Davidson County, Tennessee - Bench and Bak of Davidson County, 1880
From History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. 15,482 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
25 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
- Bench and Bak of Davidson County
- Bench And Bar
- Members Of The Bar Associ.A.Tion
- Hon. .John Overton
- Thomas Stuart
- Robert Whyte
- Hon. Felix Grundy
- Hon. John Haywood
- Hon. James Trimble
- Bench And Bae
- Oliver B. Hays
- George S. Yerger
- Gen. George W. Gibbs
- Hon. John C.Vtron
- Bench And Bak Patrick H. Dauby
- Hon. Henry Crabb
- Thomas H. Fletcher
- Hon. Tiiojias Washington
- Hon. James Rucks
- Hon. Thomas Claiborne
- David Craighead
- Gen. Sam Houston
- William E. Anderson
- Andrew C. Hayes
- George W. Campbell
The text
15,482 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Bench and Bak of Davidson County
Status of the Legal Profession - List of Admissions to the Davidson County Bar - Bar Association - Biographical Slietches of Prominent Lawyers and Judges.
From the earliest period of the history of our country the legal profession has constituted a most valuable and important element in society. In all countries where jurisprudence has reached the dignity of a science, it has become more complicated and minute in its ramifications from one generation to another, extending through all the frame-work of society, from the greatest to the least of human concerns, and exerting an omnipresent spell and power second only to that of religion itself To people thus educated reverence for the law becomes a powerful and controlling sentiment, and this reverence attaches in a very large degree to the outward exponents and officers of the law, whose duty it is to expound and apply its principles, to pronounce its authoritative judgments, and to enforce and execute its mandates.
In proportion as a country is free or despotic, in proportion as her laws are oppressive or just and beneficent, does this reverence become a fear and a dread, or, on the other hand, a loving and cordial appreciation of that which is designed to subserve the highest ends of justice and liberty among the people. Hence a very different feeling prevails towards lawyers and judges in a free country from that which exists in a country ruled more or less by despotic power. In the one case they are dreaded as more or less the tools and agents of irresponsible and arbitrary rulers ; in the other they are loved and venerated as the wise and just executors of laws of their own enactment, based upon an authority emanating from the people themselves and designed to promote the welfare of the humblest citizen. Especially does this reverence become a cordial and an affectionate sentiment, and promotive of the highest influence for good, when the characters of these legal executors become conspicuous for honor, for patriotism, for eminent abilities, for learning, for high culture, and for all the domestic and social virtues.
In a free country, like our own, members of the legal profession exert an influence which they can nowhere else attain. They are not merely expounders and administrators of the law, but law-makers also; not only counselors and jurists, but legislators as well. It is not only a fact apparent at the present time that a large proportion of the members of our legislative bodies, both State and national, are lawyers, but it has always been so from the foundation of our government. The fact did not escape the observation of that great statesman, Edmund Burke, who remarked on a very grave and interesting occasion in Parliament, when our national struggle for independence was in progress, that in both the national and colonial Legislatures, and in the first Congress of the Union, a much larger proportion of lawyers wore occupants of seats in those bodies than had been elsewhere known. This order of things, which began with the first legislative bodies of our government, has continued to the present time in all the States of the Union.
Bench And Bar
The influential bur of Diividson County has furnished a , striking illustration of this rule, from the time when Jackson and Grundy, Campbell and Whiteside, Houston and S Peyton, Bell and Foster, Cooper and Harris, and many other bright lights, among whom are the Browns, the Ewings, the Claibornes and the Trimbles, carried their great talents and abilities from the legal profession to the halls of Congress and the State Legislature. From this profession, too, how many have graduated up to the highest bench of the State and nation, and worn the judicial ermine with honor to themselves and their country !
On looking over the following sketches of lawyers and judges, it will be seen how large a proportion of them have been sent to the legislative bodies, both State and national. The plan of the present subject, the bench and bar of Davidson County, has been arranged in sueh a manner as to give first a list of the lawyers of the county, with dates of their admission to the bar, and then to follow the list with personal sketches of greater or less length of the more prominent and noticeable members.
1829. - Orville Ewing, Felix Catron, George W. Foster, Samuel Watson, Henry A. Wise, William L. Washington, Thomas J. Lacy, Micajah Claiborne, John A. Walker.
Members Of The Bar Associ.A.Tion
To this list should be added the following-named members of the Davidson bar, not members of the Bar Association, the dates of whose admission to the bar have not been obtained. Some of them are noticed in sketches further on in this chapter : J. B. White, Neill S. Brown, Thomas T. Smiley, George Stubblefield, Jackson B. White, George Maney, Mattheiv W. Allen, M. M. Brien, Nathaniel Baxter, J. W. Ilorton, Jr., E. H. East, John C. Grant.
The above list of admissions to the Davidson County bar contains the names of but three lawyers of any considerable note up to 1806 : these are Andrew Jackson, Thomas Stuart, and Robert Whyte. With respect to Jackson, it may be remarked that he exhibited no special greatness either as a lawyer or as a jurist, nor did he remain long in the profession. His taste, his ambition, and his providential calling led him into other fields in which his great talents were fully displayed, and where he won imperishable I'enowu. The life of Gen. Jackson, as a hero, patriot, and statesman, will be found in another part of this work. It is only necessary to record here the few brief facts respecting his early career as a lawyer and judge. He read law and obtained license to practice before emigrating from liis native State. When he came to Nashville he was admitted to the Davidson County bar, at the date above given,
1789, and practiced in the courts here with other early lawyers several years. For about six years he exercised the functions of judge of the Supreme Court of Tennessee, from the autumn of 1798 to the month of June, 1804, when he was appointed major-general, and was succeeded on the bench by Hon. John Overton.
Hon. .John Overton
Judge Overton was born in Louisa Co., Va., the 9th day of April, 1766. His family was not wealthy, and his education was only such as could be procured at that day in; the best common schools of Virginia. While a youth he taught school for several years, chiefly for the purpose of educating his brothers and sisters ; but his attention sooHi ' became directed towards the profession of the law, in which numbers of his family connections, the Wythos, Tazwells, and Currs, had become highly distinguished. He removed to Kentucky before his majority, studied law there, but, it is believed, began the practice in Nashville, Tenn. The litigation then was chiefly concerning the titles to real estate, and old lawyers, as well in Kentucky as Tennessee, will remember that there was a good deal of it, and very profitable it was too. A good land-lawyer was the highest eminence of the profession. Judge Overton at once obtained a full practice, and by his industry and atteijtion to business kept it till he was transferred to the bench. , A system of law, based upon the acts of 1777 and 1783 of the North Carolina Legislature, disposing of lands in the Territory of Tennessee, had to be built up by the bar and bench of Tennessee, and Overton, as lawyer and judge, exercised considerable influence in moulding the system to suit the wants and necessities of the new community. The English law-books failed to afford a precedent for settling the titles to boundaries of adjacent wild lands, involving the questions of special entries, younger grants, elder entries, the ages -of marks on trees, the authority of plats to control the calls in grants, and various other points springing from the peculiar system adopted by North Carolina; and hence the difficulty of the task which had to be encountered by our earlier judges. The constructions of our land-laws, as ruled whilst Overton was on the bench, became established law, and the points arc not now controverted in the courts. He i was conscientious in the discharge of his duties, giving to 1 every case, no matter how small the amount involved, a patient attention, and stucli/ing it before he delivered an opinion. His private journal, now in the possession of his son-in-law, shows that during vacation he was constantly engaged in studying the cases which had been laid over from the last term, and there is an abstract of the principal points of almost every case that was before the court whilst he was a member.
He was appointed supervisor of the revenue of the United States, and held the office till it was abolished by Congress. The office was one of responsibility and trust, and, as a mark of his industry, it may be proper to state that he kept copies of every letter to his various agents, his correspondence with the department at Washington, and of even the minutest transaction, so that a correct statement of the business and accounts of his office could now, after the lapse of half a century, be accurately made.
In 1804 he was elected a judge of the Superior Court of Law and Equity, in place of Gen. Jackson, wlio resigned, and held the office till the abolition of the court on the 1st day of January, ISIO. During this period Judge Overton was also appoiiiteJ by the Legislature as agent to confer with the Legislature of North Carolina respecting the landtitles of the separate States, and to make such agreement, stipulation, or compromise as might be necessary. The appointment evidences the estimation in which Judge Overton was held as a land-lawyer. In November, 1811, he was elected a judge of the Supreme Court in place of Hon. George W. Campbell, who was transferred to the Senate of the United States, and continued to discharge the duties of said office till his resignation in 1816. Overton's Reports run through a series of years from 1791 to 1817, and arc valuable as a repository of the land-law, now almost obsolete, however, as tlie healing power of the statute of limitations has cured all titles originally defective, and titles at this day are seldom controverted except on principles arising from irregular sales, the construction of wills, etc.
