Contra Costa County, California - The whole text, 1882 (part 8 of 22)
From History of Contra Costa County, California, Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description; Together with a Record of the Mexican Grants ... Also, Incidents of Pioneer Life; and Biographical Sketches of Early and Prominent Settlers and Representative Men .., published 1882. 14,680 words, reproduced complete and unedited. Source changes inside the text are labelled in place.
Contents
3 sectionsThe section headings the book prints inside this chapter. Each one jumps to where it begins.
Parts
The book prints this as one long chapter. It is split here so no single page grows too heavy to load; the text runs continuously across the parts and nothing is omitted.
The text
14,680 wordsMachine-read from scans of History of Contra Costa County, California, Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description; Together with a Record of the Mexican Grants ... Also, Incidents of Pioneer Life; and Biographical Sketches of Early and Prominent Settlers and Representative Men .., published 1882. Nothing has been corrected: fixing what looks like a misspelled name is how an invented one gets published. Source changes are marked where they occur.
2. That "in whatever mode these lands were distributed, it should be in full and exclusive ownership, so that their owners may enclose them (without prejudice of paths, crossings, wnterin^-placeg and servitudes), to enjoy them freely and exclusively, and destine them to such use or cultivation as they may be best adapted to ; but withnut the owners ever being able to entail them or to transfer them, at any time or by any title, in mortmain."
3. " In the transfer of these lands shall be preferred the inhabitants of the villages (or settlements) in the neighborhood where they exist and who enjoyed the same in common whilst they were vacant."
temporalities as national property, and places them with " other rural and suburban estates " under charge of a director-general. The executive regulations for colonizing the territories may raise an idea of territorial and native property in them, but it puts out of the question any proprietary rights in the missionaries.
The seventeenth article of these regulations (executive regulations for colonization of the territories, adopted November 21, 1828) relates to the missions, and directs that " In those territories where there are missions, the lands which they occupy shall not at present be colonized, nor until it be determined if they ought to be considered as property of the settlements of the neophyte catechumens and Mexican settlers."
The subsequent acts and measures of the general Government of Mexico, in direct reference to missions, and affecting those of California, are briefly as follows :
A decree of the Mexican Congress of November 20, 1833, in part analogous to the decree before quoted of the Spanish Cortes of September, 1813, directing their general secularization, and containing these provisions :
2. In each of said missions shall be established a parish, served by a curate of the secular clergy, with a dotation of two thousand to two thousand five hundred dollars, at the discretion of the Government.
7. Of the buildings belonging to each mission, the most fitting shall be selected for the dwelling of the curate, with a lot of ground not exceeding two hundred varas square, and the others appropriated for a municipal house and schools.
" The Government is authorized to take all measures that may assure the colonization and make effective the secularization of the missions of Upper and Lower California, being empowered to this effect to use, in the manner most expedient, the defincas de obras pias (property of the piety fund) of those territories, to aid the transportation of the commission and families who are now in this capital destined thither."
The commission and emigrants, spoken of in this circular, were a colony under the charge of Don Jose Maria Hijar, who was sent out the following Spring (of 1834) as director of colonization, with instructions to the following effect : That he should " make beginning by occupying all the property pertinent to the missions of both Californias," that in the settlements he formed, special care should be taken to include the indigenous (Indian) population, mixing them with the other inhabitants, and not permitting any settlement of Indians alone ; that topographical plans should be made of the squares which were to compose the villages, and in each square building lots to be distributed to the colonist families ; that outside of the villages there should be distributed to each family of colonists, in full dominion and ownership, four caballerias* of irrigable land, or eight, if dependent on the seasons, or sixteen, if adapted to stock raising, and also live stock and agricultural implements ; that this distribution made, (out of the movable property of the mission) one-half the remainder of said property should be sold, and the other half reserved on account of government, and applied to the expenses of worship, maintenance of the missionaries, support of schools, and the purchase of agricultural implements for gratuitous distribution to the colonists.
2. That the missions shall be converted into curacies, whose limits shall be demarked by the governors of the States where said missions exist.
I have, so far, referred to these various legislative and governmental acts in relation to the missions, only to show, beyond equivocation or doubt, the relation in which the government stood toward them, and the rights of ownership which it exercised over them. My attention was next directed to the changes that had taken place in the condition of those establishments, under the various provisions for their secularization and conversion into private property.
Under the act of the Spanish Cortes of September, 1813, all the missions in New Spain were liable to be secularized ; that is, their temporalities delivered to lay administration ; their character as missions taken away by their conversion into parishes under charge of the secular clergy ; and the lands pertinent to them to be disposed of as other public domain. The question of putting this law in operation with regard to the missions in California was at various times agitated in that province, and in 1830 the then Governor, Echandrea, published a project for the purpose, but which was defeated by the arrival of a new Governor, Victoria, almost at the instant the plan was made public. Victoria revoked the decree of his predecessor, and restored the missionaries to the charge of the establishments, and in their authority over the Indians.
Subsequent to that time, and previous to the act of secularization of August, 1833, nothing further to that end appears to have been done in California. Under that act, the first step taken by the Central Government was the expedition of Hijar, above noticed. But the instructions delivered to him were not fulfilled. Hijar had been appointed Governor of California, as well as Director of Colonization, with directions to relieve Governor Figueroa. After Hijar's departure from Mexico, however, a revolution in the Supreme Government induced Hijar's appointment as political Governor to be revoked ; and an express was sent to California to announce this change, and with directions to Figueroa to continue in charge of the governorship. The courier arrived in advance of Hijar, who found himself on landing (in September, 1834,) deprived of the principal authority he had expected to exercise. Before consenting to cooperate with Hijar in the latter's instructions concerning the missions, Figueroa consulted the Territorial Deputation. That body protested against the delivery of the vast property included in the mission estates - and to a settlement in which the Indian pupils had undoubtedly an equitable claim - into Hijar's possession, and contested that his authority in the matter of the missions depended on his commission as Governor, which had been revoked, and not on his appointment (unknown to the law) as Director of Colonization. As a conclusion to the contestation which followed, the Governor and Assembly suspended Hijar from the last-mentioned appointment, and returned him to Mexico.*
Figueroa, however, had already adopted (in August, 1834,) a project of secularization, which he denominates a " Provisional Regulation." It provided that the missions should be converted partially into pueblos, or villages, with a distribution of lands and movable property as follows : To each individual head of a family, over twenty -five years of age, a lot of ground, not exceeding four hundred nor less than one hundred varas square, in the common lands of the mission, with a sufficient quantity in common for pasturage of the cattle of the village, and also commons and lands for municipal uses ; likewise, among the same individuals, one-half of the live stock, grain, and agricultural implements of the mission ; that the remainder of the lands, unmovable property, stock, and other effects, should be in charge of mayor domos, or other persons appointed by the Governor, subject to confirmation by the general government ; that from this common mass should be provided the maintenance of the priest, and expenses of religious
ยป Manifesto a la Republica Mejicana, que hace el General Jose Figueroa, coniandante general y gefe politico de la Alia California. Monterey, 1835.
service, and the temporal expenses of the mission ; that the minister should choose a place in the mission for his dwelling ; that the emancipated Indians should unite in common labors for the cultivation of the vineyards, gardens and field lands, which should remain undivided until the determination of the Supreme Government ; that the donees, under the regulation, should not sell, burthen, or transfer their grants, either of land or cattle, under any pretext ; and any contracts to this effect should be null, the property reverting to the nation, the purchaser losing his money ; that lands, the donee of which might die without leaving heirs, should revert to the nation ; that rancherias (hamlets of Indians) situated at a distance from the missions, and which exceeded twenty-five families, might form separate pueblos, under the same rules as the principal one. This regulation was to begin with ten of the missions (without specifying them) and successively to be applied to the remaining ones.
The Deputation, in session of the 3d of November of the same year (1834), made provision for dividing the missions and other settlements into parishes or curacies, according to the law of August, 1833, authorized the missionary priests to exercise the functions of curates, until curates of the secular clergy should arrive, and provided for their salaries and expenses of worship. No change was made in this act, in the regulations established by Governor Figueroa, for the distribution and management of the property.
