BlockBefore

Nomination for Barnstable County Courthouse

The case file that argued this property on to the National Register: 2,561 words across 10 pages, filed in 1981. Reproduced in full, word for word.

Source document Held by the National Archives in Record Group 79 as reference 81000104, where it exists only as a scan with no text layer. The words below were read off that scan by machine, so the occasional stray character is the recogniser's and the typewriter's. Nothing is summarised, corrected or written by this site. See the catalogue record, or return to the property.

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

FHR-8-300 (11-78) United States Department of the Interior Heritage Conservation and Recreation Service National Register of Historic Places Inventory - Nomination Form See instructions in How to Complete National Register Forms Type all entries - complete applicable sections 1. Name For HCRS use only receivedMAY 11 1981 date entered JUN | 1 198| historic Barnstable County Courthouse Barnstable County Superior Court House and/or common 2. Location street & number Main Street (Route 6A) not for publication city, town Barnstable vicinity of state Massachusetts 3.

Classification Category Ownership - district xpublic x building(s) -eprivate - structure both - site Public Acquisition - object in process being considered code 025 county congressional district Barnstable twelve code 001 Status &occupied unoccupied work in progress Accessible X yes: restricted yes: unrestricted no Present Use .agriculture commercial - educational _ entertainment Xgovernment - industrial military museum park private residence religious scientific transportation other: 4. Owner of Property name County of Barnstable street & number Main Street city, town Barnstable - vicinity of 5. Location of Legal Description state Massachusetts courthouse, registry of deeds, etc. Barnstable: County Registry of Deeds street & number Main Street city, town Barnstable state Massachusetts 6.

Representation in Existing Surveys the Commonwealth #114 title Inventory of the Historic Assets of has this property been determined elegible? - yes * no date 1979 _federal x state county local depository for survey records Massachusetts Historical Conmission city, town Boston state Massachusetts 7. Description Condition excellent X good fair deteriorated ruins unexposed Check one - unaltered X altered Check one * original site _ moved date Describe the present and original (if known) physical appearance

Description of the property

The Barnstable County Courthouse is sited on a hill overlooking Barnstable Village and harbor and Cape Cod bay beyond. It is surrounded by approximately 4 acre of landscaped building reflects its public institutional function and its primary role in the develop- ment of Barnstable County. The original structure was rectangular in plan and rose two stories to a pitched roof. It is constructed of coursed rough faced Quincy granite with corner quoins of lighter gray granite. Fenestration throughout the building is regular and consists of 8/8 double hung sash at the first story and 12/12 double hung sash at the second story. The roof, originally covered with slate, is now asphalt shingle. Atop its front pitch is an eight colum cupola with a copper cap set on a three tier base. The most imposing feature of the courthouse is its correctly detailed Greek Doric por- tico.

Four fluted colums support an entablature whose architrave bears the words "Barnstable County Court House" and whose frieze is detailed with triglyphs and metopes. A triangular pediment with raking cornice and mutules completes the composition. Al- though the portico appears to be constructed of granite it is actually fashioned of The only feature of the facade, behind the portico, is a generously scaled entry which appears to be a colonial revival addition. It consists of two eight paneled doors su rmounted by first a glazed transom and then a solid transom. These elements are enframed by simple pilasters and a cornice which is supported on consoles. entry is approached by three granite steps upon which the colums of the portico rest. Additions to the building have included the following: In 1897, a 24' by 26' south central wing was added.

The architect was Samuel D.Kelley, the Bay State Brick Co. did much of the work. The interior floors and ceilings are of North River flagstone. All the rooms within the original courthouse and additions are fireproof with 400 pound metal doors dividing them. These doors are molded and studded with rosettes and fine hinges. All of the lumber used is spruce with the trusses of hard pine. A cellar was also included in this addition. As with all oi the additions, Quincy granite, when available, was used in maintaining the texture and historical integ- rity of the outside facade. In 1893, the area for the Registry of Deeds was determined to be too small an area. J. Williams Beal of Boston designed a one story, 40 square foot east wing. Portland cement and Quincy grantite were again used. In 1906, the Boston Museum of Fine Arts architect, Guy Lowell, of Boston, designed an accompanying 40 sq.

foot two story west ell and a second story addition to the 1893 FHR-8-300 (11-78) United States Department of the Interior Heritage Conservation and Recreation Service ational Regi t r of Historic Places nventory - Nomination Form For HCRS use only received MAY 1 1 1981 date entered JUN | | 1981 Continuation sheet Item number 7 Page 1 east ell. The builders were Ernest L. Sampson of Plymouth, and Robert J. Ryder; the total cost was $35,000. The west addition included a Probate Court room, and office for the Registry of Probate, and on the second floor was a law library, 16' by 36', the County Treasurer's office and the office of the District Attorney; below was the basement. The east wing consisted of two jury rooms, 16' by 18', rooms for the judges of the Superior and Supreme courts, an office for the County Sheriff and additional smaller rooms.

