Davidson County, Tennessee - Chapter 12, 1880
From History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. 8,961 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
8,961 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Teeaty Of Hopewell
Effects of the Treuty - Freneh and Spanish Intrigue - Complicated Difficulties of the Seltlers - Attack upon Ephraim and Thomas Peyton and Others - Character of the Pioneers for Courage and Endurance - Tax-List of Davidson County in 1787.
In 1785 the progress of settlements was much retarded by the limitations of a treaty made with the Indians. This treaty, known as the treaty of Hopewell, was concluded Nov. 28, 1785, by commissioners on the part of the United States and the chiefs and head men of the Cherokee Nation at Hopewell, on the Keowee River, in South Carolina. Benjamin Hawkins, Andrew Pickens, Joseph Martin, and Lachlin Mcintosh were the United States commissioners.
This treaty was remarkable for its futile attempt to restrict and drive back the progress of Anglo-American settlements. A land-office had been established under an act of 17.83, extensive entries had been made, and upon many of the lands settlements had been inaugurated ; yet such were the powers and prerogatives granted to the Indians that they had the right to dispossess those now declared by the treaty to be within the bounds of the Indian Territory, and to punish all intruders as they might think proper. This was simply deliv- criug the settlers over to the tender mercies of savages. By tliis same treaty tlio Lidians were clotlied with judicial and executive powers of a most startling character. They could arrest persons whom they might deem guilty of capital offenses, and punish them in the presence of the Cherokees in the same manner as they would be punished for like oiFenses committed against citizens of the United States. More than this, one article of tlie treaty gave the Cherokees the right to be represented by one of their own savage delegates in the Congress of the United States. By this treaty the territory of tlie Cumberland settlers was restricted to the narrow limits east of the dividing ridge between the Cumberland and Tennessee Rivers, and south of the Kentucky boundary to about forty miles above Nashville. The distinguislied chief, Tassel, presented a map to the commissioners on which those boundaries were marked, and they were recognized and adopted by the treaty.
At this time the French and the Spaniards were devising the ruin of the Western settlements, and it is thought that the plan of this restriction of territory was furnished by the Spanish Governor. We quote two paragraphs from the report of the Commissioners to Congress :
" Tlie Spaniards and the French are making groat efforts to engross the trade of the Indians. Several of them are on the north side of the Tennessee River, and well supplied with goods proper for the trade. The Governor of New Orleans has sent orders to the Chiekasaws to remove all traders from that country, except such as should take the oath of allegiance to the Catholic king.
" The Cherokees say that the Northern Indians have their emi.ssaries among the Southern tribes, endeavoring to prevail with them to form an alliance offensive against the United States, and to commence hostilities against us in the spring, or next fall at the furthest; that not only the British emissaries are for this measure, but that the Spaniards have extensive claims to the southward, and have been endeavoring to poison the minds of the Indians against us, and to win their affections by large supplies of arms, military stores, and clothing."
Against this combination of enemies the settlers in Cumberland had to contend. The treaty had been designed to conciliate the Cherokees and to preserve them as a friendly, or at least a neutral power between the settlers and the Creeks, who soon began a war of extermination upon the Georgia colony. The ink had hardly become dry upon the treaty wlien depredations within the limits conceded to the settlers was begun by the Cherokees them.selves. They j killed Peter Barnet below Clarksville, on the waters of Blooming Grove ; killed David Steele and wounded William Crutcher in the same region. The story of Crutcher is quite romantic. The Indians had left him badly wounded, as they supposed mortally, with an old hunting-knife sticking in his body; but he revived, reached one of the stations, and lived to a good old age. Crutcher kept the knife many years, and probably the Indian did the same with his, which he took in exchange. Capt. Prince said to Crutcher one day, " I suppose, William, the Indians went upon the principle that a fair exchange is no robbery." " I am glad," said Crutcher, " he used his old, dull knife instead of my long, sharp one. I would not object to the exchange if he would let me stick my knife in him." "Crutcher liad received two gunshot wounds also, one in the side, the other in his thigh, from which he fell, and the Indians rushed upon him." Neither he nor Steele were scalped. For many years Crutcher was on the lookout for his " long, sharp knife," and for the Indian who left the old, dull one in his body, but he never discovered either.
These events happened in 1786. They were followed by an attack upon John Peyton, a surveyor, Ephraim and Thomas Peyton, his brothers, Thomas Pugh, John Frazier,:'' and Esquire Grant, by a large band of Cherokees, in February of the same year. We condense the account from several histories of this period. The party of white men having killed much game, encamped for the night at a place since called " Defeated Creek," near the line between Smith and Jackson Counties. The Indians were sixty in number, under Hanging-Maw, a Cherokee chief The party of hunters or surveyors were fatigued, and were lying upon the ground around their camp-fire, their horses being fastened near by. It was Sunday night ; they had given some part of the evening to playing cards ; their dogs and horses gave some intimations of danger, but the tired hunters coneluded that wild animals - wolves - were attracted by the meat of the camp, and that there could be no other enemy near. Therefore they " chunked up their fire," and laid themselves down again, John Peyton " leaning on his elbow near the fire hissing on the dogs." Suddenly the Indians fired a volley upon them, wounding four of the six men in camp. As John Peyton sprang to his feet he had the forethought to throw his blanket over the fire, thus to give him and his party a better chance of escape in the intense darkness. The whole party fled, escaping through the Indian lines. They oast their blankets from them and each fled his own way through the woods, bareheaded and without shoes. They were seventy miles from Bledsoe's Station, the ground was covered with snow, and yet each of these men, after several days' wandering, arrived at the station and recovered from their wounds and exposure.
