BlockBefore

Nomination for Burnham, David, House

The case file that argued this property on to the National Register: 4,383 words across 30 pages, filed in 1983. Reproduced in full, word for word.

Source document Held by the National Archives in Record Group 79 as reference 83000574, where it exists only as a scan with no text layer. The words below were read off that scan by machine, so the occasional stray character is the recogniser's and the typewriter's. Nothing is summarised, corrected or written by this site. See the catalogue record, or return to the property.

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

NPS Form10-900 (7-81) United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Inventory - Nomination Form See instructions in How to Complete National Register Forms Type all entries-complete applicable sections 1. Name historic David Burnham House (preferred) and/or common Lakeside Farm or Burnna House 2. Location street & number Pond Street city, town Essex N/Avicinity of coagreasionat dietiat. state MA code 025 3. Classification Category Ownership -district - public X building(s) X private _ structure both _ site Public Acquisition .object in process being considered NA 4. Owner of Property county Essex Status X _ occupied unoccupied . work in progress Accessible X yes: restricted yes: unrestricted .no Present Use _agriculture commercial educational entertainment government industrial military name Adrian C.

Larkin street & number Pond Street city, town Essex N/Avicinity of 5. Location of Legal Description state MA courthouse, registry of deeds, etc. Essex Registry of Deeds street & number 32 Federal Street city, town Salem 6. Representation in Existing Surveys state MA title Inventory of the Historic Assets of the Commonwealth #25 date 1979 has this property been determined eligible? federal X state depository for survey records Massachusetts Historica] Commission city, town Boston state MA OMB NO.1024-0018 EXP. 10/31184 For NPS use only received date entered FEB 8983 N/A not for publication code 0n9 _museum -park X private residence - religious scientific transportation . other: - yes X no county - local 7. Description David Burnham House, Essex, MA Condition X excellent .

good fair deteriorated unaltered X altered Check one 4 original site moved unexposed Describe the present and original (if known) physical appearance

Description of the property

Built between 1680 and 1690, the Burnham House is situated on Pond Street in a wooded, sparsely settled area of Essex. The 2.5. acres immediately surrounding the house stalls andidescchpo oh. on aine late 12, meentoned imosphe of ahe carly deeds ls photo- located in the front and to the west of the house. A shortdistance to the west of the orchard and house lies a salt marsh, and just beyond that is the northeastern portion of Lake Chebacco. The main block of the Burnham House is approximately 30 feet long across its south or front elevation and is of basic five bay center-chimney construction with a one and one- half story lean-to along the rear elevation.

Various appended structures were attached on the west, north and east, and all remain, but do not seriously compromise the late 17th century appearance of the clapboarded main portion of the house, The diamond pane leaded sash with wrought hinges and probably the heavy front door with decorative nail pattern date from the restoration of the house by George Francis Dow in 1924. The 6/6 sash in the peaks of the gable ends appear to date from the late 1700's or early 1800's. The chimney has been rebuilt, but retains an early scale and proportion, if not design. The wood shingle roof adds to the early appearance of the house. The later additions, which are all well documented as to dates (see attached plan and below), includes small, one story structures, some of which were originally outbuildings on the property. To the east of the house lies a large early 19th century barn and a shed.

22 The following statement offers a description of the late 17th century interior construction of the main block of the Burnham House, and of the early 18th century construction of the lean-to on the north elevation (rear).. Details of the 1924 restoration by George Francis Dow of the Essex Institute, with assistance from the Society for the Preservation of New (sac attached Fioor 1yasl England Antiquities, are also noted. (See attached Floor Plans) - - AETOE The roof framing represents a very early type with the rafters joined together and pegged There are six principle rafters, two at each end of the attic, with four running across the middle. There are three purlins on these rafters, the middle set of which overlaps and is pegged in to the rafters.

Beneath the middle of purlins on each rafter is a very stout wood-pegged knee brace, apparently original to A number of roof sheathing or decking boards are greater than , and some are up to 18'' wide. All of the roof framing appears to be oak. Carpenters' scribe marks can be seen on the west sides of the second and third center rafters. The studs in the end walls are toenailed with wrought nails. On the north side of the attic, there is clear evidence that the lean-to was added after the main portion of the house had been built. Tops of exterior sheathing boards have been hewn off at a bevel. to take the roofing for the lean-to. Some of the bevelled sheathing evidently was removed when the lean-to was built and has been used as flooring on the south side of the attic.

