This building, commissioned by the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company as small-scale pre-sold speculative housing in the midst of the commercial center of the town, is one of a group of four rowhouses in the Civic Center of Rancho Santa Fe designed by Lilian Rice in emulation of urban residences in Spain. The public (street) facade is decorated with iron window grills and heavy wooden gate, and there is a front patio and back garden for privacy. PART I. HISTORICAL INFORMATION A. Physical History: 1. Date of erection: An article by Lilian J. Rice, "More Building in than ever Before," (Rancho Santa Fe Progress vol. 1 no.
7 (January 11, 14) states that in the "group of four residences were built along the west side of Paseo Delicias." A "Completion Report" on the four Paseo Delicias rowhouses, dated April 12, and submitted to each rowhouse owner by L. G. Sinnard of the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company, states: "The Civic Center Cottages, consisting of four dwellings, were constructed by Mr. C. M. Paddock under contract dated July . . . Work on these cottages, hereinafter designated as cottage A, B, C, and D, was begun July 15, and practically completed December 1, (p. 1) 2. Architect: Lilian Jenette Rice 3.
Original and Subsequent Owners: Chain of Ownership Taken from Assessment Records, Santa Fe Irrigation District, Rancho Santa Fe and Deed Books, Office of the County Recorder, San Diego County: SPURR-CLOTFELTER ROWHOUSE - (Cottage A) HABS No. CA-2310 (Page 2) * title to portions lots 21 and 22, Block D owned by Santa Fe Land Improvement Company bought by Louise Garvey Spurr (sales contract bought by Ellis Bishop, 26. N. Morengo Ave., Pasadena, CA title transferred to First Trust and Savings Bank, Executor, Ellis Bishop Estate reacquired by Santa Fe Land Improvement Company (rented by Reginald M. and Constance C. Clotfelter) bought by Thomas R. & Clara H. Cummins (Deed book page bought by Reginald M. 6c Constance C.
Clotfelter (Deed book page 62) The Clotfelters continue to own the property in although they have rented it to a succession of tenants since 4. Builder, contractor, suppliers: The builder/contractor, as cited in the "Completion Report," was C. M. Paddock, an independent builder in Rancho Santa Fe. This document does not mention, nor is there any other evidence of, the names of any suppliers or subcontractors who worked on the project, although, under the terms of the contract between the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company and Paddock signed on July 12, subcontracting work was permitted. No information on Paddock has been obtained. 5. Original plans and construction: The original plan for the four Paseo Delicias rowhouses, published in the October Architectural Record (p.
copy included here in supplemental material), shows the Spurr-Clotfelter residence at the far left. Early views can be found in a scrapbook entitled "Douglas Fairbanks-Mary Pickford Fairbanks" in the Rancho Santa Fe Historical Society Archives, and on p. 52 of Connie Clotfelter's Echoes of Rancho Santa Fe. The original plan shows a two-bedroom residence, with living room, dining room, kitchen and laundry room, and one bath. There were closets in the entryway and in the hallway. A front patio led from Paseo Delicias to the front door; a back garden was reached through small flights of steps from either the living room or laundry room. A one-car garage fronted on an alleyway. The entire complex was enclosed within a wall, ensuring privacy from the nearby commercial strip.
Building materials were not indicated on the original plan. SPURR-CLOTFELTER ROWHOUSE _ - - (Cottage A) HABS No. CA-2310 (Page 3) CM. Paddock's original bid for the construction of "Cottage 'A'" was submitted to the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company on June 18, The final cost to Louise Spurr was this sum included which represented the cost of alteration orders specified by the purchaser during construction. 6.
Alterations and additions: Alterations to the original structure have been minimal and have not radically altered the original fabric as seen from the street: a drop ceiling has been added to the kitchen, the original bathroom has been modernized, the windows in the dining room have been replaced by aluminum sash windows and two closets have been added to the north and west walls of the back bedroom. There have been major additions to the rear of the house, in two stages: an additional bedroom and bath in the same wood frame and stucco construction were added (in on the north side of the back bedroom, and between and a day porch and screened porch in board and batten construction with exposed ceiling beams were added. (Source for dates: Reginald M. Clotfelter interview) B.
Historical context: Among the first residences to be built in Rancho Santa Fe, the Spurr- Clotfelter rowhouse, like the three others in the row constructed simultaneously, was commissioned by the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company, and designed by their resident architect Lilian Rice, of the San Diego firm Requa and Jackson. First purchased by Louise Garvey Spurr, the building has housed a succession of families. Spurr came to Rancho Santa Fe at this time as a widow or divorcee with a young son. Her sale of this rowhouse in was occasioned by her remarriage to Hal Badger that year. After their marriage, the Badgers ran the garage block and fountain lunch on Paseo Deliclas; the rear of the garage block was occupied by the orchard contracting business of Hal Badger's brother, Ray.