John Peyton was shot through the arm and shoulder, Thomas Peyton through the thigh, Frazier through the leg, and Grant through the knee. Ephraim Peyton and Pugh escaped without a wound, but Peyton, in jumping down the bank to cross the creek, sprained his ankle very badly, and lay for some time in agony. Crawling along on the ground, he found a stick which answered the place of a staff" to support and aid him in hobbling along. He was thus several days suffering and laboring to reach the white settlement, and was the last of the party to come in. All the others arrived, one at a time, each reporting the rest killed. John Peyton sent a message the next year to the chief that he might retain the horses, blankets, saddles, guns, etc., if he would return the compass and chain, to which he received reply : " You, John Peyton, ran away like a coward and left all your property ; and as for your Jandstca/er" (the compass), " I have broken that against a tree."
We clo.se our sketch of the pioneers with the following eulogy from the pen of one who knew and understood their character, and rightly estimated the value of their achievements: much of the malign influence of the emissaries of England and France, but their exposure to Spanish and Indian jealousy and hatred combined was greater than that endured by any other portion of the country. Had the three hundred pioneers who came to the Cumberland in the winter and spring of 17S0 crossed the Atlantic and selected their liomes in the deuseness of a forest among wild beasts and hostile savages, two to four hundred miles from other snndl settlements of civilized men, there to endure hardship, there to lay the foundations of a great State, the voyage, the enterprise, its men, measures, and results would interest the historian, the orator, and the poet. It was a great which these emigrants undertook, - tliey endured more than the dangers of the sea; they suffered a thousandfold more than they anticipated, - and great and penetrating as may have been their gaze into the fafure, and extensive and glorious as may have been the hopes of improvement and power to result from what they did, they could not have conceived of one ten-thousandth part of what even some of their children now see and enjoy."
Names of persons who were in Davidson County in 1787, being the first year in which the tax on land and polls was taken, being (white) males over twenty-one years three hundred and seventy- two, and blacks one hundred and five between twelve and sixty years old y^
The Coldwater Expedition, June, 1787 The Cold'Watee Expeditiobt, Jukte, 1787
French Trnders at Tudian Towns on the Tennessee - Nieknjack, Runuing Water, and Coldwater, settled by the Indians - Their Design to Destroy the White Settlers on the Cumberland - Expedition to Coldwater - Suecessful Capture and Destruction of t'lc Indians - Noble' Character of Piamiiigo - Incidents of the Return of the Soldiers - History of the Water Expedition - Successful Shooting- Parties-^Contest with Rig-Foot.
In con.sequeneo of a treaty held with the Southern Indians at Nashville in June, 1783, by commissioners on part of Virginia, and that of Hopewell, Nov. 28, 1785, there was a marked abatement of hostility on the part of the Cherokees. The treaty of Nashville stood on the same footing with that of Col. Henderson in 1774, known as the Transylvania treaty ; that is, the general government did not recognize the authority of a State to make a treaty with an Indian tribe, as it claimed a paternal and protecting relation to these people. The first President took upon himself the title that the kings of England had borne in their dealings with them, - that of the " Great Father." While many of the provisions of the treaty of Nashville were confirmed at Hopewell, yet large concessions had been made to the Cherokees, and recession of boundaries which had been confirmed to North Carolina in the most solemn manner and for which they had received a stipulated price.. Col. Robertson was much opposed to the selection of Nashville as the treaty -ground, and a majority of the stationers on the south side of the Cumberland joined with him ; but the question being submitted to a vote of all the stations, it was carried in the aiBrmative by the decisive vote of Eaton's, which was fifty-four for and one against the proposition. The objection to having the treaty held here was that it would admit a large body of Indians to the midst of the settlement and disclose the weakness of the whites. Eaton's, being protected in a measure by the river, felt more security, and consequently was not so solicitous. However, everything passed off very well, the treaty having been held four miles northwest of Nashville, at the place afterwards selected by Gen. Robertson as his residence, and well known to a later generation as the Nashville Camp-Ground. There is no account of the tribes represented. The Cherokees and Chickasaws were present, but probably no Creeks, or at least an insignificant representation. Those present expressed themselves as well pleased, particularly with Col. Robertson, who was a person calculated to strike the Indian fancy of a great man and leader in an eminent degree. The gathering undoubtedly had a good effect, as it was followed by some abatement of the outrages that had marked the previous years. Still, murders did occur occasionally and horses were stolen, but the settlers breathed freer, and by the year 1785 stations had extended as far up the Cumberland on the north side as Bledsoe's Lick, now Castilian Springs. Yet a sense of security was never felt, and constant vigilance and the practice of measures dictated by experience doubtless saved many lives.
