From the form
The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.
NPS Form 10-900 (Rev. 10-90) United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Registration Form OMB No. 1024-0018 1256 OCT 1 4 2004 This form is for use in nominating or requesting determinations for individual properties and districts. See instructions in How to Complete the National terms on continuation sheets (NPS Form 10-900a). Use a typewriter, word processor, or computer, to complete all items. 1. Name of Property historic name South Burying Ground other names/site number Winchester Street Burying Ground (Newton MRA) 2. Location street & number Winchester Street N/A not for publication city or town _ Newton N/A _ vicinity state_ Massachusetts _code_MA county Middlesex code 017zip code_02461 3.
State/Federal Agency Certification As, the designated authority under the National Historic Preservation Act of 1986, as amended, I hereby certify that this nomination request for determination of eligibility meets the documentation standards for registering properties in the National Register of Historic Places and meets the procedural and professional requirements set forth in 36 CFR Part 60. In my opinion the property meets - does not meet the National Register Criteria. I recommend that this property be considered significant - nationally - statewide ocally.
([See continuation sheet for additional comments.) feetay Fredleerg, hationel Register Auech pao 10/12/04 Massachusetts Historical Commission, State Historic Preservation Officer In my opinion the property meets [ does not meet the National Register Criteria.([See continuation sheet for additional comments.) Signature of certifying official/Title Date State or Federal Agency and bureau Date 4. National Park Service Certification 1, hereby certify that this property is: rentered in the National Register - see continuation sheet - determined eligible for the National Register - see continuation sheet - determined not eligible for the National Register - removed from the National Register Bonaturegr ine Keper Edsor Beall Date of Action 11/27/04 - other (explain): South Burying Ground Name of Property 3.
Classification Ownership of Property _private X public-local -public-State public-Federal Category of Property building(s) district site structure object Name of related multiple property listing (enter N/A if property is not part of a multiple property listing) Newton MA (MRA), 1986 6. Function or Use Historic Functions Funerary: Cemetery 7. Description Architectural Classification Narrative Description See continuation sheets. Middlesex County, Massachusetts County and State Number of Resources within Property Contributing Non contributing buildings sites structures objects Total Number of contributing resources previously listed in the National Register N/A Current Functions Funerary: Cemetery Materials Granite, Marble, Slate NPS Form 10-900-a United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Continuation Sheet OMB Approval No.
1024-0018 Newton MRA South Burying Ground Newton, Middlesex County, MA Section number 1 _Page 1 7. NARRATIVE DESCRIPTION South Burying Ground, the third burial place established in Newton, is a small municipal cemetery that retains strong historical associations and distinctive burial markers associated with residents of the Upper Falls and Oak Hill neighborhoods. There are 357 recorded burials that occurred here between 1803 and 1938, primarily in the first part of the 19" century. These are represented by approximately 165 standing headstones, six small monuments, and nine tombs. The city of Newton lies immediately to the west of Boston and Brookline. The Charles River forms the municipal boundary on the north, west and south. Newton is unusually decentralized for an eastern Massachusetts community, consisting of 12 villages, each with its own distinct identity.
The varied topography, composed of glacial outwash with seven glacial drumlins and low swampy areas, adds to the physical diversity of the community. While Newton was settled in the 17* century, its present character was largely shaped by 19" and 20" century development. South Burying Ground is a rectangular 1.37-acre site that lies in the southwestern part of Newton near the intersection of Winchester and Needham Streets, between the villages of Newton Upper Falls and Newton Highlands. It is a few hundred yards south of Boylston Street (Route 9), a major east/west regional route. Winchester Street, which abuts the burying ground on the east, is a busy two-lane street that is occupied primarily by late 20# century commercial, industrial and office buildings, including a large lumberyard that abuts the burying ground on the south and west.
The MBTA mass transit tracks run a short distance to the west. The most prominent topographic features of the burying ground are two knolls, one on either side of the main entrance. The south knoll, with the tombs located along its western edge, occupies most of the southeast quadrant of the cemetery. It is the highest point in the burying ground, rising about 12' above the surrounding landscape, which is relatively level. The east-facing slope, which abuts Winchester Street, is extremely steep while the other sides slope more gradually. The north knoll is both smaller and lower, rising only about 5' above the adjacent areas, with gentle slopes. A dry-laid fieldstone retaining wall (NR #1) marks the east (Winchester Street) boundary of the burying ground and portions of the north and south boundaries as well.
