Contra Costa County, California - The whole text, 1882 (part 7 of 22)
From History of Contra Costa County, California, Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description; Together with a Record of the Mexican Grants ... Also, Incidents of Pioneer Life; and Biographical Sketches of Early and Prominent Settlers and Representative Men .., published 1882. 15,948 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
2 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
15,948 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Contra Costa County, California, Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description; Together with a Record of the Mexican Grants ... Also, Incidents of Pioneer Life; and Biographical Sketches of Early and Prominent Settlers and Representative Men .., published 1882. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
E. P. Baldwin - Born in Alabama. Immigrated from thence in January, 1849. Arrived in California May 1, 1850. Represents San Joaquin district. Resides in Sonora, Tuolumne county.
A. P. Crittenden - Born in Lexington, Kentucky. Educated in Ohio, Alabama, New York and Pennsylvania. Settled in Texas in 1839. Came to California in 1849. Represents the County of Los Angeles.
Alfred Wheeler - Born in the City of New York the 30th day of April, 1820. Resided in New York City until the 21st of May, 1849, when he left for California. Citizen and resident of San Francisco, which district he represents.
Joseph C Morehead - Born in Kentucky. Immigrated to California in 1846. Resides at present in the county of Calaveras, San Joaquin district.
Thomas J. Henley - Born in Indiana. Family now resides in Charlestown, in that State. Immigrated to California in 1849, through the South Pass. Residence at Sacramento.
Elisha W. McKinstry - Born in Detroit, Michigan. Immigrated to California in March, ] 849. Residence in Sacramento district, city of Sutter.
George B. Tingley - Born August 15, 1815, Clermont county, Ohio. Immigrated to Rushville, Indiana, November, 4, 1834. Started to California April 4, 1849. Reached there October 16th. Was elected to the Assembly, November 13th, from Sacramento district, and is now in Pueblo de San Jose".
At the start considerable dissatisfaction was felt in respect to the accommodation offered by the State House, and only four days after its first occupation, George B. Tingley, a member from Sacramento, introduced a bill to remove the Legislature to Monterey. It only passed its first reading and was then consigned to the purgatory of further action.
Governor Burnett Assumes Office. - Governor Riley resigned his gubernatorial functions to Governor Peter H. Burnett on the 20th of December, 1849 ; on the same date Secretary Halleck was relieved of his duties, and at noon of the day following the new Governor delivered his first message. On this day also Colonel J. C. Fremont received a majority of six votes, and Dr. William M. Gwin a majority of two, for the United States Senate.
In the year 1850 General-Senator Mariano Guadalupe Vallejo became convinced that the capital of California should be established at a place which he desired to name Eureka, but which his colleagues in the Legislature, out of compliment to himself, suggested should be named Vallejo. To this end the General addressed a memorial to the Senate, dated April 3, 1850, wherein he graphically pointed out the advantages possessed by the proposed site over other places which claimed the honor. In this remarkable document, remarkable alike for its generosity of purpose as for its marvelous foresight, he proposed to grant twenty acres to the State, free of cost, for a State Capitol and grounds, and one hundred and thirty -six acres more for other State buildings, to be apportioned in the following manner : Ten acres for the Governor's house and grounds ; five acres for the offices of Treasurer, Comptroller, Secretary of State. Surveyor-General, and Attorney-General, should the Commissioners determine that their offices should not be in the Capitol building ; one acre to State Library and Translator's office, should it be determined to sepai-ate them from the State-house building ; twenty acres for an Orphan Asylum ; ten acres for a Male Charity Hospital ; ten acres for a Female Charity Hospital ; four acres for an Asylum for the Blind ; four acres for a Deaf and Dumb Asylum ; eight acres for four common schools ; twenty acres for a State University ; four acres for a State Botanical Garden ; and twenty acres for a State Penitentiary.
But with a munificence casting this already long list of grants into the shade, he further proposed to donate and pay over to the State, within two years after the acceptance of these propositions the gigantic sum of §370,000, to be apportioned in the following manner : For the building of a State Capitol, $125,000 ; for furnishing the same, $10,000 ; for building of the Governor's house, $10,000 ; for furnishing the same, $5,000 ; for the building of State Library and Translator's Office, $5,000 ; for a State Library, $5,000; for the building of the offices of the Secretary of State, Comptroller, Attorney-General, Surveyor-General, and Treasurer, should the Commissioners deem it proper to separate them from the State-house, $20,000 ; for the building of an Orphan Asylum, $20,000 ; for the building of a Female Charity Hospital, $20,000 ; for the building of a Male Charity Hospital, $20,000; for the building of an Asylum for the Blind, $20,000; for the building of a Deaf and Dumb Asylum, $20,000 ; for the building of a State University, $20,000 ; for University Library, $5,000 ; for scientific apparatus therefor, $5,000 ; for chemical laboratory therefor, $3,000 ; for a mineral cabinet therefor, $3,000 ; for the building of four common school edifices, $10,000 ; for purchasing books for same, $1,000 ; for the building of a Lunatic Asylum, $20,000 ; for a State Penitentiary, $20,000 ; for a State Botanical Collection, $3,000.
In his memorial the General states with much perspicacity his reasons for claiming the proud position for the place suggested as the proper site for the State Capital. Mark the singleness of purpose with which he bases these claims :
" Your memorialist, with this simple proposition (namely, that in the event of the Government declining to accept his terms, it should be put to the popular vote at the general election held in November of that year, 1850), might stop here, did he not believe that his duty as a citizen of California required him to say thus much in addition - that he believes the location indicated is the most suitable for a permanent seat of government for the great State of California, for the following reasons : That it is the true center of the State, the true center of commerce, the true center of population, and the true center of travel ; that while the Bay of San Francisco is acknowledged to be the first on the earth, in point of extent and navigable capacities, already, throughout the length and breadth of the wide world, it is acknowledged to be the very center between Asiatic and European commerce. The largest ship that sails upon the broad sea can, within three hours, anchor at the wharves of the place which your memorialist proposes as your permanent seat of government. From this point, by steam navigation, there is a greater aggregate of mineral wealth within eight hours' steaming', than exists in the Union ; besides, from this point the great north and south rivers - San Joaquin and Sacramento - cut the State longitudinally through the center, fringing the immense gold deposits on the one hand, and untold mercury and other mineral resources on the other ; from this point steam navigation extends along the Pacific Coast south to Sa7i Diego, and north to the Oregon line, affording the quickest possible facilities for our sea-coast population to reach the State Capital in the fewest number of hours. This age, as it has been truly remarked, has merged distance into time. In the operations of commerce and the intercourse of mankind, to measure miles by the rod is a piece of vandalism of a by-gone age ; and that point which can be approached from all parts of the
" Your memorialist most respectfully submits to your honorable body whether there is not a ground of even still higher nationality ? It is this : that at present, throughout the wide extent of our sister Atlantic States, but one sentiment seems to possess the entire people, and that is, to build, in the shortest possible time, a railroad from the Mississippi to the Bay of San Francisco, where its western terminus may meet a three weeks' steamer from China. Indeed, such is the overwhelming sentiment of the American people upon this subject, that there is but little doubt to apprehend its early completion. Shall it be said, then, while the world is coveting our possession of what all acknowledge to be the half-way house of the earth's commerce - the great Bay of San Francisco - that the people of the rich possessions are so unmindful of its value as not to ornament her magnificent shores with a Capital worthy of a great State ?"
Upon receipt of General Vallejo's memorial by the Senate, a committee, composed of members who possessed a local knowledge of the country comprised in the above-quoted document, both geographical and topographical, was directed to report, for the information of the President, upon the advantages claimed for the location of the Capital at the spot suggested, in preference to others. The report, in which the following words occur, was presented to the Senate on April 2, 1850 : " Your committee cannot dwell with too much warmth upon the magnificent propositions contained in the memorial of General Vallejo. They breathe throughout the spirit of an enlarged mind, and a sincere public benefactor, for which he deserves the thanks of his countrymen and the admiration of the world. Such a proposition looks more like the legacy of a mighty Emperor to his people than the free donation of a private planter to a great State, yet poor in public finance, but soon to be among the first of the earth."
The report, which was presented by Senator D. C. Broderick, of San Francisco, goes on to point out the necessities which should govern the choice of a site for California's Capital ; recapitulates the advantages pointed out in the memorial ; and, finally, recommends the acceptance of General Vallejo's offer. This acceptance did not pass the Senate without some opposition and considerable delay ; however, on Tuesday, February 4, 1851, a message was received from Governor Burnett, by his private secretary, Mr. Ohr, informing the Senate that he did this day sign an Act originating in the Senate, entitled " An Act to provide for the permanent location of the seat of Government." In the meantime General Vallejo's bond had been accepted ; his solvency was approved by a committee appointed by the Senate to inquire into that circumstance; the report of the commissioners sent to mark and lay out the tracts of land proposed to be donated was adopted ; and, on May 1, 1S51, the last session of the Legislature in San Jose" was completed ; but the archives were not moved to the new seat of government at Vallejo at that time, the want of which was the cause of much dissatisfaction among the members.
