Davidson County, Tennessee - Chapter 22, 1880
From History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. 15,167 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
18 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
- Hon John Bell
- Bench And Bar
- Hon. Francis Bkinley Fogg
- Godfrey M. Fogg Hon. Aaron V. Brown
- Bailie Peyton
- Henry Hollingsworth
- Return J. Meigs
- William L. Brown
- John M. Bass
- Henry B. Shaw
- David Campbell
- William T. Brown Morgan W. Brown
- Hon. Andrew Ewing
- Hon. Edwin Ii. Ewing, Ll.D.
- Uon. W. F. Cooper
- Hon. John Trimble
- Ex. Qov. Neill S. Brown
- Judge Josephus C. Guild
The text
15,167 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
Hon John Bell
This gentleman, who.se talents and distinction shed a lustre upon the place of his birth, was a native of Davidson County, born about 1795. He was educated at the University of Nashville, and began his career as a lawyer in Williamson County. He was sent to the Legislature from Williamson County before he was twenty-one years of age. He came to practice at Nashville, and entered into partnership witli Judge Crabb prior to the elevation of the latter to the Supreme Bench in 1827. Before he entered politics as a lifc-busiuess he had acquired a high standing at the bar as a lawyer of great acuteness, research, and ability, and as a speaker of no ordinary merits. He was about thirty-five when he entered the lower house of Congress, and from that till 1860 he was in public life most of his time. With the exception of appearing occasionally with his usual force and ability, he did little in the practice of his profes- .sion after he entered into public life.
We cannot resist the temptation to introduce a passage or two here from Governor Foote respecting Mr. Bell's introduction into politics and a few other incidents of his life. We quote from Mr. Foote's work on the " Bench and Bar of the South and Southwest," page 177 :
" In his first contest for a seat in Congress he had to encounter as an opposing aspirant the celebrated Felix Grundy. A more excited canvass than that just alluded to has never occurred in any State of the Union. There are some remarkable features about it which imparted to it at the time it was in progress peculiar interest. Mr. Bell was a young man of yet une.-tablished reputation. Mr. Grundy was a man past the middle stage of life and of world-wide fame. They were both avowed friends and supporters of Gen. Jackson in the coming Presidential election, but Jackson openly declared his preference for 5Ir. Grundy over his more youthful and inexperienced opponent. Often did the two candidates meet in discussion, and sometimes words were uttered by each of them not altogether comporting with kindness and courtesy. Several of the speeches made by Blr. Bell during this heated conflict are yet referred to often by old residents of Tennessee as master pieces in what may be called political digladiation. The success of BIr. Bell over such a competitor as Mr. Grundy at once gave him a high national attitude.
" When he reached Congress he soon found himself in the midst of a new contest. Mr. Polk and himself were pitted against each other by their respective friends as candidates for the Speakership of the House, and a bitter political antagonism sprang up between them, which did not sensibly abate for a long scries of years. Mr. Polk attained the Presidential station through the election of 1844 ; Mr. Bell was ui>succcssfully run for the same high place in 1860. Mr. Polk served in the ofiice of Governor of Tennessee for a single term ; Mr. Bell officiated as senator of the United States for two full terms. They are both now dead, and the questions upon which they were arrayed against each other are at rest, perhaps forever. . . . They were both men of eminently conservative turn of mind and devoted friends of the National Union. . . . BIr. Polk, as a popular speaker, has perhaps never had his equal in Tennessee ; Mr. Bell occasionally delivered a profound and statesmanlike discourse which would have done credit to any public man that our country has produced."
Governor Foote refers to his great speech, delivered at Vauxhall Garden, in Nashville, in 1836, and relates a very interesting incident connected with it. " Having," he says, " the honor of being on exceedingly intimate terras with Mr. Bell in the latter years of his life, I recollect having said to him, in the presence of his most intelligent and estimable lady, that I thought this Vauxhall speech by far the best I had ever seen of his composition, and that I had heard much as to its effect upon those who listened to it. He very modestly declared that he had taken more pains in preparing it than he had exercised in any other instance. Mrs. Bell said, with that noble and hearty frankness and freedom from false delicacy which so distitiguished her, that there was an anecdote connected with that same speech which she would relate to me, which she did, very much in those words : ' I had never seen Sir. Bell until the day on which he addressed the large assemblage at Vauxhall, though I had heard much of him and sympathized with him deeply as a public man. I listened to the whole of it with the warmest admiration. When, he had closed, I whispered to a friend that, though I had never before thought of marrying a second time, I did not know how I should be able to refuse a nuptial off'er from such an orator and patriot as I had been just listening to with such unfeigned delight. Whether Mr. Bell heard of my commendations or not, it is not for me to say ; but not many days elapsed before he called to pay his personal respects, and in little less time we became, as you see us, man and wife.' "
Judge Cooper says in a recent note, " Mr. Bell was a practicing lawyer at the bar, after I came to Nashville, for two or three years. On every occasion in which he undertook to argue a cause he showed a thorough mastery of it, and in one case, certainly, and perhaps two cases, where the cause was worthy of his steel, his forensic eflForts were masterly. He was possessed in an eminent degree of the power of sarcasm. The late Judge William B. Turley, who was at college with Mr. Bell, once said to me that the young men rated their college-mates much as they stood in afterlife, and that they all looked upon John Bell as the most, talented man at college, - Cumberland College, now the University of Nashville."
Hon. E. H. Ewing, in furnishing some reminiscences of Mr. Bell, remarks, " He was a man of a powerful and comprehensive mind, in many respects well fitted to occupy the highest positions as a statesman. Though not a man of learning in the usual sense, lie was a man of very extensive readincT and information. His knowledtro was of the most practical and effective character. In speaking he was equally at home before a jury, a crowd at the hustings, a Supreme Court, or the United States Senate. He enlisted attention everywhere by his complete mastery of his subject in all its bearings, and his earnestne.ss and impressivcnoss in the enforcement of his argument. He had little wit, some humor, no coruscating brilliancy like Prentiss, but a large vocabulary, brought well into use in the clothing mighty thoughts and well-considered opinions."
Ephraim H. Foster was born near Bardstown, Nelson Co., Ky., on the 17th of September, 1794. His father, Eobert C. Foster, located with his family in Davidson County, near Nashville, in 1797. He became a prominent citizen, filling at different times almost every civil office within the gift of the people, was repeatedly elected to both branches of the State Legislature, and was twice made presiding officer of the Senate. He died at Col. Foster's residence in 1845, at the advanced age of seventy-six, respected and honored by a people among whom he had so long lived. Col. Foster received the best advantages in the way of an education that the schools of a now and sparsely settled country afforded, and graduated in 1813 with the first class that was matriculated in Cumberland College, afterwards known as the University of Nashville. . He immediately commenced the study of law with John Dickinson, a lawyer of fine acquirements, who had emigrated from Massachusetts, and at that time stood high at the Nashville bar.
While pursuing his studies the news reached Nashville of the Indian massacre at Fort Mimms, and upon a call being made for men he enrolled as a volunteer, and marched under Gen. Jackson to the scene of action. He was taken into Gen. Jackson's military family as private secretary, and manfully endured all the hardships of this perilous campaign, bearing himself gallantly in the battles of Talladega, Enotocligpee, Emucfaw, and Topeka.
Upon the Indians being subdued and the campaign closing, Mr. Foster was lionorably discharged, returned home, and in a short time commenced the practice of his profession.
He soon took rank with the first members of the bar, and by close application to business, combined with a high and manly bearing, and being kind, courteous, and pleasant in his intercourse with all, was soon the recipient of a large and lucrative practice. In 1817 he married the widow of Mr. Dickinson, the gentleman with whom ho had prepared himself for his profession, and about this time, his engagements becoming too arduous and heavy for one person, he formed a partnership with William L. Brown, a man of quiet and retiring disposition, but without a superior in his profession, and who was subsequently placed upon tlie bench of the Supreme Court.
When Mr. Brown assumed his place upon the bench, Mr. Foster formed a partnership with Francis B. Fogg, who had emigrated from Connecticut to Tennessee in 1817. Mr. Fogg was a retiring, studious man, possessed of an inexhaustible store of legal learning, combined with & most remarkable knowledge upon all subjects and the most re- tentive of memories, but so reserved that his practice was limited. The association with Mr. Foster brought him more fully before the public, and his immense powers soon became known and appreciated. In a little while he took rank with the first lawyers of the State, and his services were eagerly sought, especially in the higher courts. This good man and great jurist lived to the advanced age of eighty-five, and was regarded by all as one of the founders of Tennessee jurisprudence. This partnership continued until Col. Foster's political engagements forced him to retire from the practice. To the last hour of his life he always regarded his old friend and partner with the affection of a brother.
