, to let a little troubled child break in on his "quiet hour" long enough to receive comfort and go away happy - carrying with him the inspiration that comes from contact, even so brief as that with a man who was truly good. That is Horace Winslow as I recall him.
I remember, also, how I used to tease my mother to take me to the church socials and suppers. I always hoped there would be music at these affairs, for music meant the late William C. Jillson playing his well-remembered flute. I knew if Mr. Jillson was there, playing in the church orchestra, he would skip a note occasionally, to smile at the children. For when he was around, making sweet music, the sun always shone merrily for the church and Sunday school youngsters. In my own little category of saints and near-saints Santa Clans came first and W. C. Jillson second.
Another man who radiated happiness and gladness wherever he went was Fayette Safford who also was one of the saints of my childhood, and Fayette Safford continued to be a saint to me, albeit a very human one, through all the many later years that I knew him. Gentle, humble, patient, always sweettempered, he seemed to have almost a monopoly of those qualities which, in a superlative degree, I imagined every saint must have.
The Rev. Samuel R. Free both loved the children of the Willimantic church and was loved by them. I remember, in a vague, indefinite way, that Mr. Free's preaching wasn't quite orthodox enough to suit some of the elders. I heard the grown-ups arguing about it from time to time and I sensed that Mr. Free was the center of a controversy of some sort ; but in the details of that controversy I was not interested. I knew that Mr. Free was good to me, and that he was good to the boys and girls with whom I played and went to school ; therefore he must be a good and upright man. Those who said or thought otherwise must be all wrong. That was the way it struck me, a boy in grammar school then; and if memory served me right, such came to be the judgment of the community'almost as a whole - perhaps not all at once, but surely in later years.
Passing now to the pastorate of the Rev. Charles A. Dinsmore - now Doctor Dinsmore - when his sermons, as delivered from the Willimantic pulpit, prsl began to attract wide attention as the products of an unusually scholarly and brilliant mind, I had begun to reach " years of understanding," and as boy and young man I shared, more or less, in the " feast of good things," intellectual and spiritual, which this brainy young preacher spread weekly before large congregations. Mr. Dinsmore was not only a fine preacher but a good organizer - "executive," I believe is the proper word to use now. The Young Men's Sunday Evening Club, with the many splendid musical services that it provided, was the result of his work. I had my first military drilling and discipline as a member of the company of boys' brigade that he and Mr. Frederick A. Verplanck organized, receiving such good instruction under the drillmaster, Capt. Herbert R. Chappell, that when I joined the State Guard, in recent years, I had no hesitation in saying "Yes" when asked by the recruiting officers if I could lay claim to previous military training.
It is for his sermons though that I remember Doctor Dinsmore in his Willimantic pastorate best, and I think all who recall his preaching will agree with me that the outstanding feature of his ministry there was the strong appeal that his sermons made, especially to the men of the church and community, leaving upon them a marked impress, which still endures.
The Willimantic Congregational Church, both as an institution and through its members, has held a leading place not only in the religious life of the town, but in social and educational activities as welL And if, as has sometimes been charged, the "brick church" has taken active part in the politics of the town, also then it has always stood for the right and for what was for the good of all the townspeople. It has had for its pastors, in most instances, men who by both inclination and training were well fitted to lead, and men who could not only give the message of better citizenship from the pulpit on Sundays, but knew how to put it into practice on week-days.
When the Rev. Edward A. George came to Willimantic to be pastor of its Congregational Church he brought with him qualities of leadership along 1 1 somewhat different ' 9 lines. He, too, was a thoughtful man and a studious man, but he laid more emphasis than had any of his predecessors, perhaps, on the fact that the religion of Jesus Christ is essentially a cheerful religion. He was glad of what the old New England fathers had done for us, and was willing to give them due credit for building the foundations and building them strong and well; but he had no tolerance for long-faced Christianity of the old-fashioned kind. He was once heard to remark, after listening to a twenty-minute prayer, as delivered by one of the deacons in the Sunday school, that he believed the Lord appreciated quality (rather than quantity) in prayers as well as in men.
