BlockBefore

Stratford Town (part 7 of 14)

Part 7 of 14 of the account of this town in A History of the Old Town of Stratford and the City of Bridgeport, Connecticut, published 1886. 15,992 words, covering 9 settlements. Source changes inside the text are labelled at the exact paragraph where the next book begins.

Contents

1 section

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter, on this part. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Parts

14 pages

The source prints this as one continuous account. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs straight on across the parts and nothing is omitted.

The chapter

15,992 words

Reproduced complete and unedited from A History of the Old Town of Stratford and the City of Bridgeport, Connecticut, published 1886. The text is machine-read from scans, so expect recognition errors: misspelled names, dropped words, and stray characters. Nothing has been corrected, because correcting a proper name invents one. The headings below are the books' own; source changes are labelled in place.

The farmers of Stratford resided in the village, and went out to their farms, from one to three miles, in the true oriental style, to do the work of the farm. In the morning they were seen going out with their teams, man}^ of them to the south, to the Old Field, and the Great Neck, all of which was put into one great field, about 1693, the fence crossing from the rocks on Little Neck, west to mill brook, and all the land south of it, being in the field. The Old Field, at first did not include the Great Neck. Other of the farmers went to the New Field, joining the village on the southwest, between it and the swamp. Then there was a field called Nesingpaws, on the west side of Mill brook, as called in the deeds about 1700, and after, or west of the swamp extending to Bruce's Brook; and from this field, or Bruce's Brook to the old yellow mill, was the Far-field; then the Newpasture field south of Old Mill Green, and Pequonnock field south of Golden Hill. There was also a common field - not very large - at Oronoke, besides what was called the great meadow at that place.

As the families settled back into the wilderness, they needed mills of various kinds to facilitate the work and comfort of life. To build a small saw mill was an enterprise of venture, requiring much energy and considerable money, as then money was estimated. The town owned all the millsites, as well as the land around them, and therefore none of them could be used without a grant from the town. At first, besides granting the privilege of the mill, the town gave to the person who should build a gristmill several acres of land, upon condition that the party "should grind the town's corn," for a sixteenth or twelfth or an eighth part of the grain brought to the mill.

At this time, 1700, there had been two gristmills and two fulling mills built, and soon after several other mills were erected, as the following records show :

" December 25, 1704, Benjamin Sherman, John Williams, and John Seeley were granted liberty to erect a gristmill upon Pequonnock river at the narrows below Essay's pond." Upon securing this site they were to sign certain articles of agreement with the selectmen.

"January 11, 1705-6, the town granted liberty to Mr. Ephrain-. Stiles to set up a gristmill at Farmill river, a little below Black brook, near the place called the Plum-trees." At the same time the town granted full liberty to Lt. Tomlinson to maintain his fulling mill on Farmill river.

"February 14, 1721-2, Mr. John Edwards requested liberty to " erect a fulling mill upon the river on the west side of Ox hill," and in 1724 Mr. Edwards and Lt. Richard Hub-

" December 5, 1725. Upon the request of Zechariah Beardslee, Charles Lane and Ephraim Judson, to erect a sawmill and make a dam for said mill at the south corner of Acquanquedy plain on the west sprain of the Farmill river, the town grants their request, with this proviso, that they satisfy for all damage that their dam may cause in any particular person's land."

"December 29, 1725. Liberty was granted Captain Josiah Curtiss and Mr. John Willcoxson, Jr., to erect a sawmill on the halfway river," at the north end of the town.

The Rev. Israel Chauncey died at Stratford March 14, 1702-3, in the 39th year of his ministry, and the 59th year of his age; which appears to have been an unexpected event without forewarning, as he was not aged, or in any way enfeebled. He had been a successful, faithful minister, and seems to have been very acceptable in the parish, his salary having been increased at several times, being the highest, and standing at ;^i 12, and his yearly allowance of wood, at his decease.

Two candidates for the supply of the pulpit were soon secured; Mr. Nathaniel Hubbard, of the class of Harvard, 1698, and Mr. Joseph Morgan. Upon this the town came together on May 7, 1703, and voted to buy a house "of Daniel Shelton for ;^ioo cash, for the minister in Stratford," but "after the vote was recorded, Isaac Knell, Joseph Fairchild, Edward Hinman, Samuel Peat, sen., and Timothy Titharton, did protest against buying Mr. Shelton's house." This is the first intimation of trouble that the records afford, nor is there any reason stated for the opposition.

The next proceeding, at the same meeting, was to apply for Mr. Reed to preach, and " Nathaniel Sherman was by vote chosen as agent for the town, forthwith with all convenient speed to go to Hartford and endeavor, by all lawful means, the obtaining of Mr. Reed for the work above said." Mr.

Reed was secured and preached, and the August following the town voted him " ^40 pay in provision and £6 for firewood for half a year, and Mr. Nathaniel Sherman, Sergt. John Hawley, Mr, Jeremiah Judson, were appointed a committee to " take care of transporting Mr. Reed's family from Hartford, and providing a suitable habitation for him." The next February - 8, 1703-4 - on a proposition for settling a minister, Mr. Reed received 96 votes; Mr. Hubbard, 18; and Mr. Morgan, 15.

Mr. Reed continued to preach regularly until November 14, 1704, when he received 70 votes, and there were " 14 votes to the contrary," On the 24th of April, 1705, "there being some persons dissatisfied with the former vote," another was taken, and Mr. Reed received ^"j, for settlement, there being "43 otherwise," and 32 not voting. The last vote taken to settle him was on September 25, 1706, in which the whole number of votes was much smaller, he having 63 votes.

Very soon, following this last vote, perhaps before, some talk was indulged in by the public, which Mr. Reed resented and demanded inquiry, and hence the following action by the town :

" November 20, 1706. Whereas, the Revd. Elders in their advice to the town of Stratford, recommended to take all suitable care to purge and vindicate Mr. Reed from such scurrilous and abusive reflections (if any be) that such sentiments may reasonably be supposed to being upon him; and Mr. Reed in order thereto, having laid before the town his request that the town would be pleased to call a Council of Elders to hear what shall be proper to lay before them in order for a clearing of his name from those abusive reflections that he is apprehensive have been put upon him."

In harmony with this request choice was made of the " Revds. Mr. Andrews, Mr. Pierpont, Mr. Webb and Mr. Chauncey, by the town, to be a committee for that end ;" and a day of fasting and prayer was appointed.

No indication as to what was said offensive to Mr. Reed or to his parish, has been found, except the intimation that he had made overtures to join the Episcopal Church ; but what-

It has been represented, also, that Mr, Reed was unkindly and almost uncivilly treated by his parish, in an effort to deprive him of his salary ; and that they were countenanced in it by the neighboring ministers. This is a wholly gratuitous reflection, since his salary was continued regularly by town vote at one hundred pounds a year - a salary nearly equal to that of the preceding minister, and also to that of Mr. Cutler, who followed him, and this salary was as regularly paid, probably, as that of any minister in the Colony ; as exhibited, in the records in the book of town acts for those current years of his service.^ Mr. Reed regularly resigned his ministerial relations to the town on the 27th of March, 1707^ and a full settlement was made with him.

Following Mr, Reed, Mr, Francis Goodhue was a candidate, and on July 18, 1707, he had 41 votes for settlement, with quite a number of persons present not voting. The meeting was adjourned one week when he had 42 votes, out 83 cast, and the town voted to allow him one hundred pounds a year while he should preach here ; but he continued only a short time and Mr. James Hale preached for a time in the latter part of the year 1707.

" not one vote against or for any other person, but the vote was so small that nothing was done further until January following, when he had 55 votes in favor, and 38 for others. The next June they voted to seek for a stranger, and appointed seven prominent men to obtain one ; the result being that, on September 16, 1709, action of the town was taken " for the continuance of Mr. Cutler amongst us in the work of the ministry in order for a settlement, of 103 in favor and none against;" and he was offered £'^0, yearly salary, which was less than they had paid, during several years previous, but it was afterwards raised.

They next proposed a settlement, and September 30, 1709, "voted to give Mr. Cutler a home lot of one or two acres, to build a house on it of forty-two feet in length and twenty in breadth, a girt house, two story high with a suitable porch, every way well finished, and one hundred acres of land in the six-mile division, to be his own, his heirs, executors forever, provided he settle with us and continue in the work of the ministry, and to give him the use of eight acres pasture and four or five of meadow, and after two years to pay him yearly ^^140 country pay as salary. This amount was afterwards changed to ^^"93-06-8, current mone3% instead of " produce at fixed prices." " All, provided his disciplining be agreeable with the way of the Colony or country at present or future."

During these years of progress from 1680, the meeting house, from which the old bell rang out a cheerful sound every day at nine o'clock in the evening,^ became crowded, and on January 22, 1700-1, the town voted that there should be a gallery built in the meeting house, and a committee was appointed to proceed with the work, which they did, for the remaining expense of it was ordered paid the next January. This was an end gallery, for in 1715 "two side galleries " were built " at the charge of the town,"' and on March 2,

* "Dec. 29, 1691. The present townsmen by vote were impowered to hire some suitable person or persons to sweep the meeting house and ring the bell on all public days and at nine of the clock every evening.

* "January, 1715-16. The committee of the Meetinghouse gallery then agreed and bargained with Josiah Hubbell and Israel Burritt to build the flank galleries

1718, they "voted that the seats of each gallery shall be seated, the west side gallery with married men, the east gallery with married women, and antiant bachelors and antiant maides the second seats."