Accordingly, for most or all of the missions, administi'ators were appointed by the Governor ; and in some, but not all, partial distributions of the lands and movable property were made, according to the tenor of the regulation. From this time, however, all tracts of lands pertinent to the missions, but not directly attached to the mission buildings, were granted as any other lands of the territory, to the Mexican inhabitants, and to colonists, for stock farms and tillage.
The act of the Mexican Congress of 1835, directing the execution of the decree of 1833 to be suspended until the arrival of curates, did not, as far as I could ascertain, induce any change in the policy already adopted by the territorial authorities.
On January 17, 1839, Governor Alvarado issued regulations for the government of the administrators of the missions. These regulations prohibited the administrators from contracting debts on account of the missions ; from slaughtering cattle of the missions, except for consumption, and from trading the mission horses or mules for clothing for the Indians ; and likewise provided for the appointment of an inspector of the missions, to supervise the accounts of the administrators, and their fulfillment of their trusts. Article 11 prohibited the settlement of white persons in the establishments, " whilst the Indians should remain in community." The establishments of San Carlos, San Juan Bautista and Sonoma were excepted from these regulations, and to be governed by special rules.
On March 1, 1840, the same Governor Alvarado suppressed the office of administrators, and replaced them by mayor domos,. with new and more stringent rules for the management of the establishments ; but not making any change in the rules of Governor Figueroa regarding the lands or other property.
By a proclamation of March 29, 1843, Governor Micheltorena, " in pursuance (as he states) of an arrangement between the Governor and the prelate of the missions," directed the following named missions to be restored to the priests " as tutors to the Indians, and in the same manner as they formerly held them," namely, the missions of San Diego, San Luis Rey, San Juan Capistrano, San Gabriel, San Fernando, San Buenaventura, Santa Barbara, Santa Ynes, La Purisima, San Antonio, Santa Clara and San Jose'. The same act set forth that " as policy made irrevocable what was already done," the missions should not reclaim any lands thitherto granted, but should collect the cattle and movable property which had been lent out either by the priests or administrators, and settle in a friendly way with the creditors ; and likewise regather the dispersed Indians, except such as had been legally emancipated, or were at private service. That the priests might provide out of the products of the missions for the necessary expenses of converting, subsisting and clothing the Indians, for a moderate allowance to themselves, economical salaries to the mayor domos, and the maintenance of divine worship, under the condition that the priests should bind themselves in honor and conscience to deliver to the public treasury one-eighth part of all the annual products of the establishments. That the Departmental government would exert all its power for the protection of the missions, and the same in respect to individuals and to private property, securing to the owners the possession and preservation of the lands they now hold, but promising not to make any new grants without consultation with the priests, unless where the lands were notoriously unoccupied, or lacked cultivation, or in case of necessity.
Micheltorena's governorship was shortly after concluded. There had been sent into the Department with him a considerable body of persons called jjresidarios, that is, criminals condemned to service - usually, as in this case, military service on the frontier - and their presence and conduct gave such offense to the inhabitants that they revolted, and expelled him and the presidarios from the country. He was succeeded by Don Pio Pico, in virtue of his being the " first vocal " of the Departmental Assembly,* and also by choice of the inhabitants, afterward confirmed by the Central Government, which at the same time gave additional privileges to the Department in respect to the management of its domestic affairs.
The next public act which I find in relation to the missions is an act of the Departmental Assembly, published in a proclamation of Governor Pico, June 5, 1845. This act provides: 1. " That the Governor should call together the neophytes of the following-named missions : San Rafael, Dolores, Soledad, San Miguel and La Purisima ; and in case those missions were abandoned by their neophytes, that he should give them one month's notice, by proclamation, to return and cultivate said missions, which if they did not do, the missions should be declared abandoned, and the Assembly and Governor dispose of them for the good of the Department. 2. That the missions of Carmel, San Juan Bautista, San Juan Capistrano and San Francisco Solano, should be considered as pueblos, or villages, which was their present condition ; and that the property which remained to them, the Governor, after separating sufficient for the curate's house, for churches and their pertinencies, and for a municipal house, should sell at public auction, the product to be applied first to paying the debts of the establishments, and the remainder, if any, to the benefit of divine worship. 3. That the remainder of the missions to San Diego, inclusive, should be rented, at the discretion of the Governor, with the proviso, that the neophytes should be at liberty to employ themselves at their option on their own grounds, which the Governor should designate for them, in the service of the rentee, or of any other person. 4. That the principal edifice of the mission of Santa Barbara should be excepted from the proposed renting, and in it the Governor should designate the parts most suitable for the residence of the bishop and his attendants, and of the missionary priests then living there ; moreover, that the rents arising from the remainder of the property of said mission should be disbursed, one-half for the benefit of the church and its ministry, the other for that of its Indians. 5. That the rents arising from the other missions should be divided, one-third to the maintenance of the minister, one-third to the Indians, one-third to the government."
On the 28th October, of the same year (1845), Governor Pico gave public notice for the sale to the highest bidder of five missions, to Avit : San Rafael, Dolores, Soledad, San Miguel and La Purisima ; likewise for the sale of the remaining buildings in the pueblos (formerly missions) of San Luis Obispo, Carmel, San Juan Bautista, and San Juan Capistrano, after separating the churches and their appurtenances, and a curate's municipal and school houses. The auctions were appointed to take place, those of San Luis Obispo, Purisima and San Juan Capistrano, the first four days of December following (1845) ; those of San Rafael, Dolores, San Juan Bautista, Carmel, Soledad and San Miguel, the 23d and 24th of January, 1846 ; meanwhile, the government would receive and take into consideration proposals in relation to said missions.
In the same proclamation Pico proposed to rent to the best bidder, for a period of nine years, and under conditions for the return of the property in good order and without waste, the missions of San Fernando, San Buenaventura, Santa Barbara and Santa Ynes ; the rentings to include all the lands, stock, agricultural tools, vineyards, gardens, offices and whatever in virtue of the inventories should be appurtenant to said missions, with " the exception only of those small pieces of ground which have always been occupied by some Indians of the missions ;" likewise to include the buildings, saving the churches and their appurtenances, and the curate's, municipal and school-houses, and except in the mission of Santa Barbara, where the whole of the principal edifice should be reserved for the bishop and the priests residing there. The renting of the missions of San Diego, San Luis Rey, San Gabriel, San Antonio, Santa Clara and San Jose', it was further announced should take place as soon as some arrangement was made concerning their debts. It was also provided that the neophytes should be free from their pupilage, and might "establish themselves on convenient parts of the missions, with liberty to serve the rentee, or any other person ; that the Indians who possessed pieces of land, in which they had made their houses and gardens, should apply to the government for titles, in order that their lands might be adjudicated them in ownership, " it being understood that they would not have power to sell their lands, but that they should descend by inheritance."
1. Authorizing the Governor, in order to make effective the object of the decree of 28th May previous, to operate, as he should believe most expedient, to prevent the total ruin of the missions of San Gabriel, San Luis Rey, San Diego and others found in like circumstances.
2. That as the remains of said establishments had large debts against them, if the existing property was not sufficient to cover the same, they might be put into bankruptcy.
3. That if, from this authorization, the Governor, in order to avoid the destouction to which the said missions were approaching, should determine to sell them to private persons, the sale should be by public auction.
4. That when sold, if, after the debts were satisfied, there should be any remainder, it should be distributed to the Indians of the respective establishments.
5. That in view of the expenses necessary in the maintenance of the priest, and of Divine worship, the Governor might determine a portion of the whole property, whether of cultivable lands, houses, or any other description, according to his discretion, and by consultation with the respective priests.
6. The property thus determined should be delivered as by sale, but subject to a perpetual interest of four per cent, for the uses above indicated.
7. That the present Act should not affect anything already done, or contracts made in pursuance of the decree of 28th May last, nor prevent anything heing done conformable to that decree.
8. That the Governor should provide against all impediments that might not be foreseen by the Act, and in six months, at farthest, give an account to the Assembly of the results of its fulfilment.
Previous to several of the last-mentioned acts, that is on August 24, 1844, the Departmental Assembly, in anticipation of a war breaking out, passed a law authorizing the Governor, on the happening of that contingency, either " to sell, hypothecate, or rent, the houses, landed property and field lands of the missions, comprehended in the whole extent of the country from San Diego to Sonoma," except that of Santa Barbara, " reserved for the residence of the bishop."