The masonry mass that carries the flue through the roof is so broad that instead of trimmers, it was actually trimmed by the existing original rafters. (Continued) NPS Form10-900-a (3-82) United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination Form OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp. 10-31-84 Far NPS use anly recelved 7/0/53 date antered Continuation sheet David Burnham House, Essex Item number 7 Page 1 In the attic stairs two'pockets" consisting of diagonal slashes into a framing member along the east side of the present stairway look as if they might have taken the original door framing. postcasing on the post which supports a major carrying beam has old rose head wrought nails. cut nails that are clamped at the head, then hammered.

The floor in the hallway of the second floor appears to be 18th century, and the beaded feather-edge paneling is probably from the 1924 restoration by George Francis Dow. In 1 by conge rancis Do. the 15' wide west chamber, one massive shouldered exterior post shows up-and-down saw marks that were possibly made by a pit-saw. The paneling on the fireplace wall shows signs of paint removal, and to the upper right corner of the fireplace is illegible but certainly very old handwriting. The raised field panels over the 29'' deep fireplace may date from 1715 to 1720. Old wrought nails, some with heads hammered to make them narrow for use as proper finishing nails, attach the fireplace wall paneling. moulding below the mantel reveals newer millwork, and was probably done by Dow in 1924. Except for this later moulding, the paneling could be early 18th century.

The 16' wide east chamber has a smaller fireplace, measuring 16' deep. There is new wall surface treatment in this chamber, so it is difficult to tell what may have been there originally. The flooring, however, seems original, of a character typical of the late 17th century. It has the same type of nails that can be seen in the 1636 Fairbanks House in Dedham, Massachusetts, which are rather rare. The summer beams in both the east and west chambers are chamfered and show crudely hacked attempts at lamb's tongue stops. (The summer beams in the two downstairs rooms show more carefully carved lamb's tongue stops to the chamfers.) On the back of the north side of this room (now a passageway above the lean-to) wrought nail holes are visible in the sheathing.

These indicate that on top of this sheathing there was rather thick and broad clapboarding, four and one-half" or more in width, given the spacing of the nail holes. The ceiling of these chambers, as well as the rooms downstairs, are quite high. The stairway between the first and second floors shows evidence of having been widened as does the attic stairway. There are indications that there was a soffit under the stairway to the attic. The beaded, feather-edge paneling that sheathes the wall appears to have been added in 1924, as was the newel post and balustrade. The first floor exhibits numerous early features. The interior side of the front door shows painted beaded, feather-edge paneling.

The horizontal pieces of wood, some of which are quite wide, have been "sandwiched" with vertical pieces, all of which were nailed together with what appears to be Tremont Nail Company "Rose Head" nails with little round knobs in their centers instead of hammered heads (probably the work of Dow in 1924). The hinge hardware, though, is extremely old. Butterfly-head hand wrought nails hold the top hinge strap. The door, then, shows a combination of very early material, that is evident in many areas in the house. There is no basement under the 17' wide east room. The joists are quite substantial, and are at least 8' at the cross section. Subflooring beneath the present floor is attached with cut nails, so neither floor is original to the house.

The posts in this room (Continued) NPS Form 10-900-a (3-82) United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination Form OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp. 10-31-84 For NPS use anly recelved k/1/r) date entered Continuation sheet David Burnham House, Essex Item number Page 2 are not shouldered. The lamb's tongue stops, mentioned above, in the chamfers, are original. An extremely large fireplace (very much like the one in the 1671 Swet- Ilsley House in Newbury, Massachusetts), of which there is a well documented account of lts restoration in 1924, 15 located on the west side of the room, near the rear (north) wall. The huge lintel above the fireplace shows in an opening almost nine teet across in front and 12-14" deep in section.

