Davidson County, Tennessee - Chapter 15: Renewed Hostilities, 1792, 1880
From History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. 3,257 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
The text
3,257 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 15: Renewed Hostilities, 1792
Outrages on the Cumberland - St.itions Abandoned - Gen. Robertson restricted by the Government .at Washington - rnsutficiency of Troops - Treachery of the Chiefs - Cherokecs Incited to War by a Lying Creek Chief - Assembling of the Militia - Attack on Buchanan's Station - A'ictory of the Stationers - Desultory Attacks by the Indians in 1793 - Abe Castleman's Expedition.
But a little more than a half-month of the new year had pa.sscd when throe sons of Col. Valentine Sevier, a brother of the general, had been butchered in an open boat while ascending the Cumberland from Clarksville. Following this the murders came so thick and fast that all outlying stations and settlements south of the river were abandoned except Robertson's, Raines', and Buchanan's. At Johnson's Station four children, brothers and sisters, were killed and wounded while at the spring, and three of these scalped and piled in a heap, the other making his escape with a broken arm. At Brown's four others were killed and treated similarly. On the 24th of May Gen. Robertson and his son Jonathan were severely wounded, and only escaped death by a well-directed shot from the latter, which woundedtwo of the Indians. Col. Kilpatrick, while heading a small party in pursuit of some of the murderers, was fired upon from an ambuscade near Denham's Station and killed and beheaded. Zigler's Station, in Sumner County, containing thirty persons, was taken, only three or four escaping death or captivity. These and other outrages so wrought upon Capt. John Edmeston that he raised a company to avenge the repeated injuries, no matter to what lengths he would have to go in the execution of his purpose. Gen. Robertson, though his heart bled with a sense of the enormous injuries of his people, felt constrained, by his oath as an officer to carry out the instructions of the government, to forbid the proposed expedition, and it was reluctantly abandoned.
The troops then on regular duty numbered only one hundred and ninety men, infantry and cavalry, under Maj. Sharp and Capt. Lusk,and were distributed in nine stations or over a distance of seventy miles. As the term of their enlistment was out in October the Governor ordered Gen. Robertson to enlist others in their places, but " to avoid a heavy expense." In the spring of this year he (Gen. R.) had visited the Indian nation, and had been received at Coyatee with much barbaric pomp by two thousand warriors drawn up in martial array. The chiefs Watts, Hanging Maw, and the Breath of Nickajack had renewed, with much seeming manifestation of sincerity, professions of friendship, and a desire to comply with the stipulations of the late treaties. He was so much elated with his reception, and so favorably impressed with what he saw and heard, that after his return in May he thought proper in a letter to rebuke the Cumberland settlers for their despondency and disposition to put out reports of danger that alarmed immigrants. He bade them to be of good cheer, - that all would now be well with them. It may be proper to state that Governor Blount was not insensible to the sufferings of his people, or careless of their interests ; he merely allowed himself to be duped into a belief that the chiefs were true to their professions, and that in the course of time they would be able to bring their roving bands under proper restraint.
On the 10th of August, Governor Blount and Gen. Pickens met a full deputation of Chickasaw and a small representation of Choctaw chiefs at Nashville, and made a large distribution of presents. At this treaty a Creek chief named Coteatay was present, and on his return home through the lower Cherokee towns made a lying report of a " talk" which Gen. Robertson had made him, which was to tliis effect : " There has been a great deal of blood spilt in our settlements, and I will come and sweep it out clean with your blood. And now take notice that the first mischief that is done I will come." His advice to the Cherokees was that they had better prepare for war and strike the first blow. All of this was reported to the Governor with much naivete by Watts, the Glass, and the Bloody Fellow, accompanied with new declarations of amity, saying that they had ordered home all parties that were out and likely to do mischief, and that there would be no occasion for Gen. Robertson to put his threat in execution. At that very time the scalp and eagle-tail dances were being held at the lower towns, and men being embodied for an attack on the Cumberland settlements in heavy force. However, the news of these warlike preparations reached the Governor througli a friendly Indian two days before the peace-talks of the chiefs sent from Lookout, and he at once dispatched orders to Gen. Robertson to call into service a part of the brigade of the Mero District, by which term the three counties on tlie Cumberland were officially designated. Two days later, on the 14th, the talk of the chiefs came to hand, and so thoroughly deceived him that he discredited the first report and revoked the order for the assembling of the militia, saying, " I congratulate you and the people of the Mero District upon the happy change of affairs. I had dreadful apprehensions for you." On the 16th he received positive information that the Cherokees had crossed the river and were on the march for the Cumberland, and he then issued orders not only for the assembling of the brigade of Gen. Robertson, but that of Gen. Sevier, urging them to delay not an hour, that the danger was imminent.
In the mean time tidings of the meditated invasion had reached the settlements from another source. Early in September, Findleston, a half-breed Cherokee, and Duval, a French trader, came direct from the nation under pretense of spying for the Indians and then returning, and stated in the most positive manner that over six hundred Cherokees and Creeks had crossed the Tennessee, and would attack Nashville on the full of the moon. Findleston offered to go to jail as a surety for the truth of his assertion. The news quickly spread to all of the stations and roused the inhabitants to a sense of the impending danger. So when the order came assembling the militia they turned out at once, ready and equipped for the conflict, and assembled at Rains' big spring, two miles south of Nashville. Their numbers are variously stated at from three to seven hundred.