After Judge Overton's retirement from the bench he practiced in important cases, and used the same industry and energy that had characterized his early professional life. His private business also required his attention, and that, with his limited but important practice, kept him constantly engaged. He never knew what it was to be idle, and always did well what he undertook. Judge Overton and Gen. Jackson wore throughout their lives firm and unwavering friends, and it was singular that individuals differing in many points of character should have such an ardent attachment for each other. Gen. Jackson seldom advised with anybody but Judge Overton, and it is said, by those who know, that it was his custom to consult Judge Overton upon all important subjects; he certainly had a very high respect for his opinion, and a confidential correspondence was carried on between them till the day of Judge Overton's death. During the Presidential campaigns of 182-1 and 1S28, Judge Overton labored assiduously for the success of Gen. Jackson. He had the happiness to see his early and fast friend elected to the Presidency, and immediately withdrew from political strife. Tlie relations of Gen. Jackson and Judge Overton were most intimate and confidential and unreserved on all subjects of men and measures. A few days before Judge Overton's death he caused all the correspondence of Gen. Jackson, embracing a life-time (for Judge Overton never lost or mislaid a paper or letter), to be brought to his bedside. Political excitement was then at the highest pitch, and the war between Jackson and the Bank was raging. He reflected that, after his death, many of those letters, intended for his own eye, might fall into the hands of his friend's enemies, and garbled extracts find their way to the public, - such a thing had happened and might happen again, - few would be living wlio could explain the circumstances under which they were written, time and the events of life might have induced a change of opinion concerning men and things, and with a singular prudence he committed the correspondence to the flames, remarking that, living or dead, ho would not betray the confidence of a friend. It is a matter of regret that this correspondence was not preserved and trusted to a judicious and impartial historian. It would have developed the true character of Gen. Jackson, and have shown that, in addition to all the honorable, noble, and generous qualities of which the world is well aware in the character of that groat man, he was also a reflecting, thinking, prudent man, - there was a degree of coolness in all his rashness.
Judge Overton died the 12th day of April, 1833, at his residence, near Nashville. He was an influential citizen. He had some peculiar idiosyncrasies of character, but was universally respected and loved by his family and a chosen body of friends, who cherished for him the warmest affection. His success in the pursuits of life was very great, and, though economical in the smallest particulars, he was liberal towards all public improvements and institutions, and by his will gave handsome legacies to many of his wife's relatives. He predicted the success of George S. Yerger, of Mississippi, as a lawyer, and gave him his law library, the largest then in the West ; he was of a discriminating mind, and read character well. Though his life was emphatically one of business, overflowing with private and public duties, and though his large private interests often brought him into conflict with others, no word of suspicion was ever whispered against his character, and his children are justly proud of the name ho has left them.
Judge Overton left three children, two of whom, a son and a daughter (Mrs. John M. Lea), reside in Nashville ; the other daughter married Mr. R. C. Brinkley, of Memphis, and has departed this life.
Thomas Stuart
Thomas Stuart was an active, industrious, and laborious lawyer; was for many years judge of the Circuit Court at Nashville, and retired from that position upon the adoption of the Constitution of 183-4. He was then a very old man, and retired to his farm in Williamson County. He practiced law in a feeble way in the courts of that county, coming into court on crutches, which he was obliged to use from an accidental injury. He died, it is believed, about 1840.
Robert Whyte
ROBERT WHYTE. Robert Whyte was a Scotchman by birth, and a very excellent lawyer and judge. He vacated the bench of the Supreme Court in 1834 upon the adoption of the new Constitution, having served as an honored judge for many years. He was then a feeble old man ; he lived to a great age, but appeared no more in public life after his retirement from the bench. He was a laborious and accurate lawyer, and exceedingly tenacious of his views and opinions. His opinions as a judge are remarkable for laborious research and accuracy. (See Haywood's, Peck's, Blartin and Yerger's, and 1 Yerger's " Reports.")
JENKIN ^VHITESIDE. " Jenkin Whiteside," says Governor Foote, in his " Bench and Bar of the South and Southwest," " has come down to the men of this generation exclusively as a great landlaiDijer. No one was more familiar than he with all that Coke and Blaokstone and the other English writers have said in their labored and profoundly-reasoned treatises upon the laws of real property. No man had mastered more fully tlian himself the principles involved in the doctrine of executory devises and contingent remainders. No lawyer of his time could talk more learnedly and luminously upon the celebrated rule in S/icIleys case ; and he manifested a steady energy and masterly dexterity in the management of all the sharp points and subtle devices that appertain to the trial of actions of ejectment, which things gave him many advantages over a sluggish and less wily adversary. No man could be more conversant than was Jenkin Whiteside with the whole history of land-titles in Tennessee, as well as with the operations of the land-ofBoes both in that State and North Carolina, - a species of knowledge quite indispensable to success in the arduous but profitable vocation in which ho had enlisted, and upon which his attention had been concentrated in a manner rarely exemplified. He was undoubtedly a man of vigorous understanding, of wonderful sagacity and acuteness, devoted much to money-making, and especially delighting in what was known as speculation in uncultivated lands, of which he had, in one way and another, at difl"erent times, accumulated largo bodies, the titles to which were not rarely involved in troublesome and expensive litigation." From an unfortunate speculation in what was called for many years Balch and Whiteside's addition to Nashville, he died insolvent, and his estate became the subject of very extensive litigation. He lived and died a bachelor. He is described as a man " of rough and unimposing exterior, of awkward and ungainly manners, and had no relish whatever for those elegant and refined pursuits which are understood to distinguish polished and aristocratic communities." Still, he is admitted by all who knew him to have been " civil and unobtrusive in his general demeanor, not deficient in public spirit, and of a coarse and unpretending cordiality which made him many friends and no enemies."
THO.AI.iS 11. BEXTOy. Thomas H. Benton, it will be seen from our list, was admitted to the bar of this county in 1806. He came from North Carolina, where he had received a collegiate education, and taught a small school upon Duck River, not many miles from Franklin, in which latter place he subsequently began the practice of law. From the first it is said that Mr. Benton was " much fonder of political pursuits than of the study of law-books, and greatly preferred the making of stumpspeeches to the argument of legal causes." He, however, possessed great powers, as is clearly evinced in his future almost unbounded control of politics in the Territory and State of Missouri, and his unrivaled career of thirty years in the United States Senate, where he was regarded as the peer of Clay, Webster, and Calhoun. " No man," says a late writer, " was ever more industrious, more persevering, or more fertile in expedients than Mr. Benton." The same writer, however, thinks that " no amount of rhetorical training could ever have enabled Mr. Benton to cope in lively and splendid forensic eloquence with such persons as Mr. Clay or Felix Grundy," or in legal argumentation " to rival the condensed vigor of a Marshall or a Pinckney." " The ready and rapid flow of choice and appropriate words," says our author, " and of earnest, clear, and forcible logic, sometimes bordering upon metaphysical subtlety, and occasionally embellished and adorned with sublime generalities, to which Mr. Calhoun was indebted for so large a portion of his fame and influence, seemed ever to arouse in Mr. Benton a feeling allied to astonishment, not unmixed with an emulation nearly akin to resentment." As a writer Mr. Benton is accorded great excellence : " AVhen he chose to do so, he could express himself on paper with a clearness and precision not often equaled. He had command of a simple, nervous, and idiomatic English style which few of his own generation could boast."
For a year or two of Mr. Benton's residence in Tennessee he was the. law-partner of the Hon. Oliver B. Hays, who became a resident of Nashville in 1808, but whose name does not appear on our list of admissions at the bar. He was probably admitted in Baltimore, where he had studied law before he came here. Mr. Benton probably removed from Tennessee on account of his difficulty with Gen. Jackson respecting the duel of his brother, Jesse, about 1810. He was exceedingly ambitious, and could not brook the ascendency of his great rival. He therefore concluded that, so far as his own personal competition was concerned, he would withdraw from the immediate arena, and leave Jackson " alone in his glory." He removed to St. Louis, where he had things very much his own way, and erected a throne on which he reigned without a rival for the rest of his days. The career of Mr. Benton in politics is one of the most remarkable in the history of our country.*
Hon. Felix Grundy
This eminent jurist and statesman was born in Berkeley Co., Va., on the 11th of September, 1777, and died in Nashville, Tenn., Dec. 19, 1S40. His father was an Englishman, and settled in Kentucky in the year 1780. Felix was educated at Bardstown Academy, and was admitted to the practice of law in the courts of Kentucky, where he soon attained a high reputation. He was a member of the Constitutional Convention of Kentucky in
Such is a brief outline of his record in Kentucky. In the winter of 1807-8 he removed to Nashville, where his fame had pr^jceded him, and for a long series of years maintained a position at the head of the bar as a criminal advocate. He was a member of Congress from 1811 to 1814: ; was in the Tennessee Legislature for several years; was United States senator from 1829 to 1838, and elected to the same oSice in 1810. He was a strong Jackson man, and was United States attorney-general from July 5, 1838, to Dec. 1, 1840.