Col. Foster was a fine speaker, had a noble carriage and commanding presence. His mind was elastic, and his perception quick ; his wit and repartee sparkling. He was social and vei-y agreeable in his manners ; very fond of a joke, which he would indulge in and play upon his best friends, either male or female. He was always companionable and pleasant with the ladies, who permitted him to perpetrate a joke that would not bo tolerated from another. All in all he was as brave and gallant a man as ever trod the earth ; was a stranger to fear ; might be inclined to yield his life, - his honor, never. He was no stickler, either at the bar, in private life, or in politics, bearing himself under all circumstances as the brave, courteous, and accomplished gentleman.
With all his good qualities, Mr. Foster was not faultless. What mortal is or ever was ? He had by nature a quick and violent temper, under the influence of which he sometimes did things that in his cooler moments no one regretted more than himself. In 1821, wliile arguing a case in which his feelings were very much enlisted, he became angry at some remark that fell from the bench and threw a book at the presiding judge, who, throwing aside the dignity of the court, sprang towards Mr. Foster, a heavy hickory walkingstick in his hand, and but for the intervention of friends a serious difficulty would have been the result. Peace, however, was restored without bloodshed. Mr. Foster made the proper apology, paid a heavy fine lor his rashness, and the honorable but belligerent court adjourned. In a few minutes Mr. Foster was in his office quietly writing, when in came the now venerable Judge J. C. Guild, then a country boy of some nineteen years, a total stranger and without recommendations, and asked permission to study law under him. Mr. Foster readily consented, thus exhibiting in a brief period of time two very antagonistic traits of character. Judge Guild remained in his office until he completed his studies, subsequently rose to eminence in his profession, and, although a zealous antagonist of Col. Foster at the height of his political career, always retained for him the warmest personal attachment, with the most profound respect and admiration, and now in his green old age delights in relating incidents, both personal and political, that occurred between them in years long gone by.
For years Mr. Foster pursued his profession with great assiduity ; his practice was large and very lucrative. Ho lived in princely style, and his hospitality was proverbial, and yet, with all his lavish expenditures upon family and friends, he accumulated a fine estate, and his surroundings
In 1832 he gave the first evidence of tlie political aspirations that marked his subsequent career. Previous to this time he had served his county in the State Legislature, but always reluctantly, and never had any formidable opposition when liis name was before the people. AVhen a member, he was invariably elected Speaker of the House, and by his courtly manners and an unequalod capacity for the despatch of business acquired an enviable reputation as a presiding oflBcer.
Hon. Felix Grundy was at this time United States senator from Tennessee, his term of service to expire in March, 1833. Col. Foster's popularity had grown until it was coextensive with the limits of the State, and his friends determined to place him in competition with Judge Grundy for this exalted position. The contests for seats in the Legislature were vrarm. In his own county Mr. Foster's friends elected by large majorities. When the Legislature assembled the name of Maj. John H. Eaton was brought forward as a candidate whose success would be more than gratifying to Gen. Jackson.
The balloting continued from time to time for weeks, and was terminated on the fifty-fifth ballot by the election of Mr. Grundy. The secret history of this result was known to but few. Mr. Foster became satisfied that Tennessee would be without her full representation in the United States Senate unless some of the aspirants should withdraw, and, fully determined that the President should not dictate who should bo the senator from Tennessee, prevailed upon enough of his own friends to vote for Mr. Grundy to secure his election.
Mr. Foster, with a zeal and devotion unsurpassed by any one, had to this time supported Gen. Jackson in all of his political conflicts. In 1835 he united his influence with that of the Tennessee delegation in the United States House of Representatives - with the exception of James K. Polk and Cave Johnson - in prevailing upon Hugh L. White, then a senator from Tennessee, to permit his name to be placed before the country for the Presidency in opposition to Jlr. Van Buren, advocated his election before the people, and ended in giving the vote of Tennessee to this pure and unspotted statesman and patriot. From this time to his death Mr. Foster was a warm, zealous, and devoted Wlii". In 1837, Blr. Foster was elected to succeed Judge Grundy in the United States Senate, whose term of service would expire in March, 1839. Soon after this Judge Grundy accepted a seat in Mr. Van Buren's Cabinet, and Mr. Foster received the executive appointment to fill his unexpired term, and took his seat in the Senate in December, 1838, and continued in office until March 3, 1839. The elections in Tennessee this year proved a Democratic success, and the Legislature which convened in the fall passed resolutions of instructions which neither Judge White nor himself could obey, and they both resigned. The resignation of Mr. Foster was transmitted to the Legislature Nov. 15, 1839, and closed with the.?e words : " I surrender without painful regret a trust which, under the circumstances, I could not hope to retain without reproach, and now deliver to the representatives of the people the commission I have the honor to hold in their service. It reached my hands without stain or corruption, and I return it without a blot of dishonor."
From this time for years the political strife and excitement in Tennessee were intense and bitter- The home of Jackson was battled for by both parties, without any regard whatever to the expenditure of brains, muscle, or money.
In 1840, Mr. Foster was placed upon the Whig electoral ticket for the State at large, and commenced in May the most exciting campaign that had ever been inaugurated in Tennessee, and continued in the field without rest until the election, and made .speeches in every county in the State. The Whigs were triumphant by a majority of twelve thousand, and to this result, without doing injustice I to others, it can bo truly said Mr. Foster contributed more tlian any other one person.
In 1841 the Democratic majority in the State Senate was one ; in the House the Whigs were in the ascendant by three votes, giving them a majority on joint ballot.
The Democratic senators, subsequently known as the " immortal thirteen," refused to join the House in convention for the purpose of a senatorial election, and the State was left without her full representation in the United States Senate.
In 1843 the Whigs were again in the ascendant, and Mr. Foster was elected senator a second time, and served until March 3, 1845. During this term of his senatorial life, Mr. Foster had the severest trial of all his political career. He advocated the admission of Texas into the Union, and his sense of duty to his native South prompted him to part company, for a little while at least, with a party to which he had so long clung alike in defeat as in victory. We give in his own words his painful feelings under the circumstances.
In a letter dated Washington, Feb. 12, 1845, to a devoted personal friend, he says, " No one can conceive the tortures I have suff"ered and am suflering in connection with the Texas question. I took my ground, as you will have seen from my declarations in the Senate, without saying a word or giving notice of my intentions to any member of that body. I did so for a reason which I also stated when I introduced my resolutions. This circumstance, in connection with the fixed and I fear deleterious repugnance of the leading Whigs here against the measure, occasioned jealousies and suspicions which it required no little skill and tact on my part to attack and overcome. Whilst all this was going on I was assailed by the locofocos with the most disagreeable flatteries and congratulations, which I always - repelled with a true and becoming spirit. And now, when I apprehend from the signs that all hope of annexation during this session of Congress is lost, you tell me that both parties at home, believing it to be in my power to accomplish the task, look to me to secure the passage of the resolutions, and that success is essential to my fate, as some of my friends think. Was ever a poor, impotent devil in such a hopeless, helpless category ? I have done my duty. I have done the best I could, and I shall continue in tlie same fidelity ; but, alas ! I do despair, and my despair is almost without hope."
Bench And Bar
ment, bitterness, and animosity that of 1340. James K. Polk, one of Tennessee's favorite sons, was the Democratic nominee. Tlie canvass throughout was one continued scene of excitement beyond description. Victory again perched upon tlie Wiiig banner, and Mr. Clay carried tlie State by the bare majority of one hundred and thirteen votes. Mr. Poster was a participant in all this excitement and strife, battling manfully for his now personal as well as political friend, Henry Clay. In 1845 be received the Whig nomination as candidate for Governor, and again made a long and arduous campaign, speaking throughout the entire State. He was unsuccessful, his competitor, Aaron V. Brown, receiving a majority of some fourteen hundred in a poll of upwards of one hundred and fifteen thousand votes. Two consecutive years of intense excitement, with the attendant labor of traveling and speaking, made great inroads upon bis constitution, and laid the foundation of his subsequent sickness and suffering.
In 1847, Mr. Foster lost his wife. She had been to bim a "help-meet" iud^ied, presiding over his hospitable home in a way to win the hearts of all, and in his absence watching with a sleepless eye his personal interest, always displaying an energy of character that could not be surpassed. The day of her death was one of mourning with all, high and low, rich and poor alike.
He subsequently lost two married daughters, in whom he had taken great pride, and to whom he had always been most tenderly attached, and was never again the social and pleasant companion of former days.
In 1852, at the earnest solicitation of numerous friends, he consented to prepare an oration for the funeral obsequies of Mr. Clay, but when the day for its delivery came he was stretched upon a bed of suffering, unable to rise, and it was read to a large audience by the Hon. Andrew Ewing. This production has always been pronounced one of the best efforts of his life.
He died Sept. 14, 1854, with an abiding hope and faith that he would be reunited in another and better world to venerated parents and an idolized wife and daughters who had gone before.