Gradually, however, matters became worse. There was an impUcatwn in the treaty of Hopewell that the Cumberland settlers were intniders, - a squinting towards disownraont on the part of the government of an interest in their welfare and success. This want of firmness had a bad influence on the evilly-disposed Indians, and cost both parties to the conflict dearly in the end. The chastisements inflicted upon the Chickamauga towns by Sevier had driven a number of these people to take shelter farther down the river in places of greater security. Thus the towns at Nickajack and Running Water were formed. Later on a small party of Cherokees established themselves at Coldwater, where Tuscumbia, Ala., now stands. Here they were discovered by the Creeks, who came to their assistance and added much to their strength. At this time the French traders on the Wabash resorted to the waters of the Tennessee, and while a Blonsieur Veiz managed the trade he seems to have acted prudently and without any disposition to stir up hostilities with the whites; but on the establishment of the band of lawless Creeks and Cherokees at Coldwater a half-dozen or more French traders resorted to the place, and being anxious to increase their trade, oflFered various inducements to them to encourage them to acts of war. They kept large supplies of ammunition, guns, tomahawks, and knives, which they could dispose of readily at exorbitant prices to the surrounding Indians, who for the most part were indifferently armed. The existence of this town was unknown to the settlers for several years, though they had often wondered why predatory bands for the most part retreated ip a westerly direction ; and they were disposed for this rettson to suspect the fidelity of the Chickasaws. At length two 3'oung Chickasaw warriors while on a hunt came unexpectedly on this village. They remained all night, and were treated in a friendly manner. The villagers informed those young men that their object in settling there was to strike the Cumberland settlers with greater facility, as the situation seemed to afi'ord a safer retreat with a wide river intervening.
On the return of the Chickasaws to their nation they infiirmed Piamingo, or the mountain leader, the head chief and firm ally of the whites, of their discovery, and he sent them immediately to Nashville to acquaint Col. Robertson with the fact, at the same time expressing the opinion that policy required that this band should be broken up at once. Their arrival was most opportune, for a short time before, in May, Mark Robertson, a brother of the colonel, had been killed after a desperate defense near the latter's residence, while about the same time a number of persons had been butchered at the stations in Sumner County on the north side of the i-iver, among them old man Price, his wife, and children, at Hendrick's Station ; Capt. Charles Morgan, old man Gibson, Maj. William Hall and two sons, James and Richard, and young Hickerson, near Bledsoe's : and old man Morgan, at Morgan's Station, besides others. The weight of grievauce was now too hard to bear, and when it bceanic knowi), through the friendly ofiBces of the Chickasaws, who were the authors and where they could be found with certainty, the settlers clamored with one voice for vengeance, and renounced any further obligations to observe treaty stipulations which forbade expeditions into the Indian country unless duly authorized by the government. They thereupon determined to carry the war into the enemy's country, and for this purpose one hundred and thirty men from the different stations collected in the neighborhood of Nashville early in June, armed and equipped with supplies of powder and bullets and wallets of dried meat and parched corn. Col. Robertson took command, assisted by Lieut. - Cols. Robert Hays and James Ford. Among the number was Capt. John Rains' company of spies or scouts, a body for efficiency in border warfare was never surpassed. The Chickasaws offered their services as guides, which were gladly accepted. In fact, their services could not have been dispensed with. None of the whites had penetrated in that direction farther than fifty or sixty miles, and a knowledge of the country beyond the Tennessee was essential to make the blow effective. A raw-hide boat was prepared beforehand to carry over the arms when they readied the river, but on the representations of the guides it was expected that Indian boats could be obtained, as some were usually kept tied to the farther bank. To provide, however, against any mishap from this source a detachment was organized to go by water, consisting of three large canoes under the command of David Hay and iMoses Shelby. This was to descend the Cumberland to the Ohio, and thence up the Tennessee to a crossing since known as Colbert's Ferry, where, if necessary, the land force could repair in case of necessity and effect a safe passage. The boats also Carried some extra supplies, and were considered useful for the comfortable conveyance of any persons who might become disabled by wounds or sickness. All things being in readiness the land force marched into Nashville from its rendezvous four miles to the northwest, afterwards known as the residence of Gen. Robertson, and also as the "Nashville Camp-Ground." The object was to afford friends who had collected from the surrounding stations an opportunity to bid the adventurous band good-by. It was a most dangerous mission, but all felt the importance of its successful execution. Indeed, there was a general rejoicing that an opportunity had occurred for retaliatory measures, and that Col. Robertson, the commandant, had taken the responsibility of ordering the movement.