In May, 1713, the town voted liberty to Doctor Laboree to "erect and build a pew on the south side of the west door of the meeting house at his own expense." A few years previous to this, Richard Blackleach had made a pew for his family in this house, and these probably were all the pews then in the house ; the other seats were high backed slips like other meeting houses at that day.

In 171 5, "liberty was granted to the farmers to erect suitable shelter for their horses on all public days at some convenient place, with the advice of the selectmen."

The Rev. Timothy Cutler had preached in Stratford just ten years, when the trustees of Yale- College invited him to become Rector of that institution, and Stratford reluctantly consented to the change. The town, in response to the desire of the trustees, communicated to it, July 31, 1719, appointed a committee to hear the propositions which might be made, and adjourned to a specified day, to hear the report ; which was communicated at the time and action taken :

"At "a town meeting in Stratford, September 7, 1719, several proposals presented by the Rev. Trustees Respecting Mr. Cutler's Remove from us to the Great work of a Rector of Yale College being laid before the town for further thought and consideration, and the town seriously cpnsidering thereof did unanimously signify their great grief and sorrow Respecting Mr. Cutler's Remove from us who under God hath been the happy instrument of uniting us in love and peace after so many years of contention. However, if the Rev"^ Mr. Cutler and Trustees are fully satisfied that Mr. Cutler hath a warrantable Call of God to Remove from us, we desire passively to submit to Divine providence.

of the meeting house - both the joiner's and the carpenter's work to be done well according to rule, and finish the said gallery by the first of June next, and for their labor the committee promises to pay them thirt3--three pounds in money."

Mr. Cutler Do allow to him the hundred acres of woodland to be his own according to his desire ; the said Mr. Cutler returning the house and home lott which he received of the town, to the town again in the capacity it now is, with all betterments, fences, &c. - always provided that the Rev. Trustees or General Court allow to the town of Stratford one hundred pounds money for and towards the charge of settling another minister among us.

Mr. Cutler went to Yale College, but there was much trouble in settling money matters between him and the town of Stratford, for one or two years afterward.

The trouble anticipated by a town vote in settling another minister, when they consented to allow Mr. Cutler to remove, was more than realized. They soon found a candidate, Mr. Samuel Russell, and took a vote on his settlement, October i, 1719, but the numbers present being small, the matter was deferred, although there were no votes against him. The next March - 1720 - the vote stood 83 for him and 41 against and 8 scattering. In the April following a council was called for advice, and the next month the matter went to the General Court, who advised a delegated council from all the ministerial assemblies of the State, if Stratford would pay the expense. This created much greater excitement and difficulty, and many names were entered on the records as protesting against making any expense in that way. Trouble increased during two years, Mr. Russell continuing to preach, until quite a number of inhabitants recorded their names as refusing to pay to his support, November 2, 1721, when it was concluded to seek another candidate.

The next February they held a day of fasting and prayer in view of their trouble in calling a minister, and they soon after found a preacher upon whom they could fully unite, as seen by the town record :

"April 16, 1722. Whereas, the society at a lawful meeting March i, 1721-2, by a unanimous vote called Mr. Hezekiah Gold to the work of the ministry in Stratford in order for a settlement among us, and having ever since sat under his ministry with great satisfaction and delight; and for his incouragement to settle with us in the work of the ministry, it was this day voted and granted to allow him 130 pounds per annum as his yearly salary in money so long as the public good requires his labors among us. And for his settlement to give him the town house [probably the one built for Mr. Cutler] and home lot of one acre and a half to be his own forever, provided he settles with us and continue with us in the work till death; also the barn and half the land adjoining to the home lot."

" To ye old Society and Church of Christ in Stratford, to whom Grace and Peace be multiplied from God our father and from our Lord Jesus Christ. Dearly beloved, these may inform you of my greatful and thankful acceptance of your generous and honorable proposals for my incouragement in ye great work of ye ministry among you in which I purpose to continue as God in his providence shall permit, your faithful servant in Christ during life. Hez. Gold."

Jan. 6, 1723-4. Mr. Gold's request of the town, " liberty to erect a pew at some convenient place in the meeting house for his family " was granted. A few years later his salary was fixed at one hundred and fifty pounds a year and so continued many years, but when the inflation of State bills went on a few years, his salary - about 1750 - was considerably over two hundred pounds old tenor.

It is during the transactions for securing and settling Mr. Gold, that the distinction between the acts of the town and the ecclesiastical society, are first noticed on the records. The General Court in 1717 passed an act defining the powers and jurisdiction of such a society;' and in 1723 added the liqerty for each society in every town to have its own clerk.

That the settled and approved inhabitants in each respective parish or society within this Colony, shall annually meet together in December, at some time and place, according to the notice thereof to be given them at least five days before

During Mr. Cutler's pastorate, in 1717, when harmony and prosperity prevailed throughout the township, the movement began, which resulted in the organization of the parish or society of Ripton, of which a careful and full account will be given further on in this book in the history of the town of Huntington.

Timothy Cutler^ J). I),, son of Major John Cutler, of Charlestown, Massachusetts, was born June i, 1684, and was graduated at Harvard College in 1701. A call was extended to him by the Stratford Church September 16, 1709, and near or in the following December he was ordained pastor of this Church and congregation.

He served the parish acceptably ten years, but without any marked success, except as a pleasing and entertaining preacher. He was held in high esteem by the parish, was " reputed as a man of profound and general learning," but his letter of resignation, herewith printed, if such it may' be such meeting, by the committee for ordering the affairs of the societ}-, or for want of such committee, by the clerk of the same. And the said inhabitants thus met and convened together are hereby fully impowered by their major vote, to choose a clerk for their society, and three or more discreet, able inhabitants to be a committee to order the affairs of the society for the year ensuing. And also the said inhabitants assembled as above, or the major part of them, shall have power to grant and levy such rates and taxes on the inhabitants for the advancing such sum or sums of money for the support of the ministry and school there, as the law directs, and to appoint a collector or collectors for gathering thereof, who are hereby ordered and impowered to proceed in collecting the same, according to the direction of the law to collectors chosen for gathering the town and minister's rates. And in case the collector or collectors shall not perform the trust hereby committed to him or them, he or they shall be accountable for such arrearages by him or them neglected to be gathered, to the committee of such society, who are impowered to demand or distrain for the same, according to the direction of said law.

To this was added, in October, 1723, "That where there are more societies than one in any town in this governmnent, every such society are enabled, and they hereby have full power, to choose their own clerk." Col. Records, vi. 33.

I hope I have, with seriousness and solemnity considered the invitation made to me for a removal from you to the Collegiate School at New Haven, and can look upon it as nothing less than a call of providence which I am obliged to obey.

called, does not sustain the reputation thus given him. A brief letter of this description, in which the pronoun of the first person nominative occurs nine times, and six times in the possessive, is doubtless a literary production, but not of a very highly cultivated style; and, instead of resigning his office, he discharges the parish from further service to him, in these words, " and discharging you from the date of this letter forever."

In the summer of 1719 he accepted the presidency of Yale College, which office he discharged acceptably three years, when, professing a preference for the Church of England and renouncing his connection with the churches of the Colony, he, upon request, resigned the presidency of the College ; went to England in 1723, where he was ordained priest and honored with the title of D. D., by Oxford University ; returned to America and became pastor of Christ Church in Boston. He died in that city in 1765, aged 82 years.

Mev, He^ekiah Gold, son of Hon. Nathan Gold, Jr., of Fairfield, was born in 1794; graduated at Harvard College in 1719, and was ordained pastor of the Stratford Church on the first Wednesday in June, 1722. Within the first year of his ministry his labors were honored by the accession of sixty persons to membership of his Church ; and from that time forward a good degree of prosperity attended his ministrathanks for all that respect and kindness I have found with you and praying God abundantly to reward you for it - and discharging you from the date of this letter forever - and praying you to apply yourselves with all convenient speed to the settling of another minister with you.

I intend, if it be not unacceptable to you, to visit you and take my farewell of you as soon as I can conveniently in some Lord's day after my return from Boston, where I am now going, if it please God. V/hen I am bodily absent from you my affections shall persevere towards you and my hearty desires and prayers shall be to God for you, that he would preserve you in his favour and in peace among yourselves; direct your endeavours for the settlement of another to break the bread of life with you and make your way prosperous, and abundantly make up my removal from you by his gifts and his painful and successful endeavours for the good of your souls and your children after you. Thus, I leave you to the care of the Great Shepherd of the sheep always remaining an earnest well-wisher to your souls and all your concerns.

tions. From 173 1 to 1746, 260 persons became members of his church ; amonof whom were the Rev. Nathan Birdseye, who died in 1818, in his 104th year, and David Wooster, afterwards General in the army of the Revolution.

Mr. Gold was placed in unusual circumstances in his ministry from 1740, to his dismission. From the beginning of his labors his zeal and spirit was in harmony with the gospel idea of saving sinners as well as to teach the church, and hence many were converted and added to the church. When in 1735 an unusual religious interest was developed under the Rev. Jonathan Edwards, at Northampton, Mass., it was in harmony with Mr. Gold's labors as much, probably, as those of any minister in Connecticut ; and it was the same when the Rev. George Whitefield of England came.

" Mr. Whitefield preached here Monda}^ afternoon October 27, 1740, on his way from New Haven, where he preached on Sunday the 26th, and on the three days preceding. He records an interview at New Haven with the Rev. Jedediah Mills of Ripton parish in Stratford, whom he calls a ' dear man of God. My soul was much united to him.'

