Davidson County, Tennessee - Chapter 20: Courts, 1880
From History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. 3,252 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
28 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
- Chapter 20: Courts
- Inferior Court Of Pleas And Quarter Sessions
- First Mill
- First Road Laid Out
- Hon. David Campbell
- Hon. Joseph Anderson
- Hon. Archibald Koane
- Hon. Willie Blount
- Hon. William C. C. Claiborne
- Hon. Howell Tatum
- Hon. Andrew Jackson
- Hon. Hugh L. White
- Hon. John Overton
- Hon. Thomas Emmerson Hon. Parry W. Humphreys
- Hon. Samuel Powel
- Hon. George W. Campbell
- Hon. Archibald Roane
- Hon. Robert Whyte
- Hon. John Haywood
- Hon. Jacob Peck Hon. William L. Bkown
- Hon. John Catron
- Hon. Henry Crabb Hon. Nathan Green
- Judges Of The Supreme Court
- Court Of Chancert
- Criminal Court
- Law Court Op Nashville
- Judge
- Convention Of Is34, For The Revision Of The Constitution
The text
3,252 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Chapter 20: Courts
Inferinr Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions - First Session in Davidson - Full List of Justices and Judges of the County - Clerks - Sheriffs - Circuit Court Record - Supreme Court of Law and Equity - Superior Court of Errors and Appeals - Court of Chancery - Law Court - Criminal Court.
Inferior Court Of Pleas And Quarter Sessions
INFERIOR COURT OF PLEAS AND QUARTER SESSIONS. Under an act of North Carolina, of Oct. 6, 1783, the Governor issued commissions to four of the citizens on the
Cumberland - to wit : Isaac Bledsoe, Samuel Barton, Francis Prince, and Isaac Lindsay - to organize " An Inferior Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions" at Nasliborough. This Inferior Court was by the act invested with extraordinary powers, and embraced a very wide range of subjects. It was, in fact, invested with jurisdiction over all the legal, judicial, legislative, executive, military, and prudential affairs of the county. It was like a country store in a now and frontier state of society, which is supplied with all sorts of' miscellaneous commodities adapted to the wants of the early settlers, but as order and population advance and society becomes more systematized, these things are separated and distributed into different branches and departments, according to the wants and demands of a more civilized community ; so the general and miscellaneous functions discharged by the first court became after a time separated and assigned to different branches of a systematic judiciary, demanded by a more perfect state of society.
At first as many of the justices of the Inferior Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions as could attend sat in court together. This continued to be the practice until the January term of 1791, when, " the several commissions of the peace being all of the same date, it was agreed by the court that each person named in the commission of the peace, with others who had been in former commissions, should all place their names upon separate tickets, which should be drawn in three classes, and a reserve. Samuel Barton was elected to succeed Robert Hay as chairman. Several subsequent attempts were made to form four separate benches for the different sessions, but without success, as each had to draw on the other for members to form a quorum."
The first emancipation of negro slaves within the county was ordered by this court April 18, 1801, on the petition of Thomas Molloy, Esq., " praying leave of the court to emancipate three slaves, - Sam, Sophi, and Harry, - or either of them, free by deed at any time hereafter, and the same may be entered ou record."
At the first session of the Davidson County Court, Anthony Bledsoe and James Mulherin were both candidates for the ofiice of surveyor. The vote resulting in a tie, that office was left vacant until the ensuing court. Samuel Ma.son was appointed constable at Maulding's, James Mc- Cain at Mansker's, Stephen Ray at Ilcatonsburg, John Mc- Adaras at Nasliborough, and Edward Swanson at Freelaud's Station. James Freeland was appointed overseer of the road from Nasliborough to as fiir as opposite Mr. Buchanan's spring, and Josiah Shaw from Mansker's to said spring, with authority to call together as many of the inhabitants of their respective stations as should be necessary.
The following persons were named by the court as the first grand jurymen: James Shaw, Ebenezor Titus, James Mulherin, Isaac Johnson, Daniel Williams, Sr., Robert Espey, John Buchanan, William Gowen, James Freeland, George Freeland, Francis Hodge, John Thomas, Heydan Wells, David Rounsevall, James Hollis, Sr., John Hamilton, Capt. Gasper Mansker, Benjamin Kuykendall, Elmore
First Mill
'' The Court give leave to Headon Wells to build a water grist-mill on Thomas' Creek, about a quarter and a half a. quarter up said creek from the mouth."
First Road Laid Out
" January 6. - On motion made to the Court concerning allegations against George Montgomery, as an aider and abettor in the treasonable piratical proceedings carried in the Mississippi against the Spaniards, it is the opinion of the Court that the said M. be in security in the sum of one hundred and fifty pounds for his appearance at our next Court, on which Elijah Robertson and Stephen Ray became securities for his appearance.