Alexander Castleman, one of the trustiest and most daring spies among the settlers, was now out to get precise information of the hostile approach. He went as far as the Black Fox camp, where Murfreesboro' now stands, and finding it deserted by the friendly Indians who had been hunting there, his suspicions were aroused, and on proceeding beyond he discovered the fresh trail uf a large body of Indians coming in the direction of Nashville. He returned at once and reported the facts, but the enemy not appearing as soon as was expected, Capt. John Rains and Abraham Kennedy were sent out. They were gone some days, and on their return Capt. Rains said he had seen no " Indian sign, but plenty of bear sign." To this he made oath, but Kennedy refused to be sworn. On this report, which was made on Friday before the attack on Buchanan's Station, the militia, who had become impatient to return home, not thinking their services would be needed, were disbanded. However, on Sunday morning, some of the inhabitants, who were not thoroughly satisfied as to the absence of danger, took the further precaution to send out two other spies, - Gee and Clayton. They never returned, and at midnight of the same day Buchanan's was attacked.
They proceeded on the bufi'alo-path until they reached a point on the ridge dividing the waters of Duck River and Mill Creek, where a hurricane had blown down the timber. Here the path divided, and a disagreement arising between them as to which they should take they separated, each following his own path. They had not proceeded far before they concluded that it would be safer to come together again, and began to holloa to each other for this purpose. It happened that they were in the vicinity of a large body of Indians, then on their way to attack the stations, and were overheard by the advance-guard, among j whom was George Fields, a half-breed Cherokee, who understood and could speak English. Fields decoyed the two spies into the woods by calling to them to '- meet half-way." This they started to do, when one of them was killed and the other fled and was likely to make his escape when he was hailed by Fields and informed that the killing was done by the accidental discharge of a gun and that they were friends. He thereupon halted and was quickly killed and scalped. That night at ten o'clock Buchanan's Station was attacked by eight or nine hundred Cherokees and Creeks, led by John Watts and Chiatohattalla, son of Torn Tumbridge, a deserter from the British army, and an Indian woman. When the Indians came in hearing of the sound of the lowing of the cattle at the fort a dispute arose between Watts and Chiatohattalla as to whether Nashville or Buchanan's should be first attacked. Watts concluded that Nashville was the chief object of attack, and " that little fort could be taken on their return," pointing to Buchanan's. The other chief then called Watts a woman, and said he could take the fort himself; that he had burnt one fort, referring to Zigler's Station, in Sumner County, and that he could burn another. Watts thereupon retorted that he might go ahead and take it ; that he would look on. At the time of the attack there were only about twenty men in the fort, which was known as Maj. John Buchanan's Station. The assault was made about eleven o'clock at night, Sept. 30, 1792. Morris Shane, who was on guard at the block-house nearest the creek, was the first to discover and fire upon a body of Indians congregated at the fort gate. Thomas Kennedy then fired into the same group from the opposite house. At the first alarm a runner was dispatched to Nashville for assistance, and Anthony Fisher of that place was the first to enter the fort, closely followed by John Rains, just as the enemy were retiring but still in sight. The Indians on being fired into retired into an open cellar a short distance ofl", and to such other shelter as they could get around the ibrt, whence they opened a warm fire on the port-holes, yelling at the same time like fiends incarnate. The whites were quickly at their posts, and returned the fire in the most spirited manner. Mrs. Buchanan and Mrs. Shane leaped out of their beds at the first alarm, and taking no time to dress began to mould bullets, which they carried around to the men, and also a supply of brandy, adding words of cheer as they passed along. Jimmy O'Connor, an Irishman, took charge of a blunderbuss, and in the noise and confusion he charged his piece several times before it went off. When it did fire Jimmy was landed under a bed on the opposite side of the room badly bruised, but he declared he " made a lane through the yellow dogs." In the midst of the assault Chiatohattalla made a most daring attempt to fire the fort. He was quickly shot down and mortally wounded, but, with the ruling passion strong in death, he continued to blow the fire as long as life lasted. The assault lasted about an hour and a half, when the Indians began to withdraw. Only one man in the fort was wounded, and he by a splinter. Tiiousands of balls had penetrated the logs, but comparatively few had penetrated to the interior. During the firing there was a constant parley going on between the parties, Thomas Kennedy calling out to the Indians that they were a " set of damned squaws," and " to put more powder into their guns." Chiatehattalla was the only Indian found dead. He was greatly dreaded bj' the whites on account of his use of fire to destroy a fort, and was known by them as the " Shawnee warrior." This appellation was a mistake, caused by the report tliat an old Shawnee chief had come from the North among the Southern tribes to introduce this practice, which had been put in sucoessful operation in the destruction of Zigler's Station some time before. Many others of the a.ssailants were supposed to have been killed and wounded from the traces of blood left on their departure. John Watts, the head chief, received a desperate wound in the hip, and was carried down behind the spring-house. Supposing himself mortally wounded, he begged George Fields, who was wounded in the heel, to cut off his head and carry it away to keep the whites from getting his scalp. His comrades, however, made a litter of blankets and carried him oiF. He recovered and lived many years afterwards, removing with his tribe west of the Mississippi. The whites ventured out the morning after the attack in pursuit, but were fired upon from a cedar-glade after going a short distance, when they returned. The Indians, however, becoming disheartened by the failure of their attack and the death of their bravest warrior and desperate wounding of Watts, retreated rapidly. The little swivel at Nashville had been firing signal-guns, and this seemed to add to their alarm. They left on the ground a number of guns, swords, tomahawks, blankets, and other articles of value. The defeat and failure of such a large force was another illustration of the want of harmony and discipline which characterized such attacks.