These comprise all the general acts of the authorities of California which I was able to meet with on the subject of missions. Of the extent or manner in which they were carried into execution, so far as the missions proper - that is, the mission buildings and lands appurtenant - are concerned, but little information is afforded by what I could find in the archives. A very considerable part, however, of the grants made since the secularization of 1833 (comprising the bulk of all the grants in the country) are lands previously recognized as appurtenances of the missions, and so used as grazing farms, or for other purposes. In some cases the petitions for such grants were referred to the principal priest at the mission to which the land petitioned for was attached, and his opinion taken whether the grant could be made without prejudice to the mission. In other cases, and generally, this formality was not observed. This remark relates to the farms and grazing grounds (ranchos) occupied by the missions, and some titles to Indians, pursuant to the regulation of Governor Figueroa, and the proclamation of Governor Pico, on record in the file of expedientes of grants before noticed. '
What I have been able to gather from the meager records and memoranda in the archives, and from private information and examination of the actual state of the missions, is given below. It is necessary to explain, however, still farther than I have, that in speaking of the missions now, we cannot understand the great establishments which they were. Since 1833, and even before, farms of great (many leagues) extent, and many of them, have reduced the limits they enjoyed, in all cases very greatly, and in some instances into a narrow compass ; and while their borders have been thus cut off, their planting and other grounds inside are dotted to a greater or less extent by private grants. The extent to which this has been the case can only be ascertained by the same process that is necessary everywhere in California, to separate public from private lands - namely, authorized surveys of the grants according to their calls, which though not definite, will almost always furnish some distinguishable natural object to guide the surveyor.* The actual condition of the establishments, understanding them in the reduced sense above shown, was, at the time the Mexican Government ceased in California, and according to the best information I could obtain, as follows :
Where Situated
The information above given concerning the condition of the missions at the time of the cessation of the former Government is partly obtained from documents in the archives, and partly from private sources. What is to be traced in the archives is on loose sheets of paper, liable to be lost, and parts quite likely have been lost; there may be some papers concerning them which, in the mass of documents, escaped my examination. I have no doubt, however, of the exactness of the statement above given as far as it goes.
It will be seen, then, that the missions - the principal part of their lands cut off by private grants, but still, no doubt, each embracing a considerable tract - perhaps from one to ten leagues - -have, some of them, been sold or granted under the former Government, and become private property ; some converted into villages, and consequently granted in the usual form in lots to individuals and heads of families; a part are in the hands of rentees, and at the disposal of the Government when these contracts expire, and the remainder at its present disposal.
* I was told by Major J. E. Snyder, the gentleman appointed Territorial Surveyor by Colonel Mason, and who made surveys of a number of grants in the central part of the country, that he had little difficulty in following tha calls and ascertaining the bounds of the grants.
If it were within my province to suggest what would be an equitable disposition of such of the missions as remain the property of the Government, I should say that the churches with all the church property and ornaments, a portion of the principal building for the residence of the priest, with a piece of land equal to that designated in the original Act of the Mexican Congress for their secularization (to wit, two hundred varas square), with another piece for a cemetery, should be granted to the respective Catholic parishes for the uses specified, and the remainder of the buildings with portions of land attached, for schools and municipal or county purposes, and for the residence of the bishop ; the same allotment at the mission of Santa Barbara that was made in the last proclamation of Governor Pico. The churches, certainly ought not to be appropriated to any other use, and less than the inhabitants have always considered and enjoyed as their right.
To conclude the inquiry in the last portion of your letter of instructions, namely, concerning " large grants " other than the supposed ecclesiastical grants.
I did not find in the archives of California any record of large grants in the sense I suppose the term to be here used. There are a number of grants to the full extent of the privilege accorded by law to individual concessions and of the authority of the local government to make independent of the Central Government - to wit, of eleven sitios, or leagues square.
There are understood in the country, however, to be large claims reputed to be founded on grants direct from the Mexican Government - one held by Captain Sutter ; another by General Vallejo. The archives (as far as I could discover) only show that Captain Sutter received July 18, 1841, from Governor Alvarado, the usual grant of eleven sitios on the Sacramento river, and this is all I ascertained. The archives likewise show that General Vallejo received from Governor Micheltorena, October 22, 1823, a grant of ten sitios called " Petaluma," in the district of Sonoma ; and I was informed by a respectable gentleman in California, that General Vallejo had likewise a grant from the Mexican Government, given for valuable consideration, of a large tract known by the name of " Suscol," and including the site of the present town of Benicia, founded by Messrs. Vallejo and Semple, on the Straits of Carquinez. It is also reputed that the same gentleman has extensive claims in the valley of Sonoma and on Suisun bay. It appears from documents which General Vallejo caused to be published in the newspapers of California in 1847, that he was deputed in the year 1835, by General Figueroa, to found a settlement in the valley of Sonoma, " with the object of arresting the progress of the Bussian settlements of Bodega and Boss." General Vallejo was at that time (1835), military commander of the northern frontier. He afterwards (in 1836), by virtue of a revolution which occurred in that year in California, became military commandant of the department - the civil and military government being by the same act divided - to which office he was confirmed in 1838 by the Supreme Government.
The following extract from Governor Figueroa's instructions to him will show the extent of General Vallejo's powers as agent for colonizing the north :
" You are empowered to solicit families in all the territory and other States of the Mexican Republic, in order to colonize the northern frontiers, granting lands to all persons who may wish to establish themselves there, and those grants shall be confirmed to them by the Territorial (government, whenever the grantees shall apply therefor ; the title which they obtain from you serving them in the meantime as a sufficient guarantee, as you are the only individual authorized by the superior authority to concede lands in the frontier under your charge. The Supreme Government of the territory is convinced that you are the only officer to whom so great an enterprise can be entrusted, and, in order that it may be accomplished in a certain manner, it is willing to defray the necessary expenses to that end."
An official letter to General Vallejo from the Department of War and Marine, dated Mexico, August 5, 1839, expresses approbation of what had thitherto been done in establishing the colony, and the desire that the settlements should continue to increase " until they should be so strong as to be respected not only by the Indian tribes, but also by the establishments of the foreigners who should attempt to invade that valuable region."
I did not find any trace of these documents;jor of anything concerning General Vallejo's appointment or operations, in the Government archives. But there is no reason to doubt the genuineness of the papers. They do not, however, convey any title to lands beyond authority to grant during the time his appointment continued to actual colonizers. The appointment of General Vallejo seems to have been made by direction of the Supreme (National) Government. I had no means of ascertaining how long the appointment lasted, nor to what extent its powers were used ; but infer from Vallejo himself taking a grant of his rancho of Petaluma, in 1843, that his own authority in that respect had then ceased. As there are other grants also of considerable extent in the same neighborhood embraced in the Government archives, I apprehend that most, if not all of the grants made by him, exclusive of what may be embraced in the town privileges of Sonoma (and which will be noticed hereafter), were confirmed or regranted to the parties by the departmental government. In this view, however, I may be mistaken. And I desire to be distinctly understood as not intending to throw any doubt or discredit on the titles or claims of either of the gentlemen I have mentioned. I had no opportunity of inspecting any grants they may possess, beyond what I have stated, and I imagine their lands can only be separated from the domain by the process universally requisite - the registration of outstanding grants and their survey.
The Public, Etc
The only points of special public importance which I learned were granted prior to the cessation of the former government, are the site of the old fort of San Joaquin, near the outlet of the Bay of San Francisco, and Alcatraz (or Bird) Island, commanding its entrance, the Key of the Golden Gate. The date of the first named grant is June 25, 1846 ; it was made to Benito Diaz, and by him transferred to Mr. T. 0. Larkin of Monterey. I understand a portion of the land embraced in the grant is in occupation of the United States troops, or has property of the United States upon it, and a part in possession of Mr. Larkin.