From the sources of information within our reach respecting Mr. Grundy's forensic character and reputation we select the following. Hon. Edwin H. Ewing, who has kindly furnished us valuable notes on a number of the leading members of the bar of which he himself has long been an honored member, says of Mr. Grundy, - especially on the criminal side of the law. He was a keen jutliie of men and motives. His manner of speaking would now be considered somewhat aiSFected and stilted ; it was, however, very effective for its time. He had very little learning as a lawyer, but was exceedingly quick and skillful in taking up and appropriating the knowledge of others. Of his more public history as a member of Congress of both houses and as attorney-general of the United States, I need not speak."
Judge Guild says, " Felix Grundy will always rank among the greatest men this century has produced. He was Tennessee's greatest criminal advocate, and he was the peer of any the United States has produced. He was not only a great lawj'cr, but was a powerful stump-speaker, and ranked with Henry Clay as an orator before he removed from Kentucky to Tennessee, which occurred about the year 1807. He had been a distinguished member of the Kentucky Legislature, a member of the convention that framed the Constitution, and chief justice of that State. He was a member of the United States House of Representatives from Tennessee, and sustained the war of 1812 with great eloquence. He was a member of the Tennessee Legislature in 1820, and was the author of the relief measures adopted by that body for the purpose of mitigating the severity of the revulsion of 1819. He was elected to the United States Senate, and was a tower of strength in that body to Gen. Jackson's administration. He was attcrney-general under Mr. Van Buren's administration, the duties of which ho discharged with the same marked ability that he had brought to bear in every position he had accepted.
" Judge Grundy was not what may be called a book man or a book-lawyer. To his fine voice and inimitable action thei-e was added a brilliant intellect, through which ran a vein of strong common sense. He was good at repartee, and his wit fairly sparkled. He possessed in a marked degree the power to arouse and sway the passions of the heart, to excite sympathy or indignation, to parry the blows of an adversary, and to carry his point by brilliant charge. He was a consummate judge of human nature, and this rendered him unrivaled in the selection of a jury. He was unsurpassed in developing the facts of a case, and wonderful in the cross-examination of a witness introduced against his client. He generally relied upon his associate counsel to bring into court the books containing the law of the case in which they were employed, and the law was read and commented upon by these associates. And then, when Mr. Grundy came to close the case, so clear were his deductions, so striking his illustrations, so systematically would he tear to pieces the superstructure of the opposing counsel, and so vividly portray the right and justice for which he contended, that all who heard him regarded him as the finest lawyer of that or any other age. So thoroughly did he carry the crowd with him that he may be aptly likened to Paul when he made his great speech before King Agrippa, and extorted from that monarch the expression, ' Almost thou persuadest me to be a Christian.'
" While I was reading law in Nashville, in 1821," says Judge Guild, " Judge Grundy and William L. Brown were engaged on the same side in an ejectment case involving the construction of the phrase, ' Being in possession of the land under a deed or assurance of title founded on a grant,' contained in the statute of limitations of 1796. Some judges held that the words ' founded on a grant' meant that the deed must be connected by a regular chain of title down to the grantee, while others held the meaning to be that the land must be granted, but the deed under which it was held need not be connected with the grant. This confiiot of opinion rendered the present case all the more important. The proof was all hoard, as also the title-papers, and the case was ready for argument. Judge Grundy had expected to make the closing speech, as was usual with him in all cases in which he was employed, and had not examined the law and the decisions bearing upon the suit. This he had left for Judge Brown to do, intending to avail himself of that gentleman's research to enable him to make the closing argument. He requested Judge Brown to open the case, but he refused. Grundy appealed to Brown to open the alignment, but the latter pointedly refused to do so. Judge Grundy was therefore compelled to open the case, and this was the only occasion, as was said at the time, that he was ever known to make an utter failure. If Judge Brown had opened with his clear and exhaustive exposition of the law, he would have laid the foundation upon which Judge Grundy would have built a brilliant and masterly argument. Judge Grundy was a great manager, and he relied for success upon his knowledge of men, his brilliant wit, and his unrivaled eloquence, more than upon the dry details of the law. . . .
" The happy personal relations between Mr. Grundy and Mr. Clay were never seriously disturbed by their political differences, and each frequently indulged in sallies of wit and humor at the expense of the other in their political speeches.
"In the Presidential campaign of 1840, Mr. Clay, Mr. Crittenden, and other leading Whig orators visited Nashville, and held forth at a great barbecue prepared for the occasion. They came first into East Tennessee and crossed over the mountains. When speaking at Knoxville, Mr. Clay said when he came through Cumberland Gap into Tennessee one of the first. questions he asked was, ' Where is ray old friend, Felix Grundy ? And,' he continued, ' on being informed that he was away down in Alabama, making speeches for Mr. Van Buren, I raised my hands and exclaimed, " Ah, yes ! still pleading the cause of criminals !" '
" When Mr. Grundy returned to Nashville he was invited to address the people of Rutherford, at Murfrecsboro'. He availed himself of the opportunity to say that he had seen the report of Mr. Clay's Knoxville speech in the newspapers, and regretted that he was not there to reply to it, or that he could not now make a reply in Mr. Clay's hearing. He said it was true he had acquired some reputation as a criminal lawyer, and expressed a belief that he still retained all his professional faculties; but he felt well assured that if Mr. Clay should be indicted and brought before a court of strict justice for all his political offenses, and he (Mr. G.) were to be retained as his counsel, it would prove to be another Bennett case.
many causes of criminals managed by Mr. Grundy, he never lost but one, and that was the cause of a notoriously guilty client- by the name of Bennett, who had murdered a Mr. Hays in Wilson County. For many years the case was continued in the courts, and at last, by a change of venue, Bennett was convicted and hanged in Williamson County."
Hon. John Haywood
[We extract the following sketch of Judge Haywood, the earliest historian of Tennessee, from the Southwestern Laio Journal and Reporter for June, 1844:]
" John Haywood, the subject of the present memoir, was born in the county of Halifax, in the State of North Carolina, on the 16th of March, 1762, of a femily engaged in agriculture. His ancestors emigrated originally from England, and settled at an early period in the city of New York, whence they subsequently removed to Norfolk, Va. The latter town was almost entirely consumed by fire in the year 17 - , and the fortune of William, his grandfather, was involved in the general ruin. With a view to retrieve his losses, he soon after withdrew from this ill-fated town to the infant colony of North Carolina, and established himself near the town of Halifax, on the Roanoke. Egbert, the father of John, was a respectable farmer in moderate circumstances, and followed his occupation in the same neighborhood. He discharged with credit to himself such county offices as are usually filled by country gentlemen, but was by no means remarkable for a love of letters. He delighted rather in the amusements of the chase, and other field .sports which are known to possess so many attractions for those who ' faterna rura bovibius exercent sitis.' From the too great love of these diversions, united with the low state of learning in the colonies, it is probable that the family name, which has been borne by very distinguished individuals in England, fell into obscurity for a time in America. Previous to the Revolution few of the family seemed to have enjoyed the smiles of executive favor, or to have been members of the public councils of the country, or in any way distinguished for literary attainments.
" William, a paternal uncle, from whom the Haywoods of Raleigh, N. C., derived their lineage, was the only one whose fortune it was, previous to the Revolution, to enjoy an office of distinction. He was a member of the Executive Council. His descendants have always filled since that time the highest offices of the State, one of whom was a distinguished United States senator in 1844. John, the subject of our brief memoir, with limited means of instruction, and deprived of the invaluable blessings of a collegiate education, by indefatigable industry, and ardent, exclusive devotion to the profession he had chosen, has acquired for himself a reputation which, if less brilliant than that of many of his contemporaries whose lot it was to enroll their names on the bright page of their country's glory, will be equally appreciated for the lasting and substantial benefits it has conferred on his native and adopted State. He may be considered a pioneer of the laio. He was the first lawyer and judge who reported cases decided in the courts of North Carolina and Tenne.ssee, and in future time, on account of his Teamed decisions, will be regarded as the leading authority on all questions which involve doubt in the organic laws of these infant States. Doubtless the individuals who have mainly contributed by their industry and learning to fix the moaning and supply the deficiencies of our fundamental institutions have done as much service and deserve no less praise than the most gifted of those who have held more distinguished stations while engaged in framing them.
" The names of Coke, Hale, and Holt, the pioneers of English law, are not less respected, nor are the benefits derived from their exertions likely to be sooner forgotten by their countrymen than the services of their political contemporaries. Who at present ever hears the names of the signers of the great English charter ? and, indeed, most of those inscribed on our own bright roll have nearly faded from the i-ecoUections of the people. Not so with our distinguished judges ; Wythie, Marshall, Haywood, are as fiimiliar in the mouths of the people as household words.
" We have said thus much to encourage the diligent student with the hope of ample reward, who with pure ambition exclusively devotes himself to his profession, by the example of one who made it the sole business of his life, - his only pursuit. He was contented with the honors to be derived from his profession alone, and owes whatever reputation he has attained to his untiring application and great diligence in its prosecution.
