This building, commissioned by the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company as small-scale pre-sold speculative housing in the midst of the commercial center of the town, is one of a group of four rowhouses in the Civic Center of Rancho Santa Fe designed by Lilian Rice in emulation of urban residences in Spain. The house has a public (street) facade decorated with iron window grills and heavy wooden gate, and private front patio and back garden. It Is the only one of the four t PART I. rowhouses with its original interior fabric still intact. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: Date of erection: An article by Lilian J. Rice, "More Building in than ever Before," (Rancho Santa Fe Progress vol. 1 no.
7 (January 11, 14) states that in the "group of four residences were built along the west side of Paseo Delicias." A "Completion Report" on the four Paseo Delicias rowhouses, dated April 12, and submitted to each rowhouse owner by L. G. Sinnard of the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company, states: "The Civic Center Cottages, consisting of four dwellings, were constructed by Mr. C. M. Paddock under contract dated July . . . Work on these cottages, hereinafter designated as cottage A, B, C, and D, was begun July 15, and practically completed December 1, (p. 1) Architect: Lilian Jenette Rice 3.
Original and Subsequent Owners: Chain of Ownership taken from Assessment Records, Santa Fe Irrigation District, Rancho Santa Fe, and Property Records, Rancho Santa Fe Association: GLENN AND IDA MAY MOORE ROWHOUSE (Cottage D) HABS No. CA-2303 (Page 2) title to portions lots 17 and 18, Block D owned by Santa Fe Land Improvement Company owned by Glenn A. and Ida May-Moore (sales contract C- owned by Ida May Moore sold by Lundi Moore, trustee, to Paula J. Worstell, Nancy Worstell Palmer, Clarence Palmer, Trustees, Telestock Partnership, 4. Builder, contractor, suppliers: The builder/contractor, as cited in the "Completion Report," was C. M. Paddock, an independent builder in Rancho Santa Fe.
This document does not mention, nor is there any other evidence of, the names of any suppliers or subcontractors who worked on the project, although, under the terms of the contract between the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company and Paddock signed on July 12, subcontracting work was permitted. No information on Paddock has been obtained. 5. Original plans and construction: The original plan of the Moore rowhouse, as documented In the October Architectural Record t (p. far right; copy Included as supplemental material for HABS No. CA-2310), is still extant in It shows a two- bedroom residence, with living room, dining room, kitchen, and bathroom with shower. There are closets in the kitchen (utility), hallway, and north bedroom.
A small covered entryway from the gate on the street facade leads to the front door and opens through an archway on to the front patio. There is also a small open window in the entryway looking on to the patio. This patio, and a back garden beginning beyond a low wall at the end of the patio, occupy the rest of the property. A garage occupies the southwest corner of the lot, facing the alley. Early views of the building can be seen in Rancho Santa Fe Progress vol. 1 no. 12 (June 4, and of the open entryway, Rancho Santa Fe Progress vol. 2 no. 2 (August 6. C. M.
Paddock's original bid for the construction of Cottage "D" was submitted to the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company on June 18, The final cost to the Moores was this sum included of alteration orders specified by the purchasers during construction. 6. Alterations and additions: The replacement of the small porch and steps leading down to the back garden from the kitchen and north bedroom with a larger covered porch is the sole major alteration to the original building. Minor alterations include the covering of the original wood plank kitchen floor with linoleum c. t and the replacement of the original floor heater in the living GLENN AND IDA MAY MOORE ROWHOUSE (Cottage D) HABS No.
CA-2303 (Page 3) room in circa The only addition, which can be dated to circa is the one-room cottage x built just beyond the porch in the back garden by Glenn A. Moore, the original owner, for the use of his son, Lundi, B. Historical context: Among the first residences to be built in Rancho Santa Fe, the Moore rowhouse, like the three others in the row constructed simultaneously, were commissioned by the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company, and designed by its resident architect Lilian Rice, of the San Diego firm Requa and Jackson. The first owners, Glenn A. and Ida May Moore, owned several other parcels of land in Rancho Santa Fe.