From the very start of Mr. George's pastorate it was generally realized that everything that savored too much of sanctimoniousness would have to go. Those who were quick to appreciate the change that he desired to bring about in the general atmosphere of the church joined with him in finding the spots to which he might apply his gospel of cheerfulness. The Y. P. S. C. E., for one thing, ceased to function, and in its place came the Young People's Society and its "Pleasant Sunday Evenings" - as the Sunday evening services held under the auspices of this new church organization came to be known.
The "Pleasant Sunday Evenings" were unique for that church and city. The services were held in the church parlors, with no pulpit in sight and no high-back pews, nor low-back pews, either. Piano lamps and easy chairs were brought in from nearby homes; cozy corners were created and the general effect was that of a large but extremely home-like drawing room. For the first half-hour there was an informal sing, with only the " cheerf ulest ' ' tunes in the hymn-book permitted. Then Mr. George would give a talk, possibly on some especially inspiring or unusually beautiful chapter of the Bible, or a brief review of some discussion of some religious question or topic, with every one free to " speak right out in meeting" and tell what he really felt.
One memorable night there was a ' ' question-box, ' ' with every person attending the meeting asked to write down on a slip of paper what he held to be, first, his greatest doubt (with regard to the Christian religion) and second, his deepest conviction. Mr. George took the slips from the box, one after another, and read what he found written thereon, answering from his own rich knowledge and experience such questions as called for answer. I think no one who was present and took part in that service will ever forget what a helpful occasion it was.
I remember also the Sunday night, at one of those meetings that Mr. George broached the subject of church membership. There was nothing spectacular or dramatic about the presentation. There was no "mourners' bench" or "conviction corner" and no' "hitting the trail." It was simply the straightforward question - did these young people believe in Jesus Christ and his church? Did they believe with him, their pastor, that the church stood for the highest life of both the individual and the community? Would they not, then, give expression to that belief by becoming members of the church - this church, their church ? That was all there was to it as far as words were concerned, but possibly a service more truly religious had never been held in that room before. And with no other appeal than that, numbers of young people did become members of the church during the succeeding Sundays.
The Young People's Society also sponsored socials, concerts and lecture courses, held in the church, and all of them conducted on a high plane. Various young men, prominent in the community but taking no particular interest in the church or its affairs, consented to serve on the society's "business committees" and in this way were brought into touch with church activities. It was all quite a departure from the "old-time religion" and some of the sister Congregational churches of the county seemed to question if it was religion of any kind.
The writer happened to be serving as president of the organization at the time of a county conference of Congregationalists, held at Thompson. Presenl at the conference as a delegate, I was unexpectedly called upon to tell what "the new Young People's Society of the Willimantic church" was all about. I was put "under fire" in a kindly but determined manner, by some of the ministers. It was all very interesting as an experiment, what I had told them, they said, but what of the Christian Endeavor Society and other soul-winnin«r agencies - agencies that had long been tested and not found wanting? Why consign them to oblivion ?
I believe my answer was that we had no desire to consign anything or anyone to oblivion. The simple fact of the situation was that in our Willimantic church we had sensed a peculiar need which the prayer meeting and the Christian Endeavor did not seem to be supplying. The church had not been reach ing nearly as many of the young people as it ought to reach. If the new Young People's Society was to be viewed in the light of an experiment, so be it. We
Mr. George and Mrs. George were persons of unusual culture. An evening at their charming home (now the residence, on Windham Street, of Mr. and Mrs. Christopher C. Case) was sure to be one of rare delight. As minister and man Mr. George carried the gospel of good cheer wherever he went. He combined, with his ministerial duties, such things as an occasional boxing match, with some athletically-inclined parishioner, or a frequent game of golf. In fact, he devoted so much of his spare time to initiating certain of youth of the town into the mysteries of the latter form of sport that he was criticised therefore by people who had no use for "such foolishness" in a minister. But if he did play golf, he played it well, and made of it a game worth playing, just as he made of a sermon something more than just a discourse - rather an appeal to his hearers to play the game of life, not only fairly and squarely, but in a big, broad, noble way.
