Nomination for Saint Peter and Saint Paul Historic District--Oliver's Second addition

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

RECEIVED MAY 2 3 1986 OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp. 10-31-84 United States Department of the Interior date entered MAR | 3 1987 1. Name Ss. Peter and Paul (Historic District)/Oliver's Second Addition 2. Location street & number 600 and 700 blocks of So. St. Clair Street city, town -vicinity of state Ohio code 095 X district - public X unoccupied _ museum X private X commercial - park - structure .both work in progress . educational - private residence X religious _ in process X yes: restricted - scientific yes: unrestricted _ military X other: Organizations 5. Location of Legal Description Ohio Historic Inventory (OHI) has this property been determined eligible?

- NRHP - September 1972 OHI - September 1979 entertainment transportation Accessible Category date government Toledo Columbus code yes object Ownership site historic industrial Public Acquisition building(s) being considered Ohio agriculture local Present Use Type all entries-complete applicable sections National Register of Historic Places (3-82) One Government Center Inventory-Nomination Form 3. Classification For NPS use only 6. Representation in Existing Surveys National Park Service NPS Form 10-900 4. Owner of Property See instructionsin How to Complete National Register Forms title Status received FEB | 0 1987 and/or common _ not for publication . county Natl. Register of Historic San Pedro Y San Pablo District) 7. Description X original site X good X altered which do not detract from the the overall integrity of the buildings.

physically separated from its urban surroundings, being enclosed into a triangular- newer brick, frame and cement block structures are found along the rear alleys. Styles represented include Italianate, Romanesque Revival, Queen Anne, Colonial Revival, convent at 738 So. St. Clair (Photos 9 & 10); Sts. Peter and Paul Church at 736 So. of the school) and the school, both at 726 So. St. Clair (Photos 2, 13, 14, 15 & 16) the corner of Harrison, along the sidewalk, is is 706 So. St. Clair (Photo 4) a Harrison, two adjoining structures at 639-41 So. St. Clair (Photos 5 & 21) and 635-37 So. St. Clair (Photos 5, 21 & 22) are Queen Anne in style, with a large addition, which does not compromise the integrity of the buildings. (photo 23) Directly across So. St. Clair are two adjoining structures, the Italianate style Condition ruins unexposed rail-line.

excellent Beginning at the intersection of Hobart and So.St.Clair and proceeding northeast vintage buildings face St.Clair Street; several adjoin with adjacent buildings; The overall character of the district is dictated by its masonry construction, as all comprises approximately two blocks of commercial and institutional use buildings facing -moveddate Classical Revival and commercial examples, all predating 1930.The buildings range school.Across the street from the main church is the Ohio Hispanic Institute of and sets back from the street.Four contributing buildings have newer rear Check one Interstate 75 and on the south by the main Conrail and Amtrack rail-lines into Toledo.

Clair 3) the only detached non-contributing structure in the district.Near The Ss.Peter and Paul/San Pablo Y San Pedro Historic District is located about one mile Harrison is a Colonial Revival style apartment building which frontson both So. is a series of connected one-story structures at 709-19 So.St.Clair 6, contains 2l lots in subdivisions known as Oliver's Divisions and is 6 acres in size. Describe the present and original (if known) physical appearance

Description of the property

adjacent to it is 721-23 So.St.Clair 8).Adjoining 721-23So.St.Clair from one story to three story the remainder two stories in height. of the historic structures in the district are built either of brick or stone.The edifice at 632 So.St.Clair 24)whichhasanewer addition attached to:the St.Clair and Harrison,at 701-05 So.St.Clair 6,19 & 20).Crossing Opportunity building Swiss Hall) at 735 So.St.Clair 8& 18); 7,& 8).Adjoining this group of buildings,is 707 6),atwo building at 634-40 So.St.Clair 4,24 & 25) anda smaller Queen Anne style 4,10,11&12),the original Sts.Peter and Paul Church part - unaltered -X fair Clair). The land is flat and divided by streets, sidewalks and alleys. The district (Photo 26) is Classical Revival with Art Deco elements. Across Hobart, the Sts.

