BlockBefore

Bradley County, Tennessee - Chapter 3: Election for Convention and No Convention, 1866

From History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866. 5,448 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

7 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

5,448 words

Machine-read from scans of History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 3: Election for Convention and No Convention

It was stated at the commencement of the second chapter, that the rebel leaders, both in church and state, very positively assumed that the rebellion was politically as well as morally right.

Every person in Bradley County knows that this was the position unequivocally taken by the rebels, not only in this county, but in the whole of East Tennessee, and that this position was maintained during the war. Throughout East Tennessee, as well as in Bradley, the rebels set themselves up as tJie loyal 2)(trty - the only true patriots in the state. Standing upon this platform, they constantly justified their cruel treatment of Union people on the ground, that these Union iDeople were traitors ; and, contended that the sufferings which they were inflicting ui)on them were not cruelties, but righteous and well deserved punishments for their crimes as tories, traitors, and rebels against their own lawful government. Upon this principle the rebels of Bradley asserted that the Union citizens had forfeited all claim to their homes, that their iDossessions were no longer theirs, and therefore, that Confederates were justified in robbing Union families, plundering their farms, hunting them through the country like so many wild beasts, and shooting them upon the run like so many robbers and outlaws.

Now, we wonder if it ever occurred to the rebels while they were engaged in all this, that as a theory, this was a wholly false position. Did it ever occur to them that this platform of theirs was, in fact, completely reversed all the time ? That they themselves, were the tories, traitors, and robbers, instead of the Union men whom they were murdering? Did it ever occur to the rebels that tliey were robbing and murdering these Union men, only because thev refused to commit the verv crimes which they alleged against them ? They murdered them, they said, because they were traitors ; but the fact is, they murdered them because they were not and would not be traitors. Traitors against the best government in the world, were murdering loyal citizens because they Avere not traitors like themselves. Men guilty of the highest type of treason, were murdering others for exhibiting the highest type of loyalty. Men guilty of treason, the highest crime known to the law, were murdering their neighbors for their loyalty, the greatest virtue known to society.

The former chapter was devoted to a consideration of this subject as a general question, a question in regard to the rebellion as a whole, and not with especial reference to it in any particular locality. If the rebellion as a v/hole was wrong - its principles offensive to God, its designs at war with His providence - then, of course, the rebellion was wrong in Tennessee, and the statements just made in regard to the criminality of Bradley rebels, consequently, correct. The question, however, of the false position of the rebels in Bradley, and their criminality in consequence, deduced from the fact, that the whole rebellion was wrong, with the remark just made, we will let pass for the present.

There is another question of importance, less general, bearing upon the subject, to be considered, and which must be considered before the guilt of Tennessee rebels can be accurately measured. Though the rebellion as a whole was fundamentally wrong, yet, if Tennessee had, by a clear majority of her people, decided to go with this rebellion, such action, if it had not palliated the cruelties inflicted by Tennessee rebels upon their Union neighbors, might, at least, have given some show of consistency to the political position which they assumed towards the ioyal people. If, however, it can be shown that this majority was exactly the other way - against secession, and was clearly expressed, then, it will not only follow that the position assumed by the Tennessee rebels that they were tl\e loyal j^arty was false and inconsistent ; but that they stand before the world as that class of men known in history as the double-headed traitors - traitors against the general Government, and also traitors against the Government of their own State. In any Republican State, the will of the people clearly expressed, is the Government of that State - is the Supreme Law, and whoever rebels against that law is a traitor. Dual treason, however, does not seem to be the only distinguishing characteristic of the Tennessee rebels ; nor the only particular brand of infamy with which they will be handed down to posterity. Having perfected this double crime, or rather having committed the crime of treason the second time, first against the general Government, then against the clearly expressed will of a majority of their own people, the course of evil had been sufiiciently protracted to harden them for the third and final denouement of indiscriminate blood-letting w^hich followed and crimsoned their footsteps, especially in East Tennessee - a barbarousness not exceeded even by the Andersonville and Belle Island horrors, and which w^hen view^ed as a third stride in the career that had already designated them dual traitors^ forever brands them as the trijpi^le and blood-stained criminals of the Great Rebellion.