Hon. Francis Bkinley Fogg
This gentleman, who recently died in Nashville, in the eighty-sixth year of his age, was the oldest member of the Davidson County bar. He was born in Brooklyn, Conn., on the 21st of September, 1705, being the son of Ilev. Daniel Fogg, a native of New Hampshire and a worthy minister of the Protestant Episcopal Church. His mother, whose maiden name was Briuley, came of one of the most respectable families of New England, and was a lady of excellent character.
The first ten years of Mr. Fogg's life were spent under the paternal roof, where he received such instruction as could bo obtaiued at homo and at the common schools. He was subsequently sent to an academy at Plaiufield, where he made rapid progress in Greek and L;itin, becoming well versed in these languages at the age of thirteen. At the conclusion of these academical studies a relative of his, - Hon. William Hunter, of Newport, R. I., for many years a United States senator, and later in life minister to Brazil, - being delighted with the early talents of his young kinsman, invited him to pursue his studies, including that of law, in his family at Newport and under his own immediate instruction. This was most fortunate for the mental training of our young student, as bis instructor was a gentleman of liberal culture and wide acquaintance with literature. While availing himself fully of these accessory advantages he made special preparation in that particular branch which he had chosen as his profession, and at the age of twenty was admitted to the Newport bar.
Declining a generous invitation of Blr. Hunter to establish himself with bim on equal terms in the profession at Philadelphia, - an unusually flattering proposition to a young man just admitted to the bar, - Mr. Fogg set bis face southward, and after spending a few days in Washington continued his journey, and in February, 1818, reached Columbia, a beautiful and thriving village of Tennessee, about .forty miles south of Nashville. Here he opened an ofiioe, but was soon induced by Hon. Felix Grundy to remove to Nashville, which he did in the latter part of the year 1818. Since that day Nashville has been his home, the theatre of his various labors and triumphs, and the scene of the checkered experiences of joy and sou'ow of his long, useful, and honored life. No man had been more fully identified with all the important legal and judicial proceedings of this county and of the State for the last half-century up to the time of his retirement from active business than the subject of this notice.
Tennessee, at the time of his advent to the then young State, was celebrated for her patriotism and for the "heroic achievements which had closed the last war with England in a blaze of glory." Nashville, though but a respectable village in size and population, was the acknowledged city of the State. Her bar, which in previous years had acquired a good degree of fame, was then renowned throughout the State and in many foreign parts for the learning, the great abilities, and the honorable bearing of its members.
At such a bar Mr. Fogg took his place, then young and inexperienced. He was not a man who, by boldness and self-confidence, would thrust himself into the professional field to reap prema^urely the fruits which he knew could only grow and ripen by patience and enlarged study. He could well afford to wait for the fruit to mature, that when the harvest came it might be full, rich, and ample. By his modesty and solid attainments he soon won the confidence and esteem of the leading members of the profession, and business followed as a natural consequence, slowly at first, but surely and cumulative, so that in a few years his professional labors were large and remunerative. He was first employed to make up pleadings, a most difficult branch of legal science; but in this bis great memory and wonderful acquaintance with law-books became apparent, and he was an acknowledged adept in that department of the profession.
While waiting for that recognition which his learning and talents justlj' entitled him to expect, he was constantly busy in his office and among his books, mingling in his daily exercises the study of law, politics, and abstruse literature, and never forgetting to keep up and extend his critical learning in the ancient classics. He was thus improving himself and enlarging those rich and abundant stores which subsequently obtained for his judgment and opinions almost oracular authority.
Sir. Fogg was for nearly twenty-five years the law-partner of Hon. Epliraim H. Foster. The latter member was engaged in the law practice, and the former in the chancery practice. A living member of the bar, intimately acquainted with Mr. Fogg, says, " He was exceedingly well educated, and even profoundly read in the elements of the law. He soon made his mark, and before 1830 was one of the leaders of the bar of Tennessee. He was a man of high honor, of amiable temper, of pleasing and kindly manners, always ready to lielp and instruct the younger members of the bar, with whom he was universally popular. I acknowledge my obligations to him in many a difficulty. He was the most learned lawyer of his day in Tennessee. He had an extraordinary memory, especially for dates and cases. Of him it might be truly said, he was a walking library. He was eminently a lawyer calculated for the Chancery and Supreme Courts, not a jury lawyer. He was of a quick apprehension and suggestive mind, able in exposition, a fluent speaker, and overflowing with learning, both classical and legal. It was a delight to hear him, even when one took no interest in the particular ease to which he addressed himself The late Chancellor Cahal, a man of strong mind and strong appetites, was in the habit of saying that he would rather hear Mr. Fogg speak than to eat. Mr. Fogg's brain did fairly ovciflow with learning. He was a long time a partner of Hon. E. H. Foster, and also for a while a partner of W. L. Brown. He never interfered in party politics, looking with some disdain upon the ignoble conflicts to which they give rise. He was a mild Union man during the civil war, but found much to censure on both sides. He will leave behind him a character unstained and almost unapproachable. He was a true but largehearted and liberal Christian. One might well say. May my last days be like his!" Mr. Fogg died on the 13th day of April, 1880, aged eighty-five years.
" A large number of lawyers and citizens assembled yesterday afternoon at two o'clock in the Circuit Court room to oifer a public tribute of respect to the memory of the late Francis B. Fogg, Esq.
" The meeting was called to order by ex-Governor Neill S. Brown, who made a motion, which was adopted, that Judge J. C. Guild take the chair. Mr. Nicholas Vaughn and the American representative were chosen secretaries.
" After the purpose of the meeting had been stated with some eulogistic remarks upon the character of the deceased and the recognition of his qualities due to the occasion, the chairman, upon motion, appointed a committee of six to draft and report suitable resolutions. The committee, composed of J. B. White, ex-Governor Neill S. Brown, Judge E. H. East, Gen. T. T. Smiley, George Stubblefield, and Judge J. M. Lea, made the following report :
" ' This meeting have heard with deep regret of the death of our esteemed and distinguished friend and fellow-citizen, Hon. Francis B. Fogg, wliich occurred at the residence of Col. W. B. Reese, in this city, on the morning of the 13th inst.
" ' Mr. Fogg was born in Brooklyn, Conn., in 1795, and after receiving an education, both scholastic and legal, emigrated to Tennessee in 1817, where he made his home for the remainder of his life. Upon his settlement in Tennessee he commenced the practice of law, which he pursued with unremitting diligence for half a century, until age and disease disqualified him for labor. It is no disparagement to his many distinguished cotemporaries in the profession during that long and eventful period to say that he had few rivals and no superiors. His success was eminent. He commanded the confidence of the community in a remarkable degree. To a mind naturally strong and vigorous he united rare industry, and, with original scholarship of a high order, he was able to amass stores of learning on all subjects. He possessed a wonderful mepiory, by which he could recall cases and incidents that most others had forgotten. He was familiar, not only with the history of the ; law, but with the history of this and other countries.
" ' Mr. Fogg was not ambitious for office, and never sought promotion; but, in 1834, he was, by the voluntary action of this community, elected a member of the Constitutional Convention, and took a prominent part in its deliberations. In 1 851-52 he was elected to the State Senate from this county, and aided efficiently in inaugurating our system of internal improvements, which has done so much for the State. He was also prominent in the establishment of the free schools of Nashville, which have accomplished so much for its population.
" ' In a word, he was the friend of education in all its phases, and contributed whatever he could to make society better and happier. It is injpossible now to tell how many of the statutes that adorn our code and measure and regulate the rights of persons and property he was the author of. It was the habit of legislators to call upon him on all occasions lor aid in the preparation of bills.
" ' But in this hour of sorrow at his loss, it is consoling to reflect upon his high moral nature. He lived a long life of struggle and toil, but no stain of vice rests upon his memory. He was a Christian gentleman, - the highest eulogium that can be paid to any man, - and for half a century he was a consistent member of the Episcopal Church. But in religion, as in everything else, he was tolerant to all. If he could have had his way he would have made all men prosperous and happy, without any special superiority to himself; therefore,
" ' Resolved, That this preamble and resolutions be published in the city papers, and that a copy be transmitted to the family of the deceased.'
and request that they be spread upon the minutes. The followina; were appointed: Mr. R. McPhail Smith, for the Federal Court ; Gen. George Blaney, for the Circuit Court ; Mr. Matthew W. Allen, for the Chancery Court; Mr. J. W. Horton, Jr., for the Criminal Court ; and Judge John C. Gaut, for the Supreme Court.