Alcatraz Island was granted in June, 1846, to Mr. Francis P. Temple, of Los Angeles. The indispensableness of this point to the Government, both for the purpose of fortification, and as a proper position for a light-house, induced Lieut-Col. Fremont, when Governor of California, to contract for the purchase of it on behalf of the United States. The Government, it is believed, has never confirmed the purchase, nor paid the consideration. This island is a solid rock, of about a half-a-mile in circumference, rising out of the sea just in front of the inner extremity of the throat or narrows which forms the entrance to the bay, and perfectly commands both front and sides. It is also in the line of the sailing directions for entering the bay * and consequently a light-house upon it is indispensable.
The local government had special authority and instructions from the general government, under date of July 12, 1838, to grant and distribute lands in " the desert islands adjacent to that department."
Whether the grants "purport to he inchoate or perfect ?" The grants made in that department under the Mexican law, all, I believe, purport to be perfect, except in the respect of requiring " confirmation by the departmental assembly." The difficulties of determining what grants have not received this confirmation have been above explained.
IV. If there BE ANY ALLEGED GRANTS of LANDS COVERING A PORTION OF THE GOLD MINES, AND WHETHER IN ALL GRANTS IN GENERAL (UNDER THE MEXICAN GOVERNMENT,) OR IN CALIFORNIA IN PARTICULAR, THERE ARE NOT CONDITIONS AND LIMITATIONS, AND WHETHER THERE IS NOT A RESERVATION OF MINES OF GOLD AND SILVER, AND A SIMILAR RESERVATION AS TO QUICKSILVER AND OTHER MINERALS ?
There is but one grant that I could learn of which covers any portion of the gold mines. Previous to the occupation of the country by the Americans, the parts now known as The Gold region, were infested with wild
Indians, and no attempts made to settle there. The grant that I refer to was made by Governor Micheltorena, to Juan B. Alvai-ado, in February, 1844, and is called the Mariposas, being situated on the Mariposa creek, and between the Sierra Nevadas and the river Joaquin, and comprises ten sitios, or leagues square, conceded, as the grant expresses, " in consideration of the public services " of the grantee. It was purchased from the grantee (Alvarado) in February, 1847, by Thomas O. Larkin, Esq., for Mr. J. C. Fremont, and is now owned by that gentleman.
The only "conditions or limitations" contained in the grants in California which could effect the validity of the title, are, that in the grants made by some of the governors, a period of time (one year) was fixed, within which the grantees should commence improvements on the grant. In case of failure, however, the grant was not thereby void, but open to denouncement by other persons. This limitation was not contained in such of the grants made in the time of Micheltorena, as I have examined, nor is it prescribed by law. No doubt, however, the condition was fulfilled in most instances where it was inserted, unless in a few cases where the lands conceded were in parts of the country infested by the wild Indians, and its fulfilment consequently impossible. In fact, as far as I understood, it was more customary to occupy the land in anticipation of the grant. The grants were generally for actual (immediate) occupation and use.
i. cannot find in the Mexican laws or regulations for colonization, or the granting of lands, anything that looks to a reservation of the mines of gold or silver, quicksilver or other metal or mineral ; and there is not any such thing expressed in any of the many grants that came under my inspection. I inquired and examined also, while in Mexico, to this point, and could not learn that such reservations were the practice, either in general or in California in particular.
V. In all large grants, or grants of important or valuable sites, OR of mines, whether or not they were surveyed and occupied UNDER THE GOVERNMENT OF SPAIN OR MEXICO, AND WHEN PUBLICITY WAS FIRST GIVEN TO SUCH GRANTS ?
The first part of this inquiry is already answered, in the statement that, as far as I am aware, there were never any surveys made in the country during its occupation by either of the former governments. Most of the grants, however, were occupied before, or shortly after they were made, and all, as far as I am informed, except where the hostile Indian occupation prevented. In respect of the grants to which I have made any reference, I did not learn that there had been any delay in giving publicity to them.
Having met, sir, as far as in my power, the several inquiries set forth in the letter of instructions you were pleased to honor me with, my attention was turned, as far as they were not already answered, to the more detailed points of examination furnished me, with your approbation, by the Commissioner of Public Lands. The very minute information contemplated by those instructions, it would have been impossible, as you justly anticipated, to obtain in the brief time proposed for my absence, even had it been accessible, in systematic archives and records. My examination, moreover, was sufficient to show me that such minute and exact information on many of the various heads proposed, is not attainable at all ; and that the only mode of approximating it must be through such measures as will produce a general registration of written titles, and verbal proof of possession where written titles are wanting, followed or accompanied by a general survey. By such means only can an approximation be made to the minute information sought of the character, extent, position and date, particularly of the old grants in California.
The first branch of the inquiries proposed by the instructions from the Land Office, relate to " grants or claims derived from the Government of Spain."
The chief local authority to grant lands in the province of California was, ex officio, the military commandant, who was likewise Governor of the province ; and the principal recipients of grants, officers and soldiers as they retired from service. The grants to the soldiers were principally of lots in and about the presidios (military posts) or the pueblos (villages) ; to the officers, farms and grazing lands in addition to such lots.
There were, also, at different times, settlers brought from Sonora and other provinces of New Spain (single men and families), and grants made to them ; usually of village lots, and to the principal men ranchos in addition. The first settlement at San Francisco was thus made; that is, settlers accompanied the expedition thither, and combined with the military post. The pueblos of San Jose and Los Angeles were thus formed. The Governor made grants to the retired officers under the general colonization laws of Spain, but, as in all the remote provinces, much at his own discretion. He had likewise special authority to encourage the population of the country by making grants of farming lots to soldiers who should marry the native bred women at the missions. The captains of the presidios were likewise authorized to make grants within the distance of two leagues, measuring to the cardinal points from their respective posts. Hence, the presidios became in fact villages. The Viceroy of New Spain had also, of course, authority to make grants in California, and sometimes exercised it. It was pursuant to his order that presidios, missions and pueblos were severally established, and the places for them indicated by the local authority. Under all these authorities, grants were made ; strictness of written law required that they should have been made by exact measurements, with written titles, and a record of them kept. In the rude and uncultivated state of the country that then existed, and lands possessing so little value, these formal- ities were to a great extent disregarded, and if not then altogether disregarded, the evidence of their observance in many cases was lost. It is certain that the measurements even of the grants of village lots were very unexact and imperfect ; and of larger tracts, such as were granted to the principal men, no measurement at all attempted, and even the quantity not always expressed, the sole description often being by a name descriptive, in fact or by repute, of the place granted. The law of custom, with the acquiescence of the highest authorities, overcame in these respects the written law. Written permits and grants were no doubt usually given, but if any systematic records or memoranda of them were kept, they have now disappeared, or I was not able to meet with them. In some cases, but not in all, the originals no doubt still exist in the possession of the descendants of the grantees ; indeed, I have been assured there are many old written titles in the country, of which the archives do not contain any trace. But in other cases, no doubt, the titles rested originally only on verbal permits. It was very customary in the Spanish colonies for the principal neighborhood authorities to give permission to occupy and cultivate lands, with the understanding that the party interested would afterward, at a convenient occasion, obtain his grant from the functionary above. Under these circumstances, the grant was seldom refused, but the application for it was very often neglected ; the title by permission being entirely good for the purposes of occupation and use, and never questioned by the neighbors. All these titles, whatever their original character, have been respected during the twenty-six or twenty-seven years of Mexican and local government. And whether evidenced now or ever by any written title, they constitute as meritorious and just claims as property is held by in any part of the world. They were, in the first place, the meager rewards for expatriation and arduous and hazardous public service in a remote and savage country. They are now the inheritance of the descendants of the first settlers of the country, and who redeemed it from (almost the lowest stage of) barbarism. Abstractly considered, there cannot be any higher title to the soil.
Many of the holders of old grants have taken the precaution to have them renewed, with a designation of boundary and quantity, under the forms of the Mexican law ; and of these the proper records exist in the archives. To what extent old titles have been thus renewed, could not be ascertained, for the reason that there is no record of the old titles by which to make the comparison.
The principal difficulty that must attend the separation of the old grants from the public lands, or rather, to ascertain what is public domain and what private property, in the parts where those old grants are situate, is in the loose designation of their limits and extent. The only way that presents itself of avoiding this difficulty, and of doing justice both to the claimant and the government, would seem to be in receiving with respect to tne old grants, verbal testimony of occupation and of commonly reputed boundaries, and thereby, with due consideration of the laws and principles on which the grants were made, governing the surveys.
