The Goerlitz house is a rustic Spanish Colonial Revival style residence constructed of local stone. It is significant for its architectural qualities and close association with the lifestyle and values of a unique middle class agricultural society typical of many citrus growers in San Bernardino County during the early century. Beginning as early as the mid-1870s and continuing through the citrus growers often built stylish homes in the midst of their orange groves, rather than the vernacular buildings of more traditional agricultural communities. Through architecture and landscaping, the Goerlitz house and setting reflect a unique citrus-based agricultural society that was highly influential in the growth and development of the area.
Description: General Character The Goerlitz house and grounds retain original rural charm as an oasis of mature landscape plantings. The landscaping includes both ornamental plantings directly associated with the residence and an adjacent fruit orchard. Mature plantings create a unique microclimate around the residence. The rustic charm of this Spanish Colonial Revival residence is enhanced by stonework. Approached by car down a long tree-lined driveway, the residence is surrounded by stone patios on the north, south and west sides. Arbors grace the interior-to-exterior circulation pattern on the north and west sides. Substantial vine- covered arbors extend from the residence, tying the residence to the site.
The entire residence, arbors, and patios fit a comprehensive site design and take full advantage of the location. The structure conforms to the topography of the site, with rooms stepping down the hillside to the east and south. Dimensions The residence is long in the east-west direction and 28' wide in the north-south direction. It is primarily a long "L" shape with the east end (the top) of the "L" shifted out of alignment by 12' to the north. At the eastern end of the building the end room (bridal room) shifts back into alignment with the main structure. At the western end the kitchen extends to the south 25' forming the bottom of the A 12'-wide ~~GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No.
CA-2681 Page2 arbor parallels the north side of the residence for 75 1 and continues for another 41 1 to the west, creating an arbor totaling long. The west side of the house is flanked by a large rectangular shaped arbor measuring 24' x 16 1 Materials The foundation is raised perimeter with crawl space. A brick-lined gray water cellar underlies about % of the structure below the current bar area. Locals assert that the brick was actually fired on-site. The areas that were originally part of the exterior patios have concrete slab-on- grade floors. Walls are constructed of poured-in-place concrete faced on the exterior with rough irregular stones. The stones have been partially troweled over with a coarsely applied cement mortar, so only portions of the stone are visible.
Walls on the interior are covered with a thin skim coat of plaster. The coating is so thin on the interior that lines from the formwork show through. The roof is a gabled roof over the main portion of the structure, constructed with open-beam trusses and purlins-and-board sheathing. The end rooms have shed roofs. The roof in these areas is constructed with open rafters and board sheathing. The porch on the south is a shed roof leaning to the main structure. Roofing is all constructed with grouted mission clay tiles. The electrical system was built contemporary with the structure cast into the walls. The door and window openings are supported with pre- cast concrete lintels. The wood lintels visible from the exterior over the doors and windows are ornamental.
Two north side patios are constructed from concrete and brick. The west side patio and arbor is constructed with concrete cast as large pavers with grout lines. The arbor is constructed from 4x wood beams and 6x wood posts covered with non-bearing grape ivy. The three-car garage is concrete slab-on-grade with wood-frame construction walls and roof. The exterior is stuccoed and the roof is Mission clay tile. Historical Context: Physical History 1. Date of erection: Herbert and Evelyn Goerlitz constructed the house in Herbert was the son of New York Metropolitan Opera Director Ernest Goerlitz who had retired and purchased citrus groves in Alta Loma in 2. Architect: Not known. ~ ~ ~ G O E R L I T Z HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page3 3.
Original and subsequent owners, occupants and uses: The property consisted of two five-acre lots on portions of Lots 5 and 6, Block 3 of the Cucamonga Homestead Association lands.1 Kate Motsinger purchased Lot 6 from Milda Carral in By it was under cultivation.2 William Motsinger owned Lot 5 by He transferred title to Kate Motsinger in George Allen purchased both lots in and sold them to Herbert and Evelyn Goerlitz three years later. Improvements for the house first appear in the Tax Assessors Lot Books in (Lot Books, Transfer Books). Lot 6 continued to be taxed for vines and trees (presumably citrus) but no improvements of any kind are listed for Lot 5. In the property was purchased by Ellen C. Van Every, also known as Ellen Loeb, who was retired from the movie industry.
The first taxation for agricultural cultivation on Lot 5 occurred in An aerial photograph of the property taken in shows a mature citrus grove on the southern half of the property (Lot 6) and newly planted trees on the north half (Lot 5). Tax records for also show a major increase in improvement values on Lot 6 from for the previous year to This suggests Ellen Van Every enlarged the house sometime during or early Van Every owned the property through the early 5 Historical Context 1. Introduction: From the mid through the an inland citrus empire existed in Los Angeles, San Bernardino, and Riverside Counties, consisting of a unique middle class agricultural society.
Many citrus growers built stylish homes in the midst of their orange groves, rather than the vernacular buildings of more traditional agricultural communities. The Goerlitz house, a Spanish Colonial Revival style residence constructed of local stone in the citrus colony of Alta Loma, reflects the lifestyle and values the unique society that developed in the citrus communities of Southern California that was neither urban or rural. The following historical narrative provides a history of citrus cultivation in San Bernardino County to provide a context for understanding the evolution of the communities represented in part by the Herbert and Evelyn Goerlitz. It is followed by a history of the community of Alta Loma and the Goerlitz family. 2.