It is approximately 24" tall, is composed primarily of local puddingstone and was probably built in the 19* century. There is a break (continued) NPS Form 10-900-a OMB Approval No. 1024-0018 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Continuation Sheet Newton MRA South Burying Ground Newton, Middlesex County, MA Section number_7 _Page 2 in the wall near the center for the entrance to the burying ground, which is marked by dressed granite posts approximately 3'tall. A 6-8' tall chain link fence surrounds the entire burying ground, which is secured by a 6' tall double-leaf chain link gate. Along Winchester Street it is set on top of the stone wall. The Winchester Street gate, which is the sole access point, is kept locked except for maintenance or special requests.
There is no paved circulation system, but the 1901 map of the burying ground (copy attached) shows a system of narrow rectilinear roads and paths that create and define the spatial organization. These are turf and rarely used, but their pattern is still partially visible on the ground, defined in part by a partial row of ash trees. A second entrance, shown on the map at the southern end of burying ground, is no longer in use. Vegetation consists of scattered mature trees, mostly ash and maple, some evergreen trees (pine and cedar), and a few shrubs (lilac and arborvitae). The ashes are generally in decline and there has already been some loss of limbs. There is also extensive volunteer growth that is impacting gravestones, particularly along the west wall of the burying ground, with fallen limbs and low branching pines obscuring some headstones.
Vegetation contributes significantly to the character of the site but also represents a potential hazard to the burial markers, particularly if it is not pruned regularly. The rectilinear spatial organization of South Burying Ground reflects the transitional style of the early 19"' century. It consists of a combination of single graves and family lots running north/south. The mounded eastern section of the burial ground contains primarily single graves, arranged in rough rows, as well as tombs. The level middle section contains the largest number of family lots, interspersed with some single graves, especially at the southern end. Narrow strips of land at the western and northern edges of the burying ground, which were added in 1833, contain primarily single graves with a few family lots.
The spatial organization is most clearly evident on the 1901 map, which shows all recorded burials, including those not marked by headstones, monuments, or corner posts. Today the spatial organization is less clear because there is no visible evidence of many of the graves. Most of the headstones face west away from Winchester Street. There are 27 family lots shown on the 1901 map, some of which are still marked by low granite corner posts. There are also nine mound tombs (NR #2), all located in the southeast quadrant of the burying ground. Eight of these (A-H) are attached tombs with brick facing on their west façade, with the brick partially collapsed in some sections and in need of repair. A single tomb is located on top of the knoll behind Tomb C. (continued) NPS Form 10-900-a OMB Approval No.
1024-0018 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Continuation Sheet Newton MRA South Burying Ground Newton, Middlesex County, MA Section number _1 . Page 3 The 1901 map shows approximately 244 headstones, 150 footstones, and 6 monuments. Today there are approximately 165 standing headstones and six monuments. There are also at least a dozen fallen and partially buried headstones and numerous fragments throughout the burying ground. It is difficult to get an accurate count of footstones because many are no longer upright and lie buried in the ground. The various types of burial markers display a range of styles that were popular during the 19* century and clearly illustrate evolving funerary styles during this period. Approximately 55 of the headstones are slate, which is primarily dark gray.
Most of these are of relatively modest size and fairly simple with little decorative carving. The willow and urn motif popular during the mid-19* century is fairly well represented at South Burying Ground. The earlier slate headstones, located primarily in the southeastern quadrant of the burying ground, have a rounded tympanum on a shouldered main block. There are also a number of rectangular slate headstones and some with a pointed Gothic-arch tympanum on a shouldered main block. The Gothic arched headstones are an unusual form that is also found at Newton's two other early burying grounds. There are also 110 upright marble headstones that vary in size and style. Most are fairly simple and are 3-4' tall, except for those of children, which are typically smaller. Many are surprisingly clean but also eroded with most of the original design softened by years of weathering.
A few retain some of their original detail. There is one small marble pillar about 4' tall commemorating Charlotte and Leonard Hurd. There are also five marble obelisks, which vary in size from 4' to 8' tall and typically commemorate multiple family members. The largest is the Boyden monument, prominently located near the northern edge of the burying ground. Most are mounted on a separate base and pedestal, reflecting the popularity of using prefabricated component parts to create a distinctive monument. There are also a few miscellaneous graves and burial markers. One grave in the northeastern section of the burying ground is slightly raised above the surrounding area and is enclosed by curbing. There is one polished black granite monument which commemorates members of the Esty family and another small granite stone, probably a replacement for an earlier stone.