" William Cocke and John Sevier were ofi"ered as securities on the bond of Matthew Talbot, elected as Clerk. It is the opinion of the Court that he is not entitled thereto.
" The following military officers were sworn : Anthony Bledsoe, 1st Colonel; Isaac Bledsoe, 1st Major; Samuel Barton, 2d Major; Gasper Mansker, 1st Captain; George Freeland, 2d ; John Buchanan, 3d ; James Ford, 4th ; William Ramsey, Jonathan Drake, Ambrose Maulding, and Peter Sides, Lieutenants ; William Collins and Elmore Douglass, Ensigns.
" 1784, April 5.- - Court met at the house where Jonathan Drake lately lived. Adjourned to meet immediately in the house in Nashborough where Israel Harmon lately lived."
We give below a complete list of the justices, clerks, and sheriffs from the date of organization of the court to the present year, 1880, with the years in which they were commissioned :
Agreeable to the " Act to Reorganize the County Courts of this State," passed by the Legislature of Tennessee, Dec. 3, 1835, the County Court was opened May 2, 1836, by Gilbert G. Washington, Esq., a justice of the former court, and commissions from the Governor of the State were presented, authorizing the following-named gentlemen to serve as justices of the peace in and for the county of Davidson for a "term of six years :
Elihu S. Hall, of Nashville, was elected chairman. Those whose names appear in italics constituted with him the quorum for the ensuing year.
f These were succeeded by Hon. James AVhitworth, who was elected first judge of the County Court of Davidson County on Saturday, I May 3d, and took his oath of office May 9, 1S56, when he immediately took his scat as judge of the Counly Court.
The judges of this court have been Hon. James Whitworth, commissioned Blay 9, 1856, and Blarch, 1858; Hon. William A. Glenn, qualified April 3, 1866, and was his immediate successor.
Hon. William K. Turner first presided over this court in July, and was sworn into office as county judge Sept. 1, 1870. He died while in office, Thursday, Aug. 10, 1871.
Hon. W. A. Glenn was elected by the court to fill the vacancy. His seat was contested by Hon. Thomas T. Smiley, - "Case of State of Tennessee on the election of Thomas T. Smiley, ss. : William A. Glenn," - which resulted in declaring Thomas T. Smiley judge of the County Court of Davidson County, to fill the vacancy occasioned by the death of Hon. W. K. Turner, in accordance with a commission from His Excellency D. W. C. Senter, Governor of Tennessee, dated Aug. 26, 1871. He took his oath and entered upon the duties of his office Feb. 11, 1872. Ho 'was succeeded by Hon. John C. Ferriss, the present judge, Aug. 8, 1872.
" Resolved, That we bid adieu to James Whitworth, late judge of this court, ;with feelings of kindness and heartfelt gratitude for the very able manner in which ho has managed^ the financial affiiirs of this county during the late troublous times incident to the war ; and that' it has been a pleasure to this court to review the acts and deliberations of this court for the last four years, when it is remembered that the County Court has been the only part of the civil machinery belonging to the civil government that has been free and untrammeled and suffi^red to exercise its legal functions, and, as this court is constrained to believe, in a very great measure, attributable to the wise head at the helm."
On the organization of the first court, in 1783, Blatthew Talbott, Esrj., was elected clerk, and given until the opening of the next day's court in which to make his bonds. Failing in this, BIr. Andrew Ewing was elected in his stead the next morning, and continued to fill the position of clerk of the court until Feb. 1, 1813, when his son, Nathan Ewing, qualified as deputy clerk. He resigned in April ensuing, signing his formal resignation upon the record of the court and affixing a seal. Nathan Ewing, who had resigned his position as register in 1812, was then elected clerk .
"At one o'clock p.m., Thomas Crutcher, Esq., treasurer of West Tennessee, came into open court and solemnly announced that Nathan Ewing, clerk of the court, was no more; whereupon, on motion of Andrew Haj's, Esq., attorney-general, the court su.spended all further judicial proceedings, and the following preamble and resolutions were unanimously adopted, and ordered to be entered on record :
" ' Nathan Ewing is dead. His long-continued and useful labors as an officer of this court are at an end ; his place cannot be filled. In the discharge of his official duties he united industry with intelligence, inflexibility with good nature and urbanity, and for a period of forty years stood before the public in a situation of the most delicate trust, not only imputation, but without suspicion ; and it may be stated with confidence that as a clerk he had no superior and scarcely an equal. As a neighbor, a citizen, and Christian he was admired by all. As a father, a husband, and master he was an example worthy of imitation. Penetrated with a just sense of the loss which the public has sustained by his untimely death, and with a view of manifesting our regard for his private virtues, -
" ' Resolved, That the justices of the court, the members of the bar, and the officers of the court will wear crape for thirty days as an evidence of their respect for the memory of Nathan Ewing, late clerk of the court.' "
Pursuant to an act. of the Legislature passed at Knoxville, Nov. 7, 1809, entitled " An Act to Establish Circuit Courts and a Supreme Court of Errors and Appeals," on the 12th day of March, 1810, a commission from William Blount, the Governor of the State of Tennessee, and under seal thereof, bearing date the 24th day of November, 1809, directed to Thomas Stuart, to be judge of the Fourth Circuit, was produced and read. The Circuit Court for Davidson County was thereupon organized and proceeded to business.