" While the committee on resolutions were absent, Hon. Horace H. Harrison made the following address, which, on motion of Gen. Maney, was directed to be published as an accompaniment to the resolutions :
" ' Mr. Chairman : I approach the bier of the distinguished and worthy dead, whose life and character we have met to speak of, with solemnity, affection, and veneration. 1 " ' He illustrated in his long and useful career all the I sterling virtues which can adorn human character. He was true to himself, true to his friends, and true to his professions. He was never known to break a promise, or to be guilty of the slightest dissimulation. He was just in his dealings and just in holding the scales as he judged his fellow-men.
! " ' He was prudent, temperate, discreet, and charitable. I He was quiet in his demeanor, unobtrusive in his manner, I and actually shrank from notoriety and prominence. He i never seemed to be conscious of his own intellectual power, or to realize that he possessed the most extensive and varied acquirements. While he was a giant in intellect and attainments, he was a child in the simplicity and modesty of his general bearing. Of his profound legal learning I need not speak in this presence. The reports of causes argued and decided in the highest court in our State for forty years, until within the last few years, are full of evidences ! of his industrious labors, his skill in dealing with the intricate and difficult questions before that court, and of the ' prominent role he played in building up our jurisprudence. " ' He has been thrown into the most intricate professional association with three generations of lawyers in Tennessee, [ and no man who ever lived in our State has been more i universally honored and respected by his brethren. I " ' No unkind word was ever heard to fall from his lips. No bitter resentments ever found a place in his bosom. Nearly thirty years ago I was an officer of the State Senate, of which he was a member, and during the eventful session of that body, of 1851-52, 1 learned to know him well. In the heated debates of that session he never lost his equality of temper or uttered an unkind word against his jjolitical opponents, and it was noticeable that at the close of the session the Democratic members of the Senate were -as warmly and affectionately devoted to him as were the Whigs with whom he acted.
" ' He lived out more than his threescore-and-ten years, and died at peace with the world at the advanced age of eighty-five, a ripened sheaf ready to be garnered in that unseen country to which faith, hope, and love all, all combined to lead his tottering steps.
" ' He has gone from us. No more will his voice bo heard in our temples of justice. No more his kindly greetings to lawyers, young and old, will be extended ; but his name we will find on the pages of our State Reports so frequently that we will be continually reminded of him, as in his day, the foremost lawyer in the State, and his character and example will, I trust, continually excite in all of us a desire to emulate his sterling qualities of head and heart.
" ' He needs no other monument to perpetuate his memory than those which he himself has erected. The Constitution of 1834, the legislation which sent the locomotive through the valleys and under and over the hills and mountains of his adopted State, the jurisprudence of the State which he aided so powerfully in placing on firm foundations, and the public-school system of our beautiful and prosperous city, will speak his praises and remind us of the master-builder long after those who knew and loved him have passed away.'
" Governor Neill S. Brown then addressed the meeting. He said he could never forget when he first met the distinguished man. He had heard of him before he knew of Coke or Blackstone. He had supposed this eminent lawyer, like many other men in high life, was arrogant and self-sufficient. He had been surprised to find a man affable and simple of manner and generous of heart. And throughout his long acquaintance with him he found him what he now could say of him, the kindest man he ever knew. His life was an example to every young man. No finger of criticism could be put upon it. He acted out the principles of honor and of the Christian religion. Governor Brown here related incidents illustrative of the wonderful memory Mr. Fogg possessed, and which he made profitably useful to others around him as well as to himself. His death was a premonition to others of the bar who were" old in years. There was something to lament in the devastation of death, even among the aged. How old must a man grow whom we have known and loved that we should be willing to see him die ? It was not well for them to refrain to give just meed to Francis B. Fogg, for who had done as much as he ? His handiwork could be seen all through the history of Tennessee. His great, quiet, unobtrusive merit, contrasted with that which has laurels and plaudits from the multitude, was what won the hearts of those who knew him. There was no better way to close these words than to apostrophize him :
" Mr. Jackson B. White here related of the deceased an incident of his great legal and historical learning which astonished those who knew of it, and which had been the cause of a great event. Shortly after the war a large gathering of Nashville lawyers were assembled at a session of the United States Court, over which Judge Trigg presided, and at which the fiimous test oath was administered. Mr. Fogg refused to take tlie oath, and gave his reasons in an exhaustive argument, which he sustained with a wealth of historical reference and illustration that combined to make his objections irresistible. When he finished his remarks, he left the court-room, followed by a number of citizens who with him had refused to take the oath. Judge Trigg, turning to Mr. White, told him to go after Mr. Fogg and induce him to write out his argument and present in the proper way, and the law would be repealed. Mr. Fogg declined to do this, as ho did not believe he could completely recall what he had said. It liad all occurred to him as he spoke. Col. W. B. Reese, however, wrote as much of it as he could recall, and it was presented to the court at Knoxville, where the same Judge Trigg declared the oath unconstitutional. Mr. Fogg was, perhaps, the first lawyer in the country to argue against the constitutionality of the act of Congress in prescribing the oath.
" Several other citizens made warmly eulogistic allusions to the character and bore witness to the profound and varied learning of the distinguished lawyer.
The meeting was one which evoked deep interest. The older members of the bar always spoke with emotion when they talked of the pure life of the man they had known and honored and who was gone from among them.
Godfrey M. Fogg Hon. Aaron V. Brown
Governor Brown was a student-at-law in Na.shville with Judge Trimble, and entered the profession in this city. He was born on the 15th of August, 1795, in the county of Brunswick, Va., the same county in which Gen. James Robertson was born. His father, the Rev. Aaron Brown, enlisted when not yet of lawful age for three years in the Revolutionary army. He was in the battle of Trenton, and participated in that ever-memorable march through the Jerseys wliere the course of AVashington's army was known to the enemy by the blood of its barefooted soldiery. He was also one of the sufferers in the encampment at Valley Forge during the severe winter of 1777-78, where disease, famine, and nakedness so often drew tears from the illustrious Washington. At the close of his term of service he returned to the county of Brunswick, where he continued to reside for nearly forty years in the midst of those who had witnessed his early and patriotic career, respected and honored by all as a faithful and useful minister of the gospel of the Methodist persuasion, an upright civil magistrate, a staunch Republican of the old Jefferson school, and an honest man.
The subject of this memoir was the issue of his second marriage, with Elizabeth Melton (corrupted from Milton), of Northampton Co., N. C. Except in the simplest tlements, Governor Brown was educated in the last-mentioned State. He was sent when very young to Westrayville Academy, in the county of Nash, in order to be placed under the care of Mr. John Babbitt, one of the best educators of his time. After continuing there for two years, he was transferred in 1812 to the" University of North Carolina, at Chapel Hill. He graduated at this institution in 181-1, iu a large class, of which Senator Mangum and Ex-Governor Manley, of North Carolina, were also members. The duty was assigned to him by the faculty and trustees of delivering the valedictory oration on commencement-day, and the service was performed in a manner which produced the most striking impression on the large as.sembly then in attendance. The collegiate career of but few young men is marked by incidents of sufficient importance to be noticed in a sketch like this. Industry in preparing for and punctuality in attending at the hour of recitation, as well as the most cheerful conformity to the rules of the institution, were the most striking characteristics of his educational course. And it should be added that these characteristics, becoming a confirmed habit, were of great service in after-life in his professional and public career.
Having finished his educational career. Governor Brown returned to his parents, who in the previous year had removed to the county of Giles, in Tennessee. About the beginning of the year 1815 he entered upon the study of his profession in the office of the late Judge Trimble at Nashville. With this gentleman he continued to read for two years, and often referred to him as one of the most \ sympathetic, able, and upright men he ever knew. Having obtained a license, he opened an office in Nashville, and commenced practice with the. most fiattering prospects of success. '
About this time, however, Alfred M. Harris, who was ; engaged in an extensive practice in all the southern coun ties in Middle Tennessee, accepted a place on the bench, ; and .solicited Governor Brown to remove to the county of Giles and close up his extensive business for him. The opportunity was inviting, and that being the residence of his now aged parents, he determined to settle in that I county. Taking charge at once of an extensive practice, both civil and criminal, including the land-litigations, then an important and almost distinctive branch of the profession. Governor Brown found all the resources of his mind brouglit into immediate requisition. No time was to be lost in idleness, none to be devoted to pleasure. One off' liis maxims about this period was " Always to be the first at court, and never to leave it until the adjourning order was made." Under such habits it was no matter of surprise to those who observed them that there were but few causes of importance in the counties in which he practiced in which he was not engaged.