The Legislature first met at Vallejo on January 5, 1S52, but there was wanting that attraction of society which would appear to be necessary to the seat of every central government. With these Sacramento abounded, from her proximity to the mines. The Assembly, therefore, with a unanimity bordering on the marvelous, passed a bill to remove the session to that city, ball tickets and theater tickets being tendered to the members in reckless profusion. The bill was transferred to the Senate, and bitterly fought by the Hons. Paul K. Hubbs and Phil. A. Roach. The removal was rejected by one vote. This was on a Saturday, but never was the proverb of " we know not what the morrow may bring' forth " more fully brought to bear on any consideration. Senator Anderson, it is said, passed a sleepless night through the presence of unpleasant insects in his couch ; on the Monday morning he moved a reconsideration of the bill. The alarm was sounded on every hand, and at 2 P. M. on January 12, 1852, the Government and Legislature were finding its way to Sacramento by way of the Carquinez Straits. On March 7, 1852, a devastating flood overwhelmed Sacramento, and where they had before feared contamination, they now feared drowning. The Legislature adjourned at Sacramento May 4, 1852, the next session to be held at Vallejo. On January 3, 1853, the peripatetic government met again at Vallejo, whither had been moved in May the archives and State offices. Once more the spirit of jealousy was rampant. Sacramento could not with any grace ask for its removal thither again, but she, working with Benicia, the Capital was once more on wheels, and literally carted off to the latter town for the remaining portion of the session, where it i-emained until a bill was passed to fix the capital of the State at Sacramento, and thereafter clinched by lai'ge appropriations for building the present magnificent capitol there.
The capital being removed from San Jose-, the Town Council sold the State-house for thirty-eight thousand dollars, which sum it was intended should be applied to the liquidation of the note mentioned above. The money, it would appear, was not so applied, therefore legal proceedings were instituted by the gentlemen holding the premises in trust for the purchasers, or their representatives, against the city, to obtain the foreclosure of amortgage executed to them by the civic authorities in 1850 to secure the purchase of the property. A decree of foreclosure was obtained, the pueblo lands brought to the hammer, and bought in by the trustees of the plaintiffs, who had organized themselves into a land company, and claimed title
The question of the legality of the removal was brought up in 1854 bebefore the Supreme Court, when a majority of the Justices, Heydenfeldt and Wells, held that according to law San Jose" was the capital of the State, who thereupon made the following order, March 27th :
" It is ordered that the Sheriff of Santa Clara county procure in the town of San Josd, and properly arrange and furnish a Court-room, clerk's office, and consultation room, for the use of the Court. It is further ordered that the clerk of this Court forthwith remove the records of the Court to the town of San Jose". It is further ordered that the Court will meet to deliver opinions at San Jose on the first Monday in April, and on that day will appoint some future day of the term for the argument of cases.
A writ of mandamus on the strength of the above was issued from the Third District Court against all the State officers, commanding that they should remove their offices to San Jose, or show cause why they should not do so. The argument was heard and the theory maintained that San Jose" was the proper capital of the State, whereupon an appeal was carried to the Supreme Court. In the interim Justice Wells had died, his place being filled by Justice Bryant. On the appeal the Supreme Court decided that San Jose" was not the State capital, from which decision Justice Heydenfeldt dissented.
Records of Court of Sessions, and Board of Supervisors. - The first record we have been able to find of the transactions of the Court of Sessions was the partitioning of the county on April 17, 1850, into the three townships of New York, Martinez and San Antonio. On April 20th an election was ordered to be held for two Justices of the Peace and one Constable for each township, the inspectors appointed being J. Woodbury at the precinct of New York ; Wesley Bradley at Martinez ; and J. S. Ridgely at San Antonio, those elected being desired to attend at the office of the County Clerk on the Monday after the election, to enter into bonds and take oath of office. On April 30th, an election was ordered to be held for the office of County Judge of Solano county, the position being rendered vacant by the failure of James Craig to qualify for the office, a move undertaken by Judge F. M. Warmcastle of Contra Costa, in accordance with law. May 13th the Court of Sessions convened by order of the County Judge at the Court-house in Martinez, when there were present F. M. Warmcastle, Judge ; Absolom Peak and Edward G. Guest, Associate Justices ; Thomas A. Brown, County Clerk ; and Nathaniel Jones, Sheriff. It was then ordered that there be assessed and collected for ordinary county expenditure of the real and personal property taxable by law the amount of twenty-five cents on each one hundred dollars ; and that in the same manner a like sum should be levied for the purpose of constructing public buildings for the use of the county, the County Clerk being directed to procure for present use a suitable building wherein to locate the Court-house and Clerk's office, to fit up the same, supply it with the necessary blank books and stationery, and otherwise render it fit for official occupation. A State Poll Tax of two dollars and fifty cents was also made collectable from those ivhom the law required to pay it. On the 3d of June the County Clerk was ordered to receive sealed proposals for the erection of a jail ; while, on July 20th, certain accounts for labor performed on the temporary county buildings were allowed. A sum not to exceed fifty dollars was also granted to procure an official seal. August 19th the following licenses were made levyable : - To vend goods, wares and merchandise, with a capital of
While on this date application was made by and license granted to Oliver C. Coffin to establish a ferry between the towns of Martinez and Benicia on his filing a bond in the amount of two thousand dollars. The fares to be charged were limited by the Court to : - .
August 26th the following Inspectors were selected for the election ordered for October 7th, viz : Antonio Peralta for San Antonio township ; John Marsh for New York township, and Wesley Bradley and Joseph Rothenhostler for Martinez township, the latter at the precinct established at the house of Jose" Maria Amador.
1851. - Under date January 25th of this year a petition from the citizens of Martinez that the town should be incorporated was granted, the limits being a mile square, and an election was ordered to be held for Town Trustees on February 8th, B. R. Holliday, Charles Pervine and J. C. Burrows being appointed Judges. This matter will be found more fully entered into, however, in the history of that township and town. On August 4th we find the Court granting a license to H. W. Carpentier and A. Moon to run a ferry " from Contra Costa, in the township of San Antonio, to the city of San Francisco," and fixing the tariff as follows :
It was ordered by the Court, September 6th, that the Surveyor-General of the State be requested, within that month, to mark out so much of the boundary line dividing the counties of Contra Costa and San Joaquin, so as to define said boundary between the San Joaquin river and the high hills in the direction of the head waters of the Alameda creek, in the Coast Range of mountains. On December 1st the Court appointed Jose Martinez, Robert Livermore, J. S. Bauer and Robert Birnie " Judges of the Plains," ' (Juez de Campo). The duties of these officials were to arbitrate between owners in all disputes that might arise as to cattle-property, and ovei-haul and inspect all brands of stock being driven from or through the county. Their emoluments consisted in " perquisites," of which there were occasionally a great many.
1852. - The first item of importance which the records of this year divulge is the order of the Court of Sessions, on May 11th, that one-half of the revenue collected for county purposes, which was fixed for the year at fifty cents on the one hundred dollars, should be set apart as a Public Building Fund, while, on the same day, a call for proposals to build a Court-house, in Court-house Square, Martinez, was made, but was afterwards rescinded on August 10th, by the Board of Supervisors.
Under the provisions of the Act of the Legislature, passed May 3, 1852, a Board of Supervisors was created for Contra Costa county, and in pursuance thereof an election was held June 14, 1852, when the following five gentlemen were elected, viz : William Patten, Samuel H. Robinson, Victor Castro, Robert Farrelly and T. J. Keefer, the first-named being chosen Chairman of the Board by his associates. On July oth, committees were duly appointed and other matters arranged for the full organization of the Board of Supervisors, who at once assumed the reins of civil government. Among their earliest orders was the laying out of a road between Oakland and San Pablo. On July 23d, Supervisor Robinson made his report on assessments within the county. As a matter of curiosity we now produce some of these, for the purpose of showing the amount of land then held by some individuals and assessed at over five thousand dollars :
The above are, by no manner of means, the only ones assessed in what was then Contra Costa county, which extended from the San Joaquin to the boundary of Santa Clara. A glance at the figures will give the reader, however, an idea of what vast tracts of land were held by the native Californians in the early years of American occupation. No county, it would appear, can revel in a freedom from debt ; even the newly defined Contra Costa, with an existence of but a little over two years, had, on July 1, 1852, a liability of one thousand three hundred and thirty-six dollars, thirtytwo cents. Under date August 12th, we find the following minute : " The Board having had the matter of the supplemental assessment made and returned by the County Assessor under consideration, and being sufficiently advised thereon do find that there are forty-four thousand two hundred and eighty acres of land believed to be covered by title and lying unclaimed between the land claimed by the heirs of Francisco Castro, the Peraltas, and some claimed by the heirs of Estudillo, and that the same is worth five dollars per acre, amounting to two hundred and twenty-one thousand, four hundred dollars, do order that the same be assessed to persons unknown." The last note in the records for this year, is that of December 28th, when the salary of the District Attorney was fixed at two thousand dollars per annum.