Following Spurr, Ellis Bishop, and after his death his daughter, owned the building and resided there. After the title was reclaimed by the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company in (when Bishop's estate failed to meet the mortgage payments), Reginald M. and Constance Clotfelter moved in. The Clotfelters remain today the prototypical Rancho Santa Fe residents--involved with real estate and sales, a couple who have raised their family, been intimately involved in civic life, and retired in Rancho Santa Fe. They came to Rancho Santa Fe in when Reginald Clotfelter was hired as the local sales representative for the Santa Fe Land Improvement Company (of which his uncle, U. T. Clotfelter, was vice president).
In this capacity Reginald Clotfelter managed the Rancho Santa Fe Inn (owned by the Land Improvement Company, and used to house potential buyers), sold property owned by the Company, and managed the property that they reclaimed during the Depression. In Clotfelter opened his own real estate company, still run today by SPURR-CLOTFELTER ROWHOUSE _ - (Cottage A) V* HABS No. CA-2310 (Page 4) his eldest son, Tom. Both Reginald and Connie Clotfelter have also been involved in numerous civic organizations in Rancho Santa Fe--the Boy Scouts, Association, Garden Club, Irrigation District Board. In addition, Echoes of Rancho Santa Fe.
Connie Clotfelter's collection of essays and columns on the history and personalities of the village, was published in In the Clotfelters bought the rowhouse from Thomas and Clara Cummins, interim purchasers, and continued to reside there until Since that date they have rented out the residence to a variety of tenants, and they continue to reside elsewhere in Rancho Santa Fe. PART II. ARCHITECTURAL INFORMATION A. General Statement: 1.
Architectural Character: This rowhouse is one of four designed as a unit by Lilian Rice and built simultaneously in As residential structures fully integrated within the semi-urban core of Rancho Santa Fe, yet architecturally segregated from the neighboring commercial strip through the use of varied setbacks, enclosed patios and gardens, low gable and flat parapet roofs, and decorative ironwork, the rowhouses are a major example of Rice's use of the Spanish vernacular idiom to give variety and character to Rancho Santa Fe's Civic Center. 2. Condition of Fabric: The rowhouse remains in generally good condition, although there are cracks in the fireplace wall, and some water damage and cracks in the living room ceiling. B. Description of Exterior: 1.
Over-all dimensions: The one-story rowhouse, with original overall dimensions of x is asymmetrical in facade and plan. The building, square feet in total living area, features a small front entrance patio and a larger back garden, which occupy about 60 percent of the property space. 2. Foundations: 1' high x 1' wide poured concrete perimeter foundation wall with interior piers. 3. Walls: Exterior walls of the structure (8" thick) are frame with stucco. 4. Structural system, framing: Wood framed building construction, with poured concrete piers embedded In the foundation soil. These are supported by wood cross-braces. 5.
Patios, stoops: The front patio, 15' x has its original tile path leading from the gate to the door, and replacement patterned SFURR-CLOTFELTER ROWHOUSE (Cottage A) HABS No. CA-2310 (Page 5) brick elsewhere; there are landscaped planting beds on three sides. The front door stoop is concrete, with brick surrounds now added. The back garden has replacement brick paths and landscaped planting beds. The stoops in the back are replacement concrete and brick. 6. Chimney: The brick chimney serves the living room fireplace. The chimney stack, which rises above the roof line, is stuccoed.
Construction alteration order #1, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that the chimney was to be built "with 4" walls instead of 8" walls." The flue was to be "plastered both inside and outside except where exposed to weather." 7. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: The entrance gate from the street has a large, heavy, tongue-and-groove side-hung plank door with its original iron latch, and is bolted with decorated ironwork. There is a rectangular open space above this gate with decorative iron grillwork. The braced, wooden plank alley gate is side-hung and has a metal latch. The original front door has been replaced with an un-paneled door with a wrought-iron latchset.
Access to the back patio is gained by an eight-light French door from the living room, and by a screen door from the sun porch. Construction alteration order #1, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that the "french doors on the north elevation [were] to be made with four lights, four high. Each pair to be made so that right hand door and right hand screen will open first as you go out." (p. 22) b. Windows: Typical windows are wood-framed single-sash casement with wood sills; other window types include fixed sash with flanking casements facing the interior patio in the living room and dining room (replaced by aluminum windows in the dining room), and six-light casements facing the street. On the additions, the windows are also wood- framed casement.
On the street facade, there are decorative iron window grills. Construction alteration order #1, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that the "living room windows on the south elevation [are] to be three lights, three high." (p. 22) 8. Roof: The roof over most of the building is flat with a parapet, covered with built-up roofing. Facing the street, however, the projecting living room and front bedroom bays are gabled, with the living room roof having a higher pitch. The gables are covered in red Spanish tile, regularly laid. Construction alteration order #2, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified the "use [of] Granada machine-made pan tile on roof in place of hand-made pan SPURR-CLOTFELTER ROWHOUSE (Cottage A) HABS No. CA-2310 (Page 6) tile." (p.