The military commandant or governor had authority, by virtue of his office, to make grants. He had, also, especial authority and direction to do so, in a letter of instructions from the Viceroy, August 17, 1773, and entitled " Instructions to be observed by the commandant appointed to the new establishments of San Diego and Monterey." These instructions authorized (as already noticed) the allotment of lands to Indians, either in community or individually ; but it is to be understood only of Indians who should be in charge of the missions, and of the parcels of land within the mission settlements. Article thirteen gave the commandant " equal authority, likewise, to distribute lands to other settlers, according to their merit and comformably to the compilation of laws concerning new conquests and settlements." That is, according to the compilation of the " Laws of the Indias," which we know make certain provisions of the most liberal character for the founding and encouragement of new populations.
Subsequently, without abrogating the general colonial laws, a special Regulation was adopted, with the royal assent, for the government of the Californias, and making special provision for the settlement of that province, and the encouragement of the colonizers. This regulation was drawn in Monterey, by Governor Don Felipe Neve, in 1779, and confirmed by a Royal cedula of October 14, 1781. Its character and objects are shown in its title, namely " Rules and directions for the Presidios of the Peninsula of California, erection of new Missions, and encouragement of the Population, and extension of the establishments of Monterey." The first thirteen articles relate to the presidios and military. Title fourteen relates to the " Political Government and directions for Peopling." After providing liberal bonuses to new settlers in respect of money, cattle, and exemptions from various duties and burthens, this Regulation prescribes : That the solares (house lots) which shall be granted to the new settlers, shall be designated by the Governor in the places, and with the extent that the tract chosen for the new settlement will allow, and in such manner that they shall form a square, with streets conformably to the laws of the kingdom ; and by the same rule shall be designated common lands for the pueblos, with pasturage and fields for municipal purposes (propios). That each stierte (out-lot), both of irrigable and unirrigable land, shall be two hundred varas square ; and of these suertes, four (two watered and two dry) shall be given with the solar, or house lot, in the name of the King, to each settler.
These rules relate to the formation of villages and farming settlements, and are exclusive of the extensive ranchos - farms and grazing lands - allotted to persons of larger claims or means, sometimes direct from the Viceroy, usually by the local Governor.
The acts of the Spanish Cortes, in 1813, heretofore quoted, may also be referred to as a part of the authority under which grants might be made in California during the continuance of the Spanish Government and prior to the colonization laws of Mexico, and afterwards, indeed, as far as not superceded by those laws.
The second point of inquiry in the instructions furnished me from the Land Office, relating to grants made under the Mexican Government, is already met in most respects, as far as was in my power to meet it, in the early part of this report. The " authority of the granting officers, and their powers for alienating the public domain," were derived from appointment by the Central Government, and from the general colonization laws and regulations of the Republic. There is little room for discrimination between such as are perfect titles and such as are inceptive and inchoate. A grant by the territorial or (departmental) governors within the extent of eleven sitios constituted a valid title, and with the approbation of the Departmental Assembly, a perfect one. After the Governor's concession, however, it could not with propriety be termed merely inceptive, for, in fact, it was complete until the Legislature should refuse its approbation, and then it would be the duty of the Governor to appeal for the claimant to the Supreme Government. I am not aware that a case of this kind arose. The difficulties, already explained, of ascertaining to what grants the legislative approbation was accorded, and from what it was withheld, the impossibility, in fact, of ascertaining in many cases, coupled with the fact that that approbation was so seldom refused, and that the party had still an appeal in case of refusal, would seem to render that provision of the law of those grants nugatory as a test of their merits.
The third inquiry touching " grants made about the time of the revolutionary movements in California, say in the months of June and July, 1846," is chiefly answered in what is said concerning the actual condition of the missions, and the grants of Fort Joaquin, at the mouth, and Alcatraz Island, inside the entrance of the Bay of San Francisco. In addition to these, the large island of San Clemente, I understood, was granted about that time, say in May, 1846. I found nothing in the archives concerning it. I do not think there were other grants to attract particular attention, except the proposed great Macnamara grant or contract, of which the principal papers are on file in the State Department, and have been printed in the Congressional Documents.
In the second branch of the last mentioned inquiry, namely, concerning any "grants made subsequent to the war," I suppose the intent is, grants, if any, made after the reduction of the country by the arms of the United States. There are, of course, no Mexican grants by the Mexican authorities which purport to have been issued subsequent to that time. The inquiry must relate, therefore, either to supposed simulated grants, by persons formerly in authority there, or to whatever may have been done, in respect of the domain, by or under the American authorities. It is believed in the country that there are some simulated grants in existence ; that is, some papers purporting to be grants which have been issued since the cessation of the Mexican Government, by persons who formerly, at different times, had the faculty of making grants in that country. It would be impossible, however, to make a list of them, with the particulars enumerated in the instructions ; for, if there be any such, they would, of course, not be submitted for public inspection, or in any way seek the light. But I believe it would not be difficult for a person skilled in the grants in that country, and acquainted with the archives and the facts to be gathered from them, to detect any simulated paper that might be thus issued after the person issuing it had ceased from his office. The test, however, would necessarily have to be applied to each case as it arose. No general rule, I believe, can be laid down.
Recurring, then, to the other point which I suppose the inquiry to relate to. The most considerable act, affecting the domain, had subsequent to the accession of the American authorities in California, was a " decree " made by General Kearny, as Governor, under date March 10, 1847, as ' follows :
" I, Brigadier-General S. W. Kearny, Governor of California, by virtue of authority in me vested by the President of the United States of America, do hereby grant, convey and release unto the town of San Francisco, the people, or corporate authorities thereof, all the right, title and interest of the Government of the United States, and of the Territory of California, in and to the beach and water lots on the east front of said town of San Francisco, included between the points known as Rincon and Fort Montgomery, excepting such lots as may be selected for the use of the United States Government by the senior officers of the army and navy now there ; provided the said ground hereb3r ceded shall be divided into lots, and sold by public auction to the highest bidder, after three months' notice previously given ; the proceeds of said sale to be for the benefit of the town of San Francisco."
Pursuant to the terms of this paper, what are termed " government reservations " were made, both within and outside the limits specified, and the remainder of the lots designated have been since in great part sold by the town of San Francisco. These lots extend into the shallow water along the beach of San Francisco, and are very suitable and requisite for the business purposes of that growing city. The number of four hundred and forty-four of them were sold in the Summer ensuing the " decree," and in December last, I have learned since my return, the remainder, or a large portion of them, were disposed of by the corporation. But little public use has been made of what are denominated the " government reservations."
Portions of them are reputed to be covered by old grants ; portions have been settled on and occupied by way of pre-emption, and other portions, particularly " Rincon Point," have been rented out, as I am informed, to individuals, by the late military government.
Under the above decree of General Keai-ny, and the consequent acts of the authorities of San Francisco, such multiplied, diversified and important private interests have arisen, that, at this late day, no good, but immense mischief would result from disturbing them. The city has derived a large amount of revenue from the sale of the lots ; the lots have been re-sold and transferred in every variety of way, and passed through many hands, and on many of them costly and permanent improvements have been made ; improvements required by the business and wants of the community, and which ought to give the makers of them an equitable interest in the land, even without the faith of the Government implied by leaving the act of its agent so long unquestioned. An Act of Congress, relinquishing thus in the lawful mode the interest of the United States in those beach and water lots, would seem to be only an act of justice to the city and to lot-holders, and to be necessary to give that validity and confidence that ought to attach to property of such great value and commercial importance.
In regard to the " government reservations," so called where they may be in private hands, whether under a former grant, or by occupancy and improvement, the same equity would seem to call for at least a pre-emption right to be allowed the holders, except for such small parts as may be actually required for public uses. In regard to the places known as " Clark's Point," and " Rincon Point," which are outside of the land embraced in General Kearny's decree, and portions of which it is understood have been put in the hands of rentees ; perhaps the most equitable use that could be made of them (except, as before, the parts needed for public uses), would be to relinquish them to the city, to be sold as the beach and water lots have been ; with due regard, at the same time, to rights accruing from valuable improvements that may have been made upon them, but repressing a monopoly of property so extensive and valuable, and so necessary to the improvement, business and growth of the city.
