BlockBefore

Lake Hodges Flume, Along San Dieguito River between Lake Hodges & San Dieguito Reservoir, Rancho Santa Fe

Lake Hodges Flume, Along San Dieguito River between Lake Hodges & San Dieguito Reservoir, Rancho Santa Fe, San Diego County, CA. Surveyed as HAER CA-307, with a 7,484-word written history.

From the record

“The Lake Hodges Flume was critical in the agricultural and residential development of the north San Diego coastal area.”

Written record, HAER CA-307 survey. Machine-read text.

Surveyed by the federal HAER program as HAER CA-307 · the record runs 7484 words · one of 194 surveyed structures published for this county.

Sources: the survey record at the Library of Congress

Location

59 words

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-307. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

Starting at Lake Hodges Dam, heading east for 4.5 miles to San Dieguito Reservoir, Rancho Santa Fe, San Diego County, California. USGS 7 .5 minute Rancho Santa Fe Quadrangle Universal Transverse Mercator Coordinates: (west end); (east end) Date of Construction: July to January Channel widened in places in Developer San Dieguito Mutual Water Company Builder Bent Brothers Construction Company

Significance

7336 words

The headings the report itself prints. Each one jumps to where it begins.

Source document Quoted word for word from HAER CA-307. Not written, edited or summarised by this site.

The Lake Hodges Flume was critical in the agricultural and residential development of the north San Diego coastal area. This structure was the only source of water for the communities of Rancho Santa, Fe, Solana Beach and Del Mar until The flume is directly associated with the activities of Colonel Ed Fletcher, a key figure in the development of San Diego's infrastructure. The design of the flume is significant as it represents the application of state-of-the-art construction and design to the problem of water conveyance over hilly terrain. The flume was evaluated as eligible to the California Register of Historic Resources and the National Register of Historic Places in Report Prepared by: Sinead Ni Ghabhlain, and Jerry Schaefer, Senior Archaeologists ASM Affiliates, Inc.

543 Encinitas Suite Encinitas, CA Date: March LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 2

Description

The Lake Hodges Dam, Flume and San Dieguito Reservoir were constructed between July 5, and January 29, Currently, this water system is in use by Santa Fe Irrigation District, and supplies water to the communities of Rancho Santa Fe, Solana Beach and Del Mar. The flume is a gravity conveyance structure, 4.5 miles in length extending from Lake Hodges Dam to San Dieguito Reservoir. The flume is composed of three sections: a 5'-6"-wide trapezoidal concrete conduit, a diameter semi-circular concrete-lined steel pipe on concrete trestles and a 4'-3"-diameter steel reinforced concrete pipe (siphon), either buried or on a concrete trestle. The eastern half of the flume is constructed over very hilly terrain, necessitating trestles to maintain steady gradient over ravines.

Siphons were used on portions of the flume where gorges were too wide to safely span with concrete trestles. Lake Hodges is fed by the San Dieguito River which has a watershed area of nearly 300 square miles at the Lake Hodges Dam. The Hodges watershed is one of the largest in the County and is capable of generating very large flows, however it is also subject to droughts with little or no runoff available for use. The Lake Hodges Dam has outlets at several different elevations to draw water (Photograph These outlets spill into a common concrete box and then discharge into a 3 '-0 "diameter steel pipe. After leaving the dam, the pipe crosses a portion of the dam spillway on supports. This pipe then discharges into the open-channel Lake Hodges flume.

The flume was designed to have a capacity of 30 cubic feet per second or million gallons per day However, it is not known whether the flume ever operated to this capacity. A recent study of the flume, including hydraulic calculations and flow measurements, reports that the current capacity is approximately 13 mgd (Boyle Engineering This reduction in capacity is thought to be due to a deterioration of the flume over the years, including build up of sediment and blockage caused by roots and other organic material.

II INVENTORY OF FLUME ELEMENTS A field inventory of the flume identified twenty-one trestles, nineteen debris shields, six siphons, seven flush valves, two flow gates, and one manhole (Table 1) (Schaefer and Moslak The location of each element was mapped, and they were numbered sequentially. Those with known original numbers are indicated in Table 1. Three representative elements of the flume, Trestle 16 with Siphon 3 and Sediment valve 6, Trestle 18 and Debris Shield 12, have been selected for detailed documentation for the purposes of this HAER submittal. LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 3 Trestles Of twenty-one recorded trestles, fifteen appear to be original, two are probably original, but obscured by vegetation, and four appear to be replacements of original trestles.

Twelve of fifteen known original trestles share a common construction technique (Type A) although they vary in height and span. Three original trestles, all associated with siphons, show a second construction technique used to convey 4'-3"-diameter concrete pipe (Type B). Table 1. Lake Hodges Flume- Inventory of Elements Element i Photo I I Original I New No. [number I Easting I Length No. Comments ISteel post and beam supporting closed pipe replaces Trestle 1 Trestle 1 !original trestle. Shield 1 I i Shield type B, possibly a replacement. Flow gate I Modern. i I I Replacement trestle of wood post and truss construction Trestle 2 i I Trestle 2 I supporting open half-pipe. Replaces trestle seen in I I I , photo.

New siphon I l487720i I Trestle 3 I Replaces an original trestle as seen in photo. Flush valve 1 I 48nooT I !Not photographed Shield 2 I I !shield type B. : Shield 3 I i jShield type A. i ! I I II Replacement trestle. Steel post and beam supporting Trestle 3 I Trestle 4 I I !closed corrugated pipe. Shield 4 I IShield type B. I I I 110 18- I Trestle 4 ' Trestle 5 ! Type A construction, 2 tiers high. Steel I-beam added. I 20, i Shield 5 ! Shield type A. I I Flush valve 2 [ Probably Buried by leaves and sediment and Trestle? i trestle 6 Trestle 5 I I I Trestle 7 Type A construction, 2 tiers high. Trestle 6 I 2, 12 I i I Trestle 8 !1 Type A construction, 4 tiers high. Trestle 7 I i Trestle 9 Type A construction, 1? tier high.