The lintel has been cut at a diagonal, and slants back into the masonry opening, which was covered by plaster pargeing. There is a curious square pocket in the masonry just above one of the pieces of wood worked into the brick - there is no corresponding pocket on the other side of the fireplace. The wall on the south side is laid up straight, but the wall on north side where the lean-to is, is laid-up corbeled outward, and a beehive oven is located on the right side, near the borbeled bricks. There are inconsistencies in the brick that reveal modifications made during the 18th and 19th century. The bricks on the hearth are small, and are the type called "pea bricks," usually associated with Salem, Massachusetts. The post to the north of the fireplace carries two beams. The timber used for this post is of large dimensions, about 14" square.

A small door opening exists leading into the lean-to beside the fireplace. The wood framing and casing of the doorway is secured with very early wrought nails with hammered heads, narrow in size; yet another piece of evidence for the heads, narrow in size; yet another piece of evidence for the 1715 construction of the lean-to. The present door on the northeast side of the room has been handplaned and shows signs of paint removal. It consists of two very large raised field panels, three feet across, al- though the door itself is rather small - only 5'4" in height. The room on the west side of the first floor measures 16' in width and has a slightly smaller fireplace (35" deep) than the one mentioned above. This room shows evidence, too, of Dow's 1924 restoration, as well as many original elements.

On the west side, one portion of the wall has been removed to allow entry into one of the one-story additions (attached in the early 20th century). The ceilings of both east and west rooms are unusually high. The present cellar doorway shows, in the major beam, diagonal insertions cut into the beam and square nail holes, indicating that there was some sort of opening there when the house was originally constructed. Brick masonry leads down the 19th century stairs to a fieldstone mass, and rubble stone which supports the large fireplace in the east room above. The masonry mass of the basement extends way back, underneath the west room to the end of the lean-to's northern-most exterior wall. The trimmer granite stone shows signs of having been hewed more in shape for the fireplace in the lean-to.

It is neatly squared off at the corners and projects beyond a fieldstone foundation wall which runs east-west across the foundation of the house. The foundation on the front of the main block of the house is much lumpier, much more a case of laid up rubble stone with no attempt at trimming and smoothing. In one area under the lean-to section, the original exterior sheathing extends down and confirms that the lean-to was built after the main portion of the house. In this same area of the basement, the mortar on the fieldstone masonry of the lean-to fireplace is made similar to a hair plaster. NPS Form 10-900-a (3-82) OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp.

10-31-84 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service National Register of Historic Places Inventory - Nomination Form Far NPS use anly received date enterec Continuation sheet David Burnham House Item number 7 Page 3 The lateral additions to the main block of the David Burnham House date largely from the late 1920's. Erected following George Francis Dow's 1925 restoration of the house. these additions were designed to harmonize with the 17th century structure and made it a more functional living space without compromising its original character. Brief descriptions of these additions follow (refer to attached plan and photos #5,6 and 7). All are wood- frame construction; the exterior walls end gable roofs are sheathed with asphalt or unpainted wood shingles. 1. David Burnham House c.1684. Described above. 2.

The bedroom ell (1929) is an L-plan 1-story structure constructed on two levels to conform to the site's sloping topography. Windows are 12/12 doublehung sash. 3. The solarium is a small (21' x 21') square 1-story structure containing four hays of late glass on each exposed elevation (south and west). Erected or moved here ir 1926, it was recently modified(1981). 4. The library is a small 1-story rectangular connector with 6/6 doublehung sash and entry. A shed of unknown construction date, it was attached to the main house in 1927 and modified in 1977. 5. Ihe servants-guests wing(1930) displays its gable end on the south elevation with three symmetrically placed 6/6 doublehung sash windows. 6. Connecting the guest wing and barn, the garage (1930) contains four arched opening bays. 7.

The barn (1926) displays nearly identical gable ends with overlighted doorways and 6/6 double hung sash windows.