Mr. George, while courteous and considerate in his dealings with all, especially delighted in the fellowship of men. He delighted to meet with them, delighted to chat with them, and, yes, delighted to smoke with them - provided the cigars were worth the smoking ! He was ' ' a man among men ' ' and seldom preached to or "lectured" his social or business acquaintances, in fact never without he gave them fair warning. When the subject of religion and church membership happened to come up in conversation, if his views were sought, he always said to mature men and women what he had already said to the young people - that the church was a very vital part of the life of nation, state and town; an institution without which no community could claim to be a Christian community, and as much entitled to the active and enthusiastic support of every public-spirited citizen as any other institution founded and maintained for the benefit of the people as a whole ; indeed much more so than many.
One well-known Willimantic business man, affiliated with a church of another denomination, once said of Mr. George, "For an aristocrat he's the most democratic man I ever knew." His daily association with men and his frank, common-sense speech with them concerning religion won to the Willimantic church, as members, a fine group of young business and professional men, many of whom have continued active in its affairs ever since and are now among those to whom the church organization looks (and never in vain) for strong and helpful leadership, wise counsel and generous support.
Rev. Horace Winslow
Such comments might have been heard as the Rev. Horace Winslow, coming from the railroad station in Willimantic one day in the winter of 1868-69, turned into Main Street on the way to consult with members of his future parish, that of the First Congregational Church. He received his call from that church in December, 1868, while acting pastor of the First Congregational
Not only were the people now to have a new pastor, after an interval of several months since the resignation of the Rev. Mr. Willard, but they were also minded to have a new church edifice. The one then in use, erected in 1828 and enlarged by an addition of fifteen feet in 1843, was in 1869 entirely inadequate for the needs of the congregation. Efforts had been made to build anew but the plans did not materialize, and the time had not seemed ripe for the attempt.
Now, however, it was decided to build and Mr. Winslow, having already had much experience in such matters, was looked to for pushing the enterprise to completion. In a historical address delivered by him in the ' 'new church'' on July 9, 1876, he describes the situation as he found it on coming to the growing parish. He says : "At this time the long-contemplated work of erecting a new church edifice was entered upon with energy. As in all former periods, the needs of the people seemed to be beyond their means. * * * It was with considerable effort that the Ecclesiastical Society could meet its annual expenses. This obstacle was still in the way. The jjhurch was not rich and but few men of independent means were connected with the society. It appeared like a desperate undertaking, to build and pay for such a house as would meet the wants of the congregation. A subscription was started and resulted in raising $10,800. By the sale of the old church and grounds the amount was raised to $19,578. With these funds in hand the society resolved to begin the work. ' '
The building committee appointed by the society consisted of Messrs. John Tracy, Allen Lincoln, William C. Jillson and the pastor. Mr. Winslow 's associates were men of the highest business standing, a liberality and sound judgment. The committee were limited to an expenditure of $30,000 but found it impossible to secure a contract at that sum for such a church as was needed. So that it was decided . to omit the chapel, the interior decoration, and the windows, and a contract was made with Messrs. Chappell and Potter of Willimantic, for a little over $26,000, above the under-pinning.
The Ladies' Society provided carpets, cushions and pulpit furniture at a cost of $2,600. The organ was paid for separately, at $2,000, and the interior painting at an expense of $1,500, was mostly provided for by separate subscription.
When Mr. Winslow suggested that the windows be left out, Mr. Tracy asked, "What will you do without windows?" Mr. Winslow replied, "I wrill have them given." Mr. Tracy said, "You can't get one!" However, Mr. Winslow thought differently and it afterward transpired that Mr. Tracy himself was the first individual to offer the gift of a window, though the Sunday school had started the campaign "by a cordial vote to raise $100 for a children's window." The entire number, those in the vestibule, the church proper, also in the lectureroom and parlors, were secured by Mr. Winslow as he had planned. All were gifts and a number were memorials. He engaged a leading firm to furnish the windows and went himself to New York City to select the designs.
