Nomination for Paige, David R., House

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

Form No. 10-300 (Rev. 10-74) UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES INVENTORY -- NOMINATION FORM SEE INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW TO COMPLETE NATIONAL REGISTER FORMS TYPE ALL ENTRIES -- COMPLETE APPLICABLE SECTIONS AND/OR COMMON STREET & NUMBER NOT FOR PUBLICATION CITY. TOWN CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT . Madison - VICINITY OF 11 - J. William Stanton PRESENT USE *PRIVATE _WORK IN PROGRESS X PRIVATE RESIDENCE PUBLIC ACQUISITION IN PROCESS XYES: RESTRICTED .BEING CONSIDERED - YES: UNRESTRICTED OWNER OF PROPERTY Dr. D. E.

Klingbeil 5 LOCATION OF LEGAL DESCRIPTION COURTHOUSE REGISTRY OF DEEDS, ETC 47 North Park Place REPRESENTATION IN EXISTING SURVEYS DEPOSITORY FOR SURVEY RECORDS 085 039 DATA SHEET LOCATION House Painesville TITLE DATE OBJECT CODE SITE Ohio COUNTY STATE OWNERSHIP HISTORIC ACCESSIBLE CATEGORY CLASSIFICATION TRANSPORTATION AGRICULTURE SCIENTIFIC ENTERTAINMENT RELIGIOUS STRUCTURE Lake PARK STATUS MUSEUM NAME PUBLIC INDUSTRIAL OTHER: RECEIVEDNOV 11 1975 _GOVERNMENT Lake County Courthouse DATE ENTERED _EDUCATIONAL - UNOCCUPIED X_BUILDING(S) MILITARY 21-29 West Main Street -DISTRICT FOR NPS USE ONLY - BOTH Paige, , David B * COMMERCIAL Judye DESCRIPTION X EXCELLENT Adam or Federal houses of 1816-1830 in the three northeasternmost a porch, as indicated by the flush siding to the level of the second- The one &1/2 story wing to the west seems to have been added within a dozen years after the main block, as indicated by the purer Greek frieze, the full-round Doric columns, and the awkward joint of the wing at a window frame on the main block.

of the distinctly Eastlake character of the ornament, the windows windows were enlarged, the sash were replaced with two panes over two, and the architraves altered with a heavy molding and incised brackets supported by turned colonnettes on oorbel blocks, a combination which could hardly have been conceived before 1875. The unsympathetic pediments over the two main entrances are of the main north-south block, and the south porch of the west materials to accommodate offices and apartments. CONDITION MOVED UNALTERED DATE DETERIORATED UNEXPOSED FAIR pattern radically altered with picture windows and irregular spacing modern additions. front is flush tongue-and-groove.On the wing there was originally and frieze of the main block were altered.

The ground story a blind arcade of shallow semi-elliptical arches.The arcade is contin- counties of Ohio.The complete pediment of the north facade contains a semi-elliptical fanlight with a keystone. The siding of the "temple original structure consists of a two-story block with the gable end to accommodate modern apartments.The only addition has been a The north-south block is considerably longer than the east-west one. with stylistic features of at least three distinct periods.The large The interior is greatly altered by partitions and modern graphs as late as 1900. ued on the east wing.This feature is a common one on several late one-story lean-to approximately five feet deep on the west elevation wing has been closed in with glass block walls.

This isa large L-shaped structure of wooden frame construction XORIGINAL SITE CHECK ONE -RUINS -GOOD DESCRIBE THE PRESENT AND ORIGINAL (IF KNOWN) PHYSICAL APPEARANCE

Description of the property

facing the street (north), together with a two-story wing to the east. Its facade is articulated by four two-story pilasters which support story windows, with clapboard siding above. It is shown in photo- XALTERED prominent corner caps.The frieze brackets consist of pierced or The south and east elevations have had the original fenestration Sometime after 1863, and possibly as late as 1885 because AREAS OF

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

SIGNIFICANCE -- CHECK AND JUSTIFY BELOW _COMMUNITY PLANNING -LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTURE _SOCIAL/HUMANITARIAN X 1800-1899 X_POLITICS/GOVERNMENT _OTHER (SPECIFY) SPECIFIC DATES ca. 1832 STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

Statement of significance

The Paige House is representative of early commercial activity in northern Ohio, and is the home and business place of an important Adam style houses in northeastern Ohio, but made especially interest- was born in Vermont in 1806, and became a farmer, merchant, and Addison Kimball, Paige's future brother-in-law and the son of Lemuel seven years, and was instrumental in the organization of the Cleveland, Painesville and Ashtabula Railroad, later part of the Lake Shore & After Paige's move, the hotel was operated by various proprietors, houses apartments and various offices.