" Of his early education there is not much to be said, for of this he had but little. His' father, being in moderate circumstances, had it not in his power, however much he might have inclined, to send him to a foreign country, or even to a neighboring province, for educatioii, which was the general practice at that time of the wealthy colonists. Enabled by their wealth to dispense with domestic institutions of learning, they illiberally failed to provide means of education for the gifted sons of their less fortunate neighbors. But this deficiency was in some measure supplied by the conductors of private academies, who were - generally well grounded in the branches they professed to teach, and the learned languages especially were thoroughly taught. To one of those in a neighboring county, conducted by an intelligent minister of the gospel, was he sent by his father at an early age to receive the rudiments of a learned education. In justice to the memory of this gentleman, whose name was Castle, it is not useless to remark that another individual, Mr. Harper, of Maryland, equally distinguished for his eminence in the legal profession, was educated at the same school. Honor to these humble benefactors of mankind, without whose fostering care many a genius of the brightest talents would be left to wither under the blighting infiuence of poverty and neglect!
" Here Haywood acquired the usual knowledge of Latin and Greek, geography, and the elements of mathematics. Of the higher branches of science, mental and moral philosophy, and physics, he learned but little, and perhaps nothing. In after-life, when he had attained distinction in his profession, he relaxed in his diligent pursuit of the law, and turned his attention to more agreeable studies. He made deep researches into history and theology, and became well acquainted with the general results of natural science. Tlius it is seen that on his return to his paternal abode he had traversed but few of the wide fields of human knowl- edge, and was but scantily prepared to thread with success the intricate mazes of a profession which requires almost universal knowledge. But so strong was the direction which his mind had received from nature towards legal pursuits that he soon after entered upon the task, under difficulties which to minds endowed with ordinary vigor and perseverance would have been unsurmountable. Less favored than other individuals who from a humble beginning have risen to eminence by the vigor of their intellect and untiring industry, he had not the advantages of access to the librai-y of a friend or the benc:fit of legal tuition in a law3'er's office. In law he was his own instructor. Coming by some accident into possession of an old volume of Raymond's Reports, with this he commenced his study, thus pursuing a course the very reverse of ordinary students. They usually study the principles of the law, which they afterwards trace in their application to particular cases, while his vigorous intellect traveled at once through the details of a case, deducing from it tKose great principles on which all law is founded. Nothing so strikingly marks the vigor of his mind and the enthusiastic ardor with which he entered upon his legal studies as the fact that he could master the extremely technical statements of Lord Raymond's Reports, interspersed as they are with the old Latin and French phrases which were in use in those times.
" With no preparation, except" such as he had made by his own unaided genius, he began the practice of law in hii^ native county, and in a very short time took his stand by the side of such men as Gen. Davie, Nash, McCoy, Badger, and Martin, - men whose learning and ability had placed them at the head of the North Carolina bar. His first argument before the Supreme Court of the State was made when he was about twenty-four years of age, and was said to have displayed as much learning and as comprehensive a view of the great landmarks of the law as any argument which had ever been made before it. From that time his services were engaged in all important causes, and he advanced rapidly to professional honor, and secured a large share of professional emolument.
" As attorney-general for the State, in the year 179-1, he had the address to procure a reconsideration of the opinion of the. judges of the Supreme Court in a case where the court had decided the act of 1793 unconstitutional, which authorized judgments to be taken by motion tvithout notice against defaulting public officers. After a most learned and elaborate argument from Haywood, the court reversed their judgment. Judge Macay remarking that he " had given such strong reasons that his objections were vanquished, and, therefore, that the attorney-general might proceed, - but yet that he did not very much like it." 1 Hay. R. 40. This was the first innovation on the common law allowing those summary proceedings by motion which are now so common in our courts; and the synopsis of the argument of Mr. Haywood, in Hay. R. 40-50, evinces thus early the power and vigor of his mind.
" During the same year he was elevated to the bench of the Superior Courts of Law and Equity. He entered immediately on a vigorous discharge of his duties. In the five or six years during which he occupied a place on the bench, he collected with great care and published three volumes of reports of cases decided by the Superior Court of North Carolina from the year 1789 to 1798. In the decision of a great majority of these cases Mr. Haywood took part, either as counsel or judge. And throughout the whole range of subjects which arose in the establishment of the government subsequent to the Revolution, no great question arose which was not elucidated by his learning and generally determined by his great ability. As an instance of the eiFect which his reasoning had upon the current of decisions in North Carolina, as well as in Tennessee, we need only refer to the case of the State vs. Long, decided at Hillsborough, N. C, April, 1795 (Haywood R. 177, Battle's Ed.). This was an indictment against Long for larceny, on the authority of the English cases, that a borrowing with a fraudulent intent to steal the property borrowed would constitute larceny. Two of the judges went with the English authorities ; Judges Haywood and Williams held that in order to constitute the offense the property should have been taken invito domino; and Long was pardoned. To Haywood's report of this case he appended a note opposing the authority of the English modern cases, and contending for the law as laid down in Coke, Hale, and Hawkins. Upon the authority of this extra-judicial opinion of Judge Haywood, the courts of Tennessee (and of North Carolina, too, it is believed) have uniformly acted: first, in Braden's case, 2 Term (Overton's) R. 68, and then in Martin and Yerg., 526; Wright's case, 5 Yerg., 154; Kite's case, 9 Yerg. R., 205 ; Dodge vs. Brittain, Bleigs' R., 84. In Braden's case, Overton, judge, said, ' The
REASONING, THOUGH CONTRARY TO MANY LATE DECISIONS IN England, is incontrovertible.' But by an act of the Legislature of 21st of January, 1842, the law which had thus been established for fifty years was thrown aside, and the English law established in all its vigor.
" But the ability and learning of Judge Haywood were nowhere so fully displaj'ed as in the celebrated case of the University of North Carolina vs. Toy & Bishop. The Legislature in 1789 conferred upon the university all the property which had or might hereafter escheat to the State ; but by an act of 1800 this right was attempted to be taken from the university, which was resisted by Judge 'Haywood, who was then at the bar. The law divesting the university was declared void and unconstitutional, and the rights of the university triumphantly sustained.
" About the year 1800, Judge Haywood left the bench and entered again into the field of litigation, where he continued to add to the already unequaled reputation which he had acquired as a judge Giving himself up strictly to the business of his profession, and to those studies which enabled him so long to adorn it, he was enabled to take the lead in all questions of constitutional and international law, and in the interpretation of the laws of descent, limitations, land-laws, etc., which arose in the courts of his native State. In the case of Crutchcr vs. Punnell (Murphey's R., 22), Judge Haywood's argument at the bar, in reference to the act of 1715, on the Statute of Limitation, had the effect to produce the decision ' that seven years' j^ossession without color of title will not bar an ejectment.' In reference to this argument Judge Murphey remarks (1 Murph. R., 30), ' that it had the efFeot of changing the current of decisions and unsettling the opinions of the profession as to the construction of the Act of Limitatio"ns, and at the distance of one hundred years after the passage of the act more diversity of opinion seems to exist as to its meaning and operation than at any former period. Twenty years after the Revolution the doctrine of color of title was introduced, which, being urged with ability, has supplanted the construction which had been given to -the act for a century.' Such a compliment from one who heard the argument and felt its force is the highest tribute to his learning and genius.
"Having already secured the highest judicial and professional honor in his own State, and having acquired a respectable fortune, Judge Haywood in 1807 came to the county of Davidson and settled seven miles south of Nashville. Middle Tennessee was then the frontier of the West. Having doffed the judicial ermine in his native State, he came with his family and entered immediately upon the practice of his profession. He was then but little over forty years of age, and almost as well known in Tennessee as in North Carolina. As a judge he had already decided many of the questions which were arising in the courts of Tennessee, and was, perhaps, at that time more familiar with the Constitution and laws of both States' than any other member of the bar. Unlike most of the profession, he kept no oiEoe in town, but kept his office and library and received his clients at his residence in the country.
" The leading members of the bar were then in the habit of attending the sessions of the Supreme Court at all the places for holding it, so that most of them were brought into immediate contact. Haywood, Grundy, Jackson, Whiteside, Robert Whyte, Hugh L. White, George W. Campbell, and others, were then the leading members of the Tennessee bar. The questions growing out of landtitles afforded a fruitful source of litigation, and in all these suits Judge Haywood was almost invariably retained.
