| March 2006 | Flood | Montezuma | $100,000 | no account filed |
| July 2004 | Thunderstorm Wind | Montezuma | $25,000 | no account filed |
| January 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | $20,000 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain and snow melt. |
| February 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | $15,000 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain and snow melt. |
| March 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | $15,000 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain and snow melt. Flooding continued into April until the morning of April 9th at 00:30. |
| February 2011 | Thunderstorm Wind | Montezuma | $10,000 | A farmer's large sprinkler system was blown over due to damaging thunderstorm wind gusts. |
| February 2007 | Flood | Montezuma | $10,000 | The Wabash River flooded in Parke County. The river remained in flood into March. Crests were over 7 feet above flood stage. |
| March 2007 | Flood | Montezuma | $10,000 | The Wabash River in Parke County remained above flood stage from February through all of March. Crests were 10 feet above flood stage. |
| January 2007 | Flood | Montezuma | $10,000 | The Wabash River in Parke County remained high through most of January. Crests were as high as 12 feet above flood stage. |
| April 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | $5,000 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain. |
| May 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | $5,000 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain. Flooding continued until June 16th at 0720. |
| May 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | $5,000 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain. |
| April 2007 | Flood | Montezuma | $5,000 | Flooding returned to the Wabash River in Parke County during late April. The crest reached two and a half feet above flood stage. |
| December 2006 | Flood | Montezuma | $5,000 | The Wabash River flooded in Parke County. Water remained high into January. |
| December 2006 | Flood | Montezuma | $5,000 | The Wabash River flooded in Parke County. The river crested at over six feet above flood stage. |
| June 2025 | Thunderstorm Wind | Montezuma | $3,000 | Thunderstorm wind gusts downed a 10 to 15-inch diameter tree limb onto house. |
| May 2009 | Flood | Montezuma | $1,000 | Extensive flooding occurred along the Wabash River near Lyford, Indiana. The river crested 7.3 feet above flood stage on May 19th at a reading of 25.3 feet. Damage costs are grossly estimated. |
| January 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | $1,000 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain and snow melt. This flooding began on December 22nd and continued into January. |
| April 2007 | Flood | Montezuma | $1,000 | Flooding continued from February and March on the Wabash River in Parke County. The crest reached seven feet above flood stage. |
| November 2007 | Flood | Montezuma | $1,000 | Lowland flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County due to heavy rain. |
| December 2007 | Flood | Montezuma | $500 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain. |
| December 2007 | Flood | Montezuma | $500 | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain and snow melt. Flooding continued until January second. |
| July 2015 | Thunderstorm Wind | Montezuma | - | An estimated 60 mph thunderstorm wind gust was observed in this location. |
| May 2011 | Thunderstorm Wind | Montezuma | - | A 65 mph thunderstorm wind gust was observed in this location. A rotating wall cloud was also reported. |
| March 2009 | Flood | Montezuma | - | Extensive flooding of agricultural land occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County in and near Montezuma, IN. The river crested 10.69 feet above flood stage at the Montezuma river gauge on March 14th, a reading of 24.69 feet. The flooding also affected some roads and possibly flooded basements. |
| March 2009 | Flood | Montezuma | - | Very minor flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including in and near Montezuma, due to heavy rain. The river crest was just under one half foot above flood stage. |
| April 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | - | Flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain and snow melt. This flooding is a continuation from flooding that began on March 3rd at 1151. March flood damage is estimated at fifteen thousand dollars. |
| June 2008 | Thunderstorm Wind | Montezuma | - | Large tree limbs were reported down due to damaging thunderstorm winds. |
| June 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | - | This flooding is a continuation of flooding that began on May 31st at 0933 EST. The flooding occurred along the Wabash River in Parke County, including near Montezuma, due to heavy rain. Flood damage estimates from May include five-thousand dollars in both crop and property damage. |
| July 2008 | Flood | Montezuma | - | Excessive rainfall along the Wabash River caused flooding in Vermillion county, including near Montezuma. |
| April 1994 | Thunderstorm Wind | Montezuma | - | Several trees and a large limb were blown down. |
| May 2004 | Hail | Montezuma | - | no account filed |
| June 2004 | Hail | Montezuma | - | no account filed |
| June 2004 | Flash Flood | Montezuma | - | no account filed |
| May 2001 | Hail | Montezuma | - | no account filed |