At the last session of September, 1861, the court met, but no judge was present. The clerk, David C. Love, Esq., recorded the meetings of the court March 3, 4, and 5, 1862 ; Sept. 1, 2, and 3, 1863 ; and March 2, 3, and 4, 1863, no judge being present on either occasion. The next court convened Sept. 5, 1861, and was presided over by Judge Brien.
The Supreme Court of Tennessee was organized under the Constitution of 1834. It was preceded by the Superior Court of Law and Equity, from 1790 to 1810, and by the Supreme Court of Errors and Appeals, from 1810 to 1834.
Hon. David Campbell
A judge under the authority of North Carolina, appointed by the President in the spring of 1790 Territorial judge. Upon the Territory south of the Ohio being admitted into the Union as the State of Tennessee, Judge Campbell went out of office. He was again appointed a judge of the Superior Courts in the fall of 1797 by the Legislature, vice W. C. C. Claiborne resigned ; went out of office on the abolition of the District or Superior Courts, on the 1st of January, 1810, and in the session of Congress, 1810 and 1811, was appointed by the President one of the judges of the Mississippi Territory, and died in the fall of
In the spring of 1797 he was appointed district judge of the Federal courts for the State of Tennessee, which office he held till his death, in 1831 (?)
Hon. Joseph Anderson
Appointed by the President Territorial judge in February, 1791 ; continued in that office till the spring of 1796, when the Territory ceased and the State took its place. He was then appointed a senator in Congress.
Hon. Archibald Koane
Appointed by the Legislature of the State in April, 1796; resigned in June, 1801. In August following he was elected Governor for two years, and in November, 1811, appointed circuit judge.
Hon. Willie Blount
Appointed in April, 1796 ; resigned in September following. In August, 1809, elected Governor for two years, and again elected to the same office in August, 1811.
Hon. William C. C. Claiborne
Appointed by the Executive, vice Willie Blount resigned, in the fall of 1796. In the summer of 1797 he resigned, and was elected a member of the House of Representatives, and by re-elections continued in Congress until appointed by the President Governor of the Mississippi Territory, in the year 1801. After the Territory of Orleans was formed he was appointed by the President Governor of that Territory, and was also elected Governor of the State in the fall of 1812.
Hon. Howell Tatum
Appointed by the Governor in May, 1797, vke John McNairy ; resigned in June, 1798, and subsequently appointed by the Legislature commissioner of land-claims.
Hon. Andrew Jackson
United States senator from Tennessee ; resigned in June, 1798; in the fall or winter of that year was appointed a judge of the Superior Courts ; continued in office until June, 1804, when he resigned, having been appointed major-general of the militia.
Hon. Hugh L. White
Appointed by the Legislature in the fall of 1801, vice Archibald Roane; resigned in April, 1807 ; the same year elected a' Senator in the State Legislature ; in the fall of 1809 appointed by the Legislature one of the judges of the Supreme Court of Errors and Appeals, which office he held till Deo. 31, 1814, when he resigned, and was afterwards appointed president of the State Bank.
Hon. John Overton
Former supervisor of the revenue of the United States, appointed in July, 1804, a judge of the Superior Courts, vice Andrew Jackson, resigned ; went out of office on the abolition of those courts &n the 1st of January, 1810. In November, 1811, he was appointed by the Legislature one of the judges of the Supreme Court of Errors and Appeals, vice George W. Campbell.
Hon. Thomas Emmerson Hon. Parry W. Humphreys
Appointed an additional judge of the Superior Courts in the fall of 1807 ; continued in office till the abolition of those courts on the 1st of January, 1810, having in the preceding fall been appointed one of the judges of the Circuit Courts. In April, 1813, he was elected a member of Congress, and thereupon resigned the office of circuit judge.
Hon. Samuel Powel
Appointed by the Legislature in the fall of 1807, vice Hugh L. White, resigned ; continued in office until the abolition of the Superior Courts. In the fall of 1812 he was elected a circuit judge, which office he declined.
Hon. George W. Campbell
Formerly representative in Congress; was appointed judge by the Legislature in the ftiU of 1809; he continued on the bench till the fall of 1811, when he was elected United States senator.