In a few years after Governor Brown commenced his career in Giles the late President Polk commenced his in Columbia, in the adjoining county of Maury. They soon formed a law-partnership, thereby extending the field of their professional labors into more counties than they could have done without this union of interests. This partnership continued for several years, until BIr. Polk engaged in his Congressional career. Its dissolution brought no termination of that cordial friendship, personal and political, in which it had commenced, and which continued until the death of the late lamented President. Governor Brown continued engaged in profession until the year 1839, when, having been elected to Congress, he gave it up altogether. Much of the time in which he was engaged in regular and full practice ho was also a member of one branch or the other of the State Legislature. This service, being near home, and the counties he represented being those in which ho practiced, produced no material impediment to the progress of his professional business. But the case was different iu his distant service in Congress. Governor Brown served as a senator from the counties of Lincoln and Giles at all the sessions of the Legislature, regular and called, from 1821 to 1S27 inclusive, except the session of 1825, when he was not a candidate. In the session of 1831-32 he was the representative of the county of Giles in the other branch of the General Assembly. In this session, by the I order of the judiciary committee, he prepared an elaborate and able report, which he submitted to the House, on the subject of capital punishment, which attracted great atteni tion throughout the country.
Governor Brown first became a candidate for Congress in 1839, and during the period of his Congressional services - - beginning 1839 and ending 1815 - he seems to have been j an active member, taking a part in nearly all the great i questions which came up during that eventful period of our political history. His services in Congress ended with the commencement of President Polk's administration. He I declined any office under the administration, and determined to return home and devote himself to the education of ills children and the management of his own private i affairs. Before he reached liouie, however, he was nomi- Dated by the Democrats as a candidate for Governor of Tennessee, and met the news of his candidacy at Pittsburgh on his return. He hesitated several days before accepting the nomination. It conflicted with bis purpose to retire to private life, and opened a wide field of labor with what seemed a doubtful prospect of success. The Whig i strength had not yet been decisively broken in the State, ( notwithstanding the prestige gained by the election of Mr. Polk to the Presidency. Besides, Blr. Polk, in organizing his administration and selecting his friends for different i offices, had withdrawn from the State some of the most influential and powerful members of the party. He himself ' was gone, Hon. Cave Johnson was gone, Gen. Robert Armstrong was gone, and several others, whose weight had always been felt in State elections. Discouraging, however, as were the prospects, he finally determined to take the field I against Col. S. Foster, a late senator, and one of the most '' popular and able men of the Whig party. The discussions of the canvass turned chiefly on the tariff, the admission of I Texas, and the Oregon question. Governor Brown was I elected by a majority of fifteen or sixteen hundred, but in ] the canvass of 1847 he was defeated by about half that number. At this period, and for some thne previous, political parties in Tennessee were so evenly balanced that they carried the State alternately against each other.
In 1850 he was a member of the Southern Convention, held at Nashville, and while he concurred fully in the resolutions passed by that body, dissented from and protested against the address.
He was also a delegate to the Baltimore convention in 1852, and introduced a resolution into that body, raising a committee of one from each State, to be appointed bj' the delegates of the same, to whom all the resolutions relative I to the principles or platform of the Democratic party should bo referred without debate. This postponing the discussion of resolutions till after the report of the committee was an important improvement, the utility of which was at once perceived by the convention, and the resolution was adopted. Governor Brown was unanimously appointed chairman of the committee, and reported the platform, which gave such general satisfaction to the party throughout the United States. He was, in foct, the great platform-maker of his party at most of the important conventions.
Bailie Peyton
Half a century ago Bailie Peyton and Henry A. Wise were practicing attorneys in Nasliville. Both have since become renowned names, - one in Tennessee and the other in Virginia, their native States.
Bailie Peyton was born in Sumner County in 1803. In 1824 he was admitted to the Davidson County bar, and soon after formed a partnership with Henry A. Wi.se, then a young man about of his own age, whom he met for the first time in Nashville. Being of a congenial disposition, they at once became fiimiliar and intimate friends. Nature had lavished her gifts upon both, and at the commencement of their career hosts of admiring friends predicted for them alike quite as much distinction as it was afterwards their fortune to acquire. The partnership lasted about two years, wlien Mr. Wise returned to win honor and distinction in a most brilliant political career in his native State. Mr. Peyton remained to become no less renowned in Tennessee.
Mr. Peyton was a Whig, and was thirtjr years of age when he first ran for Congress, in 1833. His competitor was Col. Archie Overton. Peyton was elected, and was returned twice afterwards, serving till 1839. He was lieutenant-colonel of a Louisiana regiment in the Mexican war, and was conspicuous for his gallantry. He entered heartily and eloquently into the canvass for both of the successful Whig candidates, Harrison and Taylor. The latter appointed him United States district attorney at New Orleans, and, with the concurrence of the United States Senate, sent him as minister to Chili. By President Pierce he was tendered the portfolio of the war department, but declined it, preferring to engage in the practice of law in California. How long he practiced there we are not informed.
Sir. Peyton possessed no great legal learning, and as a Icnvijer was not ranked high by the profession generally ; but as an advocate and political speaker he had few equals. He possessed wit, fervor, strong common sense, a vehement and impressive delivery, fluency, imagination, and personal magnetism. His conversational powers were of a high order, and his friends were devotedly attached to him.
Throughout his life BIr. Peyton was noted for his fondness for the turf, and it is said that no man in the South did more to maintain its purity and tone. He got up the great Peytona stake of forty-three thousand dollars, which drew thousands of people to the Nashville race-course in 1843. He was a man of fine physical appearance, "and, taken all in all, was one of Tennessee's greatest sons." He died at his home near Gallatin, Aug. 18, 1878, aged seventyfive years.
Henry Hollingsworth
forced his way up to a good position as a politician and lawyer by native strength and perseverance. He did not remain long at the bar, but acquiring considerable property by his marriage, he retired to the country, where he died many years ago.
Return J. Meigs
Eeturn J. Meigs, who, with Judge William F. Cooper, compiled the " Code of Tennessee," practiced law for many years in Athens, E. Teun., and afterwards removed to Nashville, where he ran as brilliant and useful a career as any lawyer or jurist in the State. He was concerned for nearly thirty years in the management of a large number of diifioult and important causes. He was not only learned in the law, but in ancient and modern languages, and was a comparative philologist of no common attainments. He is the author of a voluminous digest of the judicial decisions of the State of Tennessee, a work which is regarded by many as the most skillfully compiled book of the kind to be found anywhere in the United States. Mr. Meigs, being an uncompromising Union man, and unable to concur in the measures which carried the State in favor of secession in 1861, removed to Wa,?hington, and is now holding a very responsible official position under the government.
It has been remarked that when Mr. Meigs left the city of Nashville he left no equal behind him in general scholarship, and no superior in legal attainments. The only man then living who could risk a comparison with him was the venerable Francis B. Fogg, a gentleman who, for deep scholarly research and unstained purity of morals, had no superior west of the Alleghany Mountains.
William L. Brown
William L. Brown commenced his legal career in Clarksville, Tenn. He is reputed to have been a native of South Carolina. He was a man of fine natural endowments and a persevering and untiring student of books. Such was his tenacity of purpose that no difficulty could turn him aside. His energy verged upon combativeness. He had little claim to be recognized as an orator of the highest grade, but he always spoke with earnestness, precision, and force. His elaborate speeches were free from flowery rhetoric, which he utterly despised, and were models of condensed logic and argument. The great peculiarity of Judge Brown was that he sought neither argument, illustration, nor inspiration outside of his large and well-selected library of law-books, believing these to be the richest and bestsupplied armory from which to draw his weapons for every encounter, great or small, in the legal arena. He was appointed with Hon. Jacob Peck one of the judges of the Supreme Court in 1822, in the place of Judge Emmerson, resigned, and held the office two years, when he resigned.
John M. Bass
John M. Bass was admitted to the bar in 1830. He was a young man of fine estate ; married a daughter of Hon. Felix Grundy, and having no taste for the law, never practiced it. He was a man of fine abilities, of liberal education, and in every respect a first-rate citizen. He was an active promoter of every scheme for the advancement of the interests of Nashville ; was mayor of the city several times, president of the Union Bank, and an extensive planter in Louisiana and Arkansas. Though decided in his party politics, he was entirely above the tricks and devices of the ordinary politician, and was universally respected for his good sense and probity. Few men have impressed themselves more powerfully upon the city of their residence. He died a few years since in New Orleans, having become much embarrassed by losses consequent upon the civil war, and by some unfortrfnate suretyships.
Henry B. Shaw
Henry B. Shaw, admitted in 1830, was a young man of fine talents, but did not practice long in Nashville. He died young, - it is believed, in St. Louis.
David Campbell
David Campbell is still alive and a lawyer of high standing in Franklin. He was admitted to the Davidson bar in 1831, and was chancellor of this district a short time after
William T. Brown Morgan W. Brown
Morgan W. Brown came to the bar some time prior to 1830. He was for a number of years judge of the United States Court for the Middle District of Tennessee. He was a man of considerable reading and literary taste, a fine miscellaneous writer, for some time editor of one of the leading newspapers of Nashville, and a gentleman of polished manners and high social qualities. He was a brother of Hon. William L. Brown, one of the judges of the Supreme Court.
