Bradley County, Tennessee - Chapter 2: Pretensiojfs of the Rebels to Divine Favor, 1866
From History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866. 2,988 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
The text
2,988 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
The remarkable character of the rebellion in this respect, iDarticularly in East Tennessee, forces upon us even in writing a part of its history, the question of its right or wrong as a national cause.
A history of events or i^eriods of time which presents nothing positively extraordinary, may, with some propriety be sui)erficial, and deal only with the events themselves ; but periods or events, the prevailing characteristics of which startle mankind and shock the world with horror, direct our attention to causes and to the investigation of principles for the elucidation of such anomalies, and as a means of obtaining that instruction which no people, especially those most interested, should fail to glean from them.
National as well as individual crimes are aggravated or mitigated by the circumstances under whicfc they are committed, hence an accurate knowledge of all the circumstances in any given case is indispensable to a correct estimate of the guilt of the parties involved ; and the more remarkable or unususl the facts or circumstances, the greater becomes the general anxiety for a complete solution of the whole problem.
The truth of these statements has been very strikingly illustrated by our great rebellion, and especially by the rebellion in East Tennessee. This rebellion has been one of the most remarkable events in nature - one of the most astounding things in history, consequently it has awakened a deeper, a more intense feeling among mankind than any other national event of ancient or of modern times, and accordingly, more anxious, struggling inquiry, more intellectual toil and concentration of moral effort, have already been expended upon the profound problem it presents to the world, than was called forth in the same length of time, by any other event transpiring in history.
In presenting a narrative of the occurrences of this rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, we shall attempt, though briefly, to place the tragedy as a whole, so before the public that no doubt can exist as to the parties which were in the WTong at the beginning, upon w^hicli basis alone, as we have already seen, can we judge correctly of the guilt ot the innocence that attaches to the different actors in the drama.
It is well known, and will not be denied from any quarter, that at the beginning, and as long as the rebels were to any extent able to defy the Government, they did not cease to trumpet abroad in the ears of the Christian world, the assumption that they were nationally and constitutionally, as well as divinely right in striking for the independence of the South.
History presents no other instance of so strong an effort of the kind, as was made by the rebels to convince themselTes and the rest of mankind of the justice of their cause. The church and the state, the priest and the politician, the journalist and the slave-driver, were one and inseparable in swaddling their young confederacy as the legitimate offspring of heaven. It was also the beau-idealof national government, and the quintessence of social humanity. The most talented and influential, if not the most pious and godly, among the clergy of the South, never allowed themselves to doubt for a moment that the cause of the rebels was a child of special Providence, and consequently, embodying a reformation or revolution in the affairs of the world, which having God for its author and protector must be triumphant in the end.
The Southern States, in erecting themselves into an independent nation, had committed no error. They had been guilty of no wrong. They were only the passive instruments of an opening Providence, whose divinity the leaders of the great movement could not deny, dutifully and inoffensively toiling, as directed, to dispense the blessings of that Providence to the world ; and as an evidence of their sincerity and their Christian spirit, all the favor they asked of their old connections, in relation to this great work was simply " to be let alone."
Now, all this is historical fact, and as such it is not only onr privilege but our province to deal with it. Just here, therefore, we propose to join issue with the rebels. We join issue with them upon this point, their loud profession of being in the Divine favor, to the Divine prejudice against the Northern cause, simx^jy because in making a brief argument it is the best suited to the purpose.
Now, if a Southern Confederacy upon this continent, founded upon the institution of slavery, was plainly depicted in the Providential signs of the times, if it was unmistakably the voice of God as the rebels iDretended, and if His hand vras so plainly revealed in its inauguration and in its support, even for years, how is it that the rebellion so signally failed ? God being the author, the instigator, and the support of the rebellion for so long a time, upon what principle are we to account for the fact, that all at once it met with the most disgraceful overthrow of any revolutionary cause of which history gives us any knowledge ? Did the Almighty forsake his own cherished designs, or v\^as he defeated by the mudsills of the North ? It is utterly impossible by any fair course of reasoning to reconcile the fact of the sudden and complete failure of the rebellion with the supposition that God was the instigator of it, or that He ever smiled upon the enterprise, or allowed it to exist and i)rogress with any view to its final success.
"For if this counsel or this work be of men, it will come to nought: But if it be of God, ye cannot overthrow it," is a passage of Scripture which all Southern theologians who have expatiated so sweepingly upon the Divine mission of the rebellion, would do well not only to consider in a general sense, but they would do well to consider it particularly in connection with their melancholy reflections upon the disastrous end of their beloved Confederacy.