Trestle 8 I 4, 11 Trestle 10 Type A construction, 1 tier high on concr~e piles. __ 1Probably replaces large trestle seen in photo. Siphonl 8 I j Trestlell IClosed concrete pipe. Flush valve 3 j ~ottom of siphon 1. Probably replaces large trestle Trestle 9 Trestle 11 I~~~ in photo. Concrete pipe supported directly Ion concrete piles. Siphon 2 I Trestle 12 Flush valve 4 1 _ Trestle is original but there may be more that one at Trestle 10 1 Trestle 12 the botto~ of Siphon~ Type B construction, closed 1 ~---~---~'_concrete pipe on one tier. LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page4 Element Photo 1 Original New No. number I Easting Length No. Comments iType A construction. Inscription at east end: Shield 6 EWC, !Type A construction, - One tier high. - --- Shield type A. Obscured by vegetation.

30' Shield type A. Trestle 13 Obscured by vegetation. Shield 9 ... l Shield type A. - - - - - - - Structure -- Trestle 14 - -- Type - A construction, three tiers high. - -- - Shield 10 ' Shield type A. Type A construction, five tiers high. Steel I-beams Trestle 15 3 added at a later date to stabilize. Flush valve 5 Shield type A. Very long section of covered ditch Shield 11 6 !partially covered with rock fall. Unique retaining wall to construct ditch on a very steep slope. ' Siphon 3 14 ' 15 ' - -- - . L-- -- - Flush valve 6 15 --~ --- Trestle 16 1 ~ 5 ' i Trestle 21 !Type B construction, five tiers high. __1'!.estle_17_j___ .. Shield 12 _J Type A construction, two tiers high. 1() -- -- --i.Shi~ict - 13, 17 ! Trestle 18 ... 1 Trestl~-i9 - - - - , - 1 Shield 13 - - - - .

10' Type A construction, three tiers high. . __ . ! A co~~f11c;tio!1~~~o tiers ~igh. - .. Shield type B . . - - - _ _ _ _ _ _ ., __ - - - - - - - .Flush valv_e2l______L485400._ . --- Trestle 20 1 - __Trestl~7 !Type B constru~~~.._three tiers 11igh_ _ _ .. - Shield 14 70' !Shield type A. -Trestle 2i ' A T~-stl~-2-i!Type con~t~~ti;~, one tier high- . Trest!~~ I - - - - - - . - .- - 30 ' ;Very recent replacement of ongmal trestles 29 and 30 I ... - hi~~rype B. _ 10' Shield type B. --~ Shield 17 40' j~~ie.!9:type B. Obscured bJ:sediment. Shield-lS 1 14841cJO i --6 - ~-- ;Shield_!ype B. ... __ _ Shield 19 ! .. ! Unknown._()])s.c:i:iredby sediment. ! i End Siphon Flush valve 8 + Presence inferred but not found LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 5 I Element Photo I Original New No.

number Easting I Length No. Comments 1 ~M~anh~o_l_e--+~~ Flush valve 9 . 1 Presence inferred but not found I Flow gate i i IModem. Trestle 18 is representative of Type A trestle construction (Sheet 4; Photographs 13 and Type A trestles support concrete-lined steel half-pipe flumes, in diameter. Trestle 18 has four trestle piers from one to three tiers high, with a flume spanning approximately 33 ' The maximum height of the structure is 13' -6" . The flume is supported on its outer edges by x 6" wood beams resting on x 13" steel reinforced concrete beams with 4" -wide notches at the trestles. Steel reinforced concrete tie beams, measuring 4" x spaced approximately l apart, extend across the top the metal flume. Some of the concrete tie beams have been replaced with 4" x 6" wooden tie beams.

The flume is braced with steel tie-rods treaded through the ends of the crossbeams, and passing under the flume. A wooden handrail originally extended across the length of the flume. It is now in poor condition. The flume assembly is supported on steel-reinforced concrete trestles. The uppermost tier of the modular trestle structure is rectangular in cross section. Diagonal concrete crossbeams are braced against the flume rails. The second trestle tier consists of a trapezoidal section that tapers toward the base, while tier three consists of a trapezoidal section that is widens toward the base. In trestles with more than three tiers, tiers three through five are trapezoidal, expanding in width from the top to the base.

Basal tiers are supported on poured concrete piles set into the earth or bedrock. Type A trestles are constructed with one tier (Nos. 7, 8, 11, 12, two tiers (Nos. 4, 5, 17, three tiers (Nos. 14, four tiers (No. 6) and five tiers (No. depending on the depth of the ravine that must be spanned. There was once an eight-tier trestle (Original No. but it was replaced by a siphon on short pylons that now follows the deep ravine contour. One trestle (Trestle 21) stands out as the shortest, with only minimal supporting struts. Trestle 12 may also be this short, but vegetation obscures the substructure. Trestle 8 is more typical of a single tier, this one built on concrete pylons (Photographs 4 and Additional tiers were added depending on the depth of the ravine.