and the Queen Anne structure at 714 So. St. Clair (Photo 17) which is attached to the rear, y story structure. Across the street and set back along the alley is 710 So. St. date deteriorated character of the district.The one non-contributing building is of newer construction vintage Italianate style structure.Across So.St.Clair at the opposite corner of Residential streets border the district on either side.The entire neighborhood is south of Toledo's Central Business District in an isolated urban neighborhood.The district So.St.Clair St.:two parking lots separate four structures 700 block of So.St. 1& 8) the district presents a mix of styles and scales.802 So.St.Clair OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp. 10-31-84 United States Department of the Interior Ss. Peter and Paul/San Pedro y San Pablo H.D., Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio 635-37 South St. Clair Jerry and Patricia R.

Diver 639-41 South St. Clair Waterville, Ohio 43566 632 South St. Clair Toledo, Ohio 43609 701-05 South St. Clair : Allan M. and Loretta M. Campbell 6104 Whiteford Road Sylvania, Ohio 43560 706 South St. Clair Latins United, Alredo Lozano et. al. 709-19 South St. Clair 721-23 South St. Clair Rt. Rev. James R. Hoffman Ohio Hispanic Institute of Opportunity, Inc. Geraldo Realty Co., Inc. Leeper Printing Corporation Page Inventory-Nomination Form Jack Andrew Item number National Register of Historic Places 6762 North River Road Sam Geraldo Bland Printing Company date entered National Park Service Bishop of Toledo 2544 Parkwood Avenue NPS Form 10-000- (3-82) OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp.

10-31-84 United States Department of the Interior Page 2 Italianate style expressed in a vernacular mode, with elements of the Greek Revival School complex, a series of three adjoining structures and a free standing church. soaring 165 foot spire (added in 1880). A model of mid-century ecclesiastical archi- style churches, with protruding central entrance bay surmounted by the belfry and spire, dominates and is found in virtually every opening of the church, notably in the compound A choir loft, reconstructed after the 1926 fire, runs across the wall opposite the main altar, beneath the belfry.

The school complex, built around the first 1866 church (later the original school), was round arch still dominates, but is accented by an expansive use of both smooth-cut and ashlar blocks with an extended, elevated ashlar porch leading to the addition's central (3-82) date entered Inventory-Nomination Form Historic District evenly spaced columns support the roof via large round arches which spring from classical Continuation sheet roof and features squat scrolled and fluted pilaster supports; dentil work follows the first floor levels, which have been bricked in and replaced with picture-type windows plain flat-topped and segmentally arched openings on the side elevation.A newer (c.

National Register of Historic Places Style evident.Two stories in height,a five-bay facade with transomed central entrance glass in round arches; a large multiple window Romanasque tracery rises above the central National Park Service as evidenced by the wide bracketed cornice and stamped head-molds primarily over second Representative of the Romanesque Revival Style is the Ss.Peter and Paul Church and Item number built.A protruding tower with louvered belfry and flared dome were added as was a completed in 1905 in a more exuberant expression of the Romanesque Revival style.The The church completed in 1873 is the most visible structure in the district due to its The most illustrative example of Italianate styling is found at 634-40 So.St.Clair, Ss.Peter and Paul Parish,is at 738So.St.Clair.It is an early application of the 1912)two story frame addition covers the rear of the convent.

San Pedro Y San Pablo For NPS use only NPS Form 10-900-a Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio entrance. Roundels, oculus windows and round louvers accent the tower base and frame The seven side elevation bays, divided by brick and stone buttresses, contain at the roof line of the front and side elevations. The interior of the church, heavily damaged by a 1926 fire, features a central nave with two side aisles. A series of tall original church was given a new facade in 1905 when the adjoining school building was tall, round-arch stained and leaded glass windows. Two peaked gable entrances are found mid-way at the ground level of each side elevation. Heavy brick corbelling is found figuration. The capitals. The ceiling is groined; the walls are smooth plastered and heavily stencilled.