This addition was also constructed with Quincy granite to conform with the rest of the structure's fabric. All slip window sills are also of granite with white pine double hung window frames. In 1925; a southwest ell, 16'by10' by 34'4" by 31'7" was added along with a southwest ell of 68'10" by 34'4" by 31'7" '. The general contractors were Somers and Drisko of Boston. All of these additions kept a well balanced appearance to the entire structure. In 1972, G.H. Swart, Inc. of Barnstable, completed renovations in the Superior Court room and put on a south central addition of 48' by 17' to fill in between the 1925 east and west wings, the architect was Gafney Associates, Incoc. At the rear of the building is a white central two colum portico with two inside and two outside pilasters, cornice and parapet, the center of which displays an elaborate gold, blue/gray and off white County symbol.

The steps leading up are sided bya handicap ramp. The court room was rehabilitated with sensitivity, saving as much as possible of the original fabric :and putting back into use objects that had long been stored in the basement. The traditional judge's bench, tables for the lawyers, and witness stand were all retained in their highly polished tine grained wood richness. And, a silver and tin codfish, symbol of the Commonwealth and Cape, hangs among four shinning chandeliers from the center of this spacious and elegant Federal style court room. long central barrel arched hallway of the 1832 building was extended and elaborated upon in the 1879 addition. The Court House is thüs a splendid example of continual use with a rich air of tradition and history that is both alive and preserved.

A separate Registry of Deeds and Probate Court were built behind the Court house in 1955 and a District Court (first) on the east end of the County grounds was built in 1971. However, most of the County offices and the Superior Court are still in the main building. 8. S'gn ficance Period prehistoric 1400-1499 1500-1599 1600-1699 1700-1799 1800-1899 1900- Specific dates Areas of Significance - Check and justify below _ archeology-prehistoric community planning - archeology-historic conservation X agriculture economics _ architecture education art engineering commerce exploration/settlement communications industry invention landscape architecture law literature .military - music - philosophy xpolitics/government - religion science sculpture .social/ humanitarian theater transportation other (specify) 1831/32 Builder/Architect Jacob & Abner Taylor/ Alexander Parris Statement of

Statement of significance

(in one paragraph) The Barnstable County Courthouse possesses integrity of location, design, setting, materials, and workmanship and is significant on several levels. First, it has served as the seat of county govemment and justice since its construction in 1831 and therefore has played a role in many of the important events which have shaped the history of Cape Cod. Second, many of the county's most respected citizens have served at the Courthouse and even some nationally known lawyers like Daniel Webster have argued cases there. Finally, the Courthouse, which may have been designed by the well known architect, Alexander Parris, is a fine example of the monumental Greek Revival style. Therefore the Courthouse meets criteria A,B, and C of the National Register of Historic Places. The first courthouse session on Cape Cod was held in Barnstable Village in 1686.

The first Colonial Courthouse for the Cape was erected in 1774 in that village and is still standing. On the night of October 22, 1827, the Barnstable County House burned to the ground taking with it most deed and probate records. After this, the registers of deeds and probates, etc. kept these records in their homes. In 1828, arrangements were made for the erection of the jpresent Superior Court. Ground was broken for it on November 7, 1831 and the building was completed by the following Now for the first time the offices of the court and the rest of the county could be combined. This was also the original office of the first County Conmissioners; Mathew Cobb of Banstable, Samuel T. Croswell of Falmouth, and Obed Brooks of Harwich. Their positions were created when in 1828 the old Courts of Sessions and the Comm- issioners of Highways were abolished by the legislature.

Most county offices are still in this building. Many of the Commonwealth's famous judges have sat there, including Barnstable native, Chief Justice Lemuel Shaw. And, they have heard cases argued by attorneys from all ovbsttr. Oobert Bobludigersoil ons ans a l viserotriento aassac beeethis bench. Webster. Robert Among other lawyers to have argued there was Banstable native Zero Scudder, whose marble bust decorates the Court room was the only native lawyer to become a member of the Superior Court. Also of Barnstable was George Marston. He argued in this Court as County District Attorney and went on to become the Massachusetts Attorney General. In addition to its historical significance in the fields of politics and government, the courthouse also possesses considerable architectural significance.

It is a relatively early example of the Greek Revival style on Cape Cod and thought to be the first with a full two story columned portico. Due to its highly visible public function, its monumental scale and its correct detail, the courthouse must have been instrumental in popularizing the Greek Revival stylein the area. Design of the building is ascribed to Alexander Parris who is well known for his early works in granite and the Greek Revival style. 9. M or Bib ograph ca References Barnstable County Cormissioners records. Seven Villages of Barnstable, Town of Barnstable, 1976. History of the County of Barnstable, Simeon L. Deyo, New York, 1890. Barnstable Patriot, 9/14/1831, p 2 & 12/7/1831, p. 2 10.

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

Geographical Data ARRFAGE ENOTCERISEN Acreage of nominated property less than one acre Quadrangle name Hyannis UTM NOT WERQuadrangle scale UMT References ^ L119l [3\911/41310 Zone Easting 1416/117/21310/ Northing LILL Zone Easting LuLL LuLLL 1:24000 LIL Northing EL GLI FLIJ LLILLL HLLLILLL LLILLL Verbal boundary description and justification The nomination is confined to the historic courthouse and excludes modern structures on the lot. Please refer to the attached assessor's map. List all states and counties for properties overlapping state or county boundaries state code county code state code county code 11.