The infidel writer and pamphleteering castigator of John Bull in the days of the Revolution, Thomas Paine, never uttered a sentiment truer, nor one falser than this is true, than when he said, " One bad action creates a calamitous necessity for another." Tlie bloody scale on which Tennessee rebels graduated from one degree of crime to another will remain, to the end of time, a monumental illustration of this proverbial truth. We shall now give a brief statement of facts in regard to the secession of Tennessee - facts the most of which have already been made historical by appearing in ofiicial or documentary form, and all of which can be substantiated by living witnesses.

South Carolina broke the way and seceded from the Union family on the 20th of December, 1861. As well as exciting treason in other portions of the South, this also fired the rebel blood in Tennessee. On the 7th of January, only eighteen days after the great sin of South Car- olina, Governor Harris convened his Legislature at Nashville. On the 19th, this body appointed a State election for the 9th of February following, at which the people of Tennessee were to decide whether a State Convention should be called to consider the subject of the great Southern movement now commenced in South Carolina. Convention or No Convention on this subject was to be the distinct issue before the people of Tennessee at this election ; consequently, those in favor of the measure were to write on their ballots " Convention, " those opposed to it were to write on theirs, " No Convention."

In view of the possibility that the people at this election might decide to have this convention, each party, Union and Secession, nominated its candidates to be elected as members of this convention, and voted for them at the same time that they voted for Convention and No Convention. Every county in the State, we believe, on that day elected its members to this convention. The Union candidates were pledged to vote, in case the convention took place, against secession under any circumstances and at all hazards. The rebel candidates were pledged to vote for secession except on certain conditions - a redress of grievances, &c.

The results of the election were No Convention, and a majority of Union candidates. Even the city of Memphis elected its Union candidates by 400 majorit}^ The majority of Union votes cast in electing these members over those cast by the rebel candidates, was 61,114. The Union majority for No Convention was not so large, being only 30,839.

It appears that a great many Union men in the State, Vv'ho on that day voted for Union candidates, did so under the impression that, although they were thus opposed to secession, yet it was proper to have a State Convention on the subject of existing difficulties. Hence this difference between the majority for these Union candidates, and that for No Convention.

West Tennessee

The following extracts shov/ conclusively, the rebels themselves being judges, that this election was a fair trial of the question at issue - an honest and perfectly voluntary expression of the will of the people.

The first of these extracts is from the editorial of the " Cleveland Banner," a bitter rebel sheet, and which was continued till silenced by the Federal army in the Avinter of 1864.

"The Election. - The election on Saturday last resulted in the defeat of everybody, in. one sense of the word, except "No Convention" - he run like a scared dog. and beat the field out of sight. In this county the vote stood, Convention 242, No Convention 1443. Brown was elected delegate. We have but few returns from the adjoining counties, and they not full; but one thing is certain, a Convention has been voted doicn by an overwhelming majority, and those fortunate men who were elected to a convention, will have the pleasure of remaining at home."

East Texnessee

"The Result. - Tlie people of Tennessee 5'esterclay had an opportunity of sayhif? throiitjli the ballot-box. whether or not they desired the assemblin,i>^ of a State Convention, as provided for by Le^^islative enactment. The indications are that a lanje majority voted "No Convention." However much we misrht have desired a different result, we feel fully satisfied that the proposition to hold a Convention has been defeated. The 2'>eople have spoken^ and ice have naught to say against their decree. It may brin<j tlieni no harm, or it may result in evil only - which of the two will be known before the expiration of many days."

Now this election furnishes us with a two-fold expression of the will of the people in regard to the secession of the State. First, we have a clear majority of 64,114 votes, those cast for the Union candidates for membership in this convention, expressing the sovereign will of the people, that Tennessee should not under any circumstances secede from the Union. Second, in the votes at the same time cast, respecting a convention, we have another clear Union majority of nearly 31,000, not only against secession ; but, deciding that no cause whatever even for a convention on the subject, that Tennessee had no grievances to complain of, that she had no quarrel with the General Government, and proposed to remain in the Union as she was. This was the legitimate announcement of the people of Tennessee at this election, doubly expressed. That this is so, as well as being a fair and binding expression of the will of the people, is now not only the testimony of every Union man in the State, but is the testimony of the rebels themselves. The following is from the Cleveland Banner, a rebel sheet, from which we have already quoted in this connection, and taken from a number dated February 15th, 1861.