Tlie simple failure, however-, of the rebellion, to accomplish what it undertook, is not the only fact under this Jiead that argues against the assumption in question.
The rebels were not only defeated - simple failure of their cause was not the only result, but they were utterly ruined. They not only did not gain anything that they proposed, but they lost everything that they could call their own when they began. Not one stone was left upon another of their old order of things. The result to the rebellion was not merely defeat, but it was annihilation - a visitation of swift destruction. Defeat, destruction, annihilation, and the total loss of all things, were the fruits of that Divine favor that attended them. As well might these political and theological Southern Doctors contend, that God was in the midst of the Cities of the Plain, to befriend and bless the i)eople with His gracious presence, at the very moment when his wrath w^as causing the earth to open and to swallow them up for their abominable sins, as to contend that a cause with all its principles smitten to the earth and scattered to the four winds like the rebellion, was the cause of God. It is possible, however, that Bishop Pierce and Doctor Palmer can prove that the Almighty was fighting at the head of His people irom the walls of Jerusalem, and attempting to defend them against the Eoman army, by whom they were finally overcome and destroyed.
The end of the rebellion was unlike the end of any just cause recorded in history. Truth always gains by contact with error, whatever may be the immediate and aj^pareiit victory against it. Revolutions never go backward. The Commonwealth of Cromwell partially failed at the time of its ostensible objects, but it was far from being a total failure. Its princix)les lived if they did not triumph at the time. It gained much also at the time. The point of its termination was infinitely in advance of the point of its setting out. As Mr. Goldwin Smith remarks, " The principles of Cromwell partially failed in England ; but they crossed the Atlantic and perfectly succeeded in America." The principles of Cromwell produced the Americam Rev- olntion, and fully developed themselves in the fact of our 13resent American Republic. The rebellion, however, it appears, possessed no redeeming or self-sustaining qualities of this nature - qualities that live and grow in spite of defeat, qualities wresting victory from defeat itself; but Avas, in]all respects, a backward movement - a step to the rear, and so far to the rear that the point of its setting out was lost and irrecoverable, never to be seen again ; and in an utterly strange land, dying a very strange and singular death, the rebellion found its grave. Not one of its principles are now alive to defend its character or hallow its memory.
The rebellion itself w^as a strange thing, and everything about it was strange in the extreme. It had strange statesmen, strange politics, a strange religion and strange gods. Strange gods indeed the rebels must have had that could so deceive and mislead them, and false prophets that the Lord did not send.
In viewing the infatuation of the South upon this subject, and especially the infatuation of its Doctors of Divinity, one can hardly avoid being struck with the similarity of their condition with that of the prophets of Baal before Elijah; also, as Elijah did those prophets, one can hardly avoid mocking these Southern Divines by tauntingly enquiring, Why they did not call louder uj^on their god ? For he was a god, but was talking, or pursuing, or was on a journey, or fighting other battles, or peradventure he slept and must be awaked. Why did not more of these prophets leap upon the rebel altars that were made, and cut themselves after their manner with knives and lancets, till the blood gushed out upon them, crying louder and still louder, 0 Baal, hear us ! for thou art a god and will deliver us ?
The failure of the Prophets of Baal to persuade their god to answer by fire and consume their sacrifice, and the complete success of Elijah in calling upon his God to come down and consume his offering, instantaneously put an end to all controversy among the people, as to which worshiped the true God. The Prophets of Baal were false
This subject, however, has another phase which very strongly confirms the position, that Providence never favored the rebellion with any view to its final success.
As a purely worldly scheme, and a purely worldly scheme it Wa-s, the one great thing which ruined it, the rebellion did possess all the elements of success. This fact is so manifest that its total failure can be accounted for upon no other principle than that Providence was against it. There was not a moment from the bombardment of Sumter to the fall of Lee, when the preponderance of worldly sentiment and worldly policy not only in our own nation, but in all other ruling nations of Christendom, with one or two exceptions, were not in sympathy with the rebels. Our national triumph is the greatest moral victory ever achieved in so short a time, against such w^orldly odds. In regard to ourselves, the rebels at heart in the whole country were in the majority a little more than six millions. The Government, therefore, in the contest, was reduced to the ratio of two against three during the war. In other words, the whole country. North and South, contained eighteen millions of rebels, and twelve millions of loyal people ; and thus it stood on an average until the end of the contest. Disintegration of the rebel elements was all in a worldly point of view that saved us. Had the rebels in the entire nation been one in locality, as they w^ere one in sentiment, or had rebels in the North been able to combine and organize in the North, as the rebels were able to do in the South, the Government w^ould have been swept wdtli the besom of destruction. The rebellion possessed the numbers, but it lacked in one locality the power of concentration and organization.