The number of pylons also increased with height as the span lengths were generally proportional to ravine depth. Examples include Trestle 4 with two tiers (Photographs 10, and Trestle 18 with three tiers (Photograph The only example with four tiers is Trestle 6 (Photographs 2 and 12) and the only Type A trestle with five tiers is Trestle 15. With these larger trestles, the number of tiers decreases at the sloping sides of the ravines. Trestle 16 is representative of Type B trestle construction (Sheets 2 and 3; Photographs Type B trestles support concrete siphons and are constructed of modular trapezoidal steel reinforced concrete supports which increase in width toward the base. The three Type B trestles come in one-tier (Trestle three-tier (Trestle and five-tier (Trestle 16) heights.

Trestle 16 supports Siphon 3, a concrete water pipe (Photographs 14 and The siphon is supported by three trestle piers and two concrete supports, and spans approximately (Sheet LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 6 2). The tallest trestle is composed of five trapezoidal precast steel-reinforced concrete sections, each 4' -0" in height. It is 6' -4" wide at the base and is supported on 18" square concrete footings. The maximum height, including the siphon is (Sheet 3A). The trestle piers are spaced 011 apart. The siphon rests on steel-reinforced concrete beams measuring 11 x 4 11 , and is secured to the support beam by 1/2 11 diameter steel rods. A wooden plank walkway with wooden handrail originally provided pedestrian access across the top of the siphon.

This is now in poor condition with many of the original planks missing. A steel cable guide wire attached to a steel cable anchor has been installed as a safety measure. Four trestles show unique construction. All four appear to replace original trestles, although the time of replacement for each is not clear. They appear to be quite recent. Trestle 1 forms the outflow from Lake Hodges Dam, and is constructed of welded sections of steel pipe and supported by a simple assembly of "T" -shaped welded I-beams set into the ground inside a vertical section of steel pipe. Two such post and beam supports exist, one of which is held by a diagonal strut assembly of welded steel pipe.

Trestle 2 replaces a large modular concrete trestle seen in original photographs when the project was completed (Photograph The replacement is constructed of a simple arrangement of vertical wooden timber posts on either side of the original metal flume. Posts are tied together with wooden plank X-braces and the rail along the edge of the flume is supported by diagonal braces from the posts to the rails. The trestle has been subsequently reinforced with a welded steel "T" bolted to the exterior of the posts and rails. Wooden crossbeams replace the original precast concrete beams and, as with original trestles, ends of the crossbeams are tied together with a long tie rod which passes under the metal flume. Parts of the original trestle lie in the ravine below the wooden trestle.

The trestle is likely less the 50 years old. Trestle 3 appears to be much less than 50 years old. It consists of a segment of corrugated steel pipe of the type used for roadway drainage underpasses. This is supported by central vertical heavy gauge pipe sections bolted into concrete piles. Short I-beam cross members support the flume at the top and a central horizontal rail of heavy gauge pipe approximately 8 11 in diameter ties the tops of the posts together. A catwalk of expanded steel and pipe handrails is welded in place on top of the flume. Trestle 9 is located at the bottom of Siphon 1(Photograph 8). The siphon and trestle replace a very large, eight-tier high trestle seen in original photographs.

The siphon pipe and end boxes appear identical to other original siphons, which suggests that the trestle was replaced soon after it was built. The current trestle consists of nothing more than a low rectangular concrete pylon which directly supports the pipe above the narrow drainage at the bottom of the siphon. Siphons Siphons are used on the Lake Hodges Flume to convey water uphill through some ravines, rather than employing trestles. The technique was used in early Greek and Roman aqueducts. Siphons operate by both atmospheric pressure and gravity and serve to conduct water over elevations. LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No.

CA-307 Page 7 The siphon must first be filled with liquid before it will operate, but once filled, it will continue to draw water over the elevation, provided that the water discharges at a lower elevation. The elevation over which a siphon will lift a liquid is limited by the atmospheric pressure. At sea level, water may be lifted approximately In the case of the Lake Hodges siphons, water pressure from the drop into the ravine provides some of the pressure to force it up the other side of the ravine. Of the six siphons located along the course of the existing flume, three appear to be original (Siphon 3, 4, and End Siphon). Two are more than 50 years old, and from the early period of the flume when certain trestles were replaced with siphons (Siphon 1, 2).

One appears to be modern (New Siphon replacement of Trestle 3). Siphons are generally constructed of short sections of precast 4' -3 11 diameter concrete pipe supported by trestles of Type B construction discussed above. Siphon boxes at unequal elevations are located at either end, and typically include a diagonal metal grate to intercept large debris on the up-stream end (Photograph 8). The pipe sections are buried to the level of their upper surfaces on the sloping approaches to central horizontal trestles which cross the drainage below. Exceptions are the eastern and western-most siphons designated the "new" and the "end" siphon or Siphon 5, respectively. Both of these are completely buried. The new siphon replaced the original Trestle No.

3 seen in photographs (Photograph Siphon 1, supported by Trestle 9 (discussed above), replaced a very large trestle of Type A construction soon after initial construction, and is now supported by a simple concrete piling. Short lateral iron pipes with attached brass valves are located at the bottom of each siphon and served to flush sediment and release air that accumulated inside the siphon (Photograph Though these were not located on the end siphon, the presence or former presence of two such valves is inferred at this siphon. The end siphon is also the longest at approximately This siphon has two dips in elevation and rises in the middle to the crest of a low ridge located at the same elevation as either end. An original rectangular manhole measuring approximately 6' x 4'.

is located at the crest of this ridge. Debris Shields Debris shields consist of simple 6 11 thick concrete slab coverings for sections of the main concrete- lined flume. Debris shields occur in two basic varieties, referred to here as Type A and Type B (Sheet 5, Photograph 6). Type A are simple slabs poured in-situ. These may or may not rest on a raised lip on top of the trench wall, presumably the result of the removed wooden template. Damaged sections show they were tied into the concrete trench walls with short sections of reinforcement bar which extend vertically several inches above the top of the sidewall. Type A shields serve the general function of preventing sediment and rock from falling into the flume channel along steeper portions of the alignment.