It was calculated that the expedition by water, though following a long and circuitous route, could reach its destination by the time the land force would be able to penetrate to the same point through the cane brakes and thickets which would bar its progress continually, and both therefore started the same day. The route of the army is thus described by Haywood : " They crossed the mouth of South Harpeth ; thence they went a direct course to the mouth of Turnbull's Creek ; thence up the same to the head, and thence to Lick Creek of Duck River ; thence down the creek seven or eight miles, leaving the creek to the right hand ; thence to an old lick as large as a corn-field ; thence to Duck River where the old Chickasaw crossed it ; thence, leaving the trace to the right hand, they went to the head of Swan Creek, on the south side of Duck River ; thence to a creek running into the Tennessee River, which the troops called Blue Water, and which ran into the Tennessee about a mile and a half above the lower end of the Muscle Shoals; they left this creek on the left baud." The route was very devious, and rendered difficult by the avoidance, at the suggestion of the Chickasaw guides, of the trails upon which their advance might be detected by straggling parties of the enemy. It seems, however, that these precautions failed of their purpose, for one of the prisoners captured at Coldwater, a French trader, informed Col. Robertson that the Indians had been councilling for three days at the instigation of a principal Creek chief, and had unanimously agreed to fight the whites if they crossed the river. In fact Col. Robertson, in his official report of the expedition, made to Governor Caswell, distinctly states that while in the vicinity of Muscle Shoals some Indians discovered him and fired upon his back picket, which alarmed a small town of Cherokees. This town was on the opposite side of the river at the crossing. This clearly indicates that they had information of their purpose. It is cjuite probable that they even knew of the expedition by water, for this was met at the mouth of Duck River and fired upon, without doubt by a party from this village evidently there in observation.
AVlien the army reached within ten miles of the river the roaring of the rapids induced them to believe that it was near at hand, and a halt was made. One of the guides with two or three active men were ordered forward to reconnoitre, but they returned about midnight with the information that the river was yet too distant for them to reach in time to return that night. In the morning the march was resumed, and at twelve o'clock the troops struck the river at the lower end of the Muscle Shoals. Here they concealed themselves to await the approach of night.' Several spies were dispatched to take post in the cave at the water's edge and make ob.scrvations. Some cabins were seen on the opposite bank, but from the absence of crowing of cocks and barking of dogs it was justly concluded that they were not inhabited at that time. During the afternoon two Indians were observed cautiously approaching the riverbank on the other side, and from their movements it was evident that they were on the lookout for the whites. Not discovering anything indicating a hostile presence, they waded to an island near their side, and unloosing a canoe paddled out into the river, as if with the intention of crossing, but on reaching the middle of the stream they abandoned the boat to the current, while they plunged in and disported themselves for some time in the water. They then recovered the canoe, and paddling back to their own side disappeared up the bank. From this it was plain that their suspicions had not been excited. On report of these facts to Col. Robertson he determined to cross the river that night by some means, and he therefore dispatched a messenger to Capt. Rains, who had been sent up the river, to return. That officer had been ordered in the morning to take the broad buffalo trail up the river to look for canoes, and if possible to capture an Indian alive. On his return he reported no indication of an Indian settlement in that quarter. At dusk the entire force was congregated at the river-bank, with instructions to observe the utmost quietude. Col. Robertson now called for volunteers to swim the river, which was spread out fully a mile at this point, and bring back the canoe. Joshua Thomas offered his services if any one would go with him. At that instant a plunge was heard in the water, and the colonel asked "Who is that?" " Edmond Jennings," was the reply of a by-stander. lie and Thomas were inseparable on the hunt or scout, and when the latter proposed to swim tlie river he plunged in without further ceremonj'. Thomas followed, and they soon disappeared in the darkness. Jennings, who, by the way, was one of the most remarkable characters of that day, in telling the circumstances years afterwards, said that he got bothered in the darkness and swam a long time without making much headway ; but, said he, " I finerly tuck a stair to course by, and landed on the other side." Thomas also made the passage safely.