The rose window in the vestibule, over the central door, was given by Mr. Harry Boss, father of E. S. and Charles L. Boss, and Deacon J. E. Cushion n. in memory of Mr. Calvin Robinson, uncle of James G. Robinson, who joined the church in 1820, the year following its organization, and met sudden death in 1870 by being thrown from his carriage. The monogram C. R. is in the center, while the Scripture legend, "A good man and a just," tells in brief the story of his life and character. Upon the death, later, of the donors, this window became a memorial of all three men.
The two small windows in the vestibule were the gift of Mrs. Eunice Richmond Kellogg, who afterward became Mrs. George P. Heap, in memory of her granddaughter, Marion P. Lord.
On entering the audience room, one notices the beautiful children's window, at the pulpit end, the first one on the east side. The superintendent of the Sunday school at that time and for several years afterward was Deacon Nathan A. Stearns, a man of quiet manner and lovable qualities. The writer, who was among the little ones at the time of the dedication, can see him plainly - always greeting us with a smile and often a pleasant word. His son, Charles A. Stearns, now resides in Willimantic.
The next window on the east was Mr. John Tracy's gift, in memory of his two daughters, Olivia and Cora, who had died in early life. Mr. Tracy, a member of the building committee, was a leading man of the society and the town, always ready to help in any way and a liberal giver toward the expenses of the church. His death in the early '70s was a great blow to his pastor.
The third window was given by Mr. William C. Jillson as a memorial to his father and mother. Mr. Jillson, also of the committee, was one of Mr. Winslow's most valued friends and ever an active worker and firm supporter of the society. He gave largely toward the building of the church and the payment of the debt, his name appearing with a substantial figure attached, upon nearly every subscription paper circulated during those years. Many of his acts of friendliness and neighborly kindness are remembered by the recipients.
The fourth is the "Pastor's Window" - placed there through funds contributed by all the then-living pastors of the church and by personal friends of Mr. Winslow residing in other towns. The names upon the red tablet are: Dennis Piatt, Philo Judson, Andrew Sharpe, Samuel G. Willard, Horace Winslow. Although Mr. Piatt was not settled over the church, he was its first shepherd and was instrumental in establishing it upon a firm basis.
The fifth window on the east was from Mr. James D. Sawyer, a former member of the church and connected with the Hosmer family. He removed from the town about 1839, but from his generous contributions evidently retained a warm regard for his church home of former years.
On the west side, the first window - opposite the children's on the east - was presented by the Men's Bible Class, the teacher at that time being Deacon Henry B. Gates. Mr. Winslow remarked of him many years afterward: "I remember him well; he was a good man."
Next comes the window given by Mr. Hosmer, as a memorial to his daughter Letetia. The Hosmers were all liberal givers to this church. The name ' ' Hosmer Mountain" perpetuates their memory.
The third window, in memory of brothers and sisters, was a gift of Mrs. A. T. Marcy of Hartford, Conn., a sister of Mr. Jillson. It faces that one presented by him.
The fourth, inscribed with the words "Be not weary in well-doing," was the gift of Mr. Charles L. Bottum, a warm friend and ever loyal supporter of his pastor. He was one of the most generous and frequent givers to the church, according to his means. Through all the arduous years of building and of throwing off the debt, he was never found wanting. Mr. Winslow enjoyed on summer evenings driving with some of his family to Mr. Bottum's pleasant home at Conantville, where the door always stood open in hospitality. Mr. Bottum possessed a kindly spirit and cheerful disposition and after losing competence through those who owed him nought but gratitude and affection, he tried to make the best of adversity and to keep a sunny temper. In a letter written to one of Mr. Bottum's family soon after his death in 1884, Mr. Winslow said of him, ' ' He was not a church member, but when I reach the heavenly home, I expect to greet my dear old friend."
The fifth window was given by Mr. George H. Chase of New York and Stamford, in memory of his father, Mr. Laban S. Chase of Willimantic, who was injured by a fall and passed away soon afterward on Christmas day, 1869.
The two mullion windows in the gallery were the gift of Mrs. John D. Norton of Syracuse, N. Y. ; one is a mmeorial to her husband and the other to her sister, Miss Mary D. Hosmer. Mrs. Norton was a sister of Messrs. James D. and William Hosmer, her former home having been in Willimantic and she was pleased to aid in beautifying the church which her brothers were helping to erect.