1400-1499 1700-1799 RELIGION ECONOMICS ART BUILDER/ARCHITECT EDUCATION SCIENCE ARCHEOLOGY-HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE PERIOD MILITARY THEATER AGRICULTURE LITERATURE 1900- XARCHITECTURE _COMMUNICATIONS Addison Kimball _PHILOSOPHY supported the Lake Erie Seminary in Painesville and was a vestryman ARCHEOLUGY-PREHISTORIC Kimball, an early settler of Madison. Paige married Nancy Kimball _EXPLORATION/SETTLEMENT PREHISTORIC Michigan Southern and still later the New York Central.He also David R. Paige shortly after his arrival in Madison in 1832. Paige _TRANSPORTATION _CONSERVATION millinery store was operated in the west wing.Today the building among them a Mrs.Colter late in the century.It is not known who _ENGINEERING The structure was built as a residence, store and hotel for - INVENTION of the Episcopal Church.He retired to Painesville in 1863.

was responsible for the architectural alterations.Around 19o0 a in 1837,and operated his business in Madison for thirty years. -1500-1599 Hesserved as associate judge of the Court of Common Pleas for _INDUSTRY _SCULPTURE -1600-1699 ing because of the pastiche of styles. XCOMMERCE - MUSIC _LAW early citizen. Architecturally it is one of perhaps the dozen best "general man of business." The house and hotel were built by

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

MAJOR BIBLIOGRAPHICAL REFERENCES 1971), 88. 1878), 224, 232. 10 GEOGRAPHICAL DATA ACREAGE OF NOMINATED PROPERTY UTM REFERENCES VERBAL BOUNDARY DESCRIPTION LIST ALL STATES AND COUNTIES FOR PROPERTIES OVERLAPPING STATE OR COUNTY BOUNDARIES 11 FORM PREPARED BY NAME / TITLE Eric Johannesen, Preservationist July 1975 STREET & NUMBER CITY OR TOWN 12 STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER CERTIFICATION NATIONAL - hereby nominate this property for inclusion in the National Register and certify that it has been evaluated according to the criteria and procedures set forth by the National Park Service STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER SIGNATURE FOR NPS USE ONLY DEC 1 9 1975 KEEPER OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER GPO 888-445 COUNTY DATE CODE ORGANIZATION TELEPHONE Cleveland STATE NORTHING Ohio LOCAL ATTEST: .216-721-5722 The Madison Press, April 22, 197l.

ZONE EASTING less than one Williams Brothers, History of Lake and Geauga Counties (Philadelphia, As the designated State Historic Preservation Officer for the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (Public Law 89-665)./ Western Reserve Historical Society 10825 East Boulevard THE EVALUATED SIGNIFICANCE OF THIS PROPERTY WITHIN THE STATE IS: EÓ IN THÉ NATIONAL REGISTER DIRECTOR. OFFICE OF ARCHEOCOGY AND ZONE CONTROL REVIEW PHOTOS KEEPER Entered Re-submit Send-back MAPS National Register Write-up BRANCH CHIEF WORKING NUMBER Federal Register entry Cole TECH REVIEW REVIEW UNIT CHIEF T. 30. 74. 12 39 Return 7. 31 ARCHITECTURAL HISTORIAN ARCHEOLOGIST - _ 1. Name. 2. Location. 3. Classification. 4. Owner of Property. - - 5., Location of Legal Description. - ts be off by about 12. Certification. Photographic Coverage. Bibliography. SIGNED: Other Geographical Data.