" When Judge Haywood came to Tennessee the profession was much divided in reference to the construction of the act of 1797 esplaining the Statute of Limitations of 1715. The question involved in this statute had been decided in North Carolina, in the case of Crutchor vs. Parnell, 1 Murphey's R. 22. In that case the argument of Judge Haywood had the effect to produce the decision that seven years' possession, with a color of title, would bar an action of ejectment, and that it was not necessary to show a regular chain of title. The act of 1797 provided that ' the act of 1715 should apply in all cases where any person or persons shall have had seven years' peaceable possession of any land by virtue of a grant, or deed of conveyance founded on a grant, and no legal claim by suit,' etc. The cases of Sawyer's lessee vs. Shannon, 1 Tenn. R. 4G5 ; Lillard vs. Elliot, Patten vs. Eaton, 1 Wheaton R. 476, and Hampton's lessee vs. McGinnis, 1 Tenn. R. 28G, were decided about the time Judge Haywood made his appearance at the bar of Tennessee, in which the doctrine of the connection of title seemed to be settled. The case of Weatherhead and Douglass vs. Bledsoe's heirs, reported in 2
Tenn. 352, was the first leading case on the construction of this statute in which Judge Haywood took a part as counsel. A distinguished and able lawyer who was then at the bar thus describes the position of Judge Haywood in reference to this case :
" ' No ease could have been more thoroughly investigated and ably argued at the bar than that of Weatherhead and Douglass vs. Bledsoe's heirs. By the time at which it came up for final adjudication many cases involving the same question were in progress in the Circuit Courts ; the subject had been very' much discussed, both at the bar and elsewhere ; public attention was strongly directed to it, and the faculties of the profession had become quickened and invigorated, all their zeal and energy aroused, and all their resources stimulated into action, by the general interest which now began to be felt in the issue. All seemed to anticipate that a decisive battle was to be fought, and, however it might terminate, that the result would be most disastrous to some, most fortunate to others, and of very doubtful influence to the community at large. Jenkin Whiteside appeared as the great champion for Bledsoe's heirs and connection of title ; John Haywood for Weatherhead and Douglass and the doctrine of color of title." A number of other professional gentlemen of less celebrity, but of various degrees of talent and acquirement, were arranged on both 'sides of this question. The leading counsel referred to were known each to advocate his own private opinion ; and they all brought to the discussion that tliorough knowledge of the .subject which, when united with great abilities, and with the expectations which hung upon the cause, was sure to produce an intellectual display pre-eminently interesting and captivating. Such was truly the character of the distinguished forensic contest which took place on that memorable occasion. The event of it has been told ; and that which to all human appearance now seemed the consummation of the thing proved only a prelude to one of the most agitating and exacerbated controversies, perhaps, that ever grew out of a question which was purely judicial.'
" But notwithstanding Judge Haywood's great talent, he lost this case, by the opinion of all the judges, except Judge Overton, dissenting. Soon after this opinion Judge Overton resigned and Cooke died, and their places were supplied by Robert Whyte and John Haywood, in the year 181G. When Mr. Haywood became a judge of the Supreme Court, although he stood alone on the subject of his doctrine of ' color of title,' he never yielded it. From that time until 1825 he persevered in his opposition to the construction of the Statute of Limitation which made a connection of title necessary. From being alone in his view of this law. Judge Haywood found himself at last sustained by all the members of the court of five judges, with the exception of Judge Whyte, who was not to be moved from his opinion by popular feeling or the sophistry of legal learning.
" We have seen Judge Haywood establishing the doctrine of ' color of title' in his native State, and unsettling, according to Judge Murphey, the current of decisions for more than a century, while we find him arrayed against and apparently overwhelmed by the force of a powerful opposition, struggling for years against it, and finally establishing tho same doctrine in his adopted State. Much was due, no doubt, to the popular feeling which grew up in the country in favor of his construction of the law, wliich tended directly to establish the doubtful claims of many resident citizens of Tennessee against the superior claims of nonresidents."
The same gentleman quoted above says, " Judge Haywood was a fine genius and a most powerful and unrivaled advocate. In tact and eloquence - such eloquence as reaches the heart and convinces the judgment - he had no equal in Tennessee. He was often employed with and against the late Felix Grundy in the most critical criminal cases, and it would not be saying too much, perhaps, to say that as an orator he was equal, if not superior to that distinguished advocate. Both had been on the supreme bench of their respective States, and both came to Tennessee preceded by the most brilliant reputation. Both were men of great learning and attainments, but in all the learning which pertained to his profession Judge Haywood stood far in advance of his great rival. He possessed inexhaustible stores of imagination, was quick and ready in argument, and prompt in reply. But withal his judgment was too much under the dominion of imaginative faculty, which gave to some of his opinions too great an air of eccentricity and uncertainty. He had many sympathies in common with his fellow-men, and highly cherished their good opinion, particularly of his own fame. He was ambitious in the highest degree, somewhat overbearing in his desire to be considered ' the Court,' and perhaps thought too highly of his own and too little of his brotiier-judgos' opinions, and acted and felt that he was the master-spirit in the settlement and' determination of all loading questions of jurisprudence. I do not think I should do him injustice if I should say he never delivered an opinion without desiring the presence of a large audience.
" Withal, he was agreeable in his manners, fond of society, and entertaining to the highest degree in his conversation. Although not educated in his youth in the sciences, be amassed a large amount of learning in reference to natural history, astronomy, antiquarian research, relics, fossils, shells, and aboriginal history, which he gave to the world under the title of the ' Natural and Aboriginal History of Tennessee,' containing about four hundred pages.
" He also found leisure to prepare a very minute though somewhat iuartistically arranged ' History of Tennessee,' in five hundred pages, from 1770 to 1795, embracing a variety of most interesting traditions, which he obtained from the first settlers of the Cumberland Valley. During his residence in Tennessee he reported three volumes of decisions, given while he was on the bench. He also prepared a manual for clerks and justices.
" Another work which he published during his residence in Tennessee was entitled ' Tiie Evidences of Cliristianity.' It was much read in Tennessee at the time of its publication. . . . It was a worksHi yoicj'i's. It embraced a variety, it might almost be said a medley^ of historical, traditional, scientific. Scriptural, and antiquarian learning. Taken in connection with his ' Natural and Aboriginal History of Tennessee,' it might be considered a wonderful production. They both dealt largely in the suj)crnatural and marvelous, giving accounts of earthquakes, dreams, ghosts, meteors, bones of giants and pigmies ; caves and strange and supernatural voices which were heard in the air ; and portents and signs and wonders ; but with all this there was mixed up much real and valuable information, displaying great historical and scientific research. These works have given rise to the common opinion that Judge Haywood was credulous and superstitious, and his introduction into one of those works of a remarkable ghost story, with an apparent belief in its reality, has led many persons to say that he was a believer in ghosts ! The truth is, perhaps, that Judge Haywood, like Dr. Johnson and some other great men, could not entirely divest himself of a belief in the supernatural ; and it is probable, had he lived in the present day, he would, like many other distinguished judges, have been a believer in the sciences of phrenology, mesmerism, and clairvoyance. But it might as well be charged against the inimitable author of ' Waverley' that because he wrote the history of demonology and the wonderful story ~ of ' AVoodstock' he was a believer in witchcraft as to attribute superstition to Judge Haywood because he wrote the marvelous and wonderful things co'ntained in ' The Evidences of Christianity' and ' Aboriginal History of Tennessee.'
" His information and learning were varied and extensive, and we might almost apply to him the language of Canterbury when describing King Henry's great attainments :
" From the moment when he entered the profession his mind and his energies were constantly directed to the improvement and advancement of his private fortune and the attainment of distinction in his profession. Notwithstanding the whole vigor of his powerful mind seemed to have been directed to the science of jurisprudence, he was yet enabled to amass and leave to his children a very large fortune.
" But few men possessed in a higher degree the elements which constitute a great jurist ; and had he been placed under circumstances of fortune and education more favorable to the development of his faculties, he might, perhaps, have left more enduring monuments of his genius. As it was, however, he impressed his spirit upon the jurisprudence of Carolina and Tennessee, and contributed more than any other man to give it form and shape. From the year 1786, when he began the practice of his profession in his native State, to 1826, when he died, in this State, he has left in the reports of adjudications in these States evidences in every volume of his learning, ability, an-d indomitable energy of cliaracter. And even now liis opinions and arguments, whether right or wrong, are more cjuoted and relied upon in the courts of both these States than those of any other judge who has ever presided in them."
Judge Haywood died on the 22d of December, 1826, at his residence near Nashville, after a few days' illness, in the sixty-fourth year of his age. His death was hastened by his extreme corpulency, which in his old age greatly harassed him. He left three sons and three daughters.
His children were Thomas Haywood, a lawyer by profession and teacher of fine classical education, who lived and died in this county, at his residence near the Nolensvillc Turnpike, about six miles from Nashville, about 1868 ; Dr. George Haywood, a well-known physician of Marshall County, where ho died some years ago ; Dr. Egbert Haywood, who practiced in Brownville, Haywood Co., Tenn., where he acquired a fine reputation as a physician, and where he died. Of his three daughters, one married Dr. Moore, of Huntsville, Ala. ; one married Col. Jones, of Tuscumbia, Ala.; the third was the. wife of Col. Spottswood Jones, of Limestone Co., Ala. None of his descendants are now residing in Davidson by the name of Haywood.
Upon the meeting of the Supreme Court on the first Monday in January, 1827, the late Hon. Felix Grundy ofi'ered the following preamble and resolutions, which were adopted :
" Whereas, The Hon. John Haywood, one of the judges of this court, departed this life on the 22d of December last, as an evidence of that high regard justly due to his legal acquirements and extensive erudition, and the great public services rendered to his country, in a long life devoted to the profession of the law, of which he was the pride and ornament, -
" Therefore, 1st. It is ordered by the court, with the unanimous assent of the bar, that the court and the several oflicers wear crape on the left arm for the space of thirty days.