After making an exploration of the cabins, which were indeed deserted, they entered the canoe to return ; it was very old and leaky, and one had to bail the water out constantly to keep it from sinking. In fact, they made so much noise on their return that some of their comrades on shore insisted on firing upon them for Indians. Putnam and Haywood speak of seven persons being engaged in swimming the river for the canoe, but Capt. Rogan, who liad the story from the actors and from Jennings himself, mentions only the names given. In order to stop the leaks some of the men took ofi' articles of clothing, which they stuffed in the cracks and endeavored to hold in place with their feet. Forty persons got in or clung to the sides of the boat, and it was started, but after proceeding a short distance the water rushed in so rapidly that a number of them had to deposit their guns and ammunition and leap overboard in order to lighten the craft enough to got it back to land. The woods were searched and some pieces of bark secured, with which the cracks were at length stopped. This occasioned so much delay that it was daylight before the first load got over. These were posted to advantage, and the boat started on its return, but the successful landing of the first detachment now aroused such a spirit of emulation that the remainder, having daylight to guide them, now plunged in on their horses, or swimming alongside, and passed over without accident. The arms and ammunition were pushed over in the raw-hide boat brought from Nashville for the purpose. Col. Robertson's invading army now presented a singular spectacle. When they landed tlie men stripped off their wet garments and, hanging them out to dry in the sun, wandered about on the beach en disliahUle. A shower having come on, the troops resorted to the cabins, where they dressed and made preparations to mount as soon as the rain was over. From the cabins a plain path led through the open woods in a westerly direction. This the army took and followed at a brisk pace for five or sis miles, when they came to some corn-fields about two miles from the village, as the guides informed tlicm. There they made a slight change of course to strike directly for the town, which was on the opposite side of a creek formed by the water from a large limestone spring, and called by the Indians Coldwater. On reaching the slope loading down to the creek, about three hundred yards, speed was increased to a gallop in order to give the enemy no time to prepare for resistance. On account of the narrowness of the path at the crossing, which would admit only one horseman at the farther bank, the onset was hindered somewhat, which prevented the troops from arriving in the village in a body and doing more execution at this point. As it was, no halt was made by those in front for their comrades to come up, and the village was entered in this order. The enemy, having got notice by the thunder of the horses' feet, made no offer of resistance, and fled mostly to their canoes, which were moored at the mouth of the creek. The Chiokasaws had suggested to Col. Robertson tliat the enemy would in all probability endeavor to escape to their canoes, and he had detached Capt. Rains, Benjamin Castlenian, William Loggins, William Steele, Blorton Duncan, and one of the guides to a point on the creek opposite their canoes to intercept their retreat in this direction. Blany of the fugitives, in their effort to escape from the main body, crossed the creek to where Capt. Rains' men were posted on the' bank, and while looking back were fired upon at the distance of a hvi paces. Three of them dropped dead, and the rest continued their flight to the canoes, which were now being rapidly filled and pushed out into the river.
At this juncture the main body of whites appeared at the bank and opened a destructive fire upon the crowded boats. Edmond Jennings, who was mounted on a wild young mare which ran away with him, was the first to reach the place. He leaped to the ground and gettin"- a raking shot at a boat with John Buchanan's fowling-piece, a famous gun in that day, killed three warriors, when the rest plunged into the water and attempted to save themselves by swimming and diving. The pursuit was so hard and close from the village, the men having been informed beforehand of the probable direction the enemy would take, that few of the latter escaped in this quarter, nearly all being killed in the water. The number was not ascertained at the time, but the Creeks confessed to the Chickasaws afterwards that they had lost twenty-six warriors. Three of the French traders and a white woman in their company were also killed. Among the slain was the principal Creek chief and also a Cherokee chief Their force consisted of ten Creek and thirty-five Cherokee warriors and nine Frenchmen, chiefly from Detroit. The principal trader and owner of the goods was wounded and taken prisoner, along with five other traders. A large stock of goods was captured, consisting of taffia, sugar, coffee, cloths, blankets, Indian wares of all kinds, salt, shot, paints, knives, powder, tomahawks, tobacco, and other articles of traffic. But one or two Indian women were taken, and it was surmised from this that the families had been sent off in anticipation of the whites crossing. Putnam suggests that men of this character would not have fiimilies, or at least not keep them in a place like this. The fact that they cultivated the ground goes to prove that there were women among them, for on these fall work of this kind, being scorned by a brave as beneath the dignity of his occupation, which was to hunt and go to war.
After the dispersion of the enemy all of the personal property in the cabins was tlirown out for the use of the women and children in case they were lurking in the cane near by. The huts were then consumed by fire. All of the fowls and some hogs in a pen were killed. The boats, three excellent ones, were collected in the creek opposite the village, where they were loaded with the captured goods and placed under guard during the night. The troops encamped near the ruins, but on the opposite side of the creek. The next morning arrangements were completed for the return of the troops. It having been decided to send the property and prisoners by water to
Nashville, Jonathan Denton, Benjamin Drake, and John and Moses Eskridge were put in charge of the necessary crews. The Eskridges had a small canoe tied on to their own. The prisoners consisted of five Frenchmen, a squaw, the wife of one of the traders, and a child. The white men and the woman killed were buried. A new route, at the suggestion of the Chiekasaws, was selected for the return home. The boats were ordered to drop slowly down the river to a certain crossing indicated by the Chiekasaws, and await the arrival of tlie troops for the purpose of ferrying them over. The march home from that point was ascertained to be more direct and easy of accomplishment. The route pursued down the river was very circuitous and led the army much farther off from the boats than was intended, and prevented them reaching their destination that day. They then turned a course towards the river, and on reaching it discovered some persons on an island, who on being reconnoitred proved to be the boatmen. They all proceeded over the river to a point where the approaches on either side were easy and con- Tenient, the place being now known as Colbert's Ferry. The two Chiekasaws, who had rendered such invaluable services to the expedition, here left for their homes. Each of them was presented with a horse, bridle, and saddle, a rifle, and as many goods as he could pack, at which they were greatly delighted. The Chiekasaws after their treaty proved the firm friends and allies of the whites, and they boasted with pride that their nation had never shed the blood of an American. Their chief, Piamiugo, was a man of great intelligence and dignity of character, and managed the aflairs of his people with much shrewdness and ability. On a visit to the seat of government he was received with great respect by President Washington, who entertained a high opinion of his character and abilities.