The facade bays each contain three upper windows over extensively altered The window hoodmolds are simple chamfered stone cornices on the facade and This entry is covered by a small pediment with classic Greek details circumscribing a hanging frieze.Large curvilinear iron brackets support the pediment, dominates the house. and flanked by set-back entrances on either side.The round arch of the Romanesque tecture, the three bay facade form is typical of Roman Catholic Gothic and Romanesque large shaped gable.The shaped gable is repeated in three smaller roof dormerson the floor windows.This two story block has a four bay three con- eave line. OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp. 10-31-84 United States Department of the Interior Ss. Peter and Paul/ Toledo, Lucas County, Uhio Item number 7 Page 3 cornices, friezes and a floral-infilled ogee arch above a second floor window.

oriel bay hangs from the second floor, while rough-hewn stone banding and window case windows. A massive three story cement block addition, constructed c.1950, has nected by a tin band molding, feature simple cornice-like hoodmoldings. A broad story frame additions have been added to the rear of 639-41 So. St. Clair. There are two identical oriel bays on the side elevation as well, both with swag radically altered, although the showcase windows have been painted over, as the store Continuation sheet (3-82) Inventory-Nomination Form Historic District date entered feature cross-hatched mullion upper sash with Adamesque-type swags in a panel above.

National Park Service has been altered with glass block infilled windows, although the four-bay configuration, facade and irregularly spaced fenestration on the side elevation.The cornice and National Register of Historic Places Adjoining the 1905 school addition is an elaborate two-story commercial structure extensive tin work (cornices, parapets) and brick corbelling at their roof-lines. and the dominant Queen Anne style which is found in six of the sixteen structures The best examples of purely Queen Anne style commercial buildings are found at type window sets beneath the shaped gable ot the original school; a pair of narrow 639-4l has been extensively remodeled and now features four and five narrow openings are infilled with glass-block stone quoins define the corners of the tower and the open corner of the original school building.

San Pedro Y San Pablo NPS Form 10-000-a For NPS use only FEB IO 1987 canopy hangs over the central entrance, partially concealing a glazed transom. The entry level of windows/recessions run the full height of the second floor of the tower. All windows that bridges the transition between the omanesque detailing of the church and school detail and round arch of the church and school, but is primarily Queen Anne in style 639-41 is two story brick, although the buildings adjoin one another. Both employ floors; stone banding defines window and wall surfaces. The first floor was altered been appended to 635-37 but does not affect its integrity: 639-41 has a six bay corbelling extend along the side elevation as well. The second floor windows, con- window topped by a pediment which is surmounted by a stepped gable.

The bay windows received entrance.Central entrances to both sections are topped by smooth-dressed sandstone facing So.St.Clair Street.The building at 7l4 So.St.Clair exhibits the stone tin cornice divides the first and second levels on the facade. with central and off-set floor) entrances, is yet intact.A c.19i5 metal 635-37 has a three bay facade with paired windows in the center bay of the upper two OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp. 10-31-84 the windows have plain, flat or segmentally arched openings, except for the three second inspired metal canopy covers the main entry at the southern end of the facade. The interior has a series of small offices at the front, with a recently restored auditorium/ and is partially above grade. There are four non-contributing additions to the rear of contributing structures, i.e.- one story in height, at the rear of Lot 490 along the alley.

Its street address is 710 So. St. Clair and it was built as two sections, the later cement block section in There is only one free standing outbuilding in the district, a c.1912 brick garage at with single-stepped gable facing the street, and is not considered intrusive to the district. OUTBUILDINGS Page Historic District Inventory-Nomination Form date entered NON-CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURES Item number National Park Service and a stone cornice relieve the plainess of the facade surface.A decorative classically- National Register of Historic Places story facade windows which feature Colonial Revival compound round arches with stone with a balcony at the other.Its windows have been infilled with cement block except for (3-82) except for an infilled entranceway with a smaller door. front being added about 1955;it now houses Leeper Printing Co.

cement block appendages which run behind 709-19 So.St.Clair;anda c.1968 frame, For NPS use only ac.1960 cement block addition at the rear of 632 So.St.Clair;the three story cement United States Department of the Interior small glazed transoms at the top of each.The lower level has a kitchen and meeting rooms NPS Form 10-900-a Ss. Peter and Paul/ Toledo, Lucas County, Ohio are visible from So. St. Clair Street, except the upper levels ot the 635-37 addition. doorways each, leading to the apartments. The side elevation virtually has been unaltered The Commercial style is best represented by the two-story brick Ohio Hispanic Institute of Opportunity building at 735 So. St. Clair.