''The Convention. - The returns leave no reasonable doubt that the Convention has been voted down by an immense majority. This was a result not looked for. This object was gained by a systematic cry, that if you vote for '' Convention " you are for immediate secession - he who is for the Union must vote '* Xo Convention."

The practical result is, that by voting ''No Convention" the people have deprived themselves of the power of having a voice, at this time, in the settlement of the questions at issue - the}' have for the present taken it from themselves and left it in the hands of the politicians - the last place where it ought to be.

But this is not all. The Legislature, as is well known, sent on commissioners to the Border State Convention, now being held in Washington city, the vote of ''No Convention" is equivalent to say-

The arm ot our Commissioners is paralyzecl. The Black Republicans can say to them, ' what are yon here for now ? Since the Legislature sent you the people themselves have spoken, they are for standing still ; they are content with the existing state of things ; your Commissions are revoked; we are not bound to listen to your declarations that there must be no civil war; that there sliould be a tinal and peaceable settlement of all matters in issue; the verdict of the people is against lohat you ask - they are for no action - for standing still - for letting things drift on as they are - your p)eople are satisfied vrith us, and the policy on which we have declared iv^ loill administer the Government." "

It is seen that this rebel editor in this extract himself strongly testifies to the truth of the position we have just taken in regard to this election. Admitting the fact then, why did not he for the future act consistently with his own admission ? Admitting that such was the sovereign will of the people, expressed as he says by an " immense majority," why did he, traitor like, fight it for the next three years or as long as he could with all his might ? Why did not he, why did not Governor Harris, why did not this rebel Legislature, with whom this proposition for a State Convention originated, and why did not the minority in the whole State submit to this sovereign will of the people, instead of flying together in a foul conspiracy against it and trampling it under their treasonable feet ?

One statement in this extract so manifestly betrays either the stupidity or dishonest}^ or both, of this editor, that we cannot resist the temptation to give it a passing notice. He says, "The practical result is, that by voting 'No Convention' the people have deprived themselves of the power of having a voice, at this time, in settling the c[uestions at issue - they have for the present taken it from themselves and left it in the hands of the politicians - the last place where it ought to be." Just as though the sovereign voice of the people was no settlement of this question at all.

The substance of the above statement amounts to this : The vote of the people of Tennessee which settled and disposed of the question of secession in her case, forever deprived them of tlie power to settle it. The vote or act of the people which took it out of the hands of the polititN BRADLEY COU??TY, EAST TENNESSEE. Si cians put it into the hands of the politicians. The selfsame vote or act of the people which took the question {7ito their hands put it out of their hands.

A Supreme Judge from whose bench there is no appeal, receives a difficult case from the lower courts ; and after giving it a thorough and impartial trial, delivers his verdict upon it, and this verdict is a final disposition of tlie case. This Cleveland editor, however, starts up and says, Judge you have committed a grave error ! You have forever deprived yourself of the power to settle that question. You have forever taken it out of your own hands and put it in the hands of the lawyers, " the last place where it ought to be." This is exactly the position of this rebel editor in the above statement.

From the fact that this February election was a fair expression of the will of the people, it followed that this dictated and pointed out the subsequent duty of the minority. It was the duty of the minority to submit to this decision, and allow the State to be governed by the principles it announced. Even more than this, it was the duty of the parties and individuals composing this minority to become co-operators with the majority in carrying out these principles, by exerting their influence to resist rebellion and discourage revolt among the people of Tennessee. This was just what the people at this election decided to be the duty of all parties and individuals in the State, particularly those into whose hands they had entrusted the reins of authority from the governor to the lowest municipal officer among the people.

The great misfortune of the majority at this election, and the great misfortune of the State was, that nearly all her politicians and incumbents of office at the time, were among the minority. As another writer remarks, " The secession or rebellion of Tennessee was a rebellion of office-holders and politicians." The people arrayed themselves on the side of the Government; office-holders and politicians arrayed themselves on the side of the rebellion.

authorit}^, conspired with each other in public as well as in private, to defeat the wishes of the people. Hundreds of instances might be given in confirmation of this statement.