" That Mr. Gold, then pastor in Stratford, was cordially interested in the work of grace attending Mr. VVhitefield's preaching, is evident from his signature to the testimony of of the Fairfield County ministers in favor of the revival, given in October, 1743. Of the eleven signers of that paper, there were of ministers in Stratford, Mr. Cook, of Stratfield, Mr. Gold of Stratford, and Mr. Mills of Ripton.

" The sermon by Mr. Whitefield was heard by Mrs. Ann, wife of John Brooks, grand-daughter of post-master Daniel Brooks, who, herself, narrated the matter to Miss Polly Tomlinson, who related it to me in 1859, and she was so much interested that, with her infant in her arms, she went to Fairfield to hear him again the same day.

" Mr. Whitefield certainly had access to the Church, but a tradition preserved by Mrs. Victory Wetmore - daughterin-law of the Rev. Izrahiah Wetmore, and given me by her in 1859, represents a Mrs. Burritt who lived on the wood end road below Main street, as being in the yard of her dwelling, farther down, than any house now stands, and a mile nearly from the Meeting House Hill, where she distinctly heard Mr. Whitfield name his text from Zechariah ix. 12 : ' Turn ye to the stronghold ye prisoners of hope ;' and repeated it to her husband on his return home. Hence, it is probable that this sermon was delivered in the open air.

" Dr. Johnson is said to have called on Mr. Whitefield here, and desired some account of his principles, but he declined any discussion, saying he had already announced his principles in his sermon, and speedily departed for Fairfield.

" Mrs. Wetmore relates that a daughter of Mr. Jeremiah Green, who lived on Old Mill road, just beyond the railroad crossing, heard Whitfield preach, was convicted, and in the overwhelming excitement of her mind, swooned and fell into a sort of trance, or insensible state, which lasted one or two days."

In the winter following, Mr. Gold's settlement in Stratford a movement commenced, which resulted in securing a parsonage for the first society, for the use of the minister. The deed for the property so purchased was dated February 8, 1722-3, and was in consideration of ^^"67. The money was secured by voluntary subscription, the largest amount paid by one person being £\. los., there being 123 subscribers to the fund.*

^ " Stratford, November, 1722. We, the subscribers hereunto being desirous to propagate the gospel by the Presbj-terian ministry among us ; and in order thereunto, being sensible that it may be of great service to purchase a parsonage lot, and sequester it forever to remain a parsonage lot for the use of a Presbyterian

"Second Monday, February, 1742-3. Voted that it was necessary to build a meeting house for said society for the carrying on the public worship, by more than two-thirds of voters present.

" Voted, that Captain Theophilus Nichols, Mr. Robert Walker, Jr., Sergeant Daniel Porter, make application to the General Assembly in May next to appoint a committee to affix a place where the said society shall erect their meeting house."

" February 21, 1742-3. Voted that the meeting house shall be sixty feet in length, forty feet in width, and the posts twenty-six feet in length.

"June 27, 1743. Voted that Capt. David Judson, Lt. John Wilcockson and Sergt. Daniel Porter shall be the committee for building and furnishing the meeting-house on the place appointed by said society by the General Assembly in May last."

The location of this house was a few rods west of the old one, on the public green, where the academy afterwards stood, and was the one burned by lightning in 1785.

Mrs. Nancy Wells, widow of John Wells, and previously of Doctor Ezra Curtis, was the daughter of Samuel Uffbrd, and born in 1772. She was living in 1862, in her 89th year, and gave to the Rev. B. L. Swan some ministerial reminiscences. "She was a grand-daughter of the Rev. HezekiahGold, but was born under Rev. Izrahiah Wetmore's ministry and baptized by him. She said Mr. Gold's first wife was a Ruggles, of Guilford, who died, and Mr. Gold married the widow ministry in Stratford for the benefit of succeeding generations ; do freely give the particular sums prefixed to our names for the purchasing of Captain David Bostick's lot, called Harvey's lot, for the use aforesaid, and for no other."

of John Prynn, who came from the West Indies to Stratford, where he resided some years [and died November 23, 1751, ^. 51]. He brought some negroes with him and practiced the breeding of them for sale.

" After Mr. Gold married the widow Prynn, he was compelled to wait on her to the door of the Episcopal Church ; and after his own service in the Congregational Church was out to return thither and receive her at the door, into his carriage again.

" This marriage and her conduct offended many in Mr. Gold's church - among them Colonel Robert Walker - a man who came to Stratford as a weaver, but married Rebecca Lewis of Old Mill Green, who had property, and he soon rose to be Justice of the Peace, then Judge of the County Court, and became an influential man.

" Through his instrumentality Mr. Gold was dismissed from the service of his church, and Mr. Wetmore became pastor. He was a young man, and married Colonel Walker's daughter. Mrs. Wells' remembrance of Mr. Wetmore was very distinct. He was very tall, with colorless, inexpressive e3'es, red and close curling hair - the homeliest man, she said, she ever saw. He was the tallest man, except one, in the place.

" A Miss Tomlinson living at the same time with Mrs. Nancy Wells, said that the marriage of Mr. Gold, and the aversion of a party to his evangelical preaching - in which party Colonel Walker was prominent, were, together, the occasion of his being dismissed. She said, also, that this dismission caused the elderly Mr. Hezekiah DeForest, and others, to remove from Stratford to Huntington, New Haven, and other places."

There is an error in the above statement concerning the Walker family. Hon. Robert Walker, whose daughter Mr. Wetmore married, was born in Stratford, in 1705, and was not a weaver. It was his great uncle, Jacob Walker, brother of

The excitement in Stratford, as well as throughout New England, was very great, for several years following Mr. Whitfield's preaching. That preaching was very severe as to true conversion. Those persons, members of any and all churches, who had not experienced definite and remarkable exercises at the time of their professed conversion were represented as never having been converted, and as having no assurance of heaven. Mr. Gold, who had had an unusual revival for those days, soon after his settlement here, the spirit of which still continued, received Mr. Whitfield as a brother minister, and favored the public interest taken in the revival of religious interests in New England in 1741, 2 and 3. This season of unusual religious interest has since been termed " The Great Awakening." Many persons became greatly interested in religion in the specific form of a wonderful, or miraculous conversion, claiming that it was directly accomplished by the invisible power of God ; and that this power was exerted upon those only who were the elect. Hence, in this movement, there was the revival of the Calvinistic doctrines. There grew out of it, also, a strong sentiment against the union of church and state as it then existed in New England ; and hence there were two parties in the Congregational Churches, which resulted a few years later in the organization of what were called New Light Churches, but these churches called themselves Strict Congregational Churches.

There was another influence which affected Mr. Gold's parish very seriously. The Rev. Richardson Miner, settled pastor at Unity (now Trumbull), was a very successful physician as well as pastor, and practiced throughout Stratford, and largely in Stratford village, and hence attained a large popular influence. He, it is said, and with corroborating evidences, held more to the old ways of religious life than Mr. Gold, and hence, a movement sprang up about 1742 and 3, to have Mr. Gold dismissed and Mr. Miner called to Stratford; but when, in 1744, Mr. Miner joined the Episcopal Church, there was great disappointment and great excitement in this region of country, and quite a number of influential families withdrew from the Congregational communion and united with the Episcopal Church. The same was true in several adjoining parishes.

In the parish of Stratfield, although there was an Episcopal Church at Fairfield, some persons in 1751, under the New Light teachings, objecting to the levying of taxes to support the gospel, withdrew and organized a Baptist Church at Stratfield.

Some further notice of Mr. Gold's controversy with the Rev. Samuel Johnson, D.D., may be found in the next chapter of this book, in the biographical sketch of Dr. Johnson.

As far as has been ascertained by careful search, Presbyterians have existed in Stratford only in the name as applied to Congregationalists, after the establishment of the Saybrook platform of ecclesiastical government.

When in October, 1666, the General Court of the Colony ordered all the ministers to meet in convention to discuss and settle a number of ecclesiastical matters, it gave the name ynod to that meeting, but this term was so unwelcome, as being a Presbyterian name, that the Court changed it the next May, and styled the meeting " an assembly of the ministers of this Colony."

The order of the Court in May, 1708, in decreeing the delegated convention at Saybrook to remedy " the defects of the discipline of the churches of this government," used no terms that were Presbyterian or that indicated that form of government;'' nor did the convention itself, except in the title

'' "May, 1708. This Assembly, from their own observation and from the complaint of many others, being made sensible of the defects of the disciplme of the churches of this government, arising from the want of more explicit asserting the rules given for that end in the holy scriptures, from which would rise a firm establishment amongst us, a good and regular issue in cases subject to ecclesiastical discipline, glory to Christ our head, and edification to his members, haih seen fit to ordain and require, and it is by authority of the same ordained and required, that the

In 1679, the Governor of the Colony and his Assistants, in answer to inquiries made by the King's Council Chamber as to what persuasion in religious matters is most prevalent," said : " Our people in this Colony are, some strict Congregational men, others more large Congregational men, and some moderate Presbyterians; and take the Congregational men of both sorts they are the greatest part of the people in the Colony."

Upon the adoption of the Saybrook platform in 1708 it became the custom to call these churches Presbyterian, which term grew more and more acceptable until the New Light movement began in 1741, when the name became objectionable ; quite a number of churches refusing to be known as Presbyterian.

