Nomination for Satterthwaite, John, House

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

NPS Form 10-900 OMB No. 1024-0018 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service FEB 2 3 1988 Register. L for Completing National Register Forms (National Register Bulletin 16). Complete each item by marking "x" in the appropriate box or by entering the requested information. If an item does not apply to the property being documented, enter "N/A" for "not applicable." For functions, styles, materials, (Form 10-900a). Type all entries. Name of Property historic name Satterthwaite, John, House other names/site number Hal fway House Location street & number N/A not for publication N/A vicinity zip code 45068 3.

Classification Ownership of Property Category of Property Number of Resources within Property XX private XX building(s) Structure Name of related multiple property listing: Number of contributing resources previously listed in the National Register _0 State/Federal Agency Certification As the designated authority under the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended, I hereby certify that this National Register of Historic Places and meets the procedural andprofessional requirements set forth in 36 CFR Part 60. State or Federal agency and bureau Signature of commenting or other official 5. National Park Service Certification 1, hereby, certify that this property is: Ventered in the National Register.

determined eligible for the National determined not eligible for the other, (explain:) Date of Action Registration Form Noncontributing code Date site object Total district public-State NATIONAL public-Federal Waynesville RECEIVED public-local state Ohio National Register. National Register of Historic Places This form is for use in nominating or requesting determinations of eligibility for individual properties or districts. See instructions in Guidelines removed from the National Register. 498 North Third Street Signature of certifying official See continuation sheet. city, town (Rev. 8-86) In my opinion, the property Register. See continuation sheet. county Warren 6. Function or Use Current Functions (enter categories from instructions) 7. Description Materials (enter categories from instructions) walls _ Describe present and historic physical appearance.

in 1812 (Beers) by John Satterthwaite, a prominent Waynesville Quaker, who came to this area in 1803 from Bucks County, Pennsylvania. An addition was Sometime after construction, a screened-in porch (still in use) was added to the 1812 section is a stone-lined spring, complete with a livestock watering Samue1 Martin's tanyard, brewery, and distillery (Beers). roof Federal other brick portion were modified sometime after the building was constructed.The DOMESTIC/hotel (enter categories from instructions) Architectural Classification Historic Functions (enter categories from instructions) DOMESTIC/single dwelling also two stories, and is of solid brick wall construction. The outside 1812 portion.Both porches have standing seam metal roofs. DOMESTIC/secondary structure facades are common bond.Both sections have interior end chimneys.

keystone at the top of the arch.A brick arch surrounds the wood. downstairs windows are 9 over 6 panes;upstairs windows are 6 over 6 panes. Windows in the 1812 section are topped with brick 1intels.The entrance door, is framed with a simple arched wooden door surround, and has a plain wooden in good condition about 30 feet from the house, and was built c.1812-1815. house is two stories, and is of solid brick wall construction with rectangular The outside and inside doors are original.The original windows in the 1812 slate roof on the 1815 addition was replaced with 3-in-1 modern fiberglass The cedar shake roof was replaced in 1965.

Approximately 200 feet south of constructed to the Satterthwaite.This addition is trough.As early as 1800,this spring is mentioned as a water source for metal; fiberglass X See continuation sheet Satterthwaite House, constructed in 1812 and added to in 1815,is an exce1lent rear(northwest)of this portion with approximately 10 feet extending onto the example of a Federal style farmhouse.The main or southwest portion of the The facade of the c.1815 addition is Flemish bond. The other two visible The outside dimensions are 16 feet to end) by 12 feet to back). foundation limestone standing seam metal gable roof tops this section. The house was constructed In addition to the main building, a two story, solid brick smokehouse remains facing the southeast, is topped with a semi-circular fanlight.

The entrance dimensions approximately 30 feet (front to back) by 32 feet to end).A shingles.The facade and southwest elevation of the1812 section are Flemish the of the 1815 portion.An open porch was added to the dimensions are approximately 20 feet by 20 feet.In 1973,the deteriorating NPS Form 10-900e OMB Approvel No. 1024-0018 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service Section number . - Page - that a bar was once located in the main hallway. A wall mounted coat/hat rack The 1815 addition ground level is the kitchen. It has a stairway to the At one end of the bedroom is a stairway to a garret, which comprises the third A limestone wall basement is under the entire 1812 portion and approximately windows on the northeast elevation of the 1815 section to be exposed.