Typically devoid of heavy ornamentation, received Continuation sheet keystones and half-round top lights.Geometrically arranged brickwork, stone banding pent roof over the door has been removed, the structure is brick with stone detailing One non-contributing structure is a free standing cement and tile block brick building, block addition at the rear of 635-37 So.St.Clair; a series of one story San Pedro Y San Pablo Areas of Significance - Check and justify below - prehistoric -archeology-historic . conservation _ military - music X 1800-1899 The X 1900 X other (specify) Criteria A and C In addition, the district's notable examples of Italianate, Queen Anne and The district is part of two of the earliest plats in the city, i.e., Oliver's Division U.S. 24), Swan Creek, the Maumee River and the ravine where the railroad line runs.

1856, 203 lots, known as Oliver's Second Division, were laid out adjoining the original named for Major William Oliver, one of the pioneer developers of Toledo and a partner of Oliver's Divisions were settled shortly before and immediately after the Civil War, pri- In response to the growing number of German Catholics, diocesan bishop Rev. Amadeus Rappe style, two-story brick church (Photos 13,14) now remodeled as part of St. Peter's school. The church was situated on So. St. Clair Street near the southern edge of Oliver's Division. A two-story brick rectory (now a convent, Photo 9), in a vernacular Greek Revival/Italianate mode, was built in 1867 adjacent to the church at the corner of Hobart in Oliver's Divisions, and by 1873 plans for a new church were drawn, with completion in cultural landmark of the neighborhood.

A second immigrant group, German-speaking Swiss, also settled in this area during the 1600-1699 1500-1599 1700-1799 1400-1499 communications commerce education architecture economics engineering humanitarian industry art invention literature social transportation science law agriculture sculpture Urban development/Ethnic heritage 8.

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

Significance important representation of 19th century neighborhood commercial/institutional develop- Toledo now stands. Romanesque architecture bolster its status as an important representation of Toledo's parish originally consisted of sixty-five families who worshipped in a simple Romanesque Catholic Church was founded by Rev.Peter Dannenhofer,himself a German immigrant.The sentative of the history of three important immigrant populations in Toledo and is an serves as the namesake of this nomination due to its stability as a major visual and 19th century urban section 7 for additional architectural discussion) who had settled west and south of the central city.In 1866 Saints Peter and Paul Statement of Significance

Statement of significance

(in one paragraph) the central business district along Erie, St.Clair and Oliver Streets in Oliver's Divi- This plat comprised 52l lots in an area bounded by the Miami/Wabash and Erie Canal half of Toledo's population of 13,768.As the size of the German population increased modest,vernacular style buildings, such as the commercial structure at 706 So. St. Clair last quarter of the 19th and into the first quarter of the 20th century.It ws this group of Cleveland decided to establish a second parish in Toledo to serve the German catholics - politics/government 1875.It is this Romanesque 4,1l,12)with its 165 foot spire,which 4)and the original Saints Peter and Paul Church 14) and 9).

- archeology-prehistoric - - community planning landscape architecture X religion exploration/settlement - - philosophy Multiple - See text included with the original plat of Toledo in 1837 and re-surveyed and platted in 1845. sions. They were working class people - laborers, craftsmen, shop-keepers - who built the Baum Company of Cincinnati which was the original purchaser of the land on which 1866-1925 Builder/Architect Period Specific dates German immigrations.By 1860,German-speaking people reportedly accounted for over one- Street and So. St.Clair.German settlers continued to locate in the area, especially The Ss.Peter and Paul/San Pedro y San Pablo Historic District is a significant repre- 9.