Other operations in lands which had not been reduced to private property at the time of the cessation of the former government have taken place in and about different towns and villages, by the alcaldes and other municipal authorities continuing to make grants of lots and out-lots, more or less according to the mode of the former government. This, I understand, has been done, under the supposition of a right to the lands granted, existing in the respective towns and corporations. Transactions of this nature have been to a very large extent at San Francisco ; several hundred in-lots of fifty varas square, and out-lots of one hundred varas square, have been thus disposed of by the successive alcaldes of the place since the occupation of it by the American forces, both those appointed by the naval and military commanders, and those subsequently chosen by the inhabitants.
It is undoubtedly conformable to the Spanish colonial laws, that when villages were to be established, there should be liberal allotments to the first settlers, with commons for general use, and municipal lands (propios) for the support and extension of the place - that is, to be rented, or otherwise transferred, subject to a tax ; and that the principal magistrate, in conjunction with the aymitamiento, or town council, should have the disposal of those town liberties, under the restrictions of law, for the benefit of the place, and the same was the practice in California, under the Mexican Government. It is not always so easy to determine within what limits this authority might be exercised ; but in new communities, whether the settlement was founded by an empresario (contractor) or by the government, the allotments were always on a liberal scale, both for the individuals and the village. A very early law (law 6, tit. 3, lib. 4, Recop. de Indias) fixes " four leagues of limits and land {de termino y terntorio) in square or prolonged, according to the nature of the tract," for a settlement of thirty families ; and I suppose this is as small a tract as has usually been set apart for village uses and liberties, under the Spanish or Mexican Government in New Spain ; sometimes much more extensive privileges have no doubt been granted. The instructions of 1773 to the commandant of the new posts, authorizes pueblos to be formed, without specifying their limits, which would, of course, bring them under the general law of four leagues.
The Royal Regulation of 1781, for the Californias, directs suitable municipal allotments to be made, "conformable to the law;" and this likewise must refer to the law specifying four leagues square.
The letter of instructions of 1791, authorizing the captains of presidios to make grants, in the neighborhood of their respective posts, specifies the same quantity, to wit : " the extent of four common leagues, measured from the center of the presidio square, two leagues in each direction, as sufficient for the new pueblos to be formed under the protection of the presidios."
The Mexican laws, as far as I am aware, make no change in this rule ; and the colonization regulations of 1828, provide (Art. 13) that the reunion of many families into a town shall follow in its formation, policy, etc., the rule established by the existing laws for the other towns of the Republic."
From all these, and other acts which might be quoted, it would seem that where no special grant has been made, or limits assigned to a village, the common extent of four leagues would apply to it ; it being understood, however, as the same law expresses, that the allotment should not interfere with the rights of other parties. The presidio settlements, under the order of 1791, were certainly entitled to their four leagues ; the right of making grants within the same only transferred from the presidio captains to the municipal authorities who succeeded him, as is conformable to Spanish and Mexican law and custom. This was the case under the Spanish Government ; and I am not aware that the principle has been changed, though no doubt grants have been made to individuals which infringed on such village limits. The Territorial Deputation of California, however, by an act of August 6, 1834, directed that the ayuntamientos of the pueblos should " make application for common and municipal lands (ejiclos y propios) to be assigned them." Wherever it shall appear that this was done, the town, I suppose, could only now claim what was then set apart for it. Where it was omitted or neglected, custom, reputed limits, and the old law, would seem to be a safe rule.
As to the point now under consideration, that of San Francisco, I find that in the acts of the Departmental authorities the settlements in and about the presidio were styled " the pueblo of San Francisco," and the particular place where the village principally was and the city now is, " the point of Yerba Buena." The local authorities, as its alcalde, or justice of the peace, were termed those of the pueblo of San Francisco. Its privileges were not, therefore, at any time limited to the point of Yerba Buena. Originally, probably, it had boundaries in common with the mission of Dolores, which would restrict it in its four leagues ; but after the conversion of the mission into a pueblo, the jurisdiction of the authorities of San Francisco was extended, and special license given to its principal magistrate to grant lots at the mission. San Francisco is situated on a tongue or neck of land lying between the bay and the sea, increasing in breadth in a southerly direction. A measurement of four leagues south from the presidios would give the city, in the present advanced value of property, a magnificent corporate domain, but not so much as was fairly assignable to the precincts of the presidio under the order of 1791, nor so much as all new pueblos are entitled to under the general laws of the Indias. There are private rights, however, existing within those limits, apart from any grants of the village authorities, which ought to be respected ; some through grants from the former government ; some by location and improvement, a claim, both under our own law and custom and under the Spanish law, entitled to respect. To avoid the confusion - the destruction - that would grow out of the disturbing of the multiplied and vast interests that have arisen under the acts of the American authorities at San Francisco ; to give the city what she would certainly have been entitled to by the terms of the old law, what she will need for the public improvements and adornments that her future population will require, and what is well due to the enterprise which has founded in so brief a space a great metropolis in that remote region, perhaps no better or juster measure could be suggested than a confirmation of past acts, a release of government claims to the extent of four leagues, measuring south from the presidio, and including all between sea and bay, with suitable provision for protecting private rights, whether under old grants or by recent improvements, and reserving such sites as the government uses may require.
By the authorities of the village of San Jose, there have been still larger operations in the lands belonging, or supposed to belong, to the liberties of that town. The outlands there, as I learned, have been distributed in tracts of three to five hundred acres.
The pueblo of San Jose" was founded November 7, 1777. by order of Felipe de Neve, then military commandant and governor. The first settlers were nine soldiers and five laboring men or farmers, who went thither with cattle, tools, etc., from San Fi-ancisco, where had been established the year before, by order of the Viceroy, the presidio and the mission of Dolores. These persons took possession, and made their settlement " in the name of his Majesty, making out the square for the erection of the houses, distributing the solares (house lots) and measuring to each settler a piece of ground for the sowing of a fanega of maize (two hundred varas by four hundred), and for beans and other vegetables.* Subsequently, the Regulation of 1781, allowing to the new settlers each four lots of two hundred varas square, besides their house lots, was no doubt applied to this village. It was designed for an agricultural settlement, and, together with the pueblo of the south (Los Angeles), received constantly the favor and encouragement of the government, with the view of having sufficient agricultural produce raised for the supply of the military posts. Both villages are situated in fertile plains, selected for their sites with that object. In a report or information, made by the Governor, Don Pedro Fages, in February, 1791, to his successor, Governor Romeu, the encouragement of the two pueblos is the first topic referred to :
1. " Being (says Governor Fages) one of the objects of greatest consideration, the encouragement of the two pueblos of civilized people, which have been established, the superior government has determined to encourage them with all possible aids, domiciliating in them soldiers who retire from the presidios, and by this means enlarging the settlement.
2. " By the superior order of April 27, 1784, it is ordered that the grains and other produce, which the presidios receive from the inhabitants of the two pueblos, shall be paid for in money, or such goods and effects as the inhabitants have need of.
3. " The distribution of lots of land, and house lots, made with all possible requisite formalities, with designation of town liberties, and other lands for the common advantage, as likewise titles of ownership given to the inhabitants, were approved by the Senor Commandante General, the 6th February of the present year of 1784."
James Gay
There are also records of families being brought at the government expense, from the province of Sonora, specially to people the two pueblos. Both these villages - being thus objects of government favor and encouragement - claim to have been founded with more extensive privileges than the ordinary village limits ; and I have no doubt, from the information I received, that such was the case.
The village of San Jos6 had a dispute of boundary as early as the year 1S00, with the adjoining mission of Santa Clara, and which was referred the following year to the Government of Mexico. The fact is noted in the index to California papers in the Mexican archives, but I did not find the corresponding record. There is likewise in the book of records marked " 1828," in the archives at Monterey, an outline of the boundaries claimed by the pueblo at that time. But at a later period (in 1834, I believe), there was legislative action upon the subject, in which, as I understand, the boundaries were fully agreed upon. Some documents relating to this settlement are in the archives at San Jose, and also in the territorial archives. My time did not permit me to make a full investigation of the question of those boundaries, nor did I think it necessary, because, at all events, they can only be definitely settled by a survey, the same as private estates. My instructions, however, call for a discrimination between acts done " with legal formalities," and such as are " without legal sanction." It is therefore proper for me to say that I do not know of any law which would authorize the distribution of town property in California in lots measured by hundreds of acres ; such distribution, in fact, would seem rather to defeat the ends for which town grants are authorized by the Spanish law. Perhaps an act to authorize the limits of the town to be ascertained by survey, and to leave the question of the validity of those recent large grants within the limits of the same, to be determined between the holders, and the town in its corporate capacity, would be as just and expedient as any other mode.