24) Gutters are placed at the eave overhang. Clay tile scuppers project through the parapet wall. On the gable ends there are clay tiles projecting through the exterior wall to the attic space, in order to provide ventilation. 9. Decorative features: Original decorative iron lamps are on the street wall, and inside the front patio. There are original decorative iron window grills on the street facade. Construction alteration order #4, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that the "exterior front entrance features [were] to be selected by owner." (p. 28) C. Description of Interior: 1. Floor plans: The living room, front bedroom, and the front patio are aligned along the front edge of the property, facing Paseo Delicias.
The living room is to the right of the entryway; all other rooms are reached to the left. Through the dining room, the kitchen, laundry room, and added sun porch can be reached. The bedrooms open off a small hallway, also reached through the dining room. 2. Flooring: Originally narrow board oak; now carpeted. A construction alteration order (number not recorded), as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that oak flooring" was to be used "in all rooms, closets and halls, except the kitchen, laundry, and bath." Oak toe mold was also specified, 12, 24) Original flooring in the kitchen has been replaced. There is a patch of original tile on the hearth of the fireplace; the grouting has been painted. 3. Wall and ceiling finish: Painted plaster only.
There are no decorative moldings; original toe molding removed or hidden by carpet. Drop ceiling added in kitchen. 4. Openings: a. Doorways and doors: Typical door is one-paneled. There are rounded archways from the entryway into the living room and the dining room, and a flat archway from the dining room to the hall. A one-paneled swinging door separates the dining room and kitchen. b. Windows: Screened on the inside to allow for ventilation. 5. Decorative features: Built-in wooden bookcase with rounded borders in living room. Niche, with plastered shelf supported by a plaster bracket on each side, above fireplace. Construction SFURR-CLOTFELTER ROWHOUSE _ - (Cottage A) HABS No.
CA-2310 (Page 7) alteration order #7, as noted in the "Completion Report," requested the builder to "plaster exposed brick at niche of fireplace." (p. 30) Alteration order #4 specified that there were to be "hand wrought [electric light fixtures] finished with rub finish in the living room, entrance hall, and bedrooms." (p. 28) These decorative fixtures have been removed and replaced. 6. Hardware: Original fireplace screen of wrought iron. 7. Mechanical equipment: a. Heating, ventilation: Original flue removed. Originally, an electric heating system*in floor; original placement of heating vent unknown. Original vent for stove In northeast corner of kitchen. Original thermostats in living room, dining room, and both original bedrooms. b. Lighting: Original ceiling light fixture in entryway.
All other original light fixtures removed. Construction alteration order #4, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that "electric light fixtures to be hand wrought fixtures finished with rub finish in the living room, entrance hall and bedrooms. All other interior fixtures . . . to be stock fixtures." (p. 28) c. Plumbing: Modern plumbing fixtures only. d. Other: Wood-plank box enclosing original electrical meter and panel located on the back wall of the laundry room, facing the back garden. Construction alteration order #1, as noted in the "Completion Report," specified that a radio plug was to be installed "where directed." (p. 21) Alteration order #3 specified that the residence was to be wired "for telephones to be installed at a later date." (p. 26) D. Site: 1.
General setting and orientation: The house faces east onto Paseo Deliclas, the main street and village center of Rancho Santa Fe; it backs onto an alley which cuts through the block. 2. Historic landscape design: It is unknown how much of the present gardens represent the Intention of Lilian Rice, the original owners, or of the first landscaper. Today, there are many plantings in the gardens, including grass, palm, cypress, and other trees. *- SPUHR-CLOTFELTER ROWHOUSE (Cottage A) HABS No. CA-2310 (Page 8) A wall of concrete block, stuccoed completely on the front and partially on the sides, surrounds the complex. Facing the street, the wall is 9' in height; the other three sides vary in height from five to six feet according to the slope of the site.
There are gates opening on to both the street and alley. 3. Outbuildings: There is a concrete block 14' x 26' garage, featuring a flat roof which slopes toward the alley, to allow rainwater to run off, and two sets of casement windows, one of which has been replaced by an aluminum sliding window. The original garage doors have been replaced. PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Original Architectural Drawings: Architectural Record 64 (October B. Early Views: "Douglas Fairbanks-Mary Pickford Fairbanks" Scrapbook, Rancho Santa Fe Historical Society Archives, McGroarty, John Steven. The Endless Miracle of California, The Endless Miracle 1 no. 1 (July 4. Architectural Record 64 (October Clotfelter, Connie. Echoes of Rancho Santa Fe. Rancho Santa Fe: Conreg, 52. C. Interviews: Reginald M.
and Constance Clotfelter, interviewed by Lauren Farber, June 28, D.