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

Significance David Burnham House, Essex, MA Period prehistoric -1400-1499 1500-1599 X 1600-1699 1700-1799 1800-1899 1900 Areas of Significance-Check and justify below _ archeology-prehistoric - community planning - archeology-historic conservation -agriculture economics X architecture education _ art engineering commerce X exploration/settlement _communications industry invention landscape architecture _law literature _ military - music -philosophy politics/government .religion science - sculpture social/ humanitarian theater -transportation other (specify) Specific dates 1680-1690; 1924 Builder

Statement of significance

/Architect Unknown Statement of Significance (in one paragraph) The Burnham House retains integrity of location, setting, design, workmanship, materials, feeling and association. It is extremely important architecturally as a well-preserved example of late17th century dwelling design, and for the quality and unusually detailed record of subsequent alterations and restoration work. In addition, the house was associated with a prominent and early Essex (or Chebacco as it was known originally)family whose history and geneology is well documented. Thus the Burnham House meets Criteria A & C of the National Register of Historic Places and is significant on the local, state, and national levels.

1 The architectural contribution offered by the Burnham House is based on its value as a largely intact First Period dwelling which has retained its original physical setting as well as its original architectural character and design. As such, it offers a continuity in style and material that makes it a valuable architecutral statement. Later additions, and restoration have not altered the massive structural system, the roof-line, original high ceilings, the interior floor plans, or much original material. Both the integrity of the house-seventeenth century portions, and eighteenth and twentieth century additions -reveal an interesting evolution, and one of national importance for the simple reason that it has so many original and well-preserved architectural elements.

The complete record including photographs of the 1924 restoration supervised by George Francis Dow has remained with the house and proves a valuable statement of the structure's architectural history. Rarely has a house: seen such an early preservation effort and so much recognition from local historians and private citizens. The restoration work included widening the stair, installing late 17th century sash, restoring floor-boards and paneling, but it was done with a sensitivity for the original architectural elements, and on the whole was quite successful. The actual history of the house and its original owners are of significance to the town of Essex, or Chebacco as it was know originally. John Burnham, son of a settler and large landowner in mid-17th century Chebacco was probably the first owner of the house (according to a deed dated 1693, Book 17, page 110 - see Legal Description).

The house then passed to his descendants, who owned it in succession for approximately 189 years, as is evident from early deeds and wills on file in Salem, Massachusetts, until it was sold in 1869. In fact, these descendants remain a large part of the population in Essex, and one which can easily trace its heritage to the 1630's in the town. The site for house was chosen by John Burnham, or his father, Thomas Burnham, as a good location to operate their sawmiil and gristmill. The source of power was a nearby stream which emptied into Lake Chebacco and which was referred to as "The Falls" in the earliest deeds of the house. By the late 1800's, the Burnham House was recognized locally as one of the town's earliest surviving structures, and one owned by a prominent and colorful family.

An extraordinary amount of detailed genealogical and historical documentation has been compiled over the years, including early photographs, newspaper articles, (Continued) 9.

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

Major Bibliographical References Newspaper articles, photographs. SPNEA Library, 141 Cambridge Street, Boston, MA. Essex Registry of Deeds and Wills. Salem, MA. Burnham Family, Roderick Burnham, Lockwood & Brainard, Hartford, CT. , 1869. Photographic Record. Compiled by Mr. and Mrs. Richard Russell, 1924. present owner, Burnham House. 10. Geographical Data Acreage of nominated property - 2.5 Quadrangle name Marblehead North Quadrangle scale 1:25000 UMT References AL, 91 |3|5,2/2,0,01 Zone Easting 471915,20 Northing LLl Zone Easting Northing cLL E GLULLILL LILILLL FLL JLL LLLu WLLLlIL Verbal boundary description and justification See attached Property Map. List all states and counties for properties overlapping state or county boundaries state N/A code county code state N/A code county code 11. Form Prepared By Virginia A.

Fitch, Preservation Planner, with Consulting Services, Society for the name/title Preservation of New England Antiquities organization Massachusetts Historical Conmission street & number 294 Washington Street date November, 1982 telephone 727-8470 (617) city or town Boston state Massachusetts 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: national - state local As the designated State Historic Preservation Officer for the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (Public Law 89 665), I hereby nominate this property for inclusion in the National Register and certify that it has been evaluated according to thecriteria and procedures set forth by the National Park Service.