History of the Citrus Industry in San Bernardino County: From the through the late a "citrus empire" extended between the cities of Pasadena and San Bernardino through a series of small communities. Many of the towns, including Alta Loma, were surrounded by citrus groves. The settlements had their origins in agricultural colonies founded in the and These settlements evolved a unique culture that was neither urban nor rural. Lacking the ~ G O E R L I T Z HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page4 congestion of cities and set amongst the uniform rows of citrus orchards, they did not have the isolation of more traditional farming settlements; frequently they possessed many of the institutions of small cities, such as a college or university, art gallery, museum, and luxury hotel.
Handsome homes built in the groves were not vernacular farm houses, but suburban Italianate, Queen Ann, Mission and Colonial Revival or Craftsman style residences. These were among the first communities in the West to adopt urban planning ordinances and modern infrastructure such as electric lights. 6 Spanish missionaries first brought oranges, along with other citrus, to California. The British explorer George Vancouver reported oranges and other fruit at San Buenaventura Mission in The first orange orchard in California was set out in San Gabriel in Louis Vigenes of Los Angeles set out a few trees, presumably from the San Gabriel stock, in 7 Commercial development began in the growing slowly until the when serious efforts began.
8 In William Wolfskill of Los Angeles set out two acres of trees, establishing the first commercial orange orchard in California. His success led him in to set out the famous "Wolfskill" orchard, for many years a Los Angeles landmark and the largest grove in the state. 9 In the late and early other agricultural pioneers began to experiment with citrus production. In Myron H. Crafts set out a small orchard of two hundred trees at Crafton. Four years later Frank A. Kimball planted a small orchard of orange, lemon, and lime trees at National City. This was the first citrus grove in San Diego County. 10 The first orange trees in San Bernardino County were three specimens set out by Anson Van Leuven in on his farm at Old San Bernardino.
These were among six trees that he had secured from the orchards of former Mission San Gabriel. Around Van Leuven set out four acres of three-year-old nursery stock he purchased in Los Angeles. The seventh year after planting, this orchard yielded one and one half boxes of fruit per tree, and a year later two boxes per tree. Meanwhile, In L. R. Van Leuven put out 50 three-year-old seedlings. In he set out an additional 100 trees. Within six years of planting, these orchards produced one-fourth box per tree. 11 In Lewis Cram set out acres of oranges in the east San Bernardino Valley. He planted another grove of trees in By the original 1.75-acre grove netted a profit of In the state of California had orange trees and lemon trees; among these were orange and lemon in Los Angeles County.
12 W,li;J.\tiM'iv A:HflJ ~ ~~fil" GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page5 Groves continued to be expanded and production increased in San Bernardino County throughout the as recorded by San Bernardino County historians James Boyd and John Brown: ... in Colonel Tolles planted the trees of the Lugonia orchard, using the seeds of rotten Tahiti oranges brought from San Francisco. The first Orchards at Colton were put out about by R. W. Fox and Rev. James Cameron, who planted nursery stock, and E. J. Wait set out the first orchard in Redlands in the spring of W. P. Russell put out an orchard of six acres at Riverside in and the old Hewitson grove was set out the previous year.
13 By the mid-1870s there were about orange trees within the state; these included in Los Angeles County, in San Bernardino County, in San Diego County, and in Santa Barbara County. A large part had not yet matured enough to bear fruit. 14 About oranges were shipped annually to San Francisco from the Los Angeles basin. An orchard in full bearing yielded profits as high as an acre. 15 During the many groves were set out as part of agricultural colonies. These cooperative settlements combined elements of urban planning and community cooperation in rural communities based on agriculture. One of the most important of these was the Riverside Colony which set a precedent for urban style infrastructure that would become a major component of most citrus belt communities.
Promotional literature proclaimed that the proposed community would have schools, churches, lyceums, public libraries, and reading rooms. 16 Among the most important aspects and long term contributions of the colony settlements to Southern California agriculture were the numerous irrigation projects undertaken by their promoters. Local rainfall would not support intensive fruit culture but water reserves in the form of snow and underground aquifers in nearby foothills and mountains could supply the need. Again, Riverside set a precedent. The colony set to work vigorously in the winter of to construct a canal nine miles in length from the colony lands from a point on the Santa Ana River.
By the summer of the canal had been completed at a cost of By the community boasted orange, lime, and lemon trees-the largest citrus plantings in the state other than those immediately around Los Angeles. 17 Shortly after the organization of Riverside Colony, an association first known as the Indiana Colony established a townsite and agricultural I lriaiii~iji~N8 Wti!!,.'M GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page6 settlement along the Arroyo Seco east of Los Angeles. Much of the acreage was planted with oranges. The groves soon became famous for the amount and quality of fruit and the town, Pasadena, for its homes. 18 Through their examples, Riverside and Pasadena set the foundations for a society based on irrigated fruit culture.
The colony system was emulated by numerous other settlements in the following two decades. Notable citrus communities founded as colonies in east Los Angeles and west San Bernardino Counties included Pomona, Clairmont, Ontario, Etiwanda, and Ioamosa (Alta Loma). From the through the mid-1870s almost all orchards were developed from seedling trees of the sweet orange originally brought to the region by Spanish missionaries. 19 The saw introduction and adoption of two species of oranges that would come to dominate the industry by the end of the century: the Valencia and Washington Navel. The latter was especially well adapted to the warmer dry climate of San Bernardino County.