Thus furnished at one time by one firm and selected by one person, these windows have a unity as well as variety and are harmonious with each other and with the building in which they are placed.
The lot on which the church stands, at the northeast corner of Valley and Walnut streets, was a gift from Mr. Thomas Cunningham. Additional land was bought later. The old frame church standing on the south side of Main Street, after having been sold, was remodeled for business purposes and has since been known as the Melony Block. The new church was built of brick, in Italian Gothic style. It stands 104 feet by 63 feet, in the clear, and seats over nine hundred persons.
Referring again to Mr. Winslow 's historical discourse we read: "In July of 1869 the cornerstone of the new edifice was laid with appropriate ceremonies and in one year from that time it was dedicated to the service of God. Rev. Dr. Burton of Hartford preached the sermon; the pastor gave an address and offered the dedicatory prayer. The people' entered with gladness into their new and beautiful house of worship, and the congregation steadily increased. The need of a chapel was soon seriously felt * * * and it was finally decided to proceed with the addition of a chapel provided the funds could be secured as the work went on. Several hundred dollars had already been raised by subscription for this object, and the society voted to proceed with the work, so far as means could be secured. The foundation for this addition was laid in the fall of 1870 and on the 7th of May, 1871, the chapel was dedicated. * * * This addition cost $3,469. Great credit was due to Deacon Cushman, the committee, for the economy with which this work was done. The parlor was soon furnished by the ladies of the society, but the other rooms were provided only with seats taken from the old lecture room.
"Up to this time the whole cost of the enterprise was $47,700. This included land, building, organ, carpets, cushions and furniture. While no debt had been contracted in the addition of a chapel a debt had accumulated upon the society, to the amount of $12,600. * * * To raise this amount seemed hope less to most of the society. In a few cases there was faith, but the prevailing feeling was doubt, and now I think it is due to the glory of G-od, to recognize His hand in the work. He went before and prepared the hearts of this people, so that they not only gave as He enabled them to do, but they gave cheerfully. * * * The spirit of the meeting called on the first day of October (1872) to hear the result, testified to the general joy," for the $12,000 had been subscribed for and the remaining $600 were raised on the spot.
A praise service was held on the following Sabbath and the pastor writes of it that "joy and gladness filled the house. " "The debt removed," he says again, "there was a desire to have the chapel property furnished and decorated, so as fitly to compare with the main audience room. The pastor had liberty to do this if he could secure the funds, and in about a year from that time the whole was handsomely painted, seated and carpeted at an expense of about six hundred dollars."
The work of laying a slate roof on the church was done by Mr. J. F. Poindexter, who afterward put the slate on Loomer Opera House and on several other buildings in Willimantic. Mr. Poindexter, who is living at the present time in Simsbury, Conn., states that Mr. Winslow, in the interest of the society, kept the time of the men as they worked on the roof; each night he compared his notes with those of Mr. Poindexter and according to the latter, they always agreed.
Mention should also be made of the excellent work of the builders, Messrs. Chappell and Potter. There could be no complaint for everything was faithfully carried out according to contract - a lesson to many firms of today. Both members of the firm have ere this passed away, but their work remains.
As in other pastorates where Mr. Winslow had been instrumental in furthering the bviilding of new church edifices, so in Willimantic he gave the designs and proportions ; and all of those churches, including this, were so constructed in regard to hearing, speaking, seeing and ventilation, as to show that he had successfully solved those important problems.
The building of this church has been dwelt upon at some length for several reasons: it was a most important undertaking of Mr. Winslow 's pastorate and marked an epoch in the history of the First Congregational Church. It was no light load of responsibility that he carried in respect to the success of it all, as is evidenced by the fact that for the building of the church and the clearing off of the debt, more than $18,000 were raised by his personal efforts alone. He felt that no church could do its best work for a community when in cramped quarters or encumbered by debt; hence he bent all his energies to the accomplishment of that which seemed the most pressing need of the hour.
