BlockBefore

Bradley County, Tennessee - Chapter 9: Union People of Bradley Robbed of Their Private Arms, 1866

From History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866. 3,099 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.

The text

3,099 words

Machine-read from scans of History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.

Introductory to this chapter we will give an extract from the Cleveland Banner^ taken from an issue dated July 19, 1861. The extract closes with a sentence of editorial advice which we take the liberty to put in italics. Unquestionably this editorial was the first instance in which the idea of robbing the Union people of Bradley of their i^rivate arms, was thrown, broadcast, before the rebel masses of East Tennessee. The extract is as follows : has issued a proclamation calling on the State and county ofticers to collect up all the arms, rifles and shot guns new or old, in or out of order, and send them to Jackson, the capital of the State, where they may be repaired and held in readiness for the use of the soldiers. lie also notifies all citizens to arm themselves with double-barrel shot guns, and hold themselves in readiness at an hour's notice. By these means the State will be in possession of a large quantity of good arms that might otherwise be useless. We hope the proper authorities vnll folloio up the move of Gov. Fettus.^^

We are not in possession of the exact date at which this "move in the right direction" commenced in Bradley; but from other dates in our possession of the times at which individuals had their guns taken from them by Brown and his men, it appears that the movement was in progress in September, 1861. The work was continued through the following winter, or as long as rebel soldiers could find Union guns to confiscate.

In gathering in these guns, as in every other rebel enterprise within the county, Capt. Brown and his men were the most conspicuous. In many instances Brown issued orders for these arms to be brought into camp by their owners ; and in some cases this was done, the owners hoping by a ready compliance to have their property returned, or to receive its value at some future day. Most of the Union guns, however, collected by the rebels in

Bradley were forcibly taken by Brown, or at his instance, his men being sent through the county in squads for this purpose. Everything in the shape of a fire-arm, from the finished rifle to the most insignificant revolver or pocketpistol, was taken from Union men in this scheme of rebel plundering, Everj^thing in the shape of weapons were taken - old sabres, bowie-knives, and even common butcher-knives were taken. Hundreds of these arms were no better than elder pop-guns for military x)urposes - were never used by the rebels as such - but were wasted and wantonly appropriated to the amusement and gratification of those whose reckless villainy had made this property an object of plunder.

From the most reliable information on this subject, it appears that at least one thousand arms, of all grades, were taken from the Union people in Bradley in this abominable raid upon personal rights. We make this statement, feeling confident that many Union men in the county, who were in a position to judge, will regard this estimate as below the actual figures. We are aware that rebels will argue that these guns were collecle 1 in obedience to an order issued by Gov. Harris. Tliis excuse was made by the rebels when they were engaged in the robbery. It was made by Brown himself to Mrs. Harle, of Cleveland, just before his attempt to murder her husband, an account of which affair Avill be found in the latter part of this chapter.

Fortunately we are able to produce the order from Gov. Harris under the authority of wJiicli this master-piece of rebel iniquity was perpetrated upon the Union people of Bradley. It reads as follows :

'- You are hereby requested to issue to each constable in your respective counties an order requiring them to malce dilio-ent inquirj' at each house in his civil district for muskets, baj'onets. rifles, swords, and pistols belonging to the State of Tennessee, to take them into i)Ossession and deliver them to you. * A reward of one dollar will be paid to the constable for each musket and bayonet, or rifle, and flfty cents for each sword or pistol thus reclaimed. You will forward the arms thus obtained, at public expense to the military authorities at Knoxville, Xashville, or Memphis, as may be most convenient ; and will

Now, whatever might have been the concealed pin-pose of Gov. Harris in the i)reniises, this order sufficient!}^ explains itself. It instructs the clerks of the county courts, and the county constables, and these officers only, to execute its requirements. Besides, the ^^ muskets, bayonets') riiies., Sc, Jjelonging to the State of Tennessee^''' were those to be taken, not those that vrere the private property of individuals. These constables vrere to be paid for all the arms '' lelonging to tlie State " that they could thus " reclaini^^ not for all that they could steeil and press from the Union people throughout Tennessee. It is incontrovertible that this order was no license whatever for these constables, or the rebel military, or any other class of men or officers to touch private property. Arms, for instance, that individuals, who Vv'ere or ]iad been members of independent comi}anies, had drawn from the State, and had not been returned, were those, and those only, that this order, ostensibly, at least, contemplated procuring. Hovv' disgusting the predicament, therefore, in which the very face of this order places the rebel officials and rebel military, not only of Bradley, but of other parts of the State. The order not only had no reference to the military whatever, and conferred upon it no authority in the case, but particularly, in form at least, it did not dictate the favoritism and the cruelties practiced by the rebels under it in Bradley county. Capt. Brown and his men pretended that this order made it their duty to collect in all the surplus or useless arms in the county, both such as were " in " and such as were " out of order^'^ for the benefit of the rebel army. If so, why then did not they proceed to do it justly, civilly, and in a proper manner, as obeying an important order from the highest authority in the State ? Why did they in tumultuous gangs, with