In its place, a 20 feet (front to back) by 46 feet (end to end) brick veneer one and The original portions of the house retain a high degree of integrity, the National Register of Historic Places Continuation Sheet present owners. Most of the paint on the woodwork, including mantels, stair carpentry and plumbing updating has been the addition of hot water radiators, and chair rails, and doors and trim, has been removed to reveal cherry and modified sometime after the building was constructed.Paint on the brick was level of this addition. alterations, the present owners are in the process of replacing all windows to the old portion are random width ash.Other woodwork is cherry and walnut.

a half story addition was constructed.This new addition was constructed of meet the original configuration; original windows in the 1812 portion were Satterthwaite, John, House, 498 North Third Street, Waynesville, Warren Co., OH The interiors of both sections remain in excellent condition, with floor plan, living and dining rooms are each 14 feet by 18 feet; both can be entered from stairs rooms.The The ground and second floor levels of the 1812 and 1815 portions are connected by doorways. The exposed floors in basement and a back stairway to the second level. The kitchen also has a a modern garage door, and had no foundation, causing numerous structural problems in that section.

The removal of the frame addition allowed two attic with modern day standards, the new section contains a family room, a bath, a feet (end to end) by 20 feet (front to back), located to the northeast of the laundry room, and a two-car garage. This section has a slab foundation. interior of which has been carefully restored over the last 25 years by the been replaced to match the original design. Because of deterioration and past fireplace. dining room (1812 portion) and the kitchen (1815 portion). The only exposed has barn-type pegged beam construction. replicated the pitch of the historic house and addition.Built in accordance bedroom closets, and a second story bathroom.Buck stoves have been inserted part hasa concrete floor.In 1973,atwo story frame addition,c.1860,14 The master bedroom the living room)also has a corner NPS Form 10-900-a OMB Approval No.

10240018 National Park Service Satterthwaite, John, House, 498 North Third Street, Waynesville, Warren Co., OH Section number _ removed by a sanding attachment on a drill, except on areas protected by National Register of Historic Places Page Continuation Sheet of the original Satterthwaite tract. The house remains in its original setting. retaining a surrounding 5.3 acres United States Department of the Interior 8. Statement of Significance

Statement of significance

Xlocally Areas of Significance (enter categories from instructions) Significant Dates 1812 - 1837 - Cultural Affiliation Significant Person Satterthwaite, John 1827 to c. 1830. and 6/6 on the second floor, are topped with brick lintels on the facade and the attic level. Smaller in scale, the two story single pen addition was interior of the house retains its original floor plan, hardwood floors and doors, and built-in cabinets and fireplaces, all remaining in excellent exhibited in its smooth facade, semi-circular fanlight, and flat lintels, but XX See continuation sheet Transportation 1827 1815 condition. Architecture State significance of property, and justify criteria, criteria considerations, and areas and periods of significance noted above. Commerce Architect/Builder also by its Pennsylvania two room deep floor plan, directly reflecting eastern Pennsylvania Quaker buildings.

Additionally, smaller attic windows on Federal architecture and reflects the distinct form of craftsmanship and additionally significant for its association with builder and resident side elevations.The west elevation features two unusual arched windows at John Satterthwaite's roots in Bucks County, Pennsylvania.Flemish bond Satterthwaite House is significant as an excellent, well-preserved example of buildings.While Quaker farmhouses continued to utilize a particular house The main dwelling is characterized not only by its outstanding Federal design, Period of Significance masonry and deep floor plans are traits which often resemble those elements on story screened porch was added later, and has a standing seam metal roof.The buildings and bridges, and for starting the first stagecoach line between Satterthwaite House was built in two stages.The original three bay, two and Applicable National Register Criteria built in 1815,and also features a facade in Flemish bond construction.A one Certifying official has considered the significance of this property in relation to other properties: a half story double pen house was built in 1812,and exhibits Flemish bond Criteria Considerations (Exceptions) John Satterthwaite, a prominent builder/contractor noted for his fine important stagecoach stop on this line, having served as an inn/tavern from statewide nationally gable ends were distinguishing features on a high percentage of these 9.

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

Major Bibliographical References Highway to 1972. Dennis E. Dalton, 1972. Gordon, Steve, and Walsh, Rita. Friends on the Landscape: A Preliminary Examination of the Society of Friends - Their Settlement and Architecture in Clinton, Highland & Warren Counties [Ohio], 1795 - 1860. Miami Purchase Association, Cincinnati: 1981. Sumner, written for dedication of Masonic headstone, October 3, 1964. Minutes of Miami Meeting. December 1814 through April 1815. Located at the Previous documentation on file (NPS): N/A -preliminary determination of individual listing (36 CFR 67) Primary location of additional data: has been requested KX State historic preservation office previously determined eligible by the National Register designated a National Historic Landmark Local government Survey # recorded by Historic American Engineering Record # Waynesville, Ohio 10.