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

Major Bibliographical References and Toledo: Munsel1 and Company, 1888. 10. Geographical Data Acreage of nominated property - Quadrangle scale - UT M References This nomination is comprised of Lots 416-419 and 489-594 of Oliver's Division of the City of Toledo and Lots 582-587, 589, 591, 593, 595 and including that portion of Lot 472 _ state 11. Form Prepared By Ted J. Ligibel - Historic Resources (Consultant) Ohio Hispanic Institute of Opportunity, Inc. date September - December 1985 street & number 735 So. St. CLair Street Ohio 43609 12.

State Historic Preservation Officer Certification The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: As the designated State Historic Preservation Officer for the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 (Public Law 89 I hereby certify that this property is included in the National Register code date Easting Northing county organization Toledo Attest: Zone 1:24000 national Verbal boundary description and justification name/title local Chief of Registration State Historic Preservation Officer signature List all states and counties for properties overlapping state or county boundaries city or town Quadrangle name Toledo, Ohio -Mich. C/o Barbara Mann 665), I hereby nominate this property for inclusion in the National Register and certify that it has been evaluated For NPs use only American Community. Arno Press, 1976.

containing 802 So.St.Clair of 01liver's Second Division of the City of Toledo.This SHPO OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp. 10-31-84 Pedro y San Pablo Historic District) Item number 8 Swiss Society, erected the Swiss Hall at 735 So. St. Clair (Photo 18) in 1924 as their cultural center. Toledo's Swiss population has never been large, but it has been ex- the Hillebrand Furniture store, while the adjoining structure at 639-41 So. St. Clair (Photos 5,21), which features an elaborate corbelled cornice, was the American Steam served as Jacoby's Saloon, Florian's Men's Furnishings and as the Corn City Building and stamped tin work, and ogee-arched hoodmold, a semi-lunette window and a partially German/Swiss population. Also in the Queen Anne style, distinguishing elements include brick corbelling, stone trim and an elaborate tin cornice with pyramidal finials.

As noted, these integral structures featured a wide variety of neighborhood-oriented commercial ventures, with residential units above, except for the one-story buildings Several structures are known to have been demolished in recent years, including seven frame, and two brick buildings (at 702-04 So. St. Clair at the corner of Harrison St., and at 725 So. St. Clair). Other structures which one lined So. St. Clair Street to the Interstate further isolated this area which, since the 1840's, has been set apart of which were transportaton oriented, i.e., the Maumee River, the railroad, the canal In the 1920's, a third immigrant group, Spanish-speaking people of Mexican and/or Texan Page Continuation sheet Inventory-Nomination Form 1960's.

date entered turn-of-the century as the Williams and Schmidt Central Sausage Works catering to the National Park Service (3-82) Loan Co.,a forerunner of the present-day United Home Federal Savings and Loan. National Register of Historic Places of South St.Clair Street is even more pronounced as a result of the changes in the the north were demolished for the constructure of Interstate 75 which sliced through to the central business district and the rest of Oliver's Division to the north.Many stylistic eclecticism adds a unique aspect to the district and is highlighted by floral- United States Department of the Interior These Queen Anne buildings are among the finest representations of this style in Toledo.

quarters of the North American Swiss Alliance (NASA) in 1894 and the National Conven- removed; some structures also were taken for construction of the Central Post Office in frame business establishments that were built in the 1860's and 1870's were replaced by the area in 1963-64 thereby cutting off this neighborhood from its St.Clair Street link tion of the NASA was held at the Swiss Hall on So.St.Clair Street in l937. that founded Society)in 1869,and which,as the Toledo NPS Form 10-900-a more substantial two story brick structures in the 1880's,1890's and early1900's;there at 709-19 So.St.C1air 6). Ss. Peter and Paul/ San Toledo, Lucas County, OHio story Queen Anne structure, with extensive stone trim and heavy cornice, was originally Laundry. The building at 714 So. St.

Clair (Photo 17) was built around 1890 and has origin, began to settle in this area. is one three story brick structure at 635-37 So. St. Clair (Photos 5, 21). This three- by physical boundaries that defined its development patterns. These boundaries, all Its Commercial enterprise developed in response to increased settlement as well.The small The approximately thirty-five families in Toledo 1964,which occupies a several block area just north of the highway.Construction of in 1930 have grown to 10,667 Federal Census).The first Hispanic residents came festivals) in 1901,1924,1962 and 1982.Toledo was elected the National head- OMB No. 1024-0018 Exp. 10-31-84 received rEb Item number 8 So. St. Clair Street, where their descendants continue to reside today.