1853. - While the Legislature was sitting in Benicia in this year a petition was presented by H. C. Smith from the citizens of Santa Clara and Contra Costa counties, praying that a new county be formed out of portions of each, to be called Alameda. Then, as now, the county seats were San Jose and Martinez, the dividing line between Santa Clara and Contra Costa being the Alameda creek. The inhabitants living near the present city of Oakland felt the distance from Martinez, some thirty miles, to be too great for the comfortable transaction of business, while they were separated from it by a chain of mountains, which increased the difficulty of travel ; therefore the western and southern half of Contra Costa, with Washington township in Santa Clara, was formed into one county and named Alameda, by which Contra Costa lost most of its coast line - yet still retaining its misnomer of " opposite coast " - and several centers of trade, now growing up on the opposite shore of San Francisco Bay. On June 8th the Court of Sessions, who were once more in power, appointed J. F. Williams and Thos. A. Brown, the District Attorney and County Clerk, on the part of Contra Costa county, to meet the delegates from Alameda county, to settle questions on the partition mentioned above, a duty that was for the timebeing successfully performed ; while, on September 13th, the salary of the District Attorney was reduced to one thousand dollars per year.
1854- - In accordance with plans submitted by L. R. Townsend, architect, the proposal of H. J. Childers and C. Chipman to build a Court-house for twenty-seven thousand dollars was accepted, the site chosen being on the hill fronting the bay - Lot Number Four, Block Two, in the town of Martinez.
November 10th the Court of Sessions directed that the ferry-boat plying between Martinez and Benicia should make half -hourly trips in the morning between 8 and 11:30 A. M., and in the afternoon between 1 and 5:30 p. M. The last item in this year is one on which the true chronicler refuses to dwell ; enough may be gleaned from the bare statement that on December 4, 1854, the records state that John M. Jones, County Assessor, was removed on account of malfeasance in office, after a protracted trial before the Court of
1855. - By the provisions of an Act to create a Board of Supervisors for the counties of the State of California and to define their duties, passed March 20, 1855, the County Clerk, County Assessor and County Surveyor of Contra Costa divided the county into three districts, on April 30, 1855, while, in pursuance of said Act, Thomas A. Brown, County Clerk, called an election to be held throughout the county for the purpose of choosing one Supervisor for each district. The election was held April 12, 1855, and resulted in John H. Livingston being elected Supervisor of District Number One, composed of Townships Numbers One and Five ; L. E. Morgan, Supervisor of District Number Two, composed of Township Number Three ; and W. R. Bishop, Supervisor of District Number Three, composed of Townships Numbers Two, Four and Six. It has been mentioned that our county had not escaped the incubus of debt ; indeed, as the years flew by these were considerably augmented, notably by a judgment in the Gilman case, a history of which will be found hereafter, until it became necessary to raise money by the issue of county bonds. In this regard, on May 26th, Supervisor Morgan was empowered by the Board to raise a loan of such sum of money as should be sufficient to pay the interest due on such bonds in the following July, he being at the same time authorized to contract with such persons in San Francisco as would establish an agency for the payment of the coupons in the city of New York. The Board further ordered that the money thus raised should be repaid out of the first funds coming into the County Treasury from the Interest Fund of thirty cents on each one hundred dollars of taxable property, or the General Fund. On June 1st Mr. Morgan made his report, which was duly accepted, as was also an agreement entered into with Palmer, Cook & Co., of San Francisco, whereby they covenanted, on the receipt of the sum of two thousand dollars, to pay the interest on the funded debt of Contra Costa county, due and payable in the city of New York on July 1, 1855, they receiving remuneration therefor at the rate of two per cent, upon the amount of money paid by them. June 27th the following were fixed as the rates of fees to be allowed to attorne}Ts appointed by the Court to defend criminals, or persons accused of crime :
1856. - It is not until the month of November in this year that we have been able to find aughfc of common interest in the records. The total vote of the county at the general election was found to be nine hundred and forty-six. On the 17th of November it is minuted that owing to the destruction of the Union Hotel, in Martinez, of which the County Ti-easurer was proprietor, the records of his office, that he kept there, were destroyed, regarding which we find the following : " And now comes Robert E. Borden, County Treasurer, and reports to this Board, and on his affidavit states, that the books, papers and monies of the office have been destroyed by fire, and it appearing that about one thousand dollars were saved, and about one thousand nine hundred dollars were lost, belomnno- to the different funds as set forth in his statement, and from said statement it appears that the said loss was, so far as the Treasurer was concerned, unavoidable. This Board are of opinion, however, that he, the Treasurer, cannot be relieved to the extent prayed for, except by Legislative action. The Board (Thomas A. Brown being one of the sureties on said Treasurer's bond refusing to act in the matter) do recommend and petition that the Legislature do grant to the said Robert E. Borden, County Treasurer, aforesaid, the relief prayed for."
1857. - Save the elections and appointments which will be found embodied in the elaborate table at the end of this chapter, nothing of much moment would appear to have occurred during this year.
1859. - Placing our subject under a system of sub-heads, and thus condensing one subject, deprives us of having anything to say here about the transactions of the Board of Supervisors for this year.
1860. - The machinery of the county having been now in full operation for a decade of years let us for a moment glance at the state of her finances at the beginning of the year 1860. The County Treasurer in his report to the Board of Supervisors on the 6th February of that year presented the accompanying Table, which will, more clearly than words, elucidate the financial condition of Contra Costa : -
On August 6, 1860, it was ordered by the Board of Supervisors that a special tax of one per cent, be added to the tax already levied for the current year, to be set aside as a Special Fund for the satisfaction of the judgment heretofore obtained in re Gilman versus Contra Costa county, in accordance with the award of a Bill passed by the Legislature, approved March 14, 1860, entitled "An Act for the payment of a judgment in favor of T. C. Gilman against the County of Contra Costa." At the general election, held November 6th, a majority of five hundred and ninety-six voted against the holding of a Constitutional Convention ; while a majority of three hundred and one voters desired that the State Debt should be repudiated, viz: -
1861. - On the 5th February of this year it is recorded that Judge Thomas A. Brown released the county from the payment to him of six thousand dollars, being back salary for four years' services as County Judge, ending on the first Monday of December, 1861.
It should be mentioned that the salary provided by law for the office of County Judge of Contra Costa county was two thousand five hundred dollars per annum, but Judge Brown declared his intention to reduce it to one thousand dollars a year, which sum he drew, and at the end of the term freed the county from the responsibility of paying him the accrued six thousand dollars - an unusual piece of magnanimity on the part of a public official, and one which could only have emanated from the mind of a high-souled public servant.
Consequent on the death of the County Treasurer, the following resolutions were passed by the Board of Supervisors at their session on March 2, 1861 : -
" Resolved, That it is with deep regret that we have been called to act as a Board in the appointment of a person to succeed our much-lamented friend Hiram Fogg, late Treasurer of this county, and that we hereby express our united and unqualified approval of his conduct as an officer in the discharge of his duties, and as a man in the varied relations of life, and we hereby express our earnest sympathy with his bereaved family.
In the proceedings of the Board on November 5th, we find the following minute : " The petition of ' Cranky Jim ' for repair of the bridge in the town of Martinez, ordered to be rejected - his remedy is to apply to the Road Overseer of road district."
1862. - In regard to the indebtedness of Alameda county to Contra Costa, B. C. Whitman and Charles Fish were appointed by the Legislative Commissioners under the provisions of an Act passed April 26, 1862, to ascertain and award the amount of indebtedness, if any be found equitably due. This report was presented in the form of a communication addressed jointly to the Supervisoral Boards of the two counties interested, and contains the following decision : " They (the Commissioners) find that the county of Contra Costa has paid on account of obligations existing at the time of the organization of the county of Alameda the sum of thirty-six thousand seven hundred and fifty-five dollars, fifteen cents. That the said county of Alameda was justly and equitably bound for a portion thereof, amounting to fifteen thousand five hundred and eighteen dollars, seventyeight cents. That under and by virtue of an award heretofore made on June 4, 1858, said county of Alameda has paid to the county of Contra Costa the sum of three thousand nine hundred and forty-five dollars, sixtysix cents, leaving unpaid a balance of eleven thousand five hundred and seventy-four dollars, twelve cents, equitably due from the county of Alameda to the county of Contra Costa, arising out of obligations existing against the county of Contra Costa at the time of the organization of the said county of Alameda. Therefore we do hereby award said sum of eleven thousand five hundred and seventy -four dollars, twelve cents, as equitably due under and by virtue of the provisions of the Act aforesaid from the county of Alameda to the county of Contra Costa, and by virtue of the powers conferred upon us we declare and certify the same to your Honorable Bodies as by said Act directed and charged."
1864-. - In accordance with a communication from the State Comptroller dated April 11, 1864, the taxes to be levied and collected for State purposes for the year ending March 1, 1865, were fixed as hereunder given. They
March 19th the apportionment of grand and trial jurors for the different townships in the county, in accordance with the Act of the Legislature of April 27, 1863, was ordered as follows : Township Number One, one hundred and twenty-six ; Township Number Two, one hundred and fortythi-ee ; Township Number Three, one hundred and eighty-one.