Debris derives from surface runoff, small drainages, colluvial wash and talus, and even large falling boulders. Type A shields range in length from about 30' -0 11 to approximately . The efficacity of the debris shields is illustrated by the presence of boulders on the shields in several locations. In addition, several shields have been damaged by rock slides. LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 8 Type B shields are also 6' thick and poured in-situ. However, type B shields include low walls on either end to prevent surface runoff and sediment from washing into the water channel (Sheet 5). These walls and the slab typically extend beyond the top of the trench on the uphill side where they flare outward to divert surface runoff.

Type B shields measure from to approximately 11 40' in width. They also occur at the western end of the flume, where it is covered with wooden planks. The Flume Channel For much of its length the flume consists of an open trapezoidal concrete-lined aqueduct. The original channel was wide at the mouth, wide at the base and deep (Figure 2). 11 11 11 The poured concrete walls were 3 thick. Portions of the open channel were enlarged and 11 reinforced in the spring of (Photograph These sections are across at the top with 11 6 reinforced concrete walls. These enlarged sections are supported with precast 6 square 11 11 reinforced concrete braces placed 4' to 5' apart.

While the eastern end is partially covered with concrete shields to prevent sediment and boulders from falling in (Photograph 6), the western portion of the channel, located in flat terrain closer to Rancho Santa Fe, is covered with planks to prevent people and animals from falling in (Photograph 5). III IDSTORY OF LAKE HODGES DAM AND FLUME The Lake Hodges Dam, Flume, and San Dieguito Reservoir system was built between July 5, and January 29, as a solution to general water shortages in San Diego County, and in reaction to a series of early twentieth century droughts that inhibited regional land speculation and development. Lake Hodges dam and flume would accommodate and stimulate growth in the north county coast between La Jolla and Carlsbad.

Reliable waters sources have been critical to Euro-American settlement and expansion in southern California since the Spaniards first arrived in to found the San Diego Mission and Royal Presidio. Water shortages for agriculture plagued the padres from the beginning of Mission San Diego. In December they moved the mission from Presidio Hill, at the mouth of the San Diego River, to the Kumeyaay Indian village of lpaquay further up river where they hoped agriculture would be sustained by more reliable flows. This proved not to be the case, and in they completed the construction of a dam in Mission Gorge and a tile-lined aqueduct to the mission. This was the first engineered dam and reservoir system in California.

During the Mexican and early American periods, the residents of San Diego had to rely on wells and cisterns for their water supply. The phenomenal population and building boom of to saw the growth of downtown (New Town) San Diego, numerous other communities, and the agricultural hinterlands. Much of this boom cycle was driven by frenetic real estate speculation. Despite the above average precipitation of the land developers realized the need for large- scale water delivery systems for urban and rural development. Almost all of these early ventures were privately financed and managed by land development interests. The first to be completed LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No.

CA-307 Page 9 was Sweetwater Dam in March of It was built by the San Diego Land and Town Company, a subsidiary of the Sante Fe Railroad, to stimulate development of National City and Chula Vista (Fowler Next came the Cuyamaca Dam on a branch of the San Diego River, completed in by the San Diego Flume Company to serve metropolitan San Diego and Mission Valley. The Lower Otay Dam and Reservoir was next to come on line, built by the Southern California Mountain Water Company between and Many projects stalled during the national economic recession of the Renewed growth in the first two decades of the twentieth century saw San Diego County's population rise from to over almost doubling each decade.

San Diego was on the rise again, as the Navy headquartered its Pacific Fleet here, and the Panama-Pacific Exposition in Balboa Park brought it international attention. This period of growth necessitated the Chollas Heights, Morena, Barrett, Henshaw, Wohlford, and Sutherland projects, among others (Fowler By the City of San Diego began to purchase the water systems within its boundaries and assume management of the water delivery and treatment facilities. Within this context, the Lake Hodges Dam and Flume system was conceived to promote agriculture, enhance land values, and provide growth opportunities in the north county coastal region. By this time, Rancho San Dieguito was owned by the Santa Fe Land and Improvement Company, a subsidiary of the Santa Fe Railroad. W.E.

Hodges, vice-president of the Santa Fe Railroad, also served as president of the Land Improvement Company (Hill He hired Colonel Ed Fletcher in to manage the rancho in return for twenty percent of the operating profits. Fletcher's task was to turn an unprofitable property into a thriving enterprise. The Land Improvement Company had previously planted acres of Eucalyptus trees in a failed attempt to produce durable railroad ties that would compete with Oregon fir tree sources. Fletcher was co-owner of the Cuyamaca Water Company at the time, and previously had been involved in several of San Diego County's early water projects.

Applying his considerable engineering and development skills, he successfully developed a system of wells and pumping plants to irrigate fields for grain, sugar beets, and Japanese truck farm leases. Cattle ranching was also successful. Fletcher recognized that a reliable water supply could turn the entire rancho and surrounding mesas into profitable agricultural lands (Fletcher Previously in he was authorized by W. G. Henshaw, owner of Warner's Ranch and promoter of Henshaw Dam, to purchase options on available dam sites between Pamo Valley and the sea, including the San Dieguito River Valley. Several purchases were made in the name of Henshaw' s Vulcan Land and Water Company. Among them was the Lake Hodges Dam site, owned by Carroll.