Geographical Data Acreage of property _ 5.3 acres Verbal Boundary Description permanent parcel #05014760010 11. Form Prepared By Edward A. Anres, Jr./property owner organization - 27 February 1987 street & number - city or town _ _ state Northing 513/897-2736 University Easting date Specify repository: Other telephone historic integrity. Boundary Justification Ohio See continuation sheet Other State agency Wilmington College Library. Federal agency UTM References Ohioana Room, Cook Public Library 498 N. Third St. "Short Sketch of the Life of John Satterthwaite,"by great granddaughter Thelma Satterthwaite recorded by Historic American Buildings previously listed in the National Register name/title History of Warren County.W.H.Beers G Co.,1882 G 1971.

_ zip code 45068 Zone The boundary includes the farmhouse, smokehouse, stagecoach lane, and stone-lined spring that have historically been a part of Satterthwaite's House/farm and that maintain 413 8 0111 0 NPS Form 10-900-a OMB Approval No. 1024-0018 United States Department of the Interior National Park Service Satterthwaite, John, House, 498 North Third Street, Waynesville, Warren Co., OH Section number _ type native to its owner or builder between c. 1815 - 1850, thereafter, Quaker farmhouses had lost many of their distinguishing traits, assimilating into the John Satterthwaite was born in Bucks County, Pennsylvania 22 June 1786 near migrated to Waynesville, Ohio, then the largest Quaker Colony west of the was builder of several other homes and buildings within the town, some of Satterthwaite constructed the store c.

1818, and kept the store first by stagecoach line between Cincinnati and Springfield, called "The Opposition halfway between Cincinnati and Springfield. Shortly after, he was removed from the Miami Monthly Meeting as a result of lasted a short time, as he was so highly regarded by his friends. In spite of the feeling of the church, he became a charter member of Lebanon Royal Arch National Register of Historic Places made other notable contributions to the built environment of Warren County. Continuation Sheet Line." The house, known as "Halfway House," and farm served as the changing constructing the Federal style house of his down design in 1812,Satterthwaite place for stage horses as well as a stopping place and overnight lodging place craftmanship and design are elegantly exhibited in the Satterthwaite House.

spanning the Little Miami River the present site) in 1817 for $700 In 1815,Satterthwaite was asked to pay a fine to satisfy a military demand. which still stand including the general store building in Franklin Square. In 1827,Satterthwaite and William Werden of Springfield started the first general architectural style of the period. Overall, the early Quaker houses total of 126 acres for his farm. He chose this location because of the good 1811-1813. More vernacular in style, the Meeting House is characterized by consisting of 6 panes of glass. in the town of Mt. Holly, and is credited with helping to found that town. He himself and later in partnership with his brother-in-law, David Linton. The foundation of the building used to house the stage coaches was visible the street to the house is part of the old stage road.

"Halfway House" was Page including abutments.He also built bridges across Newman's Run and across the Satterthwaite built the first bridge testimony given against him by the elders of the Meeting.It is also believed for the freight teamsters.Evidence of a once-existing bar remains in the main hallway.A wall-mounted coat/hat rack has been retained in the hall. until the early 1950s.The stone step used by passengers on the stage is NPS Form 10-900e OMB Approval No. 1024-0018 United States Department of the Interior Continuation Sheet Satterthwaite, John, House, 498 North Third Street, Waynesville, Warren Co., OH Chapter No. 5 and also of the Miami Encampment No. 2 Knights Templar. He was the house, selling the farm in 1920, after the house had remained in the federal houses include 302 S. Main St. in Springboro, c.

1833 (which also incorporates later Greek Revival influence), the Hatton Farm, east of Harveysburg, c. 1833 (which features a central hall plan, Flemish bond masonry 140 Main St. in Waynesville, built c. 1815 (which features an asymmetrical three bay facade, more Georgian in influence, and is possibly one of the surrounded with a more commercial environment. Satterthwaite House remains in excellent condition, with few exterior or substantially deteriorated/altered, and its removal allowed two attic windows addition was built in its place and an effort was made to make this addition its original setting, complete with smokehouse, c. 1812-1815, and stone-lined National Register of Historic Places Township. spring. a member of Lebanon Lodge No.26 F.& A.M.

along with another prominent Warren (8-86) interior changes since its construction in 1812and 1815.Windows which had compatible with the historic house and historic addition roof village houses built by Satterthwaite.) It remains in fair condition, and is National Park Service of the Masonic Lodge of the State of Ohio in 1831.Satterthwaite additionally Of the Warren County Quaker-related properties surveyed & Walsh),no Section number _ - Page - Federalist Party in 1825. family for 106 years. John died 5 July 1837, and is buried in the Red Brick been changed over the years, are being returned to their original attachment on a drill and by sandblasting those areas which were covered by to be exposed on the 1815 addition. A one and a half story, 46 feet long township trustee, and town librarian.