The Consociations established by the Saybrook Platform - being composed of ministers and laymen - and the authority which they were intended to exercise, were the only principles which conformed to the government of the Presbyterian Church. The Halfway Covenant, which was ministers of the churches in the several counties of this government shall meet together at their respective countie towns, with such messengers as the churches to which they belong shall see cause to send with them, on the last Monday in June next, there to consider and agree upon those methods and rules for the management of ecclesiastical discipline, vvhiuh b}' them shall be judged agreeable and conformable to the word of God, and shall, at the same meeting, appoint two or more of their number to be their delegates, who shall all meet together at Saybrook, at the next Commencement to be held there, where they shall compare the results of the ministers of the several counties, and out of and from them to draw a form of ecclesiastical discipline, which by two or more persons delegated by them shall be offered to this Court at their sessions at New Haven in October next, to be considered of and confirmed by them, and that the expenses of the above mentioned meetings be defrayed out of the public treasury of this Colonie."

only confirmed, not instituted by that Platform, had nothing Presbyterian in it, but was clearly in harmony with the usages of the Episcopal Church, in as much as it opened the way for the baptism of all children, by the parents becoming sponsors for their own children, in the form denominated owning the covenant.

The specific object of the Saybrook convention was to establish a more thorough system of ecclesiastical government; or in the words of the call for that meeting, to remedy " the defects of the discipline of the churches of this government."

When the Consociations were organized under it, in the western part of the State, at least, this matter was carefully confirmed and authorized, so far as those bodies could do it.* This was the action taken by the ministers of Fairfield County, and the form of this Consociation government was strongly Presbyterian.*

^"Sigillum 1 At a Consociation or meeting of the Elders and Messengers Consocialionis \ of the County of Fairfield at Stratfield March i6, 1708-g.

The Revd. Mr. Charles Chauncey Scribe. After Solemn Seeking of God for divine guid- I ance, direction and blessing the Councill convened. [ The Acts of y" Councill at Saybrook, September 9, 1708 were read the first time as also y'' general J Assembly's approbation and sanction thereof, October 1708.

2. That y^ Pastors met in our Consociation have power with y" Consent of the Messengers of our Chhs. chosen and attending. Authoritatively Judicially and Decisively to determine ecclesiastically affairs brot to their Cognizance according to the Word of God and that our Pastors with the concurrence and consent of the Messengers of our Chhes. to be chosen and that shall attend upon all future occasions, have like Authoritative, Judicial and Decisive power of Determination of affairs ecclesiasticall, and that in further and fuller meetings of two Consociations together compliant with the conclusions of y" sd Counciil at Saybrook, there is the like Authoritative, Judicial! and Decisive power of Determination of Ecclesiastical affairs according to y« word of God. 3. That by Elder or Elders of a particular Chh in From y" Chh. of Norw.Tlk. ] said Saybrook conclusions mentioned in in our practice to use y" phrase of y° sentence of Non Communion but in y^ stead thereof Messengers. |- to use y« phrase of y" sentence of Excom-

5. That to 3'^ orderly begining of a case before a Counciil of our Chhe=. y"* aggrieved member shall make application unto y** moderator of the Counciil or Consociation for y'' time being or in case of y** moderator's death to v* free Sen"^ Pastor of y^ Consociation who upon his desire shall receive attested copies of y® Chhs. proceedings with y'= aggrieved member from their minister and y« sd. Moderator with the two free senr. Pastors of y^ Circuit or in y* Case premised of y* death of y^ Moderator y^ sd 2 senr. pastors of y" circuit being satisfied there is sufficient cause shall warn y" convening of the Consociation.

6. That a Cop}- of a Warning to appear before y* Counciil the time an J place being notified being read in the hearing or left in y" house of the ordinary abode of a scandalous member or witness concerning the case depending before two members of the designation of the Scribe for y"' time being and signed by the sd Scribe be adjudged a regular notification.

7. That a copy of a Warning to appear before y® Pastor or Chh. y** place and time notified being read in y" hearing or left in the ordinary abode of an oflTending member or witness needfull in the case before two members appointed by the pastor and signed by him shall be a fair notification y* neglect whereof unless upon sufficient reason shall be reputed a scandalous contempt in our respective Chhes

8. That all persons that are known to be Baptized shall in y" places where they dwell be subject to y" Censures of admonition and excommunication in case of scandall committed and obstinately persisted in.

9. That the Moderator and Scribe now chosen be accounted to stand in y« same respective capacities for y" time being untill a new regular choice be made, and so for the future.

10. That y« Judgment of y" Consociation or Counciil be executed by any Pastor appointed thereto by y" Counciil when y* Pastor that hath already dealt in y* case hath not a freedome of Conscience to execute y" same.

Chapter Xiii The Eighteenth Century Continued

ISTORY in church matters for many years in Connecticut, is very largely the history of ^^ the people, socially and politically. There is no nation in which religion had a larger part in its formation than the American nation of the United States, and the ecclesiastical form in which this religious influence and teaching were prominently and successfully propagated for nearly one hundred years, was Congregational. VV^hether right or wrong, better or worse, or whatever the final result, this is historical fact, so widely recorded as to be beyond the possibility of change.

It is, therefore, proper, in the further delineations of history, to recognize the religious element, in its movings and effect, in such a degree as to show its force in the formation of the national life and character. In local history especially is this true, for in it is seen more directly the democratic elements of a free people.

Some notice of the churches in Connecticut, and especially as developed in Stratford, under the name of Congregational and Presbyterian has been given, as constituting largely the settlement and organization of the place.

The second denomination recognized by law and largely by the people of the state, was the Protestant Episcopal, at that day denominated the Church of England, and the place of its first organization in this State was Stratford.

Stratford was settled by persons who had been communicants in the Church of England to the time of their sailing for America. The Rev. Adam Blakeman had been regularly ordained in that church, and had served in it as priest for several years under the Bishop, but had been silenced for non-conformity. He and his associates dissented from several requirements of the Bishop ; not from the doctrines or existing ritual of the Church ;' and as regular members of that church received their certificates from the minister of the parish where they had resided and " attestations from the Justice of the Peace," according to the order of the government, upon which they were allowed to sail as emigrants to America.

They came to America with no other name than dissenting members of the Church of England, and as such were organized into a local body and called the " Church of Christ in Stratford."

It is not a supposable thing that these persons, although placed in church organization, without the approbation of a Bishop, could at once forget, or wholly forsake the religious training received, or their affection for the church and its usages, from which they were separated. Hence, in 1666, when some questions of church discipline arose there were found those who desired to maintain and be governed by rules which had been familiar to them in England.

The eight persons who were the minority in the division which finally went to Woodbury, were all born in England, with only one exception, if any, and four of them - Richard Butler, Henry Wakelyn, Samuel Sherman and Daniel Titharton, had been, probably, communicants in the Church of England before coming to this country. They desired, when received under the Halfway Covenant, to be examined

' Those who fled from England to this country were compelled to do so or observe certain rites and ceremonies of the English Church, which they believed unscriptural, and therefore wrong. They objected to the cap and surplice, the ring in marriage, the cross in baptism, ihe rite of confirmation, kneeling at the Lord's supper, etc." - New Haven Historical Society Papers, iii. 307.

alone by the minister - or minister and elder - and to be allowed to partake of the Lord's Supper, and their children, when baptized, to be members of the church in the sense entertained then in the English Church. Hence, this church at Woodbury did admit the halfway covenant members to the communion for many years after its organization.

Nor is it to be supposed that all kindl}' remembrances and feelings of attachment for the Episcopal Church had died out in Stratford at the year 1700, while their numbers had been increased frequently by emigrants from the Church of England, yet it is doubtful if before 1706 there were any families in Stratford who stood aloof from the Congregational Church, claiming to be adherents of the Episcopal Church. This is a conclusion, after careful examination, of every family name, as to births, baptisms, civil and social relations and owners of property, to that date. It has been claimed that Daniel Shelton was an Episcopalian from 1687, onward, but if so, he was, as may hereafter be seen, a very good " pillar " in the Congregational Society as late as 1717, for his name was the first on the petition in that year for society privileges in Ripton for the Congregational Church.

Isaac Knell has been represented by the Rev. Samuel Peters as an Episcopalian as early as "about 1690," but he was a Congregationalist and took an active part in that society's proceedings, in settling a minister in 1698; and ten years later he was so much attached to Mr, John Reed when he had closed his labors in Stratford, that the following deed is found in the land records: "July 13, 1708, Isaac Knell and John Clark for good will and affection," deeded to " Mr. John Reed for the space of ten thousand years, the day of this date forward ... all our undivided lands in Stratford." Mr. Peters calls him " Mr. Knell," but there was no other Mr. Knell than Isaac, in the town, at that time ; and he died only a few months later - November 2, 1708. He was a prominent, active man in the town, but probably was never an Episcopalian.

Doctor James Laborie, son of the Rev. James Laborie, an Episcopal clergyman and a physician, was born in 1691, and settled in Stratford as a physician, where, in 1714, he was granted liberty, by a town vote, to build a pew in the Congregational meeting-house, at his own expense, it being the second pew in that house, the other scats being high-back slips.

The Episcopal Church was introduced, in form, into Connecticut at Stratford in the summer of 1706, by the Rev. George Muirson, in the. use of the church service, preaching, and the baptism of " about twenty-four, mostly grown people.'" His visits, as a missionary for the Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in foreign parts, stationed at Rye, N. Y., were repeated, and the "churchmen of Stratford were organized into a parish, with Wardens and Vestrymen, at the visit of Mr. Muirson, in April, 1707.'"

