BlockBefore

Bradley County, Tennessee - Chapter 8: Captain ^vm. L. Brown and the Fifth District Election, 1866

From History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866. 4,385 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

Contents

2 sections

The section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.

The text

4,385 words

Machine-read from scans of History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Chapter 8: Captain ^vm. L. Brown and the Fifth District Election

After the rebel forces which had attempted to capture Col. Clift on Sails Creek, had returned to their respective vicinities, their organizations, generally, were not only preserved intact, but rebel military rule from that time, especially, was instituted in a manner plainlj^ to indicate the fate of those who dared to oppose, as well as of those who failed to comply with rebel demands.

Two rebel regiments were raised in Bradley and adjoining counties, both, we believe, going into camp on Bradley county fair grounds, there to remain while recruiting and fitting out, grounds about a mile from the village of Cleveland. One of these regiments was the 4th Tennessee Cavalry, the other the 36th Tennessee Infantry. The infantry regiment, from the fact that it was armed principally with squirrel rifles and double barrel shotguns, many of which were forcibly taken from Union citizens, was by waj^ of jest denominated the squirrel origade. After its completion this regiment was ordered into the vicinity of Knoxville. The cavalry regiment, which was under the command of Col. Rogers of Bradley county, was finally ordered to Knoxville also.

among the first. This cavalry regiment left for Knoxville toward the last of Jannary, 1862, being in camp at Cleveland about three months ; this being the period in which the reign of rebel terror in that section rose to its zenith.

In entering fully upon the history of the rebellion in Bradley, we propose to introduce and briefly sketch, the character of one of the most prominent actors in the drama, Capt. Wm. L. Brown, one of the officers mentioned in the above extract ; but more commonly known as Capt. Bill Brown of Bradley.

Unquestionabh^, this Cai>t. Brown was one of the most notorious characters, in many respects, of all the rebel leaders that figured in East Tennessee. Being admirably fitted by nature to execute the dirty work planned by others, with this ability made constantly restive by a natural feeling of great self-importance, he w^as, of all others, the most blustering, insulting, and overbearing, the most reliable to be entrusted with the meanest and most disgraceful enterprizes. He was a natural liar, as well as a natural thief, and so far as moral forecast is concerned, the next thing to a natural fool ; religiously as well as otherwise a practical hj^pocrite, a base tyrant and a vile deceiver. Altogether, his composition, as a human being, such, that his greatest earthly happiness flowed from the privilege of being a dictatorial or governing spirit in the midst of just such a rebellion, as that in which he acted so conspicuous and disgraceful a part. Never was he so deliriously happy ; never so emphatically in a world of ecstacy, as wdien in Bradley county, swaggering in all the license and riot of his commission, he displayed himself as Capt. Brow^n of the rebel army.

At the opening of the rebellion. Brown perhaps was forty years of age, had been a resident of the county from an early period, was a member of the Cumberland Presbyterian Church, by trade a tailor, having followed the business of this craft for a number of years in Cleveland, but never, it appears, relied upon it as the permanent business of his life. His first surplus funds, instead of being invested the enlargement and permanency of of his business, were prostituted to the work of shaving notes, and being invested in loans at high rates of usury, and in otherwise taking advantage of the unfortunate, by which means, he soon won the name of being one of the most hard-hearted money dealers and swindling speculators in the country.

As a solitary instance among many that might be given of Browns innate villiany, we noted down from the recital of one of the most prominent citizens of Cleveland, the following case.