He was a leading member of the Satterthwaite and his wife had seven children, many of whose descendants live Friends Meeting House Cemetery in Waynesville, the first cemetery in Wayne pitch, old brick, and roof molding). The interior retains original woodwork, facade, and an outstanding Grecian portico), and the John Craft Building. CROSSWICK AS OLD STAGE RO Satterthwaite, John, House 498 North Third Street Waynesville, Warren Co., OH E, SATTERTHWAITE HOBE 5.3A. MAP OF SATTERTHWAITE PLOT SOURCE: MAP-ELLS THOMPSON REALTORS -LEBANON, OH. NOT TO SCALE -PRESENT ANDRES BOUNDARY (1856) WAYNESVILLE R5T 97.3 A. SATTERTHWAITE RUN LEGEND: LINLE MIAMI RIVER IOFZ SHEETS ROF Z SHEETS Satterthwaite, John, House 498 North Third Street Waynesville, Warren Co., OH SMOKEHOUSE LITTLE MIAMI (DEED) HOUSE RIVER (PRESENT BOUNDARIES) WAYNESYILLE N.

THIRD ST SATTERTHWAITE HOUSE 5.3A COLD STAGE ROAD) 498 North Third St., Waynesville, Warren Co., OH -1815 - PORCH HALL GARAGE BATH FRONT BAY 1812 SMOKE HOUSE SATERTHWAITE HOUSE LIVING DINING KITCHEN FIRST (GROUND) FLOOR WINDOW ROOM 1973 498 North Third St., Waynesville, Warren Co., OH BATH STORAGE MASTER 1973 1812 HALL SECOND FLOOR SMOKE SATERTHWAITE HOUSE BEDROOM 1815 FRONT HOUSE 498 North Third St., Waynesville, Warren Co., OH - 1973 815 - 1812 HOUSE SMOKE FRONT ATTIC THIRD FLOOR WASO Form - 177 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR ("R" June 1984) NATIONAL PARK SERVICE NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES EVALUATION/RETURN SHEET Satterthwaite, John, House Fed. Reg. Date: Date Due: - - RETURN nomination by person or local government owner objection Federal Agency: - -appeal L sample L NR decision Discipline Historian - __ see continuation sheet Nomination returned for: - 1. Name 3.

Classification Present Use 4. Owner of Property 6. Representation in Existing Surveys Has this property been determined eligible? 7. Description Check one -excellent -J unaltered - original site - moved Describe the present and original (if known) physical appearance

Description of the property

summary paragraph yes resubmission ruins completeness Category Ownership deteriorated dates Status unexposed REJECT Working No. alterations/integrity OHIO Action: clarity Accessible Condition 5. Location of Legal Description boundary selection 2. Location Public Acquisition Substantive Review: Warren Couty Reviewer's comments: 88000239 FEB 23 1988 _ technical corrections cited below _substantive reasons discussed below J fair -ACCEPT 3-30-88 8.

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

Significance Areas of Significance-Check and justify below Specific dates L summary paragraph - completeness -applicable criteria J justification of areas checked - relating significance to the resource J context ] relationship of integrity to significance -justification of exception -other 9. Major Bibliographical References 10. Geographical Data Acreage of nominated property UTM References Verbal boundary description and justification 11. Form Prepared By 12.

State Historic Preservation Officer Certification The evaluated significance of this property within the state is: _national _local State Historic Preservation Officer signature - Photographs Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to - Phone: _ GPO 918-450 Comments for any item may be continued on an attached sheet Date Builder/Architect title Signed Period Maps _state clarity Quadrangle name Statement of Significance (in one paragraph) 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Warren County, Ohio Edward A. Andres, Jr- Waynesville, Ohio #1 of 17 Photographs Satterthwaite House February 1987 Photographer: Front Facade and 1815 Addition looking West Negative on file at 498 N. Third St. 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Warren County, Ohio February, 1987 Waynesville, Ohio #2 of 17 Photographs South Satterthwaite House Negative on file at 498 N.