Form Prepared By name/title Candace Jenkins, Registration Director with Jack Clarke, Preservation Planner Cape Cod Planning Commission organization Massachusetts Historical Commission date April 1981 street & number 294 Washington Street telephone 617-727-8470 city or town Boston state Massachusetts 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: _national state local As the designated State Historic Preservation Officer for the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (Public Law 89 665), I hereby nominate this property for inclusion in the National Register and certify that it has been evaluated according to the criteria and procedures set forth by the Heritage Conservation and Recreation Service.

State Historic Preservation Officer signature ValuuRWeslowske Executive Director, Massachusetts Historical Commission 5/1/81 For HCRS use only I hereby certity that this property is included in the Natioteredgiste the dlelaus National Register Keeper of the National Registef date 6.11.81 Attest: Chief of Registration date GP O 938 835 DUE 6/10/81 - 6/25/81 Name State, Barnstable Genty Couchanae dnr-3 County MA Barnitahle _Fed Nom or Request-Agency Working Number 5.11.81.149 Federal Register Date 2. é Nomination _ Determination of Eligiblity /Bldg(s) Within: Site Multiple Resource Area On Nomination Form - _Object - Thematic Grour - Structure Maps L/ -District Photos 1 Nomination prepared by: - State Staff Local - Other - Intered In the Action: Natlonal RegisterCheck if Appropriate: <ACCEPT 6-/1.8) State Request for Review RETURN - Keeper's Decision to Review REJECT - 2nd Return I.

Evaluation of Resource (cont. on back if necessary) II. Evaluation of Nomination Good | Adequate | Poor Comments 1. Descriptive Statement Short Format Yes 2. Significance Statement ShortFormat Yes 3. Concepts/Integrity 4. Concepts/Criteria 5. Concepts/Boundaries 6. Contextual Evaluation No No General Comments (cont. on back if necessary): Reviewer/Date National Park Service See Attached_ U.S. Department of the Interior Barnstable County Courthouse Main Street Barnstable, Mass. Barnstable Jack Clarke 1980 Cape Cod Planning & Economic Development Commission Photo #1 of 1 Facade, facing southeast Count, lovithouie HA MAY 11 1981 JUN I 1 1981 1a/ j0 Jack ClauKe CAPE COD PLANNING AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENI COMMISSION Ist DISTRACT COURT HOUSE BARNSIABIE» MASS., 02630 RAILROAD AVE TOPT 23 'GAC REGISTRY OF DEEDS 369 AC.

BANNSTCOMA CCTON HOUSE TOAC 14-2 84 ac 2.55 AC.-S 82 - 49Ac 1.43 Ac MAUSHOO 00.3 (3, PREPARED UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE BARNSTABLE BOARD OF ASSESSORS AVIS AIRMAP INC MASS. 1970 CONN. Barnstable County Superior Court House Assessor's man in Barnstable Town Hall, # 1/2" = 100' 589 299. JUN I | 1981 37.1 1650 6A 2104c., 322-5 695 4C. 12ac. 192-5 1 95 AC. 'a-, 1.33 -BÁC. 135Ac 62 64 AC S9AC GiAc 4 -15 Liac 298-15 RECEIVED MAY 11 1981 NATIONAL REGISTER -6 MAY 11 15051 MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Office of the Secretary of State 294 Washington Street Boston, Massachusetts 02108 617-727-8470 MICHAEL JOSEPH CONNOLLY Secretary of State May 4, 1981 Mr. Jerry Rogers, Acting Keeper Registration Branch Heritage, Conservation & Recreation Service DOI, W434 Washington D.C. 20243 Dear Mr.

Rogers: Enclosed you will find the following nomination forms for publicly owned buildings: Barnstable-Barnstable County Csurthouse (state) Fall River-B.M.C. Durfee High School (local) Hull-Point Allerton Lifesaving Station (state) Lynn-Old Post Office (local) Weymouth-Fogg Library (local) All have been voted eligible by the State Review Board and have been signed by the State Historic Preservation Officer. Sincerely, Candace fenkins Candace Jenkins Registration pirector RECEIVEN MAY 1 1981 NAMIONAL REGISTER TE 10D ENTRIES IN THE NATIONAL REGISTER STATE MASSACHUSETTS JUN 1T 198T Date Entered Name Location Durfee, B. M. C., High School Fall River Bristol County Fogg Library Weynouth Norfolk County Barnstable County Courthouse Barnstable Barnstable County Point Allerton Lifesaving Station Hul1 Plywouth County Also Notified Honorable Paul E. Isongas Honorable Edward M.

Kennedy Honorable Margaret N. Heckler Honorable Gerry E. Studds Northeast Region, HCRS State Historic Preservation Officer Mrs. Patricia L. Weslowaki - Executive Director / Massachusetts Historical Connission 294 Washington Street Boston, Massachusetts 02108 Fod/uither580 information, please call the National Register at (202)343-6401.