Several stones were identified during a 1990 inventory as being signed by their makers. They include: Stanton Farnu(m) (#1125); E. W. Houghton, Harvard (#332/333, #381, #659/660); Jepson, Newton Corner (#174, #1) (whose work is also represented at East and West Parish Burying Grounds); A. H. Lord, Dedham (#282); and Runnels, Waltham (#131, #1499). (continued) NPS Form 10-900-a United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Continuation Sheet OMB Approval No. 1024-0018 Newton MRA South Burying Ground Newton, Middlesex County, MA Section number_7 Page 4 The earliest burial at South Burying Ground was Enoch Davenport (d. 1803); the most recent was Samuel Bacon (d. 1938). The family best represented at South Burying Ground is the Halls with 16 family members.
Other family names include Alden, Bacon, Barney, Bixby, Boyden, Cheney, Davenport, Everett, Fogg, Giles, Hurd, Pettee, Rand, Richardson, Scott, Stone, Taylor, and Wiswall, each with between six and nine family members buried here. The unusually high rate of infant mortality is evident throughout the burying ground. Of the 357 recorded burials, 77or 22% were under five years old. Henry and Sally Boyden were particularly hard hit, losing five children under the age of five. Childbirth and motherhood also seemed to be hazardous, with mothers frequently dying around the same time as their children. On the other hand, many of those who survived lived remarkably long lives. There are 24 people who lived into their 80s, four who lived into their 90s, and Fannie Winchester Fogg (d. 1932) lived to be 100 years, 11 months and 1 day old.
Names of those buried here are almost entirely of Anglo Saxon origin. Epitaphs indicate that several people came from England. Members of the community also served in the military. Revolutionary War veterans included: General Ebenezer Cheney (d.1853); Captain Thomas Pettee (d. 1822); Captain Jeremiah Wiswall (no dates); Lieutenant Solomon Richards (d. 1845); Lieutenant Samuel Richardson (no dates); Jonathan Bixby (d.1835); Samuel Hall (d. 1828); Elisha and Thaddeus Hyde (no dates); Benjamin Parker (d. 1836); and Aaron Richards (d. 1823). Many of these men were buried in the tombs, which are still marked by veterans markers and American flags. There are also two veterans of the Civil War buried at South Burying Ground: Sgt. C. S. Brown (no dates) and C.H. Duvall (no dates). The burying ground has become overgrown with dead limbs and invasive vegetation posing a threat to burial markers.
There are approximately 244 headstones shown on the 1901 plan. Only about 165 headstones remain, a loss of one third of the headstones over the past century. The loss of footstones is even greater. A 1990 master plan identified 112 stones as being in need of repair. Many of these have been lying on the ground for more than a decade and have suffered additional damage in the intervening years. Other stones have been damaged since that time. (continued) NPS Form 10-900-a OMB Approval No. 1024-0018 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Continuation Sheet Newton MRA South Burying Ground Newton, Middlesex County, MA Section number_7 .Page 5 Archaeological Description While no ancient Native American sites are recorded in the burying ground, sites may be present. Three sites are recorded in the general area (within one mile).
Environmental characteristics of the property indicate some locational criteria (slope, soil drainage, proximity to wetlands) that are favorable for the presence of Native American sites. Undisturbed soils are well drained and found on level to moderately sloping topography. Two knolls, the most prominent topographic features on the property and frequently favored for site locations, are also found in the burial ground. The nominated property is, however, located over 1,000 feet from the nearest wetlands. South Meadow Brook is located south of the burial ground. The town of Newton lies entirely within the Charles River drainage.
Given the above information, the small size of the burial ground (1.37 acres), and the presence of 357 recorded burials, a low to moderate potential exists for locating significant ancient Native American resources at the South Burial Ground A high potential exists for the recovery of historic archaeological resources at the South Burying Ground. Additional documentary research combined with archaeological survey and testing may locate evidence of walls, post holes, and other boundary markers within and around the burying ground area. Similar research may also locate structural evidence of outbuildings, unmarked graves and funerary related artifacts. Unmarked graves may represent the most common historic archaeological resource at the burying ground.
Unmarked graves may result from burials with lost or misplaced markers, biodegradable markers, and the intentionally unmarked graves of slaves, unknown persons, paupers, other indigent persons, and body parts. Unmarked graves may contain stratigraphic evidence of a burial shaft, a casket, skeletal remains, and artifacts. Some graves may contain multiple sets of remains, partial remains, or no remains at all. The latter two examples can refer to graves that have been partially or completely removed or reburied - END - South Burying Ground Name of Property Middlesex County, Massachusetts County and State 8. Statement of Significance