In territory also, confining our estimate to the States^ at the beginning, the Government was inferior to the Southern Confederacy. Leaving the border slave States out of the question, and allowing their conflicting forces to ballance each other, the seceded territory exceeded that left to the Government, about sixty thousand square miles, an area equal to that of the great State of Yirginia. In numbers and in territory this was the disproportion in favor of the rebels at home.
Abroad, at the beginning, as well as for two years afterwards, the prospects of the rebels were quite as bright, and ours quite as dark, as they were within our own borders. With one exception, that of Russia, the leading European governments, if not their people, were strongly in sympathy with the rebellion. Fifteen days onh^ elapsed after the dispatch of Lord Lyons announcing to his Government the fall of Sumter, before his Queen issued her proclamation recognizing the rebels as belligerents. France was equally precipitate and ungenerous, and wlw, contrary to all this, and the eager haste in which it was done, the rebels were ever after disappointed in their expectations of full recognition as an independent nation, is, to-day, upon any principle of their worldly policy alone, as indefinable by the one party as by the other. While" the rebels were exhausting every art of diplomacy to hasten the event, these governments were at work mth equal industry to get themselves ready, or in other words, to get themselves into a safe position to grant the request, yet, some invisible power retarded every step and mysteriously held back the coveted boon, till an event at the White House ; no noise of war in it either, shook the continent, if not the earth, and knelled among European thrones, that the hour of Southern recognition had passed.
Another argument that might be here presented against the assumption in question, is the spirit of the rebellion itself. Tliat instance is not on record where any just National cause, immediately successful or otherwise, characterized itself by those brutalities and studied cruelties, as a rule, practiced by the rebellion, though perhaps not without exceptions, seemingly in a spirit of revenge, and with a view to accomplishing its ends. History does not furnish a more glaring and frightful paradox than exists in this pretension to Divine guidance on the part of the rebels, and the systematic cruelties which they allowed themselyed to perpetrate under it.
Our American Revolution is now universally admitted to have commenced in justice, consequently witli the Divine approval. It was provoked by grievances and abuses which made it positively unavoidable, or made it indispensably necessary to the success of the Colonists as a people. Theirs was a case infinitely more than that of the Southern rebels, calculated to tempt and provoke revenge ; and if such a course had been good policy, much more an inducing cause of resorting to wasting cruelties as a means of defeating their enemies. Like the rebels, our forefathers believed that their cause was right, and more honestly than the rebels, appealed to God for the sincerity ol their convictions and the purity of their motives, and as submitting to Him the grievances for which they took up arms, for Him to answer to the justice of their position by giving them victory.
With them this work was real, and brought them upon too sacred ground for the kindlings of revenge or of any other spirit as an element of the contest, only such as was consistent with the Attributes of the Being to whom they applied, such as they felt and professed to be governed by at the start, and saw to be indispensable qualifications for being heard by the Creator and Judge of the world.
Thus our Revolution on the part of our forefathers was not, like the rebellion on the part of the rebels, a war of tJie 2^cissions. Their grievances being real and utterly unavoidable only by an appeal to the sword, made their dependence on God a corresponding reality; and they, from the very nature of such dependence, compelled to continue in this frame and fight the battle through upon this principle, there was no room for the spirit of revenge and retalliation, only as the latter was occasionally justified as a means of self-protection ; and being no room nor any disposition for these passions, there was, of course, no grounds for a barbarous resort to them as a means of weakening their enemies.
(lition, their spirit would have been the same also. The undeniable fact, however, that the general spirit of the rebels was the ver}^ reverse of this from the beginning to the end of the war, is evidence conclusive that their extravagant pretensions in this respect were either destructive self-deceptions, mental infatuations to which they were given up that they might be destroyed, or hypocritical and wicked devices to inspire with mistaken enthusiasm the thousands of ignorant soldiery whom the leaders were sacrificing to their own diabolical purposes.
An enlightened and considerate view of the spirit and genius of the rebellion, its fancied and falsely arrayed grievances, its insatiable greed of National power, its determination to rule or r«in, its aristocratic corruption and domineering cruelty, and the social vortex which it w^as preparing and towards which it was remorselessly driving the people of the whole land, white as well as black, causes every good man to tremble when he reflects how near the terrible effort approximated to a final success.
Provenance
Text from History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.