"Mr. Muirson died in October, 1708," and hence "the parish, with about thirty communicants and a respectable number of families, was left to the occasional services of missionaries who chanced to visit this and the neighboring towns. '"^

The circumstances in Stratford at Mr. Muirson's introduction of the church service were favorable for such an object. The community had been divided in sentiment, as to the settlement of a minister, nearly four years. Two candidates had preached, some months each, before Mr. Reed, who was called on probation in view of a settlement, with much enthusiasm, by about a two-thirds majority of voters in the town ; became a resident in the town, and held a fair majority until he resigned. The votes in opposition to him, at any time, were very few, but these, with those in favor of other candidates, ranged from thirty to fifty during his stay in the place. It was during his fourth year, in the summer of 1706, that Mr. Muirson first came to the place and held services, they being quite opportune under the unsettled state of religious sentiment as to the minister.

The same trouble occurred again just before the Rev. Samuel Johnson was appointed missionar}^ to Stratford. The division as to the settlement of a minister after Mr. Cutler left, in lyig, was much greater than when Mr. Reed ministered here, until Mr. Gold became a candidate, and when he was settled, there were some apparently who were ready to go elsewhere as soon as opportunity favored, but the greatest accessions of substantial value to the Episcopal Church occurred between the years 1740 and 1750.

In the spring of 1714, the churchmen of Stratford began the work of building a church edifice, but discouragements were so many that only little progress was made.

The next missionary who visited them was the Rev. George Pigot, in the spring of 1722, he having been recently sent as missionary to New York. After his visits had continued about one year, proceedings were revived to build a church and the first important item was to secure a site on which to place it, and they made application to the town for a certain specified locality.

Very much has been said about the persecution they received in obtaining a site and erecting a house of worship, and it is probable that in a community entertaining some considerable conflicting religious sentiments, as was the case in Stratford at the time, some persons would do things of such a character, but that the genei-al public sentiment favored such proceedings is not warranted by any reliable evidence, and is also refuted by the following town record :

"At a lawful town meeting in Stratford, June 21, 1723, voted: Whereas, Mr. George Pigott and his associates petitioned the town of Stratford to give them land to erect a church on and land for a church yard, and in their petition fixed upon two certain places, the one by Mr. Gold's house, and the other on the north side of the Town's meeting-house near widow Titharton's land, the town considering their proposals and the two places they had pitched upon, and found them clogged with great difficulties, and that it would be as they apprehend, greatly to the damage of the town in general, to build on either of those places, however nominated some other places which, as they thought, might be convenient for them ; yet, notwithstanding, they went and purchased, of John Outman, thirty-six rods of land of his lot next to our meeting-house, within some four rods of said house, and gave, as appears of record, thirty pounds for the same where they designed to erect said church as they say, which, in the judgment of all thinking persons, may be very inconvenient and a great disturbance to each society, the houses being so near together, if erected there; the town, therefore, propose and offer to Mr. George Pigott and his associates aforesaid, to change with them, and for the thirty-six rods of land purchased of said Outman, and to allow them for it forty rods of land at the place they desired in their petition (namely, by the widow Titharton's) on the north side of the meeting-house ; or in lieu of said thirty-six rods of land to let them have the forty rods aforesaid at a reasonable rate and price to erect their church on and church yard, and the town made choice of Mr. Joseph Curtis, Capt. John Hawley, Ens. Edmund Lewis and Ens. John Porter, or any of them, a committee in behalf of the town to present the above proposals and offers of the town to the said Mr. George Pigott and his associates, petitioners, etc. Test, Joseph Curtiss, Town Clerk."

Five days after this meeting a record of opposition was made, it being the only one, although the accommodating town clerk left half a page blank for others, but it has not yet been filled :

"June 26, 1723. Lieut. Joseph Beach entered his dissent against the town disposing of any land of the commons on the north of the meeting-house hill by widow Titharton's, for the erecting of a church on, or church yard upon.

The lot near the widow Titharton's was accepted, which was the one where the Episcopal burying place now is, and upon it was erected the first church edifice for this society, and the first for the Church of England in the Connecticut Colony ; and the lot purchased of Mr. Outman was sold some years later.*

The Rev. Samuel Johnson arrived at Stratford November 4, 1723, being commissioned as a missionar}' to this place bv the society in England, at which time the frame of the church edifice could scarcely have been set up, since the site was not determined upon until in July or August of that year, if as early as that time.

This building has been described as " a neat, small wooden building, forty-five feet and a half long, thirty and a half wide, and twenty-two between joints, or up to the roof," and was built, partly, at the expense of the members of the Church of England, in Stratford, and partly by the liberal contributions of several pious and generous gentlemen of the neighboring provinces, and sometimes of travelers who occasionally passed through the town.'"

Mr. Johnson's missionary field was very large ; for, besides occasional visits to a greater distance, his labors were distributed among the following places: Fairfield, Norwalk, Newtown, Ripton, West Haven, and New Haven.

Success to a good degree attended the labors of the missionaries in this place. At Mr. Muirson's death, in 1708, it is said: "The parish, with about thirty communicants and a respectable number of families, was now left to the occasional services of missionaries who chanced to visit this and the neighboring towns."*

In 1723, it is said : "The parish of Stratford, when he [Mr. Johnson] came to it, numbered about thirty families; and forty more - to say nothing of the few churchmen farther eastward - might be included in the neighboring towns and districts.'" In 1727, Mr. Johnson, in writing to the Honorable Society, represented " that he had then in his parish fifty families, or about one-seventh of the whole number of families in the town."

The fact that the supporters of the Episcopal Church in Stratford and in Connecticut were required by law to pay taxes for the support of the Congregational churches, was the one most irritating and distressing difficulty with which they had to contend. It was a sore trial, and was all wrong, but was just what dissenting bodies were undergoing in England at the same time, and this is the only excuse, that a law had been established in this respect, in harmony with the law in England, and to it the English government made no objection. The law in Connecticut was in favor of the Congregational churches; the law in England was in favor of the Church of England.

The law in Connecticut was enforced, in regard to the organization of new Congregational parishes, in that the parties were required to pay to the old society until recognized by the General Court as a new society, for a part or the whole of the year.

A close examination of the record of town acts between 1706, and 1730, reveals no vote in Stratford to release the supporters of the Episcopal Church from paying taxes to the established church ; and it would have been contrary to the law to pass such a vote.

In 1727, upon the petition of the Episcopal people of Fairfield, an act was passed by the legislature to relieve the members of the Episcopal Church from paying to the support of the Congregational churches.*

8 "May, 1727. Be it enacted by the Governor, Council and Representatives, in General Court assembled, and by the authority of the same. That all persons who are of the Church of England, and those who are of the

After this, no vote of the town of Stratford has been seen, recognizing this act, until January, 1737-8, when, instead of saying, as usual, that the tax was for the salary of the minister, it says " to defray ministerial salaries and charges." Hence, the tax was laid on all persons alike, in the society, but that collected from Episcopalians was paid to the Episcopal minister or Church.

It further appears that the Episcopal Church and people of Stratford were treated in a friendly manner by the voters and proprietors of the common lands in the town.

Dr. Samuel Johnson was greatly in favor of education in higher branches as well as the lower. His influence at Yale College was decidedly helpful and notedly generous. The following record in Stratford was a movement projected by himself:

" At a town meeting ist Monday in February, 1733-4, the Rev. Samuel Johnson, in behalf of the members of the Church of England in Stratford, requesting the liberty of erecting and setting up a School House on the Common, near the southeast corner of Lieut. Joseph Beach's house lot; on consideration thereof Edmund Lewis, John Thompson, Esq., and Captain John Wells were chosen a committee to view and consider the most important and convenient place, and where said committee shall fix the place that they shall any parish allowed by this Assembly, shall be taxed by the parishioners of the said parish by the same rule and in the same proportion, for the support of the ministrjr in such parish : but if it so happen that there be a society of the Church of England, where there is a person in orders according to the canons of the Church of England, settled and abiding among them, and performing divine service, so near to any person that hath declared himself of the Church of England that he can conveniently and doth attend the public worship there, then the collectors, having first indiferently levied the tax as above said, shall deliver the taxes collected of such persons declaring themselves and attending aforesaid, unto the minister of the Church of England living near unto such persons ; which minister shall have full power to receive and recover the same, in order to his support in the place assigned to him. But if such proportion of taxes be not sufficient in any society of the Church of England, to support the incumbent there, then such society may levy and collect of them, who profess and attend as aforesaid, greater taxes at their own discretion, for the support of their minister. And the parishioners of the Church of England, attending as aforesaid, are hereby excused from pa)'ing any taxes for building meeting-houses for the present e^tablisht churches of this government."

This was about seventy years before the building was erected on the green, still remembered as the Academy, and whether Dr. Johnson secured the erection of a school house as proposed, has not been ascertained.

Another item indicates this spirit of friendliness and also equity toward the members of the Episcopal Church, as well as all others; it was the granting of land to those members for their church or minister in proportion as the town or proprietors had granted to the Congregational ministers. When Mr. Chauncey was settled here, some land was given him, as a settlement. When Mr. Cutler was settled, one hundred acres, besides a house lot, were given to him, and one hundred acres were given to Mr. Jedediah Mills on his settlement at Ripton ; and a number of acres were given to Mr. Richardson Minor, upon his settlement at Unity.