many readers in the county will be instantly called to mind as the person referred to, had failed, by the regular proceeds of his industry, to procure means for the licjuidation of a debt, which was of the utmost importance to him to pay at the appointed time. Money matters were close, and being unsuccessful in his first efforts to borrow the amount, as a last resort he applied to Brown. Brown pretended to be out of money, whined about his own poverty, complained of the hard times, scolded about dilatory creditors, etc., but told him to call again in a short time, and he would give him an answer. Agreeably to appointment the man waited upon Brown the second time. Brown informed him that times were so hard that he had no money to loan, and that if he had obligations on the best of men, he could take them only at such and such discounts. The terms amounted to a swindle, but the man was compelled to have the money or suffer infinitely more, and consequently he submitted to Brown's proposals. Brown took the notes, counted out the man a part of the money, saying that was all he had with him at the time, but the rest should be forthcoming without fail before he would need it. Having not the least idea that Brown, by this maneuver, intended to swindle him, and knowing that he was able at any time to get the remainder, made no particular objections. The next day, however, or as soon as the time drew near, that the whole amount coming from Brown should be in his possession, the man called to procure it ; but to his astonishment Brown was per- fectty unapproachable on the subjet, coldly and indifferently pretending that he had been disappointed in collecting ; and that he could do nothing more about it at present. The man enquired what he meant by such conduct, and if lie considered the extent of the injury he was inflicting upon him by such a rascally forfeiture of his word. Notwithstanding these appeals, Brow^n gave his victim no satisfaction ; but left him to extricate himself from the dilemma into which he had led him as best he could. This, however, w^as not the sequel of the transaction. The injured man, as a matter of course prosecuted Browm for the debt, and for aught we know for his villain}^ also; but one way and another Brown staved off the issue, out of the residue of his money, till long after the notes he delivered to Brown had matured, and Brown had collected on them both principal and interest.

Taking this transaction as a basis of Brown's moral character as a private citizen before the vrar, none will be greatly surprised at the following developements in this chapter in regard to his conduct as a public man and a civil oflicer, nor at the future developments in this work of his character as a soldier and a rebel officer.

Although it Avill place us for the time in advance of some parts of our narrative, yet as we have been sketching Oapt. Brown's private character, that the reader may without too much surprise meet the facts in the history of his military career ; and as this election illustrates Brown as a public man, also as a civil officer, and as it reveals the animus of the rebellion in this section at the time, we shall introduce it here.

As already stated, Brow^n entered the rebel seiwice in the fall of 1861. His military career was short. In June, 1862, he resigned his commission, becoming once more a private citizen, and residing upon his farm with his family in the iifth district, about three miles from Cleveland.

Early in the spring of 1863 an election was to take i)lace in that district, at which, among other officers, a Justice of the Peace was to be chosen. Brown was the rebel candidate for this office against Mr. Hiram Smith of the Union party. The Union party in this district, as well perhaps as in others at this time, was considerable^ in the ascendancy : and a fair trial at this election could have resulted only in the success of the Union candidate. Being aware of this, in conformity with the general character of the rebellion, Brown and his friends must make preparations to counteract this Union advantage. At this time the Vvdiole of East Tennessee was writhing in the jaws' of a rebel military despotism, by the aid of which power it was easy for rebel citizens to control elections as well as all other matters throughout the country.

Mr. James Donahoo, one of the most bitter and relentless rebels in the district, working in the interest of Brown, managed to get himself appointed by the Sheriif of the county as President or Conductor of this election. The duties of this officer are to open and close the polls at the proper hours, to see that the balloting is legal, and that the election throughout is held strictly in accordance with law and in a manner to preserve inviolate to all parties the right of the elective franchise. Utterly ignoring these obligations, however, Donahoo, after procuring his appointment, connived with the rebel military authorities at Cleveland, stealthily effecting an arrangement, perhaps the day before the election, that all under the age of forty-five who appeared at the polls must have permits from the Provost Marshal to do so. Then, as a clincher to this, news of this arrangement was to be immediately circulated among the rebels, that Brow^n's friends could have ample time to get their permits ; but kept a profound secret from tlie Union men till the moment of the opening of the polls. The election was at the Blue Springs school house, just five miles from Cleveland.