Hon. Andrew Ewing
The subject of this memoir was the youngest of six brothers, sons of Nathan Ewing, and grandsons of Andrew Ewing, the first clerk of the County Court of Davidson County. He was born in Na.shville in 1813 ; graduated at the University of Nashville in 1831 ; was admitted to the bar in 1835, and formed a partnership in law in 1837 with his brother, Hon. Edwin H. Ewing, now of Murfreesboro'. This business connection continued till 1851, when the latter relinquished practice for a time and made a tour in Europe. Andrew Ewing, though somewhat careless in his diction, was easy, fluent, and unembarrassed at the bar from the first, and was a speaker of great persjiasiveness and force. He was also a diligent and laborious student, and strictly attentive to business. Those best acquainted with him kt the outset of his career felt sure that he only needed time to make him deservedly prominent at the bar. And it so turned out. He was one of those men (not very common) who grow in knowledge, wisdom, and ability so long as they live. While giving diligent attention to professional business, he also mingled considerably in the politics of the day as a speaker and counselor.
He was an earnest, moderate, and liberal Democrat, while his brother was a Whig. While in business together they did not discuss their political ditFereiices, and, indeed, found in some of their more private interviews that these diiferences were not so radical after all. In 184-t, and ever after, he was much sought for, at home and in other parts of Tennessee, as a political speaker. In discussion and debate, whether at law or in politics, he feared no opponent, and liad few equals. Especially were his speeches eflFective and powerful, for many years before his death, in the Circuit and Criminal Courts, and in the argument of the cases which went up by appeal from these to the Supreme Court.
He was liberal, kindly, sympathetic, and very popular, not only with his own party, but also with the MHiigs. In 1846-47, when his brother and partner was in Congress, he gave attention, not to the law branch of their business, which was his own, but also to the chancery branch, which was his partner's, and to the entire satisfaction of their clients. He was liberal in his purchase of law-books, and studied them well. He was an excellent case-lawyer, as well as one thoroughly imbued with a knowledge of elements and principles.
His party was largely in the minority in the Nashville . Congressional .District, and he did not therefore seek office at first, but in 1849 his friends thought proper to bring him forward as a candidate for Congress. He was elected against a vigorous, active, and energetic opponent, so much stronger was he than his party. He served two sessions in Congress with credit, having made two respectable speeches; but not having much taste for the House of Representatives, and not being willing to impose on his friends again an arduous struggle against a party majority, he declined a renomination by his party.
At the political convention which first nominated Andrew Johnson for Governor, Andrew Ewing was first nominated by acclamation after a number of efibrts to nominate others, but he declined, and Johnson was finally the nominee. Andrew Ewing was a prominent candidate before the Legislature for United States senator when Senator N icholson was elected, in 1860.
Upon the erection of a statue to Gen. Jackson at Memphis, by public request Andrew Ewing delivered an address on Jackson's character and services, which was one of a high order of merit, and was received with general applause.
In 1851 he formed a partnership with Hon. W. F. Cooper. This continued with mutual satisfaction till the year 1801, when Blr. Cooper was elected a judge of the Supreme Court. A partnership was then foimed between Mr. Ewing and John Marshall, of Franklin, but this was unfruitful of professional results, as the civil war came on immediately, and they both died before it ended.
Though a sincere Democrat, he was not a secessionist. On the contrary, he struggled with all his might to make the Union vote of February, 1861, as large as possible, thus offending many of his old associates and admirers. With many others, he yielded to the overwhelming current which set in against the North after Mr. Lincoln's proclamation. He retired South with the Southern army in the spring of 18U2, making every sort of sacrifice of business and property, and was appointed one of a permanent court- martial of lawyers, which sat until towards the close of the war, under the commands of Bragg and Johnson. He was much beloved and admired in the army. He died in 1864 at Atlanta, Ga., worn out and overborne by a complication of diseases, the result of exposure, anxiety, and excessive labor. He left behind him a character without stain or reproach. He was twice married, and his last wife survives him.
Hon. Edwin Ii. Ewing, Ll.D.
This gentleman is connected by his father, Nathan, and by his grandfather, Andrew Ewing, with the first settlers of Nashville. Both of his progenitors were men of prominence, and among the best educated of the pioneers of the Cuniberland Valley, being descended from the intelligent and enterprising Scotch-Irish stock, an infusion of which constituted so large and influential an element in the early population of Bliddle Tennessee. The names of the Ewings, Andrew and Nathan, appear in the County Court records as clerks, successively, from 1783 to 1830, a period of fortyseven years. The former was the chief scribe, and did most of the public writing, as well as much for private individuals, under the temporary form of government which preceded Davidson County. Both Andrew and Nathan Ewing were well educated for men of their times, with that tendency to self-reliant study and mental discipline which has been prominently characteristic of their descendants.
Edwin H. Ewing was born in Nashville on the 2d of December, 1809, and, from the age of three years till his recent removal to Murfreesboro' resided in this city constantly, with the exception of temporary absences on official duties at Washington and in travels abroad. He graduated at the University of Nashville in 1827, received in due course the degree of A.M., and within a few years past the honorary title of LL.D. He studied law without a preceptor, using the books of an older brother who had studied but did not practice the profession, and appealing for aid in his difficulties to that truly learned and generous member of the Nashville bar, Hon. Francis B. Fogg, than whom no man could be found better qualified to correctly guide his inquiries or more ready to extend to him a helping hand. Mr. Ewing cherishes a grateful remembrance of the kindness of Mr. Fogg in those day.s of preparation for the profession, and for the sympathy shown him in his early difficulties and struggles, as well as the uniform courtesy received from him on all occasions. Mr. Ewing obtained a liccn.se to practice in 1830, and was regularly admitted to the bar in 1831 . He then formed a partnership with James P. Grundy, which continued till 1837. During this time they did a large amount of business, and Mr. Ewitig was growing in character as a lawyer. In January, 1837, he dissolved the partnership with Mr. Grundy, and formed a partnership with his younger brother, Andrew Ewing, who had shortly before come to the bar. In 1840 he took a very active part in Gen. Harrison's election, having become a Whig in the previous canvass of Van Buren, White, and Harrison. This involved him in some personal conflicts and quarrels, and made him so far a favorite of his own party that he was elected along with James Campbell, Esq.,
In the canvass of 1844 he took an active part in favor of Mr. Clay's candidacy and against Mr. Polk ; and by request delivered an oration at the laying of the corner-stone of the Capitol at Nashville, on the 4th of July, 1845. In the winter of that year he was elected to fill a vacancy in the Nashville district in Congress, Hon. I. H. Peyton (a brother of Bailie Peyton) having been elected and having died without taking his seat. He served two sessions in Congress, from December, 1845, to Blarch 4, 1847, and might have been re-elected had he not declined on account of a "distaste to a seat in the house." While in the house he delivered several able speeches, - one on the Oregon question; one on the tarilF of 184G, which his room-mate, Hon. Alexander H. Stephens, of Georgia, said was the best delivered on the Whig side of the question, or against the bill ; one on the river and harbor bill of 1846 (which, b}' the way, contained some doctrines he would hardly indorse now) ; and one on the Mexican war. He delivered also some other speeches of minor importance. With characteristic modesty, Mr. Ewing has said, "I do not think I made much character in Congress." His friends think this an underestimate of his services and of the credit generally awarded him.
In the mean time his reputation as a lawyer increased. He sat frequently as a special judge on the supreme bench, delivered an opinion in the great Winchester case, which has been a good deal talked about, and has been as much cited as any case in the courts of Tennessee, together with several other opinions in important cases. His partnership which rendered him independent of further practice ; and this, together with impaired health, induced him to carry out a purpose which he had long cherished, of somewhat extensive travel. He dissolved his business relations with his brother, and in April, 1851, being forty-one years of age, he left for a tour in Europe. He was absent about eighteen months, visiting England, Scotland, Ireland, France, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Italy, Egypt, Palestine, Western Asia, Constantinople, and Greece, making extensive notes of travel, and writing many long letters. Upon his return he was urgently solicited to write a book of travels, and had some idea of it, but has never put it into execution.
In 1852 he delivered, by request, at Nashville an oration on the death and services of Daniel Webster, then lately deceased. This oration compares favorably with Mr. Ewing's many able productions. He continued to practice law, taking fees only in important cases, till 185G, when he went to Rutherford County and lived with one of his daughters, then lately married. She removed to Nashville in 18G0 ; he returned with her, and lived in the city again one year, or until the winter of 1860-61, when he went and lived with his son in Rutherford County till the war broke out. He still, however, kept his citizenship in Davidson County, and kept up constant communication by letters and visits,
He spoke and voted for the Union in the election of February, 1861. Mr. Lincoln's proclamation in April raised a storm in Tennessee which carried almost every one into opposition to the North. Blr. Ewing's sympathies being with the Southern people,'and no neutrality being possible, he naturally went with his State, and took a position against coercion with John Bell, John Marshall, Andrew Ewing, Ncill S. Brown, and others. In the latter part of 1863, however, when he saw that Tennessee was irrecoverably lost to the South, he advised the people of the State who were staying at home to submit to the Federal government. The letter containing this advice was published, and subjected him to much obloquy, and being brought out again at the time of his candidacy for judge of the Supreme Court, probably defeated his election to that bench.