The troops succeeded in crossing the river without much difiiculty, on account of the accessibility of the bunks at this point. Here it was deemed advisable to get rid of the incumbrance of the prisoners. They were accordingly given the light canoe, into which their trunks and clothing were packed, with a plentiful supply of provisions, and ordered to return up the river. They were greatly elated at such an easy deliverance, and set out at once. The stock of sugar and coffee that remained was equally divided among the troops, and the dry goods and other captured articles securely packed in the boats, with directions to be landed and stored at Eaton's for sale and division. The land force of the expedition now started on its return home, taking a due north course until it reached the path leading into the Chickasaw old crossing of Duck River. It had been absent nineteen days and had not lost a man killed or wounded.
As the boats were on their return they met five French traders ascending the river. When the latter came in sight they fired off their guns as a feu, de joie, thinking they were meeting friends. The Cumberlanders made ready their guns, and laying alongside of the traders' boats took them prisoners before they could recover from their astonishment. Their boats being loaded with articles contraband of war, the owners were required to return as prisoners. On reaching a point a few miles below Nashville they were offered their choice of proceeding on to a trial for the recovery of their goods or being set at liberty without them. They chose the latter course, and being furnished with a light canoe they departed down the river. France and the United States being on terms of amity. Col. Robertson thought it necessary to make an explanation to the representative of the former power, then in command of a post in the Illinois country. He accordingly wrote to that functionary a letter, in. which he defined very clearly the principles of international law governing such cases. He recited the grievances which his people had suffered from the savages, who were instigated to acts of war and supplied with munitions by the traders who had resided at Coldwater for several years past, of which he had ample proof, and upon which he rested his vindication of the treatment they had received at his hands in the late expedition. They had imprudently put themselves in the battle at that place, and some of thom fell. As to the capture of the traders ascending the river, he declared that they had supplies for the purpose of trading with the very Indians with whom the settlers were then at war, and the seizure of their persons and goods, though without his express order, was clearly justifiable; that he was endeavoring to collect the goods, and if the owners could prove that they were not guilty of a breach of the laws, and did not intend to furnish the Indians with powder, lead, and other goods for the destruction of the Cumberland settlers, they could recover the same on application at Nashville. He closed by declaring that any traders who furnished these Indians with arms and ammunition at a time when they were in a state of hostility with his people would render themselves very insecure. Here the matter dropped, and never, as (ar as the writer is aware, formed the subject of a diplomatic correspondence between the two governments.
It remains now to notice the history of tlie expedition that left Nashville by water to co-operate with the land force. It had the same bright prospects, and promised the voyagers a modicum only of the hardships in prospect for the other, but this did not save it from an unfortunate and tragical issue. The boats descended the Cumberland with great rapidity, although the waters were low, but on entering the Tennessee the weather was so calm that the sails, upon which they had based some expectation of increased speed, proved of no use. They proceeded, however, with oars and poles, and had reached the mouth of Duck River, when their attention was drawn to a canoe tied to the bank a short distance up that stream. Captain Shelby, who commanded one of the boats, deemed it advisable to investigate the matter before proceeding farther. He thereupon turned into that stream, and had reached to within a few yards of the canoe when a dreadful volley was poured into the crew from a body of Indians concealed in the thick cane that lined the bank. Josiah Ren froe was shot through the head, Hugh Rogau (misprinted Roqueriiig by Haywood and not corrected by subsequent historians) and John Topp through the body, and Edward Hogan through the arm, fracturing the bone ; five others were also slightly wounded by the same fire. The surprise and consternation of the crew were so great that it was with much difficulty that the boat could be got back into the main channel, but this was at length accomplished before the enemy could reload and fire again.
The several boats now collected in the middle of the liver and counseled as to their future movements. Their presence being now discovered, they would be placed at great disadvantage ascending against the current, as the enemy could easily outstrip them and fire upon them from chosen positions, against which they had no protection. They decided therefore to return to Nashville. As to the manner of their return there is some confusion in the accounts of writers. All of these except Carr state that they returned by the route they came. Carr, who is very trustworthy on matters of pioneer history, on account of his connection with most of the events of which he treats, says that Capt. Shelby abandoned his boat, and that the crew marched through the wildernesa to Nashville. This is undoubtedly the fiict, for the writer has conversed with the family of Mr. Eogan, who was one of Shelby's crew and who was shot through the lungs, and they confirm the statement. The crews of the other boats may have proceeded by water, but it is quite probable that they all acted in conjunction in a case like this, where it would be impolitic to have any division of strength, especially when Shelby's crew needed and required assistance to make sure of its march home through tlio d.ingcrs of the wilderness. The journey by water was, if anything, more diflicult, and ihe open boats afforded very little protection against attack, as had just been demonstrated. The backwoodsman wanted the shelter of a tree when he fought, and freedom of movement, which he could not obtain in the confined space of a Canoe.