State Historic Preservation Officer signature Vateua RWestonski 2/3/83 title Executive Director, Masachusetts Historical Conmission date For NPS use only hereby certify that this property is included in the National Register. atuck Andus fes/ Keeper of the National Register Attest: Chief of Registration date 7/30/83 date CELLAR Scale: 1' - 4' unexcavated DAVID BURNHAM HOUSE, ESSEX, MA 2/8/83 ATTIC Scale: 1" = 4' DAVID BURNHAM HOUSE, ESSEX, MA <1/3/2 Shouldercd RST STOR shouldered & shouldered 21" 39". - 35''- 16' TiZi" 17' DAVID BURNHAM HOUSE, ESSEX MA 2/8/83 - ." shouldered -12" chamb!e Xshouldered 15' Scale: 1" = 4' SECONDSTORY p! a S S a g W Xshoukd y AhouIdered -shouldered -29"'- h amb,e r 16'.

-16"'- / shouldered DAVID BURNHAM HOUSE, ESSEX, MA Xahouldered shauldered 2/8/63 - AKE CHEBACCO DAVID BURNHAM HOUSE PROPERTY OF ADRIAN CRAVATH LARKIN POND STREET AT CHEBACCO LAKE ESSEX, MASSACHUSETTS (1981) Source: Essex Assessor's Map N ST POND CAUSEW HOMESTEAD WOODLAND 2AC CROPLAND 2,5 AC 6.4 Ac FRESH WATER MARSA -CROPLAND -SAC 2,5 Ac. WOODLAND 32° DAVID BURNHAM HOUSE POND STREET ESSEX, MASSACHUSETTS Plan 1981 Scale 1"= 10 / 2 1929 26' 1929 SERVANTS, GUESTS GARACES 40° zi 3 REMOOELEU 1929 1980 12 12?? 1 6.1684 RESTORGO 1925 26' 1900?- 1927 4 5 2i' 68' 18 7 BARN 19mc. 3a' (9)8/2 ATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES nttod States Depertmanl ef the Interten tonal Park Service Substantive Review Burnham, David, House Essex County MASSACHUSETTS EVALUATION / RETURN SHE Working No._FEB 81983 Fed. Reg. Date:/ Date Due: _ 3/10/83= 3/25/83 Action: ACCEPT RETURN 3/1/83 - REJECT.

Federal Agoncy:- sample _ request - appeal - NR decision resubmission nomination by person or local government owner objection appeal Substantive Review: Roviower's comments: The mciin section of the horse is undoubtedly, dignificant- however there have been numerous additions to the house which are neither descrebed, nor shologiaphs provide. an rderto evaluate the abililu & this building to convey its i7thcent. ferm i is necessany sequest mere mg. (zeedeveise) Recom. / Criteria Return Reviewer_ Patuck Andus Discipline Nistouan Date- 3/16/83 _ Be- continuation sheet -Nomination returned for: technical corrections cited below substantive reasons discussad below 1. Name 2. Location 3. Classification wan roosenian 4. Owner of Property Proson uos sososatato 5. Location of Legal Description 6. Representation in Existing Surveys - M property teen cmemen 7. Description P0xx menorme.

rume check em - unertered _ artereo oodd (ll kaooet - Chock em _ moved summary paragraph completeness clarity alterations/integrity Please describe and provide of all lates additions to the main section of the house - please piovide at least photo showeng the entiie fiart facade (main house E additions). 8. Significance moos dl Stonlaem Hotveil nnd lestty summary paragraph completeness clarity applicable criteria justification of areas checked relating significance to the resource context relationship of integrity to significance justification of exception other 9. Major Bibliographical References 10. Geographical Data AT R artel bo 11. Form Prepared By 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification toca mmton Omces sxpratun 13.

Other - Photographs - see commentã sectin seven (reverse) Other Patuck Anduus Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to Signed/ Auede Metulul - Date - 3/17/83 Phone: 202 272 - 350 NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES Untted States D ¿ ef the latorie National Park Serica Substantive Heview BuRNhAm David, HouSE Essex County EYALUATION / RETURN - SHE Working No. 2-8-83 Fed. Reg. Date: 2.7,54 Date Due: 730/8 Action: ACCEPT 7/36/83 RETURN REJECT Federal Agoncy: sampie - request _ appeal - NR decision resubmission nominationby person or/local government owner objection appeal Substantive Revlew: Roviower's comments: ---. Roeto ei io tht iu eite t mant tha mi retains architectuial siqnifiiance.