After the war Mr. Ewing formed a partnership and recommenced the practice of the law at Murfreesboro', practicing also in the courts at Nashville. He has appeared in a number of very important cases since that period ; notably he was one of the counsel for Judge Frazer when he was impeached before the Senate in 1868. He was also, in connection with Judge Cooper and William B. Reese, Esq., counsel for the State in the suit for the sale of all the delinquent railroads in Tennessee under the act of 1870, and went with Judge Cooper to Wa.shington to resist the appointment of a receiver for the Nashville and Chattanooga Railroad. They successfully accomplished the object of their mission.
Mr. Ewing is now seventy years of age; his health is good, and his mental faculties scarcely impaired. He has some important cases yet unfinished, but he has been aimins for some time to draw his lesal business to a close. He has been a voluminous newspaper writer and an omnivorous reader of books, is fond of metaphysical studies, and has been much sought after as a public lecturer.
Uon. W. F. Cooper
William Friorson Cooper was born in Williamson Co., Tenn , on the 11th of March, 1820. He was reared in Blaury County, and since early manhood has resided in Nashville, where his high reputation as a lawyer and jurist has been attained. By both parents Judge Cooper is descended from the Scotch-Irish race of the north of Ireland, which constitutes so large a portion of the population of the Southern States. Both families, the Coopers and the Friersons, settled in South Carolina, his paternal grandfather being a captain in Sumter's brigade during the - Revolutionary war, and both moved to Middle Tennessee early in the present century.
Being sent early to school and having a ready memory, he was pushed forward beyond his years, and was always in classes of which he was the youngest member, and so continued till he graduated at college when only eighteen years of age. The strain upon his mental faculties was, however, as he is in the habit of saying, moderated by the absence of emulation, which he was too young to feel in its full force, and by an uncontrollable appetite for general reading. At twelve years of age he spent a winter in New Orleans, where he learned the French language and acquired a taste for French literature. In the summer of 1834, Mr. Polk, then a member of Congress from Maury County, concluded to take his youngest brother and two of his nephews to Yale College to finish their education, and young Cooper was persuaded to join them. Under the charge of the future President of the United States, these young Tennesseeans paid their respects to the then President, the vener- . able chief from their own State, and bowed before the tomb of the first President. They entered the same class at Yale College, were joined by two other students from their State, making perhaps a larger number of Tennesseeans than were ever together there at one time before or since, and five of them graduated in the class of 1838.
Upon his return home one of the leading lawyers of Columbia, who needed a young man in whom he could have confidence to aid him in his heavy practice, offered to give him an equal partnership as soon as he could obtain a license. But the young graduate considered himself unfitted'for the contests of the forum, and declined the generous offer. He had previously concluded to study medicine, and diligently applied himself accordingly for the next two years, taking during the time a course of lectures at the University of Pennsylvania. This period was sufficient to satisfy him that while the study of the profession chosen was profoundly interesting, its practice was not suited to his tastes. Having ascertained this fact, he made up his mind to change his profession, and immediately commenced the study of law. The lawyer already mentioned renewed his offer, and in the same month that he came of ago the subject of our notice obtained a license to practice law, and went into partnership witli the Jate chancellor, Samuel D. Frierson.
The next three years were spent in active business and diligent study, which so increased the self-confidence of the young lawyer that he determined to seek a wider field. He spent the fall and part of the winter in New Orleans, being inclined to remove to that city. On his return he remained a few days at Nashville to argue some of his cases in the Supreme Court, and was so much pleased that he concluded to spend at least the ensuing summer in that city. Understanding his intentions, the Hon. A. 0. P. Nicholson, lute the chief justice of the Supreme Court of Tennessee, who had then only recently removed from Columbia to Nashville, kindly took him into partnership.
Nashville thus became the home, and, as it proved, the permanent home, of the young lawyer. The comparative leisure of the next few years gave him the opportunity of deepening the foundations of his legal studies. Ho commenced at the same time, as a mode of disciplining his faculties and increasing the accuracy of his knowledge of the State decisions, to report the opinions of the Supreme Court for one of the daily papers, preparing the headnotes, and, with occasional suggestions from the Hon. W. B. Turley. one of the judges of the court, condensing the opinions themselves when too long to be inserted tM extenso. This he continued to do for several years. At the December term, 1816, of the Supreme Court, his arguments were twice favorably noticed by the judge who delivered the opinion in the cases, one of these arguments receiving the unusual, if not unprecedented, honor of being expressly referred to and adopted by the court. (Brown vs. Vanlier,
7 Hum. 239.) All of the judges of that court treated them with the kindness which was their uniform characteristic towards young men, but he formed an intimate and cordial friendship with Judge Turley, who, to a lofty intellect and genial disposition, added a fondness for general literature, which was a powerful connecting-link between them.
In 1851, upon the death of Chancellor Cahal, the Nashville bar united in recommending Judge Cooper to fill the vacancy, but he declined to allow his name to be used when he understood that Judge Nicholson, who had returned to Columbia, was willing to accept the position. And afterwards, when Judge Nicholson resigned, he warmly supported Judge Frierson for the office. In the latter part of the same year he entered into partnership in the practice of the law with the Hon. Andrew Ewing, which continued for ten years, and until he was elected one of the judges of the Supreme Court. By the terms of the partnership, Judge Cooper took exclusive charge of the chancery business, and Mr. Ewing of the business of the law-courts, each following his cases to the Supreme Court. The equity business, into which Judge Cooper thus stepped, had been built up by the Hon. Edwin H. Ewing, then and now one of the first lawyers and public men of the State, who had concluded to spend a few years in Europe. It taxed his powers to the utmost, and increasing as it did with the growth of the city, it kept him incessantly employed during this period.
On the 8th of February, 1852, the Legislature of the State appointed Return J. Bleigs, Esq., and Judge Cooper to revise and digest the general statutes of the State. Under this appointment the present code of Tennessee was prepared, and passed into a law by the General Assembly of 1857-58. Both revisers separately went over and digested the whole body of the law, compared together their separate work, and united in the drafts submitted to the legislative committee, and which were adopted by the Legislature almost without modification. The analytic plan of the code is, however, the exclusive work of Judge Cooper.
In 1854, upon the change in the State Constitution giving the election of judicial officers to the people, Judge Cooper was a candidate for the office of attorney-general and reporter, but was defeated, his successful competitor being the Hon. John L. T. Sneed, then a deservedly popular member of the opposite political party, and subsequently one of the judges of the Supreme Court. In October, 1861, he became a candidate to till the vacancy on the bench of the Supreme Court, occasioned by the resignation of the Hon. Robert L. Caruthers, and was elected. The courts were, however, almost immediately thereafter closed by the late civil war, and upon the reorganization of the State government in 18G5, new judges were appointed by the executive. The enforced leisure occasioned by the war gave to Judge Cooper the opportunity of carrying out a long-cherished plan of a trip to Europe. Some of the fruits of this trip appeared in the Southern Law Review, published in St. Louis after the civil war, under the style of " English and French Law"' and " Modern Theories of Government."
war, Judge Cooper resumed the practice of his profession, confining himself to chancery cases. He was in partnersliip for a few years with the Hon. Robert L. Caruthers, his predecessor on the Supreme Bench, and upon his retirement with Iiis hrotlier, the Hon. Henry Cooper, kite member of Congress. In November, 1872, he was appointed by the Governor chancellor of the Nashville chancery district, and in August, 1874, he was elected by the people to the same place. His decisions while upon the bench have been published in three volumes of " Tennessee Chancery Reports," the last of which appeared in 1879.
In the year 1870, Judge Cooper superintended the republication of the early " Tennessee Reports." He prepared or re\wote the head-notes of the first eight volumes of these reports, with notes and references. These volumes, together with a new annotated edition of " Meigs' Reports," were republished in 1870. Upon the republication of the " Reports of the Supreme Court of Tennessee," begun in 1875, by G. I. Jones & Co., of St. Louis, Judge Cooper consented to edit the entire work. He has since completed the forty volumes, with annotations and references rewritten,- - a herculean labor, exhibiting in its results great care, industry, and legal acumen. Of twenty-nine of the volumes he has written the head-notes. He has also just finished re-editing an edition of " Daniels' Chancery Practice" fur Little, Brown & Co., law-publisliers, of Boston, bringing down the references and annotations to the present time. In tliis work he has examined nearly a thousand volumes of reports.