Of the wounded, Renfroe died before he left the boat. It was a singular circumstance in his ease that though he was shot through the brain he still retained the use of some of his faculties. The crew had been spearing fish with sharpened canes, and as they proceeded on water for some time after the repulse, Renfroe sat upright in the bow of the bout and speared at real or imaginary fish until ho died ; but it is quite probable the act was a phase of " unconscious cerebration," in which he repeated the train of ideas that was dominant in his mind up to within a fevf moments of the reception of his injury. Rogan was an Irishman of superlative courage and strength of will, and though he was shot through one lung he not only marched home without assistance but carried his gun and accoutrements. But the men of that day possessed in an eminent degree the hardihood and tenacity of life which distinguish the lower animals in their eflbrts at self-preservation. Such men as Edmond Jennings and Josh Thomas could swim icy rivers in mid-winter without injury or much bodily discomfort.
It should have been stated in proper chronological order that Col. Robertson had in the spring of this year, in eonsequence of the depredations committed about that time, marched a body of men " near the Chickamaugas," according to his oiEcial report of the Coldwater expedition previously mentioned. He imputed these murders to the Indians at that place, not having learned at that time of the existence of the Coldwater town. After his arrival he thought it best to avoid an open war, and returned without doing them any mischief, leaving them a letter containing every offer of peace that could be made on honorable terms.
After his return they sent a flag to treat, but he put no confidence in their sincerity, as several persons were killed during their stay, and one man at his house in their sight. They imputed the murders to the Creeks, but were not believed at the time, as they gave no hint of the existence of the Coldwater town.
In the month of September of this year, 1787, Capt. Rains' company of spies was again ordered out to scour the country to the south, being joined at Nashville by Capt. Shannon's company of sixty men, the whole under command of Capt. Rains. They crossed Duck River at Greene's Lick, and passing the Pond Spring, crossed the Tombigbec Crjek near its head. In proceeding towards the Elk tlieir attention was attracted to a large number of buzzards flying around, when Capt. Rains suggested that there must be Indians about, these birds being collected to prey on the remains of the deer and other game killed by them. They encamped near by, and on search his surmise was found to be correct. The next morning Capt. Shannon was in front, but passed over a trail without noticing it. It was, however, detected by Capt. Rains, who proposed to follow it. Objection was made that it was too old, but ho insisted on following it until he found a freslier one. Before night the spies came upon an encampment, and discovering an Indian fired upon him without effect. He ran off, and the entire party of the whites dashed forward at the report. Capt. Rains discovered the Indian running rapidly up a hill, and being well mounted, he soon got close on him and ordered him to halt. The Indian turned a moment as if to comply with the demand, and then set off again. Capt. Rains then jumped from his horse and fired, wounding him severely in the arm and hands. At this moment Reuben Parks and Beverly Ridley came up and joined in the chase. They soon overtook the Indian and knocked him down, but he made a desperate struggle, which ended in Ridley's killing him with his knife. John Rains, Jr., and Robert Evans in dashing forward came fiice to face with an Indian coming out of a thicket, and on his making signals for quarter they took him prisoner. It seems that these two men were the only occupants of the camp at the time, or at lea.st the only ones discovered. Eight horses were taken, and about three hundred deer and other skins, the produce of their hunt. The horses were sold at Nashville, and the proceeds of the sale and the other property equally divided among the captors. The Indian taken was a youth about nineteen years old. He became very much attached to Capt. Shannon's family, into which he was taken for safekeeping. He was afterwards sent on to Washington (wliere a young white girl fell desperately in love witli him), and at the end of two years was brought back to Capt. Shannon. lie was finally released on exchange, but returned again to the whites, saying that the " Indians looked so dirty and lousy he couldn't stay witii them." After remaining some time he joined the Creeks, and was wounded at the battle of Talladega, in 1813, fighting against the whites.
A number of expeditions of this character were sent out during this year, which liad an excellent effect towards restraining the extent of savage depredation ; still there were thirty-three victims to the rifle and tomahawk in the course of the year. Among the mounted rangers of Evans' battalion were the companies of Capts. "William Martin and Samuel Hadley, which also did excellent service, the records of which, however, are very meagre.