An agreement was later made between the Volcan Land and Water Company and the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company to irrigate Rancho San Dieguito and surrounding coastal areas. Santa Fe would fund the dam and flume, while Volcan contributed the dam site and water rights (Fowler Preliminary work began in on what was then called the Carroll Dam and Flume. The reservoir site was surveyed in April, and the flume route was surveyed the following September under Fletcher's supervision. Fletcher petitioned the Federal Government in November for the LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 10 flume right-of-way to cross government land on the way to Rancho San Dieguito (Fletcher Papers, San Diego Historical Society: Doc.

9, File Group Prior to final approval by the government, the project went through several revisions. Originally the plan called for a dam 50' high that would supply sufficient water to irrigate acres. An aqueduct consisting of 30" steel pipe and 36" concrete pipe on a grade of 1 per 1, would be built from the dam site to the western edge of the San Dieguito Ranch, a distance of miles. The total estimated cost was (Fletcher Papers, San Diego Historical Society: File Group 42, Doc. 9). In the project was modified, and another flume survey was conducted.

The plan now proposed a dam high that would supply water for acres of farm land in conjunction with a 11.2-mile long flume and pumping plants, at a total cost of (Fletcher Papers, UCSD Fletcher Papers, San Diego Historical Society, File Group 42: Doc. 9). The proposal was again changed in March to consist of a dam with 36" concrete pipeline 4.5 miles in length, running from the dam to the east end of San Dieguito Ranch, where a reservoir and dam 50' in height would hold the water for distribution (Fletcher and Post Figure 1). The project was approved by the Federal Government, and the right-of-way in question was granted on September 13, (Fletcher Papers, San Diego Historical Society, Record Group 42: Doc.

9) The San Dieguito Mutual Water Company was incorporated in February to implement dam construction with the Santa Fe Land and Improvement Company as majority stockholder (San Dieguito Mutual Water Company Ed Fletcher was elected president by a board consisting of Santa Fe Railroad officers E.O. Faulkner of Los Angeles, Payson of San Diego and W.E. Hodges of Chicago in addition to Henshaw of Oakland. Fletcher conveyed right-of-way ownership to the company on October 1, and remained president throughout the eight-year existence of the San Dieguito Mutual Water Company.

The Bent Brothers Construction Company was hired to build the project for (Fletcher Papers, UCSD Construction began on July 5, and continued until January 29, Instead of the 36" concrete pipe that was originally planned for the entire 4.5-mile distance between Lake Hodges Dam and the San Dieguito Reservoir, a flume was constructed consisting of an "open and covered concrete ditch increasing in width from to (with) metal flume 5 in width supported on concrete trestles (and) concrete pipe siphons 42" in diameter" (Fletcher and Case Figures 2 and 3). At its completion, the system included four siphons and twenty-six trestles. Two of the trestles supported siphons over deep gullies, while the remaining trestles supported aqueducts.

Each feature was numbered consecutively from one to thirty (Fletcher Papers, UCSD The City of San Diego purchased the entire system at cost plus six percent interest in (Fletcher Beginning in portions of the open concrete-line channel were enlarged. Additional repairs and replacements have occurred throughout the system's use-life. LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 11 Currently twenty-one of the original twenty-six trestles remain.

Four trestles have been replaced with closed siphons or modern steel construction and one was removed (Trestle 30) during the diversion for the entrance to Rancho Cielo (Van Wormer and Schaefer The Lake Hodges Dam Flume provided all the water to the later Rancho Santa Fe development on the San Dieguito Ranch and surrounding region until when the area's supply was augmented by Colorado River Water. To the present day, the flume is the only outlet to Lake Hodges Dam. IV SIGNIFICANCE ASSESSMENT The Lake Hodges-San Dieguito Reservoir system, of which the flume is a vital part, is eligible for the California Register and the National Register under criteria "A", and "C" .

The flume is eligible under criterion "A" on the local and regional levels because it was critical in the agricultural and residential development of the north coastal area from La Jolla to Carlsbad, and as far inland as Rancho Santa Fe. The period of significance is from the time construction began, until the when the last major modifications were made after it was purchased by San Diego County. From the very beginning of Euro-American settlement in southern California, lack of reliable water sources severely constrained economic and demographic growth. The Lake Hodges Flume is representative of privately financed and managed water conveyance systems that were built between and to overcome a fundamental problem of developing coastal desert habitat.

These privately funded systems were often used throughout California for the development of lands under single ownership. Private speculators such as the Santa Fe Railroad could sell land of otherwise limited value for much higher prices because the land could be irrigated at specified rates or opened for residential uses. Increased land values contributed much more to long-term corporate profits than did water sales. Without the development of these water systems, the land booms of the and early would not have been possible. The Wright Irrigation Act authorized the establishment of irrigation districts made up by 50 persons or a majority of landowners.

In succeeding years, these districts came to acquire the private water systems and remain today as pivotal institutions in the creation of California's modern agriculture and infrastructure (Bean Harding Jelinek JRP and Caltrans The flume is significant under criterion "B" because it is directly associated with the activities of Colonel Ed Fletcher. Fletcher was a key figure in the inception, location, design, construction, and early management of the Lake Hodges Dam and Flume. Born December 31, in Littleton, Massachusetts, he arrived in San Diego on September 3, at the end of the great land boom. This was still a time of limitless possibilities for the bright and industrious.

Starting as an itinerant produce merchant on a bicycle, he quickly grew to be one of the major regional wholesale grocers and through his business, came to know most of the important San Diego landowners and businessmen. Unusually tall and ruggedly handsome, Fletcher must have also impressed his contemporaries with his self-confidence and trustworthiness. Despite a limited LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 12 education and no formal background in engineering or planning, he still became the agent and projects manager of some of the most powerful southern California development interests. In the process, he accumulated considerable economic and political power in his own right, with a hand in water, real estate, road construction, and development banking.