The writer of these pages arrived in Nashville five days after that city surrendered to General Buell in the winter of 1862. While there he obtained various items of important information from Union men respecting the secession of Tennessee. It was their universal testimony that the failure of this project for a "Convention" created no little excitement and no little dissatisfaction among the secessionists in Nashville. For days after the election companies of them were seen excitedly conversing upon the subject on the streets and in public places throughout the city. Among one of these companies an individual named More, a very active and strenuous Southern-rights man, was heard to use, in substance, the following language: "This election is a disgrace to the State, and Tennessee is disgracing herself by longer remaining in the Union. We will see Governor Harris, and he shall

State, we will put her out at all hazards." This remark was heard by Mr. John L. Stewart, a truthful and reliable Union man well known in Nashville, having been a citizen for many years, though now deceased.

The active hostility thus exhibited by More and his rebel crowd to this election will be recognized by Tennessee Union men as the identical spirit that prevailed against it everywhere among rebels throughout the State, and as that feeling which originated the measures immediately commenced by those in power to force the people into the vortex of rebellion. Agreeably with his own feelings, and prompted by this spirit among the rebels, Isham G. Harris, then Governor of Tennessee, convened his Legislature on the 25th of April, a little more than two months after this rebel proposition for a convention had been voted down by the people.

The President of the United States - elected according to the forms of the Constitution, but upon principles openly hostile to its provisions - having wantonly inaugurated an internecine war upon the people of the slave and non-slaveholding States, I have convened you again at the seat of Government, for the purpose of enabling j'ou to take such action as will most likely contribute to the defence of our rights, the preservation of our liberties, the sovereignty of the State, and the safety of our people; all of which are now in ibiminent peril by the usurpations of the authorities at AVashington, and the unscrupulous fanaticism which runs riot throughout the Northern States.

The Avar thus inaugurated is likely to assume an importance nearly, if not fully, equal, to the struggle of our revolutionary fathers, in their patriotic efforts to resist the usurpations and throw off the tyrannical yoke of the English Government; a war the duration of whicli. and the good or evil which must result from it, depends entirely, in my judgment, upon the readiness with which the citizens of the South harmonize as one people, and the alacrity with which they respond to the demands of patriotism.

I do not think it necessary to recapitulate, at this late hour, the long train of abuses to which the people of Tennessee, and our sister States of the South, have been subjected by the anti-republican spirit that has for many years been manifesting itself in that section, and which has at last declared itself our open and avowed enemy. In the message which I addressed to you at j'our called session in Januarj' last, these things were somewhat elaborately referred to. as constituting, in my judgment, the amplest reason for considering ourselves in imminent danger, and as requiring such action on the part of the Legislature as would place tlie State in an attitude for defence, Avhenever the momentous crisis should be forced upon us; and. also, as presenting to the North the strongest argumeni for jDeace. and, if possible, securing a reconstruction of the Union, thus already dissolved bj' the most authoritative, formal, and matured action of a portion of the slaveholding States.

The position of Gov. Harris throughout this message, and particularly those in this extract show the extent to which he disregarded the will, and disobeyed tlie instructions of the people of Tennessee, delivered to him at this February election. The very first words of this message reveal Gov. Harris as a traitor. He says, "The President of the United States, elected according to the forms of the Constitution, but upon principles openly hostile to its provisions." Now, which was the better judge of this matter. Gov. Harris or the people ? Who was the final authority upon the subject, he or the people? Mr. Lincoln was elected President on the 8th of November, 1860; and the people had from this time till the 9th of February,

1861, a period of three months, in which to consider and decide for themselves, whether Mr. Lincohis' election was or was not in accordance with the provisions of the Constitution. They did consider this subject, and at the expiration of this i)eriod delivered their opinion to the effect that this statement of Gov. Harris is false, deciding that the election of Mr. Lincoln was constitutional and binding upon them as a State ; and that they were not only Avilling but anxious to remain under the old Government, and accept its administration at his hands during the next four years.

There is not on record a more absolute and insulting case of official despotism and grinding usurpation than this act of Gov. Harris, in convening his Legislature and instructing its members as he did in this message.