About the last of July, after the return of the Coldwater expedition a Monsieur Perrautt, a French trader, happeped in Nashville on his way to the Indian nation. By him Col. Robertson dispatched a letter to the head men and chiefs of the Creeks, reciting the grievances which led to his late march into their country and the destruction of their warriors at Coldwater, and stating that the movement was purely for retaliation, but that he was now willing to be on terms of peace with them. On his way thither Perrautt met a band of two hundred Creeks, who had crossed the Tennessee and were marching on the settlements. He expounded to them, as he claimed on his return, the nature of the letter he bore, and strongly endeavored to dissuade them from their purpose. This they positively refused to do. They said that " they wanted horses and there is the place to get them. If we cannot get the horses without killing some of the people, we shall risk the worst to obtain the horses. We will not do much harm this time, but if the whites again venture into Indian country with an army then they may expect a merciless war. We know their strength, their positions, and how and whore best to worry and waste them." They claimed that their motive was to obtain satisfaction for three Creeks killed by the North Carolina people eighteen miles below Chotu. Such was the purport of Perrautt's language on his return, and Col. Robertson, on this report, hastened measures of defense at once. He pushed the work of collecting supplies for Evans' battalion, and used his authority to call into scouting service some of the immigrants who had lately arrived under the protection of tliat battalion. By this accession of strength he was now enabled to keep out strong scouting-parties in various directions, which rendered most efficient service by giving timely notice in many cases of the approach of Indians, and pursuing promptly when any mischief was done. These scouts were kept up after that as long as any necessity existed. Col. Robertson had from the first employed men in this kind of service, but now he was enabled to send out larger bodies to greater distances. Their instructions were to examine all of the buffalo-trails and crossingplaces of the streams, and to search for the camps of the enemy. The country at that time being abundantly stocked with game, the Cherokees resorted here to hunt, and brought their women with them to do the drudgery of camp. After the hunt was over the women, boys, and old men were dispatched homeward with the products of the chase, while the warriors approached the settlements to steal horses and get scalps. But the activity and bravery of the scouts at length made the formation of these stationary camps hazardous within the distance of fifty miles of the whites, and they were withdrawn to points of greater security in the neighborhood of the mountains. At that time the ground was covered with leaves that had been collecting for years, amounting in places to more than a foot in depth. They were so thick that small streams were covered over with them, and springs concealed that now afford an abundant supply of water throughout the year. It is quite probable that the Indians fired the grass only in the barrens south of Duck and Elk Rivers, and these streams acted as barriers to protect the leaves and cane-thickets from destruction. The whites were also unwilling to fire the woods on account of the great destruction of cane-thickets that would have ensued, as these afforded the main subsistence to their animals. In consequence of this uniform coating of the surface, the tracks of men and horses could be followed almost as readily and with as much certainty as if in snow. The Indians therefore resorted to the hard-beaten tracks of the buffaloes when practicable, and frequently retreated for escape along the beds of the creeks.
The duties of these scouts were very arduous and hourly attended with peril to their lives. They were particularly obnoxious to the Indians, who mangled their bodies in a most shocking manner when they fell into their hands. They always plucked but their eyes and cut off their ears, in order to heap as much indignity as po.ssible on the organs which served their owners so well in their peculiar vocation. It is a matter of deep regret that so little has been preserved of the exploits of such men as Capts. Rains, Gordon, Shannon, Murray, and Williams. The story of their scouting adventures would make a volume of stirring and thrilling incident. As it is, we have but little besides their names and the contemporary record of duties well done on all occasions during the long years of Indian hostility which hung over the Cumberland settlers. But with a knowledge of the difficulties and dangers which beset their paths at every step, the imagination will have but little difficulty in constructing the materials of their character.
Yet all of the vigilance of these active and trusty scouts could not save their people from the devastations of a savage and revengeful foe. The destruction of the Coldwater village and the killing of so many of its warriors brought only a temporary respite from acts of hostility. Representing as they did a wide circle of relations and friends in two of the most powerful nations in the South, an injury could only be atoned with blood. The warwhoop soon rang along the beautiful valley of the Cumberland, and the tomahawk, rifle, and torch were again at their deadly and destructive work. Although the spirit of vengeance rose to the highest pitch of demoniacal fury, its full gratification was checked by a prudential regard for the temper and resources of the whites at this time. The numbers of the settlers had been much augmented this year by the advent of the soldiers raised for the defense of the border, and the service they rendered in guarding emigrants safely through the wilderne.ss. In consequence of this, a large force of invaders, acting in one body, could be struck by the whites with much more certainty on account of its greater difficulty of concealment, while the same force broken into small bodies could lurk close to the stations with litile ri.sk of discovery, and escape with more facility after striking a blow. This must have been the governing consideration, for we find no record of an attack in force on any point in the county until several years later. But a number of small bands invaded the settlements continually,'and committed such havoc as they could, and retreated well loaded with booty.
Renewed Hostilities, 1792
tcrniined bravery. They had made a successful raid in which thoy had taken some scalps and secured various articles of property, when on reaching the Tennessee on their return thoy felt so secure from interruption that they halted to cook and make some preparation for getting their effects across the river. The halt proved fatal. Capt. Shannon, with a few followers as brave and determined as himself, William Pillow, Luke Anderson, and one of the dare-devil Castlemans among them, had struck Big Foot's trail, and had been following it from the vicinity of Nashville with the persistence of bloodhounds. At the time of Shannon's arrival several of the Indians were in camp eating, and the rest down at the river-bank. The whites charged immediately and dispersed those in camp, Castleman and Pillow each killing an adversary. Big Foot, who was at the river, in hearing the firing, judged correctly from the number of shots that the attacking party was small, and he thereupon collected his warriors and hastened in the most determined manner to recover his loss. The combatants were about equally divided, and the victory for some time hung in the balance. At length Big Foot, in the ardor of revenge, pressed forward among the whites and engaged in a handto-hand struggle with Luke Anderson for the possession of the latter's gun. Being of superior strength he was on the point of wresting it away, when William Pillow sprang to the rescue and sank his tomahawk deeply into the Indian's brain. At the fall of their leader his followers withdrew from the conflict with loud yells of disappointed rage, leaving five of their number dead on the field.
Provenance
Text from History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.