For the period of two months after this repulse not a hostile Indian appeared in the settlements. It augured well for peace, but as a company of cavalry was along a trail one day south of Nashville about eight miles, a volley was poured into them accompanied by the old familiar yell. The whites retreated in disorder, with the loss of John Hawkins, who halted to point an empty gun at the pursuers by way of intimidation. He was killed,. scalped, and cut to pieces. The cavalry got some addition to their numbers and returned to the place of conflict without meeting the enemy. Several other persons were killed in December, among them John Haggard, a spy, whose wife had been killed the previous summer.
On the 5th of January Governor Blount wrote to Gen. Robertson to discharge Sharpe's brigade, but that he might organize a company of infantry and eighteen horsemen in its place. The Governor was led to this by the seeming contrite confession of Watts, which the fears of himself and people had induced him to make in most humble terms. On the reception of this the Governor, in order to confirm and strengthen such good resolutions, distributed a number of presents among them and appointed a conference at the Southwest Point, the outpost in East Tennessee, for April the 17th. But in the months of January and February so many murders had boon committed, in connection with information he had obtained of an invasion about the full of the moon in April, on the 25th, that on the 28tli of March he ordered Gen. Robertson to increase his force to eighty men, and scour the woods for fifty miles from the settlements, but not to go beyond those limits unless in a case of imminent danger, when he might go to the Tennessee River. On April 14th he notified the general that "large bodies of Creeks had crossed the Tennessee for war and plunder." Maj. Beard's troop was ordered to the assistance of Gen. RoberLson. He scoured the woods back and forth, and returned to Knoxville early in June. Oapts. Rains and Johnston were also out on the same service, but were enabled to kill only a fiiw Indians. Still they rendered much service in breaking up the station-camps of the enemy in proximity to the settlements, and forcing them back to the shelter of the mountain-caves. Notwithstanding this, small bands came in and committed great havoc to life and property.
Abe Castleman'S Expedition
ABE CASTLEMAN'S EXPEDITION. In July Joseph Castleman was killed and John Castleman badly wounded in a field near Hays' Station, situated ton miles from Nashville, on Stoner's Creek. The Castlemans, on account of their contempt of danger, had suffered severely. They were among the earliest hunters and settlers, and had rendered signal service in shielding and guarding the infant settlements. At this new affliction he raised a company of volunteers to go as far as the Tennessee River with him on a hunt for Indians, and applied to General Robertson for permission to carry out the design. General Robertson sympathized with his sufferings and desire for revenge, and granted him the permission to seek satisfaction in his own way. His party consisted of sixteen men, some of whom agreed to go only as far as the Tennessee River. By the time he arrived at this boundary, although he had killed several Indians, his revenge was far from being satisfied, and he proposed to cross the river and carry the war into the enemy's country. Five of his party agreed to go with him, to wit: Frederick StuU, Zaoh Maclin, Jack Camp, Eli Hammond, and Zeke Caruthers, the rest returning to the settlements. Here they stripped themselves of their clothing, donned flaps, and painted their bodies in imitation of Indians to more eff"eotually carry out their purpo.se. Thus equipped they swam the river a short distance below Nickajack, and struck into a trail which they thought led to Wills' Town. They had not proceeded far before they came in view of a party of Creek warriors, numbering about fifty, seated on the ground in couples and engaged in eating. They were painted and unaccompanied by squaws, showing that they were on the war-path. Castleman's men were so well disguised that the Indians exhibited no concern at their approach, and continued their eating. On arriving within a convenient distance the whites made ready on a signal from their leader, and bringing down their guns fired into the groups, each man selecting an individual target. Castleman, whose gun was doubly charged, killed two, and the others one each. The fire was so sudden and destructive that the Indians were thrown into great disorder and confusion, in the midst of which the daring little band made their retreat in safety across the river, where they resumed their proper clothing, and thence returned to the settlements after an absence of three weeks, well satisfied with their adventure. It was ascertained afterwards that a chief of the Creeks was killed in this aifair, which added greatly to their exasperation. During the month of August and following a number of savage butchcries of women and children took place in the Men District. About the 1st of December James Robertson, a son of the general, was killed, making the tliird who had fallen a victim to the deadly hate of the enemy.
Provenance
Text from History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.