Anthropologist Barbara June Macklin, who studied Toledo's Hispanic population for nearly twenty years, of this area's population, living within a few blocks of South St. Clair Street, are Hispanic, with the extended neighborhood being 11% Hispanic. This compares to a city- wide Hispanic representation of 3%. Peter and Paul (San Pedro y San Pablo) parish. with Our Lady of Guadalupe Mission. Toledo's German-American Association and is headquartered in Oregon, Ohio. clude printing, woodworking, advertising and electronic firms. empty, although the convent (former rectory, Photo 9) and offices at the rear of the is the subject of this nomination (see Blade clipping, November 27, 1985).

Their hope is to attract new business, financial and educational services, as well as to establish a Hispanic marketplace, cultural center and restaurant, reusing several of the historic Page Inventory-Nomination Form (3-82) National Register of Historic Places date entered National Park Service to Toledo as railroad or industrial plant workers or as settled-out migrant agricultural in 1974 and has been headquarters for several Hispanic organizations since, including So.St.Clair l9).The Toledo Swiss Society subsequently affiliated with the Mexican-American Youth Association (MAYA),the Farm Labor Organizing Committee city, local groups and the Catholic church to revitalize the area of So. St. Clair that central focus for Toledo's Hispanic community, particularly as a result of its merger Pedro y San Pablo district are occupied at the present time.

United States Department of the Interior As early as 1927 a mission was founded by the Catholic church to meet the religious needs NPS Form 10-900-a Raza Unida of Ohio and currently the Ohio Hispanic Institute of Opportunity, ducted services in Ss.Peter & Paul's chapel 13) for Hispanics who by 1929,had The former Swiss 18) across from the church was sold to the City of Toledo For NPS use only The Ohio Hispanic Institute of Opportunity is working with the St.Peter's School 13,15,16) closed in 1983and the school building remains of Toledo's growing Spanish-speaking population. A Mexican priest, Fr. Joseph Lua, con- banded together as Our Lady of Guadalupe (Nuestra Señora de Guadalupe) Mission. In Peter and Paul Church, and met here until 1963 when the mission was merged with Ss.

Clair have vanished in response to increased mobility and different shopping patterns. structures along So. St. Clair Street. Continuation sheet Light industrial uses generally have replaced the earlier home-oriented shops and in- South Side and the major geographical focus of the Mexican-Americans in Toledo." settlement."Ss. Peter and Paul/San Pedro y San Pablo parish continues to serve as the Ohio and Toledo.Most of those who settled-out in Toledo located in the area around 1942,this group purchased the former Trinity Baptist Church, two blocks south of Ss.

old church (Photo 14) adjoining the school remain in use.All other structures in the laborers.Major increases in migrant settlers occurred after World War II in northwest (Historic District) Macklin asserts,"Not only is the Catholic Church ...important as a symbol of unity for now owns the building.FLoc has moved across the street to 714 Exp. 10-31-84 Custombook, Inc., 1967. 4. Barclay, Cynthia W., Ohio Historic Inventory, (varied forms) Cols., Ohio. Ohio Historic Preservation Office, 1979. (from Centennial Celebration publication). Toledo: Toledo Swiss Society, 1969. Co., 1891. Library, Toledo, Ohio. American Population in the Toledo Metropolitan Area., Toledo, 1973. 10. Carlson, Alvar W. "The Settling Processes of Mexican Americans in Northwestern The Journal of Mexican American History V.(1975): 24-38.

Inventory-Nomination Form Page date entered (3-82) National Register of Historic Places National Park Service OMB No.1024-0018 district includes all of the remaining resources of the neighborhood commercial area Toledo History Scrapbooks (Ethnic Groups).Toledo Blade and Toledo News-Bee along So. St.Clair Street in both Oliver's Divisions south of Interstate 75. United States Department of the Interior Item number 10 Pedro y San Pablo NPS Form 10-300-a Ss. Peter and Paul/San Toledo, Lucas County,Ohio Bollinger, Ernest. Centennial History of the Toledo Swiss Society: 1869-1969 6. Hopkins, G.M. City Atlas of Toledo, Ohio. Philadelphia: G.M. Hopkins Co., 1881. 9. Community Planning Council of Northwestern Ohio, Inc.