The Valencia orange was brought to California by Thomas Rivers about from an origin in the Azores and was found to be well adapted to cooler coastal regions. 20 The Washington Navel orange apparently originated as a bud variety, or sport, of the Selecta orange near Bahia Brazil sometime between and In twelve trees were sent from Bahia to William Saunders at the U.S. Department of Agriculture. In Saunders sent three trees to a friend, Eliza Tibbetts, at Riverside who planted them in her yard.
21 At the first citrus fair held in Riverside in February the fruit growers recognized the new orange to be so superior in size and taste to all other locally known varieties "that it created quite a furor." 22 Within a decade, over navel orange trees had been planted, and at the end of the century some were bearing fruit. 23 Together, the summer ripening coastal Valencia and the winter ripening inland navel enabled Southern California citrus growers to dominate the American market. 24 Although the navel became the most popular crop, Valencia oranges, as well as lemons and grapefruit, were also grown in San Bernardino County. True mastery of eastern markets became possible with development of the railroads in the and early eighties.
The three transcontinental lines that served Southern California included: the Southern Pacific Valley Line completed in making connections with the Central ~ ~ ~ G O E R L I T Z HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page7 Pacific and Union Pacific to the East; the Southern Line of the Southern Pacific to New Orleans completed in and the Santa Fe completed in William Wolfskill shipped the first carload of fruit east from his famous orchard in Los Angeles in It arrived in Saint Louis in good condition after a month in transit. The first shipment from San Bernardino was a mixed carload of oranges and lemons sent to Denver by G. W. Garcelon and A. J.
Twogood of Riverside in 25 In the Southern Pacific railroad, fearing competition because of the approach of the Santa Fe line, cut the rate on carload lots from Los Angeles to Chicago from to with similar reductions to intermediate points. 26 With completion of its lines in the Santa Fe joined the rate war with the Southern Pacific. It offered to ship freight between Chicago and San Diego at per 100 pounds as opposed to Southern Pacific's rate of plus litherage fees from Wilmington near Los Angeles. 27 The rate war also dropped passenger fares to an unprecedented low, bringing thousands of immigrants to Southern California. A veritable boom in orange planting followed. Profits soared. As much as from one acre was reported, with to being a common yield.
28 Shipping to eastern markets became even more practical with introduction of the ventilated car in and the refrigerated car in 29 Development of a national market brought a new era of California citrus agriculture. Eastern and midwestern residents would encounter California produce at urban markets or rural general stores as a crate of oranges or other citrus fruits. 30 By tons of oranges, which filled over boxes, were shipped annually from California to eastern markets. 31 Six years later exports totaled boxes. 32 San Bernardino County production reflected these increases.
The number of boxes of oranges shipped from San Bernardino County increased as follows: By the San Bernardino Valley produced in agricultural produce of which came from oranges, lemons and grapefruit, placing San Bernardino County first in the state in citrus production. 34 Among other important factors that led to the immense development of the citrus industry was establishment of cooperative marketing organizations. 35 By about citrus supply and demand had nearly stabilized. As new plantings grew and trees increased in size and matured, production doubled and tripled, growing much faster than the number of consumers. 36 In order to better market their products and receive favorable prices Southern California citrus growers established cooperative marketing associations.
I IEltBif!i~ itH0 El''~'!~rlf~" GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page8 The first strictly cooperative marketing organization, Pachappa Orange Growers Association in Riverside County, was informally organized in the late In Clairmont another strictly cooperative group was begun in the spring of under the direction of P. J. Dreher. It was known as the Clairmont California Fruit Growers Association. Both Pachappa and Clairmont were among the first growers' associations to band together under the Southern California Fruit Exchange, which later became the California Fruit Exchange that formed the Sunkist organization37 The exchanges became complex organizations developed to handle the packing, shipping and marketing of citrus from the thousands of growers in Southern California.
38 The California Fruit Exchange involved the establishment of local cooperative associations throughout the state. Although many developed local brands, these associations were combined into district exchanges. All district exchanges marketed through a central agency in Los Angeles. 39 Through advertising of their Sunkist trademark the exchange greatly increased the demand for California citrus during the early century. 40 The orchardist' s work was completed when the fruit was ready to pick. Cooperative associations then took charge and sent out trained crews to clip the product when the fruit matured. 41 After the fruit had been sold and cost and commissions deducted, each grower received payment according to the amount and grades of fruit supplied by his orchard.
In the a five year average revealed that through this method of operation the grower received approximately 25 percent of every consumer dollar spent for citrus fruits. 42 Fairs and expositions played an important part in upgrading and promoting the citrus industry, as documented by Boyd and Brown: Great encouragement and impetus have been given the orange industry by fairs and expositions. The first citrus fair in the world was staged at Riverside in February Its success led to another exhibit in February and a third in March In a special pavilion was built for the occasion by the people of Riverside, and a fifth annual fair in was held in conjunction with the semi- annual State Convention of Fruit Growers.