1865. - On January 5, 1865, we find that G. F. Sharp had procured an execution against the county for the sum of three hundred and ten thousand dollars and upwards, subject to a credit of thirty thousand dollars and upwards, purporting to be issued upon a judgment rendered in his favor in or about July, 1860, but as by an Act of the Legislature a special tax was raised to satisfy the judgment, the Board of Supervisors directed the District Attorney to take immediate legal steps to procure the satisfaction of record of said judgment, and the quashing of said writ of execution, and the release of and all levies made thereunder, and take such legal steps as may be proper to fully and amply protect the interests of the county. On February 8th the board entirely rejected this claim, which was the outcome of the vexatious Oilman case.
1866 - 1867. - Except the necessary elections and changes in the officials of the county, there is nothing of interest to record in these years.
1868. - On May 6, 1868, it was ordered by the Board of Supervisors that an election be held in Contra Costa county on June 20, 1868, for the purpose of submitting a proposition for the county to make a donation to the Martinez and Danville Railroad Company to aid in the construction of a railroad from Martinez to Danville, in the county of Contra Costa, in pursuance of an Act of the Legislature, entitled " An Act to authorize the county of Contra Costa to donate bonds to the Martinez and Danville
On October 23d extensive repairs were ordered to the Court-house, consequent on the damage caused by the great earthquake of the 21st; indeed, so ruinous was the destruction that the District Court was relegated to the carpenter's shop of E. W. Hiller, the proper room being considered insecure. Authorization to build a calaboose at Antioch was granted to R. B. Hard, a sum of money being set apart for that purpose - and thus ends the record for 1868.
1869 - 1870. - For these two years the affairs of the county proceeded without let or hindrance. Smooth were the sessions of the Supervisoral Board, as they paid accounts and kept the official machinery revolving.
1871. - A Special School Tax was ordered, on August 16th, to be levied upon the property in each school district in the county in which a deficiency was shown by the written statement of the County Superintendent, pursuant to an Act of the Legislature, entitled " An Act to amend an Act to provide a system of Common Schools - Approved April 4, 1871," viz :
1872. - It would appear that some change was contemplated in the boundary line between Alameda and Contra Costa counties by some individuals unconnected with the latter, for we learn that the Board of Super- visors, on January 27, 1872, protested against any such alteration, preferring that the dividing line should remain as laid down in the Act of March 25, 1853. On February 6th the town of Antioch was incorporated, the limits being fixed at one mile in width and about three in length. (For a plat of the town see page ninety-two, volume five, Records Board of Supervisors.)
1873. - On May 7, 1873, directions were given for the consolidation of the offices of County Recorder and Auditor, and that of Sheriff and Tax- Collector.
1874.. - At an election held May 2, 1874, in Township Number Four, the electors voted against the issuing of liquor licenses by a majority of sixtythree votes, while, on June 6th, elections for a like purpose were held in Townships Numbers One, Two, Three and Five, with the following result : -
1875. - It was decided in this year to build offices for the County Clerk and Recorder apart from the Court-house building. On September 6th the construction was placed in the hands of P. H. Donovan and a committee appointed to select a site for the edifice, the choice falling on Lot Number Five, Block Two, in the town of Martinez.
1876. - On February 9, 1876, measures were taken for the destruction of coyotes, and a bounty offered by the Board of Supervisors on production of the scalp and ears ; and on May 22d the Grangers' Warehousing and Business Association received permission to construct a wharf on the foreshores at Martinez.
1877. - The offices of County Recorder and Auditor were once more consolidated, by the Supervisors on May 7, 1877 ; while, on the following day directions were issued for co-operation with the Board of Supervisors of Alameda county, in a resurvey of the boundary line between that and Contra Costa. August 6th, the following resolutions, consequent on the death of Supervisor Tormey, were offered by Supervisor Loucks and adopted by the Board : -
"Whereas, Since the last previous meeting of this Board the call of death has removed from among us our late associate, Supervisor John Tormey, for a long term of years a member of this Board and one of our most active and enterprising citizens.
" Resolved, That in the death of John Tormey, Esq., this Board has lost an esteemed and valued member, the county one of its most prominent and active citizens, and his family a devoted father and husband.
" Resolved, That these resolutions be spread upon the minutes of the Board and a copy forwarded to the widow and children of the deceased, with a tender of the sincere sympathy of his late official associates in the affliction of their bereavement."
1878. - The general reader will doubtless agree with us that the political phases of the county were without especial interest, except in a general way, until the question of a new organic law for the State began to be agitated. That the old Constitution was defective in many respects was granted by all, and some favored a new instrument, while others thought that the old one could be so amended as to cover the ground and save much expense. That they were right on the last proposition is doubtless true, but as to whether or not the former was feasible was a moot-point. The question was submitted to the people from time to time, but no definite result was obtained until the general election of 1877, at which time a large majority was given in favor of calling a Convention for the purpose of framing a new instrument.
It should be mentioned here that the citizens of Contra Costa county did not accord with the feelings of the majority of the State, as the following vote will explain :
During the next session of the Legislature a bill was framed and passed providing for the election of delegates to this Convention, which was approved March 30, 1878. Thirty-two delegates were to be elected from the State at large, not more than eight of whom should reside in any one
Congressional District. In accordance with a proclamation issued by the Governor an election for the purpose of choosing delegates was held June 19, 1878, when the total vote in Contra Costa county was one thousand one hundred and thirty-nine, Thomas H. Estey receiving seven hundred and sixty votes as Joint Delegate for Marin and Contra Costa counties, and Hiram Mills four hundred and two votes as the Delegate from Contra Costa alone. The delegates convened at Sacramento City September 28, 1878, and continued in session one hundred and seventy-five days. When their labors had been completed, the new instrument was submitted to the people for their rejection or approval, and the day set for the vote was May 7, 1879. There was a very strong, and in many instances a bitter fight made against its passage, while its advocates were as energetic in their efforts to secure its adoption. The vote in Contra Costa county was :
The last item to be recorded in this year is the establishment of a calaboose at Walnut Creek and another at Nortonville, money having been granted by the Board of Supervisors for that purpose.
1879. - May 5th we find the Board directing the construction of a calaboose at Concord ; while, at the general election held September 7th the opinions of the citizens of Contra Costa are thus decidedly expressed in the matter of Chinese immigration '
1880. - Early in this year several franchises were granted for the erection of wharves at Port Costa, a little hamlet fast springing into notoriety as a shipping point, and made famous as the spot where the mammoth steamer Solano lands the western bound trains from the Atlantic. May 3d a Board of Education, consisting of A. Thurber of Pacheco, Alfred Dixon of San Pablo, Albert J. Young of Danville, and A. M. Phalin of Nortonville, were appointed by the Supervisors ; and on the following clay, on motion of Supervisor P. Tormey, it was ordered that the bodies of all deceased persons hereafter interred in cemeteries in Contra Costa county should be buried in graves dug at least five feet in depth. May 5th a calaboose was granted for the town of Martinez. On the 19th an official map, nine by five feet in dimensions, was directed to be made by Surveyor McMahon ; while, according to a minute of the same date, we find that the Northern Railroad Company had over twenty-three, and the San Pablo and Tulare Railroad Company more than thirty -four miles in length in the county, the former being valued at thirteen thousand and sixty, and the latter at eleven thousand two hundred dollars per mile. In this year, too, the County Infirmary was built and the Poor Farm laid out. On July 7th an official seal for the Board was ordered, the design being " a sheaf of grain, horn of plenty, and grapes and melons, surrounded by the words ' Board of Supervisors of Contra Costa County, California.' " The public debt of the county, amounting to ninetyfour thousand one hundred dollars, was funded in this year, bonds bearing interest at six per cent, per annum, and payable semi-annually, being directed to be issued on August 4th. On the same date the salaries of the county officers were fixed, and all fees and perquisites received directed to be paid into the Treasury. On October 4th another debt of thirty-eight thousand dollars was directed to be funded, and bonds bearing interest at the rate of six per cent, per annum ordered to be issued.
1881. - On February 7, 1881, Supervisor Renwick, of District No. 2, protested against Supervisor elect Sherburne occcupying his seat at the Board, on the plea that the Legislature of the State made no provision for the election of county officers, or members of the Board of Supervisors for the years 1880-1881. The Board on the same date authorized the erection of a calaboose at San Pablo ; and on the 3d August granted permission to the Contra Costa Telephone Company to erect posts and wire along the public highways leading from Martinez to Danville and the Colton farm, passing through Pacheco and Walnut Creek. The last item to be recorded is the appointment by the Supervisors on November 23d, of Miss C. K. Wittenmyer to a place on the Board of Education of Contra Costa county in the place of Alfred Dixon resigned.