From Santa Ana, where Glenn Moore had worked for a landscaping firm, the Moores had moved to Rancho Santa Fe in at the urging of Sidney Nelson, who at that time worked for the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company as assistant project manager. The Company then established Moore as its resident landscape architect; while he ran his own business, his services were available to all those who purchased property in Rancho Santa Fe. (This was the typical relationship between the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company and the professional people whom they brought to Rancho Santa Fe.) At first, the Moores rented a small adobe home at Paseo Delicias, owned by A. B. Harlan, an early investor In the development.
In August when the four rowhouses in the Civic Center were completed, the Moores bought this t building (Santa Fe Land Improvement Company sales contract . Moore was Involved with landscaping various properties, including La Morada (HABS No. CA-2307), the guest house for visitors to Rancho Santa Fe, and the garden and patio of this building as well. His office and nursery were located in the patio of the Administration Building in the Civic Center (HABS no. CA-2306 B). As resident landscape architect, Moore was intimately involved with transforming Rancho Santa Fe from a barren, desert-like setting Into a landscape suitable for habitation and cultivation. However, with the sharp decline in land sales brought on by the Depression, Moore was forced to close his landscaping business.
For a time, he worked in the same profession at a nursery in nearby La Jolla. His wife, who had been his bookkeeper, worked as the Rancho Santa Fe postmistress, and later did freelance secretarial work for Sidney Nelson. Both of the Moores were active in local activities. Glenn Moore held positions in the Rancho Santa Fe Association, and in the early started Rancho Santa Fe's first Boy Scout Troop. Ida May Moore was also active in the Association, as well as in the Golf and Garden Clubs. In Glenn Moore was named manager of the Rancho Santa Fe Golf Course, a position he held until In that year, the Moores divorced, and Glenn Moore left Rancho Santa Fe. Ida May Moore continued to reside in this rowhouse until her death in when it was sold to the present owners.
% GLENN AND IDA MAY MOORE ROWHOUSE (Cottage D) HABS No. CA-2303 (Page 4) PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement: 1. Architectural Character: This rowhouse is one of four designed as a unit by Lilian Rice and built simultaneously in As residential structures fully integrated within the semi-urban core of Rancho Santa Fe, yet architecturally segregated from the neighboring commercial strip through the use of varied setbacks, enclosed patios and gardens, low gable and flat parapet roofs, and decorative ironwork, the rowhouses are a major example of Rice's use of the Spanish vernacular idiom to give variety and character to Rancho Santa Fe's Civic Center. 2. Condition of Fabric: Good. Virtually unaltered. B. Description of Exterior: 1.
Over-all dimensions: This one-story rowhouse, with overall dimensions of 55' x is asymmetrical in plan and facade. It is also the smallest of the four rowhouses on Paseo Delicias in terms of living area. The building features a small front patio and a larger back garden, which occupy about 80 percent of the t property space. In the southwest corner of the complex is a one- car garage, 12' x the entire compound is surrounded by a garden wall. 2. Foundations: 2' high x 1' wide poured concrete perimeter wall with interior piers. 3. Walls: Exterior walls of the structure are frame with stucco; they are generally 8" thick, except on the street facade where they measure 4. Structural system, framing: Wood frame construction, with poured concrete piers embedded in the foundation soil. 5.
Patio, stoops: The front entryway, 6' x 7', opens on to the front patio, 26' x with random stone paving, and landscaped beds on all sides. The original concrete stoop in the back has been covered by the replacement porch. 6. Chimneys: The brick chimney serves the living room fireplace. The chimney stack, centered, rises above the roof line, and is stuccoed white. Construction alteration order #1, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that the "chimney [was to be] built with 4" brick walls instead of 8" walls." The flue was "to be plastered both inside and outside except where exposed to the weather." (p. 21) GLENN AND IDA MAY MOORE ROWHOUSE (Cottage D) HABS No. CA-2303 (Page 5) 7. Openings: a.
Doorways and doors: The entrance gate from the street has a large, heavy, arched tongue-and-groove side-hung plank door with its original iron knocker and decorative iron bolt. The braced, wooden plank alley gate is side-hung and has a metal latch. The front door is tongue-and-groove, side- hung, with original iron latch. Access to the back patio is gained by a four-light french door and exterior screen door from the kitchen, and by a four-light french door (screen door here has been removed) from the north bedroom. Construction alteration order #1, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that the "transom window in bedroom #2 of *D' [was] to be omitted, and a french door --4 lights-4 high and a full screen door to replace it.