In and about the town of Monterey, likewise, there were large concessions, as I understood, and some including the sites of forts and public places, made by the magistrate appointed there after the accession of the American authority. The limits of this town, also, I think, depend on an act of the territorial legislature, and may be ascertained by an authorized survey.
The city of Los Angeles is one of the oldest establishments of California, and its prosperity was in the same manner as that of San Jose", an object of Government interest and encouragement. An Act of the Mexican Congress of May 23, 1835, erected it into a city, and established it as the capital of the territory. The limits which, I understood, are claimed as its town privileges, are quite large, but probably no more than it has enjoyed for sixty years, or ever since its foundation. The grants made by this corporation since the cessation of the former government, have been, as far as I learned, quite in conformity with the Spanish law, in tracts such as were always granted for house lots in the village, and vineyards and gardens without, and in no greater number than the increase of population and the municipal wants required.
The only provision that seems to be wanting for the pueblo of Los Angeles is for the survey and definition of its extent, according to its ancient recognized limits. The same remark, as far as I have learned, will apply to the remaining towns of the country, established under either of the former governments.
The remarks made in a previous part of this report in relation to the missions cover to a good degree the substance of that branch of the inquiries proposed by the Commissioner of the Land Bureau. I have already stated that originally the " mission lands " may be said to have been co-extensive with the province, since, nominally, at least, they occupied the whole extent, except the small localities of the presidios, and the part inhabited by the wild Indians, whom and whose territory it was their privilege to enter and reduce. Among the papers accompanying this report is included a transcript of their recorded boundaries, as stated in a record book heretofore noticed. It will be seen from the fact first mentioned of their original occupation of the whole province, and from the vast territories accorded to their occupation, as late as the year 1828, how inconsistent with any considerable peopling of the country would have been any notion of proprietorship in the missionaries.
It is a principle constantly laid down in the Spanish colonial laws, that the Indians shall have a right to as much land as they need for their habitations, for tillage, and for pasturage. Where they were already partially settled in communities, sufficient of the land which they occupied was secured them for those pmposes.* If they were wild and scattered in the mountains and wildernesses, the policy of the law, and of the instructions impressed on the authorities of the distant provinces, was to reduce them, establish them in villages, convert them to Christianity, and instruct them in useful employments.-f- The province of California was not excepted from the operation of this rule. It was for this purpose especially, that the missions were founded and encouraged. The instructions heretofore quoted, given to the commandant of Upper California in August, 1773, enjoin on that functionary, that " the reduction of the Indians in proportion as the spiritual conquests advance, shall be one of his principal cares ;" that the reduction made, " and as rapidly as it proceeds, it is important for their preservation and augmentation, to congregate them in mission settlements, in order that they may be civilized and led to a rational life ;" which (adds the instructions) "is impossible, if they be left to live dispersed in the mountains."
The early laws were so tender of these rights of the Indians, that they forbade the allotment of lands to the Spaniards, and especially the rearing of stock, where it might interfere with the tillage of the Indians. Special directions were also given for the selection of lands for the Indian villages, in places suitable for agriculture and having the necessary wood and water.* The lands set apart to them were likewise inalienable, except by the advice and consent of officers of the government, whose duty it was to protect the natives as minors or pupils.f
Agreeably to the theory and spirit of these laws, the Indians in California were always supposed to have a certain property or interest in the missions. The instructions of 1773 authorized, as we have already seen, the commandant of the province to make grants to the mission Indians of lands of the missions, either in community or individually. But, apart from any direct grant, they have been always reckoned to have had a right of settlement ; and we shall find that all the plans that have been adopted for the secularization of the missions, have contemplated, recognized, and provided for this right. That the plan of Hijar did not recognize or provide for the settlements of Indians, was one of the main objections to it, urged by Governor Figueroa and the territorial deputation. That plan was entirely discomfited ; all the successive ones that were carried into partial execution, placed the Indian right of settlement amongst the first objects to be provided for. We may say, therefore, that, however mal-administration of the law may have destroyed its intent, the law itself has constantly asserted the rights of the Indians to habitations and sufficient fields for their support. The law always intended the Indians of the missions - all of them who remained there - to have homes upon the mission grounds. The same, I think, may be said of the large ranchos - most, or all of which, were formerly mission ranchos - and of the Indian settlements or rancherias upon them. I understand the law to be, that wherever Indian settlements are established, and they till the ground, they have a right of occupancy in the land. This right of occupancy, however - at least when on private estates - is not transferable ; but whenever the Indians abandon it, the title of the owner becomes perfect. Where there is no private ownership over the settlement, as where the land it occupies have been assigned it by a f unctuary of the country thereto authorized, there is a process, as before shown, by which the natives may alien their title. I believe these remarks cover the principles of the Spanish law in regard to Indian settlements, as far as they have been applied in Galfornia, and are conformable to the customary law that has prevailed there.*
The continued observance of this law, and the exercise of the public authority to protect the Indians in their rights under it, cannot, I think, produce any great inconvenience ; while a proper regard for long recognized rights, and a proper sympathy for an unfortunate and unhappy race, would seem to forbid that it should be abrogated, unless for a better. The number of subjugated Indians is now too small, and the lands they occupy too insignificant in amount, for their protection, to the extent of the law, to cause any considerable molestation. Besides there are causes at work by which even the present small number is rapidly diminishing ; so that any question concerning them can be but temporary. In 1834 there were employed in the mission establishments alone the number of thirty thousand six hundred and fifty.f
In 1842, only about eight years after the restraining " and compelling hand of the missionaries had been taken off, their number on the missions had dwindled to four thousand four hundred and fifty, and the process of reduction has been going on as rapidly since.
It is a common opinion that nearly all of what may be called the coast country - that is, the country west of the Sacramento and San Joaquin valleys - which lies south of and including the Sonoma District, has been ceded, and is covered with private grants. If this were the case, it would still leave the extensive valleys of these large rivers and their lateral tributaries almost intact, and a large extent of territory - from three to four degrees of latitude - at the north, attached to the public domain within the State of California, beside the gold region, of unknown extent, along the foot-hills of the Sierra Nevada. But while it may be nominally the case that the greater part of the coast country referred to is covered with grants, my observation and information convince me that when the country shall be surveyed, after leaving to every grantee all that his grant calls for, there will be extensive and valuable tracts remaining. This is explained by the fact that the grants were not made by measurement, but by a loose designation of boundaries, often including a considerably greater extent of land than the quantity expressed in the title ; but the grant usually provides
* Of course, what is here said of the nature of Indian rights does not refer to titles to lots and farming tracts, which have been granted in ownership to individual Indians by the Government. These I suppose to be entitled to the same protection as other private property.
t This is not an estimate, it is an exact, statement. The records of the missions were kept with system and exactness; every birth, marriage. :md death was recorded, and the name of every pupil or neophyte, which is the name by which the mission Indians were known ; and from this record, an annual return was made to the Government of the precise number of Indians collected with the establishment.
that the overplus shall remain to the Government. Although, therefore, the surveys, cutting off all above the quantity expressed in the grant, would often interfere with nominal occupation, I think justice would generally be done by that mode to all the interests concerned - the holders of the grants, the Government, and the wants of the population crowding thither. To avoid the possibility of an injustice, however, and to provide for cases where long occupation or peculiar circumstances may have given parties a title to the extent of their nominal boundaries, and above the quantity expressed in their grants, it would be proper to authorize any one, who should feel himself aggrieved by this operation of the survey, to bring a suit for the remainder.