A Profile of the Spanish Ohio." Continuation sheet (varied dates).Local History and Gen.Dept., Toledo-Lucas County Public (Historic District) For NPS use only 109 - TOLEDO, OHIO (LUCAS COUNTY) -Commercial Style -Classical/Art Deco Style -Colonial Revival Style -District Boundary DEC. 1985 108 102 LEGEND Non-Contributing Structure HISTORIC DISTRICT Photograph Views SS.PETER&PAUL/SAN PEDRO Y SAN PABLO Italianate Style .Romanesque Style .Outbuilding .Queen Anne Style 4246 VOL) FEB 10 1987 HOBART 2 :632 1 706 TOLEDO, OHIO (LUCAS COUNTY) -Colonial Revival Style Italianate Style Non-Contributing Structure Outbuilding DEC. 1985 108 635 710 109 102 707 HISTORIC DISTRICT 634- .Romanesque Style LEGEND .District Boundary 40 639- SS.

PETER&PAUL/SAN PELRO Y SAN PABLO 735 714 INTERSTATE 721- EXPRESSWAY .Commercial Style 701 WASO Form - 177 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES EVALUATION/RETURN SHEET St. Peter and St. Paul Historic District-Oliver's Fed. Reg. Date: nomination by person or local government owner objection Federal Agency: _ J sample -request Lappeal LJ NR decision - see continuation sheet Nomination returned for: - _technical corrections cited below 1. Name 2. Location 3. Classification 4. Owner of Property 5. Location of Legal Description 6. Representation in Existing Surveys 7.

Description J excellent - unaltered - original site - moved yes Ownership resubmission ruins Category Accessible Condition Recom./Criteria dates REJECT fair unexposed RETURN Status deteriorated Reviewer OHIO alterations/integrity clarity Second Addition Discipline boundary selection Substantive Review: Working No. Public Acquisition Lucas County summary paragraph Describe the present and original (if known)physical appearance completeness Has this property been determined eligible? Check one 3-13-87 Reviewer's comments: Present Use _substantive reasons discussed below Date Due: good ("R" June 1984) Action: LACCEPT 8, Significance J summary paragraph relating significance to the resource Other 9. Major Bibliographical References 10. Geographical Data Acreage of nominated property 11.

Form Prepared By The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: State Historic Preservation Officer signature - Date - GPO 918-450 Comments for any item may be continued on an attached sheet Builder/Architect Signed context state Phone UTM References title national Maps Verbal boundary description and justification clarity Quadrangle name Photographs Statement of Significance (in one paragraph) Specific dates relationship of integrity to significance justification of areas checked 12. State Historic Preservation Officer Certification applicable criteria justification of exception Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to _local Areas of Significance-Check and justify below Period completeness 8 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 northerly along So. St. Clair 7. Photo No. 1 District overview, looking (Street Scene) St.

from Emerald Ave. San Pablo Historic District 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. west side, showing church and school, looking southwest 7. Photo No. 2 San Pablo Historic District (Street Scene) LEEPER PRINTING 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Non contributing structure at 710 So. St. Clair, lo0king west 7. Photo No. 3 San Pablo Historic District (Street Scene) 5. Negatives: Ligibel 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. West side, looking southwest 7. Photo No. 4 San Pablo Historic District (street scene) EXIT 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. East side, looking southeast 7. Photo No. 5 San Pablo Historic District (Street Scene) 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. East side, looking southeast 7. Photo No.