" Therefore. I I'espectfnlly recommend the perfecting of an oi'diiianee by the General Assembly, formally declaring the Independence of the State of Tennessee of the Federal Union, Venonncing its authority, and reassuming eacli and exery function belonging to a separate sovereignty."

We have seen that this Legislature convened on the 25th of April, 1861. In obedience to the above recommendation respecting an ordinance of secession, among the first acts of this body we find the following :

United States Of America

First. We, the people of the State of Tennessee, waiving any expression of opinion as to the abstract doctrine of secession, but asserting the right, as a free and independent people, to alter, reform, or abolish, our form of Government in such manner as we think proper, do ordain and declare that all the laws and ordinances by wliich the State of Tennessee became a member of the Federal Union of tlie United States of America, are hereby abrogated and annulled, and that all obligations on our part be withdrawn therefrom ; and we do hereby resume all the rights, functions, and powers, which by any of said laws and ordinances were convej^ed to the Government of the United States, and absolve ourselves from all the obligations, restraints, and duties incurred thereto; and do herebj' henceforth become a free, sovereign and independent State.

requires members of the General Assembly, and all officers, civU and military, to take an oath to support the Constitution of the United States be. and the same are hereby abrogated and annulled ; and all parts of the Constitution of the State of Tennessee, makino^ citizonnhip of the United States a qualification for office, and recognizing the Constitution of the United States as the supreme law of this State, are in like manner abrogated and annulled.

JOINT RESOLUTION TO APPOINT COMMISSIONERS FROM THE STATE OF TENNESSEE TO CONFER WITH THE AUTHORITIES OF THE CONFEDERATE STATES, IN REGARD TO ENTERING INTO A MILITARY LEAGUE.

Bcsolved by the General Assembly of the State of Tennessee, That the Governor be, and he is hereby authorized and requested to appoint three Commissioners on the part of Tennessee, to enter into a Militar}^ League with the authorities of the Confederate States, and with the authorities of such other slaveholding States as may wish to enter into it; having in view the protection and defence of the entire South against the war that is now being carried on against it.

Message Of The Governor

By virtue of the authority of your joint resolution, adopted on the 1st day of May inst., I appointed Gustavus A. Henry, of the county of Montgomery, Archibald O. W. Totten, of the county of Madison, and Washington Barrow, of the county of Davidson, "Commissioners on the part of Tennessee, to enter into a Military League with the authorities of the Confederate States, and with the authorities of such other slaveholding States as may wish to enter into it ; having in view the protection and the defence of the entii-e South against the war that is now being carried on against it."

The said Commissioners met the Hon. Henry "W. Hilliard, the accredited representative of the Confederate States, at Xashville, on this day, and have agreed upon and executed a Military League between the State of Tennessee and the Confederate States of America, subject, however, to the ratification of the two Governments ; one of the'duplicate originals of which I herewith transmit for your ratification or rejection. For many cogent and obtious reasons, unneces- * sary to be rehearsed to j'ou, I respectfully recommend the ratitica-' tioii of this League at the earliest practicable moment. \QTy IJespectfiill}',

Isham G, Harris

The State of Tennessee looking to a speedy admission into the Confederacy established by the Confederate States of America, in accordance with the Constitution for the Provisional Government of said States, enters into the following temporary Convention, Agreement and Military League, with the Confederate States, for the purpose of meeting pressing exigencies affecting the common rights, interests, and safety of said States, and said Confederacy.

First. 'Until the said State shall become a member of said Confederacy according to the Constitution of both powers, the whole military*^ force, and military operations, offensive and defensive of said State, in the impending conflict with the United States, shall be under the chief control and direction of the President of the Confederate States, upon the same basis, principles and footing, as if said State were now, and during the interval, a member of said Confederacj% said force, together with that of the Confederate States, to be employed for the common defence.

Second. The State of Tennessee will, upon becoming a member of said Confederacy under tke permanent constitution of said Confederate States, if the same shall occur, turn over to said Confederate States, all the public property acquired from the United States, on the same terms, and in the same manner as the other States of said Confederacy have done in like cases.

Third. Whatever expenditures of money, if any, the said State of Tennessee shall make before she becomes a member of said Confederacy, shall be met and provided for by the Confederate States.