The grants in California, I am bound to say, are mostly perfect titles; that is, the holders possess their property by titles that, under the law which created them, were equivalent to patents from our Government ; and those which are not perfect - that is, which lack some formality, or some evidence of completeness - have the same equity as those which are perfect, and were and would have been equally respected under the Government which has passed away. Of course, I allude to grants made in good faith, and not to simulated grants, if there be any such, issued since the persons who made them ceased from their functions in that respect.
I think the state of land titles in that country will allow the public lands to be ascertained, and the private lands set apart by judicious measures, with little difficulty. Any measure calculated to discredit, or cause to be distrusted the general character of the titles there, besides the alarm and anxiety which it would create among the ancient population, and among all present holders of property, would, I believe, also retard the substantial improvement of the country ; a title discredited is not destroyed, but every one is afraid to touch it, or at all events to invest labor and money in improvements that rest on a suspected tenure. The holder is afraid to improve ; others are afraid to purchase, or if they do purchase at its discredited value, willing only to make inconsiderable investments upon it. The titles not called in 'question (as they certainly for any reason that I could discover do not deserve to be), the pressure of population and the force of circumstances will soon operate to break up the existing large tracts into farms of such extent as the nature of the country will allow of, and the wants of the community require ; and this under circumstances and with such assurance of tenure as will warrant those substantial improvements that the thrift and prosperity of the country in other respects invite.
I think the rights of the Government will be fully secured, and the interests and permanent prosperity of all classes in that country best consulted, by no other general measure in relation to private property than an authorized survey according to the grants, where the grants are modern, or since the accession of the Mexican Government, reserving the overplus ; or, according to ancient possession, where it dates from the time of the Spanish Government, and the written evidence of the grant is lost, or does not afford data for the survey. But providing that in any case, where from the opinion of the proper law officer or agent of the Government in the State, or from information in any way received, there may be reason to suppose a grant invalid, the Government (or proper officer of it) may direct a suit to be instituted for its annulment.
In glancing at the heading of this chapter we must ask the reader not to indulge in the vain hope that a full history of the grants comprised within the limits of what is known as Contra Costa county will be found ; such, indeed, would be beyond the limits of this work, even had we at hand the infinity of resources to be found in the hundreds of cases which have arisen out of them. Our compilation must of necessity be accepted in its crude form. We have striven to our utmost capacity to produce some information which would combine both usefulness and correctness, and to this end have relied chiefly on the information contained in a legal work, on whose title page is the legend, " Reports of land cases determined in the United States District Court for the Northern District of California, June Term, 1853, to June Term, 1858, inclusive. By Ogden Hoffman, District Judge, San Francisco; Numa Hubert, 1862." The first case we find on page 79, vol. 1 : -
The United States, Appellants, vs. Salvio Pacheco, claiming the Rancho Monte del Diablo. Claim for four leagues of land in Contra Costa county, confirmed by the Board, and appealed by the United States. In this case a grant from Governor Figueroa to the claimant is produced and proved, and evidence is offered to prove the occupation and cultivation of the land within the year, as prescribed in the grant. In the opinion of the Board, the grant is treated as undoubtedly genuine, and the fact of the performance of the conditions as indisputable. No additional testimony has been taken in this Court, nor has any reason for refusing the decree of the Board and rejecting the claim been suggested to us on the part of the appellants. The only objection that could have been raised - viz., the want of judicial possession, and the fact that the land is within the ten littoral leagues, has already repeatedly been overruled. A decree confirming the claim must therefore be entered. (December Term, 1855.)
The United States, Appellants, vs. Joaquin Moraga, claiming the Rancho Laguna cle Polos Coloraclos. - Claim for three leagues of land in Contra Costa county, confirmed by the Board, and appealed by the United States. The claimants in this case petitioned on the thirtieth of August, 1835, for the place called " Laguna de los Palos Colorados." The petition was referred to the Ayuntamiento del Pueblo de S. Jose- Guadalupe, and also to the Rev. Padre, for their reports. On receiving these reports, which were favorable, Jose' Castro, Primero Vocal of the Assembly and Political Chief, ad interim, made his concession on the tenth of October, 1835, and directed that when the Departmental Assembly should have approved the grant, the corresponding title should issue. On the twelfth of October, 1835, the concession was approved, but the " title " does not seem to have issued until the thirtyfirst of July, 1841. All the foregoing facts appear from the expediente on file in the archives of the former Government. The claimants have also produced the original title delivered to them, which bears date on the tenth of August, 1841, to which is attached a map or diseno certified by Jimeno, Secretary of the Government, to be a copy of that accompanying the expediente. The translation of this certificate seems to be omitted. There also accompanies this document the certificate of approval by the Departmental Assembly, and a note or record of an arrangement between Moraga and Candelario Valencia, who seems to have been a colindante or coterminous owner, fixing their common line, and providing for the use in common of an ojo de aqua, or spring of water, which is on the land. The authenticity of all these documents is fully proved, and it is shown that in 1836 the parties went upon the land, built houses, corrals, and placed cattle upon it, and cultivated a considerable portion. The boundaries of the tract are given with some precision in the original grant, and it appears in evidence that the limits of the rancho are well known to those residing in the vicinity. The claim was confirmed by the Board, and we think their decision should be affirmed. (December Term, 1855.)
The United States, Appellants, vs. Joaquin Y. Castro, Administrator of Francisco Maria Castro, deceased, claiming the Rancho San PaWo. - Claim for about four leagues of land in Contra Costa county, confirmed by the Board, and appealed by the United States. This case has been submitted to the Court on appeal without argument or the statement of any objection to its validity. We have, however, as in other cases, examined the transcript, which is unusually voluminous, and have perceived no obstacle to its confirmation. The first application for the land appears to have been made by Don Francisco Castro in 1823, and to have been addressed to the Deputation. On the same day a decree was made granting the place solicited, and directing the Military Commander of the Presidio of San Francisco to put the petitioner in possession. Tltis seems, from various causes, not to have been done, nor does the title to the land appear to have issued to Francisco Castro during his life-time, although, as appears from the expediente, he had gone upon the land, placed cattle upon it, and from time to time solicited of the Governor the formal title. On his death, his son and the administrator of his estate, Joaquin Ysidro Casti-o, petitioned the Governor on the twenty-sixth of May, 1834, for the land occupied by the family, stating it to be three leagues in extent, and annexing to his petition a map of the land solicited. The Governor, after having caused the documents on file in the case of the previous application of Francisco
Castro to be produced, acceded to the petition, and on the twelfth of June, 1834, the formal title issued to the successors of Francisco Castro. In this title the boundaries of the land are mentioned, and reference is made to the map which accompanies the expediente. The extent of the land granted is stated to be three square leagues, more or less. On the twenty-third of June, 1835, Joaquin Ysidro Castro presented another petition to the Governor, in which he states that he had, through inadvertence, neglected to ask for all the land included in the boundaries indicated on the diseno, and he solicited an augmentation of the previous grant so as to include the whole tract designated on the map. By the report of Negrete, the Secretary to whom the Governor referred this petition, it appears that the land comprised within the boundaries refen-ed to had been ascertained to be of the extent of four and one twenty-fourth square leagues. On the fourteenth of August, 1835, the Governor granted to the successors of Francisco Castro the augmentation solicited, and on the twentieth of August, 1835, the formal title was issued for the land, as originally bounded, and in the fourth so called condition of the title the extent of the tract is declared to be " four square leagues and a little over, including the surplus which by the decree of the fourteenth of August of the present year was granted to them, and as shown by the map which accompanies the expediente and already conceded to them." It is this tract of four square leagues and a little over that is now claimed by the appellees. All the above recited facts appear from the expedientes on file. The authenticity of the original documents produced by the interested parties is fully proved, and their long continued occupation and extensive improvements of the land for more than thirty years clearly established. It also appears that the grant was approved by the Departmental Assembly. We are of the opinion therefore that this claim is valid, and that the decision of the Board should be affirmed. (December Term, 1855).
Provenance
Text from History of Contra Costa County, California, Including Its Geography, Geology, Topography, Climatography and Description; Together with a Record of the Mexican Grants ... Also, Incidents of Pioneer Life; and Biographical Sketches of Early and Prominent Settlers and Representative Men .., published 1882, in the public domain in the United States and digitised by the Internet Archive.