Hon. James Trimble
James Trimble, counselor and attorney-at-law, was born in 1781, in Rockbridge Co., Va., a Scotch-Irish settlement famous for its schools and churches and its self-dependent people, and their patriotism during the war of independence. His ancestors - the Trimbles and Alexanders - were plain, educated, and religious people in the middle class of life. The Trimbles of Oiiio and Kentucky - two of whom were members of the United States Senate, one a justice of the United States Supx-eme Court, and several members of the lower house of Congress - were connections. Dr. Archibald -Alexander and his sons, well-known divines at Princeton College, New Jersey, were also connections on his mother's side.
James Trimble was educated at Washington College, East Tennessee. He studied law at Staunton, Va., and settled at Knoxville, E. Tenn., the seat of government of
While a member of the General Assembly he procured the charter of the Nashville Female Academy, and upon its organization became an active trustee thereof.
He was also a trustee of Cumberland College, now the University of Nashville, and in connection with Judge Henry Crabb, an eminent member of the Nashville bar, was active in reviving the college in 1823, and he was instrumental in procuring as its president Philip Lindsley, one of the most famous and distinguished educators of the Mississippi valley.
James Trimble was known throughout the State as one of its leading minds, and as one of the leading members of the Nashville bar. He ranked with Whiteside, Overton, Dickinson, White, Williams, Crabb, and others. His lawlibrary was a large and costly one, consisting of standard English and American works, and with which as a lawyer he was well acquainted. He was also a student of history, and had a choice and select library of English and American works.
He was well acquainted with human nature and with the people among whom he lived. In his manners and conversation he was pleasant and affable, and mingled with all classes of society, and had the good-will and respect of the entire community.
His ability, skill, and integrity as a lawyer procured him a large practice and secured lo him a large estate, which he bequeathed to his wife and children.
As a citizen, in his politics, he was a Republican, of the school of Madison. In 1822 he preferred Crawford to Jackson, although the latter was a personal friend. From Jefferson and IMadison he received several civil commissions.
He was a close and intimate friend of John Dickinson, an eminent lawyer, and also with George W. Campbell, Felix Grundy, William Brown, lawyers and well-known public men of Tennessee.
Among the law-students in his ofiice were Gen. Sam Houston, Aaron V. Brown, Judge William 111. Kennedy, of Maury County, Samuel P. Blontgomery, who was killed at the battle of the Horseshoe under Gen. Jackson, George S. Yerger, attorney-general of the State.
He was a member of the First Presbyterian Church, and for many years an elder therein. He was liberal in his religious ideas, and was held a man of integrity and honor, and of high moral character.
In his law-cases he was laborious and always well prepared to conduct them. His style was that of animated conversation. He reasoned well and was persuasive. His tone of voice and expression of eye told his zeal and interest in his cases. He died, from over-labor in his profession, in July, 1824. His funeral was largely attended by citizens of Nashville.
Bench And Bae
Jolin Dickinson was Massucliusetts born and educated, came to Nashville a young man, earned a living as deputy clerk in the office of the United States District Court, and prosecuted the study of the law. His mind and moral greatness, and liabits of industry and economy, soon qualified him for his profession, and he rose to distinction, and stood among the most eminent of the able men of the profession and times. His success was brain-work and training, close, faithful attention to his business, and honorable conduct; he was a cool, clear-headed, upright, honorable man, respected and esteemed throughout the State for his intellect and moral qualities. Always selfpossessed and under self-control, he earned and deserved his high place. He never sought popularity. His self-respect was high, and he deserved and had the respect of his fellow-men. He was one of the able land-lawyers of his day, an able commercial lawyer, and collected the claims of Eastern merchants. He acquired a large and remunerative practice. His capacity and fidelity and honorable conduct secured him a large estate, - probably the best estate up to that day which any lawyer had earned and laid up. He died in 1813-14, of consumption, in early manhood, leaving a rich widow, young and handsome, and a son. Ephraim H. Foster, a law-student in his office, afterwards United States senator, married his widow. John Dickinson and James Trimble were close and intimate friends; the latter survived the former for many years. From him these reminiscences and traits of character of Mr. Dickinson were obtained by the writer, from and through James P. Clark and Thomas Warington.
Oliver B. Hays
Oliver B. Hays was a native of Massachusetts, and received in that State a liberal education. He studied law and was probably admitted to the b:ir in the city of Baltimore. Governor Foote is authority for saying that he came to Nashville in 1808, which is probably correct, as he was a partner with Thomas H. Benton before the removal of the latter to Missouri. Mr. Hays had a taste for classical studies, which he pursued more or less all his life. He was a good speaker, had an extensive and accurate acquaintance with the law, was an acute, diligent, and energetic practitioner. " He appeared often in the argument of land-causes, and the briefs filed by him will be found always to have been skillfully framed and full to exuberance of the citations of adjudicated cases."
At middle age he retired from the bar, became a Presbyterian minister of what was known as the New School, led a rather reeluse life, and died an old man in 1858. f
George S. Yerger
"Towards the close of the last century a very worthy Dutch family was residing in the town of Lebanon, Tenn., now so celebrated for its institutions of learning, and especially for its law-school. The Yerger mansion is still standing, and in a comfortable state of preservation. In this
The eldest brother was the subject of this notice ; he was at one time a prominent member of the Nashville bar, and officiated for some years as reporter of the judicial decisions of the Supreme Court of Tennessee, at first alone and afterwards with his younger brother. Hon. E. H. Ewing, speaking of him in a recent letter, says, " George S. Yerger was rather an uncommon man. I do not know when he came to the bar ; I should say, however, not bofore 1820. He was first a merchant's clerk, with very little education, but felt this to be too narrow a field for his abilities. He read law at odd times, and when he began practice soon got into business. He was what might be called eminently an indefatigable man. He became State reporter in 1831, and we have ten volumes of his reports. The editing and compiling of these did not interfere with a full and extensive practice at the bar. He was fluent, had a remarkable memory for cases and dates, never gave up a point, however desperate, and occupied a first rank at the bar, where he had as associates and rivals Washington, Fogg, Bell, and others. He removed to Mississippi early in 1839, and there maintained his character as a sound and able lawyer."
Governor Foote speaks of him as an intimate acquaintance, and, in some important cases, an associate in practice in Mississippi. He says, " He brought with him to this new home a high reputation for legal learning, and this reputation he succeeded in maintaining unimpaired to the last moment of his life. . . . His impulsive nature was easily roused, but never ran into excesses of any kind. He always .spoke with animation, and sometimes with no little fervor and emphasis. His manner was uniformly easy and natural, his diction chaste and unpretending, and his gesticulations decorous and impressive. . . . He preferred taking part in the trial of commercial causes, or in the discussion of such as were of equitable jurisdiction ; but he was well fitted both by temperament and intellectual training for the vindication of the innocent or the prosecution of the guilty before courts of criminal cognizance."^ He died in Mississippi about 1859.
J. S. Yerger, a younger brother of the above, possessed many of the qualities of mind which give fame at the bar. His stock of general knowledge was larger than his brother's. His powers of perception were unusually quick, and his judgment strong. He had read deeply and generally, and was a good judge both of men and their motives of action. He was of an eminently sociable disposition, and possessed conversational powers of a most entertaining and instructive order. He had made his mark as a lawyer at this bar before removing to Mississippi, where he became an eminent circuit judge. A still younger brother, William Yerger, was afterwards judge of the Supreme Court of Mississippi. He was a very gifted man, and it is- said that an elFort of his made in court when he was only twenty-two years of age - his first plea at the Mississippi bar - "suggested almost
In our list we find the name of Samuel Yevger, admitted in Nashville in 1824. He was probably one of the brothers, as seven out of the eight are known to have been lawyers. But of Samuel we have no further account.
Gen. George W. Gibbs
Gen. George W. Gibbs was admitted to the Davidson bar in 1817, and was for many years the law-partner of Judge James Rucks. Both maintained high characters as gentlemen, and did a large amount of professional business. Gen. Gibbs settled on a farm near or including the site of Union City, Tenn. The present Secretary of State, Flon. Charles N. Gibbs, is one of his sons.
