Nomination for Carty, J.--R. J. Tussing House

From the form

The catalogue entry the section above was filed under.

United States Department of the Interior National Park Service JUL 03 1989 Register. L (Form 10-900a). Type all entries. 1. Name of Property Carty - R. J. Tussing House 2. Location state Ohio code OH code 049 zip code 43110 3. Classification Category of Property 4 building(s) J public-State - structures _ objects Name of related multiple property listing: Number of contributing resources previously Historic Resources of Canal Winchester, Ohio State/Federal Agency Certification As the designated authority underthe National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, as amended, I hereby certify that this Signature of certifying official 5. National Park Servico Certification ZZentered in the National Register. / See continuation sheet.

determined eligible for the National determined not eligible for the other, (explain:) Signature of the Keeper Noncontributing NATIONAL site district vicinity public-local National Register. Total Registration Form county Franklin public-Federal removed from the National Register.

Date National Register of Historic Places Ownership of Property other names/site number N/A and areas of significance.enter only the categories and subcategories listed in the instructions.For additional space use continuation sheets Number of Resources within Property historic name This form is for use in nominating or requesting determinations of eligibility for individual properties or districts.See instructions in Guidelines Date of Action Hereby, certify that this property is: listed in the National Register State or Federal agency and bureeu Signature of commentingor other official 1025 city, town Canal Winchester National Register of Historic Places and meets the procedural and professional requirements set forth in 36 CFR Part 60 Register. Soe continuation sheet.

not for publication N/A Ynominationrequest for determination of eligibility meets the documentation standards for registering properties in the for Completing National Register Forms (National Register Bulletin 16). Complete each item by marking "x" in the appropriate box or by entering Entered in tha 6. Function or Use Historic Functions (enter categories from instructions) Current Functions (enter categories from instructions) Domestic - single dwelling 7. Description Materials (enter categories from instructions) (enter categories from instructions) and a low-pitched hip roof that is covered with imbricated slate. The between the front portion which ig parallel to the street and the rear The north elevation is five bays wide, with a projection. This a single bay.

A one story hipped roof porch with ornamental wood * See continuation sheet concrete foundation roof The slate Italianate sandstone brick walls Architectural Classification rear bay. Italianate characteristics of this house include the entablature, wide shutters and the precast concrete porch. The rear (west) elevation is three bays wide, two of which occur in the pre-cast concrete and dates fram the early 2oth century. The south elevation is four bays wide, the bays being evenly divided south, and three rooms make up the portion of the house which is The interior of the J.Carty-R.J.Tussing House features a central hall walls are running bond brick with nu-bricking applied.The house has a also features three-light sidelights with wood panels at the bottom.A plan.A one-story hipped roof addition is located in the joint of the L.

projection is two bays wide and is separated from the northeast corner by The east.facade is five bays wide.A projection two bays wide is located front portion. brackets is located ta the west of this projection and staps short of the Other: Hipped Ell Plan window on the first floor. All windows in the house are 2/2 light double with an open stairway. One room rung the length of this hall to the portion which is perpendicular to the front and thus creates the L-shaped This recessed entry at the northern end of this facade.This projection also features a bay the second.A single door entry with a single light transom defined by front to the southeast corner. The porch is constructed of rock-faced eaves, and shallow-pitched hip roof, and tall, narrow windows.

chimneys: one at the south end, one centrally located, and two at the L-shape in plan.It has an woad entablature with dentils, wide eaves, main roof ridge runs north-south which is parallel to the street.The wood ornanental brackets occupies the center bay. 8. Statement of Significance

Statement of significance

Certitying official has considered the significance of this property in relation to other properties: Areas of Significance (enter categories from instructions) Period of Significance 1874 - 1897 Significant Person Significant exterior details include the single door entry, slate roof, X Soe continuation sheet commerce Unknown architecture Cultural Affiliation North High Street Historic District. Jacob Carty Significant Dates part owner/founder of the winchester Mills. noninated individually and one example is within the boundaries of the floors, wood trin and baseboards, and central staircase with turned Architect/Builder design, all of which are brick.Three of the examples are being spindles, newel post and paneling.

This is one of four houses in the incorporated limits with Italianate Jacob Carty acquired two acres and 82 poles of land in this area in 1868 Waterloo Streets inafrane house constructed in 1840,prior to his move is said to have been a resident here in c.1926. -statewide Applicable National Register Criteria Criteria Considerations (Exceptions) 212 light double hung windows, corbeled chimneys, dentiled entablature, and front bay with cornice. Jacob Carty (1805-1897) was one of four founders of the Winchester Millg Historic Context E.2.

"Agricultural Commerce: Railroad Era, 1869-1904" as nationally Israel Julian.The Carty & Julian store was located on the Town Lot on Intact interior details include the wood early 2oth century precast concrete porch.It is also significant under High Street.As early as 1834 or 1835,Carty and Rodgers built a frame in 1868,which was 1ocated just north of this property across the Hocking 1897 and the property was sold to Rudolph Judson Tussing in 1898. OMB Aoprovel No. 1024-0018 National Park Service Description, Statement of Sig. cont. 8. Statement of Significance continued Whitehurst (Whitehurst & Carty) which becane the Whitehurst, (John) Gehn, & Co. between 1860 and 1870, and Whitehurst, Lehman & Carty in 1877.