Fairs continued to be held annually at Riverside, with the exception of several at Colton, until in which year San Bernardino held its first citrus fair in its new pavilion. Colton had the fairs in and l~~ ~ ~~ GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page9 At the New Orleans Exposition of San Bernardino County won the following premiums: Gold medal for the best twenty varieties of oranges grown in California; gold medal for the same grown in the United States; gold medal for the same grown in the world; silver medal (highest prize) for the best display of lemons from any part of the world.
These prizes were won in competition with oranges and lemons from various districts in California, from Sonora, and other Mexican states, from Louisiana, Florida, the West Indies, and various places along the Mediterranean. 43 The annual National Orange Show in San Bernardino, which began in has been the most important exposition. Known as a showcase of new orange techniques, equipment and orange products, orange buyers and growers from across the nation came to see the innovations and presentations.44 Many growers felt a good showing each season at the National Orange Show was essential to a successful marketing of their citrus.
45 The communities established as a result of the development of successful citrus production and marketing evolved a unique culture that was neither urban nor rural. Lacking the congestion of cities and set amongst the unending uniform rows of citrus orchards, they did not have the isolation of more traditional farming settlements and frequently possessed many of the institutions of small cities such as public transportation, a college or university, art gallery, museum, and hotels. The handsome homes amongst the groves were not vernacular farmhouses but suburban Italianate, Queen Ann or Craftsman style residences. These were among the first communities in the west to adopt urban planning ordinances and modern infrastructure such as electric lights.
46 As historian Robert Glass Cleland expressed it in "In a certain sense the California citrus ranchers thus constituted almost a separate agricultural class, a phenomenon in American society interesting and significant enough warrant more extensive study." 47 This unique culture was made possible by the relatively large profits citrus could produce on comparatively small acreage.
During a period when many family farms were failing and the nation's demographics changed to a point where for the first time more people lived in urban areas than on farms, California citrus ranchers "enjoyed a degree of comfort, prosperity, and culture that bore little resemblance to the restrictions and hardships of the traditional farmer's life." 48 Economic analysis has shown that in during a national farming depression that began in the early "the owner of an average fully productive, debt free, ten acre grove would have realized a profit of after all operating expenses, including taxes, and packing charges, had been ~J!iaif hH8 ;iiW~'iGOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 10 paid.
In that profit would have topped roughly four times the per capita income in the country that year." 49 During the Great Depression of the while many farmers in the Midwest during this period were forced to flee the agricultural ruin of the dust bowl, California citrus producers continued to make a profit, even though prices for their crops declined. . . . growing citrus was a profitable, and sometimes extremely profitable venture. . . . Owners of small, residential groves could amass considerable equity, guarantee themselves a comfortable income, and even survive the Depression. Owners of large commercial groves could make a small fortune. 50 The nature of citrus farming attracted and required a different type of society than that of many traditional agricultural communities.
Throughout the Midwest and the western states during the late century, landless immigrants with little capital could homestead on 160 acres of government land and establish a farmstead. Others purchased unclaimed government land at extremely reasonable prices. Capital was acquired gradually over time as the property developed. Although success often came after years of hard work, the initial cash outlay was relatively small. Many agricultural communities, centered on a one- room schoolhouse and a post office, developed in this way. Individual farmsteads were large, resulting in smaller populations. These communities lacked many urban infrastructure comforts such as public transportation, secondary educational facilities, museums, hotels, running water, or electric lights.
51 Housing tended to consist of vernacular designs that often evolved as family needs and income grew. 52 Social attitudes in rural communities often differed from those in more urban areas. In spite of the increased mechanization of farm work and the participation of farmers in a market economy after the Civil War, agrarian household values and consumption habits remained more traditional to their century roots. A rural society with values more reminiscent of colonial times existed alongside the more modern Victorian culture of the city. 53 Citrus, on the other hand, required a capital investment. Land had to be purchased and cleared. Trees had to be obtained and planted, then protected and regularly irrigated for several years before full production could be expected.
54 The initial capital requirements necessarily excluded anyone who did not have access to substantial cash. 55 Residents of citrus communities tended to be more urban middle class in origin and attitudes than other rural communities. In the lliiM@R"t1~1~ N GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 11 opinion of historian Vincent Moses, Southern California orange growers: . thought and behaved like full fledged industrial capitalists. Over the period from to they shaped citrus production in Southern California into a vertically integrated cartel of great economic prowess and efficiency . . . .
Unlike their anti-industrial dirt farming brethren in the Farmers Alliance and Populist Peoples Party of Riverside Growers and their cohort group [were] more at home with cooperation and organization than with the rugged individualism of traditional Jeffersonian yeomen. 56 A unique agricultural society resulted. Capable of generating livable incomes from smaller land plots, fruit culture encouraged families to live on the land. The loneliness of rural life was reduced by the small size of holdings, as five to ten acres was the most common size, fifteen to twenty the average.
As a result of the capital available in citrus communities and the urban planning incorporated into the original design of many citrus colonies, residents commonly enjoyed public transportation, locally available institutions of higher learning, and cultural events and institutions. "Fruit culture resulted in a level of rural civility and the nurturing of social and recreational amenities" which stood in complete contrast to the limited infrastructure and isolation of more traditional farming communities. 57 In addition the citrus communities of San Bernardino County enjoyed a uniquely beautiful setting. By the area consisted of rows of gently rolling fruit trees broken by lines of eucalyptus and palms with stylish homes scattered amongst the orchards.