6 San Pablo Historic District from Harrison St. (Street Scene) 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Non-contributing additions San Pablo Historic District behind 709-19 So. St.C1air (Street Scene) Photo by: 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. East side, looking northeast 7. Photo No. 8 from Hobart San Pablo Historic District (Street Scene) 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. 738 So. St. Clair, looking 7. Photo No. 9 southwest San Pablo Historic District (Rectory/convent) 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro Y San Pablo Historic District - 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Rear view 738 So. St. Clair, 1ooking northeast 7. Photo No. 10 (Rectory/Convent) 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y (Ss. Peter and Paul's Church) 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Belfry/steeple, looking heaven- 7. Photo No.

11 San Pablo Historic District ward So.St.C1air) 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y (Ss. Peter and Paul's Church) 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Main entrance, looking west 7. Photo No. 12 San Pablo Historic District 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y (St. Peter's School) 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Facade, looking west (726 So. St. Clair) 7. Photo No. 13 San Pablo Historic District 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro Y (St. Peter's School) Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Rear view showing main church 7. Photo No. 14 San Pablo Historic District roof, part of original church (at left) & present day Looking south. 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y (St. Peter's School) 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Facade of 1905 addition, looking 7. Photo No. 15 westerly San Pablo Historic District 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y (St. Peter's School) 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6.

Rear elevation of 1905 addition, 1ooking east 7. Photo No. 16 San Pablo Historic District 5. Negatives: Ligibel 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 Looking northwest 7. Photo No. 17 San Pablo Historic District (Metzger Building) 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Facade & south side elevation, San Pablo Historic District stitute of Opportunity) (Swiss Hall/ohio Hispanic In- 1ooking northeast So. St. 5. Negatives: Ligibel Shoto No. 18 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 6. Facade and north side elevation, San Pablo Historic District November 1985 (Apartment Building) 1ooking southeast (701-05 So. Photo No- 70 3 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Facade detail, looking east 7. Photo No. 20 San Pablo Historic District (Apartment Building) HITACHI AUTHORIZED 1. Ss.

Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Facades and south side elevation, 1ooking northeast 7. Photo No. 21 San Pablo Historic District (635-37/ 639-41 S0.St.C1air) 5. Negatives: Ligibel 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Facade detail, 3rd floor; 1ooking up-easterly 7. Photo No. 22 San Pablo Historic District (635-37 So.St.C1air) 5. Negatives: Ted J.Ligibel 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Non-contributing addition rear, looking northwest 7. Photo No. 23 San Pablo Historic District (635-37 So.St.C1air) 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2. Toledo, Ohio 4. November 1985 6. Facades, looking southwest 7. Photo No. 24 San Pablo Historic District (632-40 So.St.C1air) 1.Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedro y 2.Toledo, Ohio 6. Rear and south side elevations 1ooking northeast 7. Photo No.

25 4.November 1985 San Pablo Historic District 634-40 So.St.C1air 1. Ss. Peter & Paul/San Pedreo y San 802 So. St. Clair 2. Toledo, Ohio 3. Photo by: Ted J Ligibel 4. November, 1985 5. Negatives: Ligibel 6. Facade and north side elevation, 7. Photo No. 26 looking south Pablo Historic District Easting: 287720 Northing: 4612610 TOLEDO, OHIO- MICH. TOLEDO QUADRANGLE OHIO_ MICHIGAN GEOLOGICAL SURVEY UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR 7.5 MINUTE SERIES (TOPOGRAPHIC) Ss.Peter&Paul/San Pedro Y San Pablo Ohio Historic Preservation Office 1985 Velma Avenue Columbus. Ohio 43211 February 3, 1987 Ms. Carol Shull, Chief 1100 L Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20240 Conner, Alexander, House East Broad St. Historic District (E. Broad St. Heyne-Zimmerman House (E. Broad St. MRA) W.

Ray Luce Greene 614/297-2470 SOCIETY County HISTORICAL Sincerely, Lucas Knox Enclosures Franklin Dear Carol: MRA) Enclosed are three new National Register nominations and four resubmissions. State Historic Preservation Office National Register of Historic Places East High Street Historic District National Park Service SINCE 1885 All of the appropriate notification procedures have been followed for the new New Submissions Ohio Farm Bureau Federation Offices San Pablo Historic District Broad Street Presbyterian Church St. Department of the Interior WRL:bp Please contact me if you have any questions. St. Peter and St. Paul/San Pedro Y