One of his parishioners remarked to him upon the completion of the church, "If you had never accomplished anything else, this one work would be sufficient for a lifetime." Mr. Winslow deeply appreciated the whole-hearted manner in which the people responded when he approached them for money, even when called upon again and again. He once stated that no one to whom he applied ever refused him. Mr. Allen Lincoln, of the building committee, was a leading business man of never-failing friendliness and generosity. At the time of removing the debt, Mr. Winslow asked him for the $100 which had been promised by Mr. Lincoln, who promptly replied, "I'll give you three hundred. ' '
Deacon Cushman was another large giver. In a certain conversation which he had with his pastor, Mr. Cushman said that he had given toward the building of the church one-tenth of his property - not one-tenth of his income, but of all that he possessed. His liberality is well illustrated by an incident of a few years later, when the good deacon having removed to a neighboring city attended one of the largest and wealthiest churches in that place. It was customary in that church for anyone who had not as much money with him as he desired for any special object to write the sum upon a slip of paper and drop that into the box. One Sunday, a collection for foreign missions being called for, Mr. Cushman dropped into the box a slip representing $100. After the service an official of the church came to him and said : 1 1 The slip you put in is a mistake, I suppose; it is marked $100. I presume you intended it for $1.00." "No," said Mr, Cushman, much amused, "I intended it just as I wrote it - $100."
Mr. Cushman finally settled in California for his health but lived only a few years afterward. As a proof of the love he bore, to his latest day, for the Willimantic church of which he was for many years a faithful and liberal officer, he left to it in his will a considerable sum of money.
Mrs. Cushman, with other "honorable women," gave years of service in the Sunday school, and the church was the recipient from Mrs. Cushman of the beautiful communion service, presented in 1870.
So, on every side, were evidences of the generosity and cordial responsiveness of men and women both within and without the circle of the church and congregation. Few churches, perhaps, have been built which were more truly labors of love, love that demanded, in many cases, no doubt, a real self-sacrifice. Thus, wrought into the very structure itself, glowing through the incoming light, heard in the tones of the organ, were the faith, the love, and the good deeds of scores of persons, the majority of whom have probably even now gone to their reward. But sweet and holy influences are still all around to lead those who come after up into the glorious light o£ the Gospel.
In all this activity above considered, the pastor's mind and heart were not directed from what is usually considered the legitimate business of a Christian minister. During the nineteenth century, revivals were common and some people looked upon them as rather essential to a well-conducted pastorate. Mr. Winslow was in sympathy with sincere desire for arousing the indifferent and spurring on the slackers. Revivals occurred in all the churches over which he was settled. He believed it important for a church to sustain a healthy religious interest at all times, but also that there were seasons which for one cause or another seemed conducive to a general awakening in religious and spiritual matters.
He advocated union meetings as a means of promoting Christian brotherhood among churches of different denominations, and years before inter-church movements or the like were generally thought of.
For a number of years in "Willimantic he conducted a Bible class of young men and was ever deeply anxious for the growth and welfare of the Sunday school. He also founded a Young People's Meeting which before the days of Christian Endeavor had a goodly attendance of the young people of the church and was usually conducted by one of their number. At the close, most of them stayed for the regular evening service, where they formed no inconsiderable portion of the assembly.
In the latter part of his service, he organized at the "New Village" a mission Sunday school, the success of which was made possible by the generous cooperation of the late Hon. Eugene S. Boss, agent of the Willimantic Linen
Company. This school, whose teachers were men and women of the Congregational Church, numbered over one hundred members when Mr. Winslow left town and turned the superintending over to Mr. Benajah Smith.
Mr. Winslow was fond of young people and loved to work among them. Mrs. Winslow, too, was interested in the children and as soon as the chapel was finished, started a primary class which she taught until nearly the close of her husband's pastorate, having at times over sixty children on the membership roll. Before leaving Willimantic she turned over the class to Mrs. Morse, wife of Capt. Stephen Morse. ' ' Eddie" Morse, one of the little ones at that time, is now the head of Morse Business College in Hartford.