The region was set against a dramatic backdrop of snow-covered peaks and sunlit blue skies. California historian Kevin Starr has noted: Rarely, if ever, has such beauty and civility, such luxuriance and orderly repose been achieved on an American landscape as that brought about by citrus on the landscape of Southern California. Groves ... broken intermittently by gingerbread cottages or Spanish - style haciendas conferred on parts of Southern California an ambiance of Mediterranean idyll, a visual poetry of leaf, blossom, or fruit that offset the realities of the American Present with a charm that was enthusiastically exported on the orange crate labels. 58 Like any type of farming, citrus ranching necessitated constant hard work.
Although absentee owners who lived and worked in the city owned some ranches, most were family operations. As soon as the children were old enough they went to work, and often outside help was required. 59 A large community of working class Orientals, GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 12 Hispanics and Anglo Europeans in San Bernardino County provided the labor force that supported the citrus industry. 60 Many families had a vegetable garden, a cow, chickens, and sometimes pigs; and most had at least one team of horses or mules to do the ranch work. Farmers with smaller holdings often hired out to do the ranch work for others to supplement their income. 61 Irrigation was a central force in the citrus grower's life.
By concrete standpipes could be seen at the north end of each grove with additional standpipes at the head of each row. In each standpipe were two to four gates to regulate the flow of water. The Zanjero was in charge of delivering the water to the right place at the proper time. He notified each rancher of his irrigation schedule and it was the farmer's responsibility to be there, with furrows ready and gates adjusted, whenever the water was scheduled to appear. The ranchers were completely tied down by the irrigation schedule. 62 Many ranchers had small concrete reservoirs that were filled during irrigation time. This water ran by gravity flow to the ranch house to supply domestic water.
63 Freezing weather caused severe problems and required use of oil fueled orchard heaters, known as smudge pots, to protect the fruit from frost. During the winter months starting in the late frost warnings were broadcast over the radio in San Bernardino County every evening at eight o'clock. Growers slept little on cold nights. They would light the pots and work all night checking thermometers and monitoring heaters. Many a Christmas Eve was spent smudging. Most cold spells didn't last long, but January saw freezing weather that lasted for 20 days. 64 Following the Second World War, changing population and economic patterns brought a decline of the local citrus industry of San Bernardino County.
One factor was the increase of industrial and automobile smog that caused a decrease in individual tree production. In addition, central California growers were able to lower their cost of production with the advent of additional water and less expensive land assessments. Florida was also able to out-produce California because of climate, and their location allowed them to command eastern markets with lower prices. After World War II residential building began to encroach on citrus land and acreage began to dwindle. As a result, less than 10 percent of the acreage that was in production during the height of the citrus era was still under cultivation in 65 3.
History of Alta Loma and the Goerlitz Family: Alta Loma developed as a typical citrus community of western San Bernardino l~iiiiji.11~fit'.M\~ GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 13 County. It had its origins in the Hermosa and Ioamosa citrus colonies. The land was originally a part of Rancho Cucamonga. Among prominent residents of Alta Loma during the early century was Ernest Goerlitz; influential in community affairs and development, his son Herbert built the house that is the subject of this study. Governor Juan Bautista Alvarado granted Rancho Cucamonga to Tiburcio Tapia on March 3, The grant was three square leagues in size or approximately acres. 66 The ranch later became the property of John and Merced Rains. 67 Isaias W.
Hellman foreclosed on a mortgage and obtained title to the entire rancho on May 9, During the next few years he divided the land into three sections. He sold one to a group of San Francisco investors and subdivided the other two parcels for sale as the Cucamonga Fruit Lands Company and the Cucamonga Homestead Association. The latter would eventually become the location of the community of Alta Loma. Hellman failed to guarantee an adequate supply of water, and few lots were sold. 68 In Adolph Petsch and Benjamin S. Eaton, both of Pasadena, purchased the 160-acre homestead of Henry Reed lying north of the Cucamonga Homestead Association tract and formed the Hermosa Land and Water Company.
69 They augmented the original tract with the purchase of 120 acres from the Cucamonga Homestead Association. The Hermosa Colony was immediately successful. All lots in the original 160-acre Reed homestead sold in the first five weeks. 70 Hermosa developers established the Hermosa Water Company to irrigate orchard lots. Tunnels dug into nearby mountain canyons secured an ample supply. 71 Based on the Holt - Chaffey Mutual Water Company plan first implemented in nearby Etiwanda, the Hermosa enterprise guaranteed an equal share of water to all residents. Each purchaser of land received an equal share in the water company for every acre acquired.
The water company assumed responsibility for distribution of water to each tract, regardless of distance from the reservoir and no one was entitled to more than their respective shares of water company stock. This system resolved problems inherent in distribution systems used in California up to that time, in which those near the source enjoyed plenty of water without concern for those further downstream. 72 The Hermosa Colony Tract had been so successful that it led to development of the neighboring Iowa Tract consisting of 500 acres of Cucamonga Homestead Association land put on the market by Mr. Petsch, Judge Eaton, A. E. Pomeroy, L. H. Washburn and R. M. Baker. GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No.