Oapt. Brown in tlieir lead, rave through the country like so many Devils, ruthlessl}^ seizing upon all the Union arms, leaving unmolested at the same time every rebel ianiilv in the county ? It this order made it the duty of the rebel military to collect up all tlie arms in the whole < ountry, irrespective of parties, why did they utterly neglect it in respect to one party, and drive its fuliillment beyond all decency in regard to another ? Not one in a hundred of that immense collection of guns thus brought and piled up in Cleveland, were forcibly taken from rebel owners. Some few rebels, possibly, volunteered to give some of their arms, always, however, reserving enough for themselves ; while many, perhaps, put them into the hands of their sons when they sent them to the rebel ranks. But in every instance, rebel families, known to be such, and who thought they needed their guns to shoot Lincolnites, and to aid the rebel military in catching conscripts, were allowed to keep them. Not an instance occurred, perhaps, in the whole county, in which a rebel family donated all its arms, or was required by the rebel military to do so ; while, on the other hand, Union families vrere completely stripped.

But more than this, we were credibly informed that, in some instances, arms were taken from Union families and given to rebel families, who in this respect were destitute. The pretext was to procure arms for rebel soldiers ; but the real design in Bradley was to disarm and render helpless Union citi'zens, and cirm the whole rebel element, citizen as well as soldier. This is precisely what was accomplished by this rebel raid upon Union people, or, as the rebel editor styles it, ''A move in the right direction."

With the utmost propriety, as a rebel, could the Cleveland editor, in speaking of this as an enterprise in the interest of the rebellion, announce it as "Amove in the right direction." This Slaveholders' Kebellion, in view of the great light and great blessings bestowed upon us as a people, was the greatest crime ever perpetrated on the earth. It was an aspiration of half the nation, fanned into a white heat of Satanic frenzy, to culminate in every abom- ination and wickedness for which God ever punished angels or men. The means it used and all the ends it proposed were degrees of wrong and human violence which in their collidings with the justice of Omnipotence, ultimately would have extinguished the race. Most emphatically this rebel plundering of Union arms in Bradley was a fit means to promote such an end. It was attended with all the violence, murder and reeking oppression requisite to make its completion no mean stride in the direction of such an end - an end installing these curses as laws of society and rules of human life. With great propriety, therefore, in this sense, but in this sense only, could this editor announce it as " A move in the right direction." Wrong was the rule of the rebellion, both as to its means and its end. Wrong permanently triumphant was the great end proposed. This rebel enterprise in Bradley was violence itself, and fraught with incalculable wrong - consistent with the end proposed - consequently, to the rebels was "Amove in the right direction." Had this Cleveland editor rounded out his announcement to include the end as well as the means, it would have had more philosophic completeness, and might with its emphatic truthfulness in this case, have been enlarged as follows : Tliis rebel raid upon Union families in Bradley was one of the moves in the right direction to ruin the American people, insult God, and curse the world throughout time.

This rebel editor might not have seen nor felt the subject exactly in this light, yet this is the exact philosophy of his remark above considered.

If any of the rebels in Bradley take the position, or in other words shift their position, and argue that, while this order purported the arms only belonging to the State, it nevertheless had a secret design through the military to reach the private arms of the Union people also ; thus, with a view to strengthen the rebellion, proposing completely to disarm the loyal people of the State - just what it accomplished in Bradley, - yet this by no means relieves them from "guilt" and "shame" in the transaction. Al- though this position may be nearer the truth than the other - for we believe that this order was in reality designed by Gov. Harris as an instrument of cruelty against the Union people of East Tennessee - it does not at all relieve these Bradley rebels, but brings down Gov. Harris to a level with themselves, and equally criminates him with them in this infamous and hypocritical piece of business.

We will close our history of this affair with an account of Capt. Brown's assault upon the family of Mr. Baldwin Harle, of Cleveland, ostensibly to carry out the provisions of this order from Gov. Hams. The following statements of the case are from Mr. and Mrs. Harle and their two sons, the most of which are given in their own language.

About the 15th of October, 1861, Thomas Hawkins, who had, when a boy, lived with Mr. Harle, came to his house with nine other armed rebel soldiers. Hawkins was met at the door by Mrs. Harle, when he enquired if Mr. Harle or the boys had two guns in their possession. "Well, what if we have ?" was Mrs. Harle's reply. "I must have them," he returned. "You shall not have them if I can help it," was her rejoinder. Hawkins then ordered his men to enter the liouse and take the guns, attempting at the same time to force his way by Mrs. Harle into the house, she, however, preventing him by maintaining her position at the door. At this juncture, Joseph Harle, a son, being in some part of the building, and attracted through a back door to the spot by the disturbance, standing near his mother, told Hawkins that if he came in he should shoot him. At this Hawkins and his men desisted, held a short parley among themselves, and left the premises.