Brown and Donahoo were old and crafty performers in the work of rebellion, and in this particular case engineered their scheme through with so much stealth and skill that it succeeded entirely to their own wishes, allowing them to have entirely their own way at the polls, whisky and all. Every rebel voter perhaps in the district having been secretly posted in regard to the treacherous game, was promptly at the polls with his permit concealed in his pocket, ready to fulfill the farcical obligation of being there by military authority. In regard to the Union voters, however, just the contrary was their condition. Not a Union voter in the district, knew that it was his duty to obtain a permit to attend the election till the balloting commenced. To spring this villainous trap, however, with additional certainty, Donahoo, although sworn to open the polls at nine o'clock in the morning, delayed to do so, purposely dallying away time, till between eleven and twelve in the day. Some Union men present asserted that it was even after this time when the polls were opened. This put it beyond the power of the Union voters to comply with Mr. Donahoo's military regulation. Not one in ten, unprepared as they vvere with animals, at that late hour could reach Cleveland, a distance of five miles, obtain his permit, and return in time to vote.

By the success, therefore, of this infernal scheme, every Union man in the district under the age of forty-five was debarred from voting, for Mr. Donahoo refused to allow any of them even to approach the polls for the want of these permits, having in the meantime brought with him a guard of six rebel soldiers whom he had already stationed at the door to enforce these abominable regulations. As a matter of course the Union voters were indignant at suf-h treatment, some of w^hom expostulated with Mr. Donahoo and Capt. Brown, asserting that this regulation should have been published to all the day before, that they as well as the rebels could have been prepared. These expostulations, however, were met by these men with all that insolence and positive abuse that one would expect from those endeavoring to carry an election by such measures.

A part of these Union voters, compelled to do so by the rebel authorities, were then at work, not as soldiers, but simply as employees of the Confederate government, on tlie railroads, getting timber, procuring wood, etc., all of them, we believe, within the District; and Mr. Donahoo in answer to their complaints replied, that having left their work to attend that election without permits, they were all deserters, rebel deserters, and ought to be reported and arrested as such.

Most of these Union employees were at work near the polls, a quarter and a half mile from them, and had they all been permitted to vote, as they had a right to do, could have done so with the loss of but very little time, without going out of the District. Many of them would have voted during the hour of recess at noon, without being absent from their w^ork at all. Besides, doubtless, none of the men did leave their work without the consent of their gang boss, hence their absence was no injury to his business. Yet, notwithstanding these i)alliating circumstances, Mr. Donahoo calls these men deserters, simply because they w^ere there without permits. Inasmuch then, as this was Mr. Donahoo's own position, voluntarily taken, he cannot object to having his own conduct brought forward and put to the test by it. No man can complain when he and his theories are tried by rules w^hicli he has made himself.

Now, if these men were deserters, because without permits they left their work to attend this election, then by the same rule, they would have been deserters, had they left their work and gone five miles to Cleveland to get the permits he required of them. And not only so, but the latter would have been a much stronger case of desertion than the former. In this case some of the men - those whose work was a mile or two south of the school house - would have been compelled to travel from five to seven miles to Cleveland, entirely out of the district, and back, being absent from their work perhaps the whole day, while, as we have seen, in the first instance, none of them had to go out of the district. Many of them

Iiad to walk but a short distance, necessarily ])eing absent from their work but a few minutes. Some of these men were but a few yards from their work when Donahoo was accusing them of desertion. According to Mr. Donahoo's own interpretation of desertion, therefore, it was imijossible for these Union voters to comply Avith his regulation, not only without being guilty of desertion simi)h% but without being guilty of it in a much more aggi^avated sense, than they were in coming to the election as they did. Even Mr. Hiram Smith himself. Brown's opponent, had he at the time been an employee of the Confederate government, could not have attended that election and cast a vote for himself without first being guilty of desertion, and laying himself liable to be arrested lual tried for the crime. Had these Union voters by some accident discovered Mr. Donahoo's military clap-trap in time, and early on the morning of the election, left their work and hurried to Cleveland for their permits, very likely Donahoo or Brown, or both, would have met them at the Provost Marshal's and had them all arrested and punished for desertion. According to Donahoo's own theory, he could have done so. The management of this election, therefore, was such as to drive a portion of the Union voters of the district, effectually from the polls, or drive them into desertion, and consequently to subject them to arrest and punishment by the rebel authorities. There is no escape from this conclusion. All the rebels in Bradley county, with the sophistical editor of the Banoier thrown in, can never extricate these men from this humiliating and disgraceful dilemma. Little did Donahoo, Brown and Shugart, think at the time, that their villainy was thus preparing a liook to be put into their own jaws, and by which they were to be historically drawn up and left exposed and helplessly dangling before the whole country, a disgrace to themselves and their posterity, while their names are known in Bradley county.