The earn of Oilman versus Contra Costa County. - In the foregoing pages much has been said regarding this case, but as the entire circumstances connected with it may not be generally remembered we now place these before the reader, as given in a Statement of Facts, drawn up for the State Legislature by Judge Thomas A. Brown, and most courteously placed by that gentleman at our disposal : -
On October 28, 1852, the Board of Supervisors of Conti'a Costa county made a contract with Oilman to build a bridge across the San Antonio creek, in Oakland, the contract price being seven thousand four hundred dollars. It was stipulated in the contract that should the Treasurer refuse to pay any warrant or order drawn in favor of Gilman, the Treasurer having in his hands any money belonging to said county, they agreed to pay Gilman a penalty of five per cent, per month on the amount, to be deemed an interest. On March 8, 1853, the Board of Supervisors met, and accepted the bridge, and made an order directing the County Auditor to draw a warrant upon the County Treasurer, in favor of Gilman, for seven thousand six hundred and sixty-two dollars and fifty cents, being the contract price of the bridge, together with interest thereon at five per cent, per month from the time the bridge had been completed up to the time the order was made. A warrant was drawn (number two hundred and sixteen), by the Auditor, in favor of Gilman, and delivered to him, March 8, 1853, for seven thousand six hundred and sixty-two dollars and fifty cents. The warrant was accepted by Gilman, and on the same day was presented by him to the County Treasurer, and the Treasurer made the following endorsement on the warrant : " Not paid for want of funds ; March eighth, eighteen hundred and fifty -three ; D. Hunsaker, Treasurer ; by A. M. Holliday, Deputy." Gilman retained the warrant. It does not appear that Gilman presented his warrant to the Treasurer for payment again. On November 15, 1S54, Gilman commenced an action against the County of Contra Costa, to recover the contract price of the bridge, together with five per cent, per month interest from and after March 8, 1853. The cause was tried in Solano county, and judgment was rendered in favor of the county. An appeal was taken to the Supreme Court ; the judgment of the District Court was reversed, and a new trial ordered. The cause was again tried in the District Court on January 30, 1856, and judgment was rendered against the county for twenty thousand four hundred aud twenty-seven dollars, being the amount of the original contract price of the bridge, with five per cent, interest thereon from March 8, 1853, to the date of the judgment, and the said judgment to bear interest at five per cent, per month. On February 14, 1855, an Act was passed funding all the indebtedness of Contra Costa county, which accrued prior to April 1, 1855 ; and the thirteenth section of the Act provided that it should not be lawful for the County Treasurer to pay or liquidate any of the indebtedness of said county of Contra Costa which accrued prior to February 1, 1855, in any other manner than in such Funding Act provided (Statutes 1855, page 12). Oilman did not present his claim to be funded. That on January 10, 1857, Gilman caused execution to be issued on the judgment in his favo:-, recovered on January 30, 1856, for twenty thousand four hundred and twentyseven dollars. The execution was levied on all the moneys in the County Treasury belonging to all Funds. This levy was made January 19, 1857. On February 2.5, 1857, the Sheriff, under the dfrection of Gilman, levied on the Court House, and on March 5, 1857, again levied on the funds in the County Treasury. In March, 1857, the county moved the District Court to quash the execution and the several levies. The District Court denied the motion. The cause was appealed to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court reversed the order of the District Court, and ordered the executions should be quashed and the levy vacated, the Court holding that the county buildings were exempt from seizure and forced sale on execution ; and also held that the levy upon the revenues, in the hands of the Treasurer, was illegal and void ; that the revenues were authorized by law, and appropriated to distinct purposes, and were not the subject of seizure upon execution (8 Cal. Kep. page 58).
On July 9, 1857, Gilman caused another execution to be issued on said judgment, and levied on private property, being an undivided eighth of the San Pablo Rancho. The property was advertised for sale, and the owner, Joseph Emeric, obtained an injunction from the District Court of the Seventh District, enjoining the sale. The case was appealed to the Supreme Court ; that Court decided (10 Cal., p. 404) that the private property of an inhabitant of a county is not liable to seizure and sale on execution for the satisfaction of a judgment recovered against the county, and that no execution can issue upon a judgment rendered against the county. Gilman again caused an execution to be issued on his judgment against the county, on April 1, 1858, and levied the same on the funds in the County Treasury. A motion was made to set aside the execution and quash the levy ; the District Court granted the motion and Gilman appealed to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court affirmed the order of the District Court (10 Cal. Rep. p. 508.) This left Gilman without any remedy whatever to collect his debt, and the county without any power or authority whatever to pay. The Supreme Court having decided, in the case of Hunsaker vs. Borden (5 Cal. Rep., p. 288), that the county of Contra Costa had no power to pay any of the indebtedness which existed against that county prior to February 1, 1855, in any oth^r manner than as prescribed in the Act to fund the indebtedness of said county, passed February 14, 1855, and that the payment in any other manner was unlawful. Gilman's debt having been contracted prior to February 1, 1855, and he having failed and neglected to fund his debt, he was without remedy. The rights of the parties continued thus until March 14, 1860, when an Act was passed entitled " An Act providing for the payment of a judgment in favor of Trusten C. Gilman, against the county of Contra Costa" (Stat. 1860, p. 94.) In the preamble of the Act it is recited :
" Whereas, The Supreme Court has affirmed a judgment entered in the , Seventh Judicial Disfa-ict Court, in favor of Trusten C. Gilman, against the county of Contra Costa, which judgment was entered in said District Court on the twenty-second of March, eighteen hundred and fifty six, for the sum of twenty thousand four hundred and twenty -seven dollars, and interest and costs."
The Act provides for levying and collecting a special tax of one per cent, on the taxable property in the county, to pay said judgment, together with interest thereon at ten per cent, per annum from its date. The fifth section of the Act provides that the Treasurer of the county of Contra Costa should pay the money collected by virtue of the Act from time to time, upon demand, to said Trusten C. Gilman, his executors, administrators, or assigns, and at the same time take a receipt therefor from his assigns ; and have said judgment credited with said payment or payments by the proper party or parties entitled to receive the same ; and the said party or parties entitled to receive from the Treasurer the payment of said judgment, shall, before any payments are made by the Treasurer on account of the same, deliver to the Treasurer the warrant heretofore issued in favor of said Gilman, and known as Warrant Number Two hundred and sixteen, and the Treasurer shall cancel the same. Section eight of said Act provides that said T. C. Gilman, or his assigns, should be allowed until the first Monday in August next hereafter to make known to the Board of Supervisors of said county his or their acceptance of said amount in full satisfaction and payment of all demands accruing at any time in his favor against the county of Contra Costa for building a bridge across the San Antonio creek ; provided, that if he fail to declare said acceptance to the Board of Supervisors on or before the first Monday in August next, then said special tax shall not be collected.
That on August 6, 1860, George F. Sharp, to whom Gilman had assigned said judgment, and who was the legal assignee of the judgment rendered in favor of Gilman against the county of Contra Costa on March 22, 1856, for twenty thousand four hundred and twenty -seven dollars, with interest and costs, came before the Board of Supervisors of Contra Costa county and in writing accepted the provisions of the Act of March 14, 1860, in full satisfaction and payment of all demands accruing at any time in favor of said Gilman against the county of Contra Costa for building a bridge across the San Antonio Creek, and he also surrendered to the Treasurer of said county, as provided in said Act, the County Warrant number two hundred and sixteen, for seven thousand six hundred and sixty-two dollars and fifty cents, which was canceled, as provided in the fifth section of the Act. On the same day, August 6, i860, the Board of Supervisors of Contra Costa county levied a tax of one per cent, on the taxable property of the county, as provided in said Act, for the payment of said claim. The payments made by tne Treasurer to Sharp, as the assignee of said judgment and in satisfaction of said claim, amounted in the aggregate, on June 19, 1862, the time of the last payment, to thirty-one thousand six hundred and eleven dollars and twenty-one cents, that being the full sum due for principal and interest, as in said Act provided. And upon making the several payments the Treasurer took from said Sharp receipts as follows : " Office of the County Treasurer of Contra Costa county. Received from Hiram Fogg, County Treasurer of Contra Costa county, the sum of ten thousand dollars, lawful currency of the United States of America, in part payment and satisfaction of the judgment recovered by Trusten C. Gilman against the county of Contra Costa. The said sum is paid out of the Gilman Judgment Fund, which was levied and collected in pursuance of an act of the Legislature of the State of California, entitled an "Act providing for the payment of a judgment in favor of Trusten C. Gilman against the county of Contra Costa, approved March 14, 1860," and by order of the Board of Supervisors of Contra Costa county, made on the sixth of August, eighteen hundred and sixty, a copy being annexed to this receipt, and the said sum is received in part satisfaction of said judgment, in accordance with the provisions of the said Act of the Legislature, and I hereby authorize satisfaction of the amount receipted for to be entered." There were thirteen different payments made, and thirteen receipts given by Sharp, as assignee of Gilman, to the Treasurer, of like tenor to the above. The debt was fully paid, as provided in said Act, on June 19, 1862.
That on March 15, 1860, prior to the passage of the Act of March 14th mentioned, George F. Sharp, as the assignee of Gilman, commenced an action in the District Court of Solano county to revive the judgment of March 22, 1856, in favor of Gilman and against the county, for twenty thousand four hundred and twenty -seven dollars, with five per cent, per month interest. Judgment was entered in said action in favor of Sharp, assignee of Gilman, by default, in the Clerk's office, on July 18, 1860, for eighty-five thousand and forty-two dollars and eighty cents, to be an interest at five per cent, per month. When this action was commenced a demurrer was filed, but after the Act of March 14, 1860, the officers of the county, believing that the Act of March 14th provided for a full settlement of all matters growing out of the Gilman bridge transaction, and intending also in good faith to pay the claim, as provided in that Act, and believing that Gilman and his assignees also intended to act in good faith in accepting the »terms of said Act, the county paid no further attention to the last named suit; and afterwards, on July 18, 1860, Sharp applied to the Clerk of Solano county, who entered in a vacation judgment by default against the county for eighty-five thousand and forty-two dollars and eighty cents. No action was taken by Sharp on this last judgment until long after he had been fully paid, as stated, on and prior to June 19, 1862.