This Convention entered into and agreed, in the city of Xashville, Tennessee, on the seventh day of 3Iay. A. D., 1861. by Henry W. Ililliard, the duly authorized commissioner, to act in the matter of the Confederate States, and Gustavus A. Henry. Archibald O. W. Totten. and Washington Barrow, commissioners duly authorized in like manner for the State of Tennessee - the whole subject to the approval and ratification of the proper authorities of both Governments respectively.

Joint Resolution Ratifying The League

A. Henry, and Washington Barrow, Commissioners on the part of the State of Tennessee, and H. W. Hilliard, Commissioner on the part of the Confederate States of America, subject to the conlirmation of the two Governments :

Be it therefore resolved by the General Assembly of the State of Tennessee, That said league be in all respects ratified and confirmed, and the said General Assembly hereby pledges the faith ana honor of the State of Tennessee to the faithful observance of the terms and conditions of said league.

We, the people of Tennessee, solemnly impressed by the perils which surround us, do hereby adopt and ratify the Constitution of the Provisional Government of the Confederate States of America, ordained and established at Montgomery, Alabama, on the 8th day of Februar3^ 1861, to be in force during the existence thereof, or until guch a time as we may supersede it by the adoption of a permanent Constitution.

Sec. G. Be it further enacted, That those in favor of the adoption of said Provisional Constitution, and thereby securing to Tennessee equal representation in the deliberations and councils of the Confedei-ate States, shall have written or printed on their ballots the word ''Bepresentation; those opposed, the words "iVo BepresentationP

Sec. 7. Be it further enacted, That in the event the people shall adopt the Constitution of the Provisional Government of the Confederate States, at the election herein ordered, it shall be the duty of the Governor, forthwith to issue writs of election for delegates to represent the State of Tennessee in the said Provisional Government; that the State shall be represented by as many delegates as it was entitled to members of Congress to the Congress of the United States of America, who shall be elected from the several Congressional Districts as now established by law, in the mode and manner now prescribed for the election of members of the Congress of the United States.

At the commencement of this chapter we assumed that Tennessee rebels were not only rebels against the General Government, but also rebels against the government of their own State.

one case gave a majority of G4,114 forbidding the secession of the State under all circumstances ; in the other a majority of nearly 31,000, not only against secession but declaring that no occasion whatever existed for a State Convention on this or any other subject then agitating the country ; that Tennessee had no grievances to complain of, was satisfied with the General Government, and proposed to remain in the Union as she was.

Second, we have seen, that those Avho on the same day were found in the minority, or in other words found to be the rebel element of the State, immediately rebelled against this decision, setting on foot all possible unfair means and measures forcibly to set aside the people's A^erdict, and officially hurled Tennessee out of the Union. By overwhelming majorities the people of the State declare themselves to be loyal; instantly, however. Gov. Harris and his legislature, in secret conclave, assume themselves to be the people, convert the power entrusted in their hands into a law of brute force, blind and gag every Union man whom they cannot bribe, take the majority by the throat, and in three months from the time the people expressed their will to the contrary, league Tennessee with the rebellion.

Language cannot express facts, nor can facts prove any proposition if the above is not the logical showing of the case of this election. The proposition, therefore, is incontrovertibly made out that the rebels of Tennessee were not only rebels against the General Government, but rebels against the government of their OAvn State.

Viewing the proceedings above described in the same light that we have considered them, the people of East Tennessee, through their delegates, assembled at Greenville, Green county, on the 17th of June, 1861, with a view, among other things, to petition their Legislature for the privilege of East Tennessee to withdraw as a part of the State, and become independent, that she might thereby not only avoid actual conflict between herself and its secession portions, but avoid complicity with their treason, and especially escape being swept with the rest of the State into the vortex of secession and rebellion. The following is substantially an extract from the views of this body expressed in regard to the conduct of Governor Harris and his legislature, developed and examined in this chapter: liesohed. That the action of the State Leo-islature, in passiiif^ a declaration of independence, and forming- a military league with the Southern Confederacy, was unconstitutional and not bind ivg upon the loyal citizens of the State.

Provenance

Text from History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.