Following construction of the Hocking Valley Railroad, a spur was run vestige of agricultural business of Canal Winchester, operating until Continuation Sheet his specific contributions are unknown, therefore the period of National Register of Historic Places Infornation regarding the significance of his greenhouse operation and side. related.He was the presiding officer of the Madison Grange #194 in 1880 In the northwest corner of the house, the interior plan has been altered grain warehouse on the west side of High Street, north of the canal.It structure with a slate covered gable roof.The building appears to date significance ends with Carty's death. staircase has a turned spindles and newel post and wood panels on its the tine of his acquisition of the property in 1898 through at least In 1868 the Winchester Mills were built by Jacob Carty, M. C.

Whitehurst, United States Department of the Interior enclosed staircase believed to be original),and the addition ofa with the removal of a wall separating two rooms, the removal of a rear to the same period as the house. its own right. A pool has been added to the exterior grounds, but it has Rudolph Judson Tugging was a greenhouge operator at thig location from not affected the general setting of the house. Between 1840 and 1850,he began in the grain business with M.C. and 1892 and also secretary of the Franklin Farmers Institute in 1887. down High Street which ran to the Whitehurst & Carty warehouse until Section number _7,8 1978.The mil1 complex was demolished in 1987.

- See continuation sheet -preliminary determination of individual listing (36 CFR 67) Primary location of additional data: State historic preservation office ] Federal agency recorded by Historic American Buildings Jrecorded by Historic American Engineering 10.

The rest of the file

Bibliography, boundary description, and the people who prepared and reviewed the nomination.

Geographical Data Acreage of property - Verbal Boundary Description 11. Form Prepared By street & number 2595 Summit Street . telephone - _ zip code 43202 614-263-3440 University Easting Record Zone Local government Previous documentation on file (NPS): N / A has been requested non-contributing structures on them. designated a National Historic Landmark in Franklin County Administration Building,41o South High St.,Columbus, Northing previously listed in the National Register UTM References Situated in the village of Canal Winchester, Franklin County, Ohio, being .805acre parcel in Southeast quarter section30,Parcel #307,asrecorded city or town _Columbus Other state Ohio Historic Inventory - FRA-3257-24 Ohio - Map Book N-6: Boundary Justification Less than one acre Other State agency previously determined eligible by the National Register Franklin County, OHIO 1. Arendt Seymour House 2.

Barnhardt-Bolenbaugh House 3. Beery, Dr. L.W., House 4. Bruns-Wynkoop House 6. David's Reformed Church 7. Decker, Elias, Farmhouse 8. Deitz, Samuel, Farmhouse 9. Epley, Henry J., House 10. Foor-Alspach House SVI1. Gayman, Christian, House 12. Griffith, James, House 13. Haffey, Parley, Farm Complex 14. Helpman--Chaney House 15. King, William, House 16. Lehman, Abraham, Farmhouse S.N18. Methodist Church Parsonage 20. Peoples Bank Company Building Page COVER Continuation Sheet National Register of Historic Places Date Listed Canal Winchester MPS National Register National Park Service Entered in the United States Department of the Interior Section number National Substantive Revlew National leglater NPS Form 10900a 19. North High Street Historic District 8115/8 NATIONAL PARK SERVICE EVALUATION/RETURN SHEET Carty, J.--R. J.

Tussing House DATE OF 45TH DAY: NOMINATOR: STATE COMMENT WAIVER: N 7/03/89 REJECT 8/17/89 MULTIPLE DATE 8/04/89 DISCIPLINE PROPERTY REVIEWER RETURN NAME: RECOM./CRITERIA Entered in the Canal Winchester MPS DATE RECEIVED: NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES DATE OF WEEKLY LIST: UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR National Register DATE OF 16TH DAY: N SLR DRAFT: N ABSTRACT/SUMMARY COMMENTS: NATIONAL: REASONS FOR REVIEW: _count STATE/FEDERAL AGENCY CERTIFICATION Summary paragraph GEOGRAPHICAL DATA ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENTATION/PRESENTATION _photographs _presentation current acreage context FUNCTION materials DESCRIPTION clarity Period completeness resource type CLASSIFICATION historic architectural classification BIBLIOGRAPHY descriptive text other Builder/Architect SIGNIFICANCE justification of areas checked justification of exception Phone boundary justification relationship of integrity to significance applicable criteria Date Specific dates relating significance to the resource Questions concerning this nomination may be directed to USGS maps sketch maps verbal boundary description Signed OTHER COMMENTS Statement of Significance one paragraph) Areas of Significance--Check and justify below UTMS Historic Resources of Canal Winchester, Ohio J.

Carty - R.J. Tussing House 48 Elm St. ,C.W. . Franklin Cty, Ohio Winter, 1987-88 Facade (East) & N. Elevation - S.W. Canal Winchester Area Hist. Soc. Kathy Mast Kane Historic Resources of Canal Winchester, Ohio J. Carty - R.J. Tussing House Franklin Cty, Ohio Facade (East) Elevation , W. Canal Winchester Area Hist. Society Winter 1987-88 Kathy Mast Kane 48 Elm Street Historic Resources of Canal Winchester, Ohio J. Carty - R.J. Tussing House Franklin Cty, Ohio Winter 1987-88 Rear (West) Elevation , E. Kathy Mast Kane Canal Winchester Area Hist. Society 48 Elm Street Historic Resources of Canal Winchester, Ohio J. Carty - R.J. Tussing House Franklin Cty, Ohio Winter 1987-88 Outbuilding, W. Canal Winchester Area Hist. Society Kathy Mast Kane 48 Elm Street Multiple Property Cover Sheet Reference Number: 64500475 for this property Multiple Property Cover Sheet Please refer to the map in the