In a short time Hawkins re-appeared, with about sixty men; the company was led this time by Capt. Brown himself. Brown and his men immediately forced their way into the house, he very abruptly demanding the two gun^ of Mrs. Harle, saying at the same time that Gov. Harris had ordered all the guns in the country to be taken, and that his men needed them as they were going to cap- ture old Olift, tlien lortifyiiig on tlie Tennessee river. Mrs. liarie replied, " Well, if it is right for you to have the guns, tlien I suppose you can take them." Mr. Harle, absent until then, approaching and hearing his vrife's remark, continued hj saying, "Well you shall not have the guns b}" ?>?// consent," emphasizing the i:)ronoun my in a way to give Brown the idea, that although his v/ife had given her consent, and although he presumed that his force would enable him to take the guns, yet he would have to take them against his consent.

At this. Brown immediately raised and leveled his gun to shoot, or as though he would shoot Mr. Harle. Mr. Ilarle, however, quickly caught the muzzle of Brown's gun, and held it to one side. Brown soon got his gun at liberty, drew back, and taking deliberate aim at Mr. Harle's breast, pulled the trigger, but the cai:> bursted without discharging the piece. Seeing himself thus foiled. Brown instantly raised his gun, and v\ith it struck Mr. Harle, apparently with all the force that anger could summons, dealing him a blow across the forehead which opened the flesh to the skull, knocking him against the side of the house, which together with being caught by Mrs. Harle, prevented him from sinking entirely to the floor. While he was in this position, if possible, with more fury than before, BroAvn raised his gun and the second time struck at the senseless and bleeding head of Mr. Harle. But Mrs. Harle throwing herself before her husband, received the blow upon her arm and shoulder, from the effects of vdiich she will probably never entirely recover. Notwithstanding this injury, Mrs. Harle, with what remaining strength she had, continued to protect and defend her husband shrieking for help, and crying for Brown to desist.

By this time, Joseph Harle had come to his mother's assistance, and also plead with Brown to refrain, saying "You have already killed my father, and is not that enough?" At this remark from Joseph, Brovrn's rage was transferred to him, Brown asking him in a vociferous manner, if he "had come to take it up?" Joseph promptly replied that he had. Some of Brown's men then near, hearing this, leveled tlieir guns at Josepli, tlireatening to shoot him for interfering with Bro^vn. Mrs. Ilarle, yet holding her husband, covered with blood, implored them to put down their guns, saying, " You see tliat Brown has killed his father, don't take his life also.

At this moment, a younger son, compelled by Brown's men, or acting on his own judgment, thinking it best to deliver up the guns, as soon as possible, was bringing them through the door of a small out-house, a few stei)s to the rear of the main building, and handing them to the men. Brown seeing this said, " Well men, we've got the guns, let's go." And this murderous brute, Avith his equally murderous gang of rebel villains left the premises, gloating over their savage and bloody victory.

Mr. Harle's dwelling stands upon the west side of a nortli and south street, in the village of Cleveland, and of course fronts to the east. At the commencement of this outrage, wliile most of Brown's men were surrounding the house and ransacking the premises. Brown and a few of his body guards entered at the front or east door, into one of the front rooms, where he had his conversation with Mrs. Harle, and where, near a door of this room conducting into a porch attached to the rear of the main building, he met Mr. Harle. In Brow^n's assault upon the old gentleman, he forced him back through this door into this porch on the floor of which he was standing, when Brow^n knocked him against the side of the main building ; and from which place he was taken up insensible, and apparently dying, by Mrs. Harle and her sons, after the rebels had disappeared. With careful watching and medical treatment, however, Mr. Harle revived, and finally recovered, at least so far as a man of his age can recover, from such an injury as he received.

Mr. and Mrs. Harle were perhaps, upv/ards of sixty years of age at the time, and were among the oldest and most respectable citizens of the place. Mr. Harle was a quiet, peaceable, inoffensive man, constitutionally the

Notwitlistanding this affair transpired in the very heart of Cleveland, and was known in less than an hour to the whole community, rebel and Union, yet no attention was paid to it by the rebel authorities. Nor was Brown called to an account for his conduct any more than if he had assaulted a lot of swine on the street. Mr. Harle and his family were " Lincolnites," and this was not only a bar to anything like an arrest or prosecution, but it was the reason that rebel praise, oftener than rebel censure was awarded to Brown for the brutality which he inflicted on them.

While this injured man was lingering upon his couch for weeks, in a critical condition. Brown was frequently seen galloping by his dwelling, not only at his ease, but wdth greater self-complacency, more individual pomposity and insulting defiance, as he would look in the direction of his victims, than could have been put on, perhaps, by Jeff. Davis himself.

Provenance

Text from History of the Rebellion in Bradley County, East Tennessee, published 1866, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.