That on July 16, 1865, Sharp commenced another action to revive the last judgment of eighty -five thousand and forty- two dollars and eighty cents against the county. The action was commenced in the Fifteenth District Court in San Francisco City and county. The county defended the action on the ground that the debt had been fully paid, satisfied and discharged. The cause was tried, and judgment was rendered in the District Court in favor of the county. The Court decided that the county had fully paid and satisfied the said debt and the said judgment, and ordered and directed that Sharp should cancel and satisfy said judgment of record. Sharp appealed from said judgment to the Supreme Court. The judgment of the District Court was affirmed. The Supreme Court held that the county was not, either legally or equitably, indebted upon the demand in any sum whatever, but on the contrary, that the county had, under the Act of March 14, I860, fully paid and discharged the said claim. The case is entitled Sharp vs. Contra Costa County, and is reported in 34 Cal. Reports, p. 284.
Oilman's claim is now (1872) made to the Legislature for the same identical claim for building the bridge across the San Antonio creek, and in relation to which the litigation named was had, and the same for which payment was provided in the Act of March 14, 1860, and is the same which was fully paid and satisfied under said Act. His county warrant has been surrendered and canceled; his judgment has been paid, satisfied, and discharged, and satisfaction entered of record ; he now makes a claim against the county of over six hundred and seventy-six thousand and ninety dollars upon this claim. It is submitted that the county has not only paid the claim, but has actually paid more than double what was due to him according to law. When Gilman received his warrant for seven thousand four hundred dollars on March 8, 1853, and presented the same to the Treasurer, the Treasurer made the indorsement thereon required by law. From that time the debt drew ten per cent, per annum, interest, and no more. Section ten of the Act concerning County Treasurers, passed March 27, 1850, (Statutes, 1850, p. 115), provides when any warrant shall be presented to the County Treasurer for payment, and the same is not paid for the want of funds, the Treasurer shall indorse thereon " Not paid for want of funds," annexing the date of presentation, and sign his name thereto ; and from that time till redeemed, said order or warrant shall bear ten per cent, per annum. That section of the statute has been in force ever since it was passed in 1850. When Gilman accepted his warrant, and presented it to the Treasurer and procured it to be indorsed by him, and had received it back into his possession, he knew or was bound to know what the law was ; that from that time no officer was authorized by law to pay any greater rate of interest on that debt than ten per cent, per annum. The interest on the debt up to June 19, 1862 - the time when the full amount was paid under the Act of 1860 - being nine years and three and one-third months, would have been six thousand eight hundred and sixty-five dollars, which, added to the principal, seven thousand four hundred dollars, amounted to fourteen thousand two hundred and sixty-five dollars. The county actually paid thirty-one thousand six hundred and eleven dollars and twentyone cents, being seventeen thousand three hundred and forty-six dollars and twenty-one cents more than was due on the warrant, according to the law concerning indebtedness of counties.
The facts in this case are fully set out and authenticated in the record on the appeal of the action of Sharp vs. The County of Contra Costa, in the Supreme Court in the case reported in 34 Cal. p. 284. The transcript, briefs and decision of the District Court, with its findings, and the testimony in the case, will he found bound in volume seventy of California Supreme Court Record, pp. 50 to 102.
The petitioner has no claims whatever upon the county, either legal or equitable ; but he has been paid by the county actually more than twice as much as was justly due him, and his present claim is a sham without foundation, and is neither supported by equity nor good conscience, and should be postponed indefinitely. -
This is the full history of that vexatious suit, tersely and fully put forth as already said by that learned exponent of the law, Judge Thomas A. Brown.
We will close this chapter by calling the attention of our readers to the Tables herewith appended. In the second will be found a list of taxes levied since the foundation of the county, exclusive of the poll-tax, while in the third we have handed to posterity a full list of all the officers who have served the county, from State Senator to Constable, with the votes received at the various elections. Also notes showing the appointments made by the Court of Sessions and Boards of Supervisors between each general election. This Table is as complete as it is possible to make, and all records of the county have been thoroughly searched for the purpose of making it perfectly correct and reliable, and it is with no little degree of pride that we present to our patrons the result of our labors, feeling well assured that it will be fully appreciated by all who have occasion to refer to it.
The subject of the tenure of land in California is one which is so little understood, that it has been deemed best to quote at length the following report on the subject of land titles in California, made in pursuance of instructions from the Secretary of State and the Secretary of the Interior, by William Carey Jones, published in Washington in the year 1850 - a more exhaustive document it would be difficult to find.
On July 12, 1849, Mr. Jones had been appointed a "confidential agent of the Government, to proceed to Mexico and California, for the purpose of procuring information as to the condition of land titles in California." Pursuant to these instructions he embarked from New York on the 17th July ; arriving at Chagres on the 29th, he at once proceeded to Panama, but got no opportunity, until that day month, of proceeding on his journey to this State. At length, on September 19th, he arrived at Monterey, the then capital of California. After visiting San Jose and San Francisco, he returned to Monterey, and there made arrangements for going by land to Los Angeles and San Diego, but finding this scheme impracticable on account of the rainy season, he made the voyage by steamer. On December 7th he left San Diego for Acapulco in Mexico, where he arrived on the 24th ; on the 11th he left that city, and on the 18th embarked from Vera Cruz for Mobile.
Of California
TO THE MODE OF CREATING TITLES TO LAND, FROM THE FIRST INCEPTION TO THE PERFECT TITLE, AS PRACTICED BY MEXICO WITHIN THE PROVINCE OF CALIFORNIA.
All the grants of land made in California (except pueblo or village lots, and except, perhaps, some grants north of the Bay of San Francisco, as will be hereafter noticed), subsequent to the independence of Mexico, and after the establishment of that government in California, were made by the different political governors. The great majority of them were made subsequent to January, 1832, and consequently under the Mexican Colonization Law of August 18, 1824, and the government regulations, adopted in pursuance of the law dated November 21, 1828. In January, 1832, General Jose Figueroa became Governor of the then territory of California, under a commission from the government at Mexico, replacing Victoria, who, after having the year before displaced Echandrea, was himself driven out by a revolution. The installation of Figueroa restored quiet, after ten years of civil commotion, and was at a time when Mexico was making vigorous efforts to reduce and populate her distant territories, and consequently granting lands on a liberal scale. In the act of 1824, a league square (being 4,428 $020 acres) is the smallest measurement of rural property spoken of ; and of these leagues square, eleven (or nearly fifty thousand acres) might be conceded in a grant to one individual. By this law the States composing the federation were authorized to make special provision for colonization within their respective limits, and the colonization of the territories, " conformably to the principles of law " charged upon the Central Government. California was of the latter description, being designated a Territory in the Acta Constitutiva of the Mexican Federation, adopted January 31, 1824, and by the Constitution adopted 4th October of the same year.*
The colonization of California and granting lands therein, was, therefore, subsequent to the law of August 18, 1824, under the direction and control of the Central Government. That government, as already stated, gave regulations for the same November 21, 1828.
The directions were very simple. They gave the governors of the territories the exclusive faculty of making grants within the terms of the law - that is, to the extent of eleven leagues, or sitios, to individuals ; and colonization grants (more properly contracts) - that is, grants of larger tracts to empresarios, or persons who should undertake, for a consideration in land, to bring families to the country for the purpose of colonization. Grants of the first description, that is, to families or single persons, and not exceeding eleven sitios, were " not to be held definitely valid," until sanctioned by the Territorial Deputation. Those of the second class, that is, empresario or colonization grants (or contracts) required a like sanction by the Supreme Government. In case the concurrence of the Deputation was refused to a grant of the first mentioned class, the Governor should appeal, in favor of the grantee, from the Assembly to the Supreme Government.
"The political condition of California was changed by the Constitution of 2tfth December, and act for the division ui the Republic into Departments of December 30, 1836. The two Californias then became a Department, the confederation being broken up and the States reduced to Departments. The same colonization system, however, seems to have continued in California.
The "first inception " of the claim, pursuant to the regulations, and as practiced in California, was a petition to the Governor, praying for the grant, specifying usually the quantity of land asked, and designating its position, with some descriptive object or boundary, and also stating the age, country and vocation of the petitioner. Sometimes, also, (generally at the commencement of this system) a rude map or plan of the required grant, showing its shape and position, with reference to other tracts, or to natural objects, was presented with the petition. This practice, however, was gradually disused, and few of the grants made in late years have any other than a verbal description.