CA-2681 Page 14 In October the two colonies Hermosa and Iowa combined, and the name was changed to Ioamosa. 73 The land boom following completion of the Santa Fe Railroad in accelerated development and the entire region was soon planted with oranges, lemons, grapefruit, apricots, peaches, and vineyards. 74 Among the new residents were immigrants from foreign lands, families who came west to California, and the wealthy from Los Angeles who wanted a ranch in the country. The Ernest Goerlitz family moved to Ioamosa in Ernest had been manager of the Metropolitan Opera Company in New York. He retired due to health problems and moved his family to California.
Goerlitz purchased 20 acres of citrus property in Ioamosa and a house on Hellman Avenue that had been constructed by the Thorp family in He took an active interest in community affairs and served as secretary of the Citizens League of Alta Loma. In he became president of the newly established Cucamonga Growers Fumigation and Supply Company. He also became involved in a project to bring a railway line through the colony as well as the development of local packinghouses and marketing associations. Elegant parties at his home attended by his Ioamosa farming neighbors often featured world famous opera stars vacationing in California such as Caruso or Galli-Curi. 75 In residents of Ioamosa pooled their resources to acquire a railway line closer to their ranches.
Up to this time they had been required to haul their fruit to packinghouses on the railway line at Cucamonga or Upland. On April 11, a mass meeting was held and a committee elected to secure a right of way for the Pacific Electric Railway Company. Members included: Capt. Demens, Dr. Reid, Ernest Goerlitz, C. F. Thorpe, Henry Albert, Frank A. Kelly, and Robert Wagner. At this time the Pacific Electric had completed tracts from Los Angeles to Upland. Through efforts of the committee rights of way were secured and on January 20, the Pacific Electric line was completed through Ioamosa to Etiwanda and finally to San Bernardino on July 11, 76 Following a vote of the Ioamosa residents the new station for their community was designated Alta Loma.
The name of the school district and post office were also changed and Alta Loma became the new name of the former Hermosa and Ioamosa colonies. 77 The new line provided not only freight service but also public transportation. Students from Alta Loma and nearby Etiwanda took the Pacific Electric to Upland to attend high school. 78 Completion of the new railway system brought about the building of four large new packinghouses in the business district of Alta Loma 1,r:R8EiR,'il, ldifD.J;!W~~ GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page15 located on either side of the Pacific Electric tracks. The Alta Loma Warehouse, Hillside Groves Packinghouse, Ioamosa Foothill Citrus Association, and American Fruit Growers were all completed within a span of two years.
79 Ernest Goerlitz served as vice president of the Alta Loma Warehouse Company, also known as the Alta Loma Heights Citrus Association. 80 However, he continued to suffer severe health problems, and committed suicide in December 81 The family lived in the Hellman Avenue house until when Herbert built the house that is the subject of this study on 10 acres of land he had purchased with his wife Evelyn in March of the previous year. 82 The dwelling was constructed of local stone in a rustic Spanish Colonial Revival style. A small house for Herbert's mother was constructed next door. 83 She lived there until her death in December 84 The property consisted of two five-acre lots on portions of Lots 5 and 6, Block 3 of the Cucamonga Homestead Association lands.
85 Kate Motsinger had purchased Lot 6 from Milda Carral in By it was under cultivation. 86 William Motsinger owned Lot 5 by He transferred title to Kate Motsinger in George Allen purchased both lots in and sold them to Herbert and Evelyn Goerlitz three years later. Improvements for the house first appear in the Tax Assessors Lot Books in (Lot Books, Transfer Books). Lot 6 continued to be taxed for vines and trees (presumably citrus) but no improvements of any kind are listed for Lot 5. In the property was purchased by Ellen C. Van Every, also known as Ellen Loeb, who was retired from the movie industry.
The first taxation for agricultural cultivation on Lot 5 occurred in 87 An aerial photograph of the property taken in shows a mature citrus grove on the southern half of the property (Lot 6) and newly planted trees on the north half (Lot 5).
Tax records for also show a major increase in improvement values on Lot 6 from for the previous year to This suggests Ellen Van Every enlarged the house sometime during or early 88 Van Every owned the property through the early 89 Alta Loma continued to be an important citrus producing community until after World War IL In spite of economic stagnation in the late Alta Loma and Cucamonga growers of packed boxes of navel oranges, boxes of Valencias, boxes of lemons, boxes of grapefruit, and an additional boxes of miscellaneous fruits in 90 Production apparently rose in spite of the national depression of the For the to season Alta Loma - Cucamonga production totaled boxes of navel oranges, boxes of Valencias, boxes of lemons, boxes of grapefruit, >HMtt~~i~lifie~ GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No.
CA-2681 Page 16 and boxes of miscellaneous fruit. In addition the area produced tons of juice grapes, tons of raisin grapes and 575 tons of table grapes. 91 Aerial photographs from the period reflect the productivity of the community, showing the area around the Van Avery house as well as all of Alta Loma covered in orchards and vineyards. 92 In Alta Loma farmers cultivated acres of oranges, lemons, and grapefruit that required the facilities of six large packinghouses. 93 Ten years later the same number of acres was still under cultivation. 94 From through Alta Loma residents annually displayed samples of their produce at the San Bernardino County Orange Show where they won over in prize money for their exhibits.