During Mr. Winslow 's connection with the Willimantic church, a large number of persons joined it by profession and by letter. Outside of the duties to his family, his church was his first care and its calls were paramount. At the time of the trial of Henry Ward Beecher, Mr. Winslow was invited to sit in the council of ministers that was to hear and pass upon the charges that were brought against the famous divine. A great admirer and loyal supporter of Doctor Beecher, he would have been glad to help counteract the effect of what he considered mere calumnious attacks upon a great and good man; but as attendance upon the council would have obliged him for a considerable period to be much away from home between Sundays, he declined the appointment.
At another time he was urged to be a candidate to represent the Town of Windham in the Legislature. Intensely interested in good government and in whatever would make for the welfare of the community and the state, such an opporunity, though unsought, made its appeal to him. That work would also have taken time and effort that he felt in justice belonged to his parish, and again he declined.
Mr. and Mrs. Winslow in after years often recalled with gratitude the almost universal kindness which their household received at the hands of the people of Willimantic and especially of the Congregational Church. They were located in the midst of pleasant neighbors to whom they were indebted for numberless acts of friendliness.
In 1876 Mr. Winslow suffered a severe accident, his case being considered by his physicians as serious, even critical for a time. At this his church generously gave him a six-mouths vacation which, no doubt, was the means of prolonging his life. Though recovery was rapid, he was never afterward in as firm health as before. At last feeling no longer able to endure the strain of active pastoral labor, he offered his resignation, in March, 1881, and left town two or three months later, removing after a pastorate of twelve years, to the Town of Simsbury, in Hartford County, Conn. Until laid aside by illness in the late '90s, he continued preaching, supplying pulpits in Connecticut and neighboring states.
On January 22, 1903, occurred the seventy-fifth anniversary of the organization of the First Congregational Church of Willimantic, and Mr. Winslow was invited to give an address, but the inclemency of the season and increasing infirmities made it impossible for him to attend that interesting occasion.
Horace Winslow was born in Enfield, Mass., May 18, 1814, and passed away at his residence in Weatogue, Simsbury, Conn., March 6, 1905, at the age of nearly ninety-one years. Funeral services were held in the Simsbury Congregational Church and burial was in the ancient Simsbury cemetery.
He served for a time as chaplain of the Fifth Regiment, Connecticut Volunteers, in the Civil war, and was long an officer of the Joseph R. Toy Post, Grand Army of the Republic of Simsbury. Comrades of the post bore his body to the grave.
Of strong convictions and with a deep spiritual nature, yet he was progres sive in thought and possessed a vigorous, inquiring mind. With these and many lovable qualities, he commanded the respect of men in every walk of life. One of his parishioners once remarked to the writer : ' ' Your father was always my ideal of a Christian minister." When eighty-three. years old, and not in the best of health, he was in attendance at a conference of ministers and church members, when he was unexpectedly called on to address the company and the brief remarks he made were not surpassed in strength and clarity of thought by those of the other speakers.
"Early in August, 1849, a week or two before the close of my three years in the Divinity School at New Haven, I received a handsomely written letter dated at Willimantic, and signed by William L. Weaver, stating in behalf of the committee that the church needed a pastor, and asking if I would come and preach three or four Sabbaths. Of Willimantic I knew nothing except that it was on the' line of the Railroad over the charter of which such an excitingcontest had been waged in the Legislature at New Haven three years earlier. I was an entire stranger to almost every one in that portion of the state, and was at a loss to understand to whom I was indebted for an introduction to the Willimantic Church. However, I accepted the invitation, and promised to preach the Sabbath following Commencement.
"The manner of reaching the place from New Haven was by stage every other day from Hartford. Leaving New Haven by the railroad at eleven A. M., Hartford was reached by one o'clock, and as it was my first visit, I was interested in the somewhat primitive way in which the train was pushed into the station which stood some distance southeast of the present structure. Half an hour later I entered the four-horse stage-coach for Willimantic. Among the passengers was Mr. Samuel Perkins, of Philadelphia, and his son, whom I hail known as a student in College; also, Mr. Hill, a native of Norwich, and a graduate of Yale four years earlier, '45."
Provenance
Text from A Modern History of Windham County, Connecticut : a Windham County Treasure Book, published 1920, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.