Such personal histories are rare indeed, but typify the potential that western American growth afforded to select ambitious and skilled entrepreneurs, despite humble beginnings. In at the age of 31, Fletcher became interested in water and land development and began to look for investors for the development of the San Luis Rey River Valley catchment. As co- agent of South Coast Land Company, controlled by the enormously powerful railroad magnate, H.E. Huntington, he trumped competing Los Angeles interests in the purchase of most of Del Mar, Leucadia, Agua Hediona Ranch, Carlsbad, and much of Oceanside (Fletcher Pourade Thus began a series of major development projects that were the foundation for much of San Diego's modem infrastructure.

These projects included construction of Murray Dam, revitalization of the San Diego Flume Company (Cuyamaca Water Company), development of the community of Grossmont, Lake Hodges Dam and Flume, development of Rancho Santa Fe, Henshaw Dam, El Capitan Dam, and a San Diego-Yuma automobile route via Mountain Springs Grade and the Plank Road. Fletcher was also very active in state politics, working with George Marston and other progressive Republicans to release the political grip on California of the Southern Pacific Railroad (Pourade After completion of Lake Hodges Dam, Fletcher began the five-year subdivision and sales process that led to the development of Rancho Santa Fe. He also played a pivotal role in organizing the San Dieguito and Santa Fe Irrigation Districts.

It is the latter that completed the San Dieguito Dam and currently operates the Lake Hodges Dam and Flume system. The Santa Fe Irrigation District originally encompassed some acres from Rancho Santa Fe to the ocean between Cardiff and Del Mar. The district also secured water delivery contracts with the town of Del Mar. He then participated in the creation of the San Dieguito Irrigation district that watered some acres in Cardiff, Encinitas, and Leucadia. His own Ed Fletcher company owned several hundred acres in the San Dieguito District (Fletcher In expressing the importance of this project, Fletcher wrote: ... I want to bring out the point that the value of the Lake Hodges water development to San Diego County has not been appreciated by many.

Water on our coast lands is surely the blood of the soil (Fletcher The flume is significant under criterion "C" because it "embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, region, or method of construction". The flume represents the application of state-of the-art construction and design to the problem of water conveyance over hilly terrain. The 4.5-mile long system originally included twenty-six trestles, four siphons, and miles of a concrete- lined ditch, covered in some areas. To the present day, the flume is the only outlet from Lake Hodges Dam, terminating at the San Dieguito Reservoir. The use of precast modular concrete LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No.

CA-307 Page 13 supports in the trestles is a particularly innovative design feature that may be unique to the flume (Tolley Most of the flume's features are contributing elements because they date to the original construction or early modifications within the period of significance. Because portions of the original flume have been replaced in recent years, several elements do not contribute to its significance. They include, as numbered for this survey, Trestle 1, Trestle 2, siphon replacement of Trestle 3, Trestle 3, Siphon 1 and Trestle 9, Trestle 22, and the initial and terminal flow gates. All other elements are significant.

Sources

Bean, Walton E. California, An Interpretive History. Second Edition. New York.: McGraw- Hill, Boyle Engineering. San Dieguito Reservoir Rehabilitation Study. Prepared for Santa Fe Irrigation District. February Fletcher, Ed. Memoirs of Ed Fletcher. San Diego: Pioneer Printers, Fletcher Papers, San Diego Historical Society. File Group 42, Document 9: "Application of Ed Fletcher. .. For Right-of-Way for Canals, Ditches, and Reservoir Site Over and Through Certain Surveyed and Unsurveyed Lands of the United States in the County of San Diego." Fletcher Papers, University of California, San Diego. "Lake Hodges Conduit - Trestle Account - Trestles and Pipe Siphons, Box 8, Lake Hodges Conduit Monthly Estimates File", Fletcher, Ed and E.W. Case. "Affidavits of Ed Fletcher and E.W.

Case on Map Showing Amended and Definite Location of Carroll Canal of Ed Fletcher, Being an Amendment of the Carroll Canal of Ed Fletcher, June 19, " Fletcher Papers, San Diego Historical Society Archives, File Group 42, Fletcher, Ed, and William S. Post. "Affidavits of Ed Fletcher and William S. Post on Map Showing Survey of Center Line of Carroll Canal of Ed Fletcher, being Amendments of the Carroll University Canal of Ed Fletcher". Fletcher Papers, San Diego Historical Society Archives, File Group 42, Document 10, Fowler, Lloyd Charles. A History of the Dams and Water Supply of Western San Diego County. University of California, Berkeley, Masters Thesis, Harding, E.S. Water in California. Palo Alto, California: N-P Publications, LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 14 Hill, Joseph J.

History of Warner's Ranch and Its Environs. Los Angeles: Young and Mccallister, Jelinek, Lawrence J. Harvest Empire: A History of California Agriculture. San Francisco, California: Boyd and Fraser Publishing Co., JRP Historical Consulting Services and the California Department of Transportation. Water Conveyance Systems in California: Historic Context Development and Evaluation Procedures. Jointly prepared by JRP Historical Consulting Services and the California Department of Transportation, Cultural Studies Office, Sacramento, National Park Service. Recording Historic Structures & Sites for the Historic American Engineering Record. Department of the Interior, National Park Service. Pourade, Richard F. The Glory Years. San Diego: The Union-Tribune Publishing Company, . Gold in the Sun.