The next step was usually a reference of the petition, made on the margin by the Governor, to the prefect of the district, or other near local officer where the land petitioned for was situated, to know if it was vacant, and could be granted without injury to third persons or the public, and sometimes to know if the petitioner's account of himself was true. The reply (informe) of the prefect, or other officer, was written upon or attached to the petition, and the whole returned to the Governor. The reply being satisfactory, the Governor then issued the grant in form. On its receipt, or before, (often before the petition, even,) the party went into possession. It was not unfrequent, of late years, to omit the formality of sending the petition to the local authorities, and it was never requisite, if the Governor already possessed the necessary information concerning the land and the parties. In that case the grant followed immediately on the petition. Again, it sometimes happened that the reply of the local authority was not explicit, or that third persons intervened, and the grant was thus for some time delayed. With these qualifications, and covering the great maiority of cases, the practice may be said to have been : 1. The petition ; 2. The reference to the prefect or alcalde ; 3. His report, or informe ; 4. the grant from the Governor.
The originals of the petition and informe, and any other preliminary papers in the case, were filed, by the secretary, in the government archives, and with them a copy (the original being delivered to the grantee) of the grant ; the whole attached together so as to form one document, entitled, collectively, an expediente. During the governorship of Figueroa, and some of his successors, that is, from May 22, 1833, to May 9, 1836, the grants were likewise recorded in a book kept for that purpose (as prescribed in the " regulations " above referred to) in the archives. Subsequent to that time there was no record, but a brief memorandum of the grant ; the expediente, however, being still filed. Grants were also sometimes registered in the office of the prefect of the district where the lands lay; but the practice was not constant, nor the record generally in permanent form.
The next, and final step in the title was the approval of the grant by the Territorial Deputation (that is, the local legislature, afterward, when the territory was created into a Department, called the " Departmental Assembly.") For this purpose, it was the Governor's office to communicate the fact of the grant, and all information concerning it, to the Assembly. It was here referred to a committee (sometimes called a committee on vacant lands, sometimes on agriculture), who reported at a subsequent, sitting. The approval was seldom refused ; but there are many instances where the Governor omitted to communicate the grant to the Assembly, and it consequently remained unacted on. The approval of the Assembly obtained, it was usual for the secretary to deliver to the grantee, on application, a certificate of the fact ; but no other record or registration of it was kept than the written proceedings of the Assembly. There are no doubt instances, therefore, where the approval was in fact obtained, but a certificate not applied for, and as the journals of the Assembly, now remaining in the archives, are very imperfect, it can hardly be doubted that many grants have received the approval of the Assembly, and no record of the fact now exists. Many grants were passed upon and approved by the Assembly in the Winter and Spring of 1846, as I discovered by loose memoranda, apparently made by the clerk of the Assembly for future entry, and referring to the grants by their numbers - sometimes a dozen or more on a single small piece of paper, but of which I could find no other record.
There were not, as far as I could learn, any regular surveys made of grants in California up to the time of the cessation of the former government. There was no public or authorized surveyor in the country. The grants usually contained a direction that the grantee should receive judicial possession of the land from the proper magistrate (usually the nearest alcalde), in virtue of the grant, and that the boundaries of the tract should then be designated by that functionary with " suitable land marks." But this injunction was usually complied with, only by procuring the attendance of the magistrate, to give judicial possession according to the verbal description contained in the grant. Some of the old grants have been subsequently surveyed, as I was informed, by a surveyor under appointment of Col. Mason, acting as Governor of California. I did not see any official record of such surveys, or understand that there was any. The "perfecting of the title " I suppose to have been accomplished when the grant received the concurrence of the Assembly ; all provisions of the law, and of the colonization regulations of the Supreme Government, pre-requisites to the title being " definitely valid," having been fulfilled. These, I think, must be counted complete titles.
1. " 1828. Cuaderno del registro de los sitios, fierras y senales que posean los habitantes del territorio de la Nueva California." [Book of registration of the farms, brands, and marks (for marking cattle), possessed by the inhabitants of the territory of New California.]
This book contains information of the situation, boundaries and appurtenances of several of the missions, as hereafter noticed ; of two pueblos, San Jose" and Branciforte, and the records of about twenty grants, made by various Spanish, Mexican and local authorities, at different times, between 1784 and 1825, and two dated 1829. This book appears to have been arranged upon information obtained in an endeavor of the government to procure a registration of all the occupied lands of the territory.
This book contains records of grants, numbered from one to one hundred and eight, of various dates, from May 22, 1833, to May 9, 1836, by the successive Governors, Figueroa, Jose Castro, Nicholas Gutierrez and Mariano Chico. A part of these grants (probably all) are included in a file of expedientes of grants hereafter described, marked from number one to number five hundred and seventy-nine ; but the numbers in the book do not correspond with the numbers of the same grants in the expedientes.
This book contains a brief entry, by the secretary of the department of grants, including their numbers, dates, names of the grantees and of the grants, quantity granted, and situation of the land, usually entered in the book in the order they were conceded. This book contains the grants made from January 18, 1839, to December 8, 1843, inclusive.
5. File of expedientes of grants - that is, all the proceedings (except of the Assembly) relating to the respective grants, secured, those of each grant in a separate parcel, and marked and labeled with its number and name. The file is marked from No. 1 to No. 579 inclusive, and embraces the space of time between May 13, 1833, to July, 184G. The numbers, however, bear little relation to the dates. Some numbers are missing, of some there are duplicates - that is, two distinct grants with the same number. The expedientes are. not all complete ; in some cases the final grant appears to have been refused ; in others it is wanting. The collection, however, is evidently intended to represent estates which have been granted, and it is probable that in many, or most instances, the ommission apparent in the archives is supplied by original documents in the hands of the parties, or by long permitted occupation. These embrace all the record books and tiles belonging to the territorial, or departmental archives, which I was able to discover.
I am assured, however, by Mr. J. C. Fremont, that according to the best of his recollection, a book for the year 1846, corresponding to those noticed above, extending from 1839 to the end of 1845, existed in the archives while he was Governor of California, and was with them when he delivered them in May, 1847, to the officer appointed by General Kearny to receive them from him at Monterey.
CHIEFLY THE LARGE GRANTS, AS THE MISSIONS, AND WHETHER THE TITLE TO THEM BE IN ASSIGNEES, OR WHETHER THEY HAVE REVERTED, AND VESTED IN THE SOVEREIGN ?
I took much pains both in California and Mexico, to assure myself of the situation, in a legal and proprietary point of view, of the former great establishments known as the Missions of California. It had been supposed that the lands they occupied were grants, held as the property of the church, or of the mission establishments as corporations. Such, however, was not the case. All the missions in Upper California were established under the direction and mainly at the expense of the Government, and the missionaries there had never any other rights than the occupation and use of the lands for the purpose of the missions, and at the pleasure of the Government. This is shown by the history and principles of their foundation^ by the laws in relation to them, by the constant practice of the Government toward them, and, in fact, by the rules of the Franciscan order, which forbids its members to possess property.
The establishment of missions in remote provinces was a part of the colonial system of Spain. The Jesuits, by a license from the Viceroy of New Spain, commenced in this manner the reduction of Lower California in the year 1697. They continued in the spiritual charge, and in a considerable degree of the temporal government of that province until 1767, when the royal decree abolishing the Jesuit order throughout New Spain was there enforced, and the missions taken out of their hands. They had then founded fifteen missions, extending from Cape St. Lucas nearly to the head of the sea of Cortez, or Califbrnian gulf. Three of the establishments had been suppressed by order of the Viceroy ; the remainder were now put in charge of the Franciscan monks of the college of San Fernando, in Mexico, hence sometimes called " Fernandinos." The prefect of that college, the Rev. Father Junipero Serra, proceeded in person to his new charge, and arrived with a number of monks at Loreto, the capital of the peninsula, the following year (1768). He was there, soon after, joined by Don Jose* Galvez, Inspector-General (visitador), of New Spain, who brought an order from the King, directing the founding of one or more settlements in Upper California. It was therefore agreed that Father Junipero should extend the mission establishments into Upper California, under the protection of presidios (armed posts) which the government would establish at San Diego and Monterey. Two expeditions, both accompanied by missionaries, were consequently fitted out, one to proceed by sea, the other by land, to the new territory. In June, 1769, they had arrived, and in that month founded the first mission about two leagues from the port of San Diego. A presidio was established at the same time near the port. The same year a presidio was established at Monterey, and a mission establishment begun. Subsequently the Dominican friars obtained leave from the King to take charge of a part of the missions of California, which led to an arrangement between the two societies, whereby the missions of Lower California were committed to the Dominicans, and the entire field of the upper province remained to the Franciscans. This arrangement was sanctioned by the political authority, and continues to the present time. The new establishments flourished and rapidly augmented their numbers, occupying first the space between San Diego and Monterey, and subsequently extending to the northward. A report from the Viceroy to the King, dated Mexico, December 27, 1793, gives the following account of the number, time of establishment, and locality of the missions existing in New California at that period :
Situation When Founded
At first the missions nominally occupied the whole territory, except the four small military posts of San Diego, Santa Barbara, Monterey and San Francisco ; that is, the limits of one mission were said to cover the intervening space to the limits of the next ; and there were no other occupants except the wild Indians, whose reduction and conversion were the objects of the establishments. The Indians, as fast as they were reduced, were trained to labor in the missions, and lived either within its walls or in small villages near by, under the spiritual and temporal direction of the priests, but the whole under the political control of the Governor of the province, who decided contested questions of right or policy, whether between different missions, between missions and individuals, or concerning the Indians. Soon, however, grants of land began to be made to individuals, especially to retired soldiers, who received special favor in the distant colonies of Spain, and became the settlers and the founders of the country they had reduced and protected. Some settlers wei-e also brought from the neighboring provinces of Sonora and Sinaloa, and the towns of San Jose, at the head of the Bay of San Francisco, and of Los Angeles, eight leagues from the port of San Pedro, were early founded. The Governor exercised the privilege of making concessions of large tracts, and the captains of the presidios were authorized to grant building lots and small tracts^ for gardens and farms within the distance of two leagues from the presidios. By these means the mission tracts began respectively to have something like known boundaries, though the lands they thus occupied were still not viewed in any light as the property of the missionaries, but as the domain of the crown, appropriated to the use of the missions while the state of the country should require it, and at the pleasure of the political authority.