While i isclammed that the fanuly associated with the hose was proniment, thee is no evideomiation rolirndtor: are sianefiient undee cuteriar A - technical corrections cited below _substantive reasons discussed below Recom. / Criteria auet c Reviewer Anduus Discipline_ Nistoriun Date 7/30/83 - 800 continuation sheet 1. Name 2. Location 3. Classification Prosont Uen 4. Owner of Property 5. Location of Legal Description 6. Representation in Existing Surveys 7. Description aentormo noca en - unerara 6Blores ender (l b summary paragraph completeness clarity alterations/integrity dates boundary selection chees en NOved 8.

Significance erter Ares ef ie dates t edsi atteenso (i ter Lrettteet summary paragraph completeness clarity applicable criteria justification of areas checked relating significance to the resource context relationship of integrity to significance justification of exception other 9. Major Bibliographical References 10. Geographical Data horaago ol naminatad properry - uedrangie neme - UMT Reterences Verbel beadery e I hostifleathen 11. Form Prepared By 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification The evalurted eigniticance of thie property within the scene ie: netionet stabd oca Mlstoric Preeervation Officar signeture 13. Other Maps Photographs Other Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to.

Signed - Date- Phone: 202 272-3504 Comments for any item may be continued on an attached sheet David Burnham House Pond Street Essex, MA Photo: Bill Graham Location of Negative: Bi Rear 643 Hale Str Beverly Farms, Ma David Burnham House Photo #1 of 7 David Burnham House Pond Street Essex, MA Lamb's Tongue Champfer Photo: Bill Graham Rear 643 Hale Street Beverly Farms, MA 01915 (also location of negative) Photo #2 of 7 Feb.1982 2/8/r David Burnham House Pond Street Essex, MA Purlins Joining Rafter in Attic Photo: Bill Graham Location of Negative: Bill Graham Rear 643 Hale Street Beverly Farms, MA 01915 Photo #3 of 7 2(8/13 Feb.1982 David Burnham House Pond Street Essex, MA Paneling - East Chamber Photo- Bill Graham Location of Negative: Bill Graham Rear 643 Hale Street Beverly Farms, MA 01915 Photo #4 of 7 218/83 Feb.1982 David Surnham House Pond Street Essex, MA Photo: Roger Smith Pond Street, Essex, MA Negative föled with photographer South elevation.

Left to right: solarium, main house, library. Photo # 5 of 7 David Burnham House Pond Street Essex, MA Photo; Roger Smith Pond Street, Essex, MA Negative filed with photographer West elevation. Left to right: bedroom wing, solarium, main house. Photo 6 of 7 David Burnham House Pond Street Essex, MA Photo: Roger Smith Pond Street, Essex, MA Negative filed with photographer North elevation. Left to right: barn, garages, guest-servant quarters. Photo 7 of 7 Lakeside Farm Essex, Massachusetts 01929 Dear Mrs. Fitch: Aie:i3 MASS. HIST.

COMIA This is to inform you that as present owner of Lakeside Farm and of the David Burnham House, the central element of buildings of the property, L endorse the placement of The David Burnham Hous on the National Register I would like to add that I am sensitive to the stewardship which ownership of a first period house represents, and I intend exercise my responsibility to the best of my ability and understanding. Sincerely, Paranfarantancin- Adrian Cravath Tarkin Mrs. Virgina Fitch Massachusetts Historical Commission 294 Washington Street Boston, MA 02108 April 26, 1983

What happened here

An account from the chapter on Essex town, in the words of 1897.

1897, Essex Town

By Eliza Philbrick

We have but a faint conception of the sheep the privilege of grazing them on severe and varied labors of pioneer life, the common lands, and dogs that had Nearly everything we use today we buy killed sheep were hung, and the owners ready-made, while in the old days the of the guilty canines had also to pay colonists had to produce whatever they twice the value of the sheep killed, needed.

Read the rest of this passage