San Diego: The Union-Tribune Publishing Company, San Dieguito Mutual Water Company. Articles of Incorporation No. San Diego Historical Society Research Archives. Schaefer, Jerry and Ken Moslak. A Cultural Resources Inventory and Evaluation for the San Dieguito Reservoir Rehabilitation and Lake Hodges Flume Replacement Project. Prepared for the Santa Fe Irrigation District. December Tolley, Jim. (Engineer, Santa Fe Irrigation District). Personal Communication with Stephen R. Van Wormer, July Van Wormer, Stephen and Jerry Schaefer. Historical and Structural Assessment of the Lake Hodges Flume. Report for the Santa Fe Irrigation District by Mooney-Levine and Associates, San Diego, LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 15 INDEX TO FIGURES Figure No.

Caption Page Figure 1 Map Showing Survey of Center Line of Carroll Canal of Ed Fletcher, San Diego County, California. William S. Post and Ed Fletcher, March 21, Scale 1" San Diego Historical Society Archives. Figure 2 Final Profile of Carroll Conduit, E.W. Case, Chief Engineer, San Dieguito Mutual Water Company. March Santa Fe Irrigation District Headquarters. Original Horizontal Scale 1" = , Vertical Scale 1" = 6' Reduced to forty percent of original. Figure 3 Condensed Profile, Showing Relation of Lake Hodges Reservoir, Conduit, San Dieguito Reservoir and Distribution Lines. E.W. Case, Chief Engineer. San Dieguito Mutual Water Company. April Santa Fe Irrigation District Headquarters. Original Horizontal Scale: 1" Vertical Scale 1" Reduced to forty-two percent of original.

LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 16 !, Ed Fle:'"cher, do hereby cerr/ry lh<il11" W////a;-n S Posr ,.,-ho .subscr/bt!>cl lhe eccorn,,001,,...,y;n.J? a///d.:7v/r/ ;5 e'/7j1- /neer/ C1rro// C oV7v// &.s vrq/-u/y re;cu-e.senl"<?d on by Thi:!' 1ccornpany/n_y field no/-< ,.,01'<,,,,;o.,;-<!'d me On /he Z/g dOl'y o/ /'4.ii'rCh cii'S de/'.,n/re /oc&r/on o,r The sa/d CJ"rro// Cwi'nv/ descr/bed OT.5 :/o//ovv.:s .' c,;un1NG al' a 1n 16: T. R 2 IS rnar-"'ed po/n/- OT 0 rOCJ,, /n/Jl'/a/ . Vo. I, ,.,.,,hence :t'.he $. E. corner o / T /.7 R 3 ~ S. 8 M., bears S 40" /Z reer, 7hence ,,,,/onj' /-he CC',,,,.rses and d/s 1-anc es s.hovvn <'n oy -I.he ,;;n::con?,PSny/nj' nores ,.,t.o /errn/n<1'/ pcun7" or y Net. Z, ,-.rhence J'he N Corner or /?..,ncho L:J,,-e51L/1'ro, ~,,yrA-eu 0. Yo.

8 0#1i'r.s /V 6 ., Yo,/ s reer. ell /e-ny/h or Un.Sur- ;f!?9ed land or 0. 78 ./77.1'/es on surv-eyed' /a'nd o/ 3. B 7 ies. re- len-9 7h Or c..ii'n.;I c/ _; Inc' no Ilk(!' or , ed s or _, N5 U.'S'<!'ol / o r '65 sha_.,,,,, on /??#_,ID; <ii''u:I th.vi' ,Prt!!"_p#re>i:I' l"o C~ :;/;;let:)! Tor / p / ..Sil!'C - rl!!'r.;u-1.; o/ ?he /nrer/or ,r; oro'er / /7?-illf' qbr.;;ir7 ~1!.?e:.:>-,,s c/ 7-?e acr o/ Con9rc-J.- d',P,Pre>r<!"c' Jnd Sl!'c,:";on ,2 or ?'he ;er ;,;o/::u-OYt!'d J'her c ;;be r?pA>r o / s o'e-;: , _,.-ed /or c;/ Figure 1. (Part 1 of 4) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 17 Sri!lfle cl" C,,gl/Forn.18 J C1>u17ry or_r ~Bn ,,- .S.

PosrJ du/y s>Vorn 1 /he Ch.1ir1' or Ea' fid"/'e.hd'r, ?'hoPr sur>'t!l'J" C.;111'-ro// Cr01ne/ or F/11reht!1'.r .I J'J /q//O#'V..:S: .8 6/N.f'IONS Ir 8 po/i-11- ,,, T. /J R. .2 W.1 S. B. /S l?'Uifr;lrtf>c:f .srHr/on dO Pr .SU.rV4"!1' /Vo. / 1 . o.,r ~ 3 ~, S . bears $. 4 9 / 4 /e111r1 ~henc,e 1/1ut9 111no' .srhovvn on 1"/u'.:$ ,nip ~y 1eca~p.,.-y,,.nf nol-tns 'f"o s/"11'/on OT Sur"IYl!!y' ho. .? - 24 80 I rerrn; n1/ wht1nc;e N. . cornf!fr oF Rancho o.;e9,o'ro, .-n1r.rreo' S 0. /'le. 8 oe1rs JV. 6' &e,,ny e unJvrYeyed /end oF o. 78 /??//es und o,,.., $v,,....ve-~f!'d ,;::u:.nf1//c /iPnd en/:'" 8 7 > r!i' 1'-o!-01/ o/ Cll'?-tif/ or 4 n?<iiilde vna'er or.s ch/e/ t4'"n!f'/"74'er Ed F/eJ-cht9>- di''1d undt!>r aunl7o.r,, r!Y co,.,., 17?