It was the custom throughout New Spain (and other parts of the Spanish colonies also) to secularize or to subvert the mission establishments, at the discretion of the ruling political functionary ; and this not as an act of arbitrary power, but in the exercise of an acknowledged ownership and authority. The great establishments of Sonora, I have been told, were divided between white settlements and settlements of the Indian pupils, or neophytes of the establishments. In Texas the missions were broken up, the Indians were dispersed, and the lands have been granted to white settlers. In New Mexico, I am led to suppose, the Indian pupils of the missions, or their descendants, still in great part occupy the old establishments ; and other parts are occupied by white settlers in virtue of grants and sales.* The undisputed exercise of this authority over all the mission establishments, and whatever property was pertinent to them, is certain.
The liability of the missions of Upper California, however, to be thus dealt with at the pleasure of the Government, does not rest only on the argument to be drawn from this constant and uniform practice. It was
* Since writing the above, I have learned from the Hon. Mr. Smith, Delegate from the Territory of New Mexico, that the portion of each of the former mission establishments which has been allotted to the Indians is one league square. They hold the land, as a general rule, in community, and on condition of supporting a priest and maintaining divine worship. This portion and these conditions are conformable to the principles of the Spanish laws concerning the allotments of Indian villages. Some interesting particulars of the foundation, progress and plan of the missions of New Mexico are contained in the report, or information, before quoted, of 1793, from the Viceroy to the King of Spain, and in extracts from it given in the papers accompanying this report.
inherent in their foundation - a condition of their establishment. A belief has prevailed, and it is so stated in all the works I have examined which treat historically of the missions of that country, that the first act which looked to their secularization, and especially the first act by which any authority was conferred on the local government for that purpose, or over their temporalities, was an Act of the Mexican Congress of August 17, 1833. Such, however, was not the case. Their secularization - their subversion - was looked for in their foundation ; and I do not perceive that the local authority (certainly not the supreme authority) has ever been without that lawful jurisdiction over them, unless subsequent to the colonization regulations of November 21, 1828, which temporarily exempted mission lands from colonization. I quote from a letter of " Instructions to the commandant of the new establishments of San Diego and Monterey," given by Viceroy Bucareli, August 17, 1773 :
"Art. 15. - When it shall happen that a mission is to be formed into a pueblo (or village) the commandant will proceed to reduce it to the civil and economical government, which, according to the laws, is observed by other villages of this kingdom ; then giving it a name, and declaring for its patron the saint under whose memory and protection the mission was founded." (Cuando llegue el caso de que haya de formarse en el pueblo una mision, procedera el comandante a reducirlo al gobierno civil y economico que observan, segun las leyes, los demas de este reino ; poniehdole nombre entonces, y declarandole por su titular el santo bajo cuya memoria y venerable proteccion se fundo la mision.)
The right then, to remodel these establishments at pleasure, and convert them into towns and villages, subject to the known policy and laws which governed settlements of that description* we see was a principal of their foundation. Articles 7 and 10 of the same letter of instructions, show us also that it was a part of the plan of the missions that their condition should thus be changed ; that they were regarded only as the nucleus and basis of communities to be thereafter emancipated, acquire proprietary ' rights, and administer their own affairs ; and that it was the duty of the governor to choose their sites, and direct the construction and arrangement of their edifices, with a view to their convenient expansion into towns and cities. And not only was this general revolution of the establishments thus early contemplated and provided for, but meantime the governor had authority to reduce their possessions by grants within and without, and to change their condition by detail. The same series of instructions authorized the
* A revolution more than equal to the modern secularization, since the latter only necessarily implies the turning over of the temporal concerns of the missions to secular administration. Their conversion into pueblos would take from the missions all semblance in organization to their originals, and include the reduction of the missionary priests from the heads of great establishments and administrators of large temporalities to parish curates ; achange quite inconsistent with the existence in the priests or the church of any proprietary interest or right over the establishment.
governor to grant lands, either in community or individually, to the Indians of the missions, in and about their settlements on the mission lands, and also to make grants to settlements of white persons. The governor was likewise authorized at an early day to make grants to soldiers who should marry Indian women trained in the missions ; and the first grant (and only one I found of record) under this authorization, was of a tract near the mission edifice of Carmel, near Monterey. The authorization given to the captains of presidios to grant lands within two leagues of their posts, expressly restrains them within that distance, so as to leave the territory beyond - though all beyond was nominally attached to one or other of the missions - at the disposition of the superior guardians of the royal property. In brief, every fact, every act of government and principle of law applicable to the case, which I have met in this investigation, go to show that the missions of Upper California were never, from the first, reckoned other than government establishments, or the founding of them to work any change in the ownership of the soil, which continued in and at the disposal of the crown, or its representatives. This position was also confirmed, if had it needed any confirmation, by the opinions of high legal and official authorities in Mexico. The missions - speaking collectively of priests and pupils - had the usufruct ; the priests the administration of it ; the whole resumable, or otherwise disposable, at the will of the crown or its representatives.
The object of the missions was to aid in the settlement and pacification of the country, and to convert the natives to Christianity. This accomplished, settlements of white people established, and the Indians domiciliated in villages, so as to subject them to the ordinary magistrates, and the spiritual care of the ordinary clergy, the missionary labor was considered fulfilled, and the establishment subject to be dissolved or removed. This view of their purposes and destiny fully appears in the tenor of the decree of the Spanish Cortes of September 13, 1813.*
The provisions of that Act, and the reason given for it, develop in fact the whole theory of the mission establishments. It was passed " in consequence of a complaint by the Bishop elect of Guiana of the evils that afflicted that province, on account of the Indian settlements in charge of missions not being delivered to the ecclesiastical ordinary, though thirty, forty and fifty years had passed since the reduction and conversion of the Indians." The Cortes therefore decreed : -
1. That all the new reducciones y doctrinas (that is, settlements of Indians newly converted, and not yet formed into parishes), of the provinces beyond the sea, which were in charge of missionary monks, and had been ten years subjected, should be delivered immediatelyto the respective ecclesiastical ordinaries (bishops), "without resort to any excuse or pretext, conformably to the laws and ccdulas in that respect."
2. That as well these missions (doctrinas) as all others which should be erected into curacies, should be canonically provided by the said ordinaries (observing the laws and cedulas of the royal right of patronage) with fit ministers of the secular clergy.
3. That the missionary monks, relieved from the converted settlements, which should be delivered to the ordinary, should apply themselves to the extension of religion in benefit of the inhabitants of other wilderness parts, proceeding in the exercise of their missions conformably to the directions of paragragh 10, Article 335, of the Constitution.*
4. That the misionary monks should discontinue immediately the government and administration of the property of the Indians, who should choose by means of their ayuntamientos, with intervention of the superior political authority, persons among themselves competent to administer it ; the lands being distributed and reduced to private ownership, in accordance with the decree of January 4, 1813, on reducing vacant and other lands to private property.!"
It has also been supposed that the Act above alluded to of the Mexican Congress (Act of August 17, 1833) was the first assertion by the Mexican Government of property in the missions, or that they by that Act first became (or came to be considered) national domain. But this is likewise an error. The Mexican Government has always asserted the right of property over all the missions of the country, and I do not think that the supposition has ever been raised in Mexico, that they were the property of the missionaries or the Church.
The General Congress of Mexico, in decree of August 14, 1824, concerning the public revenue, declares the estates of the inquisition, as well as all temporalities, to be the property of the nation (that is, no doubt, in contradistinction from property of the States - making no question of their being public property). This term would include not only the mission establishments, but all rents, profits and income the monks received from them. A like Act of July 7, 1831, again embraces the estates of the inquisition and
"The provincial councils of the provinces beyond sea shall attend to the order, economy, and progress of the missions for the conversion of infidel Indians, and to the prevention of abuses in that branch of administration. The commisioners of such missions shall render their accounts to them, which accounts they shall in their turn forward to the Government."
1. That " all the vacant or royal lands and town reservations (propios y arbitrion, lands reserved in and about towns and cities for the municipal revenue), both in the peninsula and islands adjacent, and in the provinces beyond sea, except such commons as may be necessary for the villages, shall be converted into private property ; provided, that in regard to town reservations, some annual rents shall be reserved."
Provenance
Text from History of Contra Costa County, California, Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description; Together with a Record of the Mexican Grants ... Also, Incidents of Pioneer Life; and Biographical Sketches of Early and Prominent Settlers and Representative Men .., published 1882, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.