Hon. John C.Vtron
A life of Judge Catron, or rather a somewhat humorous letter embracing the principal points of his life, written by himself from Washington, D. C, in December, 1851, while he was a justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, appears in " Sketches of Eminent Americans," having been furnished at the solicitation of John Livingston, Esq., the editor of that work. We have also been furni.shed with a copy of the same in pamphlet form by the friends of Judge Catron. It is a rich and original document, full of the quaint humor of the judge, which rendered his speeches and writings so pleasing, and often amusing. We regret that we have not space to quote it in full ; but such extracts as we shall make will serve the double purpose of giving the reader an outline of his legal career, and at the same time a sample of his racy, original, and interesting style. He begins :
" I do not believe there is a man living who could give you any tolerable account of my early life except myself; and when the incidents were narrated they would pnly prove what Campbell sa3-s of Lord Mansfield, - that when became up from Scotland to Westminster school on a Highland pony, the chances were a billion to one against his ever being chief justice; and I can safely say that quite as many chances stood in the way of my being a supreme judge when of the same age as was His Lordship at the time he wended his solitary way south, with his pony as his only companion. Y'our readers would only learn that I had been reared on a farm, and been flogged through the common schools of Western Virginia and Kentucky, and then had had the advantages of such academies as the Western country afforded, - humble enough, in all conscience, and where little else than Latin and the lower mathematics was added to the common-school training ; that, with this amount of acquired knowledge, I read history, novels, and poetry ; grounded myself well, as 1 thought, in Virginia politics ; that I read everything which came to hand as it came, - Fielding, Smollett, Sterne, Goldsmith, and up through Tom Paine, Hume, and Gibbon. Everything, or nearly so, then to be had in the country, of history, ancient and modern, was read, and much of it with a devouring appetite. Prester John, Peter the Hermit, Richard and Saladin, Falstaff and Frederick, were all jumbled up together. It is due, however, to say that preparatory to taking up Blaekstone
I carefully re-read Hume's ' History of England,' with Smollett's and Bisset's continuations; Robertson's 'Charles the Fifth,' and also Gibbon's ' Decline and Fall,' and made extensive notes on each, which I thought exceeding valuable at the time. They were on large foolscap, bound in pasteboard, and, all told, were, when packed on each other, two-thirds as high as a table ; nor did I doubt that my condensed Gibbon would go forth some day in print; nor do I now remember at what time it was used to kindle the ofiice fire, but this was its fate. With my old friends, Pope, Shakspeare, and Sterne, I iiad to act as I have often done since with my snuffbox, - hide them from myself . . .
"The Bible being the common reader of my early schools, of course I knew almost by memory. Of geography I learned more than most men and know more now. AVith this confused mass of self-taught knowledge I commenced to read law in April, 1812, in the State of Tennessee. Up to this date I had never been sick a day or hour and had a frame rarely equaled,; one that could bear ardent and rigorous application for sixteen hours in the day, and which was well tried about four years at something like this rate. Late in 1815 I tried my chances at the bar and succeeded, certainly in the main chance of getting fees ; but then I ' had a good deal of worldly experience and availed myself of the eases in court, throughout a heavy circuit, of a re- '.} tiring brother-lawyer and friend who was elected to Con- ,^ gross. . . . The courts were full of indictments for crimes from murder down. Here I had to fight the battle single and alone and to work day and night. No man ever worked much harder, I think ; my circuit judge was an excellent criminal lawyer, and being partly Scotch always stood firmly by the State and leaned strongJij against the culprit; so that I got on very well, but often with an arrogance that would have done credit to Castlereagh, for blundering in my law certainly, if not in my grammar. Like His Lordship, I was given to white waistcoats and small-clothes, and drew pretty largely on the adventitious aids furnished by the tailor.
" The lawyers then traveled the circuit from county to county usually of a Sunday. Each man that was well appointed carried pistols and holsters and a negro waiter with a large portmanteau behind him. All went on horseback. The pistols were carried not to shoot thieves and robbers, but to fight each other, if by any chance a quarrel was hatched up furnishing an occasion for a duel, then a very favorite amusement and liberally indulged in, and the attorney-general for the circuit was expected to be, and always was, prepared for such a contingency. He managed to keep from fighting, however. His equipments were of the best, with a led third horse now and then for the sake of parade." . . .
We cannot quote further from Judge Catron, although his account of himself is very interesting to the end. He settled in Nashville at the close of the year 1818. In 182-1 he was elected by the Legislature a judge of the Supreme Court, and continued on the bench till the change of the judicial system by the Constitution of 1834. On the 4th of March, 1837, he was nominated to the Senate by President Jackson as a judge of the Supreme Court of
Bench And Bak Patrick H. Dauby
PATRICK H. DAUBY. Patrick H. Darby was a native of Ireland. He came to Tennessee from Kentucky about 1814., He was a lawyer of considerable ability, a fluent speaker, but did not sustain himself as to character. He returned to Kentucky, where he died about 1830.
Hon. Henry Crabb
Henry Crabb came to the bar about 1814. He was a dignified, somewhat haughty and polished gentleman of more than common talents, and a man of learning for his time. He was probably about forty years of age when he died. He occupied a position in the front rank at the bar, and was elevated to the bench of the Supreme Court in 1827. He was then in a state of rapid physical decline, and died a few years after. The opinions delivered by him during the brief period he occupied his seat upon the bench are found in Blartin and Yerger's Eeports, the most noted of whijh was upon the question. How far an attorney in the State of Tennessee was entitled to claim pecuniary remuneration for professional services rendered by him, upon the basis of a quanUim meruit, and the interesting case of Vaughn vs. Phebe.
Judge Crabb left one son, Henry A. Crabb, who became quite prominent aS a lawyer and politician in California, where he was a candidate for the United States Senate, and was one of the Fillmore and Donelson electors of that State in 185G.
Thomas H. Fletcher
THOMAS H. FLETCHER. Thomas H. Fletcher, one of the early and well-known attorneys of Nashville, was a resident of the city upwards of thirty-five years, and held a higli rank in the profession. He was born in the town of Warren, Albemarle Co., Va., on the 15th of September, 1792. He came to Nashville in 1808, at the age of sixteen, having walked all the way from Virginia. His first engagement in business was with Col. Andrew Hynes, as clerk in his store, with whom he subsequently became a partner. He afterwards largely engaged in mercantile pursuits, but was uniortunate, like hundreds of his fellow-citizens, in the financial disaster of 1818 -19. This led him to the study of law. He commenced practice in Fayetteville, Tenn., in 1821, having been appointed by his life-long friend, Governor Carroll, district attorney or attorney-genei'ul. His acquaintance with the politics of the country was very general, and few men could trace their progress from the early days of the Constitution to his own lime with more accuracy.
He had a great taste for political pursuits, and his ready talents would have adorned any station to which he might have aspired, but his pecuniary disasters prevented him engaging in that field, and hung over him like a cloud the whole of his life. In 1825 he represented the county of Franklin for two terms in the State Legislature, and was chiefly instrumental in the romovai of the seat of government from Blurlreesboro' to Nashville, and at a later period served as Secretary of State under a pro (em. appointment from his intimate and valued friend, Governor Carroll.
Mr. Fletcher served his country in the Indian campaigns of 1813 ; was in the battles of Talladega and the Horseshoe as a member of Capt. Deaderick's company, which was Gen. Jackson's life-guard ; and in December, 1812, was appointed by Gen. Jackson his second aide-de-camp, but declined the position. During the Creek campaign at Camp Coffee, Gen. Jackson tendered him the appointment of military secretary, which he also declined.
He married, Jan. 10, 1814, Sarah G., a daughter of Thomas Talbot, an old resident of Davidson County. He died suddenly of apoplexy, Jan. 12, 1845, in the fiftythird year of his age. He was the father of twelve children, four of whom are yet living.
Mr. Fletcher became widely known in 1823-24 as the author of "The Political Horse race," in which he humorous! v and graphically portrayed the characteristics and conjectured popularity of the Presidential candidates of that period, Messrs. Clay, Crawford, Adams, Jackson, and Calhoun. It was one of the most popular effusions of the kind ever written, and has been several times republished. It appeared lately in the Nashville Banner, with some very excellent and appreciative introductory remarks respecting ' the article and its author by Hon. John M. Lea, which we cfuote, as containing the best summary of Mr. Fletcher's character and standing as a lawyer which we have seen. Judge Lea says, -
" The piece was copied with notices of commendation in the newspapers, and inquiry showed the author was an eminent lawyer of Nashville, the late Thomas H. Fletcher, a most eminent advocate, who stood in the front rank of his profession, the peer of Whiteside, Brown, Grundy, and Crabb. Mr. Fletcher, though he had a large and general practice, stood pre-eminently high as a criminal lawyer, and possessed all the requisites for success in that special forensic field. A good judge of human nature, knowing its strong and its weak side, he selected his jury with great discriminatio'n, and having a heart as tender as a woman's, his feelings were naturally with his clients in their distress, and he always made their cause his own. There have been great criminal lawyers in Tennessee, but few his equals and none his superior. His voice was clear and strong ; manner earnest and excited, but never rude and boisterous ; pathetic or humorous as the occasion suggested, he always spoke with good taste and made, perhaps, fewer fiiilures than almost any lawyer at the bar. He was very popular with the profession, especially among the younger lawyers, whom he always treated with the utmost kindness and courtesy. His reading was extensive and not confined to professional works, and often he beguiled his leisure hours in composition for the newspapers on ephemeral subjects of the day. Those who have had the good fortune to listen to his interesting conversation will never forget the pleasant impression which he always made. There was in his manner no rudeness, in his speech no coarseness or invective, and his sympathy for the misfortunes of his fellow-men was unbounded. His death was the subject of universal grief in Nashville. He had been engaged for a week on the trial of a murder case, - of course, for the defense, - and became very much exhausted. On Saturday a verdict of acquittal was brought in, and Mr. Fletcher walked to his office, saying that he did not feel at all well. The next afternoon, about three o'clock, the unhappy news was circulated that this worthy man and distinguished advocate had instantly died from a stroke of apoplexy. The writer of this brief notice immediately hastened to his office and assisted in raising from the floor his manly form, his hand still grasping the book from which he had been reading when death summoned his presence to the higher court above."