The attached National Register Inventory-Nomination form is being returned to your .Acreage. Clarification or correction of the above items must be made prior to the initiation Form Prepared By. necessarily insure that the nomination will then satisfy the National Register Thank you for your attention to the above items checked. Map Coverage. criteria in full. Please check. - 6. Representation in Existing Surveys. DATE: of our professional review.Correction of these technical errors does not NAME OF PROPERTY office for clarification of the information indicated below. ARCHITECTURAL HISTORIAN Inventory - REVIEW UNIT CHIEF * DEC 2 3 1975 INT:2106- 74 OTHER HAER Maps CONTROL Send-back TECHNICAL Re-submit Review HISTORIAN ARCHEOLOGIST Photos Federal Register Entry Working Number 7, 30,74.

1239 BRANCH CHIEF State National Register Write-up 12-3-75 11-2-8-75 11.12.75 Lake 2 3 1975 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service WAso No.7 -3-74 75001450 PROPERTY OF THE NATIOMI REGISTER NPS Number Loc UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR Form No. 10-301 a NATIONAL PARK SERVICE ENTRY NUMBER DEC 2 3 Paige, Judge David, House AND/OR HISTORIC: LOCA TION STREET AND NUMBER: CITY OR TOWN: DATE OF PHOTO: NEGATIVE FILED AT: DESCRIBE VIEW, DIRECTION, ETC. * U.S.

GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1973-729-152/1446 II- I Madison 1974 085 039 Ohio DATE COUNTY Ohio Historical Center STATE Lake NATIONAL COMMON: REGISTER CODE (7/72) 25 East Main Street North facade IDENTIFICATION (Type all entries -attach to or enclose with photograph) NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES Judith Kitchen PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPH FORM PHOTO CREDIT: FOR NPS USE ONLY NAME PHOTO REFERENCE RECEIVED PAIGE, JUDGE DAVID, HOUSE EXTERIOR VIEW OF RIGHT SIDE WING. PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER VIEW FROM THE NORTH. LAKE CO, OHID NPS Number Form No. 10-301a UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR NATIONAL PARK SERVICE FOR NPS USE ONLY ENTRY NUMBER Paige, Judge David, House AND/OR HISTORIC: LOCA TION JUL 3 0 1974 CITY OR TOWN: DATE OF PHOTO: NEGATIVE FILED AT: DESCRIBE VIEW, DIRECTION, ETC.

INT: 154-72 085 039 Madison Ohio 8/24/72 IDENTIFICATION COUNTY NAME STATE DATE Lake 25 East Main Street PHOTO REFERENCE COMMON: CODE Fazio, Michael W. NATIONAL Lake County Historical Society Library, Mentor, Ohio PROPERTY OF THE NATIONAL REGISTER NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES (Type all entries - attach to or enclose with photograph) PHOTO CREDIT: Exterior view from the north (7/72) PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPH FORM STREET AND NUMBER: DEC 2 3 1975 LAKE CO , OHIO PAIGE, JUDGE DAVID, HOUSE EXTERIOR VIEW FROM TWE NORTH. NPS Number MADISOW,OHO PAIGE, JUDGE DAVID HOUSE Form No. 10-301 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR Rev. 7-72 NATIONAL PARK SERVICE FOR NPS USE ONLY (Type all entries -attach toor enclose with map) DEC 2 3 1975 Paige, Judge David, House AND/OR HISTORIC: STREET AND NUM BER: CITY OR TOWN: U. S.

Geological Survey Madison, Ohio Quadrangle 1960 Revised 1970 JUL 3 0 1974 TO BE INCLUDED ON ALL MAPS 1. Property broundaries where required. 2. North arrow. 3. Latitude and longitude reference.

INT: 155-72 085 039 Madison COUNTY REGISTER NAME DATE REQUIREMENTS CODE STATE Lake NATIONAL LOCATION 1:24000 MAP REFERENCE COMMON: SOURCE: Ohio SCALE: NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES ENTRY NUMBER PROPERTY MAP FORM 25 East Main Street Longitude: 81° 02' 531r GEOLOGICAL SURVEY MADISON QUADRANGLE MADISON, OHIO 17 496/000 East UNITED STATES 4624/150 North ROAD CLASSIFICATION DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR STATE OF OHIO 81 °00 Latitude: 41* Paige, Judge Devie, House Also Notified State Historic Preservation Officer INT: 2950-75 Location STATE Name MMott/je Lake County 12/30/75 Date Entered Regional Director, Midwest Region ENTRIES IN THE NATIONAL REGISTER Interstate 7l at 17th Avenue Director,The Ohio Historical Society OEIO Dr.Thomas H.Smith Hon. J.