Third St., Edward A- Andres, JI- Photographer:E Rear Facade & 1815 & 1973 Additions looking 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Warren County, Ohio Edward A. Andres, Jr- February, 1987 Waynesville, Ohio Satterthwaite House looking West tions, Smokehouse & General Surroundings Photographer: Overall Front View showing 1815 & 1973 Addi- Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., February, 1987 Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., #4 of 18 Photographs Satterthwaite House Warren County, Ohio Rear Facade & 1815 Addition looking East Waynesville, Ohio 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Edward A- Andres, Jr- Photographer: Edward A. Andres, Jr- February, 1987 Waynesville, Ohio 1ooking Southwest #5 of 17 Photographs Photographer: Front Facade showing Main Door Details Satterthwaite House Warren County, Ohio Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Warren County, Ohio Edward A.

Andres, JI- February, 1987 Waynesville, Ohio #6 of 17 Photographs Satterthwaite House Photographer: Shaped Limestone Stage Step Rear (Lane Side) of House showing Keystone 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Warren County, Ohio Edward A. Andres, Jr- February, 1987 Waynesville, Ohio #7 of 17 Photographs Satterthwaite House Front Facade of Smokehouse looking South Photographer:E Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Warren County, Ohio Edward A. Andres, JI- February, 1987 Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Ohio #8 of 14 Photographs Satterthwaite House Photographer: Rear Facade of Smokehouse looking North 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, February, 1987 #9 of 17 Photographs Portion Satterthwaite House Living Room in 1812 Warren County, Ohio Negative on file at 498 N.

Third St., Waynesville, Ohio Edward A. Andres, Jr. Photographer: Warren County, Ohio February, 1987 Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Ohio #10 of 17 Photographs Portion Satterthwaite House Dining Room Fireplace in 1812 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Warren County, Ohio February, 1987 #11 of 17 Photographs Satterthwaite House 1812 Portion Negative on file at 498 N. Third St Photographer: Edward A. Andres, Jr- Waynesville, Ohio Dining Room Corner Cupboard in 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Warren County, Ohio Edward A. Andres, JI- February, 1987 Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Ohio #12 of 17 Photographs Satterthwaite House Photographer: Main Door in Front of Hallway showing Semi- circular Fan Light, in 18i2 Portion Edward A- Andres, Jr- February, 1987 Negative on file at 498 N.

Third St., Satterthwaite House Rear of Hallway showing Stairway, Stage Coach Photographer:E Entrance & Ash Floors, in 1812 Portion #13 of 14 Photographs Warren County, Ohio 498 N. Third St., Waynesville Waynesville, Ohio 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Edward A. Andres, JI- February, 1987 Satterthwaite House Rack in 1812 Portion Photographer:E Negative on file at 498 N. Third St Warren County, Ohio Waynesville, Ohio #14 of 1g Photographs Inside Wall of Hallway showing Coat/Hat Warren County, Ohio Negative on file at 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Ohio #15 of 14 Photographs Portion Satterthwaite House 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, Photographer: Edward A. Andres, Jx. Master Bedroom (Walnut) Fireplace in 1812 February, 1987 Waynesville, Ohio #16 of 18 Photographs Satterthwaite House Kitchen Fireplace in 1815 Addition Negative on file at 498 N. Third St. Warren County, Ohio 498 an.

Third St., Waynesville, 498 N. Third St., Waynesville, February, 1987 #17 of 14 Photographs Addition Satterthwaite House Warren County, Ohio Negative on file at 498 N. Third St Kitchen Pine") Cupboard in 1815 Waynesville, Ohio Edward A. Andres, Jr- Photographer: WAYNESVILLE, OHIO WAYNESVILLE QUADRANGLE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR CENTERVILLE 7.5 MINUTE SERIES (TOPOGRAPHIC) STATE PARK Ohio Historic Preservation Office 1985 Velma Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43211 SINCE 1885 February 19, 1988 Ms. Carol Shull, Chief National Register of Historic Place: Department of the Interior P.O. Box 37127 Satterthwaite, John, House Please contact me if you have any questions.

WRL : ae FEB 2 3 1988 Enclosures 614/297-2470 County Warren Sincerely, HISTORICAL New Submissions National Park Service Dear Carol: State Historic Preservation Officer notification procedures have been followed for this new submission.We Enclosed is one new National Register nomination.All of the appropriate addition to the house. request a substantive review on this nomination, due to the large modern