Appointed by the Governor, May 27, 1815, vice H. L. White, resigned ; also appointed by the Legislature, Oct. 21, 1815, and remained in office until his-death, July 20, 1816.
The vacancy had been tendered by the Governor to Samuel Powel, of Rogersville, January 2d; to Enoch Parsons, of Maryville, in January ; to George Duffield, of Elizabethtown, in February; and to John Williams, of Knoxville, in March, 1815 ; but they had severally declined. Mr. Powel was afterwards elected to Congress, and Blr. Williams to the United States Senate.
Hon. Archibald Roane
HON. ARCHIBALD ROANE. Appointed by the Legislature as third, or an additional, judge of the Supreme Court of Errors and Appeals, Oct. 21, 1815.
Hon. Robert Whyte
Appointed by the Legislature, May 22, 1816, vice John Overton, resigned, and continued in office till the court was abolished in 1834 by the adoption of the new Constitution. Judge Haywood had been offered the appointment, April 23, 1816, but had declined.
Hon. John Haywood
HON. JOHN HAYWOOD. Appointed by the Legislature, Sept. 1-1, 1816, vice William W. Cooke, deceased, and remained on the bench till his death, Dec. 22, 1826.
Hon. Jacob Peck Hon. William L. Bkown
Appointed by the Legislature in 1822, upon the resignation of Judge Emmerson, and resigned in 182-1, and Hon. Henry Crabb was appointed in his place.
Hon. John Catron
HON. JOHN CATRON. Appointed by the Legislature in December, 182-t, vice William L. Brown, resigned, and remained upon the bench until superseded by the election under the new Con.stitution of 1834. He was afterwards, in March, 1837, appointed a judge of the Supreme Court of the United States.
Hon. Henry Crabb Hon. Nathan Green
Appointed by the Legislature, in 1831, an additional judge, and remained on the bench till the change of the court under the Constitution of 1834.
Nine of the above judges - viz., Messrs. McNairy, Tatum, Jackson, Overton, Campbell, Emmerson, Cooke, Haywood, and Whyte - were residents of Davidson County; the others resided chiefly or wholly in East Tennessee.
Judges Of The Supreme Court
In May, 1869, there was an election by the people, under the restricted suflFrages which then prevailed, and the following judges were chosen :
Of the judges of the Supreme Court since 1834 only Messrs. Caruthers, Nicholson, and Cooper are, or have been, residents of Davidson County.
Judges of the Supreme Court were elected by the Legisture till 1853, at which date, by provision of the revised Constitution, they became elective by the people, and hold their office eight years instead of twelve, as under the former Constitution. District and State attorneys also hold for a term of eight years.
Court Of Chancert
From the adoption of the Constitution of 1834 to 1847 the Court of Chancery was held at Franklin. In the latter year a Court of Chancery was established at Nashville for
Davidson County. Hon. Terry H. Cahal was appointed chancellor in 1S4G, and continued to occupy that station till his death, which occurred in February, 1851. We give
Benjamin Litton, clerk of the Court of Chancery-for Williamson County, was a resident of Nashville, and resided till his death at the Litton place, where the Vanderbilt University now stands. He was a brother of Mr. Isaac Litton, one of the present justices of the County Court.
Criminal Court
This court was organized under the revised Constitution of 1853, and originally embraced Davidson, Rutherford, Sumner, and Montgomery Counties. On the 17th of June, 1870, its limits were reduced to Davidson and Rutherford Counties. The judges of this court have been as follows:
Law Court Op Nashville
LAW COURT OP NASHVILLE. This court was established by act of the Legislature in 1870, with jurisdiction of law causes for Davidson and Sumner Counties. The first term began in Nashville on the first Monday of September, 1870.
Judge
Hon. Josephus C. Guild, elected by the people for a term of eight years, and occupied the bench till September, 1878, when the court was abolished by the Legislature.
We subjoin the following list of United States Senators and Representatives from Davidson County, with the number of the Congres^s in which they served : convened at Knosville, January 11th, and adjourned Feb. 6, 1796. Hon. William Blount, President ; William Maclin, Secretary ; John Sevier, Jr., Reading and Engrossing Clerk.
Of the two members from each county appointed by the Convention to draft the Constitution, Hon. John McNairy and Hon. Andrew Jackson were appointed for Davidson.
Convention Of Is34, For The Revision Of The Constitution
Delegates from Davidson. - Francis B. Fogg, Robert Weakley. Three only of the members of this Convention from the whole State are living at this writing, viz. : Francis B. Fogg, of Davidson ; West H. Humphreys, of Fayette ; and Boiling Gordon, of Hickman.
Provenance
Text from History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.