In August, 1878, Judge Cooper was elected one of the judges of the Supreme Court of the State for the constitutional term of eight years from Jan. 1, 1879. The duties of this high and responsible position he is now discharging with the modesty, ability, and address which have characterized him in all his official and professional relations, together with his other various and arduous labors in the departments of jurisprudence. His works will be a monument of which his native State will have reason to be proud.
It should be stated, also, that Judge Cooper, among his other labors, has succeeded in cstablisliing a bar association at Nashville, and in building up in connection therewith a law-library now numbering about three thousand volumes. As a suitable tribute the American Bar Association, which convened at Saratoga in the summer of 1879, elected him one of its vice-presidents.
Judge Cooper is now sixty years of age. The longevity of his ancestors and his temperate and orderly habits and cheerful disposition point to the conclusion that many years of useful labor yet remain to him. Those years will yield the greatest benefits to society if consumed in the labors of judicial science. It may with some degree of truth be said of a judge, as of a poet, that he is born, not made. We mean that the judicial temperament is innate in some men. Judge Cooper is one of those men. He loves the administration of justice. The possession of an ample competence places him beyond the reach of every ambition, except the ambition that has moved the greatest and best of judges, - the desire to do right and to leave behind an honorable name. The death of his former partner, the great and learned Chief Justice Nicholson, reduced the judges of the Supreme Court to five, the number provided for by tlie revised Constitution of 1870. At the next election Judge Cooper took his place upon the bench. Says a late writer, intimately acquainted with the character and services of Judge Cooper, " We shall not be contented to see his usefulness limited to that position," - the Supreme Court of Tennessee. " For twelve years the South has had no representative on the supreme bench of the United States. The exclusion from the national court of last resort of a section embracing one-third of the population of the Union - a section which has contributed to that bench such great names as Marshall, Taney, Catron, and Campbell ; a section, too, whose laws and institutions contain so much that differs from those of the rest of the Union - cannot be expected to last much longer. The South is fairly entitled to her representative on that bench, - unless she is unable to produce lawyers worthy of that high position. She can certainly produce one such man, and that is the subject of this sketch. When it shall become necessary to look to the South for a suitable appointee to that great court the general consent of the bar will, unless we are greatly mistaken, point to him."
Hon. John Trimble
John Trimble, counselor and attorney-at-law, son of James Trimble, was born in Roane Co., E. Tenn., on the 7th day of February, 1812. He was educated at Nashville at a classic school taught by Moses Stevens, and at the Nashville University, whose president was Philip Lindsley.
He preferred his professional pursuits, and he acquired a large practice in all the courts, criminal, law, and equity, in both State and United States courts.
He soon found himself in possession of as large an estate as he desired to have, and losing his taste for the profession he gradually retired from it. He acquired a taste for literary pursuits, and his ruling passion became love of knowledge and culture, mental and moral. He had acquired a large and select library of miscellaneous works, the best English and American authors, and he gave his time almost wholly to the acquisition of knowledge and culture.
In 1859 he was placed by the Whig party on their ticket as a candidate to the State Senate. He was elected without canvassing, and almost without opposition.
He was in the extra session of the Senate in January, 1861 ; also in the extra se.ssion of April, 1861, during which session was passed the " ordinance of secession," against which and all acts tending towards secession of the State he voted, being an '-unconditional" Union and National man. When the act of secession was passed he resigned his seat as a senator and retired to private life.
Ex. Qov. Neill S. Brown
During the entire civil war he was well known to be a National Union man, with firm convictions and faith in favor of the United States government.
His firm convictions were that the Rebellion ought not and could not succeed, and if by possibility it did it would be the greatest of calamities to the South and Southwest ; and that the State had been betrayed by its public men and forced out of the Union. Yet during the entire war his opinions were respected, and he was treated kindly and with respect by all, which he will ever hold in grateful remembrance.
In 1862, Justice Catron, of the United States Supreme Court and circuit judge for Tennessee, brought with him from Washington a commission for Mr, Trimble from Mr. Lincoln, appointing him United States district attorney. This position he held for two years and then resigned.
In ] 865 he was again elected to the State Senate, and as such sat in the " Reconstruction General Assembly," and aided in reconstructing the State government.
While in the Senate at this time he voted for the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution ; also in favor of unicersal suifrage and the re-enfranchisement of the people of the State.
In 1867 he was elected a member of Congress, and sat as a member of the Fortieth Congress in the House of Representatives. As such member he voted for the Fifteenth Amendment and for the restoration of the Southern States to the Union.
He liberated his servants he/ore the emancipation proclamation of President Lincoln, from a conviction that it was an emancipation of the whites from the greatest of evils, and his views were from a white man's standpoint looking at their enlightened interests and welfare.
Hon. Ncill S. Brown, ex-Governor of Tennessee, is a native of Giles County, in this State, where he was born on the 18th of April, 1810. His parents were descendants of Scotch Presbyterians, respectable and enterprising people, and were among the pioneers of Giles County when that region of country was a wilderness. In such a new country educational advantages were limited, so that the subject of this sketch received little more than a knowledge of the common English branches up to the age of seventeen, at which time he was thrown upon his own resources, and took to teaching school as a means' of promoting his ardent desire to obtain a collegiate enucation. In this laudable undertaking he was not disappointed, his energy and ambition being sufficient to carry him through the multiplied difficulties and hardships which beset his path until he had completed, unassisted, his college and his law course, and been admitted to the bar with as brilliant and encouraging prospects as most young lawyers.
In 1836 he served as a soldier in the Seminole war in Florida, and upon his return in 1837 was elected a member of the Legislature from Giles County. He soon acquired in politics not only influence, but considerable ambition, being a fluent and efi'ective speaker both in the hall of legislation and upon the stump. His oratory was of that earnest and persuasive kind, mixed with anecdote, keen wit, and satire, which renders a speaker popular and effective with _ juries and before the people. When the great political parties were formed he took an active and prominent part as a Whig, and after a very spirited contest was elected Governor in 18-17. He was an honorable and popular chief magistrate. In 1850 he was appointed United States minister to Russia, and was abroad in that capacity about three years. In 1855 he was chosen to represent Davidson County in the Legislature, and was elected Speaker of the House. From this time he held no political ofilce until 1870, when he was elected a member of the convention called to remodel the existing Constitution of the State.
Governor Brown, though opposed to the war of 1861-65, and an anti-secessionist, yielded to the issue when it was made up, and took sides with the South. Since the war he has neither held nor sought any public office, but has been an active and open advocate of the Union and of peace and reconciliation. His professional career as a lawyer began in 1835, and he has practiced ever since except when prevented by political engagements. Few men in the profession have attained a better standing at the bar, although it is undoubtedly true that public duties have somewhat divided his attention and detracted from the full exercise of his powers and abilities in the strict line of his profession. Still, he is one of the ablest lawyers of the county bar, and his services are retained in the most important cases both in the criminal and civil courts.
He took an active part in thepoli'.ical campaigns of 1836, 1840, 184-1, 1856, and 1860, and was an elector on the ticket of Judge White in 1836 and of Henry Clay in 1844. He has always been an ardent friend of common schools and of education in all its branches, and few men are more fully trusted and highly esteemed in the community in which he resides. We might write much moie in his praise, but such is his modesty that we forbear, lest we might inflict a wound where we mean simply to do
Gen. Thomas T. Smiley was born in Nashville, Oct. 8, 1813. He graduated at the University of Nashville in 1833 ; studied law with Hon. Ephraim H. Foster, and was admitted to the bar in 1836. He has ever since practiced in Nashville. Gen. Smiley was fourteen years clerk of the Circuit Court, from 1844 to 1859.
Judge Josephus C. Guild
Judge Josephus C. Guild was born in the county of Pittsylvania, Va., in 1803 ; came to Sumner County with his parents in 1806 ; studied law with Ephraim H. Foster at Nashville, and admitted to practice in 1822 ; began piactice in Sumner County, where he remained till the close of the civil war, and acquired a high reputation at the bar and as a public speaker and lecturer. He was a member of the General Assembly in 1833, 1835, and 1852, and of the Senate in 1837 and 1845; was lieutenant-colonel of the Second Tennessee Ilegimeut, under Gen. Armstrong, in the Florida campaign of 1836; Presidential elector for James K. Polk in 1844; elector at-large for Franklin
Pierce in 1852 ; and was elected chancellor for the seventh chancery division of the State in 18G0. The court was broken up by the war in 1861. In 1870, Mr. Guild was elected judge of the law-court at Nashville for a term of eight years, and held the office until the court was abolished by the Legislature in 1878.
Provenance
Text from History of Davidson County, Tennessee, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, published 1880, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.