William Stanton, DEC 2 3 1975 Columbus, Onio 43211 3 OTHER NAMES: MOSTATE ( O deteriorated 17) features: Oruins 2O NOT INTACT-O -good Ounexposed - Unknown Ounknown -unexcavated ACCESS - RECREATION -28 QCLAIMS: explain 'first'O CARCHEOLOGY - prehistoric -2 - LAW-16 RELIGION- 22 - SETTLEMENT-29 ARCHEOLOGY -historic-1 - LITERATURE - 17 - SCIENCE- 23 'oldest' O AGRICULTURE -3 - CONSERVATION - 8 - HEALTH-27 - MILITARY - 18 - ECONOMICS- 9 INDUSTRY - 13 - MUSIC - 19 - SOCIAL / CULTURAL-30 'only' O - ART-5 - PHILOSOPHY - 20 - TRANSPORTATION - 25 major alterations : - ENGINEER 6artisan: EVENTS : ETHNIC ASSOCIATION CONDITION GROUP YES-Unrestricted ADMINISTRATOR INSTITUTIONAL: historic events: SUBSTANTIALLY INTACT-1 vicinity of ARCHITECTURE-4 master builder: Xexcellent COMMERCE-6 LAKE URBAN PLANWING-31 Xoriginal site EDUCATION-10 6NPS REGION: SAVED?

YES Bfunetions PAGE JVDEE DAVID,HOUSE Dfair 12)SOURCE of NOMINATION ZO NOT APPLICABLE - 9 - No Access IS PROPERTY A HISTORIC DISTRICT? Oyes - ENTERTAINMENT-26 - INVENTION -14 residence/ store/ notee @builder/contractor: IIF ADDITIONAL SPACE NEEDED. NUMBER& PUT ON REVERSE Federal t Oreconstructed - EXPLORATION -12 @architeot: ENGINEERING-11 artist: LOCAL PRIVATE ORGANIZATION NATIONAL REGISTER DATA SHEET ADAPTIVE USE if state who prepared form? county code: Dmoved MADISON te of entry: 12.23.75086 +05a. Vicinity Public (local) Field way be left blank if information is not given. Mandatory data element; field must he filled in. 12-19-84 State Code Date List County Stop Sites City Non-contr ibut ing This field should be left blank. NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISIORIC PLACES DATA COLLECTION FORM Bui ldings Public (State) Objects tll. No.

of Contr ibut ing Public (Fedetal) Restt icted Stiuctures Resource Nane T120T (B. D, S, U, O) page 1 of 4 t03. Other Nave/Site Nuuber P Private from p. 2 *08. County Code 8S Agency Start Resoul ce Type Nominatol +19. Curtent Certification Field way be left bland if information is not given. Mandatory data element; field wust be filled in. Federal Local 12-19-84 t16.Nan.Nane/Designations This field should be left blank. Multiple Naue page 2 of 4 T120T *13. Non/Det Type S Other : *18. New Certification +19a. Othet Certification Dates State NPS Patk Nane 22. Construction Materials Funct ion/Subfunct ion Codes Other Description Criter ia Consideration + This fleld should be left blank. * Mandatory data elenent that must he corpleted. Data element that may be left blank if information is not given. 12-19-84 20/20a. *24. Level of Significance 30. Cultual Affiliation +23a.

Arch Style +29a. Specific Significant Yeats +31. Architect/Builder/Engineet/Designer NHL 12-19-84 DOE Acreage 32a. HABS/N This field should be left blank. Mandatory data element; field must be filled in. +ol.Reference Nunber x/_ - / 11 - - 1_ *34. UIM Coordinates - --11_-1_-1_- 32b. HAERNO