In the winter of 1735-6, the supporters of the Episcopal Church petitioned the proprietors of the common lands in the town to grant them land for their church in proportion to what had been granted to the Congregational ministers of the town, and a committee was appointed by the proprietors to ascertain how much land should in equity be thus sequestered. Upon that committee's report the following action was taken by the proprietors' meeting :

" March, 1736. Whereas, several persons belonging to the Church of England in Stratford for themselves and the rest of their brethren proprietors in said Stratford belonging to said Church of England, making request and desiring an equivalent of land may be allowed them for the lands formerly given to several Presbyterian ministers in fee and some given the use in said Stratford, in consideration whereof it was voted that our friends and neighbors in Stratford belonging to the Church of England, and being also proprietors in the common and undivided land in said Stratford, shall have the liberty of having laid out to them, collectively considered, ten acres of land in any of the common and undivided land six miles distant, provided it be in full satisfaction for their proportion in all lands formerly given to the Presbyterian ministry in said Stratford, either for use or in fee, said land to be taken up in one entire piece in the six-mile division, so called. Said vote passed nemine contradicente."^

" To the moderator of the Proprietors' meeting in Stratford the nth day of instant, February, A. D., 1739-40, and the proprietors of Stratford of the common and undivided land, the humble request of us, the subscribers for ourselves, and on behalf of the rest of our brethren members of the Episcopal Church of England in Stratford, that, whereas sundry persons have subscribed to an instrument of equal date of these presents to give out of our rights of land in the last six-mile division granted the first Tuesday of instant, February, for the proper use, benefit and behoof of the Episcopal Church of England in Stratford, this is, therefore, to request that we, the subscribers, may have the liberty to take up the same land subscribed adjoining to a tract lately laid out [the ten acres] for the use of the Church of England, or if that cannot be, we may have liberty to take the whole of the subscription in one piece, if that may be found convenient. Subscribed by Samuel Blagge. Samuel French. William Beach. Francis Hawley. Joseph Brown.

" Which above said request, at said meeting, was granted, provided they lay not out above twenty acres, as aforesaid." These petitioners were the officers of the church.

The restriction to twenty acres, limited only the laying twenty acres in one piece. They might have given hundreds of acres, in various places, if they had chosen.

Laid out ten acres by the proprietors' Committee - adjoining to the South end of Menhantuck Swamp, so called - beginning at a pond of water on the east side of Newtown road.

It should be remembered that proprietors of common, or undivided lands, were a different class from freeholders, for there were some freeholders who had no rights in common lands, but the number was small.

There were seventeen names attached to the paper referred to in the above petition, and the number of acres given are recorded, except in the case of the two last names, one of which the figures arc not intelligible, the other has no figure attached, probably by the carelessness of the recorder.'"

The owners of the common land, at this time, numbered 199, holding rights, claiming from a small fraction of an acre to nearly fifty acres, according as each held a greater or less proportion of one of the original seventeen rights. There were at this time a number of thousand acres of land undivided, but lying in smaller pieces in many portions or parts of the township.

assembled, and those of the proprietors of the common lands are concerned, there seems to have been a spirit of equity and neighborly conduct manifested, throughout, toward the supporters of the Episcopal Church in Stratford.

Some misapprehension seems to have been entertained as to the relation of the Connecticut government to other denominations than the legally established churches. The early settlers were very nearly unanimous in their religious prefer-

'" " To all whom these presents shall come, Greeting - Know ye that we whose names are under written, Do give unto the Episcopal Church of England in Stratford, the several parcels of land affixed to our names .... for the only use, benefit, and behoof of ye s'' Church of England and their successors forever.

ences and ideas of church g-overnment ; but soon persons began to settle here, holding different views in these matters, and as soon as these persons became sufficient in number to indicate the propriety of toleration, the General Court conceded the question, and acted accordingly.

This Court having seriously considered the great divisions that arise amongst us about matters of church government, for the honor of God, wellfare of the churches, and preservation of the publique peace so greatly hazarded, doe declare that, whereas the Congregationall churches in these parts for the generall of their profession and practice, have hitherto been approved, we can doe no less than still approve and countenance the same to be without disturbance until better light in an orderly way doth appeare ; but, yet, for as much as sundry persons of worth for prudence and piety amongst us are otherwise persuaded (whose wellfare and peaceable sattisfaction we desire to accommodate). This Court doth declare that all such persons being allso approved according to lawe as orthodox and sownd in the fundamentalls of [the] Christian religion may have allowance of their persuasion and profession in church wayes or assemblies without disturbance.""

This did not include Quakers, for they were regarded, in those da)'S, as not orthodox, but light was springing as if from a hundred hamlets and spreading like the rays of the rising sun, and hence, six years later, in 1675, the Quakers w^ere relieved from persecution, in the following act, although not allowed to meet in separate assemblies. " This Court being moved to consider of the law respecting Quakers, doe see cause at present to suspend the penaltv for absence from our publique assemblies or imprisonment of those of that perswasion, provided the}^ do not gather into assemblies in this Colony or make an}- disturbance."

The act of 1669 allowed persons of every persuasion, if orthodox in faith, to hold public worship - or, in its own words, " that all such persons being also approved, according to law as orthodox, and sound in the fundamentals of [the] Christian religion, may have allowance of their persuasion and profession in church ways, or assemblies, without disturbance."

Although these acts did not secure full liberty of conscience - a thing then unknown to law in the world - yet, how great was the contrast between the religious liberties of Connecticut at that time, and those of England, the mother country whence the pilgrims came, where the Church of England was then in the ascendancy, and her Bishops held full sway. King Charles II. was restored to authority in 1660, and soon after a convocation of divines changed various parts of the Prayer Book, and added severe terms of conformity ; and it has been said it " was the study of the Bishops to make the terms of conformity as hard as possible ;" and, " on St. Bartholomew's day, August the twenty-fourth, in the year 1662, the act of uniformity expelled from the establishment [the English Church] all ministers who would not swear their unfeigned assent and consent to everything in the Book of Common Prayer. In many parts of the kingdom, the ministers could not procure the book before the time within which the law required them to swear to it or resign their livings, so that, in their farewell sermons, they told their flocks, that they were obliged to leave them for not swearing to a book which they had not been able to see.

" Two thousand ministers resigned their livings in the establishment, and exposed themselves to the loss of all things, rather than submit to these new terms of conformity, which their consciences condemned.

" The conventicle act was passed, decreeing, that if any person, above the age of sixteen years be present at an}' meeting for worship, different from the Church of England, where there shall be more than five persons more than the household, they shall, for the first offence, suffer three months imprisonment, or pay five pounds; for the second, the punishment was doubled; and for the third, they shall be banished to America, or pay a hundred pounds ; and if they return from banishment, suffer death."

" The oath of an informer was sufficient to inflict all the severity of this statute, and thus, while many of the best men filled the jails, the vilest of the human race rioted in debauchery by informing- for the sake of the reward.""

A few years later and further measures were taken against the non-conforming ministers. " An act of passive obedience, and non-resistance was enacted ; and all who refused it, were prohibited from coming within five miles of any corporate town where they formerly preached ; or from keeping schools, or taking boarders, under a penalty of forty pounds. Thus, though they were not actually burnt alive, they were intentionally starved to death.""

Such is the contrast between England and the Connecticut Colony, from 1660 to 1680. Connecticut, it is true, did enact a severe law against the Quakers, Ranters, Adamites and such like notorious Heretics," as styled in the language of that day ; and did hang a few witches, which is, and ever will be, greatly to her dishonor, but her colonists brought the laws, sentiments, usages and customs, by which these things were done, with them from England, adhered to them a few years only, and then in the grandeur of the freedom of which they just began to taste, threw off the yoke of bondage and religious persecution, and established a platform of civil freedom such as the sun had never before shone upon, and such that the English government sought, for nearly one hundred years, with many inventions, to deprive them of, but failed, and that failure established the nation called the United States of America.

The Act of Toleration, under King James II. of England was established in 1687, eighteen years after the like act was made a law in Connecticut. " It suspended all penal laws against all classes of non-conformists ; authorized Roman Catholics and Protestant dissenters to perform public worship ; forbade the molestation of any religious assembly; abrogated all laws imposing religious test as a qualification for office; and granted entire liberty of conscience, to all the King's subjects.""

This act, although planned and executed by the King for another end than ireedom, was, nevertheless, a law of great progress and value, compared with the terrible laws of religious persecution which had been in existence unto that day ; but Connecticut had already adopted like regulations, and these from England were readily accepted by her.

One thing has been charged 'to the discredit of the forefathers of Connecticut with less consideration and with greater censure than all others put together; namely, the union of church and state, and thereby the levying of taxes by law to support the ministry.

To this but two things need be named in reply ; one, that they knew no other way ; and the other, that it seemed to them a self-evident law, that those who were benefited, should, in proportion to their ability, pay for the benefits received.

As to the first it was the law of the land whence they came, all their experiences had been under that discipline, and when they left their mother country they had made no complaint whatever at being required by law to support the preaching of the gospel.

When they had effected a settlement in the wilderness, and the question of permanency arose as to the life they were to live, and the characters they hoped and proposed to form, of right and righteousness, they judged the preaching of the gospel the most important agent to be used, and for that reason made the most equitable provision for that end, of which they had any knowledge.