95 Over the next 40 years agricultural production at Alta Loma gradually declined. The community had reached its peak agricultural production by the start of World War II in Establishment of Kaiser Steel and other industrial plants in the area following the war brought population growth and subdivision. 96 In the mid-1970s elimination of citrus groves began to accelerate, followed by tract housing construction in the 97 Aerial photographs from show small housing tracts already beginning to replace orchards in Alta Loma. 98 In Alta Loma, along with Cucamonga and Etiwanda, incorporated as the City of Rancho Cucamonga. In the early the Goerlitz house became the El Rancho Grande Wedding Chapel, for which it is still used today.
Much of the surrounding property was sold and incorporated into new residential subdivisions. ~ r . , ~ G O E R L I T Z HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 17 Notes The parcel consisted of the West half of the West half of Lots 5 and 6, Lot 3, Cucamonga Homestead Association Lands. Title Transfer Book entry# 996 San Bernardino County Archives. Assessor Lot Books Assessor Lot Books Ibid. Ibid. Carey Mc Williams, Southern California Country: An Island on the Land, (New York, Dell Sloan and Pearce, James Boyd and John Brown, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, Vol. I (Chicago, Lewis Publishing Company, 71.
Herbert John Webber and Leon Dexter Batchelor, editors, The Citrus Industry, Volume I: History, Botany and Breeding, (Berkeley, University of California Press, Cleland, From Wilderness to Empire, Boyd and Brown, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, 71. 10 According to Kimball there were at that time a few isolated trees near San Diego and in San Luis Rey Valley. Webber and Batchelor, The Citrus Industry, 11 Boyd and Brown, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, 73. 12 Webber and Batchelor, The Citrus Industry, 37. 13 Ibid. 74. 14 Robert Glass Cleland and Osgood Hardy, March of Industry, (San Francisco, Powell Publishing Company, I 00. 15 Cleland, From Wilderness to Empire, 16 Webber and Batchelor, The Citrus Industry, 17 Ibid.
18 Cleaned and Hardy, March of Industry, 98. 19 Albert E. Canham, Joel W. Carter, and James A. McCarthy, The Development of the Citrus Industry in the San Bernardino, Redlands, East Highlands Area, Section A of a Report Submitted to the San Bernardino Regional Parks Department. (Copy on File San Bernardino County Archives, 71. Boyd and Brown, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, 73. 2 Canham et al., Development of the Citrus Industry, 22. 21 During the early another navel orange had been introduced from Australia. The navel orange from Brazil was called the Washington Navel to designate it as the species sent to Riverside by the Agricultural Department in Washington and distinguish it from the species from Australia, which was appropriately called the Australian Navel.
The latter soon fell into disfavor because of the inferior quality of the fruit. Webber and Batehelor, The Citrus Industry, 22 Boyd and Brown, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, 23 Cleaned and Hardy, March of Industry, 98. Mlf!R!~iDiiilfil~N GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 18 24 Kevin Starr, Inventing the Dream: California through the Progressive Era, (New York, Oxford University Press, 98. 25 Webber and Batchelor, The Citrus Industry, 26 Ibid. 27 Gloria Ricci Lothrop, "The Boom of the Revisited," Southern California Quarterly 75 (Spring & FaJI Glenn S. Dumke, The Boom ofthe Eighties in Southern California, (San Marino, Henry E. Huntington Library, 28 Cleland, From Wilderness to Empire, 29 Canham et al., Development of the Citrus Industry, 22.
30 Starr, Inventing the Dream, 31 Boyd and Brown, History ofSan Bernardino and Riverside Counties, 32 Cleaned and Hardy, March ofIndustry, 33 L.A. Ingersoll,Ingersoll's Century Annals of San Bernardino County to (Los Angeles, L.A. IngersoJI, 34 Federal Writers Project, Sands and Sierras, in WPA American Guide Series - San Bernardino County: A Guide to the Nation's Largest County. Unpublished text, photographs, and artwork, San Bernardino County Archives 35 Cleaned and Hardy, March ofIndustry, 98. 36 Canham et al., Development of the Citrus Industry, 94. 37 Canham et al., Development of the Citrus Industry, 47; Cleaned and Hardy, March ofindustry, 38 Canham et al., Development of the Citrus Industry, 47. 39 Ibid, 51.
4 Canham et al., Development of the Citrus Industry, 47; Cleaned and Hardy, March ofIndustry, 41 Federal Writers Project, Sands and Sierras, 11. 42 Ibid. 12. 43 Boyd and Brown, History of San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, 77. 44 Canham et al., Development of the Citrus Industry, 62. 45 Ibid. 88. 46 McWilliams, Southern California Country. 47 Cleland, From Wilderness to Empire, 48 Ibid. 49 For an analysis of the agricultural depression of the see James H. Shideler, Farm Crises - (Berkeley, University of California Press, I-J.ER-i~:R+ 1tU8 ~oi GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 19 50 Ronald Tobey and Charles Wetherell, "The Citrus Industry and the Revolution of Corporate Capitalism in Southern California, California History (Spring 17.
51 For a discussion of the development of more traditional agricultural communities in Southern California see Stephen R. Van Wormer, A History of Jamacha Valley: Agricultural and Community Development in Southern California, (Master's thesis, San Diego State University, and "Beeves and Bees: A History of the Settlement of Pamo Valley, San Diego County," Southern California Quarterly (Spring For more general discussions of agricultural community development see Gilbert C. Fite, "Daydreams and Nightmares: The Late Nineteenth Century Agricultural Frontier," Agricultural History 40: and "The Pioneer Farmer: A View Over Three Centuries," Agricultural History 50 See also Wayne E. Fuller, "School District 37: Prairie Community," Western Historical Quarterly.