"n /7 d1y OT /VOVt:!"n?O*r /.Jil/&; ,p,n<JI" end/'?J7' On l'"he d'Y 01' lt!!'t:t!!',,.,,be.r r/un~ rke .surYl:'J" o / SO'/t:?' ct c-n::cur417'-tP/y rep.resenril'o' v,,con rn#,O a.?d by .orc- COn?,PCiln!;l";?f nores. /lnol ,no /1ke or beot, sf.-eQl'rn .b<i"<I".. <5 v.rea' CO'/hiii'/, e.;rce,,.or a.s on .1-rNfl!',,o SUb.!!l"t::/'"/b~ <511/'o,,.-, \ , 2. / sr f7 1f, o/" / .Iii. . ": .~ ii _ ,. _,_ ,;::i..,, ,e,//c. ,. . ,; Figure 1. (Part 2 of 4) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 18 JYIAP SHOW/NG

Survey of

CeNTel? L/NE Or CRRROLL CRNAL Or EO PL.ETCHER OJ.EGO COUNTY., CRL./rO/i'N/A E: r : : eooo BEING /IN /9/r7E/VOM NT OF THE C/?Rl?OU. - UNIVcRSITY OF EO FL.fi:TCHcR t'Jan .Oie9uifo Rane ho ~ "' I l Figure 1. (Part 3 of 4) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 19 r Inches Figure 1. (Part 4 of 4) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 20 Figure 2. (Part 1 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 21 Match Line B - - - --- Figure 2.(Part 2 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 22 Figure 2. (Part 3 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 23 . -.- - - 0 0 0 i a Figure 2. (Part 4 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 24 Match Line D Match Line E g- s " Figure 2. (Part 5 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 25 \ Match Line F ; ' i .

~ 0 ?, ' :;- ~ " t' t 5 Figure 2. (Part 6 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 26 , , ' ~ f , . ~ '~ - ~ '' ! ., ~ . < ~ ! ! ' ' ~ 5 ,. r E ' Figure 2. (Part 7 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 27 Figure 2. (Part 8 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 28 Figure 2. (Part 9 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 29 Match Line I Figure 2. (Part 10 of 10) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 30 Figure 3. (Part 1 of 3) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 31 Figure 3. (Part 2 of 3) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No. CA-307 Page 32 Figure 3. (Part 3 of 3) LAKE HODGES FLUME HAER No.

CA-307 Page 33 Project Information This documentation was prepared in part as mitigation for future site and structure modifications associated with the proposed San Dieguito Reservoir Rehabilitation and Lake Hodges Flume Replacement Project. The Project entails various site improvements, including replacement of the existing flume with a new underground pipeline along the 4.5 mile alignment between Lake Hodges Dam and the San Dieguito Reservoir. Funding for the Lake Hodges Flume HAER was provided by the Santa Fe Irrigation District. This document incorporates two previous studies of the Lake Hodges Flume by Stephen Van Wormer and Jerry Schaeffer and by Jerry Schaeffer and Ken Moslak ( The Lake Hodges Flume HAER was prepared by ASM Affiliates, Inc ..

The HAER drawings were prepared by the office of architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, F AIA. Field survey and site documentation for the drawings was completed by Carmen Pauli and Richard Stewart of Architect Milford Wayne Donaldson, F AIA, in November, HAER written documentation was prepared by Sinead Ni Ghabhlain, and Jerry Schaefer of ASM Affiliates, Inc .. Photographic documentation was completed by Christopher Wray.

In context

Rancho Santa Fe, California The place record: every map, photograph and survey of this town.
San Diego County, California 602 topographic sheets across the county.
Library of Congress record The original filed report as the survey filed it.

Also surveyed in Rancho Santa Fe

24 of 31 records shown

The federal surveyors worked through Rancho Santa Fe building by building. These are the other structures they measured and filed a report on, longest report first.

SheetStructure SurveyReport
Rancho Santa FeHABS CAL,37-RANSF,11-18,900 words
Glenn & Ida May Moore RowhouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,1-6,089 words
La Flecha HouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,2-5,669 words
La MoradaHABS CAL,37-RANSF,5-4,227 words
Spurr-Clotfelter RowhouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,8-3,752 words
Baker-Megrew RowhouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,10-3,643 words
Sidney & Ruth Nelson RowhouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,9-3,622 words
Santa Fe Land Improvement CompanyHABS CAL,37-RANSF,4C-3,243 words
Joers-Ketchum StoreHABS CAL,37-RANSF,6-2,676 words
Joers-Ketchum RowhouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,7-2,521 words
Santa Fe Land Improvement CompanyHABS CAL,37-RANSF,4B-2,385 words
Santa Fe Land Improvement CompanyHABS CAL,37-RANSF,4A-2,345 words
Studio Shop & Tea RoomHABS CAL,37-RANSF,12-2,168 words
HouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,17-110 words
Rancho Santa Fe School (Third)HABS CAL,37-RANSF,25-96 words
Rancho Santa Fe Civic CenterHABS CAL,37-RANSF,3-95 words
Rancho Santa Fe Garden ClubHABS CAL,37-RANSF,20-93 words
El Tordo ApartmentsHABS CAL,37-RANSF,23-89 words
Whitsitt HouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,26-88 words
Stoltzfus-Humphries HouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,14-74 words
F. W. Joers HouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,21-72 words
Samuel Bingham HouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,16-71 words
Leandro Osuna HouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,27-58 words
Juan Osuna HouseHABS CAL,37-RANSF,28-49 words

Provenance

  • Written history. Quoted verbatim from HAER CA-307. United States federal work, no copyright under 17 U.S.C. 105.
  • Text capture. Machine-read from the scanned typescript filed with the survey, so spelling and spacing follow the original page.
  • How this page is made. Documentary passages are quoted from the linked federal record; page labels and counts are clearly marked as site presentation or calculations.