" Whereas, the most considerable persons in these colonies came into these parts of America that they might injoye Christ in his ordinances, without disturbance; And, whereas, among many other precious mercyes, the ordinances are, and have been, dispensed among us with much purity and power: The Commissioners took it into serious consideration, how some due mayntenance according to God might be provided and settled, both for the present and future, for the encouragement of the ministers who labour therein, and concluded to propound and commend it to each General Court, that those that are taught in the word in the several plantations, be called together, that every man voluntarily set down what he is willing to allow to that end and use ; and if any man refuse to pay a meet proportion, that then he be rated by authority in some just and equal way ; and if after this, any man withold or delay due payment, the civil power to be exercised as in other just debts. '"^

This was the beginning of the law which, a few years later, required every taxpa3^er to pay to the support of the church or churches in his plantation or town.'^ When the law was enacted to allow freedom or choice as to church preferences, and worship in 1669, it did not release the citizen from paying tax for the support of the legally established church

" It is ordered by this Court and Authority thereof, that every inhabitant shall henceforth contribute to all charges, both in Church and Commonwealth, whereof he doth or may receive benefit, and every such inhabitant who doth not voluntarily contribute proportionally to his ability with the rest of the same Towne to all common charges, both Civil and Ecclesiastical, shall be compelled thereunto by assessments and distress, to be levied by the Constable or other officer of the Towne as in other cases ; And, that the Lands and Estates of all men, wherever the)- dwell, shall be rated for all Towne Charges, both Civil and Ecclesiastical, as aforesaid, where the Lands and Estates shall lie, and their persons, where they shall dwell."

At this time all persons from 16 yeais old and upwards, were taxed [ist] "every person, except Magistrates and Elders of Churches, two shillings six pence per head, and [2d] all estates, bothe real and personal, at one penny for every twenty shillings." Conn. Col. Rec. i., 547.

of his community. Nor did the act of toleration in England release any one from paying to the support of the ministry in the English Church. So far had the idea of freedom in religious matters advanced in America, that, when from 1706, to 1727, the communicants of the Episcopal Church were required by law, as all others, to pay to the support of the Congregational Churches, they judged it a very grievous oppression, and some refused to do it and were imprisoned just as Congregationalists would have been if they had refused ; but at the same time all denominations were taxed in England for the support of the ministers of the Episcopal Church.

There was also a great difference between the union of Church and State in England and that in Connecticut. In the former the layity had nothing to do in calling a minister or the salary paid him, while in Connecticut the}- controlled both, in the most democratic form then known, and the tax collected for the minister was kept separate from all others, and applied yearly, only upon the vote of the parish.

Such are some of the historical facts from which the early settlers of Connecticut had come and through which they had passed, and by which they were surrounded when a second denomination of Christians had become established by law in their territory.

The following extract is taken from a book called A General History of Connecticut, by the Rev. Samuel Peters, published first in London, England, in 1781, and at New Haven in 1829, page 166 :

Mr. Peters, being a very strong loyalist in the time of the Revolution, found it to his comfort to go to England, where he published this book, in which are many things of true history and also many things without a shadow of truth, and which have the appearance of being published for the purpose of defaming the people of Connecticut.

The story which he relates concerning the Indian powwow, had some foundation in tradition, and historical fact. The Indians held yearly powwows, and held ceremonies with

There are three streets running north and south and ten east and west. The best is one mile long. On the centre square stand a meeting with a steeple and a bell, and a church with a steeple, bell, clock, and oi-gan.

It is a beautiful place, and from the water has an appearance not inferior to that of Canterbury. Of six parishes contained in it, three are Episcopal.

The people are said to be the most polite of any in the colony, owing to the singular moderation of the town in admitting latterly, Europeans to settle among them. Man}^ persons come also from the islands, and southern provinces, for the benefit of their health.

A ver}^ extraordinary story is told concerning the occasion of it, which I shall give the reader the particulars of, the people being as sanguine in their belief of it as they are of the ship's sailing over New Haven.

An ancient religious rite called the Pawwaw, was annually celebrated b}^ the Indians ; and commonly lasted several hours every night for two or three weeks. About 1690, they convented to perform it on Stratford point near the town. During the nocturnal ceremony the English saw, or imagined they saw, devils rise out of the sea, wrapped up in sheets of flame, and flying round the Indian camp, while the Indians were screaming, cutting, and prostrating themselves before their supposed fiery gods. In the midst of the tumult the devils darted in among them, seized several, and mounted with them into the air; the cries and groans issuing from whom quieted the rest. In the morning, the limbs of Indians, all shrivelled, and covered with sulphur, were found in different parts of the town. Astonished at these spectacles, the people of Stratford began to think the devils would take up their abode among them, and called together all the ministers in the neighborhood, to exorcise and lay them. The ministers be-

The inhabitants were about to quit the town, when Mr. Nell spoke and said: "I would to God that Mr. Visey, the Episcopal minister at New York, was here ; for he would expel these evil spirits." They laughed at his advice; but, on his reminding- them of the little maid who directed Naaman to a cure for his leprosy, they voted him their permission to bring Mr. Visey at the next pawwaw.

Mr, Visey attended, accordingly, and as the pawwaw commenced with bowlings and whoops, Mr. Visey read portions of the holy scripture, litany, etc. The sea was put into great motion; the pawwaw stopped ; the Indians dispersed and never more held a pawwaw in Stratford.

The inhabitants were struck with wonder at this event, and held a conference to discover the reason why the devils and pawwawers had obeyed the prayers of one minister, and had paid no regard to those of fifty. Some thought that the reading of the holy scripture, others that the Litany and Lord's prayer; some, again, that the Episcopal power of the minister, and others, all united were the means of obtaining the heavenly blessing they had received.

Those who believed that the holy scriptures and litany were effectual against the devil and his legions, declared for the Church of England; while the majority ascribed their deliverance to a complot between the devil and the Episcopal minister, with a view to overthrow Christ's vine planted in New England. Each party acted with more zeal than prudence."

This story of expelling the devils from Stratford has about as much force against the Congregationalists as the story still told as to the cause of the mosquitoes in Stratford. That cause, it is well known, is the great salt meadow of 1,500 or 2,000 acres below Stratford on the Sound, yet a jocose story is told of another cause.

It is said, when the Rev. George Whitefield preached in Stratford, he represented all the Episcopal people as never having been converted, and they, in turn, were very severe in remarks on Mr. Whitefield ; and that when he left Stratford he shook off the dust of his feet against them, saying, the curse of God would come upon them. That curse, it has been said, was the coming of the mosquitoes.

The purpose in copying these inscriptions, has been to present every one just as it is on the stone - the names, dates, verses and spelling, every word and letter on each and every stone to the date of June loth, 1885 ; and much care and effort have been employed to make this record correct. There are four or five inscriptions so effaced that they could not be copied.

Sacred to the Memory of Clarissa, wife of the Rev. Ashbel Baldwin, & Daughter of Mr. Samuel & Mrs. Margaret Johnson of Guilford: born July 7, 1761, & departed this Life April 16, 1823, aged 62. Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord.

Dearest son since thou hast left us Here thy loss we deeply feel, But 'tis God that hath bereft us. He can all our sorrows heal. Yet again we hope to meet thee When the days of life are fled, Then in heaven we hope to greet thee, Where no farewell tear is shed.

died Oct. 15, 1822, aged 62 years. Ephriam, their son, died Jan. 10, 1793 : aged 16. Two Infant children of David & Rebecca Beardsley, one died 1817, the other June, 1S22. In memory of Henry Beardslee, who died Aug. 13, 1806, aged 69 years.

Here lies Inter'd tlie Body of Mrs. Hannah Beach, Relict of Mr. Isaac Beach, who Departed this life Oct'r y« 15"', A.D. 1750, in the 79*'' year of her age.

[A Tablet.] [The first or uppermost inscription on this tablet is gone by the slate-stone being removed. It was that of William Beach, who m. Sarah Hull, and died in 1751.]

His worthy Relict JMi's. SaraJi Heach, was afterwards married to the Reverend Dr. Johnson, President of Kings College at New York: and died of the small-pox with much patience. Faith and Resignation, Feb'>' g"", 1763, ^tat. 61 : And lies interred under the Chancel of Trinity Church there. Colo. Aaron JienjaftiiUf Nov. 23, 182S, Aged 72 years.

He was an officer of the Revolution and served his country faithfully through the whole of that struggle for freedom which resulted in the complete establishment of our National Independence. He also had command of the important post of New London during the 2d war with Great Britain.

Dorothy JBenjainin, wife of Col. Aaron Benjamin, Born March 3, 1768, Died Oct. 4, 1853. Precious are the memories of the Home that was blessed with her love and virtue. Sacred is the grave of our Mother.

In Memory of 3Irs. Lucrefia Benjamin,. Wife of ttie late Colo. John Benjamin, who died March 22'', 1803, Aged 69 Years. Jolin BacJcinson, son of John & Hannah S. Benjamin, Died Aug. 7, 1870, aged 1 year & 6 mos.

Here lies Buried the Body of 3Ir. John Benjamin, who departed this Life April the 13"', 1773, in y"^ .73 Year of His Age. Laura Gertrude, Daughter of W. M. & S. J. Benjamin, died Sept. 5, 184S, ^. 4 yrs. & 4 mo. Oh not in cruelty, not in wrath

In memory of Sarah Benjamin, wife of Gideon Benjamin, who died Jan. 16, 1841, in the Si year of her age. Sarah Marie, wife of William Benjamin, Aged 71, Born Oct. 17S2, Died April, 1853.

God took him away from mortal sorrow Before his little heart was ripen, For a bright long day without a morrow. To join his mother in the songs of heaven.

Here lies intered the Body of Mr. Boger Bessin (?), late of Antigua, who departed this life Oct. )'* 26"', 1743, Aetatis 47, Having given a 100 pounds to the Church of England iti this town.