The above, however, is not the whole of the rebel history of this election. Major D. G. McCuUey, a Union man of the district, and living near the polls, was, as a mere pretense to fairness, put on the bench as one of the judges, Dr. Shugart also of the district, and a Mr. Reed of Georgia, both relentless rebels, being the other two. At tlie discovery of Mr. Donahoo's military valve for shutting off Union votes, Major McCulley promptly entered his protest against it, and as other abuses and violations of law developed themselves through the day, raised his voice against them, also. At the closing of the polls, he told Mr. Donahoo and the other judges that Union men had been prevented from voting by intrigue and the presence of rebel bayonets; that as they had conducted the election, throughout, it was not only illegal but a positive fraud; that consequently, he should not sign the scrolls, but, as one of the judges, send up his protest against the w^hole affair. Donahoo and the other judges attempted to win him over but without effect; and after exhausting their powers of persuasion their patience gave way, and threats were employed instead. He was told that if he did not sign the scrolls he would be arrested by the military. One of Donahoo's guards, one that had indulged too freely in artificial stimulants to his patriotism, also was allowed to abuse the Major as a Lincolnite, a traitor, a tory, and so on. He swore that he w^ould sooner run his bayonet through him than to do anything else. The Major, however, was not more easily frightened at their threats, than cajoled by their importunities, persisting in his refusal to append his name to the scrolls ; and the returns went up under his protest as one of the judges of the election.

In justice it should be stated here, that two others of this guard, while this contest was going on, interfered in Major McCully's behalf, rebuking the drunken guard for the abuse he was heaping upon him, and saying that the Major had as good a right to his opinion as the other judges had to theirs ; that he had a right to express his opinion, that as to the election, they believed the Major was right in holding that the election had not been fair, and that they were sorry it had been necessary for them to have anything to do with it.

Under the circumstances, only six Union votes were cast, and only sixteen rebel votes, notwitlistanding an unusual effort was put forth by the rebels to get their friends to the polls. By actual count, at the time, of the Union voters in the district, it was demonstrated that liad the election been legal, the Union majority would at least have been two to one.

Mr. Hiram Smith, Brown's opponent, discovering early in the day the intervention and proscription inaugurated, and so insolently enforced by Donahoo, considering himself insulted as well as disgraced by such company, immediately left the polls in disgust, advising his friends to do so also, and save themselves the shame of attending such a farce. In fact Mr. Smith objected in the beginning to having his name announced as a candidate in opposition to such a man as Wm. L. Brown.

One would suppose that the foregoing combination of disgraceful means would have been thought sufficient by these rebels, not only to carry this election, but as comprising all the corruption and wickedness that one occasion of the kind ought to bear. The fact, however, was otherwise. Even the exhilarating effects of whisky, as well as the temptings of bribery were added to complete the list of abominations with which these rebels were polluting the polls of the fifth district.

Early in the day. Brown procured of Mr. Joseph Henderson, then manufacturing liquor not far from the polls, a quantity of the needful article, which was slyly, though liberally distributed by Brown to all that would accept of it, at the election, to induce them to vote for him, and to prepare them to more effectively electioneer in his favor. The first supply being soon exliausted, Brown arranged with Mr. Henderson to furnish the article through the day as it was needed. The contract was faithfully kept by ^Ii\ Henderson till the closing of the polls. Brown's money footing the bills. In addition to this contemptible business, Brown offered this same Mr. Henderson a bribe of five dollars for his ballot. Mr. Henderson was a Union man, and Brown's offer was indignantly refused. No ways abashed at this, Brown instantly raised his bid to twentyfive dollars, providing Mr. Henderson would, besides giving him his own vote, interest himself and secure him the votes of certain other parties. This proposal, however, was as quickly rejected as the other.