): 52 Thomas Hubka, "Just Folks Designing: Vernacular Designers and the Generation of Form," in Common Places: Readings in Vernacular Architecture (Athens, University of Georgia Press, Fred W. Peterson, "Vernacular Building and Victorian Architecture: Midwestern American Farm Homes," in Common Places: Readings in Vernacular Architecture (Athens, University of Georgia Press, For examples of vernacular housing styles on farmsteads in Southern California, as well as residential homes of citrus growers, see Wallace W. Elliott, History of San Bernardino and San Diego Counties (San Francisco, Wallace W. Elliott and Company, 53 James A.
Henretta, "Families and Farms: Mentalite in Pre-Industrial America," William and Mary Quarterly, (January): Daniel Walker Howe, "American Victorians as a Culture," American Quarterly, (December): 54 Martha, Gaines Stobe, Hazel Stobe Billings and Wallace Stobe, The History ofAlta Loma, California: (Alta Loma, B & S Publishing ): 22. 55 Tobey and Wetherell, "The Citrus Industry and the Revolution of Corporate Capitalist," 17. 56 H. Vincent Moses, "'The Orange Grower is not a Farmer: G. Harold Powell, Riverside Orchardists and the Coming of the Industrial Agriculture," California History (Spring 25. 57 Starr, Inventing the Dream, 58 Ibid. 59 Stobe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 22.
6 For a discussion of the labor force in the citrus industry and the role of minorities in it see Grace Larsen, "Commentary: The Economics and Structure of the Citrus Industry: comment on Papers by H. Vincent Moses and Ronald Tobey and Charles Wetherell," California History (Spring and Gilbert G. Gonzalez, "Women, Work, and Community in the Mexican Colonias of the Southern California Citrus Belt, California History (Spring 61 Stobe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 22. 62 Ibid. 63 Ibid. 10. 64 Ibid. 22. 65 Canham et al., Development of the Citrus Industry, 62. 66 Leah J. Lovitt, "The Early History of Alta Loma," Pomona Valley Historian (April): 67 Stobe, Martha Gaines, Hazel Stobe Billings and Wallace Stobe, The History ofAlta Loma, California: (Alta Loma, B & S Publishing 13.
Hubert Howe Bancroft, History of California, Vol. III, (San Francisco, The History Company, 68 Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 3. Il~ili~:~'r :A:~W~GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page20 69 Lovitt, "Early History of Alta Loma," 4; Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 70 Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 4. 71 Ibid. 9. 72 J. A. Alexander, The Life of George Chaffey (New York, MacMillan Company, 34. 73 Lovitt, "Early History of Alta Loma," 5; Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 7. 74 Lovitt, "Early History of Alta Loma," 7. 75 Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 67; Daily Report, 13 Dec., Articles of Incorporation# Cucmonga Growers Fumigation Supply Company, San Bernardino County Archives.
76 Lovitt, "Early History of Alta Loma," 13; Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 17; Alta Lorna's Silver Jubilee, Alta Loma, California, Souvenir Program, June Alta Loma Vertical File, Model Colony Room, Ontario City Library, Ontario, CA. 77 Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 18. 78 Ibid. 79 Lovitt, "Early History of Alta Loma," 13. 80 Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 18; Daily Report 28 Feb. Articles oflncorporation # Alta Loma Heights Citrus Association, and# Alta Loma Warehouse Company, San Bernardino County Archives. 81 Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 67; Daily Record 15 Dec. 82 Assessor Lot Books Title Transfer Book entry# 996 San Bernardino County Archives. 83 Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 67. 84 Daily Report 10 Dec. 13 Dec.
85 Title Transfer Book entry# 996 San Bernardino County Archives. 86 Assessor Lot Books 87 Assessor Lot Books 88 Ibid. 89 Ibid. 9 County of San Bernardino, Office of Horticultural Commissioner, Report on Crop Production, Acreage and Valuation, On file San Bernardino County Archives. 91 County of San Bernardino, Office of Agricultural Commissioner, Report on Crop Production, Acreage and Valuation, On file San Bernardino County Archives. 92 Transportation/ Flood Control Aerial Photograph AXL June 3, San Bernardino County Archives. 93 Map of the Cucamonga District, Comprising the Communities of Alta Loma, Cucamonga, Etiwanda, and Gausti, Alta Loma Vertical File, Model Colony Room, Onatrio City Library, Ontario, CA. 94 Stoebe et al., History ofAlta Loma, 22.
I IURi8ER' @ GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 21 95 Lovitt, "Early History of Alta Loma," 13. 96 Hickcox, History of Etiwanda, 3. 97 George McGuire, interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 12, Etiwanda, CA. 98 Transportation Flood Control Aerial Photograph No. 56, Dec. 2, San Bernardino County Archives. t"eN!~~1Ar~1'8 E~~ GOERLITZ HOUSE HABS No. CA-2681 Page 22 PART III. SOURCES OF INFORMATION A. Original Architectural Drawings: None have been located. B. Early Views: None have been located. C. Interviews: McGuire, George (Great grandson of James C. Isle early Etiwanda resident). Interview with Stephen R. Van Wormer, June 12, Etiwanda, CA. D.