Perhaps the character of Mr. Fletcher's legal mind may be best illustrated by one of his own anecdotes, which he in the habit of telling with great glee. Owing to his reputation as a jury advocate, he was retained as counsel in a large ejectment suit pending in an adjoining county. Now, Mr. Fletcher would say, if there was any branch of the law about which he know less than any other (and, he would add, he knew very little about any), it was land-law. He tried to read up for the occasion, but the more he read the less he know about it. AVhen he went to try the case he was in great tribulation. Luckily, however, it was developed in the testimony of one of the first witnesses that the parties had gone upon the land for the purpose of trying to adjust the matters of difficulty amicably, the result of which was a free fight, participated in by the litigants and their friends in attendance. At once, Fletcher would say, " my foot was on my native heath and my name was Macgregor." He was at home in an assault-and-battery case. He set to work to bring out all the details of the fight, turned the whole case into the charge of an assault by the opposite party on his client, and won his case with flying colors.*
Hon. Tiiojias Washington
HON. TIIOJIAS WASHINGTON. Thomas "Washington (not mentioned in the above list) came to the bar in 1813. Although making an unpromising beginning, he attained a good degree of eminence in his profession. By perseverance and application he brought out what was latent within him, and became a very able and effective lawj'er. His law-papers were drawn with great care and ability, and were perfect models of their kind. He was a slow, deliberate speaker, but always correct in his lano-uase. In manner he was courteous and dignified, firm and outspoken in his opinions, and " a gentleman to the core." He was fine and polished as a literary writer. The obituary notices of Chancellor Kent and Hon. W. G. Campbell (printed in the beginning of 8 Humphreys) and of Judge Turley (at the end of 11 Humphreys) were written by him. Perhaps the ablest of his arguments was made in the great case of the Ohio Life Insurance and Transportation Company vs. Merchants' Insurance and Transportation Company (11 Humph. 1). He died quite advanced in years during the civil war.
Hon. James Rucks
Hon. James Rucks was at one time a prominent attorney at Nashville, and afterwards circuit judge. He was born in North Carolina, and came to Tennessee with his parents when in his seventeenth year. He soon went back and finished his classical education at the university of his native State. Returning to Tennessee, he read law diligently and successfully for two years, and commenced the practice of his profession in Carthage, where he soon obtained a profitable business, in competition with some of the ablest attorneys that Tennessee could then boast. He is said to have been singularly industrious in the preparation of his cases, and remarkably clear and forcible in his manner of discussing them in court. He subsequently located in the town of Lebanon, where he remained until 1828, when he removed to the city of Nashville, and was associ- ! ated in business with Felix Grundy and Gen. Gibbs. He afterwards became one of the circuit judges. Ho removed to Jackson, Miss., in 1829, where he became quite wealthy,
Hon. Thomas Claiborne
Hon. Thomas Claiborne was admitted to the Nashville bar in 1807. He was distinguished more in politics than in law, being an intense Jeffersonian Democrat. He was an able and fluent speaker, and a man of honorable and upright character. He left many descendants. He was member of Congress from 1817 to 1819. He was the first Grand Master of the Blasonic Grand Lodge of Tennessee.
David Craighead
David Craighead came to the bar about 1814, and would have gcquired more distinction as a lawyer had he not when young married into wealth, and thus become relieved from the spur of necessity. He was a man of native wit, a good speaker, and possessed fine conversational powers. Occasionally he appeared with great effect at the bar in important cases. His son, Thomas B. Craighead, now resides in Nashville.
Gen. Sam Houston
Gen. Sam Houston deserves to be mentioned in connection with the bar of Davidson County, pot because he was great or very much noted as a lawyer, but because of his eminent distinction in other respects. His career was truly one of the most remarkable of modern times, and we have reserved a sketch of him to be placed by the side of Gen. Jackson's, whom he somewhat resembled in certain phases of his character. Probably his reverence and respect for Jackson, under whom he had fought and achieved his first distinction in the Southern Indian war, brought him to the home of that great hero to embark in his civil and political career. He read law for a short time with James Trimble, at Nashville, and was admitted to the bar in 1819. His personal qualities rather than his learning or legal attainments - of the latter of which he must have possessed very little at that time - gave him prestige and place, and in a very short time he was district attorney and member of Congress. He was elected to the former office by the Legislature in October, 1818, and to the latter in 1823, and again in 1825, serving two consecutive terms, which closed in 1827. In August,,1827, he was elected Governor of Tennessee by a majority of about twelve thousand over his worthy competitor, Hon. Newton Cannon. Such was his personal popularity that upon his accession to the gubernato- rial office he had not a single opponent in the Legislature. He was the nominee again for Governor in 1829, and undoubtedly would have been elected had he not, in consequence of his unhappy domestic difficulty, renounced the canva.ss and the prospect not alone of immediate success, but of a future brilliant and perhaps unrivaled career in Tennessee, and hid himself for several years in the heart of the Cherokee Nation, west of the Mississippi. He emerged, however, from the wilderness and from a life among savages to be the herald of the " Lone Star" of the Texan republic, and the leader and founder of civilization upon
I the great southwestern frontier of the United States, carving out for himself a sphere of splendor which far outshone his earlier achievements in Tennessee. When he had, by his
I military genius, achieved the independence of Texas, he was chosen its civil president, then its representative in the hall of Congress from 1838 to 1840, then again president
I had he not been early tempted to abandon his professional studies for the allurements of political life. But he was doubtless better adapted to the sphere of action into which he seemed to drift, almost without intention on his part, than to the forensic arena or the judicial seat.
William E. Anderson
I He is described by Governor Foote as " truly a Samson Agonistes, alike in his physical frame and in his gigantic mental proportions. He was considerably more than six feet in height. His shoulders were broad and massive. His limbs were huge and muscular, but of most harmonious proportions. His figure was perfectly erect, even when he was far past the meridian of life. His expansive chest gave shelter to one of the most generous and sympathizing hearts that ever yet palpitated in a human bosom. His physiognomy was most striking and expressive, and when kindled into excitement, as in his later days he rarely was, there flashed forth from his commanding visage the mingled light of reason and sentiment, the effulgent beamings of which no man ever beheld and afterwards forgot." He has been compared to a volcano ordinarily in a state of slumberous repose, but capable of being stirred into sublime and terrible commotion by some adequate cause. Although such was his great power, he has left behind him the reputation of having never been a very diligent student of the learning appertaining to his profession. He was self-indulgent and fond of conviviality. One who knew him well, writing of this peculiarity of his character, and how it sometimes betrayed him into excesses, says, " But with all this he was a man of powerful intellect, and such were his acuteness, ingenuity, and analytic power that the truth seemed to be more subtle and hair-splitting order (rail-splitting, rather), but, like the trunk of the elephant, tore up trees while it could pick up pins. He stood high at the bar, and his services were eagerly sought, but he was too negligent in the preparation of his cases to be a truly successful lawyer. His resources and power, however, in the day of conflict frequently overcame his negligence in preparation. I was once smashed by him before a jury in this way where I had felt secure of a verdict.
" Anderson and Yerger in their encounters at the bar reminded me sometimes of a powerful bull and a stubborn bull-dog : sometimes the dog would be gored and tossed upon the horns, and sometimes the bull, bellowing with pain, would have his nose dragged to the ground and held there as in a vice. Anderson, for native intellectual power, had few superiors anywhere, so far as I have known men ; and I have known Webster, Clay, and Calhoun." He was at one time a judge of the Circuit Court, and removed to Mississippi about 1845.
Andrew C. Hayes
Andrew C. Hayes is yet well remembered by his surviving friends and old associates in Tennessee. He was a native of Rockbridge Co., Ya., and was educated at what was formerly known as Washington College. During his practice in Nashville he held the office of district attorney for several years. He removed to Mississippi in 1837, and was there associated in practice with Yolney E. Howard. He died quite suddenly a few years after his settlement in Blississippi.
George W. Campbell
George W. Campbell was an early member of the Davidson bar, and a contemporary of Felix Grundy and Gen. Jackson during his early career. He enjoyed a large and lucrative practice, acquired national distinction, and accumulated a handsome fortune. He was a member of Congress prior to 1809, when he was appointed a judge of the Supreme Court; he continued on the bench till 1811, and was then chosen United States senator, which office he filled till Mr. Monroe made him Secretary of the Treasury, 1813 -14. He resigned his place in the Cabinet, and wa.s appointed minister to Russia.
Some interesting reminiscences might be related of Judge Campbell's family did space permit. His only daughter, a most accomplished lady and heiress, became the wife of Gen. Ewell at the close of the late war. In 1873 they both died at the same time with malignant fever. " The dying hero, on hearing of her decease, demanded a last sight of those beloved features which he had so long felt to be identified with his own being. Her yet life-like but inanimate form, dressed for the tomb, was borne to his bedside ; he gazed upon the face of his beloved for one single moment of heart-convulsing but tearless agony, and fell back upon his pillow as dead as the corpse upon which he had been tenderly gazing."
Provenance
Text from History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.