The polls being finally closed, Brown was declared elected ; and although the returns went up under tlie protest of Major McCulley as heretofore given, yet this Ijroved no imj)ediment to Brown's claim, not even eliciting the least inquiry, or causing the least hesitation. His name was immediately forwarded to Governor Harris as the legally elected candidate, and forthwith his credentials were returned installing him as the lawfully elected and authoritative justice of the peace in the fifth district. He held and exercised his ofl[ice until he fled before our army to Dixie in the winter 1864.

Arrest Of Mr. Samuel Wyrick

We will now follow Capt. Brown for a moment as a civil officer, and view the harmony that existed between the means by which he obtained his office and the manner ill which he subsequently distributed its justice to the people. Having opened his office for business in Cleveland, soon after he obtained his commission from the suiDreme authority of the State, Brown ascertained through some of his rebel advisers, or through some of his rebel spies, that Mr. Samuel Wyrick of the ninth district, a Union man, had purchased for a sick woman, the wife of a Union soldier then in the Northern Army, a quart of spirits as a medicine. Brown kept the matter quiet, but watched his opportunity to ensnare Mr. Wyrick, remembering, perhaps, the amount of whisky fees it had cost him to obtain his sacred office. In a few days the opportunity presented itself, when Brown issued a process against Mr. Wyrick, and had him arrested and brought to trial for the ofience of buying spirits for a sick woman. The process was founded upon some temporary regulation established by the rebel military authorities, either as a specific tax on sales and purchases, or as a pro- liibitory regulation in regaixl to the sale of spirits m the country. Mr. Wyrick acknowledged that he purchased the liquor, but explained that it was for ano'ther person whowas actually in want of it as a medicine, and that he was. ignorant at the time, that in such a case he was violating any law, or that any tax was imposed on such purchases^ sajang, that if he had violated any law, he was ready to make restitution to any proper extent. Brown, how^ever, Avas in no mood for compromises, or for yielding a particle of the advantage in his hands, and at once fixed the penalty to the extreme end of the law, mulucting Mr. Wyrick in a fine wdth costs, amounting to S106, wliich had to be paid forthwith. Mr. Yv^yrick not having that amount in his pocket at the moment, Brown seized upon a quantity of goods in his possession, which he had just purchased in Cleveland, principally for other parties, and for which he had paid S140 in cash. In addition to this. Brown attempted to levy upon the horse which Mr. Wyrick rode into town, but Union friendssmuggled the animal out of his reach until Mr. Wyrick finally escaped with him to his home, some eight miles from Cleveland, where he had to settle with his neighbors for his loss of their goods as best he could.

Thus was Mr. Wyrick robbed by this infernal brute,, and that upon the hypocritical pretence only, that he had violated a law which the v^retch, but a short time before, had so shamefully violated himself in order to obtain the ofiice, by the authority of which he now prosecuted and fined Mr. AVyrick. The facts of this transaction were furnished by Mr. Wj^rick himself, and may therefore be relied upon. They will not be doubted by those who know Mr. Wyrick. All the information in regard to the election narrated in this chapter, was furnished by the most reliable Union men in the fifth district, and althougli in some instances we may have used strong language - for none other is suitable in describing such abuses, yet it is believed, that as a general description the abuses of this case have not been exaggerated, and that Union men who w^ere i:)resent, and saw for themselves all the facts.

In fact this account is not the aggregate of the villainy and demonstrations of treason connected with this affair. Dr. Siiugart in particular, at this election, availed himself of the opportunity to falsify and berate the Government, stating in substance that the Government had become an engine of oppression, persecuting and grinding the Southern States generally; that in view of the prohibitory enactments of Congress in regard to the institution of slavery, the Union ought to have been overthrown and completely demolished twenty years before, etc.

Such delineations of the sej^arate, distinct rebel crimes and abuses in the South are tedious and laborious. Tliey require great patience and industry in the collection as well as in the arrangement of the facts, but we deem them of the utmost importance, for nothing else will save to history, or place before the country in its true light, the studied vdckedness and unrelieved depravity of the rebellion.

Provenance

Text from History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.