Sept. 10*'', 1795, Aged 76 Years. Reader, reflect when you these lines peruse On thy own self. What thou art & When The grim triumphant tyrant Death may come Oh ! be then like to him, & meet it, good.

Nov. 28, 1812 ; aged 66 yrs. Caroline E. Bowdhi, Daughter of Rev. John Bowden, D.D., LL.D. died Jan. 22, 1877. Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord.

Sacred to the Memory of Mrs. Mary Boivdeti, Relict of the late Rev. John Bowden, D.D., who died Dec. 29, 1819 : aged 64 years. The kind friend, The affectionate Mother, The faithful Wife, The exemplary Christian.

In Memory of Mrs. Elizabeth Brooks, the Beloved Consort of Mr. Benjamin Brooks, who departed this Mortal life on the 9*'' of October, 1773, in y" 28 year of Her Age.

Sacred To the memory of BatJi Br oivn, who was born in this town October lo, 1779, and died in New York, March 6"', 1846 : in the 67*'' year of her age.

who departed this life Oct. 26"», 1S02, in the 40"' year of his age. And in meinory o( Abel Barritt, a child 6 weeks old, son of Ephraim Burritt, Jur. & Ann his Wife.

Here lies Buried the body of Mrs. Phebe Burritt, wife of Mr. Ephraim Burritt, Who died Oct. 26*'', 1708, in the 67"' Year of her Age. In Memory of Leivis Burritt, Who died Jan. 8, 1839, in the 67 Year of his age. In Memory of Esther Burritt, Wife of Lewis Burritt, who died Oct. 10, 1839 : in the 61 year of her age.

Here lies Buried the Body of 3Ir. Charles BurrouffJis, Junr., Who Departed this Life July the I2"> A. D. 1770, in the 40"^ year of his age. Here lyes y** Body of 3Irs. Elizabeth. BurrouffJis, Wife to Mr. Stephen Burroughs, Dautr. of Mr. Joseph & Mrs. Parnai Brown, Who died December 4*, 1764, in y® 36"^ Year of Her Age.

In Memory of Lettice^ Wife of Charles Burroughs, who died July 16, 1S02, aged 64 years. Behold and see as you pass by, As you are now so once was L As I am now so you must be, Prepare for death and follow me.

Sacred to the Memory of 3Irs. Francis Chapman, who exchanged this Life in hope of a better one the 30"' of December, A.D. 1783, in the 80"' Year of her Age.

Sacred to the Memory of Mr. Georf/e Chapman, who exchanged this Life in hopes of a better on the 6"' June, A. D. 1777, in the forty eighth Year of his Age.

In Memory of Chloe, Wife of Hannibal Curtiss, who died April 24, 1S28, Aged 72. God has bereaved me of My wife, His will for him 1 stood, It was God and he is Kind, He does what seemeth him good.

in the 19'^ Year of her Age. Rich in every Virtue & directed by a sound understanding, she was ever in pursuit of useful knowledge while the cheerfulness with which she discharged her duty endeared her to all her Relatives and Friends : having a mind stored with ever useful & ornamented acquirements, she seemed fitted for an example for the young & beautiful, & a Comfort to the Aged, When by a momentary stroke of Death she was called from health and Youth to a life of everlasting felicity. [Several lines effaced.]

Sacred to the Memory of Henry Davies^ Esqr., late of New York, and formerlj' of his Britanic Majesty's Navy in which he discharged many offices of trust and importance with honor to himself and integrity to his Country. After living in the constant practice of piety toward God and benevolence to MEN; after fulfilling every dut}' in social and domestic Life, died at this place on the 28"^ day of April, 1S02, in the 57 year of his age in full hope of receiving that reward which a redeemer hath purchased for all who trust in him.

Respected and beloved by all ; a most brilliant example of virtue and loveliness she departed this life rejoicing in the hope of a glorious immortality.

In Memory of Robert Wells, son of William and Hannah Fairchild, who departed this life Sept. iS, 1805. Lewis C, son of Benjamin & Eunice Fairchild, died April 22, 1829, aged 7 yrs. & 8 mo.

In Memory of Capt. Ezra Hubbell, who was lost at sea Sept. 1801, in the 35 Year of his Age. Mrs. 3Iary Alice, Wife of Capt Ezra Hubbell, Died August 11, 1811, Aged 28 Years.

This mortal shall put on immortality. And of Henjatnin [out - stone broken.] Here lyes Buried the Body of 3Irs. Sarah Hubbell, Wife of Mr. Joseph Hubbell, who died March 9^'', 1790, Aged 56 Years.

In Memory of tTatie, wife of Jacob Hurd, who died May 2, 1S25, aged 63 Years. In Memory of Daniel Jackson, a Revolutionary pensioner, who died Aug. 25, 1841, aged 78 yrs.

In Memorj' of Daniel fJacLsou, who died Aug. 16, 1829, Aged 38 years. Ah 'tis a holy rite remembrance of the dead. That will not oblivion blight around the grave be shed.

Collegii Regalis Novi Eboraci Prsesidis prmi et hujus Ecclesise nuper Rectoris. Natus Die 14 to. Octob. i6g6, Obit. 6 to. Jan. 1772.* In decent dignity and modest mien. The cheerful heart and countenance serene If pure religion and unsullied truth, His age's solace, and his search in youth. If piety in all the paths he trod Still rising vigorous to his Lord and God ; If Charity thro' all the race he ran. Still willing well, and doing good to man : If learning, free from pedantry and pride ; If Faith and Virtue, walking side by side ; If well to mark his being's aim and end. To shine thro' life a H usband. Father, Friend, If these ambition in thy soul can raise. Excite thy reverence, or demand thy praise ; Reader, ere yet thou quit this earthly scene, Revere his name, and be what he has been. Myles Cooper.

*This inscription is taken from Mr. J. W. Barber's Historical Collections, for the reason that the slate-stone inlaid on the tablet, on which the lettering was placed, is entirely gone. The same is true as to the slate-stone on several other tablets in thisburying-place.

[Tablet.] In Memory of 3Irs. Mai'i/ Jones, consort of Joel Jones and eldest daughter of Isaac J. Curtis, who departed this life Jan. 15, 1817 ; in the 25 year of her age ; leaving with her afflicted friends a tender infant which survived until April 21, 1817, when it declined the bitter cup of life and joined its departed Mother; aged 4 months & 22 days. Also in Memor}'^ of Julius Curtis, son of Joel & Mary Jones, who departed this life Sept. 20, 181 5, aged 3 years and 5 months. Unerring wisdom drew the awful veil Bade the eye languish and the cheek grow pale. From lips beloved the vital warmpth retired, And life's faint lustre silently expired ; The immortal spirit reached its destined height, A star forever in the realms of light. Here also lies entombed the remains of Dillissenea, eldest son of Isaac J. & Charity Curtis, who after long and distressing illness which he bore with Christian fortitude, resigned his soul to God who gave it, on the 11 of June, 1817, in the 21 year of his age. When tides of youthful blood run high, And promised scenes of joy draw nigh. Youth presuming, beauty blooming, O ! how dreadful 'tis to die.

Here lyes Buried the Body of Collo. Edmond Leivis, Who Departed this life May i4">, 1757, in ye 78 Year of his Age. Calm he commits his flesh to Dust, 'Till the last trumpet wakes the Just, And he immortalized shall Rise To mansions far beyond the skies.

Here lyes Buried y« Body of Mrs. HannaJi Leivis, wife to Colo. Edmond Lewis, who Departed this life July y"^ 13"^, 1756, in y° 75"" Year of Her Age.

In Memory of Mr. James Letvis, Who departed this life August 13"^, 1779, Aged 39 Years. Just as he arrived, to those scenes Where pleasures seemed to flow, Just as he tasted those sweet charmes Death struck the fatal blow.

PheneasS Phehe, Son & Daughter of Mr. David & Mrs. Phebe Lewis, died Sept. y" 7, 1751. Pheneas in the 17"" Year of his Age: Phebe aged 3 Years.

JEi. 41. Death like an overflowing stream. Sweeps us away, our life's a dream. An empty tale : a morning flower. Cut down and withered in and hour.

In Memory of Anna Moberts Lynus, Daughter of Mr. Robert & Mrs. Mary Linus, who departed this Life May 5"*, 1786, Aged I }-ear 6 months & 18 days.

In Memory of Lticy, wife of Elijah Marshall, who died April i, 1840, aged 56. Here lieth the Body of 3Lr. Paul 3Iarerich, who Departed this Life Janry. the 20''', Anno Dom 1745-6 in the 52°'* year of his age.

[The following 23 inscriptions are found in tiie NicoU's plot.] [Monument.] Sacred to the Memory of Francis IF. Xicoll, son of the late Gen. Matthias Nicoll, who died Sept. 24, 1842. aged 57 years. It may be truly said of him that he was a father to the fatherless, a friend to the widow, kind and benevolent to the poor.

At Peace with his God, Himself and the world, He died lamented, By all who knew him. [South side.] Sarah, Relict of Genl. Matthias Nicoll, Deed. Jan. 6, 1848, Aged 90 Years.

The righteous shall be had in everlasting remembrance. [East side.] Died at Canton, in China, on the first day of November, 1829, where his remains are interred, George Hobert Doivdall, Son-inlaw of Genl. Matthias Nicoll, in the 47*"^ year of his age.

Provenance

Text from A History of the Old Town of Stratford and the City of Bridgeport, Connecticut, published 1886, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive. The settlements listed against this township are matched by point-in-polygon test of each Geographic Names Information System coordinate against the Census Bureau's county subdivision boundary, not by name.