French door 4-lights-4-high, and full screen door instead of a stock sash door for the kitchen." (p. 23) b. Windows and shutters: Typical windows are wood-framed single-sash casement with wood sills. Other window types include fixed sash with flanking casements facing the interior patio in the living room, and eight-light french windows facing the street from the living room and dining t room. On the street facade, there are decorative iron grills. Construction alteration order #1 specified that the "windows in the south elevation of the living room [were] to be 4 lights, 4 high." (p. 23) 8. Roof: The roof over the back half of the building is flat with a parapet, covered with built-up roofing. Over the front living room-dining room bay, however, the roof is gabled, with a medium pitch.
There is also a gable roof over the entryway, perpendicular to the main roof, with exposed construction underneath. Here, the left side of the gable extends much further than the right. The gable roofs are covered in red regularly laid Spanish tile. Construction alteration order #2 required the contractor "to use Granada machine-made pan tile on roof in place of hand-made pan tile." (p. 24) Clay tile scuppers project through the parapet wall for drainage, on every facade. On the gable ends there are clay tiles projecting through the exterior wall to the attic space, in order to provide ventilation. 9. Decorative features: Decorative iron lamps on the street wall, inside the front patio, and on the garage wall. Decorative iron window grills on the street facade.
Construction alteration order #4 noted that "exterior front entrance fixtures [were] to be selected by the owner." (p. 28) GLENN AND IDA MAY MOORE ROWHOUSE (Cottage D) HABS No. CA-2303 (Page 6) C. Description of Interior: 1. Floor plans: The living room and the dining room are in the front of the structure, facing Paseo Delicias,- with the kitchen and a small utility closet directly behind. Two bedrooms in the back open into a small hall, which is reached through the living room. 2. Flooring: Narrow board oak, with blue and white ceramic tile in bathroom. Construction alteration order nos. 1 and 4 specified that select oak flooring [and oak toe mold were] to be used in all rooms except the bath, instead of O.P. flooring." (p.
21, 24) Alteration order #7 required the contractor to "add blue floor tile in bathroom as selected by owner." (p, 30) Original flooring has been replaced by colored linoleum in kitchen. There is a patch of tile on the hearth of the fireplace. 3. Wall and ceiling finish: Painted plaster only. Original wooden toe molding in every room except the bath; partially removed in kitchen. Wooden wainscot rail and tile toe molding in bathroom. 4. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: Despite the request made in t construction alteration order #1, that 1 built- up doors, surfaced and chamfered both sides, [be used] instead of stock one-panel doors," (p. 23) the typical door in is one-paneled.
There Is a rounded archway from the living room into the dining room, and a flat archway from the living room to the hallway. There is a one-paneled swinging door from the dining room into the kitchen. Construction alteration order #9 requested that the contractor "change the door in living room to open into hall." (p. 33) b. Windows: Screened on the inside to allow for ventilation. 5. Decorative feature and trim: Built-in wooden bookshelves in the hallway, one on either side of the opening to the living room. Plastered mantelpiece above fireplace. Alteration order #4 specified that there were to be "hand wrought [electric light fixtures] finished with rub finish in the living room, entrance hall, and bedrooms." (p. 28) 6.
Hardware: Original decorative Iron curtain rods: two In living room, one in dining room, two In south bedroom. Alteration order #4 specified that "finish hardware to be stock Western Metal hardware, nickel finish in bath, kitchen and laundry, and sanded brass finish in all other rooms." (p. 28) t GLENN AND IDA MAY MOORE ROWHOUSE (Cottage D) HABS No. CA-2303 (Page 7) 7. Mechanical equipment: a. Heating, ventilation: Original electric heating system still extant; including the wall heater in bathroom. In kitchen above range, ceiling bends upwards to a small vent. The floor furnace in the living room is a ca. replacement. Alteration order #8 specifies the contractor "To build up a 30 gallon full automatic everhot water heater with a watt element. This to be properly insulated." (p- 31) b.
Lighting: Original decorative iron wall sconces: two each in living room, north bedroom, and south bedroom. Alteration order #4 specified that there were to be "hand wrought [electric light fixtures] finished with rub finish in the living room, entrance hall, and bedrooms." (p. 28) c. Plumbing: Original cast iron, two-compartment sink with drainboards in the kitchen; all other plumbing fixtures are modern. Alteration order #1 requested that the contractor install a "shower instead of bath tub in with Speakman Mixometer with china wall plate and swivel china head. Shower to be covered with an approved metal lath and plastered 2 coats of cement plaster troweled to a smooth polished surface. Shower to have a cement floor." (p.
21) Alteration order #2 specified the placement of "a nickel plated curtain rod In shower." (p. 24) d. Other: Kitchen contains all original appliances (except refrigerator), cabinets, and sink. Alteration order #5 requested that the contractor "add cupboards in kitchen of *D' as shown on attached blueprint." (p. 29) Wood-plank box enclosing original electrical meter and panel located on the back wall of the north bedroom. Alteration order #1 "specified that a radio plug was to be installed 'where directed;'" and that a power plug and plate for electric iron In kitchen" and a power plug for refrigerator in kitchen" also be installed, (p.
21) Alteration order #3 specified that the residence was to be wired "for telephones to be installed at a later date;" that the contractor was to "place a double power plug in the dining room instead of a single power plug; place a 110 volt power plug near the radio plug;" and "add a base plug on the west wall of the living room." (p. 26) D. Site: 1. General setting and orientation: The house faces east onto Paseo Delicias, the main street and village center of Rancho Santa Fe; it backs onto an alley which cuts through the block. GLENN AND IDA MAY MOORE ROWHOUSE (Cottage D) HABS No. CA-2303 (Page 8) 2.
Historic landscape design: Although the original landscape design for this property is unknown, it is clear from the reminiscences of Lundi Moore, son of the original owners, that his father, Glenn, who ran a nursery and landscape architecture office in Rancho Santa Fe, reworked a considerable part of the original landscaping to suit his and his family's taste. Lundi Moore's reminiscences are appended to this report as supplemental material. Today, there are still many plantings in the gardens, including grass, palm, cypress, pepper, and other trees. The grill mentioned by Lundi Moore is still extant, although long abandoned, near the back wall of the lot. A wall of concrete block, stuccoed completely on the street facade and partially on the sides, surrounds the complex.
Facing the street, the wall is 7' in height; the other three sides vary in height from 5' to 6' according to the slope of the site. This surrounding wall curves at the southeast corner of the lot, where it meets the adjoining house. There are gates opening on to both the street and alley. 3. Outbuildings: There is a concrete block 12' x 24' garage, featuring a flat roof which slopes toward the alley, to allow rainwater to run off, and two sets of casement windows. 2' thick tongue-and-groove pair of side-hung garage doors, with latches on both interior and exterior, appear to be original. Construction alteration order #8 required the contractor "to build a store room partition in garage D of T&G flooring with a stock door where directed. Store room to be mouse proof.
Provide screens for windows." (p. 32) This room was presumably used for storage, and is no longer extant. There is also a one-room 10' x 11' board and batten cottage, (ca. with built-in bookshelves, four-light french door, and two sets of fixed sash windows with flanking casements. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Original Architectural Drawings: Architectural Record 64 (October B. Early Views: "Douglas Fairbanks - Mary Pickford" Scrapbook, Rancho Santa-Fe Historical Society Archives, McGroarty, John Steven. The Endless Miracle of California, GLENN AND IDA MAY MOORE ROWHOUSE (Cottage D) HABS No. CA-2303 (Page 9) The Endless Miracle 1 no. 1 (July 4. Rancho Santa Fe Progress 1 no. 10 (April 8; 1 no. 12 (June 4; 2 no. 2 (August 6. Architectural Record 64 (October Clotfelter, Connie.
Echoes of Rancho Santa Fe. Rancho Santa Fe: Conreg, p. 52. C. Interviews: Lundi Moore telephone Interview with Lauren Farber, 6 August D.